Understanding Scope 3 Emissions Guide
Understanding Scope 3 Emissions Guide
guide to Scope 3
emissions
Contents
SECTION 1
What is Scope 3? 3
SECTION 2
SECTION 3
Measuring Scope 3 9
SECTION 4
Considerations: businesses 10
SECTION 5
SECTION 6
What is Scope 3?
Scope 3 is a term defined by the Greenhouse Gas Protocol
(GHG Protocol). The GHG Protocol provides the world’s most
widely used greenhouse gas (GHG) accounting standards, which
organisations and governments use to understand, quantify and
manage their GHG emissions. Created to bring consistency, the
GHG Protocol categorises emissions into three ‘Scopes’:
• Scope 1: Direct emissions from activities within your organisation’s control. This
includes onsite fuel combustion from buildings and company vehicles as well as
manufacturing and process emissions and direct emissions from agriculture.
• Scope 2: Indirect emissions from any electricity, heat or steam you purchase and use.
By using the energy, you are indirectly responsible for the release of GHG emissions.
• Scope 3: Any other indirect emissions from sources outside your direct control. The
GHG Protocol’s Scope 3 Standard categorises emissions across 15 different categories
covering business activities common to many organisations, such as purchased goods
and services, business travel and waste in operations. It also encompasses activities
like leased assets, transport and distribution, the use and disposal of sold products and
the impact of any investments.
Why Scope 3
emissions matter
Scope 3 almost always represents the largest proportion
of emissions. Across the private and public sectors, these
emissions are typically responsible for 70-90% of an
organisation’s carbon footprint. It makes accelerating
action on reducing Scope 3 emissions all the more
important if we want to keep 1.5C alive.
Many businesses are optimising their operations The regulatory lens is on carbon reporting
to reduce emissions. Yet, they cannot meet their
The regulatory landscape is also witnessing a global shift as
climate goals if they ignore the impact of their full
countries across the world are beginning to mandate the disclosure
value chain. of emission data for larger businesses:
Since Scope 3 emissions can make up the • Task Force for Climate-related Financial Disclosures (TCFD
majority of an organisation’s carbon footprint, The TCFD framework requires businesses to disclose their
the Science Based Targets initiative (SBTi) has climate-related risks and opportunities. While not mandatory,
made quantifying and setting Scope 3 targets TCFD encourages businesses to disclose Scope 3 emissions.
TCFD-aligned reporting is already compulsory across the UK, with
a requirement of their validation process. Any
more countries and regions expected to follow, including the EU,
business whose Scope 3 emissions represent Colombia and the US.
more than 40% of the total footprint must now upstream and downstream activities.
• Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (CSRD)
report on its Scope 3 reduction efforts.1 • International Sustainability Standards Board (ISSB)
The EU has announced it will bring sustainability reporting in line
with financial reporting. The new CSRD framework will be rolled In June 2023, the ISSB issued its inaugural IFRS Sustainability
out in a phased approach from 2024 and requires businesses Disclosure Standards – IFRS S1 ‘General Requirements for
to be more detailed in their sustainability reporting. For Disclosure of Sustainability-related Financial Information’ and
environmental reporting, EU businesses should have footprinted IFRS S2 ‘Climate-related Disclosures’. The Standards create a
their whole value chain (Scope 1, 2 and 3) and have set (science- common language for disclosing the impact of climate-related
based) targets. risks and opportunities on a company in the short, medium and
• Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) long term.³
The climate crisis is global, but its impact will The benefits of measuring and tackling Scope 3
be felt locally. It is a tremendous driver for public emissions
bodies, cities and regions to invest in climate
Scope 3 emissions are everyone’s responsibility and require a
action, and reduce carbon emissions. collaborative approach. By measuring and communicating your
Scope 3 emissions, you can hold yourself, your employees and
By their very nature, public bodies offer services to support your supply chain to account. Through a Scope 3 assessment,
people and communities in living happier, healthier lives. you can:
Pollution, fuel poverty, and excessive waste linked to climate
• Obtain a clear picture of how Scope 3 emissions contribute to
change can be centrally tackled through local government
your overall footprint.
action and policy, education, and public health services.
