An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024

The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

AN CHÚIRT UACHTARACH
SUPREME COURT

For Monday 22nd April 2024

With effect from 1st February 2023 attendance at the Supreme Court Office is by appointment and you can
make an appointment online via [Link] For urgent matters, where it is not
possible to book an appointment online, please email supremecourt@[Link] or phone the office on +353 1
888 6395 or +353 1 888 6394.

Please note that the public opening Hours for the Supreme Court Office are from Monday to Friday: 10.00am -
4.30pm. Filings in either hard copy or electronically should be made within the public office opening hours.
Electronic filings received after 4.30pm are deemed filed on the following day. All relevant filings made on a
Friday should be made by 1.00pm to facilitate circulation of papers to members of the Court by Friday evening.
The Chief Justice
Ms. Justice Dunne
Mr. Justice Charleton
At 11.00 o’clock
Panel meeting for consideration of applications received seeking leave to appeal under Article 34.5.3º and
Article 34.5.4º of the Constitution (In Chambers).
1. 3/2024 Scotchstone Capital Fund Limited & Anor -V- Ireland & Anor

AN CHÚIRT ACHOMHAIRC
THE COURT OF APPEAL
NOTICES – (updated 20th December 2023)

The Court of Appeal Office in Áras Ui Dhalaigh is conducting business by appointment only

An appointment may be arranged via email to courtofappealcivil@[Link]. Documents will also be accepted
by post or via DX (No. 262001).

APPEALS FOR HEARING

All Appeals are heard by way of a physical hearing unless otherwise directed by the Court.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on June 1st 2022 a copy of which is available on
the Courts website [Link].

LODGING OF BOOKS OF APPEAL

Parties are required to lodge complete books of appeal (in hard and soft copy) not later than 4 weeks prior to the
date of the appeal in accordance with Practice Direction CA06 or such other date as shall be fixed by the Court.
This must include the transcript of the DAR or approved note of the judgment of the High Court where
appropriate and a joint book of authorities. A party who has been authorised to file the books of appeal may file
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
the books in accordance with this direction notwithstanding the failure of another party to the appeal to furnish
its written submissions to such party for inclusion in the books of appeal.

In the event that the books are not lodged within the time fixed, the appeal shall be relisted in the next
directions list in the Court of Appeal for mention. If the books are not lodged by the latter date, the Court may
make an order extending the time for the late filing of the books of appeal for such short period as it deems
appropriate subject to an order that the appeal shall stand struck out for failure to comply with the directions of
the court. In the event of a failure to comply with such order the appeal shall be struck out. Where an appeal is
listed in the directions list by reason of the foregoing, the party in default may be liable for the costs arising
from attendance at the directions list.

Parties should lodge the books of appeal (including the books of authorities) in hardcopy (x 4) and also in soft
copy via the ShareFile platform.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on June 1st 2022, a copy of which is available
on the Courts website, [Link].

DIRECTIONS LIST AND MOTION LISTS

From 12 January, 2024 the weekly directions and motions lists before Ms. Justice Costello will no longer be
conducted routinely by way of hybrid hearing in Court of Appeal Court 1, Old Public Records Building, The
Four Courts. This means that all parties must attend in person, save where the court directs otherwise.

In accordance with provisions of Order 86A Rule 16(1) the directions book is to be lodged in the office by close
of business on the preceding Friday. In accordance with the provisions of Order 86 Rule 12(5) (dealing with
interlocutory applications) the motion book is to be lodged in the office by close of business on the preceding
Tuesday.

FRIDAY CALLOVER OF APPEALS LISTED FOR HEARING

From 12 January, 2024 the weekly advance Callover of appeals listed for hearing are conducted in person
before Ms. Justice Costello unless otherwise directed by the court. The Callover lists for each respective Friday
list are published in advance in the Legal Diary. The Legal Diary list is updated on a daily basis. It is the
responsibility of the parties in listed appeals to check the Legal Diary for the date of the relevant Callover
(usually scheduled for six weeks in advance of the appeal hearing date).

Parties will be aware that the purpose of the Callover is to confirm that the submissions and books of appeals
(including books of authorities) have been lodged, and that there has been compliance with any other directions
previously given by the Court. It is vital therefore that there be an attendance at the Callover by all parties to an
appeal.

VIRTUAL MEETING ROOM (VMR) DETAILS FOR FRIDAY LISTS - IMPORTANT

Parties are asked to note that the Virtual Meeting Room (VMR) details for the Callover / Directions / Motion
list on each Friday will no longer be furnished unless directed by the court. If any party is unable to attend in
person, they may apply to the Office of the Court of Appeal for leave to appear remotely for a decision by the
judge in charge of the list, which application should be supported by a medical report which details the medical
reasons why the party concerned is unable to attend in person. Without prejudice to the foregoing, the court
may in any case for good and sufficient reason permit a party to appear remotely.

COURT OF APPEAL ORDERS

Due to the recent upgrade to the High Court case management system, it is not currently possible to view when
Court of Appeal Orders are perfected on High Court Search.
Please email courtofappealcivilorders@[Link] for updates on the perfection of Orders.

DELIVERY OF ELECTRONIC JUDGMENTS

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Written judgments of courts may be delivered by means of a copy of the judgment being sent electronically to
the parties and a copy, subject to such redactions as would ordinarily apply, being posted as soon as possible on
the Courts Service website. The date and time of delivery to the parties will be notified in the Legal Diary.
The parties may be invited to communicate electronically with the Court on issues arising (if any) out of the
judgment such as the precise form of order which requires to be made or questions concerning costs or they
may be requested to attend physically to address the Court on these issues. If there are such issues and the
parties do not agree in this regard concise written submissions should be filed electronically with the Office of
the Court, courtofappealciviljudgment@[Link], within 14 days of delivery subject to any other direction
given in the judgment.
CIVIL APPEALS FOR HEARING IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE
Civil appeals with a custody element i.e. Article 40 habeas corpus, extradition, bail and judicial review arising
out of criminal proceedings are now dealt with by the criminal office which is situated on the 4th Floor of the
Criminal Courts of Justice Building, Parkgate Street, Dublin 8. The civil office will continue to issue the Notice
of Appeal and identify whether the appeal comes within the category of appeal to be heard in the Criminal
Courts of Justice and allocate the next available case-management list in the Criminal Courts of Justice for a
directions hearing. The file will then be transferred to the criminal office and all subsequent documents in the
appeal process are to be lodged in the criminal office which will have responsibility for the management and
listing of the appeal. Any enquiries in relation to such appeals should be made to the criminal office by email
to courtofappealcriminal@[Link] or by telephone on (01) 7988004.

EASTER 2024

Monday the 22nd April 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
The President
Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Noonan
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 305 Burke -v- An Adjudication Officer & Anor (1 day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Binchy
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2017 549 Clohessy & ors -v- Brian Long t/a Brian Long Solicitors
(appeal for hearing and Motion)
2014 437, 2014 1211 and 2019 467 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors (2 Motions for hearing) (2.5 hours)

For Electronic Delivery

Ms Justice Costello
Ms Justice Pilkington
Ms Justice Butler
At 11.00 o’clock
For Judgment (via electronic delivery)
2023 287, 2023 291 & 2023 296 Byrne -v- Mars Capital Ireland DAC & Ors

Ms Justice Ni Raifeartaigh
Mr Justice Meenan
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 11.30 o’clock
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
For Judgment (via electronic delivery)
2023 82 T -v- The Minister for Justice

Tuesday the 23rd April 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Pilkington
Mr Justice Allen
Ms Justice Butler
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 312 Coulston -v- Doyle (1 day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Meenan
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 328 The Revenue Commissioners -v- Maloney (1 day)

Wednesday the 24th April 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Faherty
Ms Justice Pilkington
Ms Justice Butler
At 10.30 o’clock
For Continued Hearing
2023 299 McKenna -v- Pepper Finance Corporation (Ireland) DAC & Anor (1.5 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Mr Justice Woulfe
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
Ms Justice Power
At 09.30 o’clock
For Continued Hearing
2023 121 M -v- M (in camera)

Thursday the 25th April 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Binchy
Ms Justice Pilkington
Mr Justice Allen
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 1 M and J Duddy Developments Limited -v- Everyday Finance DAC & ors (half day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Noonan
Ms Justice Butler
At 9.30 o’clock
Costs Hearing
2023 31 Hade -v- Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank UC & anor
2023 32 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Hade & anor
2023 45 Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank -v- Hade & anor
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2023 46 Hade -v- Bank of Ireland Mortgage Bank UC & anor

Mr Justice Noonan
Ms Justice Butler
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 2 Reidy -v- Swiss Krono Tex GmbH (Half day)

For Electronic Delivery

Mr Justice Noonan
Mr Justice Binchy
Ms Justice Butler
At 11.00 o’clock
For Judgment (via electronic delivery)
2023 208 Fox -v- Data Protection Commissioner

Friday the 26th April 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
At 10 o’clock
Callover List
1. 2024 23 Bowe -v- Sherriff & ors
2. 2023 321 McDowell & ors -v- Sea Fisheries Protection Authority
3. 2024 52 Lawless -v- Technological University of the Shannon Midlands Formerly Athlone Institute of
Technology & Ors
4. 2024 53 Lawless -v- Technological University of the Shannon Midlands Formerly Athlone Institute of
Technology & Ors

5. 2024 27 Naughton -v- Independent Star Limited

6. 2024 28 Naughton -v- Irish Examiner Limited
7. 2023 176 H -v- The Mental Health Tribunal (In Camera)
8. 2024 10 AIB Mortgage Bank u.c. -v- Grogan & Anor
9. 2024 88 Ulster Bank Ireland DAC & Ors -v- McDonagh & Ors

Appeals for Mention

2015 87 Dowling & ors -v- Minister for Finance
2015 209 Dowling & ors -v- Permanent TSB Group Holdings & ors

At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 14 Davey -v- Ulster Bank Ireland Limited
2. 2024 79 Fresh Opportunities Stepaside Limited -v- Woods & anor
3. 2024 82 Padden -v- McDarby & ors
4. 2024 83 Howley -v- Onyenemezu
5. 2024 84 Howley -v- Onyenemezu
6. 2024 85 Mars Capital Finance Ireland DAC -v- Phelan
7. 2024 87 C -v- The Minister for Education & ors
8. 2024 64 Ulster Bank Ireland DAC -v- Greene
9. 2023 310 O'Neill -v- Canice M. Egan & Company
10. 2023 311 O'Neill -v- Canice M. Egan & Company
11. 2024 80 D -v- CAFA & ors
12. 2024 99 Keogh -V- Mars Capital Finance Ireland Designated Activity Company & Ors
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
At 11 o’clock
Motion List
13. 2023 310 O'Neill -v- Canice [Link] & Company
14. 2023 311 O'Neill -v- Canice [Link] & Company
15. 2024 27 Naughton -v- Independent Star Limited
16. 2024 28 Naughton -v- Irish Examiner Limited
17. 2024 14 Davey -v- Ulster Bank Ireland Limited
18. 2024 99 Keogh -V- Mars Capital Finance Ireland Designated Activity Company & Ors
19. 2024 100 Krjiwizki & anor -v- The Minister for Justice and Equality

Tuesday the 7th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Binchy
At 9.30 o’clock
Costs Hearing
2014 616 Framus Ltd & ors -v- CRH plc & ors (30 minutes)

Appeal for Mention

2014 738 In the matter of Amantiss Enterprises Ltd (in Voluntary Liquidation) and Wilbury Ltd (in Voluntary
Liquidation

Mr Justice Noonan
Mr Justice Binchy
Mr Justice Meenan
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 314 Gibson -v- Kevin O’Gorman p/a Kevin O ‘Gorman & Company Solicitors
2023 315 Gibson -v- Kevin O’Gorman p/a Kevin O ‘Gorman & Company Solicitors (1 day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Faherty
Ms Justice Pilkington
Ms Justice Butler
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 316 Xerico Ltd -v- The Residential Tenancies Board (Case Stated) (1 day)

Thursday the 9th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice Noonan
Ms Justice Pilkington
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 8 Cooper -v- An Bord Pleanála (1 hour)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Binchy
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2014 437 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2014 1211 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
2019 467 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors (1.5 days)

Friday the 10th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
At 10 o’clock
Callover of Appeals listed for hearing in weeks beginning the 24th June and the 1st July 2024
1. 2024 5 Scott -v- St Vincent’s Healthcare Group
2. 2024 26 D & Ors -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & Anor
3. 2024 18 Roberts -v- Roberts & anor
4. 2024 29 Elsharkawy -v- The Minister for Transport
5. 2024 19 Solas Éireann Developments Limited -v- Cleary
6. 2024 22 Start Mortgages DAC -v- Smith & Anor (Preliminary Issue)
7. 2024 32 Muldowney -v- The Governor of Mountjoy Prison & ors
8. 2024 17 Meany -v- Data Protection Commission
9. 2024 41 In the matter of GTLK Europe DAC
10. 2024 35 Mahony & anor -v- Pepper Finance Corporation Ireland DAC & anor (Motion to extend time to
appeal)
11. 2024 30 LOC8 -v- The Department of the Environment Climate and Communications & Ors
12. 2024 33 Start Mortgages Designated Activity Company -v- Simpson & Anor
13. 2024 42 Lundin -v- Kuhn & anor

At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 21 Everyday Finance Designated Activity Company -v- Quinn
2. 2024 39 O'Brien & ors -v- The Chief Legal Costs Adjudicator
3. 2024 89 Everyday Finance DAC -v- Gleeson & Ors
4. 2024 90 Fortberry Limited & Anor -v- Allied Irish Banks PLC & Ors
5. 2024 91 Quinn -v- Larkin & anor
6. 2024 92 I -v- The Minister for Foreign Affairs & anor
7. 2024 94 Pirannah Freight Limited -v- Kiely
8. 2024 95 Fagan -v- Minister for Employment Affairs and Social Protection & Ors
9. 2024 96 Christopher-nicholas -v- The Road Safety Authority & ors
10. 2024 20 Malone -v- Governor of Cloverhill Prison

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Binchy
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2014 437 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
2014 1211 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors
2019 467 Clohessy -v- Legal Aid Board & ors (Half day remaining)

Monday the 13th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Allen
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 34 Norton (Waterford) Limited Trading as TEVA Pharmaceuticals Ireland -v- Bristol-Myers Squibb
Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company (4 days)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Mr Justice Noonan
Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Meenan
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing (Motions)
1. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (adduce further evidence (3))
2. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery - Law Society)
3. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party)
4. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party) (1.5 days)

Tuesday the 14th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Allen
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 34 Norton (Waterford) Limited Trading as TEVA Pharmaceuticals Ireland -v- Bristol-Myers Squibb
Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company (3 days remaining)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Mr Justice Noonan
Ms Justice Faherty
Mr Justice Meenan
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing (Motions)
1. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (adduce further evidence (3))
2. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery - Law Society)
3. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party)
4. 2023 156, 154 and 155 Murphy -v- Law Society of Ireland & anor (Discovery – Non Party) (Half day
remaining)

Wednesday the 15th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Allen
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 34 Norton (Waterford) Limited Trading as TEVA Pharmaceuticals Ireland -v- Bristol-Myers Squibb
Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company (2 days remaining)

Thursday the 16th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
Mr Justice Allen
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 34 Norton (Waterford) Limited Trading as TEVA Pharmaceuticals Ireland -v- Bristol-Myers Squibb
Holdings Ireland Unlimited Company (1 day remaining)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Ms Justice Pilkington
Ms Justice Butler
Mr Justice Meenan
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 86 Rajpal -v- The Health Service Executive (1 day)

TRINITY 2024

Wednesday the 29th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing (Preliminary Issues)
2024 41 In the matter of GTLK Europe DAC (1 day)

Thursday the 30th May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 51 Sanvito -v- Goracy & Anor (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 4 Lavery -v- Humphreys & ors (half day)

Friday the 31st May 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Costello
At 10 o’clock
Appeals for Mention
2023 235 O’Brien -v- BDO Simpson Xavier & anor

At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 97 Keane & Anor -v- Ulster Bank Designated Activity Company
2. 2024 75 In the matter of C.M., a Ward of Court
3. 2024 63 Z & ors -v- The Minister for Justice

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 77 Howley -v- McClean
2024 78 Howley -v- Howard (1 day)

Tuesday the 4th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 3 Carrownagowan Concern Group and ors -v- An Bord Pleanála & ors (1.5 days)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 23 Bowe -v- Sherriff & ors (Half day)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

Wednesday the 5th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 3 Carrownagowan Concern Group and ors -v- An Bord Pleanála & ors (Half day remaining)

Thursday the 6th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 15 Barrett -v- The Commissioner of An Garda Síochána & anor (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 24 Duignan -v- Chief Appeals Officer & ors
2024 25 Hughes -v- Chief Appeals Officer & ors (2 hours)

Monday the 10th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 321 McDowell & ors -v- Sea Fisheries Protection Authority (1.5 days)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 52 Lawless -v- Technological University of the Shannon Midlands Formerly Athlone Institute of
Technology & Ors
2024 53 Lawless -v- Technological University of the Shannon Midlands Formerly Athlone Institute of
Technology & Ors (2.5 hours)

Tuesday the 11th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2023 321 McDowell & ors -v- Sea Fisheries Protection Authority (Half day remaining)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 27 Naughton -v- Independent Star Limited
2024 28 Naughton -v- Irish Examiner Limited (2 hours)

Thursday the 13th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 176 H -v- The Mental Health Tribunal (In Camera) (Half day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 10 AIB Mortgage Bank u.c. -v- Grogan & Anor (2 hours)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

Friday the 14th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10 o’clock
Appeals for Mention
2022 240 Enright & ors -v- Balbeggan Park Company Limited

