Annual Report of International Bridges To Justice
Annual Report of International Bridges To Justice
I support International Bridges to Justice. I believe very fervently that the accused have rights, and we must do everything we can to stop torture being used as an investigative tool. These people,the accused, are not guilty until they are proven so. They are innocent until they are proven to be guilty, and so I would commend every right thinking person to support International Bridges to Justice. Desmond Tutu
International Bridges to Justice is dedicated to ensuring the basic legal rights of ordinary individuals throughout the world. Specifically, IBJ works to guarantee everyone the right to competent legal representation, the right to be protected from cruel and unusual punishment and the right to a fair trial.
Contents
Message from the CEO IBJs Model Help IBJ End Torture JusticeMakers Country Programs: Cambodia China India Burundi Rwanda Zimbabwe eLearning IBJ in Singapore Message from the Chairman Financial Report Governance Staff & Consultants Volunteers 2010 Donors 1 2 3 4 8 10 12 14 16 18 19 20 22 23 24 26 26 27
64 rue de Monthoux CH-1201, Geneva, Switzerland [email protected] Phone: +41(0).22.731.24.41 Fax: +41(0).22.731.24.83
www.ibj.org
Founders Vision
We are grateful for your leap of faith with us, allowing us to work with defenders throughout the world to kindle the flame against darkness.
IBJ CEO and Founder Karen Tse
iBJs Model
tation and enhances societal understanding of the importance of defense attorneys, increasing public support for their work. IBJ employs a variety of media platforms to raise awareness, from posters to radio broadcasts.
Trainings
IBJs most basic function is to increase defender capacity. There simply are not enough skilled defense attorneys available to provide adequate representation to everyone accused of a crime. Nor is there the necessary infrastructure to support their work. To address these shortfalls, IBJ provides training to new and experienced criminal defense attorneys, both increasing the number of lawyers taking criminal cases and improving each lawyers ability to provide competent representation. IBJ also trains other actors within the justice system, such as police, prison officials, and judges, in best practices for safeguarding the rights of the accused.
2
Mission
International Bridges to Justice is dedicated to ensuring the basic legal rights of ordinary individuals around the world. Specifically, IBJ works to guarantee every person the right to competent legal representation, the right to be protected from cruel and unusual punishment, and the right to a fair trial.
Theory of Change
IBJs mission is global in scope, marshaling a worldwide community of public
Partner
IBJ is building a global network of institutions to tackle legal abuses at www.ibj.org/donate a local level. Whether youre a lawyer or human rights officer with expertise, an engineer with a technological solution, or a government official who can help IBJ navigate policy, we need your help!
+41(0).22.731.24.41 [email protected] 3
JusticeMakers
Congolese JusticeMakers Fellow Justine Mwanaisha Saidi with a group of juveniles she is representing
a stable source of income. Through various activities, he hopes to engage Irans judicial sector with the goal of reducing the countrys prison population. (By mutual agreement, no funding was provided.) Nana Chapidze (Georgia) established a resource center with an information database regarding juvenile rights in Georgia. She is also providing direct legal assistance to juveniles and organizing roundtable discussions regarding the juvenile justice system with civil society organizations. Rasul Agagasan Jafarov (Azerbaijan) started a hotline to provide legal rights information to citizens and, specifically, family members of prisoners. He is publicizing the right to early release for prisoners in Azerbaijan by holding trainings for prisoners and their families. Rasul is also assembling a team of lawyers to provide legal assistance to prisoners.
about the legal system in Georgia, defines legal terms in a way that students can understand, and clearly highlights several important tenets of criminal procedure: the right to a lawyer, the right to remain silent, the right to receive medical care in custody, and the right to be informed of the charges against you.
was developed in
JusticeMakers
legal rights abuses about their legal rights. He is also collaborating with local lawyers and NGOs to establish a legal resource center to provide direct case support to the accused. Finally, he is working with local media channels to maximize coverage of legal abuse. Rosselynn Jae Garcia de la Cruz (Philippines) created a paralegal module that serves as an educational tool to apprise farmers of their rights under the criminal justice system, with the objective of ending the phenomenon of criminalization of agrarian reform. She also established a paralegal class to train local women as paralegals, so that they may quickly respond to arrests in agrarian communities on the Bondoc Peninsula. These paralegals will ensure the preservation of evidence, gather affidavits, and help farmers navigate the legal process.
Junaid Khalid (Pakistan) is establishing legal camps throughout Karachi to provide citizens with direct and easily accessible legal advice and counsel. These camps, facilitated by lawyers, government officials, law enforcement authorities, and community leaders, will complement an online initiative offering citizens a platform to submit legal questions and access electronic legal-rights education resources. Yasmeen Shariff (Malaysia) is working with the government, police, parents, and social workers to provide an alternative to custody for accused juveniles in Kuala Lumpur. Upon arrest, these parties will work together to decide on an alternative, appropriate recourse, such as warning and caution, mediation, family conferencing, counseling, or therapeutic treatment.
