Analyzing Philosophical Concepts of Self
Analyzing Philosophical Concepts of Self
C1-UNDE
RST
ANDI
NGT
HES
ELF
Na
me: Ha
mda
n I
sma
el P. S
auma
y
Cl
assS
che
dul
e:T
ue,
4:00-
5:30
E
XERCI
SES
A.
Tex
tua
lAna
lys
is.
Expl
ai
nea
choft
hef
oll
owi
ngpa
ssa
ges
.
Rubr
ics
:
Cont
ent:
50%
Me
cha
nic
s(g
ramma
r): 50%
“Ia
mthewi
ses
tma
nal
i
ve,f
orIk
nowonet
hing
,andt
hat
i
s,t
hatI
knownot
hing“
(
Soc
rat
es)Pl
atot
heRe
publ
i
c
I
nthi
sphr
ases
tat
etha
tWepe
opl
ebor
nandna
tur
edi
nus
t
oknowonet
hinga
ngt
hati
swek
nownot
hing
,Asf
ara
swe
t
rav
eli
nthi
swor
ld,wea
rei
nte
rac
ti
ngwi
tht
hepe
opl
e
ha
vingt
hate
xpe
rie
nce
s,i
dea
sandpe
rce
pti
ona
ndt
huswe
a
rec
apa
bleofl
ear
ningi
tca
usewea
rea
llwi
ses
tma
nal
i
ve
a
ndf
orust
oknowonet
hing
,Iti
sst
art
edt
oknownot
hing
.
“Idi
scov
ert
hatt
her
ear
eot
hermi
ndsi
nunde
rst
andi
ng
wha
tot
herpe
opl
esa
yanddo”
.
Gi
l
ber
tRy
le,
TheConc
eptofMi
nd
I
nthi
sphr
ase
,Imus
tsa
yiti
squi
tec
ompl
i
cat
edbuti
fwe
l
ookc
los
elya
ndunde
rst
andi
t,Wec
ans
eet
her
eal
thoug
ht.
F
ormea
sIbe
li
evet
hatourmi
ndsi
sdi
vi
dedi
ntomul
ti
pl
e
i
nte
ll
ect
uala
cti
vi
ty,T
hepa
rtsofourbr
ainsha
sthepa
rtof
t
hink
ingl
ogi
cal
,sol
vi
ngma
th,a
nal
ysi
ngwha
twer
eada
nd
e
tc.T
hisc
anbea
nex
ampl
etha
tweha
veourot
hermi
nds
t
ounde
rst
andwha
tot
herpe
opl
esa
yanddo.T
osi
mpl
i
fy
t
hisi
dea
,Weha
vea
llk
nowt
hati
fot
herpe
opl
eornotus
ual
pe
opl
ewec
ommuni
cat
e,i
snotwor
thyofourt
rus
tthuswe
ha
vea
not
hermi
ndt
othi
nkwha
tthe
ysa
yanddot
hanwha
t
weus
ual
l
ythi
nkoni
t.I
t'
sme
answec
anha
vedoubt
ing
i
nst
eadofbe
li
evi
ng.
“
Looki
ntot
hede
pthsofy
ourowns
oula
ndl
ear
nfi
rs
tto
k
now y
our
sel
f,t
heny
ouwi
l
lunde
rst
andwhyt
hisi
l
lnes
s
wa
sbound t
ocome upon y
ou a
nd pe
rha
psy
ou wi
l
l
t
henc
efor
tha
voi
dfa
ll
ingi
l
l”
S
igmundF
reud,
Cha
rac
tera
ndCul
tur
e
Myowna
nal
ysi
sont
hisphr
ase
,Iwoul
dsa
yiti
sve
yus
ual
oni
t.F
ore
xampl
eweha
veadi
abe
tesa
ndt
hiss
tag
ewewi
l
l
i
mag
inewha
twa
swe
'vedonet
oha
vet
hisk
indofi
l
lne
ss.
S
impl
yweputa
nana
lys
isa
ndbyt
hatwel
ook
ingour
de
ppe
rse
lft
oex
ami
nedt
hisa
ndt
huswec
anr
eal
i
zet
hati
f
wedon'
tdoha
ves
omuc
hcons
umi
ngofs
uga
randpe
rha
ps
wewi
l
lthe
nce
for
tha
voi
dfa
ll
ingi
l
l.I
nconne
cti
ont
oour
e
mot
[Link]
tha
veourde
epe
stunde
rst
andi
ngi
nour
owns
elft
opr
eve
ntt
hisk
indofs
adne
ssa
ndpe
rha
pswe
i
nst
eadha
veaha
ppi
nes
sfor
eve
r.
“
Allourk
nowl
edg
ebe
ginswi
tht
hes
ens
es,pr
oce
edst
hen
t
otheunde
rst
andi
ng,a
nde
ndswi
thr
eas
on.T
her
eis
not
hinghi
ghert
hanr
eas
on.
