0 ratings 0% found this document useful (0 votes) 541 views 34 pages Railway Modeller - Issue 011 - July-August 1951
Railway Modeller is a monthly British magazine about model railways now published by Peco Publications in Beer, Devon. It has been in publication since 1949 with Vol. 1 No. 1 published as The Railway Modeller, being an Ian Allan Production for October–November, 1949.
Copyright
© © All Rights Reserved
We take content rights seriously. If you suspect this is your content,
claim it here .
Available Formats
Download as PDF or read online on Scribd
Go to previous items Go to next items
Save Railway Modeller - Issue 011 - July-August 1951 For Later
SMALL ADVERTISEMENTS
‘Announcements can be accepted up to the Ist of the
‘month for the following month's issue. The Chorges ore
22 ber ror, private (minum dharee 3); and
ber word, trade (minimum charge 5]-). Cash with order.
No Box Advertisements con be accepted.
MODEL RAILROADER, America’s leading monthly
‘One year's supply, 32/3: specimen, 3/~
magazine catalogue free. Hobson, 79,
Southbrook Read, Exeter.
Have you booked a regular order for RAILWAY.
MODELLER with your local bookstall or bookseller?
The lord Junior Railway Club, a small_ group of
railway enthusiasts, has vacancies fora few more
members. A Prize-Winning Model. Railway 15 on
Bermaneng toan co che Club, together with x wel.
Lads between 134 and 18 years old
are cordially inviced co communicate with J.K. Nelson,
36, South Park Drive, Iord.
READY SOON.—The " Track-Taylor "for tailor-
made track. 6d. P.O, brings details of the patented
Brecision tool for making ©-O soldered tracks Brian
Taylor. 36. Pullman Street, Rochdale, Lancs}
Complete range of Meccano Sets Nos. 0 to 9, prices
from 7)9. Buy while stocks last. George Bradshaw,
5:6, Western Road, Hove, Sussex.
ANORMA Kies still at pre-tax price. From A.L to
36. Good stocks available.» George Bradshaw, 5-6,
Western Road, Hove, Sussex.
Now and unused Hornby Dublo. clockwork track.
Seraighe and curved at 2/- each, Trackmaster clock:
work locos, 29/3. Trackmaster_wagons, open 2/11,
vans 3/6. ‘George Bradshaw, 5-6, Western Road,
Hove, Sussex.
New Trix Equipment now available. Passenger
Sets, £7146, Goods Sets, £6 16 6 Track formations
915, 995, 935, 945. Transformers, 50/-. Crane truck
30012419, Crane on base, 14/4, land platform, 23/6
Personnel, 2/9. Passenger Merchandise, 3/3.
Bogie Wazons, 93." Costes Bradshaw, 22, Western
Road, Hove, Susse>
Graham Farish trackstillavailable. 2-ral steel 3/4b,
a-rall brass 7/4, Srail steel 5/6 per yard. George
Bradshaw, 5-6, Westarn Road, Hove, Sussex.
WHEN BUYING 2 railway book
‘the name lan Allan, you can't do betcer
MODEL MAKER required by leading Manufaceurert
sparing in he OO ruse, “Huse be capable cf
Siting fratlass ‘Railway’ Models Including rack
work'and finishing, paining,leteering, ete, 20 the
‘a coduee show cards
int be prepared to
ingle man preferred,
Wriee inthe: frse“inatance, giving fall Seti “of
Sxpevience, age selary required ete to Dept AWE
358, Vauxhall Bridge Road, SWS
0 GAUGE ELECTRIC LAYOUT, Four Tracks and
Sidings, on S{e. 6in, x IL fe- Oin. Folding. Table, with
detachable legs. | Control Panel, numerous astorted
Buildings and Stations. £18 or offer, Hartley, 17,
Elm Park Road, Finchiey, N.3.
AMERICA’S famous ‘Model Railroader,” the most
authoritative magazine available, -32/- per annum,
Back numbers, 3- each, Free booklet listing Model
Railroader's books and other American magazines
from Willen Led. (Depe.33),I01, Fleet Screet, London,
ECA.
"Tel. FIN. 1919: -
ATTENBOROUGH MODEL RAILWAY
82, Arkwright Street, NOTTINGHAM
64, Narborough Road, LEICESTER,
Why not send 4d. for a copy of our
“AMR. CHRONICLE”?
which has temporary price list for Gauges
© and OO under the prevailing conditions.
For those interested in railways,
we stock geod range of books,
Apply for our “AMR, LIBRARY NEWS"—
Complete list. 6d. post free.
“OO” GAUGE ¥
EQUIPMENT — NESS &
SEND US A POSTCARD
WITH YOUR NAME AND
ADDRESS AND GET ON
OUR MAILING LIST
WHEN YOU WRITE
WE REPLY
| IMMEDIATELY !
GEORGE BRADSHAW
5 & 6 WESTERN ROAD
HOVE - SUSSEX
SCALE RAILWAY MODELS
Railways _Locos,, 9/6,
fer. Tanks, 70/3. “OO”
0-62 Tanks 48) both sulable Hornby of Graham
Farish. "OO" Plastic “Loco Crews, I/é. Scale
Bushes, 4fd. | Scale Hedges, 1/3. Postcards (Loco
and Triin): Coopers LMR: listard, Ta? G.W.Rey
UNE and SiR. list and card, 74, Special Loco
Train Postcards, usually 6/- dozen, per ¢ dozen, 1/9.
OO" oF “O” Lists, 3d. each.
TYLDESLEY & HOLBROOK
META,
109 Deansgate, Manchester, 3
PLEASE MENTION RAILWAY MODELLER WHEN WRITING TO ADVERTISERSTHE RAILWAY MODELLER
Vol. 2. No. II.
Edited by C. J. FREEZER
JULY-AUGUST 1951
An lan Allan Publication
THE LINLEY, MELOR & SENTOR RLY.
Part Il. Planning the Line.
by W. J. & J. G. Faulkner
Vil. Lower end of Sentor Station,
‘S we have already stated in Part I, the
Linley Melor and Sentor Railway
was designed in full before any
constructional work was undertaken. Pre-
vious experience gained on the old Linley
Melor and Sentor Railway had shown us
that building a Model Railway was only
a success if it pleased a photographer,
satisfied an engine driver, and above all,
worked efficiently and realistically.
Accordingly the following points were
borne in mind: —
(1) Maximum length of track. It is im-
portant that the train should travel as far
as possible between the termini of the line,
and this without passing through the same
station a dozen times en route. Realism is
only attained if one can conceal effectively
the fact that the longest model track is
very short when compared with a full size
93
illustrating effect of concealing tracks. (Photo, D. Priday
line. For example, the LL.M. & S.R. has
a good length of run, approximately 120ft.
This, in full size figures, is only 12 miles,
less than the distance from Victoria to
Clapham Junction. The folly of having
stations every few yards is thus apparent.
The method used to help in overcoming
this obvious defect, was: —
(2) Concealment of a portion of the
track, This may at first sound Irish, but
concealing sections of the track very
materially assists the illusion that the track
is longer than it is actually. The specta-
tor is left in some small degree of doubt
as to the route and destination of the train.
This may not seem so from the diagram
as this is all too horribly clear, but it is so
in practice. The method that we used to
conceal track is also clear in the diagram.
Fig. VII shows the effect of concealingTHE LINLEY MELOR & SENTOR RAILWAY.
the two tracks at the lower end of Sentor
Station (right-hand side of the diagram).
‘As yet, no proper tunnel mouth has been
constructed here, but the hole through
which these tracks disappear is just visible
through the spans of the double skew
bridge.
(3) The next important point if realism
is desired, is that the train must essen-
tially go from somewhere to somewhere,
and must travel the same ground on the
return journey, i.e., there must be an end
to end run. Realistic working is impos-
ible with a continuous circuit. “To under-
stand this point, imagine a full size tr
travelling through the same station several
times on one journey! To depart from
A and arrive at A with the same train is
equally ridiculous. Only with an end to
end run is it possible to simulate full size
pra In this respect the number of
stations en route is immaterial, as long as
they are not traversed more than once on
the same journey. However, with a lay-
out the size of the L.M. & S.R. where
more than one operator was not only
desirable but essential, a compromise had
94
to be made.
(4) Continuous Circuit—More than one
operator was not always available, and it
niust be possible for one operator to give a
reasonable show for visitors. So to save
this person dashing from one control panel
to the next, a continuous circuit was incor-
porated it: the layout, although only with
certain safeguards. Portions of the circuit
were concealed to disguise its continuity
and only one station was situated on it,
Sentor. Thus one person, without any
attempt at realistic working, could operate
at least a portion of the layout effectively.
From a study of the diagram it can be
seen how the continuous and end to end
types of layout were incorporated.
Consider the layout working as designed
with three operators. The train leaves
Linley under the control of operator A.
Just before the first double junction on the
lower right-hand side of the diagram, the
train passes to operator B, who then con-
trols its journey up the bank at the bottom
of the diagram, and then down through
Sentor Station. At the double junction
the train then runs onto the portion ofFig. Vill. Linley Turntable and Loco Shed, positioned in’:
track already traversed, and proceeds once
more up the bank. ‘The next time it
reaches the junction at the left-hand side
of the diagram, this same operator directs
it up the track to Melor, and just past the
junction, operator C ‘takes over. He
brings the train to rest at Melor. The
portion of track which is traversed twice
is either concealed completely or partly
hidden, as it is lower than Melor Station.
