Public International Law Assignment

Under the guidance

Of
Professor Joseph Jobi

Submitted By: Kunal Dalvi

Roll no: 213018

Class: T.Y. LL.B

Signature:

1
 Index
Sr. no Content Page no
1. The role of U.N.C.L.O.S in 4-9
peaceful settlement of
disputes & resolving
disputes
2. The rights given to children 10-12
as per the convention of
rights of children
3. The special provisions in 13-16
Indian Constitution for the
upliftment of women.
Explain with help of land
mark judgment
4. The term state & 17-21
enumerate on different
kinds of state
5. The evolution of public 22-24
international law & explain
the role of U.N in
maintaining peace & order
of the world
6. The term territory & 25-28
different modes of
acquisition & loss of
territory
7. Universal declaration of 29-30
human rights
8. Vienna convention of law of 30-31
treaty

9. Peaceful settlements of 32-33

disputes
10. Directive principle & human 33-34
rights

11. U.N environment 35-36

programme

12. Amnesty international 36-37

2
 Group D

Long Questions

Q.1) Explain the role of U.N.C.L.O.S in peaceful settlement of disputes & resolving
disputes?

Q.2) Discuss the rights given to children as per the convention of rights of children?

Q.3) Explain the special provisions in Indian Constitution for the upliftment of women.
Explain with help of land mark judgment?

Q.4) Explain the term state & enumerate on different kinds of state?

Q.5) Explain the evolution of public international law & explain the role of U.N in
maintaining peace & order of the world?

Q.6) Explain the term territory & different modes of acquisition & loss of territory?

Short Questions

1. Universal declaration of human rights

2. Vienna convention of law of treaty

3. Peaceful settlements of disputes

4. Directive principle & human rights

5. U.N environment programme

6. Amnesty international

3
 Long Answers

Q1. Explain the role of U.N.C.L.O.S in peaceful settlement of disputes & resolving
disputes?

The United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS) is an international
treaty that establishes a comprehensive legal framework for the use and protection of
the world's oceans and their resources. It defines the rights and responsibilities of
countries regarding maritime boundaries, navigation, exploitation of marine resources,
and environmental protection. UNCLOS aims to promote peaceful cooperation among
nations and prevent conflicts over maritime issues by providing a set of rules and
guidelines for the use and management of the oceans and their resources.

UNCLOS plays a significant role in the peaceful settlement of disputes and resolving
conflicts related to maritime issues. It provides a framework for nations to resolve
disagreements through diplomatic means rather than resorting to force. The treaty
encourages countries to use peaceful mechanisms to address disputes, including
negotiation, mediation, arbitration, and adjudication.

One key mechanism under UNCLOS is the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea
(ITLOS), which provides a forum for parties to resolve disputes related to the
interpretation and application of the convention. The tribunal can issue binding
decisions on cases brought before it, helping to resolve conflicts and clarify maritime
rights.

Additionally, UNCLOS emphasizes the importance of good faith negotiations and

encourages countries to establish bilateral and regional agreements to settle disputes. It
provides a platform for nations to cooperate and engage in dialogue, helping to prevent
tensions from escalating into conflicts.

Overall, UNCLOS promotes the rule of law in maritime matters and offers a structured
approach to peacefully resolve disputes, fostering stability and cooperation among
nations sharing oceanic resources and boundaries.

4
Certainly, here are some additional points about the role of UNCLOS in peaceful
settlement of disputes and resolving conflicts:

1. Compulsory Dispute Settlement Mechanisms: UNCLOS offers compulsory

dispute settlement mechanisms, requiring parties to engage in negotiations and
other peaceful means before resorting to more aggressive actions. This helps
prevent conflicts and encourages dialogue.

2. Arbitration: UNCLOS provides for binding arbitration to resolve disputes related to

the interpretation and application of the convention. Arbitral tribunals can be
established by parties to a dispute, ensuring an impartial resolution process.

3. Advisory Opinions: UNCLOS allows parties to request advisory opinions from

ITLOS on legal questions related to the convention. This contributes to clarifying
legal uncertainties and assisting parties in finding peaceful solutions.

4. Prevention of Escalation: By providing a clear legal framework for maritime

activities and boundaries, UNCLOS helps prevent conflicts from arising in the first
place. Countries are more likely to engage in peaceful discussions when the rules
are well-defined.

5. Preservation of Marine Environment: UNCLOS encourages countries to

cooperate in the protection and preservation of the marine environment. Disputes
related to environmental concerns can be resolved through negotiation and
cooperation, fostering peaceful solutions.

6. Promotion of Diplomacy: The convention promotes the use of diplomacy and

dialogue to address differences. By establishing guidelines and rules for
negotiations, UNCLOS supports a structured approach to resolving disputes.

7. Strengthening International Cooperation: UNCLOS fosters international

cooperation by promoting the joint development and management of shared
maritime resources, leading to mutually beneficial outcomes rather than conflicts.

8. Contributing to Regional Stability: UNCLOS helps maintain stability within regions

by offering a framework for neighboring countries to establish maritime boundaries
and cooperate in managing resources, reducing the potential for tensions.

9. Binding Decisions: Decisions made through ITLOS or other dispute settlement

mechanisms established under UNCLOS are binding on the parties involved,
ensuring that agreed-upon resolutions are followed.

5
10. Preserving Freedom of Navigation: UNCLOS safeguards the principle of freedom
of navigation, contributing to peaceful interactions between countries and preventing
conflicts that may arise from restrictions on navigation.

In essence, UNCLOS provides a comprehensive framework that encourages peaceful

dialogue, legal resolution, and cooperation among nations, reducing the likelihood of
disputes escalating into conflicts and promoting stability in maritime affairs.

Of course, here are some additional aspects regarding the role of UNCLOS in peaceful
settlement of disputes and conflict resolution:

1. Promoting Predictability: UNCLOS establishes clear rules and procedures for

various maritime activities, including navigation, resource exploitation, and boundary
delimitation. This predictability helps prevent misunderstandings and disagreements,
contributing to peaceful relations.

2. Avoiding Unilateral Actions: The convention discourages unilateral actions that

could lead to conflicts, such as unilateral exploitation of marine resources or
establishment of artificial islands. Instead, it encourages parties to collaborate and seek
mutually acceptable solutions.

