Moll Flanders LitChart
Moll Flanders LitChart
com
Moll Flanders
instruction for the modest reader looking to live an honest life.
INTR
INTRODUCTION
ODUCTION He references “the Advocates of the Stage,” who have argued
through the ages for the usefulness of plays when “applied to
BRIEF BIOGRAPHY OF DANIEL DEFOE virtuous Purposes.” Beginning in the 16th century, plays
Defoe was born in the parish of St. Giles Cripplegate in London performed in public settings (such as theaters) were thought to
to James Foe, a successful candle-maker and butcher, and his carry messages of excessive humor and vice, which some
wife, Anne, who died when Defoe was just 10 years old. Defoe’s feared would poison society and lead to increased sin and
father was a Presbyterian dissenter—meaning he did not follow crime. Additionally, there was some concern over playwrights,
the Church of England—and even though it was illegal to who were often of the lower classes, representing royalty and
worship outside the Church of England, Defoe was educated at the upper classes, and some worried that plays and the theater
a dissenting academy in London, where he most likely attended would lead to the feminization of society, since men and boys
a Unitarian church. After his schooling, Defoe became a often played women’s roles. In 1642, London theaters closed
merchant, dealing mostly in wool and wine, and he married entirely and the official stance on plays aligned with that of the
Mary Tuffley, a wealthy merchant’s daughter, in 1684. Defoe Puritans: the theater exposed citizens to “lascivious Mirth and
was accused of marrying Mary for her dowry, but though it is Levity” and made them more susceptible to sin and immorality.
said they had a rocky union, they were married for 47 years and London theaters remained closed until 1660, at which time the
had eight children together. In 1685, he joined the Monmouth English monarchy was restored, and theaters as they are
Rebellion, which attempted to overthrow King James II of known today opened. The “Advocates of the Stage” that Defoe
England, but Defoe was later pardoned. After Mary II and mentions in Moll Flanders supported the theater as a form of
William III were crowned as Queen and King of England in moral instruction and warning, which is exactly how Defoe sells
1689, Defoe worked as a trusted adviser and spy for King Moll’s story—as a cautionary tale. Defoe’s note situates Moll
William. By 1692, Defoe was bankrupt and later arrested and Flanders within a historical context that was still very
jailed for excessive debts. After he was released from prison, conservative in its views of sin and virtue (especially for
Defoe travelled for a bit before returning to England in 1696. woman) but that was becoming more open to considering
Around this time, Defoe began writing—mostly political, depictions of sin—so long as they served a moral purpose.
economic, and social essays and pamphlets—and published An
essay upon projects, a series of writings on society and RELATED LITERARY WORKS
economics, in 1697. In 1703, Defoe was arrested for his
political and religious views—like his father, Defoe was a Defoe’s novels Robinson Crusoe and Moll Flanders are seen by
nonconformist—and he was sent to Newgate Prison, the same many as the earliest English novels. Defoe’s novels, while not
prison where Moll Flanders is held in Defoe’s novel of the same always received well in his day, paved the way for other major
name. He was later released and went on to write over 300 novels of the 18th century, such as Samuel Richardson’s
essays, novels, and pamphlets. He published his most famous epistolary novel, Pamela, or Virtue Rewarded and Laurence
work, Robinson Crusoe
Crusoe, in 1719; however, the book was Sterne’s Tristram Shandy. Early English novels such as these
originally published with Robinson Crusoe as the author as well influenced generations of English novelists, including Charles
as the title character and was received much like a travel Dickens, who went on to write some of the Victorian era’s most
journal. Defoe wrote Moll Flanders in 1722, but the book was famous novels, like Gr Great
eat Expectations
Expectations, David Copperfield
Copperfield, and
published without an author and was assumed to be an Oliv
Oliver
er T
Twist
wist. Defoe’s Moll Flanders is, above all, a critique of
autobiography. It was not until 1770, many years after Defoe’s 17th- and 18th-century English society, a tradition that is well
death, that he was credited as the book’s author by a London established in English literature. Other works that remark on
bookseller. He wrote one of his last books, The Complete English the state of English society include Down and Out in P Paris
aris and
Tradesman, a political work that also focuses on trade, London and 1984 by George Orwell, as well as Aldous Huxley’s
economics, and marriage, in 1726. Defoe died of a likely stroke Br
Brav
avee New W
World
orld. Moll Flanders also explores marriage and the
in 1731, at which time he was penniless and still running from role of women in society, a theme that is central to works
creditors. He was 70 years old. including Anna KarKarenina
enina by Leo Tolstoy, George Eliot’s
Middlemar
Middlemarch ch, and The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton.
