Understanding Globalization: Key Concepts
Understanding Globalization: Key Concepts
DEFINING GLOBALIZATION ● Steger (2005) explains that globalization has been commonly understood either as a process,
a condition, or an ideology.
NAME/SCHOLAR/REFERENCE DEFINITION
As a Process:
Giddens (1990:4) the "intensification of worldwide social relations which link 1. Worldwide social interdependencies and exchanges while at the same time fostering in people
distant localities in such a way that local happenings are shaped a growing awareness of deepening connections between the local and the distant" (Steger,
by events occurring many miles away and vice versa"
2005: 13).
Robertsons (1992:8) refers both to the compression of the world and the a. Argument: about the compression of time and space brought about by changes in
intensification of consciousness of the world as a whole...
technology and the political, cultural, and economic aspects of human existence.
Harvey (1989) introduced globalization as the compression of time and space
and the annihilation of distance Table 1. Globalization according to Social Science and Human Disciplines
Sunny Levin Institute a process of interaction and integration among the people,
companies, and governments of different nations, a process
driven by international trade and investment and aided by Disciplines Time Agency/Domain Keywords
information technology
Supporting Facts:
1.) Globalization was first used as a term in academic circles in the decades of 1960s and 1970s
Geography Space, Place Local Global interaction,
(Nederveen Peterse, 2012; Steger, 2005) but had gained wide interest in the 1990s. Glocalization
2.) Scholars from the traditional disciplines of political science, economics, history, sociology, and
philosophy have examined globalization using the analytical tools and methods provided by their
respective disciplines.
a.) Historians, for instance, are more interested in determining whether globalization is Economics 1970 Multinational corporations, Global corporations, world
really a modern phenomenon. technologies, banks, finance product, global value chains,
hedge funds new economy, sovereign
b.) Economists, on the other hand, look into the changing patterns of international trade
wealth funds
and commerce as well as the unequal distribution of wealth.
c.) Political scientists focus more on the impact of the forces of globalization, such as the
international non-governmental organizations and international organizations, on the
state and vice versa.
Globalization as a condition
Cultural studies Media, film, advertising, ICT Global village, ● Globalization is also referred to by scholars as globality.
McDonaldization,
Disneyfication, hybridization Scholte’s (2008) idea, argument, and concept
● globality as a social condition characterized by trans-planetary connectivity and supra-
territoriality.
Trans- planetary relations Supra-territorial relations
Philosophy 1950 Ethics Global problems, global
Ethics
● establishment of social links between people ● Social connections that transcend territorial
located at different places of our planet. geography” (Scholte, 2008: 1480).
Sociology 1800 Modernity Capitalism, Industrialism, ● Planet is not treated as a collection of ● social condition is characterized by thick
urbanization, nation states geographical units but as social space or an economic, political, and cultural
arena of social life interconnections and global flows that render
political borders and economic barriers
irrelevant (Steger, 2008).
Political Economy 1500 Modern Capitalism Conquest of the World Market Globalization as an Ideology:
Michael Freeden’s ideas, concepts, and arguments,
● Globalization exists in people`s consciousness because it consists of a set of coherent and
History, Historical 3000 BCE Population movement, trade, The widening scale of global, complementary ideas and beliefs about the global order.
anthropology technologies, world religions corporation, Global flows,
ecumene.
The 6 Core Claims
1.) Globalization is about the liberation and global integration of markets or as stated
succinctly in a Business Week article published in the late 1990s: “Globalization is about the
Biology, ecology Time Integration of ecosystems Evolution, Global ecology, triumph of markets over governments” (quoted in Steger 2005)
Gaia 2.) Globalization is inevitable and irreversible. State leaders pushing for neoliberal policies have
been heard proclaiming that globalization is happening and cannot be stopped, as it was a
global wave that has been sweeping the world.
Source: Nederveen Pieterse, Jan (2012) “Periodizing Globalization: Histories of Globalization, “New 3.) Nobody is in charge of globalization. Globalization does not promote the agenda of any
Global Studies, Vol.6, Issue 2, Article 1. specific class or group. In this sense, globalist are not dictating their own agenda on people.
4.) Globalization benefits everyone in the long run. Free trade and free market, globalist believe,
Flynn and Giraldez (2006) ideas, arguments, and concepts. will bring wealth and prosperity to everyone.
● Globalization is synonymous to permanent global trade, which began when all the major 5.) Globalization furthers the spread of democracy. Although democracy and freedom
regions of the world "exchange products continuously...and on a scale that generated deep and compromise a particular type of political system while free markets and free trade refer to a
lasting impacts on all trading partners" particular economic system
● They conclude that the birth of globalization took place in 1571, the year Manila was founded 6.) Globalization requires a global war on terror. This belief, which resulted from the 9-11
as a Spanish entrepot connecting Asia and the Americas. attack, combines the idea of economic globalization with the American brand of right-wing
foreign policy (openly militaristic and nationalistic).
