Powder Bed Fusion: SLS Overview
Powder Bed Fusion: SLS Overview
Introduction
Parts is built by sintering when CO2 laser beam hit a thin layer of powdered
material. That raises the temperature of powder to near its melting point.
It resulting in particle bonding, fusing the particles to themselves and
previous layer to form a solid layer.
The building of part is done layer by layer. Each layer is consist of cross
section of solid model (.STL file). Next layer is applied by roller & sintering.
The packing density of powder particles affects the part density obtained.
Packing densities are in range of 50 to 60 %.
N Hot closed Chamber: use of infrared heaters / resistive heaters for bed.
Filled with Nitrogen gas.
N Layers: after one layer, build platform moves down (Z) and 2nd layer is
laid. Beam scan slice file and process is repeated…. till completion.
N Energy required in sinter bonding is approx. 300 to 500 times higher than
photo-polymerization.
D-EX plastic: toughness and impact resistance, e.g. unmanned air vehicle,
hinges, grills, bumpers, aerospace.
D-Flex plastic: thermoplastic elastomer material, flexible, durable, tear
resistance, finish and feature details. E.g. Athletic footwear, hoses and seals.
2. LaserFoam material
LaserFoam A6 metal is used in creation of rapid tooling and mfg.
High hardness, good features, metallic appearance.
e.g. complex tooling inserts for injection moulding.
Fig. Separate, Composite, Coated and Indistinct mixtures Powders variations in LPS.
ii. Composite particles:
Composite particles contain both the binder and structural material within each
powder particle.
The benefits of composite particles are that they typically form higher density
green parts and typically have better surface finish after processing.
e.g. glass-filled nylon. In this case, the structural material (glass beads) is used
to enhance the properties of the binding material (nylon), rather than the typical
use of LPS where the binder is simply a necessary glue.
In Pattern approach, the part created in the PBF process is a pattern used to create
the metal part. Used for Investment casting-pattern, Sand casting-cores.
Process Parameters
In PBF, process parameters can be lumped into four categories:
(1) Laser-parameters (laser power, spot size, pulse duration, pulse frequency),
(2) Scan parameters (scan speed, scan spacing, and scan pattern),
(3) Powder-parameters (particle shape, size, and distribution, powder bed
density, layer thickness, material properties, etc.),
(4) Temperature- parameters (bed & powder feeder temperature, uniformity)
Most of these parameters are strongly interdependent, are mutually interacting.
A typical PBF m/c includes two galvanometers (for X and Y-axis motion).
Laser power, spot size and scan speed, and bed temperature together
determine the energy input needed to fuse the powder into a useable part.
The longer the laser (CW) dwells in a particular location, the deeper the
fusion depth and the larger the melt pool diameter.
Typical layer thicknesses range from 0.02 to 0.15 mm.
Operating at lower laser powers requires the use of lower scan speeds in
order to ensure proper particle fusion.
The powder bed density, as governed by powder shape, size, distribution,
and spreading mechanism, influence the part quality. (50 to 60 %)
Higher the powder packing density, the higher the bed thermal
conductivity and the better the part mechanical properties.
Applied Energy Correlations and Scan Patterns
Both melt pool size and depth are a function of Absorbed energy density.
A simplified energy density equation for correlating input process
parameters to the density and strength of produced parts is:
Applied Energy Density, EA is
𝑃
EA = where, P = laser power, U= Scan velocity
(𝑈∗𝑆𝑃)
SP = Scan spacing of parallel lines.
For pLS., typical SP is ~100 μm, whereas typical laser spot sizes are
~300 μm. Thus, typically every point is scanned by multiple passes.
Above equation, does not include powder absorptivity, heat of fusion,
laser spot size, bed temperature, or other important characteristics.
Powder Handling Challenges:
Any powder delivery system for PBF must meet at least four characteristics.
1. It must have a powder reservoir of sufficient to maximum build height.
2. Volume of layer transported must cover the previous layer, without wasteful.
3. The powder must be spread to form a smooth, thin, repeatable layer.
4. Spreading should not create excessive shear forces to disturb previous layer.
Universal characteristics of powder feeding must deal with:
1. As particle size decreases, inter particle friction and electrostatic forces
increase. These result in a situation where powder can lose its flowability.
2. When the surface area to volume ratio of a particle increases, its surface
energy increases and becomes more reactive. Kept inert atmosphere.