In any case the scenery behind the visible
portion is, or at least will be, non-com-
mittal; just a series of green’ fields and
hills. ' Operator B, it will be seen can, if
necessary, operate trains o2 his section
quite conveniently, and with a minimum
of trouble to satisfy the casual visitor.
The advantage of having three entirely
separate sections, each with its one opera-
tor is that real operating conditions can be
simulated. As the train passes from one
operator to the next, the correct bell code
may be given, and signals set accordingly.
We feel that if and when the L.M. & S.R.
is complete from the operating point of
view, it will be possible to run a complete
series of full size operations, operate a
timetable, and in general, please some of
the sceptics who defy railway modellers to
operate trains as the British Railways do.
Sentor Station is completely signalled, and
these, together with all. points, are operated
from’a lever frame. With the assistance
of a friend, we have already tried some
95
(Photo, 0. Pridey.
recess of the wall.
sequences of train movements, and every-
thing indicates that the completed rail
will satisfy the engine driver’s critical
mind. Further to this intention of simu-
lating real conditions, point No. 5 arises.
(5) It is absolutely necessary to design
the station and facilities as they would be
in real practice. Thus carriage sidings
must be provided, together with shunting
necks that allow’ correct movement of
trains. One criterion of a correctly de-
signed station and layout is whether it can
be signalled properly, and the designer will
not be far adrift if his signalling evokes
no comment from the man on the foot-
plate. There are many books on the de-
sign of stations, goods yards, etc., in fact,
recent issues of the Railway Modeller have
carried articles on this very subject, and
so we do not intend to enter into a detailed
discussion here. ‘The design of the indivi-
dual stations, and the facilities that they
give are apparent from the diagram. One
point worth mentioning, however, and that
is the use of a turntable, positioned to
ive maximum use of corners and recesses.
See the position of Linley loco shed and
turntable, in Fig. VIII* and also in the
diagram.
‘With regard to Fig. VIIT, and some subsequent
pe oes Seer
Eerning the background. “In Fig, VIII, it has been
pari blocked out because, although i looks most
Etnfietory to the eye it photographs in a mostFig. IX.
(6) Not too much track, a point that is,
however, very often overlooked, and in
this respect the L.M. & S.R. is not a good
example. On reflection we feel that we
have fallen into this error. Not enough
space has been left for the extras that are
the spice of a first class model railway.
It is most important to have say a street
of houses, farmyard, brick yard and some
such lineside effects in detail. Otherwise
the railway is not complete. Painted
scenic backgrounds are all very well, but
you should not rely on them to provide
the facilities for which the Model Railway
should be running. If the LM. & SR.
were to be redesigned this fault would be
corrected, though probably not without
some loss of railway facilities.
(7), Long platforms. This is a point
that’ is too often overlooked. In “OO”
Gauge, a platform six feet long will
accommodate 1 tank engine and 6 coaches,
or 1 express loco and 5 coaches only.
‘These are very short trains by full size
standards, particularly if they are main
line types. Thus, for scale modelling,
6 feet is the shortest length that one
should make a main line platform. Fig.
IX is included to illustrate this point.
Linley Platforms are 6 feet long, and the
LM. '& S. 4-4-0 Compound loco with 5
coaches is only just under its maximum
capacity. Consider, a 4-6-0 loco with
Linley Station—the main platforms are 6 ft. long.
96
Photo, O. Priday
three coaches; this would require a plat-
form four feet long. We offer no apology,
however, for the proposed length of Beam-
side platform, as a push-pull 0-4-2 Train
plus coach is all that will operate here.
And last but not least: —
(8) All station facilities should be easily
accessible to the operators. It is no good
making stations and marshalling yards so
large that you cannot reach the far sidings
ithout standing on your toes and stretch-
ing. Damage in some form or other will
surely follow. The actual width accessible,
of course, depends on many factors, height
of operator, height of baseboard, etc., but,
to those who take our advice and design
their layouts before building them, do not
overlook this last point.
Looking back now after five years on
the original drawing of the L.M. & S.R.,
we recognise many minor faults not then
apparent, and no doubt some readers will
be able to find discrepancies between the
ideals enumerated above and the present
layout of the L.M. & SR, but do not
forget that the line, as with every line,
has to be a compromise between these
ideals. We put forward the design of the
LM. & SR. as a brave effort at incor-
porating them all.
(To be continued)L.N.W.R. STANDARD SIGNAL CABINS
— by 1.
HESE notes have been prepared to
help the growing number of en-
thusiasts who are working to proto-
type practice. In order to fit these pages,
the drawings have been reproduced to the
small scale of 4mm. to the foot. Small
details, therefore, are not easy to show,
but workers in the smaller scales should
find enough information for the building
of a good representative model. A scale
of feet and inches, from which dimen-
| sions may be taken, accompanies each
of the drawings.
The drawings show a standard London
& North-Western “G” type 24ft.-1din,
K. NELSON — _
cabin. Many are still in use and a model
‘of one will be as much “at home” on an
up-to-date model railway as on one re-
presenting pre-grouping practice. The
only obvious difference is in the position
of the name boards. Before L.M.S. days,
they were on the cabin sides, Later, they
were moved to the ends as shown on the
drawings. This is the standard position
today.
British Railways are now replacing the
wooden steps with a welded steel structure,
but many of the older ones are still in use.
All standard L.N.W.R. cabins are
12ft. wide outside. “The lengths vary
according to the number of levers. It is
important, therefore, to esti-
mate the number of levers
needed in relation to the
cabin’s position before start-FRONT ELEVATION
ing to build a model. The regular sizes, up
to 70 lever cabins are shown in the table.
Many factors govern the height. 8ft.
from rail level to the floor is a dimension
frequently found when no obstructions
exist. If coaches or covered wagons’ on
an adjacent track are likely to obscure
the signalman’s view, the height may be
12ft. or 14ft. Where overline bridges are
98
ins, QL 234 $ 678 POU ONS Ip
near the cabin and good sighting under
the bridge is not possible, exceptionally
tall cabins, sometimes 24ft. to the floor
level, are found. It should be noted that
in these and other large cabins, the brick
structure is panelled with plinths and
pilasters.
Although the cabins are always 12ft,
wide, when they are situated betweenFT.
LIN.W.R. STANDARD CABIN SIZES
NO. OF LEVERS
THRE] LENGTH) chaning spares
G 13 sar Is
D ler 2a" 20
E ler 9% 25
F 2 6 30
G 2 ye 35
H 26’ 6" 40
J 29 8” 45
kK 37 34" 50
L 35’ 0” 55
M 38° 7)" 60
N 44” 0" 70
tracks or in other places where space is
limited, the brick part is under 12ft. The
cabin then projects on one side or on
E
012345678901 2345 6
UNS, id eel el enenbtmielcliend
END ELEVATIONS
both. Openings for signal wires and point
rods are not shown as these vary with
local requirements.
The drawings show a “glass all round”
cabin. A common alternative is for the
back ‘to have no windows. In this case
the end further from the door has one
window 7ft. 6in. wide. The space between
this window and the back is boarded.
Another variation is for the roof to finish
flush with the end walls without any over-
hang.
The perspective drawing has been pre-
pared to show the general arrangement
and to be a guide to modellers who like
to include simple interior fittings.
Conversation with signalmen and others
who were familiar with L.N-WR. practice
has produced nothing certain about the
style of painting. Most of them say thatoe
t
4
nd
REAR ELEVATION
j
there has been no obvious change. Some
notes, bearing the stamp of the LN.W.R.
Signal and Telegraph Dept., Crewe, how-
ever, show that the following parts were
painted brown (a shade lighter than
G.W.R. brown), roof end boards, finials,
gutters, doors, stairway, cast iron brackets.
All the remainder, buff, except for the
100
window frames which were white.
Acknowledgement must be made for the
assistance given by Mr. John E. Skinley
in obtaining official information from
which the drawings have been prepared
and also for the help given by officials of
British Railways for permission to take
photographs and to check certain details.Beginners Please ——- QUTDOOR RAILWAYS
Outdoor railways present a few diffi-
culties to the modeller, mostly around and
about suitable substructures. One can
hardly call them baseboards.
‘The first thing to remember is that in
England we haven’t a climate but we do
have weather. In other words, it rains.
Rain may seem a fairly harmless thing
but it will, in course of time, do consider-
able damage. Timber for the substructure
of an outdoor model railway should be at
least 1}”X 2” and should be well creosoted.
The posts should, if possible, be treated
with some rot-proofing compound before
they are driven in this may be expensive
at the start but it is decidedly better than
having the whole structure subside gently
onto the ground in a year or two's time.
‘The general design of substructures will,
of course, follow those of indoor lines (see
Railway Modeller, Jan.-Feb., 1951), except
that the timber ‘sections will be larger.
However, ply and hardboard are out of
place outdoors, unless you know that the
ply is a resin bonded variety that will not
warp or part. Instead matchboarding or
asbestos sheeting must be used, or failing
that, thick planks.
An important point to watch is drain-
age. If water is allowed to collect on the
baseboard top it will cause considerable
damage apart from looking extremely un-
tidy and therefore drainage holes should
be provided. Moreover ballast ceases to
be a scale accessory of purely scenic value,
it is an integral working part of the model.