Indonesian JusticeMakers Fellow Ajeng Larasati talking to detainees at Cipinang Prison in Jakarta
Shahanur Islam (Bangladesh) is running training sessions to promote respect for human rights amongst local police, prison officials, and lawyers in Dhaka, and selecting volunteers from these groups to facilitate awareness-raising activities in the wider community. He is also collaborating with the local legal community to provide
legal aid to prisoners from religious and ethnic minorities whose rights have been violated. Muhammad Waqas Abid (Pakistan) is conducting 10 seminars in rural areas of Punjab to educate brick kiln workers and agricultural laborers those most susceptible to
media relations skills she learned at IBJs Singapore Justice Training Centre to inform the press of Ms. Somawathis story. The case was published in a recent book as an example of corruption within the police department and attorney generals office. Harshi has obtained the release of two additional detainees through her project. She credits the training she received on
leadership, media relations, and presentation skills at the SJTC as instrumental to the projects success. The presentation skills have helped me to conduct awareness meetings in a more confident manner, she stated. Harshi recalled that a fellow JusticeMaker encouraged the group to never ever give up. She agrees, Yes. We will never ever give up until we die.
resources to understand their rights, and as a result, they are prime candidates for mistreatment and abuse in the criminal justice system. To help remedy this, IBJ secured a grant from the Levi Strauss Foundation, funding three $5,000 JusticeMakers Fellowships to address this problem in Argentina, Indonesia, and Azerbaijan. Justine Mwanaisha Saidi (Democratic Republic of the Congo) is responding to the problem of denial and delay of access to competent legal representation for poor people accused of crimes, including vulnerable youth, in the city of Bukavu by collaborating with the police and prison officials and implementing seminars to raise awareness. She also plans on raising the number of lawyer volunteers to provide early access to legal counsel for women and children accused of crimes. Adriana Patricia Castano Roman (Colombia) is providing direct legal representation to young victims of arbitrary detention in the city of Medelln. Her project will also include legal training for criminal defense lawyers to enhance their skills, support to victims of abuse and arbitrary arrest, documentation of their cases to increase transparency regarding these practices, and rights-awareness trainings for youth. Alejandro Tomas Vianda Ovalle (Chile) is assisting accused juveniles in Chile by providing them with the opportunity to have direct contact with their attorneys via video communication. His project is in response to the denial or delay of access to competent legal representation for accused juveniles. To achieve enhanced access, he will create collaborative events involving legal sector participants.
Veronica Marisol Quiroga Pando (Bolivia) notes that the right to counsel is often denied to citizens in Bolivia due to very high crime rates, extreme poverty, and a lack of resources for public defender offices. This systematic denial of access to counsel is even more serious for women, who are often unable to obtain criminal defense lawyers due to existing cultural norms and persistent stereotypes. Veronicas project seeks to provide legal representation for women prisoners in order to ensure access to justice from a perspective focused on gender and human rights. Gabriela Eugenia Vazquez (Argentina) is helping to raise HIV/AIDS awareness and reduce the problem of HIV/ AIDS in prisons by engaging security professionals to help with prevention, as well as strengthening the counseling unit within prisons. She will conduct counseling sessions on internal health in which safe sex practices will be promoted to help prevent the spread of HIV/AIDS in penitentiaries. Gautier Zomissi (Cameroon) is improving communication between the various actors in Cameroons judicial system to ensure that prisoners are no longer unlawfully incarcerated beyond their sentenced terms. He is also seeking to increase the speed of prosecutions by creating an intelligence office that will coordinate prisoners files and facilitate communication between different judicial actors. In addition, Gautier will also create a hotline in partnership with the government that will allow inmates to obtain urgent assistance or needed information relating to processing their cases. Maria de la Paz Martinez Irigoitia (Paraguay) is working
7
Pakistani JusticeMakers Fellow Muhammad Waqas Abid conducting a rights awareness event
to eliminate abuses by police and prison officials by fostering collaboration between public defenders and medical schools in the region to tend to abuse victims. She intends to have physicians treat victims and issue medical reports so that defenders can report abuse and the concomitant human rights violations. Mahfuza Folad (Afghanistan) is providing direct legal representation to accused women, as well as expanding female prisoners knowledge about their rights and responsibilities within the Afghan criminal justice system. She is representing 14 indigent women in Kabul accused of crimes, providing 12 days of criminal justice training for accused women, and creating and publishing 1,000 Know your Rights brochures that will be distributed to the accused and other actors in the criminal justice system. Alex Argo Hernowo (Indonesia) is combating the discrimination and stigma associated with HIV/AIDS by providing legal services for people living with the disease, producing educational tools about legal and human rights issues impacting individuals with HIV/AIDS, and training
individuals to become paralegals to address the criminal defense needs of accused HIV/ AIDS sufferers. Elchin Abullayev (Azerbaijan), in response to the rapidly spreading epidemic of HIV/ AIDS in his country, is increasing public attention on prisoners suffering from this disease. He is strengthening advocacy for these prisoners to ensure that they get proper medical attention, as well as promoting their early release from prison. Mabel Jenny Atezana Arispe (Bolivia) plans to organize a group of volunteer attorneys to train both detainees and the attorneys that represent them on human rights and criminal procedure. The attorneys will then utilize their new skills and knowledge to defend their clients. The trainings will also raise awareness amongst the accused of the human rights protections to which they are entitled. Go online and learn more:
justicemakers.ibj.org IBJs JusticeMakers website includes biographies of current and past JusticeMakers Fellows and in-depth descriptions of their innovative approaches to legal reform implementation.
iBJ
in
caMBodia
IBJ solidified its reach into 13 provinces throughout Cambodia, providing much needed representation to regions with no other providers.
