Cadmium Removal via Micro-Bubble Flotation
Cadmium Removal via Micro-Bubble Flotation
net/publication/318307828
CITATIONS READS
0 196
3 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Baseem Al-Sabbagh on 16 July 2019.
Abstract
In this work, microbubble dispersed air flotation technique was applied for cadmium ions removal from wastewater aqueous
solution. Experiments parameters such as pH (3, 4, 5, and 6), initial Cd(II) ions concentration (40, 80, and 120 mg/l) contact time( 2,
5, 10 , 15, and 20min), and surfactant (10, 20and 40mg/l) were studied in order to optimize the best conditions .The experimental
results indicate that microbubbles were quite effective in removing cadmium ions and the anionic surfactant SDS was found to be
more efficient than cationic CTAB in flotation process. 92.3% maximum removal efficiency achieved through 15min at pH 5, SDS
surfactant concentration 20mg/l, flow rate250 cm3/min and at 40mg/l Cd(II) ions initial concentration. The removal efficiency of
cadmium ion was predicted through 11 neurons hidden layer, with a correlation coefficient of 0.9997 between ANN outputs and the
experimental data and through sensitivity analysis, pH was found to be most significant parameter (25.13 %).The kinetic flotation
order for cadmium ions almost first order and the removal rate constant (k) increases with decreasing the initial metal concentration.
Keywords: cadmium ions, flotation, microbubbles, ANN model, kinetic flotation rate.
https://doi.org/10.31699/IJCPE.2019.2.1
Corresponding Authors: Name: Abeer I. Alwared , Email: [email protected], Name: Nada Abdulrazzaq, Email:
[email protected], Name: Baseem Al-Sabbagh, Email: [email protected]
IJCPE is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
Dissolved air flotation with microbubbles, treating SAMTONG) in which it was compressed from1 bar to up
water, wastewater and domestic sewage is known for a to 7 bar and then passed into the microbubble generator
number of years and is now gradually entering in the (MBG) which consists of a ceramic micro-porous diffuser
mining environmental area [12]. Though there are several (Point Four TM diffuser) (Riverforest Corporation, USA,
studies on the removal of heavy metal by dispersed air AS MK-III). The dissolution of gas into the solution was
flotation such as those applied by[13][14][15], more of achieved inside the MBG by applying a high pressure.
them used frother in order to reduce the size of the air The microbubbles (mean diameter= 100μm) were
bubbles in a flotation cell to present sufficient surface generated by the release of pressure, and then entered to
area for collection. the tank through a pre-calibrated rotameter (0-
Artificial Neural Network are powerful techniques used 2.5cm3/min). The desired concentration of cadmium ions
in modeling complex systems that seeks to simulate was prepared by dissolving the calculated amount of
human brain behavior by treatment of data on the basis of Cd(NO3)2.4H2O in distilled water. The main
trial and error. ANN has been identified as tool to physicochemical properties of the cadmium ions was
determine and optimize complicated nonlinear shown in Table 1 .Cd(II) ions feed gently from the top of
relationships between parameters [16]. the tank. Simultaneously, the tank was pressurized so as
Numerous studies have been conducted in which ANNs to prevent liquid to spew from the holes[24], then samples
were used in different wastewater processes such as were drawn through port at the center of the surface
flotation [17], advanced oxidation process[18] power (19cm high and 8 cm) of the tank at different periods ( 2,
generation by microbial fuel cell[19], adsorption[20] , and 5, 10, 15 and 20 minutes) . Firstly, 2ml of solution was
sorptive flotation [21]. The scope of this study was to drained from the port before withdrawing each sample in
investigate the effect of micro- bubbles in the removal order to reduce the entrainment of air bubbles. The
efficiency of Cd(II) ions from aqueous solution at concentration of the Cd(II) ions was determined by using
different parameters , ionic strength , flotation kinetic and flame atomic absorption spectrophotometer (AAS;
use the artificial neural network (ANN) to describe this SHIMADZU, Model: 7200, Japan).
behavior. The initial pH of the working solutions was adjusted by
the addition of 1 mol/l NaOH or HCl using a pH meter
2- Flotation Kinetics (WTW, inoLab 720, Germany) and all experiments were
carried out at room temperature. HCL was used to clean
The variation of floated concentration with time will be the tank between experiments and then washed twice with
studied by flotation kinetics, which are useful in the distilled water.