For many, climate action is intertwined with the public • Prioritise decarbonisation efforts where they can make the
sector’s core purpose and has spurred a movement of climate biggest difference.
emergency declarations and Net Zero commitments. • Collaborate closely with suppliers, encouraging them to act on
their emissions. This will lead to a butterfly effect that prompts
In addition, many public bodies are setting carbon reduction businesses to become more sustainable.
targets earlier than national Net Zero targets. In doing so,
they have directly or indirectly committed to reducing • Demonstrate commitments to creating healthier communities.
emissions beyond Scope 1 and 2. • Engage with employees to reduce emissions from business
travel, employee commuting, waste and water.
• Communicate a comprehensive footprint and progress with
stakeholders, such as constituents.
• Support national endeavours towards Net Zero.
7. Plan for emissions reductions If you would like to find out more about calculating and
(recommended) communicating an organisational or product footprint,
please refer to the Carbon Trust’s introductory guide to
8. Improve the accuracy of your Scope carbon footprinting for businesses.
3 footprint on a continuous basis and
rebaseline where appropriate
Considerations: businesses
The quality of Scope 3 emissions calculations 1. Identify your business needs 2. Start with the data at your disposal
needs to be good enough to identify where
Identify your business objectives and the value you seek Accept that the accuracy of Scope 3 reporting will not be
to prioritise your decarbonisation efforts and to generate from measuring and interpreting your value perfect first time, and instead, will improve as more specific
implement decisions. chain footprint. While initially it may be to meet regulatory data becomes available.
reporting requirements, you can use the data to drive
Yet, with 15 different categories to report on, conducting innovation, strengthen supplier conversations, or set science- Begin by calculating your Scope 3 footprint with your best
a Scope 3 footprint can seem daunting and resource based targets. To stay on track, organisations must always available data at hand, so you can understand where your
intensive. By their very nature, these emissions are indirect, revert their focus back to the business value that a Scope 3 biggest emission hotspots lie. Many businesses start by using a
so organisations will feel discouraged that they may not footprint and reduction plan can generate. spend-based approach to calculate their upstream emissions.
have immediate access to activity data. To make the most The use of spend-based data offers a very wide, but shallow
of the resources at hand, it is important to consider the lens on your emissions that focuses on the ‘purchased goods
following points. and services’. Often, the procurement data for the entire year
is used, taking the 'amount bought' multiplied by the most
applicable emission factors. This approach can be limiting
as it captures secondary data, which lacks the detail to base
business decisions on. Since these emissions factors are not
specific to products or suppliers, they do not allow for year-on-
year comparisons. While this data collection should not be used
in the long term, it is often easier and cheaper to obtain, making
it a good starting point.
It will also help bring the best returns as you address your Home appliances
carbon footprint.
4. Make data collection a company-wide exercise 5. Engage with suppliers and other value chain partners 6. Delve into your data and model solutions
It is crucial that cross functional experts from your business Scope 3 data can inform decision making, but only if the Product design and procurement decisions influence your
are involved in collecting and analysing this data, so they can footprint’s most material aspects are specific and granular footprint. After collecting your Scope 3 data, it is important to
understand how their decisions impact the total value chain, not enough to make strategic decisions. Once you identified the interpret your data and analyse which products have the biggest
just their operations. Treating your footprinting with the same big emitters across your value chain, engage with them. potential to help reduce emissions across your supply chain as
level of importance and scrutiny as financial reporting can well as during logistics, product use and end of life phases.
lead to successful outcomes. Here, setting key performance Encouraging suppliers to calculate their specific footprint is
indicators (KPIs) related to the accuracy and reduction of crucial for anyone working with a large number of suppliers, Product design and procurement teams need to consider the
Scope 3 emissions can be highly beneficial. such as an electronic goods manufacturer. This way you can impacts of the products they buy or create across their lifecycle.
compare the emissions intensity of your supply chain each year This means taking into account factors such as recyclability,
and ultimately reduce uncertainty in your footprint by improving energy efficiency, and the use of alternative materials even
the quality of data. Once you have identified the big emitters before the products are made, all the way through to their end
across your supply chain, engage with them. Doing so will build of life phase.
confidence in your emission data, ensuring it is ‘good enough’
to inform decision making.
Over time you will begin to replace secondary emission data Not all categories identified by the GHG Protocol Scope 3
with primary data from your suppliers. When this happens, Standard will apply to your business or sector. For example,
it is important to recalculate your own baseline to ensure emissions of' use of sold products' (Category 11) may be
your measured progress is accurate and not a result of significant to an electronic devices manufacturer but irrelevant
comparing different data sets. Upon receiving primary data to a furniture manufacturer.
from suppliers, ask for their historical data too, so you can
recalculate your baseline. In such cases, it may not be necessary to quantify categories
that do not apply. However, transparency is crucial in order
to conduct a credible Scope 3 assessment. In your reporting,
disclose any excluded Scope 3 categories and provide reasons
Re-stated 2019 and assumptions for their exclusion. By doing so, you can
baseline**
justify the boundaries you have set.
