Decision Tree Case Study
A new product has been developed by a company and
preliminary marketing potential has been estimated as a
chance of 40% (0.4 probability value) for successful
launch which would result in annual profit with net
present value 2,000,000 EUR and failure would mean a
loss of 300,000 EUR.
Options
Drop the idea
Launch immediately
Try in a test market (cost 40.000)
Case Study
Possible test results
(a)less than 10% of the public decided to test (we should think of dropping the idea)
(b)more than 10% of public decided to test but less than 25% of those who try
decide to buy on a second or subsequent occasion
(c)more than 10% of public decided to test and repeat purchase rate is 25% or more
Based on subjective estimates of experts:
(a) has prob. 0.5, (b) has prob. 0.25 and (c) has prob. 0.25
Test market response
(a) (b) (c)
Success (S) 0.1 0.4 1.0
Failure 0.9 0.6 0.0
Decision Tree
2
1
4
7
3
5
8
6
9
Decision Tree Analysis
2
1
4 7
3
5
8
6
9
Decision Strategy Not launched due
to negative EMV
therefore final
Decision scenarios expected monetary
1 – Drop : EMV = 0 value is
1–2 : EMV= 620,000
1 – 3 -4 –Drop : EMV =-40,000 or Launch: EMV = -70,000 0,5 0
1 – 3 -5 –Drop : EMV =-40,000 or Launch: EMV = 620,000 0,25 155,000 EMV: 615,000
1 – 3 -6 –Drop : EMV =-40,000 or Launch: EMV = 2,000,000 0,25 500,000 (655K-40K)
Risks
1-2 EMV 620,000 Risk is -180,000
1-3 EMV 615,000 Risk is -45,000-40,000 (you can also add the = - 85,000
Conclusion:
WITH LESS THAN 1% DECREASE IN YOUR EXPECTED MONETARY VALUE (615K instead of 620K)
YOU CAN DECREASE YOUR RISK SUBSTANTIALLY (-180K to -85K)
Recommended Action: TRY IN THE TEST MARKET