3. Customary International Law: Many provisions of UNCLOS have become

customary international law, even for countries that are not parties to the treaty. This
means that the principles outlined in UNCLOS guide the behavior of nations, further
promoting peaceful interactions.

4. Enhancing Trust: UNCLOS fosters trust among nations by offering a neutral

platform for resolving disputes. Parties have confidence in the impartiality of
mechanisms like ITLOS, leading to more willingness to engage in peaceful resolution
efforts.

5. Balancing National Interests: UNCLOS strikes a balance between the interests of

coastal states and those of maritime users. This balance is critical in preventing conflicts
over issues such as resource exploitation and navigation rights.

6. Addressing Historical Claims: UNCLOS provides a framework for addressing

historical claims to maritime areas. By establishing clear criteria for maritime boundary
delimitation, the convention helps resolve long-standing disputes that could otherwise
lead to conflict.

6
7. Promoting Regional Cooperation: The convention encourages countries within the
same region to cooperate in the management of shared resources and the settlement of
disputes. This regional approach contributes to stability and peaceful coexistence.

8. Ensuring Legal Certainty: UNCLOS contributes to legal certainty by defining terms,

rights, and obligations related to maritime activities. This clarity reduces the potential for
disputes arising from differing interpretations of international law.

9. Human Rights and Safety: UNCLOS emphasizes the safety of human life at sea
and the protection of the marine environment. By addressing issues such as search and
rescue operations and pollution prevention, the convention reduces potential sources of
conflict.

10. Capacity Building: UNCLOS supports capacity building in developing countries,

helping them participates effectively in negotiations and dispute resolution processes.
This inclusiveness promotes global stability and peaceful outcomes.

In summary, UNCLOS serves as a cornerstone of international law, guiding nations in

their interactions on the oceans and fostering a culture of cooperation and diplomacy.
Its provisions and mechanisms contribute to preventing conflicts, resolving disputes,
and promoting peaceful and sustainable use of maritime resources.

Certainly, here are more detailed insights into the role of UNCLOS in peaceful
settlement of disputes and resolving conflicts:

1. Exclusive Economic Zones (EEZs): UNCLOS defines the concept of EEZs, giving
coastal states exclusive rights to explore and exploit marine resources within a certain
distance from their shores. This clear demarcation reduces conflicts over resource
exploitation in shared areas.

2. Continental Shelf: The convention outlines principles for the delimitation of the
continental shelf, which helps avoid disputes over overlapping claims and ensures fair
access to underwater resources.

3. Transboundary Pollution: UNCLOS addresses issues of pollution from land-based

sources and vessels, promoting cooperation among countries to prevent and mitigate
pollution. This collaborative approach reduces potential conflicts stemming from
environmental harm.

7
4. Fishing Disputes: The convention provides a framework for the conservation and
management of fishery resources, reducing tensions over fishing activities in shared
waters and ensuring sustainable practices.

5. Dispute Resolution Timeframes: UNCLOS specifies timeframes for different stages

of dispute resolution processes, such as submitting claims and responding to
notifications. This helps expedite the resolution of conflicts and prevents unnecessary
delays.

6. State Responsibility: UNCLOS establishes principles of state responsibility for

wrongful acts that could harm other countries or the marine environment. This
encourages countries to take preventive measures, reducing the chances of disputes.

7. Customary Practices: UNCLOS codifies certain customary practices that had been
followed even before the treaty's adoption. This recognition of existing practices helps
maintain stability and predictability in maritime interactions.

8. Amicable Settlement: The convention encourages parties to seek amicable

settlements through negotiation or other peaceful means, emphasizing the importance
of finding mutually acceptable solutions.

9. Follow-up on Decisions: Parties are required to comply with decisions of ITLOS or

other dispute settlement mechanisms established under UNCLOS. This ensures that
conflicts are resolved conclusively and that resolutions are implemented.

10. Promoting Sustainable Development: UNCLOS encourages countries to manage

and exploit marine resources in a manner that ensures their long-term sustainability.
This approach minimizes conflicts arising from overexploitation.

11. Freedom of Scientific Research: The convention promotes the freedom of

scientific research in marine areas, contributing to peaceful cooperation among nations
in the exploration and study of the oceans.

12. Principles of Equitable Sharing: UNCLOS promotes equitable sharing of benefits

from marine resources, fostering cooperation and preventing conflicts over the
distribution of economic gains.

13. Regional Fisheries Management Organizations: The convention allows for the
establishment of regional organizations to manage and conserve fishery resources.
These organizations facilitate cooperation and conflict resolution among countries
sharing fish stocks.

8
In essence, UNCLOS offers a comprehensive framework that covers a wide range of
maritime activities and potential sources of conflict. By providing clear rules,
mechanisms for dispute resolution, and avenues for cooperation, the convention plays a
crucial role in ensuring peaceful interactions and preventing conflicts in the world's
oceans.

Q2. Discuss the rights given to children as per the convention of rights of
children

The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) is an international treaty that outlines
the rights of children. It was adopted by the United Nations General Assembly in 1989
and has been ratified by almost all UN member states. The CRC recognizes various
rights for children, including the right to life, survival, and development, the right to
protection from violence and abuse, the right to education, the right to participate in
decisions affecting them, and the right to express their opinions. These rights

9
emphasize the importance of a child's well-being, protection, and active involvement in
matters that concern them.

Certainly! The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) consists of 54 articles that
comprehensively address the rights and needs of children. Here are some key rights
outlined in the CRC:

1. Right to Life, Survival, and Development: Children have the right to a standard of
living adequate for their physical, mental, spiritual, moral, and social development.

2. Non-Discrimination: Children are entitled to all the rights in the CRC without any
discrimination based on race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion,
national or social origin, property, birth, or other status.

3. Best Interests of the Child: All actions concerning children must prioritize their best
interests.

4. Parental Care and Protection: Children have the right to parental care, and
governments must provide appropriate assistance to parents and legal guardians in
fulfilling their responsibilities.

5. Freedom of Expression: Children have the right to express their views freely on all
matters affecting them, and their opinions should be given due weight according to
their age and maturity.

6. Protection from Violence and Abuse: Children have the right to protection from all
forms of physical or mental violence, injury, abuse, neglect, or exploitation.