At 12 o’clock
Matters for mention
1. 2023 156 Murphy -v- The Law Society of Ireland & anor
2. 2023 150 Murphy -v- The Law Society of Ireland & anor
3. 2023 154 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy
4. 2023 155 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy
5. 2022 272 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy (extension of time to appeal)
6. 2022 280 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy (extension of time to appeal)
7. 2023 24 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy (extension of time to appeal)
8. 2023 25 The Law Society of Ireland -v- Murphy (extension of time to appeal)
9. 2023 146 Murphy -v- The Law Society of Ireland & anor
10. 2023 153 Murphy -v- Murphy
11. 2023 151 Murphy -v- Solicitor X
12. 2023 163 Murphy -v- Solicitor X
13. 2023 164 Murphy -v- Solicitor X
14. 2023 165 Murphy -v- Solicitor X
15. 2023 167 Murphy -v- Solicitors Disciplinary Tribunal (in the matter of Solicitor X)
16. 2023 152 Murphy -v- Kirwan
17. 2023 160 Murphy -v- Kirwan
18. 2023 161 Murphy -v- Kirwan
19. 2023 162 Murphy -v- Kirwan
20. 2023 168 Murphy -v- Kirwan
21. 2023 166 Murphy -v- MacMahon

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 88 Ulster Bank Ireland DAC & Ors -v- McDonagh & Ors (3 hours)

Monday the 24th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 5 Scott -v- St Vincent’s Healthcare Group (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 26 D & Ors -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & Anor (1 day)

Tuesday the 25th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 18 Roberts -v- Roberts & anor (2.5 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
For Hearing
2024 29 Elsharkawy -v- The Minister for Transport (Half day)

Thursday the 27th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 19 Solas Éireann Developments Limited -v- Cleary (1 hour)

At 2 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 69 ON & Anor -v- B (1.5 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing (Preliminary Issue)
2024 22 Start Mortgages DAC -v- Smith & Anor (1 hour)

At 2 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 32 Muldowney -v- The Governor of Mountjoy Prison & ors (1.5 hours)

Friday the 28th June 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10 o’clock
For Directions (Commercial Appeal)
2023 126 Trafalgar Developments Limited & Ors -v- Mazepin & Ors

At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 62 Gaultier & Anor -v- Reilly & Ors

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

Ms Justice Whelan
Mr Justice Binchy
Mr Justice Allen
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2022 67 Smith -v- Cisco Systems Internetworking (Ireland) Limited (2.5 hours)

Monday the 1st July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 17 Meany -v- Data Protection Commission (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 41 In the matter of GTLK Europe DAC (2 days)

Tuesday the 2nd July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing (Motion to extend time to appeal)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2024 35 Mahony & anor -v- Pepper Finance Corporation Ireland DAC & anor (1 hour)

At 2 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 59 Nowak -v- The Judicial Council & Anor (1 hour)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 41 In the matter of GTLK Europe DAC (1 day remaining)

Thursday the 4th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 30 LOC8 -v- The Department of the Environment Climate and Communications & Ors (1 day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 33 Start Mortgages Designated Activity Company -v- Simpson & Anor (2 hours)

Friday the 5th July 2024

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 42 Lundin -v- Kuhn & anor (2 hours)

Monday the 8th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 60 Carlow Foods Limited -v- The Minister for Agriculture Food and the Marine (1.5 hours)

At 2 o’clock
For Hearing (Motion to Extend Time to Appeal)
2024 76 Warner -v- M&T Windows and Installation Services Limited

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 54 Mulrooney -v- McGrath & Shee t/a John Shee & Co. Solicitors (2 hours)

Tuesday the 9th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 47 Baynham -v- The Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & ors (1 day+)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 57 Leahy -v- Tippo International Limited (2.5 hours)

Thursday the 11th July 2024

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 11 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 72 R -v- TUSLA & ors (2.5 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 61 Sweetman -v- The Environmental Protection Agency & ors (1 day)

Friday the 12th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
Directions List
1. 2024 55 Y & Anor -v- Office of the Disability Appeals Officer

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 65 In the matter of the estate of Mary Dooley, Deceased (3 hours)

Thursday the 18th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Faherty
Ms Justice Pilkington
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 144 Coomey (Legal Personal Representative of John Richard Cox, deceased) -v- Cox (1 day)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 36 Howley -v- Lohan (2 hours)

Friday the 19th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10 o’clock
Appeals for Mention
2019 238 Grant & Anor -v- The County Registrar for the County of Laois

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 68 Beatty -v- Beatty (suing by his Guardian Ad Litem Walter Beatty Junior) (3 hours)

Monday the 22nd July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Pilkington
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2023 289 In the matter of KK (2 days)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 50 M -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & anor
2024 11 G -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & ors (2 days)

Tuesday the 23rd July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
Ms Justice Whelan
Ms Justice Pilkington
Mr Justice O’Moore
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2023 289 In the matter of KK (1 day remaining)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 50 M -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & anor
2024 11 G -v- The International Protection Appeals Tribunal & ors (1 day remaining)

Thursday the 25th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10 o’clock
Appeals for Mention
2022 221 K.N. -v- The Minister for Justice

Friday the 26th July 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 12 o’clock
For hearing
2024 70 McGreal -v- Office of the Information Commissioner (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 12 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 73 Harrington -v- Ireland & ors (2.5 hours)

MICHAELMAS 2024

Tuesday the 8th October 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
2024 71 Flaherty -v- The Revenue Commissioners (2 hours)

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
2024 74 Nolan & ors -v- Dildar Limited & ors (3 days)

Wednesday the 9th October 2024

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2024 74 Nolan & ors -v- Dildar Limited & ors (2 days remaining)

Thursday the 10th October 2024

In Hugh Kennedy Court, Gandon Building
At 10.30 o’clock
At Hearing
2024 74 Nolan & ors -v- Dildar Limited & ors (1 day remaining)

Friday the 11th October 2024

In Court 1, Court of Appeal Building
At 10 o’clock
Appeals for Mention
2023 119 Butler -v- Ireland & ors

AN CHUIRT ACHOMHAIRC (CHOIRIÚIL)

THE COURT OF APPEAL (CRIMINAL)
NOTICES – updated 3rd January 2023

The Court of Appeal Office Criminal in The Criminal Courts of Justice building is conducting business by appointment
only.
An appointment may be arranged via email to courtofappealcriminal@[Link]. Documents will be accepted by hand
arrangement – please phone the court of appeal office at (01) 7988004 when you are in the CCJ building outside Court
16, by post or via DX (No. 262001).

APPEALS FOR HEARING

All Appeals are being conducted by way of a physical hearing unless otherwise directed by the Court.

LODGING OF DOCUMENTS FOR CRIMINAL APPEAL HEARINGS

Parties are required to lodge all document pertaining to criminal appeal hearing not later than 2 weeks prior to the hearing
date.

LODGING OF BOOKS OF APPEAL (CIVIL APPEALS ONLY)

Parties are required to lodge complete books of appeal (in hard and soft copy) not later than 4 weeks prior to
the date of the appeal in accordance with Practice Direction CA06 or such other date as shall be fixed by the
Court. This must include the transcript of the DAR or approved note of the judgment of the High Court
where appropriate and a joint book of authorities. A party who has been authorised to file the books of
appeal may file the books in accordance with this direction notwithstanding the failure of another party to the
appeal to furnish its written submissions to such party for inclusion in the books of appeal.

In the event that the books are not lodged within the time fixed, the appeal shall be relisted in the next directions list in the
Court of Appeal for mention. If the books are not lodged by the latter date, the Court may make an order extending the
time for the late filing of the books of appeal for such short period as it deems appropriate subject to an order that the
appeal shall stand struck out for failure to comply with the directions of the court. In the event of a failure to comply with
such order the appeal shall be struck out. Where an appeal is listed in the directions list by reason of the foregoing, the
party in default may be liable for the costs arising from attendance at the directions list.

Parties should lodge the books of appeal (including the books of authorities) in hardcopy (x 3) and also in soft copy via
the ShareFile platform.

A revised version of Practice Direction CA06 came into effect on the 1st day of June 2022, a copy of which is
available on the Courts website, [Link].
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

CASE MANANGEMENT LIST

The weekly Case Management List before The President will be conducted by way of hybrid hearing in Court of Appeal
Criminal (CCJ-Court 16).
This means that The President/Judge and the Registrar will be sitting in the Courtroom physically and that Parties can
either attend physically or attend remotely by means of the VMR platform.

While it is intended to have a list every Friday in term practitioners are advised to check the Legal Diary on an ongoing
basis to confirm that there is a list scheduled on a Friday where a matter is required to be listed for case-management.
The court office will also be able to confirm the dates of such lists.

In relation to civil appeals listed in case management and accordance with provisions of Order 86A Rule 16(1) the
directions book is to be lodged in the office by close of business on the preceding Friday.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
VIRTUAL MEETING ROOM (VMR) DETAILS FOR FRIDAY LISTS - IMPORTANT
Parties are asked to note that the Virtual Meeting Room (VMR) details for the Case Management List on each Friday will
be furnished to them directly by e-mail from the Court of Appeal Office on the Tuesday preceding the Friday listed.
Parties are advised, in this regard, to ensure that e-mail contact details furnished to that Office remain valid /are fully up
to date. Any party may attend the Court physically.

DELIVERY OF JUDGMENTS
Judgments are delivered physically in the Courtroom and parties will be notified prior to the date.

Written judgments of courts may be delivered electronically if directed by the Court and in such cases will be delivered
by means of a copy of the judgment being sent electronically to the parties and a copy, subject to such redactions as
would ordinarily apply, being posted as soon as possible on the Courts Service website. The date and time of delivery will
be notified to parties. The parties may be invited to communicate electronically with the Court on issues arising (if any)
out of the judgment such as the precise form of order which requires to be made or questions concerning costs or they
may be requested to attend physically to address the Court on these issues. If there are such issues and the parties do not
agree in this regard concise written submissions should be filed electronically with the Office of the Court of Appeal by
emailing courtofappealcriminal@[Link] within 14 days of delivery subject to any other direction given in the
judgment.

CIVIL APPEALS FOR HEARING IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

Civil appeals with a custody element i.e. Article 40 habeas corpus, extradition, bail and judicial review arising out of
criminal proceedings are now dealt with by the criminal office which is situated on the 4th Floor of the Criminal Courts of
Justice Building, Parkgate Street, Dublin 8. The civil office will continue to issue the Notice of Appeal and identify
whether the appeal comes within the category of appeal to be heard in the Criminal Courts of Justice and allocate the next
available case-management list in the Criminal Courts of Justice for a directions hearing. The file will then be transferred
to the criminal office and all subsequent documents in the appeal process are to be lodged in the criminal office which
will have responsibility for the management and listing of the appeal. Any enquiries in relation to such appeals should be
made to the criminal office by email to courtofappealcriminal@[Link] or by telephone on (01) 7988004.

Sentence appeals and undue leniency applications

See Practice Direction (CA02) for requirements as to materials (reports, testimonials etc) for the use of the court in
sentence appeals and undue leniency applications. Practitioners are urged to ensure that any such materials are furnished
to the court office at least two weeks in advance of the remote hearing date to facilitate the transmission of the materials
to the Court. Practitioners are also reminded that there is no necessity to apply to Court for the preparation of a
Governor’s Report or an Educational Report so that such Reports are available in the event of the Court finding an error
in principle in the sentence imposed by the court of trial. On receipt of an email to the court office (in good time in
advance of the hearing date) specifying the nature of the Report required, the date of the appeal hearing and the prison
where the appellant or respondent (as the case may be) is incarcerated the office will request the required Report from the
relevant prison.

Chief Prosecution Solicitor – service of documents and notification of any intended application
Practitioners are reminded of the requirement to serve on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor for the Director of Public
Prosecutions written submissions lodged in or transmitted via email to the court office. Except for the documents referred
to in Order 86C Rule 7 (1) (a notice of appeal or a notice of application pursuant to section 2 of the Criminal Procedure
Act 1993) and in Order 86C Rule 15(1) (a notice of abandonment) notice of which the Registrar is required to give to
various parties including the Chief Prosecution Solicitor all other documents lodged in or transmitted via email to the
court office must be served on the Chief Prosecution Solicitor. Notice of any intended application to the Court must be
given to the Chief Prosecution Solicitor as well as to the court office.

Monday 22nd April 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Enlargement of Time Applications
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
290/23 DPP -v- P.B. (Vallely Legal)
245/23 DPP -v- Brian Kelly (Midland Legal)

Undue Leniency Application

54CJA/23 DPP -v- Dean Dullaghan (Michael Hennessy Solicitors)

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
Conviction Appeal
214/13 DPP -v- John Dundon (plus motion) (Madden & Finucane Solicitors)

Tuesday 23rd April 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.00 o’clock
The President
Interim List to Fix Dates
Part Heard / Priority Appeals
1. 39/22 DPP -v- V. W.
2. 154/20 DPP -v- James Bates
3. 159/21 DPP -v- Dermot O’Callaghan
Conviction Appeal
4. 253/22 DPP -v- P.M
Sentence Appeals
5. 271/23 DPP -v- N.Q.D.
6. 167/22 DPP -v- D.M.
7. 181/23 DPP -v- Tom Dignam
Civil Appeals
8. 2023 259 DK -v- DPP
9. 2023 324 Stokes -v- The Courts Service & Ors

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
At 10.30 o’clock
For Judgment
142/21 DPP -v- L.N. (John Moynihan Solicitors)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For Judgment
9CJA/22 DPP -v- R.D. (Phelim O’Neill Solicitors)

The President
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
At 10.30 o’clock
For Judgment
153/23 DPP -v- Samy Taib (Sheehan & Partners)
For re-sentencing
217CJA/23 DPP -v-Cameron Curtis (Michael Staines Solicitors)

For hearing
Civil Appeals
2024 37 A -v- DPP
2024 38 DPP -v- A
2024 44 DPP -v- M (a minor)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

Thursday 25th April 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Sentence Appeals
108/22 DPP -v- A.T. (KOD Lyons)
167/21 DPP -v- Gerald Donnelly (McIntyre O’Brien Solicitors)

Undue Leniency Application

35CJA/23 DPP -v- Alan Melia (Lorraine Stephens Solicitors)

Friday 26th April 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote Hearing)
Case Management List
For Mention
24/24 DPP -v- E.D.L.S.D. (Daniel Kreith & Co. Solicitors)
49/24 DPP -v- Richard Walsh (David Burke & Co Solicitors)
38/24 DPP -v- Philip McCabe (KOD Lyons)
1/22 DPP -v- John O’Donoghue (Michael B O’Donnell Solicitor)
160/23 DPP -v- Paul Murphy (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
170/23 DPP -v- Jason Bonney (Daniel Kreith Solicitors)
210/23 DPP -v- B.G. (Padraig J O’Connell Solicitors)
47/24 DPP -v- Michael Lynn (John P. O’Donohoe Solicitors)
191/23 DPP -v- T.F. (Frank Buttimer & Co. Solicitors)
Motion
208/22 DPP -v- Eoin Hannan (In Person
Enlargement of Time Applications
27/24 DPP -v- S.G. (Hughes Walsh Solicitors)
Civil Appeals
2024 81Granahan -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions & Ors

The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o’clock
For Judgment
214/15 DPP -v- Klass Meijvogel (Conway Solicitors)

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Undue Leniency Application
86CJA/23 DPP -v- Dylan Clements (French Kenny Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
198/23 DPP -v- J.M. (Phelim O’Neill Solicitors)

Tuesday 7th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Burns
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
At 10.15 o’clock
For Judgment
Civil Appeal
2023 138 Minister for Justice -v- Szlachcikowski

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Sentence Appeals
146/22 DPP -v- Victor Akinlade (John P. O’Donohoe Solicitors)
146/23 DPP -v- Gerard Mackin (John M. Quinn Solicitors)
65/23 DPP -v- Edward Conroy (Cahir O’Higgins & Co. Solicitors)

Thursday 9th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.15 o’clock
For Judgment
166/22 DPP -v- J.G. (Barry Fitzgerald Solicitors)

Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Undue Leniency Application
5CJA/24 DPP -v- Clive Gargan (Ferrys LLP)

Conviction Appeal
234/21 DPP -v- Gavin Ryan (Siuna Bartels Solicitor)

Friday 10th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote Hearing)
Case Management List
288CPA/23 DPP -v- Eve Doherty (KRW Law)
246/21 DPP -v- Alan Harte (John M. Quinn Solicitor)
247/21 DPP -v- Alan O’Brien (John M. Quinn Solicitor)
5/22 DPP -v- Darren Redmond (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
77/24 DPP -v- S.M. (John Shanley Solicitor)
1. 235/23 DPP -v- Patrick Sweeney (Ferry’s LLP)
2. 244/23 DPP -v- Martin O’Toole (Kieran O’Brien Solicitors)
3. 231/23 DPP -v- Paul Beirne (Tracey Horan & Co. Solicitors)

Motion
270/23 DPP -v- Edmond (Eamon) O’Neill & Ors (O’Gorman Solicitors, Hughes Murphy & Co. Solicitors, Carey
Murphy & Partners Solicitors, Sarah Ryan Solicitor)
Enlargement of Time
67/24 DPP -v- Andrew McCulloch (MacGuill & Co. Solicitors)
112/24 DPP -v- Evan Toomey (John Casey & Co. Solicitors)

Civil Appeal
2024 66 Brady -v- The Director of Public Prosecutions
2024 98 Minister for Justice -v- F. B.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction & Sentence Appeal
211/21 DPP -v- Gerard Harrington (John Gerard Cullen Solicitors)

