Elements of Protection
Elements of Protection
1. It is a state of network in which the current flowing through it is the rated current
provided that the voltage and frequency is constant.
2. The current is not diverted to the other path that is generally towards the earth then
the condition is said to be normal condition.
Abnormal condition
On the other hand when a failure (e.g. short circuit) occurs on any part of power
system, a heavy current flows through the equipment. threatening damage to the
equipment and interruption of service to the customers. However, the switchgear
detects the fault and diseonnects the unhealthy scction from the system. In this way,
switchgear protects the system from the damage and ensures continuity of supply. In
this chapter, we shall present the elementary introduction to switchgear.
In power system abnormalities generally occurs due to internal or external
faults and switching as transient. Usually the transients can be considered as fault
and system gets disturbed by tripping circuit breakers.
Abnormal Condition:
1. It is the defect in the any part of the system which produce abnormalities like over
current, over voltage, disturbance and elements are likely to be damagcd and the
system is disturb.
2. It is the defect in part of the power system due to which the current is diverted from
the desired path with increase in magnitude called fault.
3. Due to abnormalities following are the defects observed:
Voltage and Current unbalanced
Over Voltages
" Reversal Power
Power Swinging
Under Frequeney
Temperature Rise
" Instability of System
Types of faults and causes of faults
Introduction to Electrical Faults
Electrical nctworks, machincs and equipments are often subjccted to various
faults while they are in operation. When a fault occurs, the lypes ol
as impedance) of the machines may change fronm existing characteristic values (such
tillthe fault is cleared. values to different values
There may be lot of probabilities of faults to appear in the
power system network.,
including lighting. wind, tree lalling on lines, apparatus failure, etc.
Electrical Faults
Short-circuit Faults
(c). Phase-to-phase
UB
Consider that a transmission line is working with a balanced load before the occurrence of open
and
circuit fault. If one of the phase gets melted, the actual loading of the alternator is reduced
this cause to raise the acceleration of the alternator, thereby it runs at a speed slightly greater than
synchronous speed. This over speed causes over voltages in other transmission lines.
Thus, single and two phase open conditions can produce the unbalance of the power system
voltages and currents that causes great damage to the equipments.
Causes
Broken conductor and malfunctioning of circuit breaker in one or more phases.
Effects
Abnormal operation of the system
Danger to the personnel as well as animals
Exceeding the voltages beyond normal values in certain parts of the network, which
further leads to insulation failures and developing of short circuit faults.
Causes
These may be due to internal or external effects
Internal effects include breakdown of transmission lines or equipment, aging of
insulation, deterioration of insulation in generator, transformer and other electrical
cquipments, improper installations and inadequate design.
External effects include overloading of equipments, insulation failure due to lighting
surges and mechanical damage by public.
Effects
Arcing faults can lead to fire and explosion in equipments such as transformers and
circuit breakers.
Abnormal currents cause the equipments to get overheated, which further leads to
reduction of life span of their insulation.
The operating voltages of the system can go below or above their acceptance values that
creates harmfuleffect to the service rendered by the power system.
The power flow is severely restricted or even completely blocked as long as the short
circuit fault persists.
3. Symmetricaland Unsymmetrical Faults
As discussed above that faults are mainly classified into open and short circuit
faults and again these can be symnmetrical or unsymmetrical faults.
Symmetrical Faults
A symmetrical fault gives rise to symmetrical fault currents that are displaced with 1200 each
other. Symmetrical fault is also called as balanced fault. This fault occurs when all the three
phases are simultaneously short circuited.
These faults rarely occur in practice as compared with unsymmetrical faults. Two kinds of
symmetrical faults include line to line to line (L-L-L) and line to line to line to ground (L-L-L-G)
as shown in figure below.