Photo courtesy of George Hsia
IBJ Cambodia lawyer Hok Meng Eam (right) talking to a detained client
Justice Facts:
Cambodia
Rule of Law:16/100 2010 Prison Population: 14,403, 94 per 100,000
Throughout 2010, IBJ continued its three-pillared approach to creating a sustainable legal aid community in Cambodia. Consisting of trainings, roundtable discussions, and rights-awareness campaigns, IBJs unique methodology facilitated collaboration with local civil society organizations like the Bar
8
Association of the Kingdom of Cambodia (BAKC) and Legal Aid Cambodia (LAC). Working closely with the BAKC, IBJ hosted two threeday training events in May and August 2010, attended by nearly 15% of Cambodias entire legal workforce. IBJ held an additional one-day session for 20 of Cambodias
criminal defense leaders and four roundtable events for police, court and prison officials, local and national government officials, and civil society organization representatives. These well-attended events help to ensure compliance with Cambodias laws relating to accused persons by disseminating institutional
DRC Coordinator Sim Dalis and volunteer Finella Murphy meeting with IBJ client Chhun Sopheap, a farmer and father of five in Prey Veng Province, was accused of murdering his neighbor on February 1, 2010. The neighbor was found stabbed to death in her home. Police found a bloodstained t-shirt at the scene, and a cell phone and battery were missing. The police had two suspects: Sopheap and another village resident. Based solely on the accusation of the other suspect, Sopheap was arrested and charged with the murder. While in custody, he was repeatedly beaten. Nevertheless, he maintained his innocence. In Cambodia, the accused often spend months in prison awaiting trial without access to an attorney. Luckily for Sopheap, the Cambodian court assigned IBJ lawyer So Bengtharun to the case almost immediately. Early access to counsel made a world of difference in Sopheaps case. Bengtharun discovered that much of the evidence against Sopheap was the product of police fabrication and that the battery stolen from the victims house was sold while he was in prison. Similarly, while in prison, Sopheap was wearing sandals the police claimed to have found at the scene of the crime stained with blood. Furthermore, the trousers and tie the police also claimed to have found at the scene were taken from Sopheaps family after his arrest under the pretense that they would be given to him to wear in prison. Bengtharun was also able to corroborate Sopheaps alibi. A medicine-seller testified that Sopheap was home the entire night caring for his sick son. Ultimately, the Court issued a warrant for the second suspect, the very person who had initially implicated Sopheap. The Court acquitted Sopheap of murder on November 16, 2010, finding that there was insufficient evidence of his guilt. Without the early access to counsel provided by IBJ, Sopheap would likely still be in detention awaiting trial. It is alternatively conceivable that he would have suffered an all-too-common fate, conviction for a murder he did not commit.
Man reads rights awareness material at a Street Law campaign in Pursat Province
iBJ
in
china
Mobilizing our national network of partners, our activities brought a spectacular end to a fruitful year of programming.
Justice Facts:
China
Rule of Law: 45.3/100 2010 Prison Population: 1.57 million, 190 per 100,000 Law student distributing IBJ rights awareness materials
10
from the Supreme Peoples Court in Beijing on how best to implement the new sentencing guidelines. With proper training, both new regulations will significantly enhance the role of defense attorneys in the criminal justice system. IBJ also initiated pilot projects promoting the rights of juvenile defendants and access to rehabilitation. After participating in an IBJ-sponsored study tour of a system of probation for juvenile offenders in Yunnan and attending a roundtable on social background investigations in Xincheng District of Shaanxi Province, the Beilin District Prosecutors office of Shaanxi implemented a program incorporating both approaches that will be expanded throughout the province, if successful. Additionally, IBJ held a conference on juvenile record sealing in April, which promoted two pilot projects we have supported since 2008 in Dezhou City, Shandong Province and Licang District, Qingdao. These projects, which may be adopted by other local governments, are quite possibly the most significant advancement in juvenile justice reform underway in China. To engage leaders in civil society, we initiated a monthly roundtable in
Beijing with the Yipai Public Interest Team. Lawyers gathered to discuss topics such as Risks Faced by Criminal Defense Lawyers and Lawyers and the Media. These lawyers also mobilized their colleagues in Inner Mongolia and Gansu provinces to participate in IBJ rights awareness activities. In addition, reaching out to more remote locales, IBJ initiated a national eLearning project, which will use Internet-based instruction to train defense lawyers. We posted five modules on client interviewing to the website of the All China Lawyers Association, our partner in the project. We also began production of three modules on the new sentencing guidelines. Finally, we conducted our annual December 4 campaign to promote rights awareness among ordinary citizens. Entitled Spirit of Cooperation, it included Street Law campaigns offering free advice in Lanzhou, Gansu Province, and Xian, Shaanxi Province, film screenings on criminal justice, and the distribution of a comprehensive family rights brochure by police, law firms, and students. Mobilizing our national network of partners, these activities brought a spectacular end to a fruitful year of programming.
11
iBJ
in
india
IBJ will work to establish a permanent system of defense lawyers on duty in detention centers and remand prisons to guarantee universal and prompt access to counsel.
Justice Facts Sources (all countries): Rule of Law indicator: World Banks Worldwide Governance Indicators Prison populations and rates: 2010 report of Kings College International Centre for Prison Studies
During 2010, IBJ established itself once again as a leading force in the development of Indias legal aid network. IBJ continued to employ its complementary approaches to improve access to justice: leading by example through direct client representation and highlevel strategic development through local partnerships. Since December 2009, IBJ lawyers have defended over 250 cases, made possible through its New Delhibased Fellow Ajay Verma and its partnership with Banglar Manabadhikar Suraksha Mancha (MASUM) in West Bengal. Ajay also led two training events in June 2010, gathering together judges, lawyers, police officials, judicial officers, and legal scholars for mutual instruction and training. Such events help ensure proper compliance with Indian criminal and procedural law at all levels of the criminal justice system. IBJs special emphasis on guaranteeing
12
early access to counsel and proper police examination techniques furthers its mission to eliminate torture as an investigative tool. Throughout October and November 2010, with the assistance of Andy Haas of the International Senior Lawyers Project and volunteer attorney Puneet Kakkar, Ajay met with key advocates, jurists, and officials to discuss how IBJ India could strengthen the criminal justice system through local partnerships and increased day-to-day participation. Both the general trainings and the advocacy programs create a well-connected community of legal aid practitioners and allow criminal justice stakeholders the valuable opportunity to collaborate on ways to improve the Indian legal system. In November 2010, IBJ and its partner, Delhi Legal Services Authority (DLSA), conducted a full day training workshop on effective legal aid advocacy to improve the skills of lawyers working for
DLSA at the trial court level. In 2011, IBJ will continue to develop its professional relationships with local legal aid organizations, working toward the creation of sustainable resource centers for legal aid lawyers. Development of resource centers in marginalized regions of the country is a priority, as they will help support the advocates and residents most in need. Looking forward, IBJ will work to establish a permanent system of defense lawyers on duty in detention centers and remand prisons to guarantee universal and prompt access to counsel.