elucidation of the mechanism of the process, and serve as
predictive tools in the implementation of flotation Table 1. Main physicochemical properties of cadmium
technology [22] ion
The flotation rate is equal to the rate of change of Property Cadmium nitrate tetrahydrate
concentration of floatable material in the cell, is
Appearance White colorless crystals
Chemical formula Cd(NO3)2.4H2O
(1) Molecular weight (g/mole) 308.7
Atomic weight (g/mole) 112.7
Where, k is the flotation rate constant and the value of (n) Density (g/cm3) 2.45
denotes the order of the equation. Solubility in water g/100 ml at 20
º 136
C
By integration Eq. (1) with n= 1 (first order) gives: Hydrated ionic radius, Å 4.26
Electronegativity 0.95
C = Co (2) Company BDH England
ln = kt (3)
3- Experimental Work
2
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
RMSE
Marquardt backpropagation (LMA) training algorithm for
correlating the removal efficiency of Cd(II) ions from
aqueous solution. 2
This algorithm was determent using Matlab program
version 78.2.0.701 (R2013b). Randomly divide the 1
subset of 100 experimental data into; 60 %, 20% and 20%
as training set, validation set, and testing set, respectively. 0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1011121314151617181920
Fig. 2 indicate the best topology for ANN for Cd(II) no. of nueron
ions removal and the variation of parameters was
calculated at (6:18:1) depending on the RMSE of the Fig. 3. RMSE at different hidden neurons no
prediction and training sets , which was the highest at
hidden neurons no. 2 then decreased significantly to reach
the minimum values 1.062 at 11 hidden neurons as can be
seen in Fig. 3, the dependence between RMSE and the
neuron number for the LMA algorithm.
3
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
pH 6.8, air flow rate 2.5 ml/min and Cd(II) ion pH5
60
concentration= 40 mg/l) , It can be seen that the removal
50 pH6
of Cd(II) ions reached 85% and 60% by using SDS and
CTAB surfactant, respectively. That‟s meant the anionic 40 pre
surfactant (SDS) is more efficient than the cationic 30 pH3
pre
surfactant (CTAB) and will be used in the next 20 pH4
experiments. pre
10
The desired collector type depends upon pH value of a pH5
solution. Generally, an anionic collector is required for 0
pH (1-7) due to that metal ion is on cationic shapes. On 0 5 10 15 20 25
higher pH, cationic collectors could be required when Time , min
metal ion was existing as an anion [25][26].
Fig. 8. Removal efficiency of Cd (II) ions as a function of
pH
50
SDS
40 4.4. Influence of SDS Surfactant Concentration
CTAB
30
Different sodium dodecylsulfate surfactant (SDS)
20 concentrations (0, 10, 20 and 40mg/l) were used while
other parameters were kept constant (pH 5, flow rate
10
=250cm3/min, Cd(II) ion concentration = 40mg/l).
0 Fig. 9 shows that the removal of Cd (II) ion reached
0 5 10 15 20 25 (92.3%) at 15 min at SDS concentration of was 20 mg/l
Time, min and by increasing SDS concentration to 40 mg/l the
removal efficiency of Cd(II) ion was deceased to (60.2%)
Fig. 7. Influence of surfactant type on the removal of
due to competition between the metal-collector complex
Cd(II) ions
and free collector ions for bubble surface sites at
excessive collector amount as well as micelle formation ,
4
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
the potential toxicity of residuals amounts of collector in Table 3. Rate constant at various SDS concentrations
the effluent and cost [23], also this figure confirms that SDS concentration
the ANN model could be effectively predicting the
experimental results. SDS10 SDS20 SDS40
To theoretically examine, if the amount of SDS
represent the optimum value for highly removal k×102 (min-1) 1.883 4.505 1.155
efficiency, ANN model was used at different
concentrations of SDS was varied around the best value 4.5. Influence of Flow rate
(15, 18, 20, 22, 25, 28, 30 and 35 mg/L) as shown in Fig.
10. It can be seen from this figure that there is a good Different air flow rate (100, 200 and 250cm3/min) were
agreement between the experimental data and the tested to examine their effect on the removal efficiency of
predicted data, in addition through ANN model, the Cd(II) ion in the microbubble dispersed air flotation
optimum value of SDS concentration was 18 mg/l. column was investigated.
