Grease Urea
Grease Urea
net/publication/327217290
CITATIONS READS
18 338
5 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Anton Lyadov on 25 March 2024.
REVIEWS
*e-mail: [email protected]
Abstract—The review deals with greases in which organic ureas of various compositions and structures are
used as thickeners. The nature of compounds participating in the synthesis of organic ureas and the main types
of polyurea thickeners are considered. The physicochemical, tribological, and operation properties of plastic
polyurea lubricants are discussed.
DOI: 10.1134/S1070427218060010
Today it is impossible to imagine the operation Table 2 illustrates the diversity of the modern
of any friction unit without using greases. Greases assortment of greases [1]. By combining base oil,
are semisolid lubricants consisting, as a rule, of two thickener, and additives, it is possible to obtain an
main components: base oil and thickener. The use and unlimited number of lubricant formulations for
composition of greases was mentioned for the first various purposes with a wide spectrum of operation
time in the survived sources from the Ancient Egypt. characteristics.
In the XIX century, soaps came into active use as Vigorous progress of technologies and engineering
thickeners. These thickeners still play an important and the development of high-capacity installations
role in production of greases. The brief history of the and aggregates made the requirements to lubricants
origination and development of greases is given in considerably more stringent. Often lubricants with soap
Table 1. thickeners no longer met these requirements, which led
Table 1. Origination chronology for various types of greases
Date Event
About 1400 BC The use of animal fat and limestone for lubrication of axes of Hittite chariots was started. In the same
period, lubricants based on olive oil and limestone were used in Ancient Egypt
1845 A lubricant consisting of mineral oil, animal fat, and limestone was invented in the United States
1853 The first sodium lubricant based on beef fat appeared in the United Kingdom
1912 The production of calcium lubricants with the dispersion medium based on mineral oil was started
in Japan
1938 Lithium lubricants were developed. They quickly conquered the world and were used as
multipurpose lubricants
1954 Invention of complex aluminum lubricants for operation at high temperatures
1955 Invention of urea greases in the United States
885
886 LYADOV et al.
This reaction is exothermic and readily occurs with- traditionally termed polyureas. True polyureas can also
out any additional actions. Despite the fact that diureas be used as thickeners. They are prepared by copolymer-
are used in most cases as thickeners, these additives are ization of appropriate diisocyanates and diamines:
The following isocyanates are used for preparing diisocyanate), PIC (polyisocyanate), and TDI (toluene
polyureas most widely: MDI (diphenylmethane diisocyanate):
MDI TDI
MDI, in particular, the 4,4′ isomer, is the most the lubricant industry after the end of the World War II.
produced diisocyanate in the world (market share about Despite the fact that the technology of their production
60%). Commercial PIC (polyisocyanate) is a mixture was developed in the United States, urea greases became
of products: 55% MDI, 25% triisocyanates, and 20% the most widely used in Japan, where their market share
polyisocyanates [5]. TDI is mainly produced as 2,4 is still about 21%. Data on the production of various
isomer, and its market share is about 30%. types of lubricants in various countries and regions are
Among amines, primary amines, namely, aniline, given in Table 3. As can be seen, PU lubricants were
individual aliphatic amines (octylamine, dodecylamine, initially produced only in Japan, China, and North
octadecylamine produced under trade name Rofamin-t America. In 2011, the situation slightly changed, and
or Flotamin), or their mixtures, are used for preparing production of these lubricants was started in Europe
urea thickeners most widely. (Fig. 1) [6].
The total production share of urea greases in the
COUNTRIES AND REGIONS PRODUCING
world, according to different estimates, does not exceed
POLYUREA LUBRICANTS
4–5%. Today in Russia there is only one enterprise
The development of plastic polyurea lubricants (PU having its own production of PU lubricants for various
lubricants) is one of the most significant discoveries in purposes, Elektrogorsk Institute of Oil Refining. The
Other
Aluminum
Polyurea
Calcium
Lithium
Fig. 1. Share of PU lubricants in the total lubricant production volume for different regions (as for 2011).
total production capacity of this enterprise is 500 t 23% of all the urea greases produced in the world
annually, which meets the demand of the Russian are consumed by agricultural enterprises, because these
Federation for this product and allows the import of lubricants are versatile and can be used in friction units
analogs to be fully abandoned. of various structures. Thus, farmers can ensure reliable
The main companies producing urea greases in the operation of diverse agricultural machines by purchasing
world and supplying them to the Russian market are only a single lubricant. The share of machine-building
Clariant, Mobil, and BASF. There are also several tens and automotive industries is 17% each, and the share of
of smaller companies producing these lubricants. The the metallurgical industry is 10%. The best illustration
final consumers of PU lubricants and their distribution is the example of metallurgical industry, where soap
are shown in Fig. 2. lubricants are replaced by urea greases, because the
modern continuous casting mills with centralized
feeding system mainly use urea greases as exhibiting
high heat resistance, good pumpability, and excellent
water resistance. That is why metallurgical enterprises
are the major consumers of urea greases in Russia.
Machine
building
Agriculture BASE OILS FOR UREA GREASES
17%
23%
Base oils of any group are suitable for preparing
greases with thickeners based on organic ureas, except
Other polyorganosiloxanes, which in the pure form cannot be
17% thickened with ureas. However, numerous lubricants
Metallurgical based on polysiloxanes are available. Mixtures of poly-
industry siloxanes with mineral or synthetic base oils are used
23% for their production. It should be noted that producers
Automotive of greases started to actively use silicone liquids for
y 6%
Fig. 3. Scheme of an installation developed by STRATCO for production of urea greases: (1) vertical reactor, (2) intermediate vessel,
(3) pumps, (4) filter, (5) homogenizer, and (6) product output for packaging.