It should therefore be distinctly overscale
to allow the water to drain away. For this
purpose large granite chips, as used to
dress road surfaces, are excellent.
TRACK ON BATTENS
Along the main line there is no need
for wide baseboards. The construction
shown in Fig. 1 is sufficient, here the track
is carried in what is in effect a trough of
ballast, relying on the ballast alone to
hold it in place. This is quite effective,
moreover it will allow for easy realignment
at any future date should this prove advis-
able. In fact, it is just prototype practice.
101
For a simple scenic effect privet bushes
should be planted beneath the line. These
can be trimmed to form cuttings and em-
bankments and will, in case of accident,
break the fall of derailed rolling stock.
However, if the fullest scenic effect is
required the line should be at, or near,
ground level. This is easy to attain but
Teads to much backache whilst operating.
However, if the modeller is also an ardent
gardener, much can be done by planting
small shrubs of suitable appearance beside
the line; your local park superintendent
will no doubt be able to help you here,
both in the choice and care of such plants
Artificial pools and rockeries add to the
attractiveness of such a line and for a
change, space is not at a premium for so
long as room is left to get at the washing
the whole garden’s yours.
GARDEN WALL
BREEZE BLOCKS
a
‘CONCRETE
Pgzifcrouno
Fig. 2.
All this is worth a bit of extra trouble.
If the garden has a distinct slope much
can be done by arranging the principal
station at the lower end. However, this
is rarely so and therefore a certain amount
of excavation will be necessary. Fig. 2
shows roughly the form such excavation
should take though local conditions wilt
largely determine how you arrange
matters. What is essential is a solid wall
and a good concrete floor to the pit with
a fall to one corner and a soakaway; a
pit some two-foot deep full of sharp
gravel which will allow surface water to
drain away. A refinement would be a
small shed or greenhouse over the station
in order that rolling stock could be kept
under cover when service was suspended,
Of all outdoor systems the ground level
has the most to offer, both in effectiveness
and hard work. It is, in fact, civil engi-
neering in miniature.NARROW GAUGE TOPICS
D.
N recent months there has been quite
[: considerable growth of interest in
narrow-gauge railway modelling and
since my recent articles on the subject I
have received numerous letters asking for
further information. In view of the
interest shown, it has been decided to run
this series to deal with readers’ queries
and matters of general interest to the
narrow-gauge modeller. In writing such
a series, I am only too well aware of my
‘own limitations. My own layout is still
in the early stages of construction, and I
cannot pretend to be anything like a real
authority on narrow-gauge matters. It,
therefore, will be anything but dogmatic.
T cannot lay down the law and say how
narrow-gauge railways should be modelled
—nor do I want to. Railway modelling,
after all, is a very personal business and
everyone develops his own views on the
best way to do things. All I can do is to
record what I have learnt from my own
experiences and to give my own opinions.
It will then be up to the individual
modeller to make up his own mind as to
what he intends to do himself.
An example of what I mean is pro-
vided by this vexed question of the “best
gauge” to be adopted for narrow-gauge
models, and it has even been suggested that
this should be fixed by the B.R.M.S.B.
HANCOCK
102
But how can one lay down a standard
narrow-gauge, when the track-gauge of
prototype lines varies so considerably?
Mr. Clayton raises this point in the
March/April issue of the Railway,
Modeller, and I quite agree with him that
anyone modelling some particular line, and
wishing to keep to one of the standard
scales, should adopt the correct gauge for
that line whatever it works out at. Alter-
natively, of course, he can model to a
scale of 4.5mm, or 8mm. or whatever is
most convenient. Moreover, when the
modeller has chosen his gauge, he should
logically refuse to model anything which
does not conform to that gauge. This
may seem a harsh doctrine to anyone who
is not over pedantic about scale accuracy,
and who has an interest in a wide variety
of prototypes. I do feel, therefore, that
it is permissible to go a certain length
along the road to standardization of
narrow-gauge but it is hardly a matter for
the B.R.M.S.B. for opinion is obviously
greatly divided as to the best gauge to
choose.
From the letters I have received it
would appear that most modellers are in-
terested in the possibilities of narrow-
gauge in 4mm. scale, and practically every
Prototype gauge has its adherents. Those
who favour the 3ft. and the 2ft. gaugesdo so largely because of the fairly wide
range of prototypes available in each;
while those who adopt the former have the
added incentive that the gauge works out
at 12mm., which is the same as that used
for the American “TT” gauge. For any-
one with access to the American market
this gauge is therefore very well worth-
while considering. It does, however, come
fairly near to standard gauge, and some
modellers may feel that much of the
charm of narrow-gauge is thereby lost.
‘They will naturally be attracted to the
smaller gauges, and to the 2ft. gauge in
particular. This has the one serious draw-
back, however, in that it gives a track
gauge-of 8mm., which does not correspond
to that of any existing scale. This is not
a serious difficulty, but it is convenient to
model to an existing gauge and there is
considerable support for 2ft. 3in, and
2ft. 4Jin. gauges. These gauges, more-
over, provide a convenient “compromise”
gauge for anyone who is prepared to
abandon a certain amount of scale
accuracy in order to include within the
scope of his modelling any of the attrac-
tive prototypes which lie within the 2ft
to 2ft. 3in. range of gauges.
The reason why both these gauges are
popular is to be found in the divergence
LAYOUTS
FOR THE
MODELLER
No. 3.
T had to happen. Ever
I since I reported
sxistence of Mr. Colson’s
“Railway in a Pantry”, re-
quests have come in for de.
tails; obviously a lot of
people want to do likewise
Well, the layout this time is
based on the principles laid
down by Maurice Deane and
followed by Colson, only I
have deliberately refrained
from following the exact lay-
out for two reasons. Firstly,
the space of the original line —
occupied was somewhat
irregular and would not, therefore,
be
of universal interest and secondly once
the principle is grasped, anyone could re-
construct the layout from the published
photos—they show best part of it. The
Present layout occupies the enormous
space of Sft. by 6ft. in 4mm. scale, leaving
just enough room in the middle’ for the
of. opinion as to the correct geuye for
“000”. When I began my own layout
I adopted a gauge of 9mm. (2ft. 3in.)
because I thought that that was the
accepted gauge for 2mm, scale modelling.
Since then I have discovered that 9.5mm.
gauge is more popular, and this gauge
scales 2ft. 44in. in 4mm. narrow-gauge.
This latter is probably the more con-
venient for those who wish to make use
of 2mm. scale equipment, but there were
very few lines built to that actual gauge,
and the advantage of the 2ft. 3in. gauge is
that it embraces a fairly wide range of
possible models.
Alll this merely goes to show that each
gauge has its advantages and its di
advantages, and it rests with the indivi
dual modeller to decide which gauge best
suits his own requirements. In making
this decision it is useful to. know what
commercial equipment is available for the
various scales and gauges, and I hope to
be able to deal with this matter in the
next issue. In the meantime I shall always
be glad to hear from prospective and
existing narrow-gauge modellers, and I will
do my best to answer all enquiries. The
only thing I ask is that correspondents will
remember to include a stamped addressed
envelope with their letters.
STATON BUILDING
SIGNAL CABIN
‘OOS SHED
CONTROL PaneL
ENGINE SHED
COAL. STAGE E WATER TANK
BRIDGE
HALT
SECTOR PLATE.
warvousun—
operator and, if both are slim enough, his
friend, The main station is quite com-
pact, has all the usual appurtenances and
though simple will be fairly interesting to
work. Thence the line runs on an un-
broken 24in. radius curve past a junction
which is optional and will be referred to
later, to a small halt. Here we have a
103Joop and a single siding but no signals or
signal box in the proper sense. Ther
however, a ground frame, either in the
open or if you feel lavish, in a tiny hut
looking rather like a signal box that has
been left out in the rain to shrink. This
frame is normally locked but can be re-
leased by an Annett key on the train staff.
This, of course, applies only to the proto-
type, the model would have a frame in the
usual manner adjacent to the station. If
you felt particularly lavish you could have
a small control panel which would nor-
mally be switched out with a D.P.D.T.
switch but which could be cut in onto the
halt section whenever you wished to shunt.
As there isn’t really room for two opera
tors it would be rather pointless but
if there were more space it would be very
handy. From the halt the line continues,
mostly on a 24in. curve, until it dis-
appears under a large overbridge which
marks the end of the visual line. This
could, of course, be a tunnel mouth but
the bridge, with the building in front does
mask the fact that the line leaves the
imaginary countryside at this point and
arrives at the runround sidings. Too
many tunnels exist for no other reason
than convenience. A tunnel is not the
only way of masking hidden runrounds.
Here all the fiddling takes place to return
trains to the terminus. There is, in addi-
tion the chain dotted line which is
optional but advisable. This exists purely
to give continuous running and the
visible end could well be disguised as a
private siding. The continuous run is, of
course, only used for testing and running-
in locomotives, for normal operation true
terminal working is essential.
Between the station and the runround
loops there is a line of semi-flat buildings.
‘These are far more effective as a means of
breaking the gap between the two sections
than a plain painted backsheet, even if
they are but Jin. in depth, for the relief
throws a true shadow that matches the
shadows on the model, something no
painted scene can ever do. Moreover, with
a simple painted backcloth representing sky
behind the runround sidings the illusion of
distance is easily attained and, providing
the buildings are at least 34in. high, the
trains behind cannot be seen.
