Labour Supply in Caribbean Economics
Labour Supply in Caribbean Economics
2
Labour Supply
Unit Overview
In labour markets, the number of hours that individuals are willingly to provide is
determined by workers. The number of hours worked is jointly decided by workers
and firms. Workers respond to incentives offered by the real wage, non-wage benefits,
social safety net programs and their own preferences for work and leisure. In this unit,
we will first determine the size and characteristics of the labour force before examining
the neoclassical model of labour and leisure. We will then apply the neoclassical model
to real-world situations.
Learning Objectives
3. Outline how the utility maximizing choice is determined using the neoclassical
labour supply model;
Note to Student:
Some hyperlinks to resources may not open on clicking. If any link fails to open,
please copy and paste the link to your browser to view/download the resource.
Required Reading(s)
Borjas, G. (2013). Labor Economics (6th ed.). New York: The McGraw-Hill
Companies. Available at: [Link]
publications/books/LE/[Link]
Wiswall, M. (n.d.). Labor Economics (Undergrad) lecture notes. Available at: http://
[Link]/user/wiswall/teaching/undergrad_labor_lectures.pdf
Required Videos
EconplusDal. (2016, May 3). Individual labour supply curve (backward bending
labor supply curve. [Video File]. Available at: [Link]
watch?v=V9FtLDdtAgk
EconplusDal. (2016, May 7). Labour supply curve (Market and firm). [Video File].
Available at: [Link]
EconplusDal. (2016, May 13). Elasticity of the labour supply curve. [Video File].
Available at: [Link]
Prante, T. (2015, June 9). Unemployment rate and labor force participation rate. [Video
File]. Available at: [Link]
WSUECO6480. (2010, September 26). Labor Supply Theory Part 1A. [Video File].
Available at: [Link]
WSUECO6480. (2010, September 26). Labor Supply Theory Part 1B. [Video File].
Available at: [Link]
Suggested Readings
CARICOM. (2014). Women and men in CARICOM member states, labour force
statistics, volume I - Data series for 1980, 1990 and 2000 round of censuses.
Available at: [Link]
CARICOM. (2014). Women and men in CARICOM member states, labour force
statistics, methodological guide volume II - 1980-2002. Available at: [Link]
[Link]/[Link]
Kane, J. (n.d.). Notes for Chapter 6. In Introduction to labor economics course lectures.
Available at: [Link]
Kim, N. (2007). The impact of remittances on labor supply: The case of Jamaica. World
Bank Policy Research Working Paper, No 4120. Available at: [Link]
[Link]/curated/en/926051468044132562/pdf/[Link]
Imbens, G., Rubin, D., & Sacerdote, B. (2001). Estimating the effect of unearned
income on labor earnings, savings and consumption: Evidence from a survey of
lottery players. American Economic Review, 91(4), 778-794. [Available via
UWIlinC]
Juhn, C., & Kim, D. (1999). The effects of rising female labor supply on male wages.
Journal of Labor Economics, 17(1), 23-48. [Available via UWIlinC]
Suggested Videos
Introduction
To correctly characterize the labour market, it is important to define key labour force
concepts and statistics. These concepts and statistics help us to understand the extent
to which labour is being utilized and hence they aid in understanding how the labour
market is performing. Once key labour force statistics have been defined, we will
then examine labour markets in the Caribbean to characterize recent trends in labour
supply in the region.
Of those who of working age and are legally allowed to work, some are excluded from
the labour force because they do not have jobs and are not actively looking for one.
This means that only persons who are of working age and who have a job (employed)
or are actively looking for one (unemployed) are counted in the labour force. The
relationship between these different measures are summarized in Figure 1.1 and the
official definitions which follow.
Here are official definitions of these concepts (the numbers in parentheses correspond
to the numbers in Figure 1.1):
• Persons not in the labour force – number of persons not available to work
a. Without work but has made specific efforts to find a job within the last 4 weeks
b. Waiting to be called back to a job from which he or she has been laid off
• The employment rate is the percentage of the labour force that is employed.