7. Right to Education: Children have the right to education that aims at developing
their personality, talents, and abilities to the fullest potential.

8. Right to Health: Children have the right to the highest attainable standard of health,
including access to healthcare services and facilities.

9. Right to Play and Leisure: Children have the right to engage in play, recreational
activities, and cultural life.

10. Freedom of Thought, Conscience, and Religion: Children have the right to
freedom of thought, conscience, and religion, and this right should be respected by
parents and guardians.

10
11. Protection of Privacy: Children's privacy should be respected, and information
about their private life should not be unlawfully or arbitrarily interfered with.

12. Participation: Children have the right to participate in decisions that affect them,
and their opinions should be given due consideration in accordance with their age
and maturity.

These are just a few examples of the rights outlined in the CRC. The convention
provides a comprehensive framework to ensure the well-being, protection, and
development of children globally. It emphasizes the importance of recognizing children
as active members of society with their own rights and perspectives.

Of course, here are a few more rights outlined in the Convention on the Rights of the
Child (CRC):

1. Protection from Economic Exploitation: Children have the right to be protected

from economic exploitation, including child labor and any work that is hazardous or
interferes with their education.

2. Protection of Identity: Children have the right to a name, nationality, and family ties
from birth.

3. Right to Family Unity: Children have the right to live with their parents and not be
separated from them against their will, except when it is deemed in their best interests.

4. Protection of Children in Armed Conflict: Children have the right to special

protection in times of armed conflict, including protection from recruitment into armed
forces.

5. Right to Cultural Identity: Children belonging to indigenous or minority groups have

the right to practice their own culture, religion, and language.

6. Access to Information: Children have the right to access information from a variety
of sources and in a variety of formats, while also being protected from harmful
information.

7. Right to Adequate Standard of Living: Children have the right to an adequate

standard of living to ensure their physical, mental, spiritual, moral, and social
development.

11
8. Protection of Children Without Family: Children who cannot be looked after by
their own family have the right to special protection and assistance provided by the
government.

9. Children with Disabilities: Children with disabilities have the right to enjoy a full and
decent life in conditions that ensure their dignity, promote their self-reliance, and
facilitate their active participation in the community.

The Convention on the Rights of the Child is a landmark treaty that sets out a
comprehensive framework for the rights and protection of children. Its principles
continue to guide policies, laws, and practices across the world to ensure the well-being
and development of children in every society.

Q3. Explain the special provisions in Indian Constitution for the upliftment of
women. Explain with help of land mark judgment

The Indian Constitution contains several provisions aimed at the upliftment of women.
One key provision is Article 15(3), which allows the State to make special provisions for
women and children. This empowers the government to create policies and programs
that address the unique challenges faced by women.

A landmark judgment related to women's upliftment is Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan

(1997). In this case, the Supreme Court of India recognized the need to address sexual
harassment at the workplace and laid down guidelines to prevent and address such

12
incidents. This judgment highlighted the importance of creating a safe and gender-
sensitive work environment for women.

Additionally, Article 39(a) and (d) of the Directive Principles of State Policy emphasize
that the State shall work to secure equal pay for equal work and ensure that women are
not subjected to exploitation. The Maternity Benefit Act, 1961, is another example of a
legislative measure designed to support working women by providing maternity leave
and benefits.

These provisions and judgments reflect the Indian Constitution's commitment to gender
equality and the upliftment of women by addressing various aspects of their lives,
including education, employment, and social well-being.

Certainly! Here are some more provisions and landmark judgments in the Indian
Constitution that contribute to the upliftment of women:

Provisions:

1. Article 14: Provides for equality before the law and equal protection of the law for all
citizens, irrespective of gender. This forms the basis for challenging discriminatory
practices.

2. Article 15(1): Prohibits discrimination on the grounds of sex, among other factors.
This ensures that women are protected from any form of gender-based
discrimination.

3. Article 15(4): Allows the State to make special provisions for the advancement of
socially and educationally backward classes of citizens, including women.
4. Article 39: Includes various principles, such as securing equal pay for equal work
and ensuring that women are not exploited. It emphasizes the importance of
securing adequate means of livelihood for all citizens.

5. Article 42: Stipulates that the State shall make provisions for securing just and
humane conditions of work and maternity relief for women.

Certainly, the Indian Constitution contains several special provisions aimed at the
upliftment of women. These provisions recognize the historical and social
disadvantages faced by women and seek to ensure their equal participation and
empowerment. Some of these provisions include:

13
1. Article 15(3): This clause allows the State to make special provisions for women
and children. It empowers the government to create policies and programs that
promote the welfare and advancement of women, addressing their unique needs
and challenges.

2. Article 39(a) and (d): These Directive Principles of State Policy emphasize equal
pay for equal work and protection against exploitation. They aim to secure economic
justice for women and prevent discrimination in employment.

3. Article 42: This directive principle emphasizes the State's responsibility to provide
just and humane working conditions and maternity relief for women. It recognizes
the importance of supporting working mothers and protecting their rights.

4. Article 51A(e): One of the fundamental duties of every citizen is to promote

harmony and the spirit of common brotherhood amongst all the people of India,
transcending religious, linguistic, and regional or sectional diversities. This helps in
fostering a more inclusive and respectful society for women.

5. Reservation: While not a specific provision in the Constitution, the policy of

reservation for women in local government bodies (Panchayats and Municipalities)
has been a significant step. As per the 73rd and 74th Amendments, one-third of the
seats are reserved for women, ensuring their direct participation in decision-making
at the grassroots level.

6. Laws and Acts: Various laws have been enacted to protect women's rights and
interests. For example, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act (2005),
the Maternity Benefit Act (1961), and the Sexual Harassment of Women at
Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition, and Redressal) Act (2013) are some legislation
that addresses specific issues faced by women.

These special provisions reflect the Indian Constitution's commitment to gender equality
and the upliftment of women by addressing various dimensions of their lives, including
education, employment, social status, and overall well-being.

Certainly, here are some more special provisions in the Indian Constitution for the
upliftment of women:

1. Article 15(4): This clause empowers the State to make special provisions for the
advancement of socially and educationally backward classes, which includes
women. It enables the government to provide targeted support to uplift women from
marginalized sections.