Table 3 shows that, the removal rate constants increased The other parameters were remained constants (pH=5,
with increasing SDS concentration. The result is in cadmium conc. = 40 mg/ l and SDS = 10 mg/l), Fig. 11
agreement with the finding of [26]. indicated that the removal efficiency was highly affected
by the gas flow rate, the large number of small bubbles
100 leads to increase the surface area available for metal-
90 collector adsorption.
SDS0
80 By increasing gas flowrate, the removal efficiency
increased. Increasing gas flow rate causes early bubble
Removal efficiency,%
70 SDS10
detachment, large fluid activities (stress) at the bottom
60 SDS20
section and bubble coalescence and (mostly) break up
50 [27] also, these results are in good agreement with the
SDS40
40 proposed ANN model.
preSDS0 To theoretically examine, if this value represents the
30
20 preSDS1 best flow rate for maximum removal efficiency, Fig. 12
10
0 presents the influence of different air flow rate around the
best value on the removal rate of Cd(II) ions (2, 2.2, 2.5 ,
0
2.7 and 3 cm3/min) it can be noticed from this figure that
0 5 10 15 20 25
2.7 cm3/min was the best predicted value.
Time, min
Table 4 presents the removal rate constants (k) at
different air flow rate, which shows that the( k) increased
by gas flow rate increased.
Fig. 9. Influence of SDS on the Cd(II) ions removal
efficiency
100 Q=100cm3/m
90 in
100
Q=200cm3/m
95 80 in
Removal efficiency, %
90 70 Q=250cm3/m
in
60
Removal efficiency, %
85 preQ=100
80 50
40 preQ=200
75
30 preQ=250
70
20
65
10
60
0
55
-1 1 3 5 7 9 11 13 15 17 19 21 23 25
50 Time, min
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36
SDS concentration , mg/l
Fig. 11. Removal efficiency of Cd(II) ions at different air
Fig. 10. Removal efficiency predicted by ANN model at flow rate
different SDS concentration
5
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
100 100
95 90
80 conc.=40mg
Removal efficiency , %
Removal efficiency , %
90 /l
70
conc.=80mg
85 60 /l
80 50 conc.120mg
40 /l
75 pre40
30
70 20 pre80
65 10
0
60
0 5 10 15 20 25
1.5 1.7 1.9 2.1 2.3 2.5 2.7 2.9 3.1
Time , min
Flow rate
Fig. 12. Predicted removal efficiency at different air flow Fig. 13. Removal efficiency as a function of initial metal
rate ions concentration
Removal efficiency , %
Q=100 Q=200 Q=250
90
2 -1
k×10 (min ) 2.375 4.456 9.156
88
86
4.6. Influence of Initial Concentration of Cd(II) Ions
84
6
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
100
Where; Ij is the relative importance of the jth input
variable on the output variable, Ni and Nh are the
90
numbers of input and hidden neurons, respectively, the
80
superscripts i, h and o refer to input, hidden and output
Removal efficeincy
4.9. Turbidity
20
wastewater. The maximum correlation coefficient was
15 Q=1 more than 0.999 which confirmed exact and powerful
Q=2 results experimentally. Hidden neuron of LMA were
10 11neurons having RMSE 1.062. The sensitivity analysis
Q=2.5
showed that the reactions were influenced by the pH,
5
input concentration of Cd (II) ions, SDS surfactant
0 concentration, flow rate and ionic strength but pH
0 3 6 9 12 15 18 21 appeared the most influence parameters with relative
Time, min importance of 25.13 %. The maximum removal efficiency
achieved was 92.3% at pH=5, 20mg/l initial Cd(II)
Fig. 16. Removal of turbidity at different flow rate concentration, 10mg/l surfactant concentration and
250cm3/cm3 flowrate at 15min contact time . The kinetic
4.10. Analysis of Sensitivity flotation order for Cd (II) ions almost first order and the
removal rate constant (k) increases with decreasing the
Garson suggested an equation assess the relative initial metal concentration and increasing flow rate.
importance of the input variables depends upon the
connection weights partitioning, as can be seen in Eq. (4) References
[31].