(E/LF)*100
A discouraged worker is a person who currently is neither working nor looking for
work but who has stopped looking for a job because of repeated failure to find one.
Many part-time workers want to work part time, but some part-time workers would
like full-time jobs. Therefore, some part-time workers are underemployed.
Critics argue that by including these measures, the unemployment rate would be a
better reflection of actual labour market conditions. Others argue that the employment
rate is a better indicator of conditions in the labour market because it shows how well
labour resources are being utilized. But there are persons who have no intention of
working in the formal market in the near future, such as students and home-makers,
who would not be represented by this measure.
• Labour force participation rates have remained steady with only slight increases
over time in most countries. Recently, however the LFPR has declined slightly
in many countries. This pattern is similar for men and women. The labour force
participation rates for men is greater than that for women in the Caribbean.
(See Figure 1.2)
[Link]
uu [Link]
[Link]
Suggested Reading
It is important to have reliable sources of unemployment data in the
Caribbean. The following is one such source. While each country will have
its own statistical agency which collects this data, the Caricom secretariat
compiles this data so data from all member countries can be easily
accessed. Please examine the section on Caricom for an overall picture
of the labour market in the region and the section on at least one of the
member states.
CARICOM. (2014). Women and men in CARICOM member states, labour
force statistics, volume I - Data series for 1980, 1990 and 2000 round of
censuses. Available at:
uu [Link]
Also read the accompanying guide which defines the labour force statistics
and explains the methods used to collect the data.
CARICOM. (2014). Women and men in CARICOM member states, labour
force statistics, methodological guide volume II - 1980-2002. Available
at:
uu [Link]
Play Video
Watch the following video which explains how the unemployment rate
and labour force participation rates are calculated. Note that in calculating
the labour force participation rate, the presenter uses the term ‘eligible
population’ rather than the working age population.
Prante, T. (2015, June 9). Unemployment rate and labor force participation
rate. [Video File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
(a)Calculate the number of adults who are in the labour force and the
number of adults who are unemployed.
2. Watch the following video and compare the trends in labour force
participation in the United States, as presented, with the trends in the
Caribbean as shown in Figure 2.2 or CARICOM (2014).
Marginal Revolution University. (2016, November 17). Labor Force
Participation. [Video File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
In this Session, we defined some key concepts and statistics which characterize the
labour force. We applied these concepts and statistics to the labour market in the
Caribbean to determine current trends in the labour supply in the region by age and
by gender. Now that we have characterized the labour force, we will examine the
neoclassical model in Session 2.2 to understand how the statistics we observed in this
session are determined
Introduction
In this session, we will analyze the worker’s preferences and the ways in which this
impacts labour supply decisions. We will do so using the neoclassical model of labour-
leisure choice. This model explains how workers select the optimal combination of
leisure and work given limitations on their income.
• The worker consumes goods, C, and leisure, L. Note that leisure is time spent
not working.
• C is also the cost of the goods consumed (the cost of consumption goods is
normally p X C where p is the price of consumption goods; here we assume p
= 1) while L is the number of leisure hours consumed.
Indifference curves
• The Utility curve: U = f (C,L)
• Indifference curves are downward sloping because consumers like both C and L.
The slope of the indifference curve represents the rate at which the consumer trades C
for L given a constant level of utility:
• The marginal rate of substitution (MRS) is the absolute value of the slope of
the indifference curve and is the ratio of marginal utilities:
• W is constant,
C = wh + V = w(T-L) + V= (wT+V) – wL
• Combinations of C and L that are above or on the budget line lies in the consumer’s
opportunity set and are affordable.
• Because the worker has non-labour income, there is a combination of goods and
leisure that can be consumed if the worker does not enter the labour market.