Justice Facts:
India
Rule of Law: 56.7/100 2010 Prison Population:
What IBJ wants to achieve through early access to counsel and creating a robust system of criminal defense could prevent suffering to many ordinary people.
Hon. K.G. Balakrishnan, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of India, 2007-2010
13
iBJ
in
Burundi
IBJ employs a comprehensive approach to rights awareness in order to reach every level of the criminal justice system.
In 2010, IBJ bolstered its legal rights movement in Burundi through the addition of two new Legal Fellows to support the day-to-day operations of its Bujumbura-based DRC and by continuing to conduct hands-on training across the nation. In addition, IBJs rights-awareness efforts significantly contributed to an inspiring 45% increase in overall media coverage of criminal justice matters, and its operational support facilitated a 13% increase in the total number of IBJtrained lawyers dedicating at least half of their practice to criminal law. IBJ employs a comprehensive approach to rights aware-
ness in order to reach every level of the criminal justice system. In 2010 alone, IBJ reached over 4,000 ordinary citizens during five Street Law campaigns, in which residents of the areas around Cibitoke, Kabezi, Rumonge, Kinama, and Gitega received one-on-one education about their rights in case of arrest. Over 130 detainees in Bubanza, Ngozi, and Gitega provinces also received desperately needed rights-awareness training through IBJs Know Your Rights programs. Participants immediately felt the impact of this training: 98% of IBJ-program participants indicated awareness of their right to legal representation
and 86% were aware of their right not to be tortured. IBJ also achieved great successes in its efforts to reshape the practices and policies of the criminal justice community. Through a mock-trial training with over 61 lawyers, judges, prosecutors, police officers, and prison directors, IBJ helped to increase systematic understanding of detainee rights and contributed to a 60% overall increase in access of lawyers to their clients in police custody. Additionally, IBJs efforts to combat prison overcrowding with the rallying cry, Freedom is the rule; detention is the exception, led to a drastic shift in Bu-
Justice Facts:
Burundi
Rule of Law: 11.8/100 2010 Prison Population:
14
rundis detention policy. (See accompanying story.) IBJ also held various roundtable discussions, bringing judges and prosecutors together with other important participants in the criminal justice sector to discuss a range of issues. These roundtables facilitated the representation of hundreds of vulnerable detainees in
the provinces of Bujumbura, Bubanza, and Bururi. With the goal of increasing both the scope and depth of coverage throughout Burundi, IBJ will continue its inclusive countrywide awareness and training campaign in 2011, while solidifying ties with the government and Ministry of Justice.
15
iBJ
in
r wa n da
Of the 140 IBJassisted individuals accused of crimes, more than 50% received assistance from local lawyers on a purely pro bono basis.
With the invaluable help of its Fellow and support staff, IBJ established a Defender Resource Center in Kigali in June 2010. Serving as a gathering place for Rwandan lawyers seeking support and guidance, the DRC quickly became a much relied upon fixture in pro bono legal circles. Currently, the DRC attracts approximately 30 visitors each day from lawyers to relatives of the accused in search of information and legal assistance. The DRC also frequently receives calls from former clients thanking the IBJ team for securing their release. The DRC receives sup-
port from a core team of 29 volunteer lawyers, specially trained by IBJ to take cases of vulnerable accused persons on a pro bono basis. In 2010, the volunteer lawyer corps assisted in cases in all five Rwandan provinces and secured either a full acquittal or a reduced sentence in 95% of its cases. As part of IBJs continuing mission to understand and evaluate the changing legal needs of Rwanda, it recruited 23 dedicated criminal defense lawyers as part of a Criminal Defense Task Force. During 2010, members of the Task Force convened on three separate occasions to
discuss their experiences as criminal legal aid lawyers and to circulate ideas on how to improve Rwandas pro bono culture and criminal justice system. IBJ continues to foster the pro bono culture in Rwanda through its partnership with the Kigali Bar Association. In July 2010, IBJ worked with the KBA to train 80 local lawyers on developing case theories and protecting the rights of their clients throughout the criminal justice process. These trainings help galvanize the legal aid infrastructure of Rwanda by connecting individual criminal defenders
Justice Facts:
Rwanda
Rule of Law: 36.3/100 2010 Prison Population:
16
to resources like the DRC. In fact, owing in large part to the July 2010 training, between June and August 2010 lawyers involvement with DRC activities rose by 42%. Even more significantly, of the 140 IBJ-assisted individuals accused of crimes, more than 50% received assistance from local lawyers on a purely pro bono basis.
IBJ will continue to grow its Rwandan programs in 2011 and plans to further integrate the KBA into volunteer lawyer programs. IBJ also plans to work with the Rwandan Ministry of Justice to formulate a national legal aid policy and secure future success in pro bono defense of vulnerable and indigent populations nationwide.
IBJ Fellow John Bosco Bugingo addressing lawyers attending an IBJ Criminal Defense Task Force meeting
17
iBJ in ZiMBaBwe
IBJ-mobilized lawyers took on 108 pretrial detainee cases between December 2009 and October 2010.