Civil Appeal
2023 143 Casserly -v- DPP

Monday 13th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote Hearing)
List to Fix Dates
Part Heard Appeals
175/19 DPP -v- Michael Collins (Patterson & Rock Solicitors)
154/20 DPP -v- James Bates (King Solicitors)
159/21 DPP -v- Dermot O’Callaghan (Vallely Legal)
Conviction Appeals
261/18 DPP -v- Jason O’Driscoll (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
292/18 DPP -v- Jonathan Keogh (Sheehan & Partners)
9/19 DPP -v- Thomas Fox (Fahy Bambury Solicitors)
149/22 DPP -v- Lisa Smith (Phoenix Law)
204/22 DPP -v- Leon Sharlott (M.E. Hanahoe Solicitors)
14/22 DPP -v- L.C. (KRW Law)
Sentence Appeals
271/23 DPP -v- N.Q.D. (David Burke & Co. Solicitors)
Civil Appeals
2023 94 DPP -v- Tobin
2023 323 DPP -v- O’Flaherty
2023 141 Harte -v- The Superior Court Rules Committee & Ors
2024 46 DPP -v- The Special Criminal Court & Anor

The President
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Ní Raifeartaigh
Not before 11.30 o’clock
For hearing
Undue Leniency Applications
282CJA/23 DPP -v- Wayne O’Callaghan (Kieran O' Brien & Associates)
283CJA/23 DPP -v- David Long (Patrick Horan)
2CJA/24 DPP -v- Paul Dundon (Hilary Delahunty)

Tuesday 14th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Ms Justice Kennedy
Ms Justice Burns
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Undue Leniency
292/23 DPP -v- Pearl Kenna (French Kenny Solicitors)
164/23 DPP -v- I.A. (Frank Buttimer & Co Solicitors)

Conviction Appeal
126/23 DPP -v- I.I. (O’Shaugnessy Bairead Solicitors)

Thursday 16th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
The President
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
At 10.30 o’clock
For further hearing
Sentence Appeal
64/23 DPP -v- Dean Cooke (Poe Kiely Hogan Lanigan Solicitors)

Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Burns
Conviction Appeal
174/23 DPP -v- Noel Noonan (Tim Kennelly Solicitors)

For hearing
Civil Appeal
2024 93 In the Matter of the People (at the suit of the Director of Public Prosecutions) -V- McDonnell

Thursday 30th May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction Appeal
49/24 DPP -v- Richard Walsh (David Burke & Co Solicitors)

Friday 31st May 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote Hearing)
Case Management List
199/22 DPP -v- T.R. (Michael Staines Solicitors)
200/22 DPP -v- D.G. (Phelim O’Neill Solicitors)
222/22 DPP -v- DR (Ferry’s Solicitors)
Motion
93/24 DPP -v- J.M. (Sheehan & Partners)
Civil Appeal
2023 277 Harte -v- The Special Criminal Court & Ors
2024 9 DPP -v- O’Brien
2023 185 Ahern -v- DPP

At 10.30 o’clock
For Mention
Section 46(3)
2023 158 McGuinness -v- A Judge of the Circuit Court & ors

At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing (plus motion)
2024 67 Flynn & Anor -V- The Commissioner of an Garda Siochana & Anor

Tuesday 4th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
111/24 DPP -v- Brian McHugh (John M. Quinn Solicitors)

Monday 10th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 11.30 o’clock
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
For Hearing
Sentence Appeals
150/23 DPP -v- Paul Flood (J.T. Flynn & Co Solicitors)
69/22 DPP -v- Martin McDermott (McIntyre O’Brien)

Tuesday 11th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For Hearing
Court Martial Appeal
132/23 DMP -v- O’S (Vallely Legal)

Thursday 13th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
For Hearing
Sentence Appeal
19/22 DPP -v- F.M. (Darach McCarthy Solicitors)

Sentence Appeal & Undue Leniency Application

20/22 & 35CJA/22 DPP -v- G. M (Kiely McCarthy Solicitors)

Undue Leniency Application

34CJA/22 DPP -v- P.B. (Kiely McCarthy Solicitors)
33CJA/22 DPP -v- M.B. (John Herbert Solicitors)

Monday 24th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Sentence Appeal
239/22 DPP -v- P.W. (Kiely McCarthy Solicitors)

Friday 28th June 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
The President
At 10.00 o’clock (Remote Hearing)
Case Management List
Civil Appeal
2023 322 Rogers -v- Cowen & Ors

Monday 1st July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
209/19 DPP -v- Sidney Sutton

Thursday 4th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing (2 days)
Criminal Procedure Act 2021 Application
270/23 DPP -v- Edmond (Eamon) O’Neill & Ors (O’Gorman Solicitors, Hughes Murphy & Co. Solicitors, Carey Murphy
& Partners Solicitors, Sarah Ryan Solicitor)

Friday 5th July 2024

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
Mr Justice Edwards
Mr Justice McCarthy
Ms Justice Kennedy
At 10.30 o’clock
For Mention
Civil Appeal
2023 278 Bourke -v- The Commissioner of An Garda Síochána & Others

At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing (2 days)
Criminal Procedure Act 2021 Application
270/23 DPP -v- Edmond (Eamon) O’Neill & Ors (O’Gorman Solicitors, Hughes Murphy & Co. Solicitors, Carey Murphy
& Partners Solicitors, Sarah Ryan Solicitor)

Monday 8th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction Appeal
97/23 DPP -v- S.S. (Michael B O’Donnell Solicitors)

Tuesday 9th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Sentence Appeals
254/23 DPP -v- Daniel Bowker (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)
232/23 DPP -v- Karl Humphries (Ferrys LLP)

Thursday 18th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction & Sentence Appeals (day 1 of 2)
235/23 DPP -v- Patrick Sweeney (plus Bail Application)
244/23 DPP -v- Martin O’Toole
231/23 DPP -v- Paul Beirne
(Day 1 of 2)

Friday 19th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction & Sentence Appeals (day 2 of 2)
235/23 DPP -v- Patrick Sweeney (plus Bail Application)
244/23 DPP -v- Martin O’Toole
231/23 DPP -v- Paul Beirne

Tuesday 23rd July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction Appeal
25/24 DPP -v- S.R. (Connolly Finan Fleming Solicitors)

Civil Appeals
2024 12 DPP -v- Kravtsov

Thursday 25th July 2024

In Court 16, Criminal Courts of Justice
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
At 10.30 o’clock
For hearing
Conviction Appeals
229/20 DPP -v- Sebastian Barczuk (Cahir O’Higgins Solicitors)
60/23 DPP -v- P. C. (Mulholland Law)

CÁSANNA AN LAE INNIU SAN ÁRD CHÚIRT

TODAYS CASES IN THE HIGH COURT

CÁSANNA AN LAE INNIU SAN ÁRD CHÚIRT

TODAYS CASES IN THE HIGH COURT

IN COURT 1
MR JUSTICE COFFEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
COMMON LAW LIST 1 (HYBRID)

IN COURT 2
MR JUSTICE TWOMEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
COMMERCIAL LIST (HYBRID)

IN COURT 3
MR JUSTICE SANFEY
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY LIST 1 (HYBRID)

IN COURT 4
THE PRESIDENT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
WARDS OF COURT (HYBRID)
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
INHERENT JURISDICTION
PROFESSIONAL DISCIPLINARY LIST

IN COURT 5
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
ASYLUM CALLOVER LIST

IN COURT 5
MR JUSTICE KENNEDY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
BANKRUPTCY LIST (REMOTE)

IN COURT 6
MS JUSTICE HYLAND
AT 11.15 O’CLOCK
NON JURY / JUDICIAL REVIEW LIST (HYBRID)
JUDICAL REVIEW EX PARTE LIST (HYBRID)
AT 14.00 O’CLOCK
ASYLUM LIST (HYBRID)

IN COURT 7
MR JUSTICE JORDAN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FAMILY LAW (REMOTE)

IN COURT 9
MS JUSTICE REYNOLDS
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
GARDA COMPENSATION LIST

IN COURT 10
MS JUSTICE STACK
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
PROBATE (PHYSICAL)

IN COURT 11
MR JUSTICE BARR
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
COMMON LAW LIST 3 (HYBRID)

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE O’CONNOR
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 13
MR JUSTICE HESLIN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
INHERENT JURISDICTION

IN COURT 13
MR JUSTICE MULCAHY
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY SPECIAL SUMMONS LIST (HYBRID)

IN COURT 14
MR JUSTICE JACKSON
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
INFANT AND FATAL RULINGS LIST
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR HEARING

IN COURT 15
MR JUSTICE NOLAN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
COMMON LAW LIST 2 (HYBRID)

IN COURT 16
MR JUSTICE O’DONNELL
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
COMMON LAW EX PARTE LIST (HYBRID)

IN COURT 18
MS JUSTICE BRETT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR HEARING
NON JURY JUDICIAL REVIEW

IN COURT 19
MR JUSTICE QUINN
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 21
MR JUSTICE BRADLEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE FARRELL
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT LIST 2 (HYBRID)

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE HOLLAND
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION (REMOTE)

IN COURT 25
MR JUSTICE OISÍN QUINN
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY

IN COURT 26
MR JUSTICE OWENS
AT 12.15 O’CLOCK
PERSONAL INSOLVENCY LIST
AFTER THE LIST
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 29
MR JUSTICE CREGAN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
CHANCERY 2 LIST (HYBRID)
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
FOR MENTION

IN COURT 36 (REMOTE)
MR JUSTICE HUMPHREYS
AT 09.30 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT LIST (REMOTE)
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
AT HEARING

IN THE CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

JUDGE TBC
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
EXTRADITION LIST

IN CORK COURTHOUSE
MS JUSTICE O’REGAN
MS JUSTICE HYLAND

FOR ELECTRONIC JUDGEMENT

MR JUSTICE O’HIGGINS

IN COURT 4
THE PRESIDENT
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
2023 344 MCA HSE -v- M

IN COURT 12
MR JUSTICE O CONNOR
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2008 11101 P TRACEY -V- IRISH TIMES LTD & ORS
2008 11102 P TRACEY -V- INDEPENDENT STAR LIMITED & ANOR
2008 11103 P TRACEY -V- INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS [IRELAND] LIMITED & ORS
2008 11104 P TRACEY -V- INDEPENDENT NEWSPAPERS [IRELAND] LTD & ORS

IN COURT 13
MR JUSTICE HESLIN
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
[Link].2024.0000178 ST. JOHNS HOSPITAL v M
[Link].2023.0000410 ST VINCENTS HEALTHCARE GROUP DA T/A ST VINCENTS UNIVERSITY
HOSPITAL v G
[Link].2024.0000102 HSE v F
[Link].2024.0000125 HSE v B

IN COURT 14
MS JUSTICE JACKSON
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2023 120 CA- MOHLICH -V- START MORTGAGES DAC & ANOR 3 MOTIONS]
2020 231 JR - K V KILKENNY COUNTY COUNCIL

IN COURT 18
MS JUSTICE BRETT
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2020 7109 P- CROWLEY & ANOR-V- BANK OF IRELAND MORTGAGE BANK & ANOR
2022 1845 P- OSBORNE -V- OSBORNE BROTHERS LTD T/A TOPLINE CORRELLS

IN COURT 19
MR JUSTICE QUINN
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
[Link].2023.0000257 ARKINS v FINN 22/04/2024 2022 8 COS WFS FORESTRY IRELAND LTD -V-
COMPANIES ACT 2014
2022 8 COS WFS FORESTRY IRELAND LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014

IN COURT 21
MR JUSTICE C BRADLEY
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
[Link].2024.0000106 O NEILL v O NEILL

IN COURT 24
MR JUSTICE HOLLAND
AT 10.00 O’CLOCK
2022 336 JR MULLOY -V- AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
2022 141 JR EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT OWNERS MANAGEMENT CLG & ORS -V- AN BORD
PLEANALA & ANOR ANOR
2021 771 JR KELLY & ORS -V- AN BORD PEANALA & ORS
2021 804 JR FERNLEIGH RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION & ANOR -V- AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
2022 471 JR LEOPARDSTOWN ACTION GROUP -V- AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
2022 473 JR CONWAY -V- AN BORD PLEANALA
2022 455 JR RESIDENTS WBC CLG -V- AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
2023 96 MCA DONEGAL COUNTY COUNCIL -V- PLANREE LTD & ANOR

IN COURT 24
MS JUSTICE FARRELL
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
2023 996 JR HERBERT & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
2023 129 JR SANDYMARK LTD & ORS -V- MINISTER FOR HOUSING LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND
HERITAGE & ORS
[Link].2024.0000200 COULSON & ANOR v AN BORD PLEANALA
[Link].2023.0001490 PURCELL v AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
[Link].2023.0001489 PURCELL v AN BORD PLEANALA & ORS
[Link].2024.0000174 O'MEARA v WESTMEATH COUNTY COUNCIL & ANOR

IN COURT 26
MR JUSTICE OWENS
AFTER THE LIST
2022 321 MCA CUMMINS -V- KEEGAN & ORS

IN COURT 29
MR JUSTICE CREGAN
AT 2.00 O’CLOCK
H.P.2023.0006158 WILSON v GHIZDAVU & ORS

IN COURT 36
MR JUSTICE HUMPHREYS
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
AT 11.00 O’CLOCK
[Link].2024.0000066 LEITRIM COUNTY COUNCIL v DROMAPROP LTD

IN CRIMINAL COURTS OF JUSTICE

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT TBC
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK

APPLICATION TO ISSUE RELEVANT ARREST WARRANTS

1. 2024 80 EXT DPP -V- RA

2. 2024 81 EXT DPP -V- RA
3. 2024 63 EXT DPP -V- RGMM
4. 2024 64 EXT DPP -V- RGMM
5. 2024 91 EXT DPP -V- IK
6. 2024 92 EXT DPP -V- IK

APPLICATION TO ENDORSE RELEVANT ARREST WARRANRTS

7. 2024 89 EXT MJ -V- EGU

8. 2024 90 EXT MJ -V- EGU

APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW RELEVANT ARREST WARRANTS

9. 2023 217 EXT DPP -V- MCM

POLISH

10. 2024 83 EXT MJ -v- OSKAR DAMIAN LOCINSKI

ENGLISH

11. 2020 214 EXT MJE -V- RICHARD GALLAGHER

12. 2022 168 EXT MJ -V- TOMASZ BARANOWICZ
13. 2024 10 EXT MJ -V- ELKHOMU DAVID EHIMARE
14. 2024 14 EXT MJ -V- ELKHOMU DAVID EHIMARE

FOR ELECTRONIC JUDGMENT

MR JUSTICE O’HIGGINS
2021 343 P BEST -V- SOUTH DUBLIN COUNTY COUNCIL

FORIARRATAS SA DLÍ COITEANN (1)

COMMON LAW MOTION (1) – (4)

This is a notice in respect of Motions in the Common Law List with a return date of the 22nd April 2024

These motions will be spilt into THREE parts and ALL THREE parts will be heard on Monday 22nd April
2024

NOTE: This list includes Motions for the Sitting of the Court (numbers 1 – 28 inclusive) which will be
heard by way physical hearing.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
DELIVERY OF MOTION PAPERS IN ALL COMMON LAW LISTS

A paginated and indexed booklet of motion papers in respect of all motions is required to be lodged no later
than 4.30 pm on Thursday 18th April 2024 for both physical and hybrid hearings. Failure to do so will lead to
the motion being adjourned.

The booklet of motion papers for all four parts of the Common Law List must be in an envelope clearly marked
with the wording “Common Law List Monday 22nd April 2024”. This should be delivered to the List Room
which is situated on the Ground Floor of the Four Courts Building (beside the Central Office).
Please email listroomhighcourt@[Link] to make an appointment to lodge the papers. Please indicate in that
email the name of the person who will deliver the booklet of motion papers.

When a matter has been dealt with (an Order made or motion adjourned), the papers must be collected from the
List room by Wednesday noon by emailing listroomhighcourt@[Link]. Papers will not be retained in any
circumstances.

The Virtual Courtroom Number and relevant instructions for practitioners will be made available to members
shortly through the Law Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites

Law Society of Ireland - [Link]

Bar of Ireland Members Area: [Link]

Please note that the name of the Judges sitting for each of the four parts of the Common Law list will
appear on the “Todays Cases/All Lists” of the Legal Diary on the Monday morning on which that
Common Law List is being heard.