14
2. Article 46: This directive principle promotes the educational and economic interests
of Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and other weaker sections, with a focus on
protecting women and children from exploitation.

3. Article 243D and 243T: These provisions, as per the 73rd and 74th Amendments,
ensure one-third reservation for women in local government bodies (Panchayats and
Municipalities). This helps enhance women's political representation and
involvement in grassroots governance.

4. Article 243G and 243W: These provisions mandate the reservation of seats for
women in the Panchayats and Municipalities in Scheduled Areas, aiming to
empower women in tribal regions.

5. Article 325 and 326: These articles ensure that no person is to be disqualified from
voting or being a candidate in elections on grounds of gender. This promotes equal
political participation for women.

6. National Commission for Women (NCW): Although not a constitutional provision,

the NCW was established in 1992 to safeguard and promote the rights of women. It
plays a vital role in advocating for women's rights and addressing their concerns.

7. Protection of Women's Rights: The Constitution provides for protection against

specific practices that discriminate against women, such as the abolition of
"untouchability" (Article 17) and the prohibition of forced labor (Article 23), both of
which can have a positive impact on women's lives.
These provisions collectively demonstrate the Indian Constitution's commitment to
addressing gender inequality and promoting the upliftment of women by addressing
various aspects of their social, economic, and political conditions.

15
Q4. Explain the term state & enumerate on different kinds of state

In international law, the term "state" refers to a recognized political entity that possesses
a defined territory, a permanent population, a government, and the capacity to engage
in relations with other states. States are the primary actors in the international legal
system and are endowed with legal personality, which allows them to enter into treaties,
engage in diplomatic relations, and participate in international organizations.

There are several different kinds of states in international law, each with its own distinct
characteristics and status. Here are some of the main categories:

1. Sovereign States: These are the traditional and most recognized type of states in
international law. They possess full sovereignty over their territory and are
recognized as equals in the international community. Examples include the United
States, France, China, and Brazil.

16
2. Microstates: These are extremely small states in terms of both population and
territory. Examples include Liechtenstein, Monaco, and Nauru. While they have the
same legal status as larger states, their small size can sometimes impact their
influence in international affairs.

3. Failed States: These are states that have lost effective control over their territory
and are unable to provide basic services to their population. Somalia and South
Sudan are often cited as examples of failed states. The concept of failed states
highlights the challenges of maintaining stability and governance within a country's
borders.

4. De Facto States: These are entities that function as states within a specific territory,
but their sovereignty is not universally recognized. They often emerge from conflicts
and seek independence from an existing state. Examples include Abkhazia,
Transnistria, and Northern Cyprus.

5. Unrecognized States: These are entities that have declared independence but are
not recognized as sovereign states by the majority of the international community.
They may have some level of control over their territory and a functioning
government, but their status is often a subject of dispute. Somaliland and Taiwan fall
into this category.

6. Dominions and Territories: Some states are organized as self-governing entities

with a degree of autonomy, but they are not fully independent. Examples include
Puerto Rico (associated with the United States) and Greenland (associated with
Denmark).

7. Colonies: Territories that are controlled and governed by another state are
considered colonies. The process of decolonization during the 20th century led to
the emergence of many new sovereign states as former colonies gained
independence.

8. City-States: These are states that consist of a single city and its surrounding
territory. Examples include Singapore and Vatican City. While small in size, they
often have significant cultural, economic, or historical importance.

9. Condominiums: In some cases, two or more states may share sovereign control
over a territory. This is known as a condominium. For instance, the New Hebrides
(now Vanuatu) was jointly administered by France and the United Kingdom.

17
These various kinds of states reflect the diverse political and territorial arrangements
that exist within the international system, each with its own legal implications and
challenges in international law.

Certainly, here are a few more specialized categories and concepts related to states in
international law:

1. Landlocked States: These are states that do not have any coastline and are
surrounded by other states. Landlocked states often face challenges in terms of
trade and transportation, as they must rely on neighboring countries to access ports
and international waters. Examples include Austria, Bolivia, and Nepal.

2. Island States: These are states that consist entirely of islands. Island states often
have unique vulnerabilities related to climate change, sea-level rise, and natural
disasters. Examples include the Maldives, Seychelles, and Fiji.

3. Buffer States: Buffer states are located between larger or more powerful states and
are intended to serve as a neutral zone that reduces the risk of conflict between the
larger states. They can play a role in maintaining stability in sensitive regions.
4. Neutral States: Neutral states are those that do not take sides in conflicts between
other states. They maintain a policy of non-alignment and do not participate in
military alliances. Switzerland and Sweden are examples of traditionally neutral
states.

5. Protectorates: A protectorate is a state that is technically sovereign but is under the

protection and control of a more powerful state. The protectorate retains its own
government and identity, but its foreign policy and security matters may be
influenced or controlled by the protecting state.

6. Mandates and Trust Territories: After World War I and World War II, the League of
Nations and the United Nations, respectively, administered former colonies and
territories of defeated states as mandates or trust territories. The goal was to
prepare these territories for self-governance or independence.

7. Emerging States: These are territories or entities in the process of transitioning to

full statehood. They might have gained partial recognition or might be working
toward international recognition as sovereign states. Kosovo is an example of an
emerging state, as it has been recognized by some countries but not by others.

8. Personal Unions: A personal union occurs when two or more distinct states are
ruled by the same monarch or head of state while maintaining separate institutions

18
 and governments. This was historically common in Europe, such as the union
between England and Scotland under the same monarch.

9. Commonwealth Realms: These are states that have the same monarch as their
head of state, typically sharing a historical connection through the British Empire.
While they are sovereign states, they acknowledge the British monarch as a
symbolic figurehead. Examples include Canada, Australia, and Jamaica.

10. Free Associated States: These are states that have a special relationship with a
larger sovereign state, often granting them a significant degree of self-governance
while maintaining certain ties. The Federated States of Micronesia, the Republic of
the Marshall Islands, and Palau are examples of free associated states with the
United States.

11. Homelands or Bantustans: In the context of apartheid-era South Africa, homelands

(also called Bantustans) were designated territories for different ethnic groups, which
were intended to be separate self-governing entities. However, these entities were
widely seen as a form of segregation and were not recognized as independent
states.

These categories and concepts further illustrate the intricate and diverse nature of
states within the framework of international law, taking into account historical, political,
and geographical factors that contribute to their distinct status and roles in the global
arena.