Justice Facts:
Zimbabwe
Rule of Law: 0.9/100 2010 Prison Population:
IBJ Fellow Innocent Maja (right) and Legal Fellows John Burombo and Pamela Chiwara pointing to IBJ rights awareness posters outside a courthouse
18
Following the launch of the Legal Training Resource Center, IBJ piloted another important eLearning initiative by creating the worlds first Wiki dedicated exclusively to global criminal defense practice. This new site, the Criminal Defense Wiki (defensewiki.ibj.org) was created using the same software behind Wikipedia, thereby creating an easy-to-use platform that facilitates the creation and discussion of global criminal defense practices. The site provides easy access to comparative crimiIBJ Fellow Ajay Verma viewing IBJs eLearning site nal procedure and standards, thereby introducing lawyers to best practices of criminal defense systems from around the globe. In 2010, more than 70,000 individuals from over 206 countries around the world visited the site, and the numbers of visitors continues to grow each month. In 2011, IBJ will work to expand the number of pages and translate the most frequently visited pages into Arabic, French, Khmer, Mandarin, and Spanish.
19
iBJ in singapore
IBJ Fellows Ouk Vandeth and Astre Muyango at the Fellows Summit
One of their first initiatives was to meet with prominent members of Singapores legal community to request their participation as judges for IBJs 2010 Asia JusticeMakers competition. IBJ was delighted to secure the services of Philip Jeyaretnam, Managing Partner of Rodyk & Davidson (Singapores
20
counterparts at Singapores Economic Development Board (EDB). IBJ was among the first wave of leading NGOs invited to operate in Singapore under the governments International Organizations Development Scheme. SJTC staff helped guide negotiations between EDB and IBJ headquarters, resulting in the award of a
IBJs training in Singapore was really beneficial for me. I not only clarified my various concepts about human rights issues, but also learned techniques for successfully implementing my project. The training put me on a proper track to move ahead in improving the criminal justice system in my country. I am really thankful to IBJ for improving my leadership skills and giving me knowledge and international exposure.
2010 JusticeMakers Fellow Muhammad Waqas Abid of Pakistan
Left and above: Country and JusticeMakers Fellows at the Fellows Summit
21
leadership
...the fundamental question is whether we are building the institutional foundation of an accessible and predictable justice system that treats all individuals in a fair, impartial and accountable manner...
Daniel R. Fung was the first person of Chinese descent to serve as Solicitor General of Hong Kong. He did so both before and after Hong Kongs reversion to Chinese sovereignty in 1997. He is the President of the Hong Kong chapter of the International Law Association and Chairman of the Peace and Development Foundation, the official partner in Honk Kong of the United Nations Development Programme in China.
Country Fellow to initiate a movement to provide pro bono representation to impoverished criminal defendants. v After five pre-trial detainee clients died in Zimbabwe, IBJ attorneys persuaded several Harare judges to waive bail for many of the poor criminal defendants they represent. What is important about these successes is the significant contributions they are making to sustainable criminal justice reform in the countries in which they occur. For every activity we undertake, the fundamental question is whether we are building the institutional foundation of an accessible and predictable justice system that treats all individuals in a fair, impartial and accountable manner, or in other words, whether our interventions promote the development of the rule of law over the long term. As the above examples indicate, I believe the answer to this question is a resounding yes in each country where we work. First and foremost, our defense services provide a concrete, on-the-ground example of best practice for how routine legal aid services can be provided. Additionally, through our roundtables and trainings we nurture the support, commitment and essential technical skills of the key stakeholders within the government whose support is crucial to building the political will needed to create a functioning and enduring legal
aid system. Finally, our rights awareness campaigns empower ordinary individuals with the knowledge they need both to participate effectively in the justice system and to demand systemic reforms within it. Each of these three prongs is carefully implemented to build long-term support for legal aid reform and the rule of law. Furthermore, by implementing each in parallel, we achieve tremendous synergies for our overall effort. We acknowledge that this is a long-term process; however, as demonstrated elsewhere in this Annual Report, we are achieving clear and concrete results. Of course, both financial resources and in-kind assistance are crucial to IBJs continued success. As IBJ works to create sustainable criminal justice reform worldwide, I ask you to contribute whatever you can to help us fulfill our mission. Thank you for your support.
Financial report
International Bridges to Justices strategy of supporting public defense lawyers around the world is high return on investment-giving.