Please note that as per the direction of The President of the High Court dated the 8th day of July 2021
(HC 108), the Practice Direction HC 89 (emailing Consent Orders relating to the Common Law List) has
been discontinued.
Applications to adjourn motions on consent and applications for Orders on Consent will be dealt with remotely
at 10.30 o'clock by the Registrar in the Court to which the lists are assigned.
On the day, parties are requested to advise the Court of any Motion where the hearing of which is likely to
exceed 15 minutes. Any Motion which is likely to exceed 15 minutes but less than 30 minutes will be
considered for transfer to the Non-Jury List to get an appropriate hearing date or subject to the management of
the list will be dealt with on the Monday in the Common Law List.
Any queries in relation to the list can be addressed by email to commonlawlist@[Link]
MONDAY 22nd April 2024
BEFORE JUDGE TBA (JUDGES name will appear on the “TODAYS CASES/ALL LISTS” Section of the
Legal Diary on Monday morning.
Common Law Motions List with a return date of 22/04/24 (Part 1 motions)
Motions (hybrid hearing)
11am onwards Numbers 1-28

1 2013 10979 P BARRETT -V- KBC BANK IRELAND PLC

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2 2017 4834 P BRAWN -V- O NEILL & ORS
3 2020 297 S CABOT FINANCIAL [IRELAND] LIMITED -V- BRADY
4 2016 1328 S CABOT FINANCIAL [IRELAND] LTD -V- DELANEY
5 2020 4158 P CAROLAN -V- NEILSON
6 2013 6966 P CASSIDY -V- KBC HOMELOANS
7 2022 5429 P DWYER -V- LEE P/A LEES SOLICITORS & ANOR
8 2022 6507 P FAHY -V- FAHY
9 2014 6033 P FALLON -V- KBC BANK IRELAND LIMITED
10 2022 3614 P FICS HOLDINGS [ONE] DAC TA FINANCE IRELAND LEASIN -V- HAND
11 2021 6813 P HEENEY -V- RENEWABLE ENERGY INNOVATIONS UK LTD & ANOR
12 2014 2817 P KAVANAGH -V- KBC BANK PLC
13 2023 697 P KINSELLA -V- HOGAN
14 2018 9200 P KNOWLES -V- DUBLIN BUS/BUS ATHA CLIATH
15 2005 1667 S LOOMES -V- MURPHY & ANOR
16 2023 231 S MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IRELAND DAC -V- MCCALLION & ANOR
17 2023 232 S MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IRELAND DAC -V- SHERWIN
18 2021 2110 P MARTINI COLLINS -V- SEAPOINT CLINIC LTD & ORS
19 2013 10439 P MELLETT & ANOR -V- KBC BANK IRELAND PLC
20 2019 7868 P MOONEY -V- CHESTNUTT
21 2017 8786 P NOWAK -V- INTESA SANPAOLO LIFE LTD
22 2016 960 P NOWAK -V- INTESA SANPAOLO LIFE LTD
23 2022 6075 P O SHAUGHNESSY -V- CORCORAN
24 2023 3411 P PARK -V- FAHY
25 2014 2721 P PHILLIPS -V- KBC BANK IRELAND PLC
26 2013 10970 P RYAN -V- KBC BANK IRELAND PLC
27 2021 547 P TYRRELL & ANOR -V- MULLINS
28 2022 4188 P VON GEITZ -V- KELLY & ORS

MONDAY 22nd April 2024 COURT TBA

BEFORE JUDGE TBA (JUDGES name will appear on the “TODAYS CASES/ALL LISTS” Section of the
Legal Diary on Monday morning.
Common Law Motions List with a return date of 22/04/24 (Part 2 motions)
Motions (hybrid hearing)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

11.00 am onwards Numbers 29 – 96

29 H.P.2023.0006222 ATKINSON v CHILD AND FAMILY AGENCY
30 2022 1882 P AYUB -V- PAUL TRACEY PUST TRACEY SOLICITORS & ORS
31 2018 655 S BANK OF IRELAND MORTGAGE BANK -V- LYONS
32 2019 9018 P BOLAND -V- OLD PARK CATERING LIMITED
33 2017 7906 P BYRNE -V- MATER MISERCORDIAE UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL
34 2021 2710 P CAHILL -V- DUN LAOGHAIRE RATHDOWN COUNTY COUNCIL
35 2022 1779 P CANNY -V- ALLERGAN LTD
36 2018 5444 P CASSELLS -V- OFFICE OF THE REVENUE COMMISSIONERS
37 2022 6136 P COCIU -V- GOGA & ANOR
38 2018 1605 S COLLERAN -V- O CALLAGHAN & ANOR
39 2019 5866 P CONDON O CONNOR -V- SIDDIQUI & ORS
40 2019 5866 P CONDON O CONNOR -V- SIDDIQUI & ORS
41 2019 5866 P CONDON O CONNOR -V- SIDDIQUI & ORS
42 2020 2169 P CONLON -V- HSE & ORS
43 2023 2466 P CONNOLLY -V- VAYA & ANOR
44 2020 8609 P CONRAN -V- MEAGHER
45 2023 963 P CULLEN -V- BROSNAHAN
46 2020 6215 P CURRAN -V- O REILLY P/A HAMPTON DENTAL & ANOR
47 2023 2606 P CURRAN DORADO [A MINOR] -V- KILDARE COUNTY COUNCIL & ANOR
48 2022 3453 P DAME PLAZA PROPERTY TRADING DAC -V- TURBONY LIMITED & ORS
49 2019 814 P DARGAN -V- THE COMMISSIONER OF AN GARDA SIOCHANA & ORS
50 2019 8108 P DEVEREUX -V- MC GUINNESS & ANOR
51 2022 2392 P DIXON -V- THE ROTUNDA HOSPITAL
52 2021 1008 P DOHERTY -V- MINISTER FOR TRANSPORT TOURISM AND SPORT & ORS
53 2020 8189 P KW REAL ESTATE LAW -V- JOHN SISK AND SON [HOLDINGS] LTD & ORS
ANOR
53 2021 975 P DRAPALA -V- KILMOSS LTD & ANOR
54 2021 3103 P DUNNE -V- COOMBE WOMEN & INFANTS UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL
55 2023 405 P EILIAN -V- KINSELLA & ANOR
56 2023 3938 P ENGLISH -V- WHELAN & ORS
57 2017 3748 P ENRIGHT MAHER -V- BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OBERSTOWN CHILDREN
DETENTION & ORS
58 2020 767 P FALLON -V- FLETCHERS OF BALLINASLOE LIMITED
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
59 2023 1046 P FLYNN -V- FANG & ANOR
60 2022 3616 P FOGARTY -V- MCCRORY P/A DEANSGRANGE MEDICAL PRACTICE & ORS
61 2023 3928 P FOY -V- ALLERGAN LTD
62 2023 3521 P GALLAGHER & ANOR -V- SF SEALANTS LTD T/A FUREY TARMAC
63 2018 11140 P GAVIN -V- KERINS & ANOR
64 2014 5839 P GIBBONS -V- BNY MELLON FUND SERVICES [IRE] LTD
65 2020 6625 P GILLEN -V- CARTER & ANOR
66 2021 3196 P GOGGINS -V- M6 TRANSPORT SERVICES LTD
67 2023 2449 P GRAY -V- CORAL QUARRIES LTD & ANOR
68 2023 2627 P GUSCIUS -V- G4S CASH SERVICES & ANOR
69 2019 4922 P HAZLER -V- KEPAK CLONEE UNLIMITED COMPANY
70 H.P.2023.0005114 HIGGINS v ROTUNDA HOSPITAL
71 2023 4246 P HUGHES [APUM] -V- NATIONAL MATERNITY HOSPITAL
72 2019 4084 P IRELAND FOOD ADVISORY SERVICES LTD -V- STRATHROY DAIRY [ROI]
UMLINITED COMPANY
73 2022 4738 P KANE -V- COGHLANS CHEMIST LTD
74 2023 389 P KAVANAGH -V- RONDAR COMMERCIAL SERVICES LTD & ORS
75 2023 387 P KAVANAGH -V- RONDAR COMMERCIAL SERVICES LTD T/A DENTAL HOUSE
& ORS
76 2021 3434 P KAVANAGH [MINOR] -V- GOVERNORS AND GUARDIANS OF THE HOSPITAL
FOR THE
77 2023 617 P KEENAN -V- BURNS
78 2020 8224 P KEENAN -V- MINISTER FOR TRANSPORT TOURISM AND SPORT & ORS
79 2019 3940 P KELLY -V- CIRCUS RENZ INTERNATIONAL & ORS
80 2021 4023 P KELLY -V- ST MICHAELS HOSPITAL & ANOR
81 2019 3938 P KIERNAN -V- CIRCUS RENZ INTERNATIONAL & ORS
82 2022 1220 P KLOOS -V- IONESCU
83 2022 587 P KOVACOVA -V- TESCO IRELAND LTD
84 2017 11504 P LONG -V- CLARE COUNTY COUNCIL & ORS
85 2020 7197 P LULLING -V- HSE & ANOR
86 2021 764 P MAGUIRE -V- O DWYER & ANOR
87 2019 9070 P MAHON -V- BYRNE & ORS
88 2022 383 P MALLON -V- MCGEOUGH & ANOR
89 2022 4165 P MARAS -V- BLACKROCK CLINIC UNLIMITED COMPANY & ANOR
90 2016 5668 P MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IRELAND DAC -V- BENSON
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
91 2023 1837 P MCBRIDE & ORS -V- HSE
92 2021 3409 P MC DONAGH -V- EIRCOM LTD T/A EIR
93 2021 3402 P MCDONAGH -V- EIRCOM LTD T/A EIR
94 2014 10026 P MC DONAGH -V- MC GANN P/A SWEENEY MC GANN SOLICTORS & ORS
95 2021 463 P MC ELHINNEY -V- START MORTGAGES DAC & ANOR
96 2020 5506 P MCGIRR -V- BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OF CLOGOWES WOOD COLLEGE &
ANOR

MONDAY 22nd April 2024

BEFORE JUDGE TBA (JUDGES name will appear on the “TODAYS CASES/ALL LISTS” Section of the
Legal Diary on Monday morning.
Common Law Motions List with a return date of 22/04/24 (Part 3 motions)
Motions (hybrid hearing)
11am onwards Numbers 97-177

97 2020 3841 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION & SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
98 2020 3694 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION & SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
99 2018 11262 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS LTD
100 2019 2020 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
101 2019 2017 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
102 2019 2022 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
103 2019 2023 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
104 2019 2027 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
105 2019 2030 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
106 2019 2029 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
107 2019 2025 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ANOR
108 2019 2021 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LIMITED & ORS ORS
109 2018 7983 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD
110 2018 11263 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD
111 2018 7987 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD
112 2020 5172 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
113 2020 5170 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
114 2020 5167 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
115 2020 5158 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
116 2019 2018 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
117 2019 2014 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
118 2019 2015 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
119 2020 5154 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
120 2020 5163 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
121 2020 5164 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
122 2020 5162 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
123 2020 5148 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
124 2020 5171 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
125 2018 11264 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDING SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
126 2020 5149 P MINISTER FOR EDUCATION AND SKILLS -V- WESTERN BUILDINGS SYSTEMS
LTD & ORS
127 2022 5760 P MOLENDA -V- ALLGLASS WINDSCREENS REPAIR LTD
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
128 2019 8600 P MORRIS -V- WATCHFORD LTD & ORS
129 2022 5276 P MUNNELLY -V- HSE
130 2019 8137 P MURPHY -V- KELLOR JOINERY SERVICES LTD & ORS
131 H.P.2023.0005801 MURRAY v GILVARRY P/A GILVARRY & ASSOCIATES SOLICITORS
132 2021 5419 P O BRIEN -V- COEN
133 2020 2919 P O CONNOR & ANOR -V- HSE & ORS
134 2022 887 P O FAOLAIN [WHELAN] -V- LIMERICK CITY & COUNTY COUNCIL & ANOR
135 2022 2248 P O HALLORAN -V- MURPHY & ANOR
136 2023 1036 P O NEILL -V- FEGAN
137 2023 2544 P O NEILL -V- GASOHA NA HEIREANN/SCOUTING IRELAND
138 2021 5528 P O SULLIVAN -V- LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND & ORS
139 2019 6877 P O SULLIVAN -V- OPTICAL EXPRESS LTD & ORS
140 2019 7164 P OKONSKI -V- COSMOPOLITAN CLEANING CONTRACTORS LTD & ANOR
141 2016 8959 P ORR -V- ORR
142 2019 349 S PEPPER FINANCE CORPORATION (IRELAND) DAC -V- RYAN
143 2021 6250 P PERZAK -V- HSE
144 2020 6866 P REAPE -V- THE SHOW JUMPING ASSOCIATION OF IRELAND CLG & ORS
145 2016 2329 P REILLY -V- ICONIC NEWSPAPERS LTD
146 2023 2027 P RICE -V- PERMANENT TSB PLC
147 2019 3937 P ROONEY -V- CIRCUS RENZ INTERNATIONAL & ORS
148 2021 5789 P SEXTON -V- DEEBERT HOUSE HOTEL LTD
149 2023 3827 P SHARAKY -V- VARGAS LTD
150 2023 184 P SHARKEY & ANOR -V- HSE
151 2022 266 P SHEEHAN -V- COEN
152 2023 573 P SHEEHAN -V- HEALTH SERVICE EXECUTIVE
153 2023 2153 P SLOMKA -V- MAGANEY INDUSTRIES LTD
154 2020 1004 P SLON -V- VALCROFT LTD T/A MR BINMAN
155 2021 3566 P SMITH -V- COMMISSIONER OF AN GARDA SIOCHANA & ORS
156 2022 864 P SMITH -V- DAWSON
157 2017 8942 P SMITH -V- MC GRATH & ANOR
158 2020 8140 P SMITH [MINOR] -V- HSE
159 2021 1512 P SOKOLOWSKI -V- LIMERICK RESIDENTIAL LETTINGS LTD
160 2021 2944 P STAVELEY -V- WARREN
161 2023 3152 P STRATAN -V- OAKLEAF CONTRACTS [EUROPE] LIMITED & ANOR
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
162 2021 6048 P STRATYNSKI -V- IRISH PRISON SERVICE & ORS
163 2016 2789 P TAPLEY -V- CROWLEY
164 2023 3699 P TOBIN -V- APPLE OPERATIONS INTERNATIONAL LTD
165 2022 753 P TOLSON & ANOR -V- MACEOIN PUST MESSRS COLM MACEOIN & CO
SOLICITORS & ANOR
166 2023 1229 P TSEKOV -V- ABCON INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS LTD
167 2022 3269 P VEDMED -V- PAGEWELL LTD & ORS
168 2019 7740 P VON GEITZ -V- ROBERTSON & ORS
169 2023 3944 P WALL -V- O SULLIVAN P/A PHILIP O SULLIVAN & COMPANY SOLS
170 2020 6680 P WALSH & ANOR -V- ELECTRICITY SUPPLY BOARD
171 2023 3936 P WALSH -V- DUN LAOGHAIRE RATHDOWN COUNTY COUNCIL
172 2022 5165 P WARD -V- GOVERNOR OF WHEATFIELD PRISON & ORS
173 2020 2737 P WARDE -V- HSE & ORS
174 2023 1863 P WHYTE -V- GOLDEN & ANOR
175 2023 1863 P WHYTE -V- GOLDEN & ANOR
176 2023 2355 P WILKIE -V- THE BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OF ST FLANNANS SECONDARY
177 2023 4440 P WOJCICKI -V- HILLFORT QUARRIES LTD

COIMIRCITHE CÚIRTE
WARDS OF COURT
(i) Unless otherwise ordered, all wardship applications will proceed as hybrid hearings. Parties, witnesses and
other interested persons may either attend the physical courtroom or join the proceedings remotely.

(ii) Where any substantive issue needs to be determined in the course of wardship proceedings, the mode of
trial will be as determined by the trial judge.

(iii) Practitioners’ when connected to the Virtual Courtroom should remain at their logon device at all times. In
the event that the Court directs that a matter be heard in camera, practitioners’ are requested to disconnect from
the Virtual courtroom with immediate effect.

(iv) The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law Society
of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - [Link]

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK -
[Link]

Hybrid Hearings
Court 4
Before the President
Monday 22nd April 2024
At 11 o’ clock
1. In Re a Ward: Byrne Wallace; General Solicitor (Gary Henshaw)
At 11.15 am
2. In Re a Ward : St John Solicitors; Crowley Millar Solicitors (Julia Ryan)
At 11.30 am
[Link] Re a Ward: St. John Solicitors; Ita Lyster Solicitor (Joseph Connolly)
At 11.45 am
[Link] Re a Minor: Callan Tansey Solicitors (AM) Minor Ruling
At 11.50 am
[Link] Re a Minor: Callan Tansey Solicitors (CM) Minor Ruling

CÚRSAÍ NEAMHGHIÚRE
NON JURY
Court List

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts Court 6(Hybrid)

Date: 22/04/2024 10:30

List Type: NON JURY

Total: 0

Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of Papers and
Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the Monday
Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information on lodgement
for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline supersedes
the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday of
the week prior to the Hearing date.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover whether
the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical. If there is
no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.

Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of papers,
requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out will not be
acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further applications must be
made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new hearing
date.

2. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers which
the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the matter is
called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to the
list ([Link] later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only be
accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to ascertain
if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be lodged
in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the list
any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes of
stopping time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the parties
wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult High
Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox (nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link]) should primarily be used to send
in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review registrar
before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday (in
respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in respect
of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the Callover of
hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for mention
on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.

PLEASE NOTE- MS JUSTICE HYLAND’S PEXIP INFINITY NUMBER FOR THE NON JURY/ JUDICIAL
REVIEW AND ASYLUM LISTS IS-
[Link]

Certain matters for hearing may proceed physically if this was indicated at the positive call over on Thursday
prior to the hearing

The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law Society of
Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - [Link]

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK [Link]

The registrar is unable to respond to emails from practitioners in relation to connection details

APPLICATIONS IN RESPECT OF THIS LIST.

ATHBHREITHNIÚ BHREITHÚNACH
JUDICIAL REVIEW

Court List

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts Court 6(Hybrid)

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Date: 22/04/2024 10:30

List Type: JUDICIAL REVIEW

Total: 0

Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of Papers and
Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later than
the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the Monday Judicial
Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information on lodgement for that
list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline supersedes the
deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday of the
week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover whether
the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical. If there is no
attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.

Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of papers,
requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out will not be
acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further applications must be made
to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new hearing
date.

2. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers which
the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the matter is
called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the Monday
Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to the list ([Link]
later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only be accepted from a
fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to ascertain
if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the Statement
of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be lodged in
the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the list any
day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance. Booklets
of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping
time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the parties
wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult High Court
Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox (nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link]) should primarily be used to send in
terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review registrar
before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday (in
respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in respect of
Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the Callover of
hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link]
along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for mention on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.