Certainly, here are a few additional concepts related to states in international law:

1. Puppet States: Puppet states are states that appear to be independent, but their
sovereignty is largely controlled or influenced by a more powerful state. This control
can be overt or covert, and puppet states often serve the interests of the controlling
state.

2. Client States: Similar to puppet states, client states have a dependent relationship
with a more powerful state, often receiving economic, military, or political support in
exchange for aligning their policies with the interests of the more powerful state.

3. Dominant Party States: In these states, a single political party holds significant
power and influence, often maintaining a monopoly on political power. China and
North Korea are examples of countries often characterized as dominant party states.

19
4. Islamic Republics: This term is used to describe states that incorporate Islamic
principles and laws into their legal and political systems. Iran is one of the most well-
known examples of an Islamic Republic.

5. Federal States: Federal states are those that have a division of powers between a
central government and constituent units, such as states or provinces. The United
States, Germany, and Australia are federal states where both levels of government
have authority over specific matters.

6. Unitary States: In contrast to federal states, unitary states have a centralized

government that holds primary authority. Decisions and policies are made by the
central government, and regional units have limited powers. France and Japan are
examples of unitary states.

7. Democratic States: Democratic states are those where leaders are elected through
free and fair elections, and political power is derived from the consent of the
governed. Democracy comes in various forms, such as representative democracies
and direct democracies.

8. Absolute Monarchies: These are states where a single monarch holds supreme
power and authority. The monarch's rule is often not bound by a constitution or
elected representatives. Saudi Arabia and Brunei are examples of absolute
monarchies.

9. Constitutional Monarchies: In constitutional monarchies, the monarch's powers

are limited by a constitution, and the country is often governed by elected officials.
The United Kingdom and Japan are examples of constitutional monarchies.

10. Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) States: These states are part of the Non-Aligned
Movement, a group of countries that choose not to align with any major power blocs
or alliances. NAM states advocate for a policy of independence and neutrality in
global affairs.

11. Peacekeeping States: Some states have a history of contributing personnel and
resources to international peacekeeping missions, often under the auspices of the
United Nations or regional organizations.

12. Rogue States: This term is often used to refer to states that are seen as acting
against international norms and principles, often engaging in actions that threaten
regional or global security. The label is subjective and can be politically charged.

20
These additional concepts highlight further nuances and characteristics of states in
international law, showcasing the wide range of political, legal, and social structures that
exist within the global community.

Q5. Explain the evolution of public international law & explain the role of U.N in
maintaining peace & order of the world

The evolution of public international law spans centuries, developing from customary
practices and treaties among states. It has progressed to encompass a wide range of
topics, including diplomacy, trade, human rights, and environmental protection. Over
time, the establishment of international organizations, such as the United Nations (UN),
has played a crucial role in shaping and enforcing international law.

The United Nations, founded in 1945 after World War II, serves as a global platform for
cooperation among nations. Its primary goal is to maintain international peace and
security. The UN achieves this through various mechanisms:

1. Security Council: The Security Council is responsible for maintaining peace and
security. Its five permanent members (P5) hold veto power, enabling them to block
any substantive resolution. The Security Council can impose sanctions or authorize
military actions to address threats to international peace.

2. General Assembly: The General Assembly is a forum for member states to discuss
and make recommendations on a wide range of issues. While its resolutions are not
legally binding, they carry significant political weight.

21
3. International Court of Justice (ICJ): The ICJ settles legal disputes between states
and provides advisory opinions on international legal questions. Its decisions
contribute to the development of customary international law.

4. Peacekeeping Operations: The UN deploys peacekeeping forces to conflict zones

to stabilize situations, monitor ceasefires, and facilitate negotiations. These missions
aim to create conditions for lasting peace.

5. International Treaties and Conventions: The UN facilitates the negotiation and

adoption of international treaties and conventions on various issues, such as human
rights, environmental protection, and disarmament.

6. Human Rights: The UN promotes and protects human rights through various
bodies and treaties, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and the
Human Rights Council.

7. Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs): The UN's SDGs provide a global

framework for addressing poverty, inequality, and environmental challenges. They
encourage cooperation among nations to achieve a more sustainable and equitable
world.

Overall, the UN's role in maintaining peace and order lies in its ability to foster dialogue,
facilitate negotiations, and provide a platform for international cooperation. While
challenges persist, the UN remains a critical entity in upholding the principles of
international law and ensuring a more peaceful and just world.

The United Nations (UN) plays a significant role in international affairs, encompassing
various functions that contribute to maintaining peace, promoting cooperation, and
addressing global challenges. Some of the key roles of the UN include:

1. Maintaining International Peace and Security: The UN's primary role is to prevent
conflicts and maintain global peace and security. This is achieved through diplomatic
efforts, conflict resolution, peacekeeping operations, and, when necessary,
authorization of military actions by the Security Council.

2. Promoting Human Rights: The UN is a leading advocate for human rights, working
to protect and promote the fundamental rights and dignity of individuals worldwide. It
establishes norms, monitors human rights abuses, and supports initiatives to
improve conditions for all people.

22
3. Facilitating Diplomacy and Negotiations: The UN provides a neutral platform for
countries to engage in diplomatic discussions, negotiations, and conflict resolution.
Its General Assembly and various specialized agencies foster dialogue on a wide
range of global issues.

4. Coordinating Humanitarian Assistance: During crises, the UN coordinates

international humanitarian efforts to provide aid, relief, and support to populations
affected by natural disasters, conflicts, and other emergencies.

5. Promoting Sustainable Development: Through initiatives like the Sustainable

Development Goals (SDGs), the UN works to address poverty, inequality,
environmental degradation, and other global challenges by setting targets and
encouraging collaborative action.

6. Providing Legal Frameworks: The UN helps establish international legal

frameworks by facilitating the creation of treaties, conventions, and agreements that
guide behavior between states and address various issues such as trade,
environment, and disarmament.
7. Environmental Protection: The UN promotes global environmental cooperation,
including efforts to combat climate change, protect biodiversity, and address
pollution through agreements such as the Paris Agreement.

8. Supporting Refugees and Displaced Persons: The UN High Commissioner for

Refugees (UNHCR) provides aid and protection to refugees and displaced persons,
working to ensure their safety and dignity.