3. Small particles have a tendency to become airborne and float as a cloud.
4. Smaller powder sizes enable better surface finish, high accuracy, thin layer.
DMLS/SLM
Both Direct Metal Laser Sintering (DMLS) and Selective Laser Melting
(SLM) produce parts via similar method as SLS.
DMLS and SLM are used in the production of metal parts.
DMLS does not melt the powder but instead heats it to a point so that it
can fuse together on a molecular level. (Solid state sintering)
SLM uses the laser to achieve a full melt of the metal powder forming a
homogenous part. (Liquid phase sintering and full melting).
Unlike SLS, the DMLS and SLM processes require structural support, in
order to limit the likelihood of any distortion that may occur.
Risk of warping due to the residual stresses produced during printing due
to the high processing temperatures. Printed parts are typically heat treated.
Directed Energy Deposition
It refer to processes where the raw material is directed into a spatial location
where the energy input and the desired material deposition site are co-located.
Two processes currently can be categorized under this type:
The Laser Engineered Net Shaping (LENS),
The Electron Beam Freeform Fabrication (EBF3),
The Wire and Arc Additive Manufacturing (WAAM).
These processes are similar in working principles but differ in the energy
source used and the form of the raw materials used.
In LENS, a laser beam and powder raw material is typically used in an
articulating tool head where the powder is injected into a spot on a surface
where the laser beam focuses its energy onto.
LENS Process:
The melt-pool formed at this spot allows the material to be metallurgically
added into the existing surface and fused into the part being built.
By manipulating the spatial locations of the melt-pool, a complete 3D article can
be built spot-by-spot, line-by-line, and then layer-by-layer.
WAAM:
Following the similar working principle, but different raw material form and
energy input.
The WAAM process feeds a metal wire into the melt-pool that is produced by
the arc struck between the feed wire and the substrate/existing surface.
It’s an automated Metal Inert Gas (MIG) Welding process in which weld
tool is controlled to follow paths that fill up a 3D part with weld lines.
The EBF3
Process was first developed by the NASA and is intrinsically a space-
compatible technology.
It uses the working principles that combine LENS and WAAM in that it
uses a wire feed system to introduce materials into a melt-pool generated
by an energy source.
In EBF3, the energy source used is an electron beam and the build
environment is under high vacuum to ensure focusing the operation.
The processes in the Direct Energy Deposition category all fall into the
category of Direct-Write technology.
Where the material of a 3D part is introduced locally into the part by
continuously directing both energy input and material into the same site.
Tyre Mould.
Similarly to mLS, in the EBM process, a focused electron beam scans across a
thin layer of pre-laid powder, causing localized melting and resolidification per
the slice cross section.
Laser beams heat the powder when photons are absorbed by powder particles.
Electron beams, however, heat powder by transfer of kinetic energy from
incoming electrons into powder particles.
As powder particles absorb electrons they gain higher negative charge.
This has two potentially detrimental effects:
(1) If the repulsive force of neighboring negatively charged particles
overcomes the gravitational and frictional forces holding them in place,
there will be a rapid expulsion of powder particles from powder bed,
creating a powder cloud.
(2) Increasing negative charges in the powder particles will tend to repel the
incoming negatively charged electrons, thus creating a more diffuse beam.
There are no such complimentary phenomena with photons.
As a result, the conductivity of the powder bed in EBM must be high
enough that powder particles do not become highly negatively charged.
Scan strategies must be used to avoid build-up of regions of -ve charged.
GE Aviation acquired Avio Aero in 2013 and developed the GE9X engine for
Boeing’s next-generation 777X jets.
The 3D-printed blades spin inside the engine at 2,500 times per minute and
face searing heat and titanic forces. “These are big blades”.
The 3D printing factory, which looks like a blue and gray jewel box of steel
and glass from the outside, holds 20 black, wardrobe-sized 3D printers,
from Arcam.
A single machine can simultaneously print six turbine blades directly from
a computer file by using a powerful 3-KW electron beam.
The beam “grows” the blades, which are 40 centimeters long, by welding
together thin layers of titanium aluminide (TiAl) powder. (Brittle)
It weighs 50 percent less than the metal alloys typically used in aviation.
GE cast the blades in a foundry, but Avio Aero, which wanted to go after the
emerging TiAl market, bet on 3D printing.
“We could see how difficult it was to make these blades,” Abrate says. “But
we had positive experiences with 3D printing on a military project.”
https://www.ge.com/reports/future-manufacturing-take-look-inside-
factory-3d-printing-jet-engine-parts/
But early runs with ProtoCast’s laser-powered printers failed. The blades
were cracking when Abrate and the team tried to separate them from the
platform on which they were printed.