PLEASE NOTE- MS JUSTICE HYLAND’S PEXIP INFINITY NUMBER FOR THE NON JURY/ JUDICIAL
REVIEW AND ASYLUM LISTS IS-
[Link]

Certain matters for hearing may proceed physically if this was indicated at the positive call over on Thursday prior
to the hearing

The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions are available to members through the Law Society of
Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - [Link]

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK [Link]

The registrar is unable to respond to emails from practitioners in relation to connection details

APPLICATIONS IN RESPECT OF THIS LIST.

FORIARRATAIS SEANSAIREACHTA (1)

CHANCERY MOTIONS (1)

FORIARRATAIS SEANSAIREACHTA (1)

CHANCERY MOTIONS (1)

MR JUSTICE MARK SANFEY

IN COURT NO 3 (HYBRID)
AT 11.00 O'CLOCK
ON MONDAY THE 22nd DAY OF APRIL 2024
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
N.B. Practitioners and unrepresented parties are asked to familiarise themselves with the List Notes below
before attending Court or contacting the Registrar. Remote access details are below.

Applications for Consent Orders before the Registrar from 10.30 am

FOR HEARING

1 2022 6415 P FARAAG & ORS -V- HE & ORS

FOR HEARING
2 2023 443 P COMBRAY LTD -V- TREACY & ORS
3 2013 5493 P COULSTON & ORS -V- ELLIOTT & ANOR
4 2022 278 P FLYNN -V- EVERYDAY FINANCE DAC & ORS
5 2022 5840 P MURPHY -V- WEXFORD COUNTY COUNCIL
6 2022 3766 P O BRIEN -V- O BRIEN
7 2022 3766 P O BRIEN -V- O BRIEN
8 2023 3232 P O MAHONY -V- FITZPATRICK & ANOR
9 2023 3050 P SAMANTA -V- KHAN [PRACTISING UNDER IMK
SOLICITORS]
10 2023 3453 P TAHBOUB -V- THE JOINT ARAB IRISH CHAMBER OF COMMERCE
COMPANY

MOTIONS
11 2022 2477 P BOYLE -V- PROPERTY REGISTRATION AUTHORITY OF IRELAND &
ORS
12 2022 2477 P BOYLE -V- PROPERTY REGISTRATION AUTHORITY OF IRELAND &
ORS
13 2023 443 P COMBRAY LTD -V- TREACY & ORS
14 2022 2618 P CUMMINS -V- TRUSTEES & BOARD OF MANAGEMENT OF ST JOSEPHS
15 2021 6017 P DALY -V- MALAHIDE WATERSIDE OWNERS MANAGEMENT COMPANY
& ANOR
16 2023 3970 P FINNERTY -V- GOOGLE IRELAND LTD
17 2022 278 P FLYNN -V- EVERYDAY FINANCE DAC & ORS
18 2020 2909 P FORTBERRY LIMITED -V- PROMONTORIA [ARAN] LIMITED & ORS
19 H.P.2024.0001274 GORDEN TRANSPORT LTD v THE REVENUE COMMISSIONERS & ORS
20 H.P.2024.0001469 HARRINGTON v SHERWOOD & ORS
21 2022 596 P HENNESSY -V- TYRELL & ANOR
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
22 2018 1814 P KBC BANK IRELAND PLC -V- SMITH & ORS
23 2023 2002 P KIRK -V- MCSWEENEY BUILDING & CIVIL ENGINEERING LTD
24 2011 8645 P LEYDEN -V- AIB PLC
25 2011 9760 P LYONS -V- DELANEY & ORS
26 H.P.2023.0005082 MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IRELAND DAC v DOHERTY
27 2022 5515 P MC DONALD & ANOR -V- EVERYDAY FINANCE DAC & ANOR
28 2022 4628 P MC DONNELL & ORS -V- PROMONTORIA [ARAN] LIMITED & ANOR
29 2020 6484 P MC GREAL -V- AIB PLC & ANOR
30 H.P.2024.0001276 MURPHY & ANOR v MATTIMOE
31 2023 3830 P MURPHY -V- MURPHY & ORS
32 2022 5978 P MURRAY & ORS -V- PERMANENT TSB
33 2022 3766 P O BRIEN -V- O BRIEN
34 2019 5744 P O CONNOR -V- DANSKE BANK A/S & ANOR
35 H.P.2023.0005426 O SHEA v O SHEA & ORS
36 2015 83 SP PERMANENT TSB PLC FORMERLY IRISH LIFE & PERMANENT & ANOR
-V- DONOHOE
37 H.P.2023.0005210 ROCHE & ANOR v THE GOVERNOR AND COMPANY OF THE BANK OF
IRELAND
38 2023 4457 P SANDYFORD PARK DEVELOPMENTS ONE COMPANY LTD BY
GUARANTEE -V- ALDI STORES [IRELAND] LTD
39 2022 4879 P SURFACE TREATMENT SPECIALISTS LTD -V- STORAN & ANOR
40 2023 3720 P TENNANT -V- SIKONO & ANOR
41 H.P.2024.0001191 WHELAN v MINISTER RODERIC O GORMON
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

NOTES ON THE OPERATION OF THE LIST

Ex Parte Applications

Moving parties are required to email the Registrar at chancery@[Link] in advance with a soft copy of the papers
for the Judge no later than 10.00 a.m. on the morning of any intended ex parte application. Hard copy papers
should be lodged with the Registrar in Court by 10.30 a.m. Such applications are not listed in advance. The
original stamped Ex Parte Docket should be handed to the Registrar in Court. A hard copy draft Notice of Motion
should be brought to Court where an order for short service may be made.

Motions for Hearing – Papers for the Court

Matters appearing in the Monday list are not ready for hearing unless the Court has been furnished with papers.
These hard copy papers are to be lodged by appointment in the List Room (not the Central Office) by 2 p.m. on
the Thursday preceding the Monday List where the application is to be opened. Papers should include a
paginated, bound and indexed booklet of motion papers clearly marked ‘Chancery Motions 1’ and be compliant
with all relevant Practice Directions.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
The Court / List Room does not retain papers for matters adjourned in the List. Papers are returned to the
List Room for collection within a week, and not retained thereafter. It is for practitioners, and in particular the
moving party, to ensure that papers were lodged (or re-lodged) the week preceding any application to the Court.
(email listroomhighcourt@[Link] for appointments)

Adjournment Applications

All applications for adjournments (including adjournments on consent) must be made to the Judge.

Transfers to the List to Fix Dates

Where a motion is likely to exceed 15 minutes an application must be made to the Judge to transfer to a List to
Fix Dates (heard each Friday during term). When applying, practitioners should be able to advise the Court
whether the affidavits are closed and if the matter is ready for hearing and to give an estimate of how long it is
likely to take to hear. The Registrar can deal with consent applications.

Default of Pleading

Practitioners should note the changes to the Rules of the Superior Courts with regards to default of pleading
applications. Some consent orders are no longer permitted; e.g. extensions of time for delivery of Defence can
only be made for a stated reason and there is a requirement to file a Defence in the Central Office where an
extension is granted. Consent orders not compliant with the rules cannot be made. Applications for Unless
Orders, including consent applications, must be made to the Judge.

REMOTE ACCESS DETAILS

Unrepresented Litigants seeking Remote Access

For anyone who is a party to a case before the High Court and who does not have legal representation, please
contact HighCourtVMR@[Link]. When doing so please provide the name of the case, the record number, the
court date and the name of the Judge (if known) and how you are associated with the matter before the court, i.e.
state if you are the plaintiff, defendant, respondent or other.

Remote Access for Practitioners

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Legal practitioners can obtain remote access via their respective professional bodies:

Law Society of Ireland [Link]

Bar of Ireland [Link]

Correspondence

Any correspondence regarding the list should be sent to chancery@[Link]

FORIARRATAIS SEANSAIREACHTA (2)

CHANCERY MOTIONS (2)
FORIARRATAIS SEANSAIREACHTA (2)
CHANCERY MOTIONS (2)
MONDAY 22nd APRIL 2024
BEFORE MR JUSTICE CREGAN
IN COURT No. 29
AT 10.30 O’CLOCK
ACCESS DETAILS FOR CHANCERY LIST:
LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK -
[Link]
BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA - REMOTE HEARING LINK -
[Link]
UNREPRESENTED PARTIES - For anyone who is unrepresented and a party to a matter before the
High Court please contact HighCourtVMR@[Link]. When contacting please provide the name of the
case, record number, court date and Judge (if known) and how you are associated with the matter before
the court i.e. plaintiff, defendant, respondent or other.

PETITIONS (Physical)
1. [Link].2024.0000034 CLONMANNON HOUSE RETIREMENT VILLAGE LTD v THE
COMPANIES ACT 2014
2. [Link].2024.0000050 ESKER PROPERTY HOLDINGS LTD v COMPANIES ACTS
3. [Link].2024.0000059 SHAPOORJI PALLONJI EUROPE LTD v COMPANIES ACTS
4. [Link].2024.0000029 STRACOMER HILL [DEVELOPMENTS] LTD v COMPANIES ACTS 2014
5. [Link].2024.0000027 TRIGLEN HOLDINGS LIMITED v THE COMPANIES ACT
FOR MENTION
6. [Link].2023.0000340 B v APPLE DISTRIBUTION INTERNATIONAL LTD
7. 2022 231 COS CEDARWOOD VENTURES LTD -V- THE COMPANIES ACT 2014
8. 2022 231 COS CEDARWOOD VENTURES LTD -V- THE COMPANIES ACT 2014
9. 2020 264 SP EVERYDAY FINANCE DAC -V- FEENEY & ANOR
10. 2022 222 COS IRISH WHISKEY MUSEUM LTD -V- THE COMPANIES ACT 2014
11. [Link].2023.0000327 KRAUSE & ORS v BARON & ANOR
12. [Link].2024.0000061 MONIGLE LIMITED v THE COMPANIES REGISTRATION OFFICE
13. 2019 203 COS SWAN FRUIT LTD -V- COMPANIES ACTS
14. [Link].2024.0000048 TOUAX RAIL & ORS -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
COMPANY RESTORATIONS
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
15. 2023 178 COS IRISH SIDE LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT
16. 2023 67 COS SOUTHFORD PROPERTIES LIMITED -V- THE COMPANIES ACTS 2014
MOTIONS
17. [Link].2024.0000067 BALLY BRAM MANAGEMENT COMPANYT LTD v COMPANIES ACT
2014
18. 2023 154 COS CEMS ENVIRONMENTAL & PROCESS CONTROLS LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT
2014
19. [Link].2024.0000069 CIRCLE INTERNET FINANCIAL LTD v COMPANIES ACTS
20. [Link].2024.0000068 DALSHANTRA LIMITED-v- COMPANIES ACT 2014
21. [Link].2024.0000053 DONEGAL DEMOCRAT LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) v COMPANIES
ACTS 2014
22. 2022 13 COS EAST DOUGLAS VILLAGE PROPERTIES LIMITED -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
23. [Link].2024.0000056 FUTURE DREAM DAIRIES LTD v COMPANIES ACTS
24. [Link].2024.0000049 GILROY AUTOMATION LIMITED v COMPANIES ACTS
25. [Link].2024.0000047 IN THE MATTER OF LOUGH SHEEVER MOTORS LIMITED v
COMPANIES ACT 2014
26. [Link].2024.0000055 KFW-IPEX-BANK GMBH v COMPANIES ACT 2014
27. [Link].2024.0000051 LIBERTY HORIZON LTD v COMPANIES ACT 2014
28. 2020 1718 P LYONS -V- ROADBRIDGE LIMITED
29. [Link].2024.0000060 R E ADMINISTRATION (IN LIQUIDATION) -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
30. [Link].2024.0000058 WAVE MEDIA COMMUNICATIONS LIMITED v THE COMPANIES ACT
2014

IN CAMERA
31. 2021 165 SP L v L
32. 2023 265 SP M v P
33. 2023 265 SP M v P
34. [Link].2023.0000305 M v M
35. [Link].2024.0000137 W v C

AT 2PM BEFORE MR. JUSTICE CREGAN

2023 6158 P WILSON v GHIZDAVU & ORS

LIOSTA TRACHTÁLA
COMMERCIAL LIST

PLEASE NOTE THE COMMERCIAL MOTION LIST IS HYBRID

MONDAY 22ND APRIL 2024
BEFORE MR JUSTICE TWOMEY
COURT 2
PLEASE REFER TO FOLLOWING LINKS FOR VMR NUMBER AND NOT THE REGISTRAR OR OFFICE:
[Link]
[Link]
PLEASE REFER TO PRACTICE DIRECTION HC 122 ATTACHED TO PART 2 OF THE COMMERCIAL LIST
AT 11:00 O’CLOCK
REMOTE CONSENT APPLICATIONS WILL BE TAKEN FIRST FOLLOWED BY PHYSICAL CONSENT APPLICATIONS

FOR MENTION
1. 2024 21 COS-WALLS CONSTRUCTION HOLDINGS LIMITED -V- THE COMPANIES ACT 2014
2. 2024 21 COS-WALLS CONSTRUCTION HOLDINGS LIMITED -V- THE COMPANIES ACT
3. 2023 169 MCA-META PLATFORMS IRELAND LTD -V- DATA PROTECTION COMMISSION
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
4. 2023 645 R- META PLATFORMS IRELAND LTD -V- DATA PROTECTION COMMISSION &
ORS
5. 2023 645 R-META PLATFORMS IRELAND LTD -V- DATA PROTECTION COMMISSION & ORS
6. 2023 2058 P-PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD
7. 2023 2058 P-PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD
8. 2023 2058 P-PROAMPAC UK LTD -V- MOVEBLOCK LTD

ENTRY MOTIONS
9. 2024 75 COS-THE INSTITUTE OF CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS IN IRELAND -V- THE
COMPANIES ACT 2014

INTERIM MOTIONS
10. 2016 9981 P-TRAFALGAR DEVELOPMENTS LTD & ORS -V- MAZEPIN & ORS
11. 2023 3317 P-SMITH & ANOR -V- O DONOVAN & ORS
12. 2023 3317 P-SMITH & ANOR -V- O DONOVAN & ORS
13. 2023 3317 P-SMITH & ANOR -V- O DONOVAN & ORS
14. 2023 122 COS-MMD CONSTRUCTION [CORK] LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
15. 2023 122 COS-MMD CONSTRUCTION [CORK] LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
16. 2023 122 COS-MMD CONSTRUCTION [CORK] LTD -V- COMPANIES ACT 2014
17. 2016 11479 P-KEENA -V- COUGHLAN & ORS

AN DLÍ TEAGHLAIGH
FAMILY LAW

MONDAY THE 22nd DAY OF APRIL 2024

FAMILY LAW LIST

FOR REMOTE HEARING

(NO PARTIES ARE PERMITTED PHYSICAL ACCESS TO THE COURT)

MR. JUSTICE JORDAN

COURT 7

AT 11.00 O’CLOCK

THE VIRTUAL COURTROOM NUMBER AND RELEVANT INSTRUCTIONS ARE AVAILABLE TO

MEMBERS THROUGH THE LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND AND THE BAR OF IRELAND WEBSITES:
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK
- HTTPS://[Link]/REMOTEHEARINGS
BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK
- HTTPS://[Link]/CONNECT/

Practitioners are requested to notify the other side, if unrepresented, of the virtual courtroom number.
Unrepresented parties are advised to identify themselves by initials only on screen when a matter is called.

MOTIONS FOR MENTION

1 2021 25 M R -V- R

2 2024 18 M F -V- F

ACTIONS FOR MENTION

3 2023 117 M H -V- A

4 2022 3 CAT K MC D -V- MC D

5 2023 24 M B -V- MC C

6 2020 110 M MC G -V- MC G

7 2020 110 M MC G -V- MC G

8 2024 12 M CFA & ORS -V- AAI

9 2023 116 M D -V- D

10 2023 113M MC H -V- MC H

11 2023 102 M M M -V- M

12 2024 18 M F -V- F

SUMMONSES

13 2022 107 M MC E -V- K

14 2023 27 M D -V- T

15 2024 61 M CFA & ORS -V- AAI & ANOR

CIRCUIT APPEAL

16 2024 17 CAF K -V- D

DIRECTIONS LIST
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
17 2024 50 M R-V- R

18 2024 52 M O D -V- O D

19 2024 18 CAF R -V- R

20 2024 51 M R -V- R

21 2023 4 CAT P -V- P

FÉIMHEACHT
BANKRUPTCY

BEFORE MR. JUSTICE KENNEDY

IN COURT 5
AT 11 O’CLOCK
22 APRIL 2024

IN COMPLIANCE WITH THE PRESIDENT’S NOTICE DATED 30 SEPTEMBER 2022 ALL MATTERS WILL
PROCEED BY WAY OF REMOTE HEARING AND NO PHYSICAL ATTENDANCE WILL BE PERMITTED.
The virtual courtroom numbers and relevant instructions will be available to Solicitors and Barristers through the
Law Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK - [Link]

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK - [Link]

1. Petition: J W: Applicant
2. Summons: P D: Clark Hill Solicitors LLP
3. Petition: D C: Mason Hayes & Curran LLP Solicitors
4. Motion: E O’S a Discharged Bankrupt: Clark Hill Solicitors LLP
5. Motion: James Callaghan a Bankrupt: Fieldfisher Ireland LLP Solicitors
6. Motion: M D a Discharged Bankrupt: Reddy Charlton LLP Solicitors
7. Motion: P L a Discharged Bankrupt: Reddy Charlton LLP Solicitors
8. Motion: A O’R a Discharged Bankrupt: Reddy Charlton LLP Solicitors
9. Motion: Steven Monaghan a Bankrupt: Reddy Charlton LLP Solicitors

SEANSAIREACHT TOGHAIRM SPEISALTA

CHANCERY SPECIAL SUMMONSES

Chancery Special Summons List Monday 22nd of April 2024

Chancery Special Summonses are listed for mention only or listed for hearing.