9. Health and Disease Prevention: The World Health Organization (WHO), a UN

agency, plays a vital role in global health, coordinating efforts to combat disease
outbreaks, promote health standards, and improve healthcare systems.

10. Cultural and Educational Exchange: UNESCO (United Nations Educational,

Scientific and Cultural Organization) promotes international collaboration in
education, science, culture, and communication to foster understanding and respect
among cultures.

11. Preventing Weapons Proliferation: The UN works to prevent the spread of

weapons of mass destruction, including nuclear, chemical, and biological weapons,
through treaties and disarmament efforts.

23
12. Aid for Development: The UN provides technical assistance and resources to help
developing countries build capacity, improve infrastructure, and achieve sustainable
development.

Overall, the UN serves as a forum for international cooperation, diplomacy, and

problem-solving, playing a vital role in maintaining a more peaceful, just, and
prosperous world.

Q6. Explain the term territory & different modes of acquisition & loss of territory

In international law, a "territory" refers to a defined geographical area that is subject to

the sovereignty and control of a specific state or entity. Territorial sovereignty is a
fundamental principle of international law that recognizes a state's exclusive authority
over its territory, including its land, water, and airspace.

Territory, in the context of international law, is a foundational concept that represents a

specific geographical area under the authority and sovereignty of a state. It
encompasses not only land but also maritime areas, airspace, and potentially even
subsoil resources. Territorial sovereignty grants a state the exclusive right to govern its
territory, make and enforce laws, and control its resources. Territorial integrity is a
fundamental principle that upholds the inviolability of a state's borders, prohibiting the
use of force to change these borders.

Here's how the term "territory" is understood in the context of international law:

1. Sovereignty: Territory represents the space over which a state exercises its
sovereignty. Sovereignty entails the supreme authority of a state to govern itself,
make laws, maintain order, and make decisions about the use of its resources within
its territory.

24
2. Territorial Integrity: This principle in international law emphasizes that the borders
of a state should be respected by other states. States are prohibited from using force
or other coercive means to alter the borders of another state. Territorial integrity is
considered a fundamental norm to maintain peace and stability.

3. Borders and Boundaries: The establishment of clear and recognized borders

between states' territories is essential to prevent disputes and conflicts. These
borders can be defined by physical features (rivers, mountains), agreed-upon lines,
or legal agreements such as treaties.

4. Jurisdiction: A state's jurisdiction extends over its territory, granting it the legal
authority to regulate activities, enforce laws, and resolve disputes within its borders.
This includes the ability to impose taxes, maintain law and order, and protect human
rights.

5. State Responsibility: A state is responsible for preventing and addressing activities

that originate within its territory and have harmful effects on other states. This
principle, known as "no harm" or "due diligence," ensures that states take
appropriate actions to prevent cross-border harm caused by their territory or
activities.

6. Territorial Waters and Maritime Zones: In maritime law, a state's territory extends
to its territorial waters, which generally extend up to 12 nautical miles from its
coastline. Beyond this, states may claim exclusive economic zones (EEZs) for the
exploration and use of marine resources.

7. Disputes and Conflict Resolution: Territorial disputes, often arising from

conflicting historical, political, or cultural claims, are common in international
relations. States may resort to negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or legal processes
to resolve these disputes peacefully.

8. Self-Determination: While not directly related to territory, the principle of self-

determination recognizes the rights of certain groups within a defined territory to
determine their political status and future. This can sometimes lead to the creation of
new states or changes in territorial boundaries through peaceful means.

In summary, "territory" in international law encompasses the physical and legal space
over which a state exercises its sovereignty and maintains jurisdiction. It's a
foundational concept that underpins the interactions, rights, and responsibilities of
states in the global arena.

25
Certainly, in international law, there are various modes through which a state can
acquire or lose territory. These modes are influenced by historical practices, treaties,
customary law, and principles of state sovereignty. Here are the primary modes of
acquisition and loss of territory:

Modes of Acquisition:

1. Discovery: Historically, discovering a previously unknown territory could lead to a

claim of sovereignty. However, this concept has diminished in significance as most
of the world has been explored and territories are already claimed by existing states.

2. Occupation: States can acquire territory through effective occupation, meaning they
physically establish control over a territory that was not previously claimed by any
other state. Effective administration and control over the territory are essential
elements for this mode of acquisition.

3. Accretion: This refers to the gradual accumulation of land through natural

processes, such as the deposition of soil by rivers or the gradual emergence of new
land from the sea. States can claim newly formed land as part of their territory if they
can demonstrate effective control.

4. Cession: Territory can be acquired through agreements between states. This can
involve treaties, contracts, or other formal arrangements in which one state transfers
sovereignty over a specific territory to another state.

5. Conquest: Historically, territory could be acquired through military conquest.

However, modern international law strongly discourages this practice, and conquest
as a means of acquiring territory is generally considered illegal under contemporary
norms.

6. Prescription: This mode of acquisition occurs when a state exercises continuous

and uncontested control over a territory for an extended period of time. If other
states do not raise objections to this control, the occupying state may acquire
sovereignty over the territory.

Modes of Loss:

1. Cession: Just as territory can be acquired through cession, it can also be lost
through cession. A state can voluntarily relinquish sovereignty over a territory
through treaties or agreements.

26
2. Sovereign State Succession: When a territory gains independence and becomes a
new sovereign state, the parent state loses control over that territory. This can
happen through peaceful processes like decolonization or secession.

3. Subjugation and Occupation: If one state occupies the territory of another state
through military force, the occupied state temporarily loses control over that territory.
However, this is generally considered a violation of international law.

4. Acquiescence: If a state remains silent or fails to contest another state's actions of

control over a territory, it might be interpreted as an implied consent to the loss of
that territory.

5. Erosion or Avulsion: If territory is gradually eroded by natural forces or moved by a

sudden shift in a river's course, the state's territorial boundaries might change,
resulting in territorial loss.
6. Annexation by another State: If a state's territory is annexed by another state
without consent or against international law, the original state loses control over that
territory.

These modes of acquisition and loss of territory demonstrate the complex and
multifaceted nature of territorial issues in international law. The principles of consent,
peaceful resolution of disputes, and respect for the sovereignty of states play central
roles in determining the legitimacy of territorial changes.