HISTORICAL CONTEXT
KEY FACTS
In the preface of Moll Flanders, Defoe claims Moll’s
story—which is full of “Debauchery and Vice”—is useful • Full Title: The Fortunes and Misfortunes of the Famous Moll
This quote appears in the early stages of Moll’s story, after money. The marriage market in London during Moll’s time is
she notes that some countries take care of orphaned tough, and only those with the best dowries are offered the
children, and it is important because it reflects Defoe’s best husbands.
argument that Moll’s life of immorality is the direct result of Women are expected to fill a very limited role in Moll’s
English society’s failure to care for orphaned children. society—they remain in the domestic sphere and usually
Moll’s mother gives birth to her in prison, and she is marry young—and they are expected to have “Beauty, Birth,
transported to America when Moll is just six months old. Breeding, Wit, Sense, Manners, Modesty, and all these to an
Moll is, quite literally, “left a poor desolate Girl without Extream.” Still, without money—without a sizable dowry to
Friends, without Cloaths, without Help or Helper in the offer her new husband—a woman is nothing. Moll, of
World.” She is taken in and cared for by strangers, but it course, doesn’t have any money, and as such, she has
seems Moll never really has a chance in life. nothing to “recommend” her to potential husbands, despite
If Moll had been cared for early in life—had caring for her beauty and fine manners. As a woman’s role is limited to
orphaned children and giving them the life they should have either marriage or working as a servant, Moll has little
had with their parents “been the Custom in [Moll’s] choice in the direction her life takes, but she is determined
Country”—Defoe implies that Moll might not have been to make her own money and provide for her herself.
destined “to the swift Destruction of both Soul and Body.”
Moll lives a tough life of poverty, crime, and prostitution,
and this “scandalous” existence takes its toll on her, Then he walk’d about the Room, and taking me by the
especially on her morality. Morality and ethics are of the Hand, I walk’d with him; and by and by, taking his
utmost importance in 17th-century English society; Advantage, he threw me down upon the Bed, and Kiss’d me
however, in Moll’s case, society is also the very reason why there most violently; but to give him his Due, offer’d no manner
Moll is unable to claim the moral high ground. of Rudeness to me, only Kiss’d me a great while; after this he
thought he had heard some Body come up Stairs, so he got off
from the Bed, lifted me up, professing a great deal of Love for
The Older Brother and Moll’s First Marriage me, but told me it was all an honest Affection, and that he
Quotes meant no ill to me; and with that he put five Guineas into my
I wonder at you Brother, says the Sister; Betty wants but Hand, and went away down Stairs.
one Thing, but she had as good want every Thing, for the
Market is against our Sex just now; and if a young Woman have Related Characters: Moll Flanders (speaker), The Older
Beauty, Birth, Breeding, Wit, Sense, Manners, Modesty, and all Brother
these to an Extream; yet if she have not Money, she’s no Body,
she had as good want them all, for nothing but Money now Related Themes:
recommends a Woman […].
Page Number: 62
Related Characters: Moll Flanders (speaker), The Lady, The Explanation and Analysis
Older Brother This quote appears early in Moll’s relationship with the
older brother, and it is significant because it reflects the
Related Themes:
novel’s connection between sex and money and suggests
Page Number: 58 that the older brother doesn’t have the best intentions for
Moll. The older brother waits for the perfect time to take
Explanation and Analysis “his Advantage” with Moll. He goes upstairs to her room and
This quote occurs when Moll is living with the lady and her waits for everyone to leave, and then he throws her on her
family, and it reflects the impossible ideal expected of bed and kisses her “most violently.” He offers Moll “no
women in the sexist society of 17th-century England. Moll manner of Rudeness,” but he clearly doesn’t respect her, as
relays this quote, which is spoken to the older brother by he is rough and jumps up the moment he hears someone
one of his sisters after he admits that he thinks Moll is coming. The older brother’s quick action implies he is
beautiful. The older brother’s sister warns him that Moll, a ashamed of his relationship with Moll—or, at least, that he
poor orphan, is only after “one Thing”: the older brother’s doesn’t want others to know about it.
The older brother professes “a great deal of Love” for Moll with only the older brother’s purse. This purse turns into
and claims to have “an honest Affection” for her. Yet he Moll’s “Bank of Money,” which she keeps and builds
keeps their relationship a secret and gives Moll throughout the novel to care for herself, indicating that for
money—“five Guineas”—as a way to convince her that he disadvantaged women like Moll, virtue and money often
means “no ill” to her. This gift of money and the older come to be interchangeable.
brother’s “violent” kisses begin a connection between sex
and money that will last throughout the whole novel. The
older brother makes it clear that he is sexually attracted to Moll Marries the Linen-Draper Quotes
Moll, and he makes it known that he is willing to pay for it,
Upon these Apprehensions the first thing I did, was to go
introducing her to the harsh reality that offering sex will
quite out of my Knowledge, and go by another Name: This I did
often be her easiest path to financial security.
effectually, for I went into the Mint too, took Lodgings in a very
private Place, drest me up in the Habit of a Widow, and call’d
myself Mrs. Flanders.