The Impact of Globalization on the Academe Globalization as universalization and westernization
The advent of globalization in the 1970s had greatly affected the academic world as it Universalization Westernization Globalization
immediately gained the interest and attention of most social scientists, who were occupied with social
phenomena related to globalization. A process of spreading various Just a variant of Universalization Homogenization of culture,
objects, practices, and together with neo-colonialism, politics, economy, and laws
experiences to the different parts Americanization, or
Domain Questions of the planet Mcdonaldization
● Should be based on domain questions, which provide the assumptive bases for theorizing
(Robinson, 2005).
Theoretical paradigms associated with globalization.
World Systems Paradigm
Misconceptions about globalization
● Proponent: Immanuel Wallerstein,
● Idea/s: globalization not as a recent phenomenon but as virtually synonymous with the birth and
Globalization as internationalization
spread of world capitalism
● The terms internationalization and globalization are interchangeable, there is a big difference in
● Argument: the appropriate unit of analysis for macro-social inquiry in the modern world is neither
their meanings.
class, nor state/society, or country, but the larger historical system, in which these categories
Internationalization Globalization are located.
● Concept: capitalism has created a global enterprise that swept the 19th century leading to the
Activities by entities such as corporations, states, Includes a gamut of human activities that do not present time.
international organizations, private organizations, require reference to a state's national borders ● System: Core as Capital Intensive, Semi Periphery as Capital and Labor Intensive, Periphery
and even individuals with reference to national as Labor Intensive.
borders and national governments
○ Semi Periphery is former Labor Intensive states that achieved development
Keynesianism
From a Unilateral to a Multilateral Trade Order ● Keynesianism: Government Spending as a solution to revive economy through bolstering
aggregate demand through fiscal and monetary policies
● Mercantilist period: 17th and 18th century ● Ideas of John Maynard Keynes (British Economist)
○ European International Trade, Colonial Expansionism and surplus of accumulation of ● The General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money
gold stocks in the balance-of-payment: boosted exports and curtailed import (Benczes, ● Argument: Market-generated equilibrium results in unemployment which causes a decrease in
2014). demand.
● Zero-sum game (the loss of the others is the gain of the one): beggar-thy-neighbor policies
resulting in trade wars.
● 19th century: Industrialization advance trade liberalization under the leadership of UK
Keynes' liberal interventionism approach ○ To maintain international peace and order.
● influenced states to invest in big governments and shaped the post-war global economic Global Governance
order that is grounded on the Keynesian compromise of promoting open markets without ● Defined as “The formal and informal arrangements that produce degree of order and collective
undermining the protection of the society and the domestic market. action above the state in the absence of global government”
● Problem: challenge during the economic crisis of stagflation (rising unemployment and inflation). ○ Involves coordination among state and non-state actors (Young, 1922: 2).
Liberalism
● Key neoliberal policies were privatization, deregulation, lesser public spending, and reduced The United Nations (UN)
corporate taxes. ● Primary organization for international cooperation, peace, and security.
Washington Consensus ○ Only organization that can authorize the use of force against an aggressor.
● a set of ten economic policy prescriptions for the recovering and crisis-ridden countries ■ Primary Concern: Collective Military Security (Chapter VII of the UN Charter)
implemented by Washington-based institutions through the facilitation of peaceful settelement of dispute among member states
1. Fiscal discipline (Chapter VI) or by [commanding allegiance of the entire UN memberships;
2. Reordering Public Expenditure Priorities sanctions].
3. Tax Reform ● Primary Objectives: Ensure Peace and Order
4. Liberalizing Interest Rates ○ As an organization can be a conflict actor in itself or an instrument for action driven by
5. A Competitive Exchange Rate the interests of particular states.
6. Trade Liberalization ■ UN membership-directed organization and the members are all states. This
7. Liberalization of Inward Foreign Direct Investment strongly affects what it can do.
8. Privatization
9. Deregulation The Six Principal Council Organs (Article 7, Chapter III)
10. Property Rights ● The UN established six principal council organs in 1945.
○ Economics and Social Council (ECOSOC)
PROBLEMS OF NEOLIBERALISM ○ Trusteeship Council
● Transnational and national resistance due to the widening gap between North and South. ○ International Court of Justice
● Zapatista Movement in Mexico ○ General Assembly
○ Against the North American Free Trade Agreement and the Battle of Seattle during the ○ Security Council
WTO Ministerial Conference in the 1990s were the prominent transnational movements ○ Secretariat
that first sought to challenge against global capitalism and neoliberal globalization.
● Broader collective resistance known as the “global justice movement” Economic and Social Council
● However, global civil society continues to persistently and relentlessly expose the ills of today’s ● ECOSOC’s primary objective is to advance the economic, social, and environmental dimensions
global economic system. of sustainable development.