27
 Short Answers

Q1. Universal declaration of human rights

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) is a landmark document adopted

by the United Nations General Assembly on December 10, 1948. It serves as a
foundational text that outlines the fundamental rights and freedoms to which all
individuals are entitled, regardless of their nationality, race, gender, religion, or any
other distinction.

The UDHR consists of 30 articles that cover a wide range of rights and principles,
including civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. These rights are intended
to create a common standard of dignity and equality for all people and to promote and
protect human rights on a global scale.

Some key principles and rights outlined in the UDHR include:

1. Equality and Non-Discrimination: All individuals are born free and equal in dignity
and rights. Discrimination on any grounds, such as race, color, sex, language,
religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, property, birth, or other
status, is prohibited.

2. Right to Life, Liberty, and Security: Every person has the right to life, liberty, and
security of person.

28
3. Freedom from Torture and Cruel, Inhuman, or Degrading Treatment: No one
shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman, or degrading treatment or
punishment.

4. Freedom of Thought, Conscience, and Religion: Everyone has the right to

freedom of thought, conscience, and religion, including the freedom to change their
religion or belief.

5. Right to Education: Everyone has the right to education, which shall be free and
compulsory in the elementary and fundamental stages.

6. Right to Work and Fair Wages: Everyone has the right to work, to free choice of
employment, to just and favorable conditions of work, and to protection against
unemployment. Everyone who works has the right to just and favorable
remuneration.
7. Right to Participate in Government: Everyone has the right to take part in the
government of their country, directly or through freely chosen representatives.

8. Right to Adequate Standard of Living: Everyone has the right to a standard of

living adequate for the health and well-being of themselves and their family,
including food, clothing, housing, and medical care.

9. Right to Privacy: No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with their

privacy, family, home, or correspondence.

The Universal Declaration of Human Rights has served as the foundation for
subsequent international human rights treaties and conventions. While not legally
binding in itself, the UDHR has played a significant role in shaping national laws,
constitutions, and international agreements related to human rights. It stands as a
powerful reminder of the shared values and principles that underpin the concept of
human dignity and rights around the world.

Q2. Vienna convention of law of treaty

The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties (VCLT) is an international treaty that
was adopted on May 23, 1969, and entered into force on January 27, 1980. It is one of
the most important and widely accepted treaties governing the principles and rules
related to the formation, interpretation, validity, and termination of treaties between
states.

29
Here are some key points and principles outlined in the Vienna Convention on the Law
of Treaties:

1. Definition of a Treaty: The VCLT defines a treaty as "an international agreement

concluded between States in written form and governed by international law,
whether embodied in a single instrument or in two or more related instruments and
whatever its particular designation."

2. Formation of Treaties: The VCLT outlines the process by which treaties are
formed, including negotiations, consent of the parties, and the role of representatives
in expressing the state's consent to be bound by the treaty.

3. Reservation: States can make reservations to certain provisions of a treaty unless

the treaty explicitly prohibits reservations or the reservation is incompatible with the
object and purpose of the treaty.

4. Interpretation: The VCLT provides principles for interpreting the text of treaties,
including considering the ordinary meaning of terms, the context, the object and
purpose of the treaty, and subsequent practice of the parties.

5. Amendment and Modification: Treaties can be amended or modified through

mutual consent of the parties, as specified in the treaty or agreed upon by the
parties.

6. Invalidity and Termination: The VCLT addresses the circumstances under which a
treaty can be considered void, such as due to error, fraud, coercion, or a
fundamental change of circumstances. It also outlines conditions under which
treaties can be terminated, such as material breach, consent of the parties, or by
mutual agreement.

7. Succession of States: The VCLT deals with situations where states undergo
changes in government or territory and how existing treaties continue to apply or not
apply to the successor state.

8. Resolutions of Conflicts: In cases where there are conflicting treaties or

obligations, the VCLT provides guidance on how to resolve these conflicts.

The Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties has become a cornerstone of

international treaty law and serves as a reference point for diplomats, legal practitioners,
and international organizations when dealing with matters related to treaties. It provides

30
a structured framework for the creation, interpretation, and termination of treaties,
thereby contributing to the stability and predictability of international relations.

Q3. Peaceful settlements of disputes

Peaceful settlements of disputes are a fundamental aspect of international law, aiming

to resolve conflicts between states or other international entities through non-violent
means. The primary objective of these mechanisms is to maintain global peace and
security while upholding the principles of international law. There are several key
methods for achieving peaceful settlements of disputes in international law:

1. Negotiation: Direct negotiations between the parties involved in a dispute are one
of the most common methods for reaching a peaceful settlement. Diplomats and
representatives from the conflicting parties engage in discussions to find common
ground and resolve their differences. Negotiation can be formal or informal, and it
often involves compromise and concessions from both sides.

2. Mediation: Mediation involves the assistance of a neutral third party who helps
facilitate discussions between the disputing parties. The mediator does not impose a
solution but instead assists in finding common interests and proposing potential
solutions that the parties can consider. Mediation is particularly effective when
emotions are high, and communication between the parties is strained.

3. Conciliation: Similar to mediation, conciliation involves the intervention of a neutral

third party. However, in conciliation, the third party may play a more active role in
suggesting potential solutions and helping the parties draft a settlement agreement.

4. Arbitration: Arbitration is a more formal process where the parties agree to submit
their dispute to a neutral third party or a panel of arbitrators. These arbitrators render
a decision, known as an arbitral award, which is usually binding on the parties.
Arbitration offers a degree of flexibility in choosing procedures, rules, and the
arbitrators themselves.

31
5. Judicial Settlement: Disputes can be brought before international courts and
tribunals, such as the International Court of Justice (ICJ). These courts provide a
forum for states to present their arguments and evidence, and the court's decisions
are binding on the parties. The ICJ handles cases involving states and certain
international organizations.

6. Good Offices: Good offices involve the diplomatic intervention of a third party, often
a neutral state or an international organization, to facilitate communication between
the conflicting parties and encourage them to reach a settlement.
7. Inquiry and Fact-Finding: Sometimes, an international body or organization is
tasked with conducting an inquiry or fact-finding mission to gather information about
a dispute. The collected information can then be used to better understand the
situation and guide the parties toward a resolution.