Matters listed for mention will generally be dealt with remotely however, where parties attend in Court, they will
be accommodated insofar as is possible.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Matters listed for hearing will be heard physically unless otherwise directed by the Judge.

Where parties wish to have a matter for hearing heard remotely, they may apply to the Court when the matter is
set down for hearing.

Matters listed by the Court for hearing take priority over matters listed for mention.

Filing papers:

Motion Papers or Special Summons must be filed in the Central Office by appointment using the following link:
[Link]

The hearing day granted to Motions / Special Summons by the Central Office is subject to the number of priority
matters before the Court on any given hearing day.

Matters for Mention

Where a matter is listed FOR MENTION in the Chancery Special Summons List, it WILL NOT be necessary
to file papers with the List Room.

Matters for Hearing

Where a matter is listed FOR HEARING in the Chancery Special Summons List, it WILL be necessary to lodge
an indexed, paginated bound booklet of pleadings in advance. Such booklets must be lodged in the List Room
of the High Court on or before 1.00 pm on the Wednesday immediately preceding the Monday upon which the
matter is listed for hearing. No late filings or lodgements to the list Room can be accepted.

When a matter has been adjourned the papers must be collected from the List room, at the very latest, by
Wednesday noon of that week. An appointment to collect the papers may be made by emailing
listroomhighcourt@[Link]. If papers are not collected by that date, same will be disposed of securely. When a
matter has concluded the papers will be disposed of securely.

As of 6th of June 2022 only matters that are transferred to the Chancery Special Summons list from another court
listing that are FOR HEARING OR FOR MENTION must adhere to the above guidelines.

Matters that are coming before the Court the following Monday will be published in the Legal Diary each
Thursday and will be clearly marked as listed for mention or for hearing. Matters for mention will be listed to
commence at 2pm. Matters listed for hearing will commence shortly after the conclusion of the matters listed for
mention and, in any event, not before 2.30pm.

There will be a call-over of the matters listed for hearing at 2pm prior to the commencement of the List. This is
to facilitate the scheduling of hearings so attendance of the parties would be of assistance but is not compulsory.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

Before: Mr. Justice Mulcahy

At: Four Courts (For Mention Remote / For Hearing Physical)

Date: 22/04/2024 14:00

List Type: CHANCERY SPECIAL SUMMONSES

Position Case Number Case Title

FOR MENTION
1 2020 133 SP START MORTGAGES DAC -V- JONES [ADMIN AD LITEM]

2 2008 706 SP START MORTGAGES DAC -V- CRINION & ANOR

3 2008 903 SP START MORTGAGES LTD -V- CULLEN

4 2018 180 SP START MORTGAGES DAC -V- COTTRELL

5 2009 1110 SP PROMONTORIA [FIELD] DAC -V- DOHERTY & ANOR

6 2023 277 SP PEPPER FINANCE CORPORATION [IRELAND] DAC V FOLEY

FOR HEARING
7 2023 209 SP MARS CAPITAL FINANCE IREALND DAC -V- VESEY

8 2022 241 SP MAHON -V- O REILLY

9 2010 457 SP START MORTGAGES DAC -V- MURPHY & ANOR

10 2007 848 SP START MORTGAGES DAC -V- WARD & ANOR

Contact for Chancery Special Summons List

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
There are new email contact details for various High Court lists due to the volume of enquiries received and so
that we can better monitor the receipt of messages in the absence of staff. Please note that the new contact for the
Chancery Special Summons List is Chanceryspecialsummons@[Link]

Virtual Court Information

• For Virtual Court information, please visit this link: [Link]

• Details of the virtual Courtroom number for this list are also available through the Law Society of Ireland
and the Bar of Ireland websites.
- LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK -
[Link]
- BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK
[Link]
• For litigants in person requesting connection details to virtual rooms please email
HighCourtVmr@[Link]
Peter Foley

High Court Registrar

Access to the Virtual Courtroom

Due to ongoing technical difficulties new Video Conferencing codes have issued for each Judge. In the ordinary
course please contact HighCourtVmr@[Link] but for convenience see the new link below for Mr Justice
Mulcahy

Mr. Justice Mulcahy

Virtual Meeting Room

Activated: 18th December 2023

Join the meeting: [Link]

Other ways to join:

From Microsoft Skype4B:

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
88898227@[Link]

From a video system (SIP/H.323):

88898227@[Link]

Don’t have internet? Join by dial-in:

Call +353 190 39773 (for other countries, click the link after "Join the meeting:")

Use conference Code: 88898227

DIRECTORS*

SRIANADH/DÍCHÁILIÚ STIÚRTHÓIRÍ
RESTRICTION/DISQUALIFICATION OF DIRECTORS

CÚITEAMH GARDAÍ
GARDA COMPENSATION
Garda Compensation List
Before Ms. Justice Leonie Reynolds
22/04/2024
Remote Sitting
At 11:00

Pursuant to S.I. No.418/2011 - Finance (Transfer of Departmental Administration and Ministerial Functions)
Order 2011 the Respondent in all Garda Compensation Special Summons is now the Minister for Public
Expenditure and
Reform. The effective date of this Order is 29th July 2011. References to the Minister for Finance shall from
the commencement date of this order be construed as references to the Minister for Public Expenditure and
Reform. New Summons issued in Garda proceedings should name the Minister for Public Expenditure and
Reform as the Respondent.

Garda Compensation Special Summons are made returnable to the Master's List for purely procedural reasons.
They are not called in the master's list and there is no need for practitioners to attend in respect of the listing.
The practice is that all such cases are automatically transferred to the Garda Compensation list.

The High Court Garda list deals only with applications under 1941 Act.
Once automatically transferred into the Garda Compensation list, the summons will sit in the list until such time
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
as the Applicant's solicitor and the chief state solicitor agree that the case is ready to get a date for hearing.

When this agreement has been reached, the Applicant solicitor can apply for a date for hearing by emailing
hcgardacompensation@[Link], copying the respondent solicitor in the same email , the email to include the
consent of the Applicant to Remote hearing along with the consent of the Respondent to the fixing of a date.

Practitioners should complete hearing date application forms (available from hcgardacompensation@[Link])
in advance of requesting a hearing date.

Where a date is fixed an indexed and paginated soft copy of the papers (copy affidavit reports etc) must
be emailed to hcgardacompensation@[Link] on the Tuesday preceding the assigned hearing date.

1. 2023 176 SP O BRIEN -V- MINISTER FOR PUBLIC EXPENDITURE AND REFORM
2. 2010 270 SP MELLAMPHY -V- MINISTER FOR FINANCE

PROBHÁID
PROBATE

ALL AFFIDAVITS AND/OR ADDITIONAL DOCUMENTS SHOULD BE FILED BY 4.00PM ON THE

WEDNESDAY PRECEDING THE MONDAY PROBATE LIST.

PLEASE NOTE THAT AN UPDATED BOOKLET CAN BE FILED IN RELATION TO ADDITIONAL FILED
DOCUMENTS. UPDATED BOOKLETS IF BEING RELIED UPON SHOULD BE FILED BY 4.00PM ON
THE WEDNESDAY PRECEDING THE MONDAY PROBATE LIST.

THE PROBATE OFFICE MUST BE NOTIFIED OF ALL APPLICATIONS FOR ADJOURNMENTS BEFORE
4.30PM ON THE THURSDAY PRECEDING THE MONDAY PROBATE LIST.

Monday 22nd April 2024

BEFORE MS JUSTICE STACK
IN COURT 10 (IN PERSON/PHYSICALLY)
AT 11 O’CLOCK

For Mention
In the estate of
Mary Dooley

On Notice at the Sitting

In the estate of:
1. Christina (o/w Nuala) Browne
2. Peter Clohessy & Ann Clohessy
3. Eugene Kelleher
4. Oliver O’Connor
5. Mary O’Connell
6. Nancy Walsh (o/w Anne Christina Clerkin)
7. John Joe O’Sullivan
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
8. Martin Hogan

On Notice
In the estate of:
9. Esther Rothwell
10. Alan Griffin

Ex Parte
In the estate of:
11. Maura Dempsey
12. Mary Angela Mangan
13. Daniel King
14. Margaret Bradley
15. James Gallagher
16. Patrick Larkin
17. Owen Nolan

For hearing at 2pm

In the estate of:
Martin Lawless

Probate Registrar
David Cullagh
davidcullagh@[Link]

TEARMANN
ASYLUM
Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of Papers
and Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the
Monday Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information on
lodgement for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline supersedes
the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday of
the week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover
whether the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical. If
there is no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of
papers, requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out
will not be acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further
applications must be made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new hearing
date.

2. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers
which the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the
matter is called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to
the list ([Link] later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only be
accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to
ascertain if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be
lodged in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the
list any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes of
stopping time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the parties
wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be
acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult High
Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox (nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link]) should primarily be used to send
in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review
registrar before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday (in
respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in respect
of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the Callover
of hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for mention
on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Court List (Web)

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts – Court 6

Date: 22/04/2024 14:00

List Type: ASYLUM PRE-LEAVE

Total: 30

Position Case Number Case Title Timeslot

1 [Link].2024.0000305 B v THE INTERNATIONAL PORTECTIONS APEALS
TRIBUNAL
2 [Link].2024.0000306 A v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTIONS APPEALS
TRIBUNAL
3 [Link].2024.0000214 L v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
4 [Link].2024.0000323 A v MJE
5 [Link].2024.0000322 A v IPAT
6 [Link].2024.0000215 M v MJ
7 [Link].2023.0001227
8 [Link].2023.0001390 N v MJ
9 [Link].2023.0001386 A v MJ
10 [Link].2023.0001306 AFRAH v MJE
11 [Link].2024.0000212 A v MJ
12 [Link].2024.0000411 CvM
13 [Link].2024.0000223 K v MJ
14 [Link].2024.0000248 A v MJ
15 [Link].2024.0000246 A v MJ
16 [Link].2024.0000247 I v MJ
17 [Link].2024.0000198 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
18 [Link].2024.0000209 H v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
19 [Link].2024.0000206 S v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
20 [Link].2024.0000207 S v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
21 [Link].2024.0000208 M v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
22 [Link].2024.0000210 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
23 [Link].2024.0000179 A v MJ
24 [Link].2024.0000314 G v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND EQUALITY
25 [Link].2024.0000316 G v MINISTER FOR JUTSICE
26 [Link].2024.0000315 O v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
27 [Link].2024.0000225 T v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION OFFICE
28 [Link].2024.0000355 I v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION APPEALS TRIBUNAL
29 [Link].2024.0000348 H v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION APPEALS
TRIBUNAL
30 [Link].2024.0000222 S v IPAT
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List Notice- Lodgement of
Papers and Correspondence with Registrars
31st October 2023
Please take notice of the following directions regarding the lodgement of papers and correspondence with
registrars:
1. Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Hearings and Callover of Hearings
Papers for hearings in Non-Jury, Judicial Review and Asylum Lists must be lodged in the List Room no later
than the Tuesday of the week prior to the Hearing date. (Please note, this deadline does not apply to the
Monday Judicial Review ex parte list and the Monday Asylum and Immigration ex parte list- for information on
lodgement for that list, see item 3 below).
Parties in Asylum, Immigration and Citizenship List hearings should note that the Tuesday deadline supersedes
the deadline for lodgement of papers for hearings included in in Asylum Practice direction HC81.
Any application for late lodgement of papers must be made to the List Judge at the callover on the Thursday of
the week prior to the Hearing date.
The callover takes placed on a hybrid basis and begins at 10 a.m. Parties must also indicate at the callover
whether the hearing will be physical, hybrid or remote. If no preference is given, the hearing will be physical. If
there is no attendance at the callover, the hearing will be struck out.
Correspondence to the registrars/mailbox/Judicial Assistant seeking permission for the late lodgement of
papers, requests to change the mode of hearing or applications to re-instate hearings that have been struck out
will not be acknowledged. No additional/missing documents will be accepted by email. Any further
applications must be made to the Court at the end of the list any day.
Papers for hearings will not be returned and will be shredded. They must be re-lodged prior to any new hearing
date.

2. Case Management Hearings

Lodgement of papers in advance is no longer required for Case Management hearings. If there are papers
which the parties wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these may be handed in by the solicitor when the
matter is called.

3. Judicial Review Ex Parte and Asylum Ex Parte Lists

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Papers for Judicial Review ex parte applications listed in the Monday Judicial Review Ex parte list and the
Monday Asylum Ex parte list must be lodged in the List Room no later than the Monday of the week prior to
the list ([Link] later than 7 days before the Listing). Due to capacity issues in the List Room, papers can only be
accepted from a fortnight before the listing date up until the Monday of the week prior to the Listing.
Papers for leave applications will not be returned and will be shredded They must be re-lodged prior to any
adjourned date.
4. Judicial Review and Asylum- “Leave on Notice” Applications
If the Court directs that an application for leave to seek Judicial Review is to be made on notice, the
applicant/applicant’s solicitor must liaise with the solicitor for the respondent prior to the return date to
ascertain if the leave application will be contested.
If the leave application will not be contested, the applicant/applicant’s solicitor must hand in a copy of the
Statement of Grounds to the Judge in court.
If the leave application is contested by the respondent(s), a hearing date will be given and papers must be
lodged in the List Room prior to the hearing in accordance with Item 1 above.

5. Judicial Review and Asylum- Applications to Open and Adjourn (to stop time)
Applications to open a Judicial Review for the purposes of stopping time only can be made at the end of the
list any day, provided the case has been issued by the Central Office and a record number has been obtained.
Practitioners do not have to email the registrar to ask for permission to mention the proceedings in advance.
Booklets of papers are not required in Court for the application to open the Judicial Review for the purposes of
stopping time.

6. Matters Listed for Mention

Papers are not to be lodged in the List Room for matters listed for mention. If there are papers which the parties
wish to bring to the attention of the Court, these are to be handed in when the matter is called.
Emails to registrars/Judicial Assistants regarding papers/correspondence for the Judge will not be
acknowledged.

7. Queries to the Non-Jury/Judicial Review List mailbox

Parties should be mindful of the volume of correspondence that registrars are receiving and must consult High
Court Search, the list diaries and Today’s cases on the Legal Diary and this notice before contacting the
registrar/mailbox.
The Non Jury and Judicial Review mailbox (nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link]) should primarily be used to send
in terms of orders or to request that certified actions are listed for mention to get a hearing date.
The most efficient way of raising queries is to mention your query to the Non-Jury and Judicial Review
registrar before the List or at the end of the list on Tuesday-Friday inclusive.
Most other requests to list matters for mention can mentioned to the Judge at the end of the List on Tuesday (in
respect of Judicial Review proceedings), Wednesday (in respect of non-Jury proceedings) or Fridays (in respect
of Asylum applications).
If sending a query to the mailbox, please ensure the record number is quoted in the subject line of the
correspondence.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

8. Consent Applications
Consent applications in the Non-Jury and Judicial Review Lists will be taken by the registrar on Tuesday,
Wednesday and Friday from 10:15. On Thursday, consent applications will be taken at the end of the Callover
of hearings.

9. Obtaining a hearing date for Non-Jury Actions

Once the Certificate of Readiness has been filed in the Central Office, please email
nonjuryjudicialreview@[Link] along with a soft copy of the Certificate. The action will be listed for mention
on the next available Wednesday.
Once the registrar provides the date, the requesting party must then inform the other party/parties of the date.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Court List (Web)

Before: Ms. Justice Niamh Hyland

At: Four Courts – Court 5

Date: 22/04/2024 10:00

List Type: ASYLUM POST-LEAVE

Total: 71

Position Case Number Case Title Timeslot

1 2023 452 JR V v MJ
2 [Link].2023.0001116 L v Minister for Justice
3 2023 718 JR S v MJ
4 2023 718 JR S v MJ
5 [Link].2023.0001111 A v Minister for Justice
6 [Link].2023.0001120 R v Minister for Justice
7 2023 840 JR WALSH -V- MJE
8 2023 665 JR B v MJ
9 [Link].2023.0001267 N v INTERANTION PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
10 2023 896 JR M v MJ
11 2023 837 JR H v MJ
12 2023 710 JR L v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
13 2023 439 JR T v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
14 [Link].2023.0001162 S v MJ
15 [Link].2023.0001083 P v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
16 2023 596 JR M v MJE
17 2023 253 JR AHMED & ANOR -V- MJ
18 2017 423 JR U v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE AND
EQUALITY
19 2023 915 JR K v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
20 [Link].2023.0001282 J v MJ
21 [Link].2023.0001415 N v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE & EQUALITY
22 [Link].2023.0001416 DARWISH v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
23 [Link].2023.0001430 A v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
24 [Link].2023.0001452 M v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
25 [Link].2023.0001439 T v MJ
26 [Link].2023.0001436 T v MJ
27 [Link].2023.0001434 T v MJ
28 [Link].2023.0001435 T v MJ
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

29 [Link].2023.0001438 B v MJ
30 [Link].2023.0001355 Y v THE MINISTER FOR FOREIGN
AFFAIRS
31 2023 666 JR S v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
32 2023 562 JR B v THE CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
33 2023 639 JR M v MJ
34 2022 1119 JR M v INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
35 2023 686 JR L v MJ
36 [Link].2023.0001262 H v MJE
37 2023 789 JR AZ v MJ
38 [Link].2023.0001264 MALLA v MJ
39 2023 903 JR N v CHIEF INTERNATIONAL
PROTECTION OFFICER
40 2023 141 JR E v MJ
41 2023 727 JR K v MJ
42 [Link].2023.0001173 A v MJ
43 [Link].2023.0001201 A v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
44 2023 728 JR B v MJ
45 [Link].2023.0001149 H v MJ
46 [Link].2023.0001270 H v THE INTERNATIONAL PROTECTION
APPEALS TRIBUNAL
47 2023 1073 JR AM v THE MINISTER FOR ENTERPRISE
TRADE AND EMPLOYMENT
48 2023 859 JR N v MJ
49 [Link].2023.0001406 O v MJ
50 [Link].2023.0001121 B v Minister for Justice
51 [Link].2024.0000285 A v MJ
52 [Link].2023.0001091 N v MJ
53 2023 1060 JR U v MJE
54 2023 1020 JR U v MJ
55 [Link].2023.0001273
56 [Link].2023.0001172 A v MJ
57 [Link].2023.0001080 A v MJ
58 [Link].2024.0000193 N v MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
59 [Link].2024.0000038 M v MJ
60 [Link].2024.0000043 M v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
61 [Link].2024.0000044 OMID v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
62 [Link].2024.0000067 F v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
63 [Link].2024.0000069 N v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
64 [Link].2024.0000084 K v MJ
65 [Link].2024.0000036 A v MJ
66 [Link].2024.0000149 A v MJ
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

67 [Link].2024.0000192 O v MJ
68 2023 926 JR I v MJ
69 [Link].2023.0001341 F v THE MJE
70 [Link].2023.0001250 A v THE MINISTER FOR JUSTICE
71 [Link].2023.0001090 A v THE MINISTER FOR FOREIGN
AFFAIRS

AN LIOSTA EISEACHADTA
EXTRADITION LIST

AN LIOSTA EISEACHADTA
EXTRADITION LIST
CCJ 20

Before Court 20 CCJ (capacity 54), unless otherwise specified.