• There is also the reservation wage which is the minimum wage acceptable to the
worker to induce him or her to supply at least one unit of labour.
• The slope of the budget constraint is w because this is the cost of…one hour of
leisure when the worker gives up one hour of work.
• A concave kink can occur if workers receive over-time pay. Workers who
are like minded with different indifference curves will separate and move
to opposite sides of the budget line. In this case, a small change in taxes or
wages will have large effects on workers’ behavior.
• Differences in preferences are shown by the slope of the indifference curves (the
MRS):
• Steep indifference curves imply a high MRS and the worker is consuming
more goods and little leisure. The worker requires a high amount of C to give
up an additional unit of leisure.
• Flatter indifference curves means the MRS is low and the worker is
consuming more leisure and little goods. The worker requires a high amount
of L to give up an additional unit of consumption.
• To maximize utility, the worker therefore chooses the bundle at the tangency of the
indifference curve with the budget constraint.
• This is also an interior solution because the tangency does not occur at either
corner of the opportunity set.
• This is also where the slope of the indifference curve is equal to the slope of the
budget constraint: w = –
• Note that for non-participants, tangency of the indifference curve and the budget
constraint is a corner solution because L = T.
Let us now consider the effects of a change in non-labour income and wages:
Reading
Read the following to learn more about worker’s preferences as expressed
through the indifference curve and the budget constraint. Pay particular
attention to the example that is worked through in section 4.8.
uu [Link]
[Link]
The following contains the graphs to accompany the resource listed above.
Wiswall, M. (n.d.). Labor Economics (Undergraduate) lecture notes*Figures,
pages 6-8. Available at:
uu [Link]
[Link]
uu [Link]
Play Video
The following video is the first in a series on the theory of labour supply. Pay
attention to the explanations given for the motivation behind the decision to
work, the leisure-labour trade off and indifference curves.
WSUECO6480. (2010, September 26). Labor Supply Theory Part 1A. [Video
File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
The following video is the second in a series on the theory of labour supply.
Focus on how the tangency condition determines the number of hours the
worker devotes to leisure vs work and how the income and substitution
effect influences how the worker responds to a rise in wages. The video also
previews how the neoclassical model can be applied to income maintenance
programs from 7:44 to 9:51 minutes that will be covered in greater detail in
Session 2.3.
WSUECO6480. (2010, September 26). Labor Supply Theory Part 1B. [Video
File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
The following video is the third in a series on the theory of labour supply.
It explains why some of the model’s assumptions are not always observed
in practice such as the non-time costs of working like childcare and
commuting. Focus on these observed conditions in the labour market affects
the neoclassical model. Further, we have focused on a static model which
describes the labour supply decision at one point in time. Note how the
model can be used to examine trends over time.
uu [Link]
2. For persons who are currently not in the labour force, where on the
budget line is their optimal choice located? (Hint: consider the interior vs
the corners of the budget constraint)
5. What happens to the budget line when the wage rate increases?
7. Which effect will cause the worker to enjoy less leisure time and work
more?
Discuss your answers with your peers in the Unit 2 discussion forum.
Introduction
So far, we have discussed how key labour market statistics are calculated, and how
workers decide how many hours that they are willing to supply in the labour market.
In this unit, we will apply the neoclassical model to real world situations. Specifically,
the neoclassical model of leisure-labour choice will be used to examine the impact of
various policies on the labour market.
• If the substitution effect dominates at lower wages and the income effect
dominates at higher wages, the supply curve is upward sloping at the initial
portions of the supply curve but backward sloping at the upper portions of
the supply curve.
• At every wage level, if we horizontally sum the number of hours worked for each
worker, the aggregate supply curve can be derived.
• The workers must be offered a wage greater than the reservation wage to entice
them to enter the labour market.