R B R B
ZB ZR ZB
ZR
Unsymmetrical Faults
power system network are
The most common faults that occur in the unsymmetrical fault
unsymmetrical faults. This kind of fault gives rise to
phase displacement). These
currents (having different magnitudes with unequal unbalanced currents in the
as it causes
faults are also called as unbalanced faults
system.
faults include both open circuit
Upto the above discussion, unsymmetrical (excluding
faults (single and twophase open condition) and short circuit faults
L-L-L-G and L-L-L).
symmetrical faults occurred due to
The figure below shows the three types of fault, phase to
the short circuit conditions, namely phase or line to ground (L-G)
phase (L-L) fault anddouble line to ground (L-L-G) fault.
Y R B
R B R
ZR Z
ZR ZR Zs
Aline to line fault occur when a live conductor get in contact with other live
conductor. Heavy winds are the major cause for this fault during which
swinging of overhead conductors may touch together. These are less severe
faults and its occurrence range may be between 15-20%.
In double line to ground faults, two lines come into the contact with each
other as well as with ground. These are severe faults and the occurrence these
faults is about 10% when compared with total system faults.
Unsymmetrical faults are analyzed using methods of unsymmetrical
components in order to determine the voltage and currents in all parts of the
system. The analysis of these faults is more difficult compared to symmetrical
faults.
This analysis is necessary for determining the size of a circuit breaker for largest
short circuit current. The greater current usually occurs for either L-G or L-L
fault.
The fault clearing system uses various protection devices such as relays and
circuit breakers to detect and clear the fault.
Some of these fault clearing or faults limiting devices are given below.
1. Fuse
It opens the circuit whenever a fault exists in the system. It consists of a thin
copper wireenclosed in a glass or a casing with two metallic contacts. The high
fault current rises the temperature of the wireand hence it melts. A fuse
necessitates the manual replacement of wire each time when it blows.
2. Cireuit Breaker
the circuit either
It is the most common protection device that can make or break
manually or through remote control under normal operating conditions.
There are several types of circuit breakers available depending on the
operating voltage, including air brake, oil, vacuum andSF6 circuit breakers. For
more information on circuit breakers, follow the link attached.
3. Protective Relays
These are the fault detecting devices. These devices detect the fault and initiate
the operation of the circuit breaker so as to isolate the faulty circuit. A relay
consists of a magnetic coil and contacts (NC and NO). The fault current
energizes the coil and this causes to produce the field, thereby thecontacts get
operated.
Some of the types of protective relays include
Magnitude relays
Impedance relays
Directional relays
Pilot relays
. Differential relays
4. Lighting Arrestor
lightning strikes on
Surges inthe power system network caused when voltage and currents in the
transmission lines and equipments. This causes high
arrestors at
system. These lighting faults are reduced by placing lighting
transmission equipments.
Functions of protective system and elementsof protective system.
Function of protective system:
abnormal conditions and
The function of the protective system is to protect the system from
working of
faults by isolating the faulty element as quickly as possible. This will ensure the
a healthy section of the network
1,
Thus referring to Fig. fault currents I. Iy and Ip willbe cqual in magnitude with 120o
displacement among them. Because of balanced nature of fault, only one* phase
need be considered in calculations since condition in the other twvo phases willalso be similar.
The following points may be particularly noted:
) Thesymmetrical fault rarely occurs in practice as majority of the faults are of
unsymmetrical nature. However, symmetrical fault calculations are being discussed in this
chapter to enable the reader to understand the problems that short circuit conditions present
to the power system.
(1) The symmetrical fault is the most severe and imposes more heavy duty on the circuit
breaker.
Limitation of Fault Current
Whe a :hot creut occu: at any pont i : teu:.
TrenstoIMer
the chort-cucut cu:e:t i: l:tedby the inpecznse vwww
of the syte: upto tie pout of faul:. Thuseiernto
Fig. 17.2. if : fauit ocew: oL the feeder at pot . w
short-cicuit cuent:.