For submarine: a powerful Arcam printer that print parts from TiAl powder.
Abrate reached out to make the powder layer thicker and speed up printing.
Running more experiments preheating the powder before printing removed
much of the residual stress from the finished parts.
The blades from Cameri are already working inside the first GE9X engines,
which GE started testing last year.
These and other new materials and technologies will help make the engine 10
percent more fuel-efficient than its predecessor, the GE90.
That’s a big deal given that fuel accounts for about 19 percent of an airline’s
operating costs.
“You have the ultimate manufacturing freedom.”
Questions (SLS)
Q.1 Show block diagram representing different fusion mechanisms applied in
PBF process along with type of powder used if applicable.
2. Enlist powder handling challenges in PBF process.
3. Draw block diagram showing setup for SLS technology.
4. Brief about polymer materials applied in SLS printing machine.
5. Explain two important design considerations in designing SLS component.
6. Compare two powder binding mechanisms in PBF systems.
7. Discuss separate and coated particles in PBF system.
8. List powder handling challenges in PBF process.
9. Brief Powder handling systems in PBF process.
10.
3D PRINTING
Z corporation 3DP.mp4
Binding energy: its surface energy and kinetic energy.
Its amount is low, about 104 times more efficient than sinter binding (SLS).
Process Parameters: Properties of powder, Binder material and Accuracy of
XY table and Z axis control.
Process:
1. Spread layer of powder from feed box to surface of build piston.
Ink-jet print head print binder solution on loose powder, build first c/s.
For multi-colour use of multiple print-heads.
2. Gluing of powder obtained by binder at specific printed position.
(Droplets: typically 80 microns in diameter)
Metal powder is bound using a polymer binding agent.
3. Other powder is loose and it gives supports to following layers.
4. For next layer, new powder layer is spread over build platform and binder
printing by ink-jet….. Component building.
5. Post processing: Loose powder is vacuumed away and part is ready.
Finishing of part-left raw (review), dipped in wax, sanding, painting.
Fig. Binder jetting in 3D printing process.
Inkjet printing.mp4
Video of Ink-jet 3d printing
Strength and Limitations
1. High speed: each layer is printed in few seconds in HS printers.
2. Versatile: parts are used for automotive, footwear, medical an aerospace
and telecommunication industry.
For Design, Communication and limited Functional testing.
Parts can be infiltered-changes its properties.
3. Simple to operate: Z corporation systems/machines are easy to operate.
System is standard and reliable and dependable 3d printing.
4. Minimal wastage of material: support/unused powder can be reused.
5. Color: it enable complex color schemes for RP parts with full 24-bit
palette of colors.
Limitations:
1. Limited functional capability: relative to SLS process, parts build are
much weak, limits functional testing capability.
2. Poor surface finish: poor finish and need post processing.
Applications:
1. Concept and Functional models, Complex geometries.
2. CAD-casting metal parts:
3. Direct metal parts: limited
4. Structural Ceramics:
5. Functionally gradient materials: can create composite materials also.
Examples: Sports shoe industry
Used by designer, marketers and managers in footwear industry.
E.g. Adidas, Nike, New balance and Wolverine used to develop prototype
GE Additive: 100,000 patients later: The 3D-printed hip is a decade old and going strong
Automobile Industry
Ford, Bentlee, F1 racing and Porsche: to enhance internal communication on
product enhancement.
Direct metal casting: pour metal directly in moulds printed on Z Corp.
Developments of patterns for investment casting and sand casting process.
Creates sand-casting molds for non-ferrous metals.
Mould Material: blend of foundry sand, plaster, and other additives,
produce strong molds with good surface finishes.
Mould can withstand the heat required to cast non-ferrous metals.
Users of this “ZCast®” process can create prototype castings without
incurring the costs and lead-time delays of tooling
Powder bed fusion (PBF), directed energy deposition (DED), binder jetting
(BJ). DED is also called laser cladding and is frequently used to add material
to an existing part, especially for part repair.
With the exception of binder jetting, most metal AM methods print with a
single point, or several fine points, within one printer, and are therefore
much slower than printing with a gantry covered in print heads. This limits
their ability to be considered for serial production.
1. What factors are taken into consideration while designing for SLS
process? Brief two factors and their role.
2. Brief various application fields along with example, where SLS process
is applied.