The labour supply elasticity expresses the percentage change in the number of hours
worked when there is a 1% increase in the wage rate. When the absolute value of σ < 1,
the labour supply elasticity is relatively inelastic. The number of hours worked does
not change significantly when wages increase. On the other hand, when the absolute
Policy Applications
We will now apply the neoclassical model of labour-leisure choice.
(a) Welfare Programs and work incentives: Welfare programs can alter incentives.
Consider a cash grant given to needy families. Eligible families are given the cash
grant as long as they are unemployed, work few hours or earn low-wages. Once
the family starts working more or earning more, they are stripped of the cash grant
altogether or have the grant reduced. The cash grant increases the reservation
wage. With this increased reservation wage, the family chooses the labour-leisure
bundle that is different than the one that would be observed without the cash
grant. That is, it may be more beneficial to the family to stay out of the labour
force, or work fewer hours to maintain the benefit. [See Kane (2001) for a graphical
demonstration]
(b) The Earned Income Tax Credit EITC): Families earning below a certain income
threshold, receive a tax credit. This reduces the tax burden and increases net
income. Since the credit is only given to persons who work, the higher net income
induces an increase in the labour supply. But the EITC also affects people who
would have chosen to enter the workforce without the EITC but realize that they
can take advantage of the credit and work fewer hours than intended. This reduces
the intended labour supply.
(c) The decline in labour force participation by older workers: This may be
attributable to pension benefits. If workers are guaranteed a decent pension, they
retire as soon as they are eligible to do so.
Read the following for an application of how the neoclassical model is used
to determine the impact of societal changes in the labour market. In this
case, the paper examines whether the increase in the number of women in
the labour force has affected the wage of men, primarily those earning low
wages. Section II contains some advanced Mathematics but still provides an
important discussion of the theory behind the model. Pay close attention to
how the elasticities presented in Table 4 and Table 5 are calculated.
Juhn, C., & Kim, D. (1999). The effects of rising female labor supply on
male wages. Journal of Labor Economics, 17(1), 23-48. [Available via
UWIlinC]
uu [Link]
The following video discusses why the shape of the individual labour supply
curve differs from the shape of the industry labour supply curve. Note the
shape of the industry supply curve is dependent on an assumption made
and the structure of the industry (whether it is competitive, monopolist or
monopsonist).
EconplusDal. (2016, May 7). Labour supply curve (Market and firm). [Video
File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
The following video explains the factors which influence the elasticity of the
industry labour supply curve. This concept is key to explaining how changes
in wages affect particular industries.
EconplusDal. (2016, May 13). Elasticity of the labour supply curve. [Video
File]. Available at:
uu [Link]
uu [Link]
[Link]
(b)What impact has the changes in the labour force participation rates have
on the labour supply?
(c) How have remittances influenced the reservation wage? Use graphs to
aid your explanation.
(f) What type of empirical analysis is used to produce the results in Table 3?
Give a brief explanation of the method and its appropriateness for this
type of study.
In this session, we discussed how the neoclassical model of labour-leisure choice can
be applied to real world situations. We learned that some programs designed to help
low-income families may provide disincentives to work causing recipients to work
less hours than intended. Therefore, some public policies may have unintended labour
market outcomes.
Unit Summary
In this unit, we discussed basic issues in labour economics. First, we defined some
concepts and statistics that are useful for characterizing the labour force. Then we
examined the neoclassical model of leisure-labour choice. We learned that the tangency
of the budget constraint and the indifference curves, which represent workers’
preferences, determines the number of hours that workers are willing to supply. Then
we used this model to analyze the labour market impact of various public policy
programs and concluded that some programs can decrease the number of hours that
workers are willing to supply because of the desire to maximize the benefits received
from the programs. We have now concluded our study of labour supply. We will
examine labour demand in the next unit.
Borjas, G. (2013). Labor Economics (6th ed.). New York: The McGraw-Hill Companies.
Smith, R. S. & Ehrenberg, R. G. (2012). Modern labor economics (11th ed.). New York:
Routledge.