Job Analysis and Design Overview
Job Analysis and Design Overview
Designing Jobs
Major HR concerns:
Employee productivity
Job satisfaction
Job design (JD) – determines how work is
performed & greatly affects how an employee
feels about a job, how much authority an
Job Design in Practice: Organizational Demands New Organizational Approaches
Strategy Total quality management (TQM)
Managerial choices of job design tactics Focuses on the quality of all the processes that
Employee acceptance of job design lead to the final product or service
decisions To be successful it requires support of top
Company characteristics management & the belief that quality is a key
Perception of fairness of job duties part of every employee’s job
Need for flexible work arrangements Customer focus in the process of designing and
Culture improving quality
Job Design Approach Adopted Proper implementation requires a clear vision
Breadth of tasks, duties, and & support of top management and a focus on
responsibilities performed results NOT the process
Employee concerns
Formalization of jobs The Office Environment
Breath and depth of tasks Work environment (space, workstations, light
etc) affects employee morale, productivity and
Job Design in Practice: Environmental Demands quality, absenteeism & turnover
Labor force Creativity can happen anywhere
Skill availability to perform tasks Retain the services of an architect or design
Job design decisions for the aging labor consultant
force
Technology Robotics
Telecommuting The use of robots to perform routine tasks
Virtual teams Industrial robots:
Globalization Anthropomorphic (approximate the
Need to address cross-cultural issues appearance and functions of humans)
Relevant labor market Nonanthropomorphic (machine-like and
Ethics/social responsibility have limited functions)
Concerns about types of tasks required First-generation robots – performed simple jobs
Attitudes toward physical conditions of job and had limited capabilities
design Second-generation robots – built with senses,
vision or touch, making them more adaptable
Job Design in Practice: Regulatory Issues New robots – perform most of the drilling,
Importance of understanding essential and non- shaping & bending tasks previously performed
essential job duties by robots
Job design and employee safety
Ergonomics
Taking into account the human factor in
designing the employee’s workstation
Relationship between the employees and their
workstations – machines used, lighting, noise,
chairs etc, these can affect productivity
IBM Employee handbook identifies the
following:
Posture
Back
Hand
Environment
Productivity Measures
Quantity or volume produced
Accurate measure of productivity is vital to
organisational improvement effort
Gain competitive advantage
Strategies to improve productivity & quality Investigates:
Depends on employee seeing a link Levels of decision-making
between what they produce & what the Skills employees need to do a job
company is attempting to achieve adequately
What will work for one company may not Autonomy of the job
for another Mental effort required to perform the job
Machines operated, reports completed &
Organisations must be careful not to measure special financial/other responsibilities
the wrong things or overlook those that are Working conditions (levels of temperature,
critical to success light etc)
Merely implementing quality techniques,
including employee empowerment and Job Analysis
benchmarking will not produce benefits Definition: Systematically identifying tasks, duties
Productivity is the relationship between what is and responsibilities expected to be performed in a
put into a piece of work (input) and what is job as well as competencies to be successful
yielded (output) Job descriptions — written summaries of the
specific tasks, responsibilities, and working
conditions of a job
Job specifications — specific competencies
required by a jobholder to be able to perform
the job successfully
Job descriptions generally should contain a Poor Hiring Practices Lead to:
complete identification of the job and its Strategic objectives cannot be met due to
location within the organisation. The section on resource constraints.
duties and responsibilities should group all High turnover
tasks into major functional categories, and each High legal risks
entry should begin with verbs. Job Damage to org reputation
specifications should include all SKAs needed Discrimination (informal practices: whether
to perform the job, as well as other minimum intentional or not)
qualifications. Difficulty building an inclusive workplace
Org culture slow to catch up to societal changes
RECRUITMENT: ATTRACTING THE
RIGHT TALENTS Example of a decent hiring process
(Candidate Perspective)
What is the recruitment? Establish minimum qualifications
The generation of an applicant pool to provide Complete application
the required number of candidates for selection Complete written exams
or promotion. Screening interview
Second interview
Selection Background investigation
The choice of job candidates from a previously Selection panel
generated applicant pool for a position or job in Psychological/medical exam
order to provide the required number of
candidates for a subsequent selection or HR ROLE
promotion program. The role of Human Resources (HR) within an
organization is vital for managing and
Best Practices for Recruitment and Selection supporting the workforce to achieve the
company's goals and objectives.