Needless to say there are limitations to
this arrangement, You are limited to
trains of two bogie coaches or three four-
wheelers and goods trains of four or five
wagons and a brake. You are also limited
to small tank engines, nothing larger than
an 0-4-4T, an 0-6-2T or a 2-4-2T is per-
missible. However, on the credit side of
the balance you have an accurate line with
great scenic possibilities that bears no re-
semblance to a toy. It is, moreover,
reasonably inexpensive to build; you don’t
need more than one engine and half a
dozen pieces of rolling stock to start with.
Nor does it take overlong to build and get
in perfect order; about a year all told at
the outside; and when in order there isn’t
a lot to do to keep it in tip top condition.
Finally it does enable you to have a model
railway where you thought you never could
get one. CLF.
A FINE L.N.W.R. LAYOUT
HE photograph on the facing page
was taken on Mr. J. K. Nelson's
HO gauge L.N.WR. line. It
shows the excellent scenic work that is an
feature of the line and concern-
ing this Mr. Nelson writes: “The stone-
work on the tunnel face is prepared by
gluing lino onto wood formers and sub-
sequently carving with lino cutting tools.
Most of the grass is surgical lint mounted
hairy side up, painted with concentrated
size and water colours, When nearly dry
a little dry earth (from the garden!) is
rubbed in here and there and when abso-
lutely dry a file card drags up the long
grass.
“The weeds growing under the trees on
the river banks in the foreground are dried
grasses, painted.
“The signal box, which has dummy
levers and fittings is built of card and
Perspex. The window frames (note the
one open window) are of Bristol Board.
“The locomotive is an LN.WR.
George V class 4-4-0, bought second-hand
about five years ago; I do not know the
maker. The coaches were built by myself
from official Wolverton drawings. Every-
thing is to a scale of 34mm. to a foot”.
A recent visit, on the occasion of the
line’s official opening, showed that the rest.
of the line was fully up to the standard
shown in this picture. Readers will prob-
ably be interested to know that Mr. Nel-
son, who is Chairman of the Ilford Junior
Railway Club, has had a great deal of
assistance from them in the construction
of the line which is, in fact, the club lay-
out. Itis pleasing to.record that although
the average age is well under eighteen the
care and respect these lads show to these
beautiful models fully repays Mr. Nelson’s
trust in them. In fact they could give
many older modellers tips on how to
handle models.
104L.M.S. & L.N.W.R.
Signal Measurements
by ‘HARDWICKE’
THOSE L.N.W. and LMS. en-
T thusiasts who demand the last thing
in realism and thus need accurate
details will, probably find the following
details of interest. It may also be of
interest to mention that all dimensions
given were obtained direct from the Signal
and Telegraph Department of the L.M.S.
Fig. 1.
before the war. The measurements of the
upper quadrant L.M.S. signals refer to
the square posted pre-war type and not
to what I call the “utility” signals with
tubular posts and plain arms.
The photographs show typical signals
of each era. Fig. I is the starter for plat-
form 3 at Buxton (Western Division) and
shows the short arm used in so many of
the lower post signals. To the right, in
the background, can be seen the home
signals, a junction having the standard
length arms with the very short calling-on
arms below. The upper quadrant, Fig. II,
106
Fig. 3,is the starter for platform 2 at Buxton
(Midland Division) and shows the calling-
on or shunt arm below the main one.
Fig. II] is the starter on the M.S.J.A. plat-
forms at London Road Station, Manches-
ter and shows, in addition to the starter,
a distant arm on the same post.
Models should not be constructed from
TABLE OF
SINGLE SIGNALS
Size of post at base, 20’-30' high
over buttress
30-40’ high
above 40” high
|—all heights
Size of post at fi
BRACKET SIGNALS
Size of post at base
yy» Over buttress |.
ton ym at joint of horizontal
Length of horizontal (two post)...
Depth of horizontal oe
Size of signal posts on horizontal. .
» at finial ...
SIGNAL ARMS
Length of main tine, home or distant
Depth nn
Length of shunting arm
Depth ,
PROTOTYPE
LAYOUTS
No. 6 HARBORNE
the terminus of the single line
branch from Birmingham (New
Street) to Harborne, The station itself
is of the single platformed type and is a
well built structure of red brick. As will
be seen by the accompanying drawing
there are the usual offices and waiting
rooms. The roof is of slate, the platform
awning is of patent glazing and the plat-
form asphalt edged with blue brick.
‘The layout is very suitable for model-
ling, being simple in design yet able to
cope with both passenger and goods iraffic.
The branch was closed to passenger
traffic in November 1934 but until then
it had a passenger service of 19 trains per
day in each direction. The goods service
is still prosperous, there being two trains
per day.
‘As will be seen from the photographs
(2 subject chosen for this article is
centre to centre, each post
the measurements alone; variations occur,
particularly in the lengths of the arms of
the L.N.W-R. types and whilst the balance
weights of these signals were almost always
on the side of the post facing the traffic,
they did vary in position whilst the L.M.S.
signals had their balance weights in
various positions on any of the four sides.
DIMENSIONS
LIN.W.R, LMS.
Isq. 11" sq.
3 14° sq
‘ we Special
a Special
64" sq.
Hi'sq. 11 sq.
l4%sq. 14" sq.
s I'sq. 9 sq.
are’ 9’0"
we? 70g
i 1 Ia
¥ se 8 sq.
6y' sq. 6} sq.
i ze i Se" Seater
: see lor
hoy etic
i 6
|
n|
a
a,
ls
Harborne Starter.
107‘ A VIEW ON Y.
be VIEW ON Xx. (rom @ drawing by E.R. Ashton).
Harborne Station, 19/11/34.
108Seon
= ‘CDODS SHED
there is also a small goods shed, most of
the goods traffic is coal, and there are
several coal merchants offices on the
station sit
Signalling is simple as there are only
two post signals and three ground discs.
The former are home and starter signals
of typical L.N.W.R. pattern, the home
being 30ft. in height, the starter 15ft.,
Harborne Station from footbridge.
109
HARBORNE-L.M.R. (EX. L.N.W.R.) —
now on a concrete post. The turntable—
now removed—was also locked from the
signal box.
There is a footbridge painted in the
usual buff colour, running from the side
of the station buildings across the goods
yard to the neighbouring Harborne
Estates.
PLB. WiTeHousE
(Photo, P. 8. WhitehouseHarborne Signal Box. [Photo P. 8. Whitehouse
Harborne Station. 11/34. Photo, W. A. Camwell
110)NE of the more unfortunate things
about the average model railway is
the lack of attention given to the
This is all too
O
civil engineering side
often left as an afterthought and fitted
in where there isn’t room for anything
else. One of the greatest sufferers in this
affair is, of course, the humble bridge.
All too often it gets shoved into a corner
because there isn’t room for it anywhere
else. Now there is nothing wrong
having a bridge on a curve, for there are
plenty of prototypes, but there is a lot
wrong with the way most bridges are built
when they are supposed to be curved.
It is flatly impossible to build a curved
bridge. You cannot bend beams, nor can
you twist a masonry arch, they would just
topple sideways under load. A bridge, or
viaduct, on a curve is in fact a succession
of short chords, as in the diagram. In
practice the curves are so gentle that this
passes unnoticed but on a model, where
the curves are far and away sharper than
their prototypes it is all too horribly ob-
vious, and unless, in 4mm. scale, the curve
is at least 36” radius the resulting bridge,
viaduct or what-have-you will look pretty
grim whatever you do. The only possible
solution is a timber trestle, for here the
piers, or rather struts, can be kept at close
centres. A normal viaduct, which has
spans of 35’ will look horrible, even on
36” curves it is as well to reduce your pier
centres to 30° to reduce the effect of the
successive dog-legs in the bridge’s plan.
Another common error is to indulge in
too many girder bridges. This, I think
is an error of taste rather than accuracy,
for there is no question that the average
girder bridge is far from being a pretty
thing, whilst a well designed masonry arch
is. Moreover there is a lot more work in
the girder bridge if it is to be correct. In
fact if every modeller were to keep a
simple self denying ordinance to eschew
any bridge that involved trusses of any
description a considerable improvement in
standards would result, I should point
EDITOR'S NOTEBOOK
ut
out in this question that there are no com-
mercial sections available from which a
respectable trussed bridge can be built; if
anyone dares mention bullhead rail I shall
scream. Despite the continual burblings
to the contrary from amateur “engineers”
you cannot build a bridge from rails they
are not a structural section.
So much for trusses. A plate girder is
quite in order and there have been a few
designs published. These take care of
larger spans, up to 60-80, which is big
enough for the most ambitious modeller.
To give variety, however, there are
masonry arches. These can run into
astonishing lengths—a scale model of one
of the larger efforts would run into four
or five feet in 4mm. scale but even in the
smaller sizes they are extremely effective.
Before you can begin to make an accurate
model you must have some idea, at least,
of how the prototype is put together. Even
if you do not, as in this particular case,
follow prototype procedure in erection, or,
in fact, construct anything remotely’ re-
sembling the prototype in its internal
economy, you have to simulate the exter-
nal appearance of the prototype.