Matthew Bishop US Business Editor and New York Bureau Chief, The Economist
Private Foundations Governments/Multilaterals Social Entrepreneur/Activist Awards Private Individuals Events Law Firms
23
goVernance
BOARD OF DIRECTORS Daniel R. Fung, Chairman Kenneth Cukier Joan Darby Francis James David Little Regina Mooney Peter Schnherr Grace Toh Karen Tse Luis Velasco Mia Yamamoto ADVISORY BOARD Scotty McLennan Anthony Saich Hilde Schwab Charles Sie Cornel West IBJ PARTNERS BURUNDI APRODH Burundi Bar Association CAMBODIA Bar Association of the Kingdom of Cambodia Government of Cambodia Legal Aid of Cambodia CHINA Center for the Rights of Disadvantaged Citizens (Legal Aid Clinic at Wuhan University School of Law) China Academy of Social Sciences (CASS) China Criminal Clinical Legal Educators (CCCLE) China Police University China University of Political Science & Law Gao Jin Law Firm Geng Min Law Firm Hubei Province Womens Federation Juvenile Protection Bar Association of Hubei Province Northwest University of Political Science & Law, Xian Office of the Yanta Procuratorate Panlong Youth Justice Pilot Project Peking University Law School PIDLI (Wuhan University School of Law) Shaanxi Female Legal Workers Association Shaanxi Womens Federation Shangquan Law Firm Tsing Hua University Law School, Beijing Wuhan University School of Law Wuhan University School of Law, Criminal Defense Clinic Wuhan University of Science and Technology, Legal Aid Center Xu Xiaoping Law Firm Yipai Impact Public Interest Firm EAST AFRICAN COMMUNITY East Africa Law Society INDIA Delhi High Court Delhi Legal Services Authorities MASUM Union Territories of Pondicherry Legal Services Authority (UTPLSA) RWANDA Kigali Bar Association Legal Aid Forum Ministry of Justice SINGAPORE American Chamber of Commerce in Singapore Association of Criminal Lawyers Clifford Chance LLP Drew & Napier LLC KhattarWong Kind Exchange Latham & Watkins LLP Law Society of Singapore Lien Centre for Social Innovation National University of Singapore, Lee Kwan Yew School of Public Policy Rodyk & Davidson LLP Shearman & Stearling LLP Singapore Management University, Lee Kong Chian School of Business Singapore Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Technical Cooperation Department ZIMBABWE Care at the Core of Humanity (CATCH) Legal Resources Foundation Law Society of Zimbabwe Zimbabwe Association for Crime Prevention and Rehabilitation of the Offender (ZACRO)
2 01 0 a s i a J u s t i c e M a k e r s c o M p e t i t i o n
1-Focus International Advocacy Forum Afghanistan Human Rights Organization Afghanistan Independent Bar Association Alliance of Independent Journalists Asia Philanthropy Forum Association of NGOs against Trafficking of Persons in Central Asia Bahrain Center for Human Rights Bangladesh Institute of Human Rights Be in Vision Pakistan Bilal Law Associates Committee for Social Justice Echoing Green Eurasia Partnership Foundation Global Giving Global Youth Action Network Human Rights Education Institute of Burma Human Rights XXI Century: Azerbaijan Humanitarian Legal Assistance Foundation 24
Independent Thought Israel Bar Association Kanesalingam & Co. KARAPATAN Kyrgyz Committee for Human Rights Lahore High Court Bar Association LBH Masyarakat: Community Legal Aid Institute Legal Rights Forum MINBYUN Mubashir Bhutta Human Rights Open Society Institute Assistance Foundation, Tajikistan Pakistan Lawyers Foundation Palestinian Centre for Human Rights Payap University, Institute of Religion, Culture, and Peace Peace & Collaborative Development Network Penal Reform International, Central Asia Office Pine Tree Preda Foundation Prisoners Assistance Nepal Qadir Foundation Singapore Management University School of Law Social Edge Southeast Asia Media Defence Legal Network Supreme Court of Mongolia United Nations Development Programme, Jordan Women Foundation of Nepal
Social Edge Southern Africa Litigation Centre Universidad Nacional de Ascuncin World Justice Project 2010 ASIA JUSTICEMAKERS COMPETITION JUDGES Subhas Anandan Daniel R. Fung Howard Hunter Philip Jeyaretnam Sidarth Luthra Teresa N. Ng Persida V. Rueda-Acosta Karen Tse Hon. Wilhelmina M. Wright 2011 JUSTICEMAKERS COMPETITION JUDGES Raquel Aldana Julie Anne Davies Kellie Krake Luis Velasco EXPERTS Subhas Anandan Scott Baggett Constance Bernstein Geoff Feltoe Andrew Haas Paul Holland Hy Sophea Richard Kern Kellie Krake May Lee Christopher Leibig Sonny Lim William Linthicum Leslie Medema Madev Mohan Alec Muchadehama Anita Mugeni Anthony Natale Gopinath Pillai Persida V. Rueda-Acosta Francesca Segre Norm Sepenuk Stephanie Slattery Jennifer Smith Susan Suh Yu-Jin Tay Larissa Wakefield
2 011 J u s t i c e M a k e r s c o M p e t i t i o n
Abusua Foundation African HIV in Prisons Partnership Network AIDS Law Project AIDS Portal American Bar Association Rule of Law Initiative Mexico and Ecuador Ashoka AVERT Centro de Derechos Humanos Universidad de Chile Centro Latinoamericano de Administracin para el Desarrollo EDUCAF Cameroon Funds for NGOs.org Global Center for Social Entrepreneurship University of the Pacific Hispanic National Bar Association Howard League for Penal Reform Hugh Wooding Law School Trinidad & Tobago i-Genius Inter-American Commission on Human Rights Inter-American Program University of the Pacific Justice for All Organization Justicia Penal Ecuador Legal Structure and International Justice Institute University of the Pacific Ms. JD NAABUR The Global Neighbor Network Prison Reform Trust Proyecto ACCESO Red Argentina para la Cooperacin Internacional