HR professionals are responsible for a wide 3. Non-traditional candidates have often
range of tasks and functions that contribute to navigated unconventional paths, demonstrating
the overall success of the organization. adaptability, resilience, and a willingness to
Overall, the HR role is multifaceted and learn. These qualities can be highly beneficial
requires a combination of interpersonal, in dynamic work environments
organizational, and strategic skills. HR 4. Embracing non-traditional candidates
professionals play a critical role in fostering a challenges societal stereotypes and biases,
positive work culture, developing employees, promoting inclusivity and equal opportunity.
and ensuring the organization's compliance This can contribute to a more equitable
with employment laws and regulations. workplace and educational system.
Advantages
Diversity of Thought and Experience Implications
Skill Transferability Education
Increased Adaptability Employment
Breaking Stereotypes Innovation
Policy Changes
1. Non-traditional candidates bring diverse In conclusion, the inclusion of non-traditional
perspectives and life experiences that can candidates can bring about numerous benefits
enrich discussions, problem-solving, and to education, the workforce, and society as a
innovation. Their unique viewpoints can lead to whole. By recognizing the value of diverse
creative solutions and approaches that might experiences and skill sets, we can create more
not have been considered otherwise. inclusive and innovative environments that
2. Non-traditional candidates might possess skills celebrate individuality and promote growth
and experiences from different fields that can
be valuable in unexpected ways. These skills 1. In the realm of education, considering non-
can be transferred to the new role, offering traditional candidates could involve
fresh insights and capabilities. recognizing prior learning experiences,
accepting alternative credentials, and designing
flexible educational pathways to accommodate These candidates are often considered valuable
diverse learners. potential hires because they may bring a strong
2. Companies that embrace non-traditional track record of success, specific expertise, and
candidates can benefit from a more diverse a demonstrated commitment to their current
workforce, leading to increased innovation, roles.
better problem-solving, and improved Simply put, Active=Keen while
employee satisfaction. Passive=Reserved
3. Non-traditional candidates often bring fresh
perspectives that can lead to breakthroughs in Active candidates are individuals who are
industries. By encouraging their inclusion, currently seeking new job opportunities and are
organizations can foster a culture of innovation. actively engaged in the job search process.
4. Governments and institutions may need to These candidates are actively applying for
adapt policies and regulations to acknowledge positions, submitting their resumes to job
and support non-traditional candidates, boards, networking, and possibly working with
ensuring equal access to opportunities recruiters to find a suitable role.
regardless of background. A balanced recruitment strategy that includes
both active and passive candidate engagement
External Recruiting can help organizations find the best-fit talent to
External recruiting, also known as external meet their current and future needs.
hiring or external recruitment, is the process of
seeking and attracting candidates for job Job Postings/Vacancy Announcement
vacancies or positions within an organization Job postings are formal announcements or
from outside the company. In other words, it advertisements created by employers to inform
involves bringing in new employees who are potential candidates about job vacancies within
not currently employed by the organization to their organization.
fill open positions. These postings provide detailed information
External recruiting typically involves a range of about the job role, responsibilities,
strategies and activities aimed at identifying, qualifications, benefits, and application
attracting, and selecting suitable candidates process.
from the external job market. Job postings serve as a crucial tool for
External recruiting offers several advantages, attracting and engaging both active and passive
such as bringing in fresh perspectives, new candidates who are interested in exploring new
skills, and diverse experiences from outside the employment opportunities.
organization. Aside from a long list of requirements that the
candidates must possess, great job postings can
also include the following details;
What’s great about the company
Attracting the Best Talent Career paths
Develop a good Strategy to succeed in your Benefits
goal. A realistic idea of the type of work they’ll be
Offer great perks and compensation doing
Build a strong employer brand
Make team building a priority Incentives
Outperform your competitors It is a contingent motivator.
Create an awesome company culture It is a thing that motivates or encourages
Promote candidates internally. someone to do something.