Please note that courtrooms and court times are subject to change at short notice and are at the discretion of the
Court.

The High Court has issued a Guidance Document and Core Booklet for the Extradition list. The purpose of this
document is to increase the efficiency in the Extradition list and to ensure that all practitioners are aware of the
manner in which the list is run.

The link to the booklet is here: High Court Extradition List - Guidance Document and Core Booklet

The booklet is also available in the High Court Procedures Section on the Miscellaneous High Court Notices
page.

All queries regarding the list should be addressed to Extradition@[Link]

2024 AN LIOSTA EISEACHADTA

EXTRADITION LIST

MONDAY THE 22ND DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

APPLICATION TO ISSUE RELEVANT ARREST WARRANTS

1. 2024 80 EXT DPP -V- RA

2. 2024 81 EXT DPP -V- RA
3. 2024 63 EXT DPP -V- RGMM
4. 2024 64 EXT DPP -V- RGMM
5. 2024 91 EXT DPP -V- IK
6. 2024 92 EXT DPP -V- IK

APPLICATION TO ENDORSE RELEVANT ARREST WARRANRTS

7. 2024 89 EXT MJ -V- EGU

8. 2024 90 EXT MJ -V- EGU
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW RELEVANT ARREST WARRANTS

9. 2023 217 EXT DPP -V- MCM
10. 2022 195 EXT DPP -V- WC

POLISH

11. 2024 83 EXT MJ -v- OSKAR DAMIAN LOCINSKI S16(NOT)

ENGLISH

12. 2020 214 EXT MJE -V- HARD GALLAGHER S18

13. 2022 168 EXT MJ -V- TOMASZ BARANOWICZ S18
14. 2024 10 EXT MJ -V- ELKHOMU DAVID EHIMARE S16FM
15. 2024 14 EXT MJ -V- ELKHOMU DAVID EHIMARE S16FM

TUESDAY THE 23RD DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2023 29 EXT MJ -V- PAWEL WOJCIECH KOSMALA STAYFM

2. 2023 225 EXT MJ -V- MARK ANDREW ADAMS S16FH

BEFORE MS JUSTICE GREALLY IN CCJ TBC AT 11.00AM

ENGLISH

1. 2022 264 EXT MJ -V- PATK SPARLING Cert of Appeal

2. 2022 265 EXT MJ -V- DANIEL O’BRIEN Cert of Appeal
3. 2022 266 EXT MJ -V- JAMES COFFEY Cert of Appeal

WEDNESDAY THE 24TH DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2023 161 EXT MJ -V- MICHAL JERZY MALECKI S16(AH)PMcG Resumed

2. 2018 389 EXT MJ -V- MICHAL JERZY MALECKI STAYFM

LITHUANIAN

3. 2023 211 EXT MJ -V- PRANAS GARBENIS S16FH

4. 2024 21 EXT MJ -V- PRANAS GARBENIS S16FH

THURSDAY THE 25TH DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2023 177 EXT MJ -V- JAMES PATK MICHAEL TOMANY S16FH

2. 2024 23 EXT MJ -V- STEPHEN ANDREW MCLAUGHLIN S16FH
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
3. 2024 48 EXT MJ -V- STEPHEN ANDREW MCLAUGHLIN S16FH
4. 2023 130 EXT MJ -V- PETER KEATING S16JT
5. 2021 214 EXT MJ -V- ANDREJ PILO ORDER

POLISH

6. 2023 118 EXT MJ -V- LUKASZ JAN KACZMAREK S16FH(Resumed)

BEFORE MS. JUSTICE MELANIE GREALLY IN CCJ TBC AT 10.30AM

ENGLISH

1. 2023 168 EXT MJ -V- HARD SHARPLES S16JT

FRIDAY THE 26TH DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2023 247 EXT MJ -V- KRZYSZTOF ARKADIUSZ WILGORZ S16FH

2. 2024 73 EXT MJ -V- PAWEL BARTNIKIEWICZ S16NOT

ROMANIAN

3. 2024 49 EXT MJ -V- LEONARD BUCURESTEANU S20FM

UKRAINIAN

4. 2023 95 EXT AG -V- OLEKSII OLEKSIYOVYCH LYTVYNENKO FM

ENGLISH

5. 2024 22 EXT MJ -V- CHRISTOPHER SHANE FRANE S16FM

BEFORE MS JUSTICE GREALLY IN CCJ AT 10.30 AM

ENGLISH

1. 2023 152 EXT MJ -V- GRZEGORZ KOLTUN (No interp required) S16FM

(decision on points raised)

MONDAY THE 29TH DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2022 188 EXT MJ -V- JOHN PATK O’DONOGHUE S18

2. 2023 63 EXT AG -V- JOHN JOSEPH DRISLANE 1965FM
3. 2024 61 EXT MJ -V- DAVID ARCHER S16NOT

ROMANIAN
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
4. 2024 9 EXT MJ -V- BOGDAN IONUT MARCU S16FH

SPANISH

5. 2024 82 EXT MJ -V- ENEKOITZ GARAY URRUTIA S16FM

BEFORE MS JUSTICE GREALLY IN CCJ AT 10.30AM

CROATIAN

1. 2023 146 EXT MJ -V- DRAGAN RAKANOVIC S16(AH)MG(FM/POSS JT)

TUESDAY THE 30TH DAY OF APRIL 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2023 193 EXT MJ -V- ALEXANDRU-IOAN GHIBAN S16AH(PMcG)

2. 2012 169 EXT MJ -V- ADRIJUS JAKUTIS S16FH
3. 2022 171 EXT MJ -V- ANDRZEJ GRUCHACZ S16FM

WEDNESDAY THE 1ST DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2023 128 EXT MJ -V- THOMAS STOKES S16FH

ROMANIAN

2. 2024 31 EXT MJ -V- MIHAI IOAN-PLESA S16FH

CZECH

3. 2024 41 EXT MJ -V- MILAN SRBEK S16FH

THURSDAY THE 2ND DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ROMANIAN

1. 2024 69 EXT MJ -V- MARCEL CIURAR S16FH

CZECH

2. 2023 197 EXT MJ -V- MILAN BUDIK S16FH

HUNGARIAN

3. 2023 241 EXT MJ -V- TIBOR CSEPKE S16FH

BEFORE MS. JUSTICE MELANIE GREALLY IN CCJ TBC AT 10.30AM

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

POLISH

1. 2023 167 EXT MJ -V- ARTUR WRONA S16FM

2. 2023 172 EXT MJ -V- ARTUR WRONA S16FM

POLISH

3. 2023 135 EXT MJ -V- ROBERT ALEKSANDER SZYMCZAK S16AH(MG)JT

FRIDAY THE 3RD DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2023 236 EXT MJ -V- KRZYSZTOF KARKOSA S16FH

2. 2023 78 EXT MJ -V- MICHAL JACEK KALINOWSKI S16FH

PORTUGUESE

3. 2023 212 EXT MJ -V- FRANCLIM JOSE SOARES VITOR S16FH

TUESDAY THE 7TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

CROATIAN

1. 2021 190 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18

2. 2021 208 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18
3. 2021 209 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18
4. 2021 210 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18
5. 2021 211 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18
6. 2021 212 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18
7. 2021 213 EXT MJ -V- IVAN HERCEG S18

ROMANIAN

8. 2023 194 EXT MJ -V- MARIAN CANTEA S16FH

9. 2023 198 EXT MJ -V- MARIAN CANTEA S16FH
10. 2023 199 EXT MJ -V- MARIAN CANTEA S16FH
11. 2023 200 EXT MJ -V- MARIAN CANTEA S16FH
12. 2023 201 EXT MJ -V- MARIAN CANTEA S16FH
13. 2023 260 EXT MJ -V- DUMITRU VERDIS S18

ENGLISH

14. 2020 388 EXT MJ -V- PATK JOSEPH WARD S16JT

15. 2020 389 EXT MJ -V- PATK JOSEPH WARD S16JT

WEDNESDAY THE 8TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
POLISH

1. 2023 169 EXT MJ -V- MARIUSZ ZAJAC S16FM

FRIDAY THE 10TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

PORTUGUESE

1. 2024 11 EXT MJ -V- RUI MANUEL CASIMIRO SEIDI S16FH

PUNJABI

2. 2023 233 EXT MJ -V- AMRIK SINGH S16FH

ENGLISH

3. 2024 22 EXT MJ -V- CHRISTOPHER SHANE FRANE S16FH

ROMANIAN

4. 2023 119 EXT MJ -V- ROBERT MOISE S16FM

MONDAY THE 13TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

LITHUANIAN

1. 2021 237 EXT MJ -V- PAULIUS ALESIUS S18

ENGLISH

2. 2017 247 EXT DPP -V- DEREK BROCKWELL FM

POLISH

3. 2024 24 EXT MJ -V- PRZEMYSLAW MAREK LANIECKI S16FM

BEFORE MS JUSTICE BIGGS IN CCJ TBC AT 11.00AM

ENGLISH

1. 2022 85 EXT MJ -V- ROBERT DUFFY S16FM

BEFORE MR JUSTICE NAIDOO IN CCJ TBC AT 10.30AM

POLISH

1. 2023 43 EXT MJ -V- IRENEUZ AGRIPA S16JT

2. 2022 32 EXT MJ -V- ARTUR SEBASTIAN TETKOWSKI FM ONLY
3. 2022 38 EXT MJ -V- ARTUR SEBASTIAN TETKOWSKI FM ONLY
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
TUESDAY THE 14TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

UKRAINIAN

1. 2023 95 EXT AG -V- OLEKSII OLEKSIYOVYCH LYTVYNENKO FH 1.5DAYS

ENGLISH

2. 2019 372 EXT MJ -V- ANDREW MCCULLOCH S18

WEDNESDAY THE 15TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2023 209 EXT MJ -V- MAKSYM LUKASZ KIMIECIK S18

2. 2024 24 EXT MJ -V- PRZEMYSLAW MAREK LANIECKI S20FM

UKRAINIAN

3. 2023 95 EXT AG -V- OLEKSII OLEKSIYOVYCH LYTVYNENKO FH .5 DAYS (cont)

THURSDAY THE 16TH DAY OF MAY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2023 235 EXT MJ -V- BARTLOMIEJ SMOLINSKI STAYFM

2. 2024 74 EXT MJ -V- BOZENA MARIA JANUCHOWSKA S16FH

ENGLISH

3. 2024 19 EXT MJ -V- STEPHEN DOLAN S18(1)(C)FM

TUESDAY THE 4TH DAY OF JUNE 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2021 241 EXT MJ -V- MICHAEL KEHINDE OLUKOYA S18

2. 2021 251 EXT MJ -V- MICHAEL KEHINDE OLUKOYA S18

MONDAY THE 10TH DAY OF JUNE 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

LITHUANIAN

1. 2020 358 EXT MJ -V- VLADISLAV SILKO S18

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

ROMANIAN

2. 2023 67 EXT MJ -V- ROSMARIN MIHALACHE SERBAN S18

ENGLISH

3. 2022 162 EXT MJ -V- LARRY O’REILLY S18

POLISH

4. 2022 246 EXT MJ -V- FILIP BRYLA S18

MONDAY THE 17TH DAY OF JUNE 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2021 218 EXT MJ -V- ANDREW CONNORS S18

MONDAY THE 24TH DAY OF JUNE 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2017 52 EXT MJE -V- JAROSLAW LIWINSKI S18

2. 2023 37 EXT MJ -V- GRZEGORZ BUCZKOWSKI S18

FRIDAY THE 28TH DAY OF JUNE 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2021 189 EXT MJ -V- MARIUSZ PIETROWSKI S18

MONDAY THE 1ST DAY OF JULY

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2022 205 EXT MJ -V-PATK MCCARTHY S18

POLISH

2. 2017 227 EXT MJ -V- TADEUSZ IGNACY JANUSZ S18

WEDNESDAY THE 3RD DAY OF JULY

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

LITHUANIAN
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

1. 2024 55 EXT MJ -V- VALIUS SAKAVICIUS S16FH

MONDAY THE 8TH DAY OF JULY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ROMANIAN

1. 2021 45 EXT MJ -V- IULIAN STAMATE S18

TUESDAY THE 9TH DAY OF JULY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT CCJ TBC AT 11:00

POLISH

1. 2022 58 EXT MJ -V- ANNA MARTA ŚWIERCZEK S18

MONDAY THE 15TH DAY OF JULY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ROMANIAN

1. 2023 27 EXT MJ -V- VASILE SORIN LAZAR S18

2. 2023 28 EXT MJ -V- VASILE SORIN LAZAR S18
3. 2023 145 EXT MJ -V- CATALIN JIMI MUNTEANU S18

ENGLISH

4. 2021 135 EXT MJ -V- PATK O’LEARY S16FM

5. 2021 136 EXT MJ -V- PATK O’LEARY S16FM

FRIDAY THE 26TH DAY OF JULY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2020 342 EXT MJ -V- MONIKA EDYTA ZARZYCKA S18

ENGLISH

2. 2021 141 EXT MJ -V- ALEXANDER JAMES KEANE S18

MONDAY THE 29TH DAY OF JULY 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

1. 2021 95 EXT MJ -V- MACIEJ RUDNICKI S18

CZECH

2. 2023 136 EXT MJ -V- PETRA DROBNA S18

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
3. 2023 144 EXT MJ -V- PETRA DROBNA S18
4. 2023 166 EXT MJ -V- PETRA DROBNA S18

WEDNESDAY THE 2ND DAY OF OCTOBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2021 306 EXT MJ -V- DAMIAN GRAMS S18

MONDAY THE 7TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2022 177 EXT MJ -V- KACPER PAWLIKOWSKI S18

MONDAY THE 14TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2022 170 EXT MJ -V- DEREK WADE S18

MONDAY THE 21ST DAY OF OCTOBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2014 158 EXT MJE -V- ANDRZEJ GRUCHACZ S18

2. 2014 159 EXT MJE -V- ANDRZEJ GRUCHACZ S18

MONDAY THE 28TH DAY OF OCTOBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2021 73 EXT MJ -V- CRISTIAN IANCU S18

MONDAY THE 11TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2021 256 EXT MJ -V- LUKASZ BAJEK S18

MONDAY THE 18TH DAY OF NOVEMBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

ENGLISH
1. 2022 165 EXT MJ -V- JOHN DARREN SWEENEY S18
2. 2022 166 EXT MJ -V- JOHN DARREN SWEENEY S18

MONDAY THE 16TH DAY OF DECEMBER 2024

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

POLISH

1. 2021 367 EXT MJ -V- ADAM ANDRZEJ WITKOWSKI S18

ROMANIAN

2. 2019 386 EXT MJE -V- IOAN GALBEN S18

3. 2020 13 EXT MJE -V- IOAN GALBEN S18

ENGLISH

4. 2021 235 EXT MJ -V- BRENDAN CASEY S18

MONDAY THE 20TH DAY OF JANUARY 2025

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ALBANIAN

1. 2022 131 EXT MJ -V- NDIM QEMA S18

THURSDAY THE 6TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ITALIAN

1. 2023 26 EXT MJ -V- BACHAR EL FATTOURY S18

MONDAY THE 24TH DAY OF FEBRUARY 2025

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2023 227 EXT MJ -V- THOMAS WALL S18