Singapore Singapore Singapore, China Zimbabwe India China Cambodia China Singapore Singapore United States Singapore Geneva Singapore Singapore Zimbabwe Rwanda Africa Singapore Singapore Singapore Cambodia Burundi, Rwanda China Singapore Singapore United States
25
s ta F F & c o n s u lta n t s
BURUNDI Claire Habimana Nadge Kwizera Astre Muyango Janvier Ncamatwi Herman Ndayishimiye Aline Nijimbere CAMBODIA Mondulkiri Cheang Makara Cheang Sopheav Khut Sreymon Phnom Penh Chan Reaseypheak Hok Meng Eam Kim Hor Han Ouk Chandyna Ouk Vandeth Sim Dalis Sok Sopheak Prey Veng Leang Sina Seang Sarika So Bengtharun Pursat Chhuon Sithann Choun Loeum Ouk Kalyan Rattanakiri Chew Sophea Mao Sary Seun Phanita Takeo Hay Dany Khut Srey Pich Po Vannophea CHINA Beijing Jean Amabile Aurora Bewicke Chen Dong Cheng Jie Feng Sien James Gronquist Paula Ho Liu Yujin Laurie Malkin Leslie Rosenberg Jill Shaw James Taylor Tse Kaho Wang Xue Wu Xiaofeng Zhang Xiaomin Zhang Yun Wuhan Cheng Xia Marcel Green Lei Yutian Luo Yawen Zhou Xiaoming Xian Lei Heng Judith Mandel Zhao Hao GENEVA Karen Tse, Founder and CEO Fanny Cachat James Carroll Paul Demakis Peter Kenyon Kellie Krake Sanjeewa Liyanage Angela Randolph Timothy Scheu James Vicente Jason Yoder INDIA Abhijit Datta Meena Kumari Ajay Verma RWANDA John Bosco Bugingo Hadijah Kamwesiga SINGAPORE Hilary Stauffer ZIMBABWE John Burombo Florence Chatira Pamela Yeukai Chiwara Innocent Maja Jessica Braun, Geneva Natasha Bronn, Geneva Jessica Callen, Geneva Claire Carpenter, Geneva Chan Vanny, Cambodia Chan Tola, Cambodia Jennifer Chang, Geneva Chen Ran, China Chen Ruting, China Maria Contreras, Cambodia Claire Davies, Geneva Michelle DeFreese, Geneva Daphne Demetriou, Geneva Sotiria Dimou, Geneva Andrea Dinh, Singapore Vivan Dinh, Geneva, Singapore Celesta Duivenvoorde, Burundi Eddie Eichler, Geneva Michelle Ericksson, Geneva Abigail Evans, Zimbabwe Eric Feldman, Sri Lanka Allyson Gaiser, Geneva Thomas Halusa, Singapore Liam Hanlon, Geneva, Malaysia Archie Hogan, Geneva Mark Janke, China Emilie Jarrett, Geneva Puneet Kakkar, India Jasmin Kang, Singapore Gayatri Khanna, India Wouter Kruijs, Geneva Zack Launer, Geneva Stephen Leung, Geneva Li Jiao, China Leslie Liao, Cambodia Quinnie Lin, Geneva Willa Lin, China Liu Li, China Stephen MacArthur, China Katherine Majzoub, China Catherine Mattesich, Geneva William Mattimore, China Chelsea McConnell, Geneva Althea Middleton-Detzner, Cambodia Mariel Murray, Geneva Dieudonn Ndayishimiye, Burundi Marvelous Ndlovu, Zimbabwe Kim Nee, Singapore Anitha Niragira, Burundi Olivier Niyonizigiye, Burundi Kara Nottingham, Geneva Ouk Rachana, Cambodia Silvia Palomba, Geneva Pan Su, China Vanessa Pastora, Geneva, United States 26 Laure Peillen, India Phai Winner, Cambodia Phon Sophoes, Cambodia Patrick Pratt, Burundi, Rwanda Paul Rickard, Cambodia Ariel Ricker, Geneva Rachel Roberts, Kenya Christian Romig, Geneva Anisha Singh, India Noah Smith-Drelich, Cambodia Josh Steinman, China Hanna Streng, Geneva Nina Sun, United States Clowie Tan, Singapore Patricia Tarre, Geneva Elene Taturashvili, Geneva Tey Sovannara, Cambodia Angelique Umuhire, China Daniel Urankar, Geneva James Vicente, Geneva Wang Dong, China Jamila Willis, Geneva Marcena Winterscheidt, Cambodia Victor Xu, China Yang Zi, China Khadijah Yasin, Singapore Sarah Yohannes, Geneva Yuan Lu, China Zhang Tianyun, China PHOTOJOURNALISTS Briana Berry, Cambodia Jeffrey Bright, Cambodia, Malaysia Mar Costa, Indonesia Philip Jacobson, Cambodia Michael Kurban, Indonesia Gaston Lacombe, Sri Lanka Sharron Lovell, Philippines Samuel Natale, Indonesia Roshan Nebhrajani, Georgia Beth Rosenberg, India Colette Van der Ven, Philippines Jasmine Van Deventer, Georgia Ayda Wondemu, Philippines IBJ is an NGO in Special Consultative Status with the Economic and Social Council of the United Nations.
Volunteers
Saatvik Ahluwalia, India Carole Amselem, Geneva Jennifer Anderson, Singapore Kirsten Anker, Geneva Caroline Arnaud, Burundi Jean-Claude Barakamfitiye, Burundi Eliana Barragan, Geneva Barbara Bijelic, Cambodia Denesha Brar, Singapore
2 010 d o n o r s
ORGANIZATIONAL DONORS Apax Foundation Chasdrew Foundation Clarence & Dyer LLP Clifford Chance Foundation Clifford Chance LLP Cottier Donz Foundation East West Management Institute European Commission (EuropeAid) Ford Foundation International Bar Association Charitable Trust John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation Kirkland and Ellis Foundation Lien Foundation Marshall Foundation Matrix Chambers Causes Fund National Endowment for Democracy Open Society Institute Open Society Justice Initiative Shearman & Sterling LLP Singapore Economic Development Board Skoll Foundation Unitarian Universalist Congregation of Fairfax United Nations Voluntary Fund for Victims of Torture United States Department of State, Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights, and Labor US-China Legal Cooperation Fund WISE Partnership IN KIND DONATIONS Book Aid International Cognita Schools Google Adwords Hogan Lovells LLP Jones Day Latham & Watkins LLP Lovells LLP Paul Hastings LLP University of Montana, Maureen and Mike Mansfield Center CORPORATE MATCHING GIFTS PROGRAMS Applied Materials Global Impact Goldman Sachs Matching Gifts HP Company Foundation Microsoft Matching Gifts
The event helped IBJ to establish a strong presence in Singapore, its first regional hub.