[1] Ksakas, A., Tanji, K., El Bali B and Taleb, M., A.
w ih
m Nh Kherbeche, (2018), “Removal of Cu (II) Ions from
w ho
jm
ih Aqueous Solution by Adsorption Using Natural Clays:
k 1 km
mn
m 1
Ni
w
Ij Kinetic and Thermodynamic Studies”, J. Mater.
ih Environ.Sci.,9,(3).:1075-1085.
k Ni wkm ho
k 1 m1 Ni wih
m Nh
wmn
k 1 km
(4)
7
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
[2] Mohammed, A. A. ,2015, „‟ Biosorption of Lead, [16] Mnatia, K. H. and Abdul Hadi, H. , 2018, „‟
Cadmium, and Zinc onto Sunflower Shell: Prediction of penetration Rate and cost with Artificial
Equilibrium, Kinetic, and Thermodynamic Studies‟‟, Neural Network for Alhafaya Oil Field‟‟, Iraqi Journal
Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering ,19(4) : 12 –
,16(1) :91- 105. 27.
[3] Abas, S. N. A., Ismail, M. H. Sh., Kamal, M. L., and [17] Alwared, A. I., (2013), "Artificial Neural
Izhar, Sh., 2013, "Adsorption process of heavy metals Network Approach for Prediction Lead Ions
by low-cost adsorbent : A Review", World Applied Removable from Wastewater by Flotation Method",
Sciences Journal, 28(11): 1518–1530. Journal of General Secretary of Arab Engineering
[4] Jimoh, O.Ti, Mercy, T. B., Musa M. and Idowu, O. F., Colleges Society, Association of Arab Universities
(2014), Development of Low Cost Adsorbent from Union, 20(1).
Cow Horn for the Biosorption of Mn (II), Ni (II) and [18] Mustafa Y. A. , Jaid G. M., Alwared A. I. ,
Cd (II) Ion from Aqueous Solution, “Research Journal Ebrahim M. (2014), "The Use of Artificial Neural
of Applied Sciences, Engineering and Technology Network (ANN) for the Prediction and Simulation of
7(1): 9-17. Oil Degradation in Wastewater by AOP
[5] Oteroa, M., Rozada F., Morán A., Calvo L.F., García Environmental", Science and Pollution Research
A.I., 2009. Removal of heavy metals from aqueous 21(12).
solution by sewage sludge based sorbents: competitive [19] Jaeel A. J., Al-wared A.I, Ismail Z.Z.,(2016), "
effects, Desalination, 239 : 46–57. Prediction of Sustainable Electricity Generation in
[6] Algureiri A. H. and Abdulmajeed, Y. R., Microbial Fuel Cell by Neural Network: Effect of
2016,Removal of Heavy Metals from Industrial Anode Angle with Respect to Flow Direction",
Wastewater by Using RO Membrane , Iraqi Journal of Journal of Electroanalytical Chemistry 767 : 56–62.
Chemical and Petroleum Engineering Vol.17 No.4 : [20] Nasrullaha A. , Bhata A.H., Isab M.H. , Danishc
125- 136. M.,Abdul Naeemd, Muhammade N. and Khan T.,
[7] Ohnari H. Waste water purification in wide water area (2017), "Efficient Removal of Methylene Blue Dye
by use of micro-bubble techniques. Jpn Journal using Mangosteen Peel Waste: Kinetics, Isotherms
Multiphase Flow1997;11:263– 266(inJapanese). and Artificial Neural Network (ANN) Modeling",
[8] Jyoti KK, Pandit AB. Water disinfection by acoustic Desalination and Water Treatment ,86 .
and hydrodynamic cavitation. Biochem. Eng. J 2001; [21] Abdulhussein, S. A., (2018) ,”Removal of Cu+2
7: 201 – 212 and Ni+2 from Aqueous Solution using Flotation and
[9] Terasaka K, Shinpo Y. Separation of fine particles Sorptive Flotation with Application of Artificial
suspended in water using microbubble flotation. Jpn J Neural Network, M.Sc. Thesis, Collage of
Multiphase Flow 2007; 21: 77 – 83 (in Japanese). Engineering, University of Baghdad, Iraq.
[10] Ketkar D.R, Mallikarjunan R, Venkatachalam S. [22] Mohammed A.A. Abed , F.I., (2011), “Removal
Electroflotation of quartz fines. Int J Miner Process of Copper Ion from Wastewater by Flotation” ,
1991; 31: 127 – 138. Journal of Engineering, 17(6).1483-1491.
[11] Liu S, Wang Q, Ma H, Huang P, Li J, Kikuchi T. [23] Gupta, A. k., and Yan, D. S., 2006,"Mineral
Effect of micro-bubbles on coagulation flotation processing design and operation", Elsevier B.V., 565-
process of dyeing wastewater. Sep Purif Technol 567.