Now despite the large number of con-
trary opinions—to judge from some
models—a masonry bridge is held up by a
very small portion of the whole. Cement
has nothing to do with it, it is purely de-
sign, ‘The whole bridge is supported upon
a series of concentric rings of bricks or
stones, depending on the construction.
‘These are forced downward by the super-
incumbent load of the spandrel walls, hard
core and traffic, and being solid, merely
jam tighter together the heavier the load,
thrusting outward onto the abutments
either side. In the case of a large arch,
anything over 50’, this side thrust is fairly
considerable and the second diagram shows
that the abutment is a massive block of
mass concrete, with brick facings. Of
course this varies with the site and design
of bridge. If solid rock is available that
can bear the thrust it is brought into use
for obvious reasons of economy.
The thickness of the arch depends on
the span of the bridge, and will vary from
two or three rings to several feet. At the
very top is the keystone. Sometimes a
very ornamental stone appears on each
end, on occasions carved with a coat of
arms, but in fact the true keystone is prob-
ably'a common blue brick, or rather a
complete course of them. Despite popular
belief the keystone does not hold up the
arch, the entire ring of stones are essen-coPing—
|-—-STRING COURSE
H
The keystone is merely the last stone
that keys the arch together.
The arch carries the two spandrel walls,
which serve merely to hold in the hard-
core, a pleasing mixture of earth, stone,
old bedsteads, bathbricks and dead cats—
tial.
in other words anything that can be
chucked in to fill the gap. In the case of
large bridges and viaducts there are fre-
quently subsidiary arches within the span-
drel walls to reduce the amount of hard-
core and, obviously, the weight. This is
essential, for solid earth can weigh quite
a lot and to avoid having too heavy piers
and over large foundations the biggest
bridges are often hollow shams.
‘The curves of the arch are set out from
the springing line, a line joining the base
of the arches. Where two or more arches
of differing heights and pitches are found
together in the same bridge they are set
out from the common springing line,
partly from appearance but principally be-
cause in this fashion the two thrusts from
the adjacent arches are to some extent
balanced and transmitted to the end abut-
ments, thus allowing the central piers to
be lighter as they only need carry the ver-
tical load. Although most viaducts have
arches of semi-circular section this is not
so with bridges of up to three or four
arches, Those are usually elliptical, and
even if the modeller thinks it a fiddle, it
18 as well to make the ellipse a three arc
affair, as shown in the diagram. It is
just as effective in the long run as play-
ing about with pins and a loop of stringto draw a true ellipse, for ten to one you
won't cut it out correctly.
In practice masonry arches are built up
on timber falseworks called centres, which
are kept in place until the mortar has set
and the arch can stand of itself. In the
model nothing of the sort takes place, ex-
cept where an outdoor modeller uses con-
crete. The perspective sketch of the via
duct shows how liberties are taken and
how, in fact, the model bridge is held up
by two wooden-side walls. The whole
affair is a fake from start to finish but if
you don’t put the paper arch on the model
the fake will show for all to see and
marvel at your inexcusable ignorance.
Really there’s nothing to the construction
of a model bridge except the marking out
and cutting of two wooden sides sticking
on the brickpaper and faking in the arch.
If it is at all a long bridge, refuges should
be provided at frequent intervals in order
that any workers caught on the bridge
may keep clear of the trains and that the
signal engineers may find somewhere to
erect their posts.
Next a word about skew spans. These
present few difficulties to the modeller,
though they cause more curses in civil
engineers’ offices than anything else, for
the courses of brick have to be placed on
a complex curve in order that the thrust
might be transmitted to the abutments and
not, as would otherwise happen, into thin
air with disastrous consequences. This is
easiest done if the cross section on the
skew is circular, elliptical skew bridges
have been known to drive men mad. How-
ever, unless a very peculiar section is used
the appearance on the straight is always
an ellipse, which simplifies matters. So far
as the modeller is concerned the brick
paper on the arch should be skewed,
though this doesn’t particularly matter as
no-one can see it anyway. The diagram
ought to make things plain,
One last word. If, for any reason, you
wish to put a plate girder span into the
centre of a set of masonry arches you
113
have, in effect, produced three separate
bridges, a masonry arch, a plate girder and
another masonry arch to finish with.
Therefore the abutments each side of the
girder should be extremely solid affairs,
capable of taking the thrust of the arches.
Otherwise the bridge would, in the proto-
type, gently collapse. Each of the masonry
arches would push sideways into the cen-
tral gap and the plate girder would sub-
side gracefully, to come to rest on a pile
of rubble. So, if you don’t want to make
a civil engineer die laughing, go careful
how you'design your next bridge. Better
still copy a prototype, it’s a lot safer.
Talking of working to prototype leads
naturally enough to photography, for one
good photograph of a prototype is worth
a ton of description. Here the modeller
can help himself, for anyone can take a
good photograph providing he uses a
reasonable amount of care, There is no
need for elaborate equipment, for pure
record work a box camera will suffice—
Thave taken dozens of useful shots with a
camera that cost 4s. 6d. pre-war. If you
load with orthochromatic film, Verichrome,
Selochrome or a similar type, you are
almost certain to get good results provid-
ing you use your head and follow two
simple rules, First, hold the camera
steady when exposing. Second, wait, in
the summer months, until the sun is
covered with a cloud. This may sound
crazy but in fact there is so much light
about in summer that if you don’t do
this you will get _a grossly over-exposed
negative, modern films are so fast. Into
the bargain, although from the pictorial
viewpoint the result will be flat, the detail
will be there and not hidden in areas of
white blankness or black shadow, otherwise
known as soot and whitewash.
I'm not suggesting that the box camera
is the ideal camera for such work, it isn’t,
but it just so happens that its particular
limitations do not obtrude. My own choice
for this work is a miniature camera, not, I
am sorry to say, a Leica or Contax, but a
much cheaper affair which can, and does,
produce excellent results within its limits.
The beauty of the miniature is the fact
that it will take 36 exposures at one load
and as covering a simple station takes a
round dozen shots it is none too many.
Anyway I hope, this summer, to put
several more South Devon stations into
the bag. It’s a pleasant side of the hobby,
station copping, and using a “runabout”
ticket it is quite cheap. Without strain
you can tackle three stations a day and
be back in time for tea, However, take
my tip and pack a thermos flask, if the
day's at all hot you'll need it!BEHIND THE
Each year thousands see the Model Rail-
way Exhibition from the outside. To them
it appears a well. organised, carefully
thought out affair. Those members of
the Model Railway Club who see what the
Central Hall is like about midday on
Easter Monday have an entirely different
idea. At that moment it looks as if the
exhibition, for once, isn’t going to go
according to plan. It seems certain that
the show will not go on; that by opening
time none of the stands’ will be finished.
But the annual miracle occurs and some-
how everything is in place when the
public are admitted.
‘The upper photograph shows much of
this confusion. The L.N-ER. stand in
the left foreground is taking shape rapidiy
114
SHGTE"NEEIS
but will probably be completely _re-
arranged before the day is out. There is
as yet little sign of the live steam track,
though its compound is up and ready for
occupation. In the far distance can be
seen the Southern stand, without a model
in sight.
‘The chaos on the lower level is worse
still, the Great Western stand, the famous
“Aquarium” is still in a state of masterly
disorder and as for the working layouts
.. At the moment they are anything but
working.
The lower photograph shows the most
onerous chore of the whole job, wiring
down the models. It has to be done, the
problem is how. It is easier to thread a
needle blindfold.Workshop Corner
HANDBRACE TURNING
‘T is no exaggeration to say that a lathe
I of some sort is essential for the keen
modeller, the operative words being
“of some sort”. Lathes vary somewhat,
from the primitive pole lathes still used by
itinerant chair bodgers to the gigantic
machines used for turning the rollers of
steel mills with every variation of preci~
sion, near precision and roughing tool in
between. The cost varies according to the
size and precision; for the modeller who
only needs his lathe for ornamental turn-
ing it can be a very simple affair. Fortu-
nately most of the precision parts, wheels,
axles, and the like, can be bought, leaving
only ‘fittings to be turned in the home
workshop.
HAND= ORILL
Basically a lathe consists of two parts,
a means for gripping and revolving the
part to be turned and a means of holding
and steadying the cutting tool. Nine times
out of ten a hand-drill held in a vice as
shown in Fig. 1 will do all that is needed,
The tool rest, is however, another matter.
It can be of the form shown in the sketch,
which is about the easiest to arrange, or
it can be more elaborate with facilities for
accurately adjusting the relative position
of the rest to the job, for it is most im-
portant that the cutting edge of the tool
should be on the horizontal centre line of
the work, as shown in Fig. 2. This is
essential if the tool is to cut properly with-
out digging in or chattering.
The simplest source for hand turning
tools is the broken ends of needle files;
what modeller has not a collection of
these? The temper is just about right
and a little work on a grindstone will bring
the jagged end to one or other of the
forms shown in Fig. 3. The most useful
is the round nose (1), two or three jof
these should be made of differing radii, the
knife (2) and the vee (3) are only used for
1s
special contours, they will not of them-
selves produce a smooth surface when used
in the hand. ‘The parting tool (4) is a
special case and will be found most useful
for light finishing cuts, it will not, how-
ever, part off in so primitive a lathe, this
should be done with a saw.