In wn 2u31Is. çe iepedance: I:uuz the taul: curent s1e lagelv rezcthve. such :ans
tomer:. 1eactor: and zeiarators. Cle: andlne:E0:tiv reiiwe, but wvhee the totalrezctance
in calcuaio:e:ceed: 3 me: the:e:l:tance. the ate1 1: u:uallv nagla:ted. The erTor oducadby
this asunpion will not exceed .
Percentage Reactance
The reactance of geze:ator:. hans forne:. reactor ats. 1: u:1zlly ex:eed i: percaninge T20ctahCe
to perm:t rapid chort cucutcaleulatious. The pe:centzze Te3tznce ofa creuit 1sdefnad 3s undar
: is the gercestage afthe toxal yiase-"oitage äpped in the cincuitwhen fuli-ioad current i:
flowing i.e.
where I = il-louTent
J = phaseolte
1 =1e1ctance u: olum: p phase
Alternat:ely. percItage eactnce ( . ) ca 3:o be exresed in te:ni:* oVA nd kV a:
under :
....u)
where Iis he reactazce in ohn:.
IfIis the only ieactance element in the cucuit. then short-cucut curent i: giv en by:
=
Iig. 17.3
g ofti vteui : chowL n Fiz. 17.3 Supoze : thoit-ciut fait berween tua zha:e: occur:
( j x10
100 10077 A
I=
= 3-20 =4 :
Full-Laadcnen: co:1e:30udins to 3000VA t 661:Vi:
30001000
=4374A
3x 66 x1000
109
Short-crit eunert. I = I x =43 74 x =972A
From the zbovellustranon. iti: clea1 that whatever n:y be thralue of base kVA. hot-cucut
cunent 1s the s3me Howeer. u: the tesetof : unpli::ry. :umeicaly conrerientaluefor the baze
LAshould be chozen.
Short-Circuit kVA
Aittough the potennal at tie poirt of fzult ezers. iti: &ro:uaal p1act:ce to expre:s the cho:t-cieat
curent in teu:: of sho1t-cucuit kVA based o the nora. syten) tcltage at dhe point of sul:.
A: proed in £: 17.3.
Shot-iuit uTent.
Short-'LrurkA fo: phase cucu:
=
1000
l000
= Base1:"A x
base LA
ttedA xo TEactAucE at rateiVA
Ful-load cumeut L3s o be found our to he baseA selected.
Use of current limiting reactors, types and their
arrangemnents
The main motive of using current limiting
that cireuit breakers with lower shortcircuit reactors to reduce short-circuit currents s0
is
be usedto protect other system components frombreaking capacity can be used. They can also
high current levels and to limit the inrush
current when starting a large motor.
Reactor Control of Short-Circuit Currents
Witthe fa:tep3ncie pcwe: v:e. the fait
al:o 1:u The crut bieaker: lera!(1 e the powe: ayaiable to flow into : fl: 1:
conected : the owe
MINWp.e hot-1eut curet: c 00cw at their pc)int: be capibl of dezl1nz it:
1e3tan ofhe ocouiechon Gne1z!y. the
sVendaf::0zd1noL:1:low
value. It otep: e taAei to.u3it tme
1ee of cruut beaker: be exce:irel zue c: thee
3ndi:cuteit: u3v1 to a cingeou:.y
h-cuc! uTents.
hugh
not onlv w!l the aur
hea bu::ko camage 13 iLes
dother equipment !
In ordar to lmit the
chot-crut uieit: to waua wu:h ha ciucuit breakers 3:
handle. adi
1ecter:: coLl of rnbe o run:
deigneto :Te a L31ductance a conpared to it: ou:
3Ld, he:e fore. the
of rector.there wndng: mu:te:olidl bace I e ided that due to
ivey ictle chzng: the eifician citie weruall1uce
tem.
i} Iroubla: ara
ther c:suL localiedor:lated a: e
efit: to cther pat: ogoL:wnete the oI1gi113te
the poVr Ttm1. without comnE
i
TEev pemr the
coLinuouppl Ihi: ine:ea:: tha cin:e 3:
in:llauor cc:reher: of lcwer:uz
17.7 Location of
Reactors
WIL e3ch eede: aL n bu:-b1:. No def:
loca tions is preferable: each
particulT demand: which ust ntallatioz 3: it: cn Hoaor.
be cefuly con::d
eredbefore a chcice ceiec to: losaion can be u2ce.
