TRIBOLOGY FALL 2023
LECTURE 3
LUBRICATION PART
Semi-Solid Lubricants
(GREASE)
1
GREASE COMPOSITION
Base Oil Additives Thickener
Lubricating OIL
2
GREASE COMPOSITION
Base Oil
75 - 95%
Performance Additives
0 - 5%
Thickener
5-20%
3
Grease internal Structure
4
Grease internal Structure
OIL BLEEDING
The oil contained in the lubricating
grease separates from the thickener.
This can be caused by low resistance
to working or low temperature
stability of grease.
5
GREASE CLASSIFICATIONS
based on based on
Thickeners Additives
• Metallic SOAP Thickeners • EP Greases
• Non-Metallic SOAP Thickeners • Graphite Greases
• Moly Greases
6
Metallic SOAP Thickeners
SIMPLE COMPLEX
Metallic Soap Metallic Soap
Example :
Li grease
7
Metallic SOAP Thickeners
SIMPLE COMPLEX
Metallic Soap Metallic Soap
Common
• CALCIUM (Ca)
types
• SODIUM (Na)
• LITHIUM (Li)
8
comparison between different thickeners properties
Dropping point: maximum temperature at which grease can be
utilized after this temperature bleeding will be very high.
9
Non- SOAP Thickeners
Examples
• Silica gel, Alumina
• Clay
• Polyureas
• PTFE
• Dropping point reaches 250 or more
• expensive
10
Note
11
Note: most greases are named by their alkali component
12
13
14
Applications Suitable for Grease
Grease and oil are not interchangeable. Grease is
used when it is not practical or convenient to use
oil. The lubricant choice for a specific application
is determined by matching the machinery design
and operating conditions with desired lubricant
characteristics.
15
Grease is generally used for (Advantages of Grease)
1. Machinery that runs intermittently or is in storage for an extended period of
time.
2. Inclined/vertical shafts.
3. Sufficiently tight enclosures for retaining liquid lubricant does not exist.
4. Continuous supply of lubricant is impractical.
5. Machinery that is not easily accessible for frequent lubrication.
6. Machinery operating under extreme conditions such as high temperatures
and pressures.
7. To prolong the life of worn parts.
8. To provide better mechanical lubrication cushion reducing noise and
vibration.
16
Disadvantages of Grease
• Low fluidity and low conductivity (poor dissipation)
• Once dust or dirt enters the grease no filtration can
be done. Therefore, contaminants and wear debris
cannot be separated.
• High coefficient of friction.
17
18
The most important property of grease is the
consistency which describes the resistance
of grease to deformation by an applied force.
The National Lubricating Grease Institute (NLGI)
divides lubricating greases into classification
groups based on their consistency
19
National Lubricating Grease Institute
NLGI Numbers
NLGI 2 NLGI 1 NLGI 000
NLGI 6
NLGI 5
NLGI 4
NLGI 3
NLGI 2
NLGI 1
NLGI 0
NLGI 00
NLGI 000
20
NLGI grease classification
21
Typical Grease Tests
Test ASTM Test Description
Method
Cone Penetration D-217 Depth a “cone” pushes into grease
Dropping Point D-2265 Temperature where grease melts
Apparent Viscosity D-1092 “Thickness” of grease
4 Ball Wear D-2266 Apply load until balls weld
Evaporation D-972 Weight loss from grease
Copper Corrosion D-4048 Chemical reactivity with metal
Water Washout D-1264 Removal of grease by water
Rust Resistance D-1743 Protection of iron & steels
Oxidation
22
Stability D-942 Storage stability
Penetrometer
23
Penetrometer
24
CONE PENETRATION TEST PROCEDURE
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=97LckifYjIA&t=94s
25
Grease Versus Oil
26
In Favor of Grease
1. Grease: I have superior stop-start
performance. (When a machine is shut down, oil
will drain back to sump but grease remains in the
component where it is needed, lowering the risk
of a dry start).
Oil’s Counterpoint. Most bath, splash and
circulating oil systems can lubricate almost
immediately on restart. Larger volumes of oil
(compared to grease in the same application)
means a larger supply of additives which
extended service life) and the ability to wash
contaminants away from the working frictional
27
zones.
2. Worn seals can retain grease better than oil, which
lowers the risk of lubricant starvation and leakage.
Oil’s Counterpoint. True, grease is less prone to
leakage, but then again leakage is a sign of a
machine problem that needs repair. Worn seals that
go unnoticed don’t get better over time. This
presents risk of a more serious or even catastrophic
failure in the future.
28
3. Surplus grease packed tightly around seals and
serves as a sealant, preventing the ingress of
particles and water. Periodic re-greasing can purge
contaminants out and away from the working
surfaces of the component.
Oil’s Counterpoint. Most industrial machines are
not re-greased frequently enough to rely on this
for displacing contaminants from seals and
cavities adjacent to bearings. In fact, the practice
of re-greasing may actually drive these
contaminants directly into the core of the bearing
and cause failure.
29
4. Grease enables the use of solid additives such
as graphite, zinc oxide or molybdenum disulfide.
These additives would settle or become filtered if
used in many oils.
Oil’s Counterpoint. Soluble additives that are
used in oil formulations today, will provide
comparable performance to control both adhesive
wear and abrasion in similar applications.
30
In Favor of Oil
5. Unlike grease, oil flows freely, enabling it to
conduct and carry away unwanted heat (thermal
convection). This keeps base oil viscosity stable
and reduces the risk of heat-induced oxidation and
additive depletion.
Grease’s Counterpoint. When properly selected
for a given application, the temperature of grease
will remain reasonably low and out of risk of
premature oxidation. Many lubed-for-life grease
applications have exceeded ten years of service.