If it is preferred, you need not have
special tools but instead you may use files
in order to remove unwanted metal. This
is perfectly alright, although all textbooks
on turning deplore it. It is admittedly
less efficient when used in a proper lathe,
even by an expert, but in our makeshift
effort the difference is small and the
amount of skill required is certainly less.
The principal objection is, of course, that
273%
'
TYPES OF LATHE
‘TOOLS.
TOOL aT
CENTRE
FelGHT /
Fig. 2.
abrasive dust is sprayed over the lathe bed
when you file the workpiece, however our
lathe has no bed so this does not apply.
As it is hard work turning the handle
with one hand whilst using the tool in the
other it is as well to press someone else
to act as “motor”. The exact method I
leave to each individual, bribery and cor-
ruption, coercion or intimidation, for it is
certain that no-one will do it twice for
love, especially on a hot day. Alterna-
tively a pistol drill will provide the neces~
sary power without any bother.
Providing the basic bar from which the
job is to be turned is smaller than the
capacity of the drill chuck no trouble will
ensue. If however this is not so, you
must arrange a spigot that can be gripped
in the chuck. There are two ways. The
most solid system, is to file a suitable
spigot but the efficacy of this depends en-
urely on your ability to file a spigot that
is reasonably true with the outer body; no
easy task. Alternatively you may put a
centre punch mark in the centre of the
bar, using a bell centre punch or odd-leg
calipers, drill and tap for the fixing screw.
‘A short length of screwed rod, locknutted,
is screwed in and then placed in the chuck.
‘There will be no tendency for this to un-screw as the effect of turning will always
be to tighten it up.
Turning is at once simple and difficult.
In principle all one has to do is to apply
the tool to the parts not wanted and re-
move them. This, of course, sounds easier
than it is and much practice will be needed
before perfection is attained. Even when
the turner is experienced it is extremely
unlikely that he will be able to do real
precision work on so primitive a machine,
for example it might be possible to remove
the unwanted flanges from the centre
wheels of a six-coupled chassis but it will
be almost impossible to turn up a pair of
wheels with any pretence to accuracy. For
this class of work a proper lathe with a
Comtng erase
respectable tool-rest is required. There is
no need to buy a large machine, nor do
you want anything as accurate as a watch-
maker's lathe, what is needed is a simple
1” centre lathe such as sell, even today,
for around £5. This, together with the
rest of the necessary equipment will cost
little over £10 and with it the modeller
may attempt most of the work needed to
produce a small scale locomotive. I have,
in fact, seen a 1 gauge live steam locomo-
tive made on such a machine, but I
should point out that the turner who did
it was a professional and knew exactly
what he was about. There are tricks in
every trade, and those in turning would
fill a volume.
Aen Awe,
Fie 6S.
SMain Lines.
=
MAIN Lines:
IDEAL Amen Ar.
Fi lier) Basto Ov Maron Consrasus (Mean 7")
[Ss
fis 67. Basto On Burrow
Mat
Fis 69(anove)
Fie To, fe 71.
Gove, os
Fie 72. =PLANNING A LAYOUT.
by Michael
CHAPTER VI.
LOCO. DEPOTS
S with stations, goods yards and
marshalling yards, so with Loco.
Depots, the size and type depends
entirely upon local conditions and volume
of traffic. They may vary from a Divi-
sional Centre consisting of a 10 or more
road loco. shed, full coaling, water and ash
pan facilities, 70° turntable, and all neces-
sary office arrangements, down to a single
track shed with a heap of coal beside the
line outside the shed for replenishing the
loco. bunker before the next run.
Sheds may be of the through road type
or dead end type, although the former are
usually planned on new depots. Positioa-
ing of the coaling plant, turntable, etc.,
vary as to siting, but the ideal arrangement
for a loco. arriving at the depot is for it to
proceed to the coaling stage, on to the ath
plant, turntable, and into the shed; and
when leaving for its next tour of duty to
proceed direct from the shed to the main
line. As a rule the ideal is seldom cb-
THE ADVICE BUREAU REPORTS .
Does anyone know any method of pre~
venting rats nesting in tunnels? I have
put down Rodine, burnt old linoleum; I
have even made an inner lining of cement
yet the pests still continue to nest in my
tunnel. “Can you help me?
Could you also tell me of any pre~
servant which can be applied to metal
signals, bridges, etc., which are left per-
manently outdoors?
A. M., KENDAL.
Rats in tunnels are a little out of our
line, we would suggest the local rodent
officer, or whatever the latest term is for
a rat-catcher, for rats require a lifetime’s
study, being persistent by nature. We
would suggest, however, that firm fitting
sheet iron doors coupled with a thick
concrete lining would act as a deterrent
but would not like to guarantee that they
could not get past such barriers had they
a mind to, With any other animal a lump
‘of wood over the holes would, of course,
suffice.
‘The only preservant for iron and steel
is paint, ordinary oil paint, Iaid on thick.
17
Leigh
tained, but the minimum amount of engine
movements is always aimed at in the
depot.
The decision as to whether the entrance
to a depot is by facing a trailing points
from the main line, depends upon impor-
tance and track arrangements.
In modelling a loco. depot a comer of
the room is probably the best position, as
the space taken up by a turntable is very
considerable and reference to the illustra-
tions will show the awkwardness of fitting
in this necessary feature of a depot. For
the small room owner, here is another i
stance where a branch line is an advan-
tage; even though the terminus boasts an
engine shed, it does not follow a turntable
must be provided, as the line could be
run entirely by tank locos., and the occa-
sional tender loco, can always return tender
first to the nearest depot for turning.
In planning a large depot with a break-
down train track, remember to ensure this
hhas_an easy exit to the main line.
Figures 65 to 68 show a few real rail-
way depots and figures 69 to 72 a few
suggested layouts for model railways.
It doesn’t look particularly pretty so it is
not usual to build outdoor fittings of tin-
plate or iron but rather of brass and zinc,
I have a fairly large Hornby Dublo
layout and I wonder if Trix engines and
rolling stock would work off Hornby
Dublo tracks.
Where could I get some Dublo chassis
as referred to in the article (A Detach-
able Wagon Body) in the Jan-Feb. issue
of the Railway Modeller?
L. J. H., GT. URSWICK.
Due to differing wheel, conductor, and
electrical standards it is not possible for
Trix and Hornby Dublo stock to run on
the same tracks.
Separate Hornby Dublo chassis cannot
be obtained, the article in question dealt
with the conversion of existing Hornby
Dublo stock to something more closely re-
sembling the actual thing. I would sug-
gest that you get some standard scale
underframes and fit PECO Hornby Dublo
standard wheels and PECO Simplex
couplings, which will fit the bill.T have an OO gauge, 3 rail (centre rail)
portable layout. ‘I am rather discontented
with the appearance of 3 rail and am
contemplating a change to two rail or stud
contact. Which would you recommend?
G. R. T., DENTON.
There is no “best” system of electrifica-
tion, but unless you wish to carry out
extensive alterations stud contact is de-
finitely the best for your particular case.
Moreover as you already have centre rail
pick-up you can convert piecemeal, as the
locomotive shoes will obviously pick up as
effectively from a continuous rail as they
will from the studs.
There are a variety of designs for stud
contact collectors, an excellent example
was described on p. 53 of the second issue
of the Railway Modeller, to which we
refer you.
One of my locomotives persists in
derailing at a points whenever I try 10
shunt, What can I do about it?
‘This, though not an actual query, is
unfortunately all too typical. We simply
can’t_answer it. Without seeing the
offending locomotive on the actual track
and trying both we cannot even begin to
guess what is wrong. As a guide, the
track may be badly laid. More likely,
the locomotive’s chassis is at fault. Then
again it could well be that this par-
ticular locomotive is a lively runner and
takes the points too fast for safety.
These are only the main headings.
Long ago we thought that we knew most
of the ways rolling stock could be derailed.
Today we know different.
‘The only way to ensure perfect running
is first to take care when laying track and
building rolling stock and second to watch
the running carefully, find out the cause
of any slight irregularity and correct it
at once. There is no easy cure.
The Bureau is willing to help those
readers who have trouble producing a lay-
out plan on their own but we would
appreciate some help in return. We are
not mind-readers, so if you ask only for
@ layout to fit a given space we can only
produce something we would like. . You
may have different ideas. Worse still is
the omission to state the scale. Really,
we must know that! So, please, do tell
us the scale, the sort of trains and the
number and type of stations you would
like to have. We'll do our level best to
fit them all in.
118
TRADE NOTES ——
‘We have had an opportunity of inspect-
ing samples of the new C.C.W. track
parts. The track base comprises ‘a com-
bined sleeper and ballast section available
in wood or cork, This can, of course,
be used with flat headed pins to which the
rail is soldered, or, naturally, F.B. rail
may be attached with Peco spikes. How-
ever CCW. have also. produced a. very
effective chair which, although slightly
coverscale, does look remarkably effective.
This is spiked to the base in the same
manner as are the chairs used in the larger
scales. We would commend this move, as
a pet fad of ours is that track should stand
close scrutiny. The chair will, of course,
be very useful to S gauge workers, who
will find that it is very close to scale. We
would advise anyone using this system to
take particular care to taper the end of
the rail before trying to force the chair
on, as otherwise damage can occur and
would also advise them to use a small stop
to push the chairs on. It can be done in
the hands but after half a yard has been
threaded with about forty chairs most of
the skin will have disappeared from thumb
and_forefinger.