8. International Organizations and Treaties: International organizations, such as the

United Nations, may play a role in resolving disputes by offering their assistance,
providing platforms for dialogue, and encouraging member states to abide by
established treaties and agreements.

These methods can be used individually or in combination, depending on the nature of

the dispute and the willingness of the parties to engage in peaceful settlement efforts.
International law encourages the use of these mechanisms to prevent conflicts from
escalating into violence and to maintain a stable and peaceful international order.

Q4. Directive principle & human rights

Directive Principles of State Policy and Human Rights are two important concepts in
governance and law, often found in the constitutions of democratic countries. Let's
break down each of these concepts:

Directive Principles of State Policy:

Directive Principles of State Policy (DPSP) are a set of guidelines or principles provided
in the constitution of a country that lay down the goals and objectives that the state
should strive to achieve in order to promote the welfare of the people. These principles
are not legally enforceable in courts, meaning citizens cannot approach the courts for
their enforcement. However, they serve as important moral and ethical considerations
for the government while formulating policies and laws.

32
For example, the Indian Constitution includes a chapter on Directive Principles of State
Policy that covers a wide range of areas, including social, economic, and political
matters. Some of these principles include promoting social justice, providing
opportunities for education and work, ensuring equal pay for equal work, protecting the
environment, and promoting the welfare of marginalized groups.

Human Rights:

Human rights refer to the fundamental rights and freedoms that every individual is
entitled to, regardless of their nationality, race, gender, religion, or any other status.
These rights are considered inherent to all human beings and are often protected by
law, both at the national and international levels.

Common examples of human rights include the right to life, liberty, and security;
freedom of speech and expression; freedom from torture and inhumane treatment; the
right to education; the right to a fair trial; and the right to participate in government.
These rights are typically enshrined in national constitutions and international treaties
such as the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the International Covenant on Civil
and Political Rights, and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural
Rights.

Relationship between Directive Principles and Human Rights:

While Directive Principles of State Policy and Human Rights both aim to improve the
well-being of individuals within a society, there can sometimes be a tension between the
two. This is because Directive Principles are aspirational goals that may require
economic and social resources to implement, while Human Rights are considered
inherent entitlements that must be upheld regardless of resource constraints.

In some cases, governments may face challenges in effectively implementing both

Directive Principles and Human Rights, especially in situations where resource
allocation becomes a concern. Striking a balance between these two concepts often
requires careful consideration, policy planning, and sometimes prioritization based on
the specific needs and circumstances of a country.

In summary, Directive Principles of State Policy provide guidance to governments on

socio-economic objectives, while Human Rights are fundamental entitlements that all

33
individuals possess. Both concepts contribute to the overall well-being and development
of a society.

Q5. U.N environment programme

The United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) is the leading global

environmental authority within the United Nations system. It was established in 1972 as
a response to the growing recognition of the need to address global environmental
challenges. UNEP's mission is to provide leadership and encourage partnership in
caring for the environment by inspiring, informing, and enabling nations and peoples to
improve their quality of life without compromising that of future generations.

UNEP works towards promoting sustainable development, protecting the environment,

and addressing various environmental issues such as climate change, biodiversity loss,
pollution, and the depletion of natural resources. It acts as a catalyst, advocate,
educator, and facilitator to promote sustainable development, and it works with
governments, civil society organizations, businesses, and other stakeholders to
advance its goals.

Key functions and activities of UNEP include:

1. Research and Assessment: UNEP conducts scientific research, assessments, and

reports on various environmental issues to provide evidence-based information for
policymakers and the public.

2. Policy Support: UNEP assists countries in developing and implementing

environmental policies and strategies, helping them integrate environmental
considerations into their development plans.

3. Capacity Building: UNEP provides technical assistance and capacity-building

support to help countries strengthen their environmental institutions and implement
sustainable practices.

4. Awareness and Advocacy: UNEP raises awareness about environmental

challenges and encourages global action through campaigns, initiatives, and events.

34
5. Conventions and Agreements: UNEP supports the negotiation and implementation
of international environmental agreements, such as the Paris Agreement on climate
change and the Convention on Biological Diversity.

6. Partnerships: UNEP collaborates with a wide range of partners, including

governments, international organizations, NGOs, academia, and the private sector,
to achieve its objectives.

7. Environmental Education: UNEP promotes environmental education and

awareness at various levels, including schools and communities, to foster a sense of
responsibility for the environment.

UNEP is headquartered in Nairobi, Kenya, and operates in various regions around the
world through its regional offices and partner organizations. It plays a crucial role in
coordinating global efforts to address environmental challenges and ensure a
sustainable future for all.

Q6. Amnesty international

Amnesty International is a non-governmental organization (NGO) that focuses on

human rights advocacy and activism. It was founded in 1961 by British lawyer Peter
Benenson. The organization's main goal is to promote and protect human rights around
the world, and it does so by investigating and exposing human rights abuses,
advocating for justice, and mobilizing public support to create positive change.

Amnesty International is known for its work in areas such as:

1. Research and Advocacy: The organization conducts thorough research on human

rights abuses, including issues like political repression, torture, discrimination,
freedom of speech, and more. They publish reports detailing their findings and
advocating for action to address these abuses.

2. Campaigns: Amnesty International runs various campaigns to raise awareness

about specific human rights issues and to pressure governments, corporations, and
other entities to uphold human rights standards. These campaigns often involve
letter-writing, protests, petitions, and social media activism.

3. Legal Support: The organization provides legal assistance and representation to

individuals and groups who are victims of human rights violations. This support can

35
 include raising awareness of their cases, advocating for their release, and mobilizing
international pressure on their behalf.

4. Education and Training: Amnesty International also focuses on educating the

public about human rights, often conducting workshops, seminars, and educational
programs to spread awareness and understanding of these issues.

5. Lobbying and Diplomacy: The organization engages with governments,

international organizations, and other stakeholders to influence policies and actions
that impact human rights. They often lobby for changes in laws and practices that
violate human rights standards.

Amnesty International is known for its impartiality and non-partisan approach,

advocating for human rights regardless of political, economic, or cultural factors. It has
received numerous awards for its work, but it has also faced criticism and controversies
over its methods and positions, particularly from governments that are the subjects of
their reports.

36
37