TUESDAY THE 1ST DAY OF APRIL 2025

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

1. 2020 281 EXT MJ -V- PATK MC GINLEY S18

MONDAY THE 28TH DAY OF APRIL 2025

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT IN CCJ TBC AT 10.30AM

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

ENGLISH

1. 2021 177 EXT MJ -V- MARK NOLAN S18

2. 2021 325 EXT MJ -V- MARK NOLAN S18

MONDAY THE 19TH DAY OF JANUARY 2026

BEFORE A JUDGE OF THE HIGH COURT

ENGLISH

1. 2019 357 EXT MJE -V- LARRY CONNORS S18

2. 2020 128 EXT MJE -V- LAWRENCE LARRY CONNORS S18

DÓCHMHAINNEACHT PHEARSANTA
PERSONAL INSOLVENCY

AN LIOSTA UM DHÓCMHAINNEACHT PHEARSANT/PERSONAL INSOLVENCY LIST

Before The Hon. Mr. Justice Alexander Owens
On Monday, 22 April 2024 At 12.15 PM
High Court - Court 26
Four Courts, Dublin 7

FOR MENTION
Position Case Number Case Title
1 2022 179 CA HYNES -V- PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012 TO 2015
2 [Link].2023.0000217 TRUMPE v SECTION 115A[9] OF THE PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS
2012 - 2021
3 2022 123 CA MCNULTY -V- PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACT
4 [Link].2024.0000018 KELLY v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012-2021
5 [Link].2024.0000032 O DWYER v THE PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012/2021
6 [Link].2023.0000227 POOLE & ANOR V PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012- 2021
7 [Link].2024.0000078 WYNNE v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012 TO 2021
8 [Link].2024.0000079 WYNNE v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS 2012 TO 2021
9 [Link].2024.0000074 TAYLOR v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS
10 [Link].2024.0000071 DELANEY v PERSONAL INSOVANCE ACTS 2012 TO 2021
11 [Link].2024.0000076 RYAN v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS
12 [Link].2024.0000077 SCANLON v PERSONAL INSOLVENCY ACTS
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
13 H:IS:H[Link] JOHN RYAN (PIA)
14 H:IS:H[Link] NIALL KELLY (PIA)
15 H:IS:H[Link] DAVID MAGUIRE (PIA)
16 H:IS:H[Link] CAROL LOMBARD (PIA)
17 H:IS:H[Link] DAVID LAWLOR (PIA)

APPLICATION

18 H:IS:H[Link] THOMAS BRENNAN (PIA)

FOR HEARING

19 H:IS:H[Link] JUNE SMITH

20 H:IS:H[Link] JAMES SMITH
21 H:IS:H[Link] THOMAS JOHNSON
22 H:IS:H[Link] VALERIE JOHNSON

BREITHNEOIRÍ COSTAS DLÍTHIÚIL

LEGAL COSTS ADJUDICATORS

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Legal Costs Adjudicator Barry Magee
On Monday, 22 April 2024 At 10:00
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 2
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OL[Link] Barbara Madrela -v- Health Service Executive

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Legal Costs Adjudicator Barry Magee
On Monday, 22 April 2024 At 11:30
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 2
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
1 H:LCA:OL[Link] Elaine Bourke -v- Felipe de Araujo and Motor Insurers
Bureau of Ireland

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Legal Costs Adjudicator Barry Magee
On Monday, 22 April 2024 At 12:00
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 2
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OL[Link] Clayton Richard Delport, Natasha Delport, Jaiden Ernst (a

minor suing by his father and next friend Clayton Richard Delport)and Aaaron Clayton Delport (a minor
suing by his father and next friend Clayton Richard Delport) and The Minister for Justice

High Court
Adjudication of Legal Costs Hearing
Before Legal Costs Adjudicator Barry Magee
On Monday, 22 April 2024 At 12:30
Office of the Legal Costs Adjudicators - Adjudication Room 2
1st Floor, Merchants House, 27-30 Merchants Quay, Dublin 8

1 H:LCA:OL[Link] Tom Riordan Farm Buildings Limited and Denis Joseph

O'Connell and Josephine Duggan

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT LIST

LIOSTA UM PLEANÁIL AGUS COMHSHAOIL
MONDAY 22 APRIL 2024

Please send all correspondence and queries to environment@[Link] copying Ms. Kathryn McKimm
(kathrynmckimm@[Link]) for cases before Mr. Justice Humphreys, Mr. Eoin Gormley
(eoingormley@[Link]) for matters before Mr. Justice Holland and Megan Delahunty
(megandelahunty@[Link]) for matters before Ms. Justice Farrell. Information about the list is set out at
[Link] The Monday list will be held remotely until
further notice. The Virtual Courtroom Number (UNDER THE JUDGE’S NAME) and relevant instructions for
practitioners will be made available to members through the Law Society of Ireland and the Bar of Ireland
Websites:

LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND - REMOTE HEARING LINK

[Link]

BAR OF IRELAND MEMBERS AREA -REMOTE HEARING LINK

[Link]

The public are welcome to contact environment@[Link] for access to the remote court facility.
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

The List to Fix Dates will take place on Monday 29th April. For cases where a completed checklist has been
supplied in accordance with the Practice Direction and Guidance Notes, dates will be fixed over the period
October to December 2024. Dates in September, 2024 are currently available and parties wishing to avail of
same should contact the List Registrar for a listing for this purpose.
BEFORE MR. JUSTICE HUMPHREYS @ 09:30HRS REMOTE
1. [Link].2021.0000058 O LONE -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
2. [Link].2021.0000507 CLANE COMMUNITY COUNCIL -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
3. [Link].2021.0000648 WATERSIDE BLOCK 9 DEVELOPMENTS LTD -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
4. [Link].2021.0000648 WATERSIDE BLOCK 9 DEVELOPMENTS LTD -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
5. [Link].2021.0000810 BALLYBODEN TIDY TOWNS GROUP -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
6. [Link].2021.0000330 KING -V- AN BORD PLEANALA
7. [Link].2022.0000528 NEWMAR GLOBAL PROPERTIES LIMITED -V- GALWAY COUNTY
COUNCIL
8. [Link].2022.0000819 STOKES & ANOR -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
9. [Link].2022.0001022 CARROWNAGOWAN CONCERN GROUP & ORS -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
10. [Link].2022.0001022 CARROWNAGOWAN CONCERN GROUP & ORS -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
11. [Link].2022.0001022 CARROWNAGOWAN CONCERN GROUP & ORS -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
12. [Link].2023.0000627 FRIENDS OF THE IRISH ENVIRONMENT -V- THE MINISTER FOR THE
ENVIRONMENT CLIMATE & ORS
13. [Link].2023.0000822 TRINITY GARDENS RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION & ANOR -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
14. [Link].2023.0000886 SHORTEN -V- AN BOARD PLEANÁLA
15. [Link].2023.0000920 SWEETMAN -V- THE ENVORONMENAL PROTECTION AGENCY & ORS
16. [Link].2023.0001002 HIBERNIA STAR & ANOR -V- CORK CITY COUNCIL
17. [Link].2023.0001028 KIMMAGE DUBLIN RESIDENTS ALLIANCE COMPANY LTD BY -V- AN
BORD PLEANÁLA
18. [Link].2023.0001252 RYAN v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
19. [Link].2023.0001412 RODEN v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
20. [Link].2023.0001464 TAMER METAL RECYCLING LIMITED v AN BORD PLEANÁLA
21. [Link].2024.0000037 MASSEY v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
22. [Link].2024.0000097 SWEETMAN & ANOR v IARNROD EIREANN - IRISH RAIL
23. [Link].2024.0000156 LYNCH v AN BORD PLEANÁLA
24. [Link].2024.0000251 SWEETMAN & ANOR v WESTMEATH COUNTY COUNCIL
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
25. [Link].2024.0000255 FOSTER v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
26. [Link].2024.0000288 PAROSI DEVELOPMENTS LTD v AN BORD PLEANÁLA
27. [Link].2024.0000301 MCKEOWN v AN BOARD PLEANÁLA & ANOR
28. [Link].2024.0000304 SMITH GROUNDWORKS & CIVIL ENGINEERING LTD v AN BORD
PLEANÁLA
29. [Link].2024.0000342 BYRNE v FINGAL COUNTY COUNCIL & ORS
30. [Link].2024.0000362 BROPHY v AN BORD PLEANÁLA
31. [Link].2024.0000379 JOYCE KEMPER v AN BORD PLEANLA
32. [Link].2024.0000407 RYANAIR DAC v AN BORD PLEANÁLA
33. [Link].2024.0000314 PUNCHESTOWN AREA COMMUNITY GROUP CLG & ANOR v AN BORD
PLEANALA & ORS
34. [Link].2024.0000550 BREEDON CEMENT IRELAND LTD v AN BORD PLEANALA

BEFORE MR. JUSTICE HOLLAND NOT BEFORE 10:00HRS REMOTE

1. [Link].2021.0000771 KELLY & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
2. [Link].2021.0000771 KELLY & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
3. [Link].2021.0000804 FERNLEIGH RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION & ANOR -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
4. [Link].2022.0000141 EXECUTIVE MANAGEMENT OWNERS MANAGEMENT CLG & ORS -V-
AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ANOR ANOR
5. [Link].2022.0000336 MULLOY -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
6. [Link].2022.0000455 RESIDENTS WBC CLG -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
7. [Link].2022.0000471 LEOPARDSTOWN ACTION GROUP -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
8. [Link].2022.0000473 CONWAY -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
9. [Link].2023.0000096 DONEGAL COUNTY COUNCIL -V- PLANREE LTD & ANOR

BEFORE MS. JUSTICE FARRELL @ 09:30HRS REMOTE

1. [Link].2023.0000129 SANDYMARK LTD & ORS -V- MINISTER FOR HOUSING LOCAL
GOVERNMENT AND HERITAGE & ORS
2. [Link].2023.0000996 HERBERT & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
3. [Link].2023.0001489 PURCELL v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
4. [Link].2023.0001490 PURCELL v AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
5. [Link].2024.0000174 O'MEARA v WESTMEATH COUNTY COUNCIL & ANOR
6. [Link].2024.0000200 COULSON & ANOR v AN BORD PLEANÁLA

APPLICATIONS IN THE LIST

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
Parties and practitioners are referred to Practice Direction HC124 (effective 11 December 2023) and to guidance
notices issued by the Judge in Charge of the List, which are available from the List Registrar
(environment@[Link]). Where it is intended to make an application in the list either for ex parte leave, for
admission of a case to the list, or otherwise, parties are encouraged to make contact with the List Registrar in the
first instance as early as possible so that appropriate directions can be given.

SHAREFILE
As per High Court Practice Direction 124 to practitioners in the Planning and Environment List each case in this
list will be allocated a Sharefile for the uploading of soft copies of core documents, pleadings and exhibits related
to the proceedings. Solicitors and Counsel are advised to contact sadhbhmooney@[Link] to gain access
to the Sharefile folder for their case.
SEPTEMBER PILOT PROJECT
All cases listed for hearing in September 2024 will be listed for mention on 29 July 2024. All schedules of
directions must require the completion of all papers, submissions and the statement of case, uploading of
authorities and the full population and organisation of the ShareFile Folder, by the very latest deadline of 24 July
2024, with a strict requirement on all parties to contact the List Registrar to re-list the matter before then if there
is any slippage in compliance with any directions that is likely to affect compliance by that deadline. In view of
the longer than usual term for the List commencing in September, 2024, it is envisaged that writing weeks will
be synchronized for the week of Tuesday 29 October 2024, so that it is not anticipated that cases would be listed
for substantive hearing that week
PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT LIST HEARING DATES

EASTER

23rd APRIL 2024

2023 0129 JR SANDYMARK LIMITED AND ORS. V MINISTER FOR HOUSING, LOCAL
GOVERNMENT AND HERITAGE AND ORS
(PHYSICAL HEARING 3 DAYS)

30th APRIL 2024

2022 0987 JR KIMMAGE DUBLIN ALLIANCE CLG -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA

(3 DAYS FULL PHYSICAL HEARING)

7th MAY 2024

2022 0528 JR NEWMAR GLOBAL PROPERTIES LIMITED -V- GALWAY COUNTY COUNCIL
(3 DAYS FULL PHYSICAL HEARING)

2022 1022 JR CARROWNAGOWAN CONCERN GROUP & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(3 DAYS REMOTE FULL HEARING)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
10TH MAY 2024

2021 0810 JR BALLYBODEN TIDY TOWNS GROUP -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(1 DAY REMOTE HEARING)

14th MAY 2024

2022 0686 JR JONES & ORS -V- SOUTH DUBLIN COUNTY COUNCIL & ORS
(3 DAYS REMOTE FULL HEARING)

2022 1061 JR WILSON & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(3 DAYS PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)

TRINITY

29th MAY 2024

2021 1110 JR SAVE ROSCAM PENINSULA CLG & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(3 DAYS REMOTE FULL HEARING)

4th JUNE 2024

2022 0339 JR OCEANSCAPE UNLIMITED COMPANY -V- DUN LAOGHAIRE RATHDOWN COUNTY
COUNCIL
(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)

2022 1101 JR DUFFY -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ANOR

(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)

11th JUNE 2024

2022 0939 JR MOUNT SALUS RESIDENTS OWNERS MANAGMENT COMPANY -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)
18TH JUNE 2024

2022 0922 JR CAIRN HOMES PLC & ORS -V- WICKLOW COUNTY COUNCIL & ORS
(3 DAY REMOTE FULL HEARING)

2022 0659 JR KAMPFF &ANOR -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA

(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)

25th JUNE 2024

2022 0863 JR DUBLIN CITY COUNCIL -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA

(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)
9TH JULY 2024

2022 0350 JR COLBEAM LTD -V- DUN LAOGHAIRE RATHDOWN COUNTY COUNCIL
(3 DAY PHYSICAL FULL HEARING)

30TH JULY 2024

An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024
2022 0672 JR CONDON -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(2 DAYS ONLY FULL PHYSICAL HEARING)

3rd SEPTEMBER 2024

2023 0748 JR GOCE LIMITED -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA

(2/3 DAYS FULL HEARING)

16th SEPTEMBER 2024

2023 1269 JR SHANNON LNG LIMITED -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA

(3 DAY REMOTE HEARING)

2024 0128 JR KENNEDY & ANOR -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(3 DAYS PHYSICAL HEARING)

23TH SEPTEMBER 2024

2023 0383 JR DAA PLC -V- FINGAL COUNTY COUNCIL

2023 1047 JR FRIENDS OF THE IRISH ENVIRONMENT COMPANY LIMITED & ANOR -V- MINISTER
FOR HOUSING & ORS
(6 DAYS FULL REMOTE HEARING)
RESERVED JUDGMENTS

1. 2021 0823 JR SALMON WATCH IRELAND CLG -V- AQUACULTURE LICENCES APPEAL BORD
2. 2021 0828 JR INLAND FISHERIES IRELAND -V- AQUACULTURE LICENCES APPEAL BORD
3. 2021 0831 JR SWEETMAN & ORS -V- AQUACULTURE LICENCES APPEAL BORD
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 11/05/2023 – SECTION 46.4 DATE 07/06/2024)
4. 2022 0148 JR MURPHY & ORS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 26/10/2023 – S46.4 DATE 30/06/2024)
5. 2022 437 JR LEECH -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 23/11/2023 – S46.4 DATE 22/04/2024)
6. 2022 0806 JR EGLINGTON RESIDENTS ASSOCIATION & ANOR -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 18/01/2024 – S46.4 DATE 30/06/2024)
7. 2022 0052 JR PROTECT EAST MEATH -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 01/02/2024 – S46.3 DATE 15/05/2024)
8. 2021 0874 JR CHURCHFIELDS MANAGEMENT COMPANY CLG -V- AN BORD
PLEANÁLA & ORS
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 14/02/2024 – S46.3 DATE 25/04/2024)
9. 2022 0898 JR PALATINE DAC -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA & ORS
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 29/02/2024 – S46.3 DATE 13/05/2024)
10. 2022 4826 P WALSH &ANOR -V- ST CLARES GP3 LTD & ANOR
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 08/04/2024 – S46.3 DATE 18/06/2024)
11. 2022 0458 JR AN TAISCE THE NATIONAL TRUST FOR IRELAND -V- THE
MINISTER FOR HOUSING LOCAL GOVERNMENT AND HERITAGE
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 08/04/2024 – S46.3 DATE 19/06/2024)
12. 2022 1074 JR MORRIS -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA/2022 1107 JR GRAYMOUNT -V-
AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 12/04/2024 – S46.3 DATE 25/06/2024)
13. 2022 1107 JR GRAYMOUNT -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(JUDGMENT RESERVED 12/04/2024 – S46.3 DATE 25/06/2024)
14. 2024 13 JR DOWLING -V- AN BORD PLEANÁLA
(JUDGEMENT RESERVED 15/04/2024 – S46.3 DATE 30/06/2024)
An Dialann Dleathach – Cásanna An Lae Inniu Dé Luain 22ú Aibreán 2024
The Legal Diary – Today’s Cases Monday 22nd April 2024

PROFESSIONAL DISCIPLINARY LIST

MONDAY 22nd APRIL 2024

IN COURT 4 (HYBRID)

AT 14.00 O’CLOCK

PROFESSIONAL DISIPLINARY LIST

1. [Link].2023.0000032 LAW SOCIETY OF IRELAND -V- BROWN

2. [Link].2024.0000166 PSI v GARAHY

3. [Link].2024.0000164 PSI v PQ LTD

4. [Link].2024.0000165 PSI v FG

5. [Link].2024.0000143 MEDICAL COUNCIL v XY

INHERENT JURISDICTION (CAPACITY) LIST

WEEK BEGINNING MONDAY 22nd 2024

BEFORE THE PRESIDENT

COURT TBC

(HYBRID)

Urgent ex parte applications will be heard this week by the President. Practitioners must contact the Registrar
at inherentjurisdictioncapacity@[Link] in order to arrange a listing as per the High Court Practice Direction
(HC 123).

For all matters non ex parte matters practitioners should check the Advanced Warning List of the Judge
retaining seisin of the matter on ‘Today’s Cases/All Cases’ for time and court room information.