31
6. Because oil doesn’t use thickeners there is no risk
of incompatible thickeners clashing, causing
changes in grease consistency and other problems.
Grease’s Counterpoint. True, oils don’t employ
thickeners in their formulation but there still
remains the risk of base oil and additive
incompatibility upon mixing. In fact, one could
argue that there is no greater security when two oils
are mixed compared to mixing two grease products.
And unlike some oils, grease additives will not
settle out during storage or when machines are at
rest.
32
7. Oil lubricants enable certain contaminants such
as water and dirt to be briefly suspended and
transported to filters, separators and settling zones.
Grease suspends these types of contaminants
permanently. In fact, some grease products will
suspend 100 percent of their weight in water.
Grease’s Counterpoint. Unlike grease, circulating
oil carries harmful contaminants to the far reaches
of a system, risking wear and corrosion to many
surfaces at the same time. Grease keeps most
contaminants localized and immobilized and even
displaced away from critical surfaces.
33
8. Oil volume in machine components can be
precisely controlled using level gauges and
sight glasses. Grease volume is nearly
impossible to monitor and control. Over- and
under- greasing are common causes of bearing
failures.
Grease’s Counterpoint. Well-trained lube
technicians using proper tools and procedures
have no problem introducing safe quantities of
grease into bearings and similar components.
34
9.Oil can be changed without dismantling
machine hardware. Grease must be repacked
periodically, which involves a considerable cost
associated with labor, material and downtime.
Grease’s Counterpoint. Many grease-lubed
machines can run for years without the need to
repack the bearings. Oil compartments,
however, sometimes require constant drains and
refills.
35
10. Oil-lubricated machines are easier to
sample for laboratory analysis of wear metals,
contaminants and fluid properties. A
representative sample of an in-service grease is
nearly impossible to obtain.
Grease’s Counterpoint. Perhaps 90 percent of
bearings and components lubricated with grease
are noncritical and don’t require routine
sampling and analysis. However, new methods
are being developed to enable grease sampling
on the run.
36
11. Used oils can be safely handled and disposed
of with minimal impact to the environment. Most
grease-lubricated machines are total-loss
systems, meaning there is no environmentally
simple way to recover and dispose of degraded or
contaminated products.
Grease’s Counterpoint. Oil is actually more
environmentally problematic than grease. As
stated above, it more readily leaks out of
machines and contaminates water, soil, plant life,
etc.
37
Notes on using
Greases in Rolling
Element Bearings
38
Kinds of Lubricants
for Rolling Contact Bearings
90% by greases
9,5% by oils 0,5% by solid lubricants only
39
Reasons for bearing failure
Other reasons
21%
Improper
mounting
27%
Improper
lubrication Material
43% fatigue
9%
40
Improper lubrication
Over
lubrication
60%
Lack of
lubrication
40%
41
Lubrication Symbols
A-Grease Symbols
B-Oil Symbols
C-Hourly Intervals
42
Grease Quantity for
Rolling Contact Bearings
43
Relubrication Intervals for
Grease lubricated
Rolling Contact Bearings
44
Relubrication Intervals
Lubrication interval, tfc
given by service hours 10 000
tfb 6 000
20 000 4 000
tfa 15 000 3 000
20 000 10 000 2 000
15 000 7 500 1 500
10 000 5 000 1 000
5 000 2 500 500
d=10
3 000 1 500 300
20
2 000 1 000 200
1 500 750 150
1 000 500 100
40
500 250 50
500 420 360 280 240 200 160 120 100 80 60
100 200 500 1 000 2 000 5 000 10 000
45 n [r/min]
tfa = Deep groove ball bearings.
tfb = Cylindrical roller bearings.
Needle bearings.
tfc = Self aligning roller bearings.
taper rolling bearings.
46
Example
A deep-groove ball bearing with an internal
diameter d = 100mm running at a speed of n =
1000 rpm.
What is the expected relubrication interval?
47
Relubrication Intervals
Lubrication interval, tfc
given by service hours 10 000
tfb 6 000
20 000 4 000
tfa 15 000 3 000
20 000 10 000 2 000
15 000 7 500 1 500
10 000 5 000 1 000
5 000 2 500 500
d=10
3 000 1 500 300
20
2 000 1 000 200
1 500 750 150
1 000 500 100
40
500 250 50
500 420 360 280 240 200 160 120 100 80 60
100 200 500 1 000 2 000 5 000 10 000
48 n [r/min]
Example
A deep-groove ball bearing with an internal
diameter d = 100mm running at a speed of n =
1000 rpm.
What is the expected relubrication interval?
Solution:
The vertical in point n = 1000 rpm on the
abscissa cuts the curve for d = 100mm. From
there the horizontal leads to the outer left-hand
scale (deep- groove ball bearings) indicating a
relubrication interval of 10000 service hours
49
Relubrication Intervals (another method)
50
Effective Means Of Lubrication
V.I
Greases Relubrication Intervals
t’=t*a
t’: grease interval time corrected for temperature
t: grease interval time for size & speed only
a: temperature correction factor.
REFERENCES:
• Lectures of Dr. Mohamed El-Komy
• “Fundamentals of fluid film lubrication”, by Hamrock
• “What is a grease thickener and what does it do?”, video lecture on lubrication
@LubricationExplained
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=coYSe0AT3cs&t=279s
• “solid and semi-solid lubricants”, video lectures on tribology by Harish Hirani,
national program on technology enhanced leaning (nptel)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4p6IR47WUY4&list=PLbMVogVj5nJRCfyN1QEiBs
NFek8d00kWw&index=16
52