The chairs cost 2s. 6d. per 100, the
track bases 2s. 6d., per 18” length
(straight), 3s. per 18” length of flexible
base. Crossover bases are 4s. 10d. each.
All prices include purchase tax.
To add a little life to a model station
it is necessary to have a few coloured
advertisements spread about the walls.
This can be done in many ways. Small
suitable coloured prints can be pressed
into service. This is rather unsatisfactory
at times, as it is hard to find suitable
small scale items and even when one does
they rarely resemble any prototype poster.
Much can be done with a few judicious
touches of water colour, applied with a
mapping pen, but this requires a certain
degree of artistic skill.
The best solution is found in the
specially prepared miniature poster. These
were fairly common before the war but
of late the supply has dwindled, due
largely to the rise in printing costs. "How-
ever, ERG (Bournemouth) Ltd., in_con-
junction with Messrs. W. D. & H. 0.
‘Wills have produced a set of 4 mm. scale
replicas of that firm’s advertisements. The
originals were produced by the Messrs.
Wills’s own poster artists, so accuracy can
be guaranteed. The set, comprising three
sheets, costs Is. 104d. including P.T.,
and can be obtained from any ERG
stockist. Failing this they can be obtained
direct from the publishers, whose address
appears in our advertisement section.HEN I said I'd have a hints and
W tips page I had a pretty good idea
of what to expect—I wasn’t dis-
appointed. I can only assume that the
great majority of my readers are an
extremely unoriginal load of modellers as
most of the hints I received had been
published before—and to gain the half
guinea the tip must be original.
The first hint came from N. F. W,
Dyelhoff who suggested taking a 3”
length of mercontrol tubing and squeez-
ing a short length of wire in one end,
bending it as shown in the sketch to
make a shunter’s pole. Unfortunately it
follows closely a design I gave in the
M.R.C, in August ’49 and I’ forget who
T lifted the idea off. I should add that
it is about the only simple tool that will
help you couple up three link couplings
in any gauge.
The next idea, from N. C. Trott, is
an old scheme with a modern twist, but
again, not original though Mr, Trott may
have ‘discovered it for himself. He uses
strips of Sellotape to mask the edges of
any line he wishes to paint and strips
the tape off later when the paint is dry.
Well, before Sellotape came out we used
to use gummed strip and it was the
devil’s own job getting it off without
removing the paint as well. Needless to
say Sellotape was hailed with joy.
Our next idea, from Mr. L. J. Wallace,
concerns insulating two rail’ pick-up.
The sketch shows the idea, a small
brush, preferably of copper carbon,
presses against the wheel rim, It is held
in an insulated bush and the. pressure
spring is itself mounted on an insulating
block. A good idea but it is rather com-
plicated and there are easier ways of
arranging pickup in two rail,
HINTS AND TIPS
9
pseynov
Two rail points feature in our next
idea from Mr. T. H. Moffat. The
sketch shows an extremely simple switch
for changing the polarity of the frog,
so simple in fact, that I am sure the
sketch explains everything. Mr. Moffat
is to be congratulated on providing a
sound set-up, though it may need an
occasional adjustment. It is, however,
quite accessible.
simplicity of Mr.
W. W. Harper’s hint just gains the
award, He has found that occasionally,
even if the utmost care has been exer-
cised, a Hornby Dublo magnet loses
some of its power whilst the chassis is
being converted to scale. He re-energises
his “Duchesses” (the post-war type with
separate pole pieces) by the simple ex-
pedient of putting an Eclipse pocket mag-
net in contact with the pole pieces. The
result he tells me, is electrifying, and I
can well believe it, Moreover no altera-
tions or additions are needed, just a mag-
net costing a couple of shillings. What
could be simpler than that?
As the response has been so poor I
simply do not think it worth while carry-
ing on with the idea of a separate hints
page. Five hints in three months does
not make the thing worth the trouble and
bother it entails. In future, any hints
that may arrive will have to go into the
mailbag se CUE.== MODELLER’S MAILBAG
STANDARDS IN H.l. GAUGE
‘Tue Eprror, Railway Modeller,
Sity—I now hear that the B.RIM.S.B. have now
recommended the ues of che DAYS Gauge
dimensions for Hx Gauge in this country. I am
Spending herewith the NLLICA. 1946 8 Gauge
data to correspond with the key letters and
humbers of the B.R-M:S.B. 1950 Booklet to show
that these, are practically identical,
Tecommendations and to ask why mine are not
regarded as practical. Ts it that the Bureau are
now afraid to admit’ that after all this waste of
me my figures could have been adopted in 1945?
‘They have had a copy of my Data Sheet for Hx
all this time, so there appears to be no excuse for
theiraction. Your readers, especially those interested
in Hr, have now the opportunity to voice their
‘opinions on the following data. N.M.R.A. 1946
fAgures are given first (mine in brackets) ai per my
1950 RM. letter.
PAGE 4 FLAT BOTTOM RAIL
% Coase") 85")
128°(093") 04s" C0469"), 105" Cot
Coss) 04s em
030° (028") _-030" 030")
PAGE 5 TRACK
c F sc
749° (757) +063" (o625") 875" (875°)
oN
812" (8125")
PAGE 7 WHEELS
A B D
1094") op" 781") 039" Coats")
+030" (0313)
PAGE &
62" (o460" 8139
+062 (o469") 782" 7813")
1-200" (1°2188")
12" C8125)
yt? Cons
1-046" (1-0313")
T have given my figures in decimal inches for the
purpere EP Smparison with the NACA. 94s
\uge figures.
In conclusion, may I ask the Bureas to submit
Bee eee cere a eae
oe amc”
Manchester
Hat Foe.
Despite che fact chat I said correspondence on this
subject should cease 1 have relaxed the bon in thie
nitance, Hal Fone feels that he has a grudge as hi
Htandards were not adopted. Lest I should be accused
Of bias, T have ve-opmned che subject.
Speaking personally, I think that the Bureau made
a tite dichion,, The advantages of international
Standardisation far outweigh any other considerations.
S"'gouse exis, parts are "manufactured. to its,
Standards, “We in Britain should follow suit instead
of going off om our own.” T have no doubt that the
‘Bureau will reply tn like terms.
INTERCHANGEABLE BLADED KNIVES
‘Tum Eorron, Railway Modeller.
SiR—In the M:
Modeller Mr. Borel
interchangeable blades suitable for cutting out card
arts.
I wonder if you could publish all the gen on this
tool, as I feel that there are many chaps like myself”
Ssull'strugaling along with razor blades,
Many thanks fr Piel Suaion. tip the, ideal
termints for a small layout. I am already trying to
‘Work a similar plan into my layout
Ipswich. G. Gopparo.
‘are several such knives on the market.
Tie Pris BRAETO ranges easly the mot renee,
fe has tools for. almoct every, purpose. 4 fee
waved inthe whet; Modeller®
eopare a5" Theres cso the Mudticrah Mee
‘has. a hollow handle to take the spare blades, thus
‘making it a pocket tool.
gl Nat Never sed, Mulirft hie, at, 1 ave
Hee mall ase he eae infest the
Sinese thing T have met for really solid sor
‘But for all that, I still prefer razor blades fen
realy dee cork |e Wie lade mat
ind they are’ the most rigid and comfortable
lades'on the market. I never use a holder, nor have
Thad any trouble from ths cause. In fact, the only
‘accident I ‘have ever had with @ razor Blade ‘wat
‘when T was misguided enough to try-a holder. The
hole ofa was so cms tha P inmadiately cut
‘When using the ordinary” slovted blade
Poreak chem into four piecet, and we the square
liner corner for citing. There is one important
Point to remember when using razor Blades,
Si not make heaty cut, theparé not svg enough,
‘After all, they are only supposed to cut whiskers!
Despite what we thought was a careful check two
errors slipped into the last issue, ‘The first. was
factual, we gave Mr. Dear as editor of the Historical
‘Model Railway Society Journal. In actual fact the
book is produced by a small editorial panel. ‘The
fault is ours entirely ; we tried to be clever and used
a bit of information we now find to be nothing more
than an inaccurate rumour, ‘The second mistake
‘concerns the captions to the photographs on pages
66 and 68. They have been reversed. ‘This is sheer
carelessness for which there is no excuse. None,
therefore, will be offered.
We are pleased to say that Mr. Garland’s “King”,
‘which, as we reported in the last issue of the Railway
Modeller, was stolen ftom the “Aquarium” at this
year’s Model Railway Club Exhibition has now been
recovered, due to the vigilance of a member of the
Model Railway Club.
IN OUR NEXT ISSUE
‘OO’ Layout for the average house.
The Linley, Melor & Sentor Railway.
*O' Gauge Standards.
Churston—G.W.R.
‘A Model Water Tower.
Advice Bureau.
Modeller’s Mailbag.
Place your Order now !poo We can recommend -~~~~~—}
Cecil F. Allen’s
THE LOCOMOTIVE
EXCHANGES
Second and Enlarged Edition
describes in detail the exchanges of Fully bound
locomotives which have taken place on 15/ = 200 pages
the railways of Britain since 1870, with
tables of running times and speeds
together with comments on the official
report of the 1948 Locomotive Exchange
trials. ‘The volume is fully illustrated
with a magnificent series of action shots,
by leading express train photographers.