Such approaches include employee referrals
Targeting Passive or Active Candidates and sign-on bonuses
Targeting passive candidates refers to the
strategic approach of identifying and engaging Boomerang Employees
individuals who are currently employed and not It is a term used to describe individuals who
actively seeking new job opportunities, but leave an organization for a period of time and
who possess the skills, experience, and then return to work for the same company later
qualities desired by your organization. on. This phenomenon has become more
prevalent in recent years as the job market and to negative experiences or conflicts, those
employment dynamics have evolved issues might resurface upon their return.
2. While boomerang employees might bring new
Reasons why organizations might consider skills, they might also need to catch up on any
hiring Boomerang Employees changes that occurred in the industry or within
Familiarity and Experience the company during their absence.
Skillset and Knowledge 3. Teams and dynamics within the company
Reduced Recruitment Costs might have changed since the employee's
Employee Loyalty and Engagement departure. Reintegration and rebuilding
Company Culture relationships can take time and effort.
4. Hiring boomerang employees could lead to
1. Boomerang employees are already familiar concerns from existing employees who might
with the company's culture, processes, and wonder why a former colleague is being
expectations. This can lead to a quicker brought back instead of hiring from outside.
integration and reduced training time compared
to hiring new employees from scratch. Internal Recruiting
2. These individuals may have gained new skills, It refers to the practice of filling job vacancies
experiences, or knowledge during their time and open positions within a company by
away from the company. When they return, considering and selecting candidates who are
they can bring fresh perspectives and ideas that already current employees of the organization.
can benefit the organization. Instead of hiring new candidates from outside
3. Hiring new employees can be expensive in the company, internal recruiting focuses on
terms of recruitment efforts, onboarding, and identifying and promoting existing employees
training. Boomerang employees can help to higher or different roles.
reduce these costs since they already have a
baseline understanding of the company. Various forms of Internal Recruiting
4. The willingness of a former employee to return Promotions
to a company might indicate a strong sense of Transfer
loyalty and positive feelings towards the Lateral Moves
organization. This can contribute to higher Temporary Assignments
employee engagement and satisfaction Job Postings and Internal Job Boards
5. Boomerang employees can help maintain and
reinforce the company's culture, values, and 1. Moving employees to higher-level positions
traditions since they are already familiar with with increased responsibilities, often as a
them. reward for their performance and potential.
2. Shifting employees to different departments,
Challenges and Considerations teams, or locations to provide them with new
Reason for Departure challenges and experiences
Change in Skills 3. Moving employees to roles with similar levels
Reintegration and Relationships of responsibility and status, often to provide
Perceived Fairness them with a broader skillset or different
Overall, the decision to hire boomerang experiences
employees depends on the specific 4. Assigning employees to special projects, task
circumstances of the organization and the forces, or temporary roles that allow them to
individual in question. When considering contribute in different ways.
rehiring former employees, companies should 5. Posting job openings within the company and
weigh the potential benefits against the allowing current employees to apply for these
challenges and carefully assess whether the positions.
individual's skills, experiences, and motivations
align with the company's current needs and Benefits of Internal Recruiting
goals. Cost Savings
Knowledge and Familiarity
1. It's important to understand why the employee Motivation and Morale
left in the first place. If their departure was due Retention
Reduced Risk
internal mobility can offer several benefits that
1. Internal recruiting can reduce the costs contribute to the overall success and well-being
associated with external recruitment, such as of both the employees and the company.
advertising, interviewing, and onboarding
2. Internal candidates are already familiar with Importance of Internal Mobility
the company's culture, policies, and processes, Employee Development and Growth
which can lead to quicker and smoother Talent Retention
transitions. Skills Diversification
3. The opportunity for career advancement within Succession Planning
the organization can boost employee morale Cultural Cohesion
and motivation Cost Savings
4. Providing growth opportunities can help retain Employee Engagement
talented employees who might otherwise seek Adapting to Change
opportunities elsewhere Workforce Diversity and Inclusion
5. Since internal candidates are known entities,
there is typically less risk associated with their 1. Internal mobility provides employees with
performance and fit within the company opportunities to learn new skills, take on new
challenges, and expand their knowledge.