”
-I
mma
nue
lKa
nt,
Cri
ti
queofPur
eRe
ason
- T
his phr
ase i
ts a
ll a
bout t
he na
tur
e of
unde
rst
andi
nge
veni
nani
nse
ctora
nani
mal
.I
tisa
lls
tar
ted
i
nse
nse
[Link]
atc
ans
ens
etha
tthe
rei
sdogbys
mel
l
ingorby
us
ings
ens
eofs
ight
.Anda
fte
rtha
titwi
l
lrol
lini
t'
smi
nd
t
hatwha
tdoe
sthi
sdogdoi
nghe
re,Andt
husi
t'
swi
l
lfi
nal
l
y
g
etst
hatt
her
eas
onofdogi
siti
shung
rya
ndi
tne
edst
o
t
hie
fca
t''
sfood.T
hati
sthena
tur
eofunde
rst
andi
ng,we
a
lsope
opl
eca
nus
eof
fourc
ommons
ens
etounde
rst
and
t
heones
tra
nge
rtha
tfol
l
owi
ngy
ouwa
lki
ngi
nthemi
ddl
e
ni
ghta
ndy
ouf
ina
ll
yunde
rst
andt
hati
tisf
oll
owi
ngy
ou
be
caus
ehea
reg
oingt
osna
tchy
[Link]
fte
ryou
r
eal
i
zet
hatt
her
eas
onofs
nat
chi
ngy
oui
shene
edamone
y
orma
ybey
oul
ooks
ori
cha
ndi
tisi
nte
nde
dhi
mfory
out
o
s
nat
ch.
Asa
dst
orybutav
erys
impl
eana
lys
isoft
hisphr
ase
.
“
Andwha
tmor
eamI
?Il
ookf
ora
idt
othei
mag
ina
tion[
But
howmi
st
ake
nly
!]Ia
mnott
hea
sse
mbl
ageofl
i
mbswec
all
t
he huma
n body
;Ia
m nota s
ubt
le pe
net
rat
ing a
ir
di
st
ri
but
edt
hroug
outa
llt
hes
eme
mbe
rs;I
amnotawi
nd,
a
f
ir
e,av
apor,
abr
eat
hora
nyt
hinga
tal
ltha
tIc
ani
mag
ine
.I
a
msuppos
inga
llt
hes
ethi
ngst
obenot
hing
.Ye
tIf
ind,
whi
l
e
s
odoi
ng,
tha
tIa
mst
il
las
sur
edt
hatI
amas
ome
thi
ng.
”
-
ReneDe
scr
tes
,Me
dit
ati
onsonF
irs
tPhi
l
osophy
-
Mya
nal
ysi
sist
hatwepeopl
eha
veourownde
sir
esa
nd
wek
eepi
ngi
tli
mit
les
sbuta
tthee
ndoft
heda
ywe
i
mag
ine
dtha
tal
li
snot
hing
.Si
mpl
ywes
tar
tedt
odr
eami
n
ourl
i
fet
hatwec
anbes
ome
thi
ngbe
tte
rtoha
vea
ndt
he
da
ysg
oonwer
eal
i
zet
hat
'swhyCa
n'tIl
eti
tbe
.itwi
l
lal
l
g
ene
rat
einourmi
ndt
hata
lli
smi
st
ake
s,wedot
hing
s
i
mpos
sibl
ebutwef
ai
ltounde
rst
andt
hatwea
rel
i
mit
ed.
Wec
an'
tfl
yast
hebi
rdbutwe i
nst
eadwa
lka
ndha
veour
r
idi
ngmot
ort
hat
'sbi
rdsc
an'
t,Whyc
an'
tweha
vet
his
mi
nds
ett
hati
tisus
,Wemus
tke
epi
nourmi
ndt
hatwha
tis
bi
rdc
andoi
swha
twec
an'
tdo,Oh Di
dyoui
mag
inea
ma
nfl
yi
nga
ndha
vet
hatwi
ngsi
nhi
sba
ck,s
owha
t'sdoe
s
peopl
ecl
ai
m t
haty
ou a
re my
ste
rious r
idi
cul
ous or
a
ccur
sed?
.Anda
tthee
ndoft
heda
yyour
eal
i
zet
hati
sis
notg
ood,i
tisnotwha
tyoue
xpe
cte
dfora
ndi
tise
ndswi
th
not
hing
.
“Whe
the
riti
saque
sti
onofmybody,t
hena
tur
alwor
ld,
t
hepa
st,bi
rt
hordea
th,t
heques
ti
oni
sal
way
stok
now
howIc
anbeope
ntophe
nome
nat
hatt
rans
cendmet
hat
,
ne
ver
the
les
s,onl
yex
istt
othee
xte
ntt
hatIt
aket
hem up
a
ndl
i
vet
hem.
”
-
Mer
lea
u-P
ont
y,Phe
nome
nol
ogyofP
erc
ept
ion
-T
hisphr
asei
sape
rce
pti
onofha
vingy
ours
elfa
san
uni
queorma
kingy
oudi
st
inc
tfr
omot
her
s.I
tisv
eryus
ual
in
us
.Wek
eepour
sel
vesi
nthet
opt
hatnoonewoul
dre
ach
y
ou,I
tme
ansy
ou ha
veat
rans
cende
nta
lmi
nd.T
he
que
sti
oni
swhywedot
hisbe
caus
ewene
edorwewa
nte
d.
Y
ouc
anus
ethi
smi
nds
ett
obeont
opbutnota
llma
tte
rs
a
cce
pti
t. Ne
ver
the
les
sIti
sonl
yex
istt
hatIt
aket
hemup
a
ndl
i
vet
hem onmyt
rans
cende
nta
lwor
ldnott
hena
tur
al
one
.