(
-auerato: 1etier:, hn the
21e
cormectedin ene: witn ecgenezItO1. 1eactor:
the 3re
case. tte Iector may be
age rezctATCe of the
co1dered a: ap:t ofleak
gaLeTato1:2ence it: te:1: to
lig 17.4
potec: tne generato: : the caLe of zny cho:t-cueut beyond the xezcto13.
Discdveutages
) The:e atouta2t toltage d op aud pcwer lo:: n te 1e3ctors even dwng normz)
opeauon
(o) Ia bt:-b8: o fee de: fauit octus cicze to the bus-ba, tise voltage zt the bus-bar wul be
re duced te alow valne. thereby cau:ng the zenerator: to fallout of stey
(R) I: fault occu: on any eder. the coztiu:r of supply to other i: l.ely to be affectei.
L'ue to the:e disadvntage: and al:o ince ocern power statio ganerators have suificiently
larze leakage teactance to protect theum agant cltort-cireut. it is not a common rZcice to u:a 2epi
1ate leactors for tthe gene:ato:.
t2) Draw a:ingle lne dig10 of the coplete neriost: andicaring the ratng. voltage and per
CentIge 192cta:e of ec elemen: of the rewoz:.
(:) Ckocse nrencally conTeLiert a.1 cekVA 3nd ccne:tll percentage 1eactance:
to thi b5# value.
(122) Ccve:poning ts the inie l1ne disq1zun of t:e natxol. azw the resc tance dia g:::how
tne 1ezct31: di: ZI3D). The tran:forcer in tie #:teun houl be ereeutec b a re3ctace
is) FLdthe tota! reactiC oi the netyorl. upto he pont ofauit. Le::be.o
(*) Fui te full-lo2d cuze: coTe:poniang to the electec bxe VA 2d tne norDia. y2
roltage 3t the fault pout. Let it be !.
C,B,
Cver-curent relay
1,0 scccndtime scl:rg
A
Line bus
Over-cunent
clays C,6 srcond
time setirg
(i) Back-up protection. It is the second line of defence in case of failure of the primary protection. It is
designed to operate with sufficient time delay so that primary relaying will be given enough time to function if
it is able to. Thus referring to Fig. relay Aprovides back-up protection for each of the four lines. If a line fault is
not clearedby its relay and breaker, the relay Aon the group breaker will operate after adefinite time delay and
clear the entire group of lines. It is evident that when back-up relaying functions, a larger part is disconnected
than when primaryrelaying functions correctly. Therefore, greater emphasis should be placed on the better
maintenance of primary relaying
Methods of Back-up Protection
1. Relay Back-up.
2. Breaker Back-up.
3. Remote back-up.
4. Centrally Coordinated Back-up.
I. kelay Backup Protection: In this scheme, asingle breaker is Used by both primary as well as backup
protection but the two protective systems are dillerent.
. Breaker BackupProtection: In this method, separate breakers are providedfor primary and backup
protection. Both the types of brcakers are at the same station.
provided for primary and backup
3. Remote Backup Protection: Inthis method. separate brcakers are completely isolated and
protection. The twotypes of breakers are at the different stationsand are
independent of cach other.
4. Centrally Co-ordinated Backup Protection: In this method. primary protection is at various stations.
backup protection for all| the stations is at central control room. Central
There is a central control room and
control continuously inspects the load flow and frequency in the system. If any elements of any part of the
system load flow gets affected which is sensed by the control room. The control source consists of adigital
computer which decides the proper switching action. The method is also called centrally controlled backup
protection.