2010; 71: 337 – 346. [24] Sulaymon, A., and Mohammed, A.,(2010),
[12] Rodrigues, T. and Rubio, J, (2007), “Review ''Separation and Hydrodynamic Performance of Air –
Article:DAF–dissolved air flotation: Potential Kerosene-Water System by Bubble Column'',
applications in the mining and mineral processing International journal of chemical reactor engineering,
industry”, Int. J. Miner. Process82: 1–13, vol. 8, :1-15
[13] Ghazy, S. E, El-Morsy, S.M, and Ragab, A. H., [25] Zouboulis, A. I., and Matis, K. A. 1987, "Ion
2008,"Ion flotation of copper ( II ) and lead ( II ) from flotation in Environmental Technology",
environmental water samples", J. Appl. Sci. Environ. Chemosphere, 16(2-3), pp.623-631.
Manage, 12(3): 75–82. [26] Muhaisn, L.F., 2014, "Competitive Removal of
[14] Mohammed, A. A., Ebrahim, Sh. E., and Heavy Metal Ions from Simulated Wastewater by
Alwared, A. I., (2013), "Flotation and Sorptive Sorptive Flotation Using Punica Granatum", M.Sc.
Flotation Methods for Removal of Lead Ions from Thesis, College of Engineering, University of
Wastewater Using SDS as Surfactant and Barley Husk Baghdad, Iraq.
as Biosorbent", Journal of Chemistry, ID 413948:1- 6. [27] Zouboulis, A. I., Matis, K. A., and Stalidis, G.
[15] Hoseinian, F.S., Rezai, B.; Kowsari, E.; Safari, A., 1990," Parameters influencing flotation in removal
M. Kinetic study of Ni(II) removal using ion flotation: of metal ions", International Journal of Environmental
Effect of chemical interactions. Miner. Eng. 2018, Studies, 35:183-196.
119, 212–221. [28] Choi, S.J., and Kim, K.H., The improvement of
the removal efficiency of foam flotation by synergistic
effect of mixed surfactant solutions, Environment
Technology, 19, 1151-1156(1998).
8
A. I. Alwared et al. / Iraqi Journal of Chemical and Petroleum Engineering 20,2 (2019) 1 - 9
التعويم باستخدام الفقاعات المايكروية ال زالة ايونات الكادميوم من المحاليل المائية :موديل
الشبكة العصبية االصطناعية والتعويم الحركي
الخالصة
تيدف ىذه الدراسة الى تطبيق تقنية دقائق اليواء المتناىية الصغر في طريقة تعويم اليواء إلزالة أيونات
الكادميوم من المحاليل المائية وذلك من خالل دراسة مجموعو من المتغيرات :الرقم الييدروجيني ( 3و 4و 5و
)6والتركيز األولي لأليونات الكادميوم (40و 80و 120ممغم /لتر) وقت االتصال ( 2و 5و 10و 15و
20دقيقة) ،تركيز المواد الخافضة لمشد السطحي ( 10و 20و 40ممغم /لتر) من أجل ايجاد أفضل
جدا في إزالة أيونات
الظروف وتشير النتائج التجريبية إلى أن دقائق اليواء المتناىية الصغر كانت فعالة ً
الكادميوم وأن مادة SDSأكثر فعالية من CTABكمادة خافضة لمشد السطحي في عممية التعويم.وبكفاءة
عالية بمغت ٪92.3تحققت خالل 15دقيقة عند دالة حامضية ، 5وتركيز مادة 20( SDSممغم /لتر )و
معدل تدفق 250سم / 3دقيقة وبتركيز اولي (4ممغم/لتر).
كما تضمنت الدراسة تطبيق برنامج ANNمن اجل التنبؤ بازالة ايونات الكادميوم من المحاليل المائية خالل
11طبقة من الخاليا العصبية المخفية ،مع معامل ارتباط 0.9997بين مخرجات ANNوالبيانات التجريبية
ومن خالل تحميل الحساسية تبين أن الرقم الييدروجيني ( )٪25.13ىو اكثر معامل يؤثر عمى العممية
كماتوصمت الدراسة الى ان كان موديل يمثل النتائج العممية ىو موديل التعويم الحركي من الدرجة الثانية ويزيد
ثابت معدل إزالة مع انخفاض تركيز المعادن األولي.
الكممات الدالة :أيونات الكادميوم ،التعويم ،دقائق اليواء المتناىية الدقة ،ANN ،معدل التعويم الحركي.
9