Considerations for Internal Recruiting 2. Allowing employees to explore different roles
Fairness and Transparency within the company can help retain valuable
Skills and Fit talent.
Skills Development 3. Moving employees across different roles and
Fresh Perspectives departments can result in a more skilled and
Backfilling adaptable workforce
Internal recruiting can be a valuable strategy 4. Internal mobility facilitates the identification
for organizations to develop and retain their and development of potential future leaders
talent pool, align employee career paths with within the organization
organizational goals, and foster a culture of 5. Employees who have experienced different
growth and opportunity. However, it should be parts of the organization can have a broader
balanced with external recruitment to ensure a understanding of the company's culture, values,
diverse and dynamic workforce and operations
6. Internal mobility can be more cost-effective
1. Organizations must ensure that internal than external recruitment. Hiring and
recruitment processes are fair, transparent, and onboarding new employees from outside the
offer equal opportunities for all eligible organization often involve higher costs
employees. compared to promoting or transferring existing
2. While internal candidates have institutional employees.
knowledge, their skills and fit for the new role 7. Providing employees with the chance to
should also be evaluated objectively explore different roles and contribute to various
3. Some roles might require additional training or projects can increase their sense of ownership
skill development for internal candidates to and engagement in their work.
succeed in their new positions. 8. In a rapidly changing business environment,
4. Internal candidates might bring pre-existing internal mobility can help organizations adapt
biases or habits from their previous roles, by quickly shifting talent to areas of strategic
which could limit fresh perspectives. importance.
5. Promoting an employee to a new role might 9. Employees who move between roles can bring
create a vacancy that needs to be filled, valuable insights and best practices from one
requiring additional recruitment efforts area of the organization to another, fostering a
culture of continuous improvement.
Internal Mobility- Is it Necessary?
Internal mobility refers to the practice of New Approaches
allowing employees to move between different There are several approaches to internal
roles, departments, or positions within an mobility that organizations can adopt to
organization. While it might not be considered facilitate the movement of employees between
absolutely necessary for every organization, different roles, departments, or positions within
the company. The choice of approach will individuals are outgoing, energetic, and often
depend on the organization's goals, culture, and seek social stimulation. Introverted individuals
specific needs. Here are some common are more reserved and tend to prefer solitude or
approaches to consider: smaller social gatherings.
Internal Job Posting Agreeableness: Agreeableness refers to an
Nomination individual's interpersonal tendencies, including
Knowledge, skills and abilities database their kindness, empathy, cooperativeness, and
Succession Planning consideration of others. High agreeableness
individuals are usually warm, compassionate,
Chapter 4: Selection, Placement and Job Fit and value harmony, while low agreeableness
Factors to Consider in Candidate Selection individuals might be more assertive and
Skill competitive.
Personality Neuroticism (Emotional Stability): Neuroticism
Desire measures emotional stability and the tendency
Attitude to experience negative emotions such as
1. Ensure that candidates possess the necessary anxiety, stress, and sadness. People high in
skills, qualifications, and experience required neuroticism may be more prone to mood
for the job. Evaluate their educational swings and emotional reactivity, while those
background, certifications, and relevant work low in neuroticism tend to remain calm under
experience. pressure.
2. When selecting a candidate for a job,
considering their personality traits and Self-Efficacy vs. Self-Esteem: What’s the
characteristics is important, as it can impact Difference?
their fit within the organization and their ability Self-efficacy and self-esteem are both
to perform well in the role. important psychological concepts that relate to
3. When selecting a candidate for a job, an individual's perception of themselves, but
considering their desire or motivation is an they refer to different aspects of self-
important aspect of the evaluation process. perception.
Candidate desire or motivation can greatly Self-Efficacy: Self-efficacy refers to an
impact their performance, commitment, and individual's belief in their own ability to
overall fit within the organization. accomplish specific tasks, achieve goals, or
4. Consider the candidate's work ethic, attitude, perform well in various situations. It's tied to
and motivation. Look for candidates who are the perception of one's competence in specific
enthusiastic, adaptable, and willing to areas and is influenced by past experiences,
contribute positively to the workplace feedback, and mastery of skills. Self-efficacy is
environment. more task-specific and context-dependent.