The physicochemical and operation characteristics (1) IR spectroscopy. The IR spectrum of urea greases
of urea greases prepared using ready organic ureas and has the following characteristic absorption bands
those synthesized in the base oil in situ were compared belonging to polyureas: 3310–3323 and 1610 cm–1 [28].
in some studies [25, 26]. It is, however, impossible to
(2) Thermal gravimetric analysis and differential
make unambiguous conclusions on what technology is
scanning calorimetry furnish information on the heat
preferable.
resistance of lubricants and on the presence or absence
PHYSICOCHEMICAL METHODS USED FOR of ash upon combustion of such lubricants.
CHARACTERIZATION OF UREA GREASES (3) Scanning electron microscopy allows studying
Determination of physicochemical characteristics is the morphology of lubricant thickeners.
an essential step in the development of new lubricants. Figure 4 shows an electron micrograph of urea
There are a number of parameters whose determination thickener isolated from a lubricant [29].
is obligatory, and procedures for their determination Along with laboratory studies, rig and industrial
are prescribed by the corresponding standards [GOST trials are also important. They are performed in cases
(State Standard), ASTM, DIN]. The main parameters when the lubricant being developed meets all the
that should be determined are as follows: requirements and the conclusion on its suitability for
– external appearance; industrial operation should be formulated. There are
– penetration at 25°С, 0.1 mm (GOST 5346–78); numerous procedures for diverse rig trials of lubricants,
– dropping point (GOST 6793–74); developed taking into account the parameters whose
determination is necessary. An example is a rig for
– ultimate strength (GOST 7143–73);
studying the pumpability of a lubricant in centralized
– colloidal stability (GOST 7142–74); feeding systems developed by SKF [30]. The final step
– corrosion action on metals (GOST 9.080–77); of the development of a lubricant involves industrial
– mechanical impurities. trials on specific friction units at enterprises that produce
Along with physicochemical studies, there are lubricants or use them [31].
approximately 30 standard mechanodynamical tests
PHYSICOCHEMICAL, TRIBOLOGICAL,
and numerous tests developed by lubricant producers.
AND OPERATION PROPERTIES
For example, the Kluber company developed 17 own OF UREA GREASES
mechanodynamic tests [27].
Along with the determination of these parameters, The greases with different types of thickeners are
there are numerous modern methods allowing compre- compared in Table 4. As can be seen, urea grease surpass
hensive study of lubricants on different levels. lubricants with other thickeners in all the parameters,
which allows their operation in various friction units in of the hydrocarbon substituents in the diurea structure.
a wide range of conditions. A study of the tribological properties of lubricants has
The structure of the urea thickener can significantly shown that the wear spot diameter tends to increase with
influence the physicochemical and tribological charac- an increase in the number of carbon atoms in the diurea
teristics of lubricants. The properties of lubricants in molecule. This fact well agrees with the results obtained
relation to the structure of organic urea are compared in studying the colloidal stability of the lubricants.
in Table 5 [29]. The lubricants thickened with diureas The results of studying the influence exerted by the
have the best operation properties. The use of aromatic degree of oligomerization of urea on physicochemical
diureas allows preparation of the most stable lubricants. and tribological properties of lubricants are described
Diureas containing both aromatic and aliphatic substitu- in [41]. Lubricants based on the same oil, thickened
ents are used very frequently for preparing multipurpose with di-, tetra-, hexa-, and octaureas, were prepared.
urea greases, which allows reaching better operation Diphenylmethane 4,4′-diisocyanate was used. An
characteristics. increase in the number of units in the oligourea
Numerous studies deal with the influence of molecule led to an increase in the colloidal stability
and ultimate strength, but the penetration and wear spot
the composition and structure of organic ureas on
the physicochemical, tribological, and operation
characteristics of greases thickened with them [32–40].
Studies are also performed to evaluate the stability of
urea greases under various operation conditions in
relation to the design of the friction unit and external
conditions of the tribocontact [41–49].
The length of hydrocarbon substituents in diureas
influences the lubricant properties. For example, the
ultimate strength, which is an important parameter of
greases, under equal other conditions increases with
an increase in the number of carbon atoms in the
hydrocarbon substituents in the amine moiety of the
diurea molecule, which suggests formation of a stronger
structural framework of the grease. Similar trend was
observed for the colloidal stability. With an increase
in the number of atoms in the diurea molecule, the
colloidal stability is improved, which is manifested in a
decrease in the amount of oil separated in the course of
testing the lubricants at elevated temperatures. The drop Fig. 4. TEM image of aliphatic diurea separated from urea
point tends to increase with an increase in the length greases.
Table 5. Comparison of urea greases differing in the type of the organic urea
Maximal Water Ultimate
Urea type operation Lubricant characteristics
resistance strength
temperature, °C
diameter increased also, which is a negative factor for greases are comparable with other lubricants with the
the operation of greases. same base oils, and their water resistance is close to that
Because organic ureas are thermally stable compounds of soap lubricants [50].
(Fig. 5) and start to decompose at temperatures higher One more important advantage of urea greases is
than 200°С, the choice of appropriate base oils allows their compatibility with other kinds of lubricants [51].
preparation of greases suitable for operation at high As seen from Table 6, urea greases are compatible
temperatures. with all the kinds of lubricants except those thickened
with the barium complex with which they are partially
The radiation resistance of organic ureas is higher compatible. This fact is important for practice, because
than that of other lubricants, especially soap lubricants. the lubricants can be replaced without cleaning the
Therefore, urea greases were recommended for use in friction units and centralized systems for feeding
atomic power engineering. In adhesion properties, urea lubricating materials.