(supplier data)
100
Unadjusted
Scope 3 emissions
80 (false)
Adjusted (true) reductions
60 reductions
40
20
3. Start with the data at your disposal: a proxy footprint 4. Identify hotspot suppliers, services and products
As with all emissions categories, different methods can be Making essential progress The aim of the spend-based footprint exercise should be to
applied to arrive at emissions estimates. Criteria such as allocate emissions per supplier. In many instances, the 80/20
Initial Scope 3
the relative size of emissions will often guide your choice of Initial Scope 3 footprint after rule will apply, with only a handful of suppliers responsible for
calculation method; but are often limited by data availability. footprint calculations supplier engagement a large portion of supply chain emissions.
Accept that data collection is a continuous cycle. As a first his shortlist of suppliers gives you the basis for your initial
T
step, most public bodies will follow a spend-based method to supplier engagement efforts. Other considerations include
calculate emissions across their supply chain. This involves contract length, type and broader strategic benefits of
confidence range
kg product / kg CO2e
multiplying the amount of goods or services bought by the collaborating with key suppliers. This information should be
Range of
most relevant emission factors. emission factor Higher available from procurement staff and account managers.
certainty
It's more common for distance estimates to be used for Here, it's useful to look into suppliers' publicly reported
business travel and employee commuting, matched with the sustainability credentials. Some suppliers may already report
relevant emission factors. In the absence of this, spend-based on their organisational or product carbon footprints, making it
data can serve as a useful proxy. Time easier for you to obtain the data you need and saving you time
Secondary More Engage in the process.
emission information suppliers
The proxy-based footprint identify emission hotspots and factors on suppliers to collect
high-emitting activities for further investigation. It is a helpful primary data
first step to focus your efforts on areas where you can make 5. Engage with suppliers
the greatest impact.
he Carbon Trust recommends engaging with key suppliers on a
T
A spend-based footprint has its limitations however, and one-on-one basis, collecting data through questionnaires or software
shouldn’t solely be relied on for ongoing reporting, due to its portals. Even if suppliers cannot provide sufficient emissions
non-specific nature. Scope 3 footprints will often start with a data, information on their general readiness, carbon reduction
lot of secondary data but will be improved as you acquire more targets, and mitigation projects can still provide valuable insights.
accurate primary supplier-specific data. As time passes, the
data collected directly from suppliers should eventually replace Over time, as regulations on carbon reporting come into action,
those initial estimates. your suppliers will increasingly be required to report on their
emissions. As this happens, suppliers will welcome centralised
systems to avoid providing multiple clients with the same
information again and again.
6. Add environmental credentials in tenders and steer 7. Update your carbon baseline 8. Communicating your Scope 3 emissions
procurement decisions
Carbon footprinting is a continuous process. With this in mind, Currently, there is limited mandate for public bodies to report
Factor in suppliers’ carbon transparency and climate your carbon measurements will change as you begin to replace on their indirect emissions. However, as public bodies have a
commitments into your procurement decisions and explore secondary emission data with primary data from your suppliers. responsibility to act transparently and educate the public on
if sustainable alternatives fit within your budget. When this happens, remember to recalculate your baseline to their Net Zero carbon reduction strategies, it is important to
ensure your measured progress is accurate and up to date. cover all emission sources, including Scope 3.
In line with this, consider including environmental metrics as a
requirement of outgoing tenders. When writing tenders, check When you receive primary data from suppliers, collect their By reporting your complete carbon footprint on an annual basis
how these credentials align with your Scope 3 reduction efforts. historical data where possible. This will help you recalculate and communicating progress, you can lead by example and
Have suppliers set science-based targets? Have they measured your emissions baseline effectively, which will become more build confidence in local climate action, ultimately serving the
their organisational or product footprint? accurate each time. public's interest.
Scope 3 emissions
and schools – you can create pressure and inspire climate 80 (false)
reductions
action by explicitly specifying what you seek from suppliers in Adjusted (true)
their sustainability efforts. It is one of the most valuable levers 60 reductions
at your disposal.
40
20
If you would like to find out more on how we can help your organisation, please get in touch with our client
support team at [Link]@[Link].