Eric Treacy’s
STEAM UP
“STEAM UP” is a railway book “for
pleasure"; a book to conjure up all
the atmosphere of railways as you sit
t
i
i
i
i
!
|
i
i
with it by your fireside. In page after {
!
|
{
{
i
|
!
!
i
!
i
t
i
j
}
i
i
i
Ab
Fully bound
Size 10in.x7 in. 10/
page of peerless action photographs,
Eric Treacy captures all the life of
engines in motion. In a series of witty
essays he communicates his own feel-
ing for them in such a way as to
strike a responsive chord in every
teader—enthusiast and layman alike.
0. S. Nock’s *
BRITISH LOCOMOTIVES
FROM THE FOOTPL ATE
Mr, NOCK fascinatingly describes in 9 /6 wee
detail the many footplate trips he has
made on Britain's express engines over
the length and breadth of British Rail-
ways since the war. ‘This fine fully
pound book contains 256 pages which in-
clude 32 pages of excellent photographs.
BOOKS NO RAILWAY ENTHUSIAST SHOULD BE WITHOUT
Obteinable from your local bookstall or bookseller or direct from the publishersGEM for “00” GAUGE
RAIL TRACK
POPULAR PERMANENT WAY
‘TRITRAK = __ SIGNALS
COACH KITS - BOGIES
‘WAGON PARTS, Se, &e.
1951 Catalogue 73d. post free
GEORGE E. MELLOR (33?)
3la, RHOS ROAD
RHOS-ON-SEA, NORTH WALES
Trade Enquiries invited
TRAINS « BRITAIN
The most
J
~
inexpensive selection of
large-size railphoto reproductions yet
produced, All the well-known. rail
photographers have contributed to this
illustrated cross-section of British Rail-
ways’ train services and motive power,
which features fine action pictures,
several of them full page in this extra
size publication.
ae
40 pages superbly printed in Photo-
gravure, Four-colour art cover. Size
10k" X84", at the low price of:
2/6
NOW ON SALE
Obtainable from your local bookstall or
bookseller or direct’ from the publishers:
Sen Allan dtd
| 282 Yorn ABeiDee ROAD, S.W.1 |
KEN VIEW MODEL RAILWAY
Running daily, including Sundays, from II am. to.
9 pm. "OO" Exhibition Layout, 5 tracks.
Agents for all leoding Monufacturers—
00” scale Locomotives and equipment built
to order.
Expert advice freely given,
27 Broadway Parade,
Crouch End, N.8.
Tel.:
MOUntview 4859.
NEW EDITIONS Seam a
the Jan Gildan
; A.B.C. of BRITISH RAILWAYS
LOCOMOTIVES
Western Region 2s.
Southern Region ot lise es.
London Midland Region 2
Scottish (ex L.M.S.) Region = a
Eastern, North Eastern Region
Scottish (ex L.N.E.) Region
NOW ON SALE
at all bookstalls and bookshops or
direct from the publishers.
oe ee
%* TRAINS ANNUAL 1952 *
Now in course of production, and available
in the early autumn. ‘This years edition
entgine the teuat collection of sparing
attcles and photographs and an’ 8-pa
colour section” Printed in full photogravute.
ORDER YOUR COPY NOW
i
San lan did |
»=282 VAUXHALL BRIDGE ROAD, S.W.I +=}
{
i
i
2s. |
i
|
!
!
{
i
!
!
i
i
i
!
!
i
i
i
i
i
i
{
{
i
{
!
i
!
if
he
GAUGE “Oo”
SiR; 46,0,7, Loco LM.C.,
.S. 0-6-0 Hunslet Diesel
Loco poraone 47.0.0.
20. A.C. Hornby
as new, 5.1%
Clockwork Loco. 0-4-2 Saddle Tank
Crane Loco, L.M.S. Maroon finish,
£4, 0.0,
G.W.R. Corridor Coaches, good exterior
and corridor detail, 3rd and brake 3rd,
B. LENG eo
12 v. D.C.
4-4-2 Flying Scotsman
37/6 each. Restaurant Car, 40/-.
Lowke and other makes of tinplate
coaches.
Complete American Clockwork Set,
Whistling Loco, £4, 4. 0.
E. B. LENG
135 HOLLAND ROAD
HARLESDEN, N.W.10
STATION—WILLESDEN JUNCTION
E
|
!
{
{
!
{
{
!
{
{
i
{
!
!
Cccp a ac hiecitearer baa aateaS ae
|
|
{
|
|
|
PLEASE MENTION RAILWAY MODELLER WHEN WRITING TO ADVERTISERS
viTHE NEW 00 MOTOR UNIT
X3 ...FORONLY £l
clthis unit asthe
finest. valve fo
money in 00
motive power. Portage and
packing,
Esper motor
SPECIFICATION:
Alnico Magnet, -pole armature, Gat copper comm
itory. wound for 12 With an approximate
consuimption of 0.35 amps.” Complete with gearbox
Sidetrames and 40:1 constant mesh worm drive, with
the worm whee! siready fitted on in, ale knurled
each end {suitable for S-R wheels}; modellers wishing
fouse Romford or any other in, axle can replace the
Knurled axle by pressing i out and substituting tbe
fequited type. The gearbox sideframes, apart {rom
tcfuring perfect mesit male the unit deal for 8 fully
Spring chassis and in the case of anon-sprung chassis
or non-sprung driven ase, this type of motor ellmt
hates the need for securing screws and special seating.
ERG (Bournemouth) LTD
529, ROUMELIA LANE, BOSCOMBE, BOURNEMOUTH
Telephone! Boscombe $3431
Dealwith your local ERG Stochist wherever possible, but
unable fo obtain you reuirements ocaly, you eof
Course welcome to order direct from ‘is.
WRITE NOW
for this NEW
ENLARGED
CATALOGUE
Its 40. pages include
Model Locomotives in
British Railway colours.
Entirely New Models
and additional access-
ories, etc,
FESTIVAL
ACTIVITIES
Your Festival activities should includea visitto the
HOUSE OF PECO
situated in delightful surroundings by the. se
‘A welcome awaits you, and the opportunity
inspect our unique range of Quality products, in
the comfort of our showroom, where also test
track facilites are available. See how the Peco
tracks can be used with Hornby Dublo, Trix and
ger proprietary sytems ether PECO:WAY, the
HO and OO Asser
PECO:INDIVIDULAY, the > and
‘True-To-Type_ components,
G06 sad'Pr Gauge PEGOMINIEAY tacks,
PECO INSULAXLES, the famour metal ‘ai:
lated axle Whees, ROCHE | PROTOTYPE
ING: i hont of other wats pa
bot rpetiia. the’ demonstration at FECO.
SIMBLES AG TO-COUPLERS and DE.COUP-
LING UNITS. ‘These facilities are just pact of
fur before-and aftersales Advice Bureau Service,
free to all Peco users,
We do not sell direct (except literature)
but Peco products are obtainable feom
all good class recognised retailers.
Peco Catologue 1/3 post free.
BE RAILWISE — USE PECO
ITCHARD PATENT PRODUCT
BML ML
The most comprehensive Gauge
*O? Catalogue yet published.
Price still only I/- (quote ref. GO/108) from
BASSETT-LOWKE LTD.
NORTHAMPTON
LONDON: 112 High Holborn, W.C.I.
MANCHESTER: 28 Corporation Street.
PLEASE MENTION RAILWAY MODELLER WHEN WRITING TO ADVERTISERSLLAN [Bhett [Channon
f
! LTD.
i 4 ;
i ave pleasure in
i advertising their large stocks of model goods
i for the coming season
{ ORDER NOW for immediate or future delivery
before the metal shortage is really felt
i
|
! LOCOMOTIVES 0-4-0 Tank ... v — 63/-
i I RI X 0-40 Tender... ... 70/6
i American Switcher Kit 87/6
i do. (Made-up)... 100/-
j POINTS Hand... ... 37/6 | Train Sets from 1483/6
; Remote control 62/- | Flying Hamburger Unit 147/-
j also RAILS, ROLLING STOCK, CONTROLLERS, PERSONNEL,
!
l TRANSFORMERS, STATIONS, etc, etc, at I/3rd prices
|
LOCOMOTIVES 4-6-0... B4/-
! GRAHAM (Gaiety) WR 0-6-0T 69/10
! FARISH (Gaiety) ER 0-6-27 67/7
j TRACK (Bft.lengths) ... 4... Brass 7/I} Steel 4/35
Le POINTS — 2-rail turnouts on fibre base 919
! 3-rail turnouts on fibre base 11/6
! also 2-rail turnouts on built-up base ... we. 16/6
| CROSSOVERS, DOUBLE JUNCTIONS and OTHER
! POINTWORK, MADE UP TO ORDER
i and, of course, we still have plenty of
{ BULL-HEAD
ij OO GAUGE NICKEL SILVER RAIL
| in [8in. lengths at 6/9 per dozen
RR RAR RR RRR nn
t Agents for PECO, ERG, LMC, MILLS BROS., }
A ( ACRO, TRACKMASTER, etc, ————_
B|
1‘ }
PLEASE MENTION RAILWAY MODELLER WHEN WRITING TO ADVERTISERS
Printed by H. 0. Liove & Co., Lxp., London Nei
32 APPROACH RD. x LONDON BDG. STN., S.E.1
¢ 282 VAUXHALL BDG. RD. * LONDON, S.W.1