JusticeMaker Bijaya Chanda, IBJ Legal Program Officer Zhao Hao, and JusticeMakers Nana Chapidze, Harshi Perera, and Jae de la Cruz
IBJ staff and volunteers at the Gala Table sponsors included the Apax Foundation, Mr. Fung, and Rohet Tolani, Managing Director of Tolani Shipping (Singapore) Pte. Ltd. Several Singaporean law firms also provided significant financial support. May Lee, a prominent Asian television personality, conducted the live auction, which included luxury trips, dinners at several top Singapore restaurants, and artwork. Proceeds from the auctions and table sponsorships garnered more than SGD$180,000 to support the SJTC. The event helped IBJ to establish a strong presence in Singapore, its first regional hub. It also served as an opportunity to unite IBJ staff and supporters, spread across different continents, in celebration of IBJs significant work and important achievements.
DONORS OF AUCTION ITEMS AmaSwiss The American Association Greg Anketell Banyan Tree Capella Singapore Country Holidays Travel DVF /Diane von Furstenberg John Erdos Eu Yan Seng Flutes Diana Francis Freja Designs Studio Grand Hyatt Singapore Alison Jordan Kashmira Kolah Kate Love Luxe Car Rental Marina at Keppel Bay Mines Resort & Golf The Prime Society The St. Regis Singapore Ski360 Swissdreams Singapore Taylor B Tippling Club TWG Tea
27
International Bridges to Justice represents an incredibly powerful force for systemic social change.
The Skoll Foundation
INDIVIDUAL DONORS
Our work to advance the rule of law and improve access to legal representation would not be possible without the generous support of many people. In 2010, individual contributions to IBJ amounted to nearly $250,000. This funding helped pay for JusticeMakers Fellowships, criminal defense trainings, roundtable discussions among police, judges, prosecutors, and defenders, and the operating costs of our offices in Asia, Africa, and Geneva. Supporting the work of innovators operating at the grassroots level is the most effective approach to implementing legal reform. It puts resources in the hands of the actors who best know how to use them and directly offers tangible benefits to ordinary people around the world. Your support has made a real difference in IBJs efforts to carry out its mission to ensure access to justice for all. We extend our heartfelt thanks to all of you.
Don Adams David P. Anderson Robert Austin Lily Auyeung Todd Avery Mary Avery Sandy Baggett Naomi Bang Wu Biao Allison Blechman Charles Bourdon Shelley Brody Tracie Brown Richard Buik Nona Cedrone Hilary Chadwick Hon. Bruce Chan Lisa Chanoff Linda Colfax James Collins Francis Crme Thuston Kenneth Cukier Charles and Peixin Dallara Joan Darby Laura Deal Paul Demakis Khuon Denis Dhaval Desai Hui Di Wallace Dietz Banba C. Donnelly Susan Donnelly Juliana Drous Tiffany Easthom Kay Elewski Jodi Erickson Mary Eu Richard Eu Richie Eu Anna Fallows David Fechheimer Sun Feng Andrew Ferguson Marta Ferro Molly Fiffer Ari Fisher Daniel R. Fung David R. Gergen Thomas Halusa Rhonda Hare Zeana Haroun Carl J. Harris Brian Hazlett Paul M. Holland A.M. Hooper-Nguyen Francis Hoskins Jason Humphreys Susan Hutcher Daro Inouye Nancy Jacotbell Renee Jakobs Francis James Betty Jeng Philip Jeyaretnam Jimmie Jones Severa Keith Peter Kenyon Judd King Kusam Kohli Leah Kowalsk Donald Lacey Patricia Lawton Simon Lea Jack Lee Michael Lee Andy Lim Michelle Limaj David Little Chad Livingston Sanjeewa Liyanage Katherine Love Tim Love Bhaskar Maddala Kishore Mahbubani Janet Mangini James Marshall Lynn Matthews Douglas McCandless Morgan McGill Patricia D. McNamara Sharon Meadows James Meriwether Diane Moore Elizabeth Morse Kathy Mulvany James Nee Teresa N. Ng Ruth A. Norris Megan Obourn Karin Ottesen Philip Oxford Michael Ping Wong Candice Reder Brian Rogove Beth Rosenberg Mark Rosenbush Veronica Sanchez Timothy Scheu Amy Schoening Leslie Senke Ivan H. Shim Christine Smith Karen Snell Kevin Snyder Julia Sportolari Steven Starley Michael J. Stirrat Mike Strasser Sandor Straus Susan Suh Greg Suhr Tony Tamburello Edward Choon Leng Tan Sharon Tan Ryan Tarr Raoul Teeuwen Josiah Thompson Elizabeth Tippett Grace Toh Rohet Tolani Rafael Trujillo Karen Tse Kenneth Tse Kathleen Urquhart Donald Van Deventer Louise Van Vliet Luis Velasco Shelley Wallace Mary and Ron Webb Alex Wong Eva Wong Wendell Wong Lyn Woodruff Florence Wuethrich Daniel Wuthrich May Wuthrich Ranko Yamada Mia Yamamoto Jason C. Yoder David H. Zemans Leila Zhang
28
To Karen and your army of public defenders, social defenders the people who are changing the world and giving hope to the people who dont have the ability to speak for themselves: You speak for them. You speak for their rights, you speak for their hearts, and you speak for their hopes. Thank you for everything you are doing, everywhere in the world. Injustice will be eradicated, and IBJ will be the tool, the army, the people who bring love and justice.
Sanford R. Climan, President Entertainment Media Ventures, Inc.
As the world community advances toward social progress and economic prosperity, more countries recognize that embracing the rule of law is crucial to shaping their futures. International Bridges to Justice works effectively with governments to promote responsible change and protect legal rights.
Hilde Schwab, Chairperson & Co-Founder Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship
29
64 rue de Monthoux CH-1201, Geneva, Switzerland [email protected] Phone: +41(0).22.731.24.41 Fax: +41(0).22.731.24.83 www.ibj.org