○ Gateway of the UN’s partnership with the rest of the world for the coordination, policy
UNIT 3: GLOBAL INTERSTATE SYSTEM AND GLOBAL GOVERNANCE review, dialogue, recommendations, and implementation of international development
The Anarchic World goals.
● No overpowering state-like entity imposes rules and order. ■ Composition: 54 elected member by the General Assembly for overlapping
○ Imperative that the Nation state imposes its sovereign power within it domain. three-year term (Chapter X).
○ The state is legitimate user of physical violence (Weber, 1964) through its military and ● The IMF and WB
police apparatus, together with its territorial, fiscal, and ideological monopolies ○ Specialized agencies and independent organizations that are affiliated with UN.
(Wallensteen, 2012). ■ Issue yearly reports to the ECOSOC
● The global system is anarchic, and this necessitates global governance ○ WTO on the other hand is related but not specialized, not required to do the same
○ World Summit of 2005 expanded the agenda in crises urging international responsibility
Trusteeship Council to protect exposed populations against mass violation of human rights, ethnic cleansing,
● Main Organ of the UN (Chapter XIII) to provide international supervision of the Trust Territories or genocide
that are under the administration of seven-member states ● The military intervention's legal status remains contested and is considered to be "a failed case
○ To ensure that adequate steps are being made to prepare the people of Trust Territories of international law and R2P since the international community saved Benghazi but lost Libya"
for self-governance. (Teimouri & Subedi, 2018: 31).
○ 11 Trust Territories achieved independence in 1994
● Operation was suspended and will meet whenever an occasion is needed Structural feature of SC
● PMs has the right or power to Veto against a substantive resolution
International Court Of Justice ○ Serves as a measure to protect states from possible threats to independence to ensure
● UN’s principal judicial organ (Chapter XIV) that UN will not be used to serve the interest of particular states.
● Settle legal disputes between states (contentious cases) and to provide advisory opinions on ● Sixth Veto or hidden Veto
legal questions referred by the UN organs and specialized agencies, in accordance with ● At least seven non-permanent members of council to prevent the nine needed votes
international law (advisory proceedings) (International Court of Justice, 2018). from reaching a decision (Wallensteen, 2012).
Security Council ● Ideal Voting System: unity, consensus, and compromise which is not present in League of
● Potent organ with the power to make legally binding resolutions. Nations
○ Compose of the strongest Military States ○ Used instrument by major powers to target Germany, Italy, and Japan.
○ A concrete manifestation of power dynamics. ● the UN Charter was never intended to espouse sovereign equality; the structural feature of the
● Composition: 15 member UN Charter-veto-is a result of an international compromise allied powers of Second World War
○ The Permanent 5 (P-5): Russia, China, Great Britain, France, & US (Carswell, 2013).
○ Granted by the US Charter (Chapter V)
■ These states are allies in WWII and nuclear states. The safeguards to sovereignty
○ The remaining seats are elected non-permanent members (NPM) elected by the ● the veto: also serve as a severe problem. When major powers are directly or indirectly involved
General Assembly (GA) for overlapping 2 years. in a conflict, it renders the also serve as a severe the Syrian armed conflict.
■ 5 states from Africa and Asian States, 1 from Eastern Europe States, 2 States
from Latin American States, 2 from Western Europe and other States. Maintaining Peace and Order
● Sanctions, Peacekeeping, Peace Enforcement.
Article 24 of the UN Charter ○ Sanctions: Non-Military measures of economic, trade or diplomatic sanctions, and
● states that the SC is mandated to act on behalf of the entire UN body to fulfill its primary targeted measures on groups particular individuals such as travel bans, financial and
responsibility for maintaining peace and security. diplomatic restrictions.
○ Functions: investigating any situations that has the potential of creating international ● Peacekeeping is also a useful tool employed by the UN in assist host countries struggling from
tensions; call for military action towards an aggressor or threat; impose economic armed conflict. UN peacekeepers are deployed to provide security to populations and political
sanctions and other measures; determine the existence of a breach of peace and and peace building support to countries transition from conflict to peace
actions be pursued. ● The blurring of lines between peacekeeping has amalgamated UN intervention with war-fighting
Article 39 (Ramsbotham et al., 2016).
● The council has the authority to determine breach in international peace
● Crisis situations can be categorized as a threat to the peace, a breach of the peace' or an act
of aggression
General Assembly
● Universal representation with all 193 member states represented in the body
● GA decides essential questions with a simple majority, while concerns related to peace and
security, budgetary matters, and new memberships admissions require a 2/3 majority.
● GA meets annually: General debates and Session participated bu several heads of the state
○ Elects GA President and 21 Vice Presidents every session for a one-year term
■ Elected according to equitable geographical representations
The Secretariat
● comprise a Secretary General and such staff as the Organization may require. The Secretary-
General shall be appointed by the General Assembly upon the recommendation of the Security
Council.