My Colour came and went, at the Sight of the Purse, and
with the fire of his Proposal together; so that I could not
Related Characters: Moll Flanders (speaker), The Linen-
say a Word, and he easily perceiv’d it; so putting the Purse into
Draper
my Bosom, I made no more Resistance to him, but let him do
just what he pleas’d; and as often as he pleas’d; and thus I Related Themes:
finish’d my own Destruction at once, for from this Day, being
forsaken of my Virtue, and my Modesty, I had nothing of Value Page Number: 108
left to recommend me, either to God’s Blessing, or Man’s
Assistance. Explanation and Analysis
This quote occurs after Moll’s second husband, the linen-
Related Characters: Moll Flanders (speaker), The Older draper, leaves her. It highlights Moll’s evolving identity and
Brother also emphasizes the connection between sex and money
within the novel. After the linen-draper leaves, Moll is left in
Related Themes: debt and is in danger of being thrown in debtors’ prison.
Knowing this, Moll thinks it is best “to go quite out of [her]
Related Symbols: Knowledge”—that is, go to where no one knows her—and
change her name. Moll takes refuge at “the Mint,” a district
Page Number: 68 in London that is a jurisdictional interzone due to the coin
mint that used to operate there. In the district of the Mint,
Explanation and Analysis the local authorities don’t have jurisdiction and criminals
This quote occurs after the older brother proposes to Moll, can’t be arrested there, making it the perfect place for
and it is significant because it further underscores the debtors like Moll.
connection between sex and money in the novel. When the Moll calls herself “Mrs. Flanders,” a name that is also given
older brother proposes to Moll, he also gives her a purse of to her later in the book by her criminal associates.
100 Guineas and offers to give her 100 more each year “Flanders” is a reference to the Women of Flanders, the
until they are married. Moll swoons at the purse and Flemish women who were known as London’s best
proposal—her “Colour came and went”—and she is prostitutes at the time. By giving herself the name Mrs.
speechless. At the “Sight of the Purse,” Moll offers the older Flanders, Moll implies that she isn’t opposed to prostitution
brother “no more Resistance,” meaning she finally consents to support herself. As Defoe claims Moll was made to
to have sex with him. rewrite her story in more modest words, Moll’s sexual
As a poor orphan girl, Moll has no money and no dowry, encounters, especially those involving prostitution, are
which is the only thing society truly cares about, and all she subtle, and her name is a prime example of this. Much of the
has of value is her virtue—which is to say, her virginity. The inappropriateness has been scrubbed from Moll’s story, but
older brother takes that virtue, and he gives Moll 100 her name—which also serves as the title of the book—is a
Guineas in return. This trade, however, isn’t exactly fair, and clear indicator of Moll’s true behavior.
it leads to Moll’s “Destruction.” Without her virtue, Moll has
“nothing of value left to recommend [her],” and she is left
desolate State.” In other words, Moll is destitute, and she becomes easy, like second nature, and Moll transforms into
has no friends, money, or food, and she asks the reader what a talented thief. In this way, Defoe illustrates how the life of
they would do in her shoes, with “want of Friends and want a criminal like Moll can get so out of hand.
of Bread.” The answer to Moll seems simple: steal or die.
Moll is initially ashamed of her need to steal (although this
shame doesn’t seem to stick), and she wants the reader to Moll’s Crimes Escalate Quotes
know this. She knows it isn’t easy to accept her or her sins, On the other hand, every Branch of my Story, if duly
and she isn’t looking for pity or a handout—she doesn’t want consider’d, may be useful to honest People, and afford a due
others to think “of sparing what they have”—she simply Caution to People of some sort or other to Guard against the
wants others to look “to Heaven for support” and remember like Surprizes, and to have their Eyes about them when they
“the wise Man’s Prayer, Give me no Poverty lest I Steal.” Moll have to do with Strangers of any kind, for ’tis very seldom that
doesn’t steal because she is an inherently immoral person; some Snare or other is not in their way. The Moral indeed of all
she steals to stay alive, and her plea here reflects Defoe’s my History is left to be gather’d by the Senses and Judgment of
argument about the link between poverty and crime. the Reader; I am not Qualified to preach to them, let the
Experience of one Creature compleatly Wicked, and
compleatly Miserable be a Storehouse of useful warning to
Moll and the Drunk Man Quotes those that read.
Thus you see having committed a Crime once, is a sad
Handle to the committing of it again; whereas all the Regret, Related Characters: Moll Flanders (speaker)
and Reflections wear off when the Temptation renews it self;
had I not yielded to see him again, the Corrupt desire in him Related Themes:
had worn off, and ’tis very probable he had never fallen into it,
with any Body else, as I really believe he had not done before. Page Number: 343
THE PREFACE
It may be difficult, Defoe says, for readers to take the following Moll isn’t who she says she is, and her concealed identity
pages as genuine when names and circumstances are immediately makes her story appear mysterious. Since Moll
concealed; however, readers must pass their own opinion on originally wrote her story in the language of Newgate Prison
the following story. The author, Moll Flanders, is writing her (London’s main prison for over 700 years), the reader can infer that
story, and she will detail early on why she must conceal her she is some kind of criminal. This passage also suggests that Moll
identity. Defoe admits that the story was rewritten, and Moll isn’t really remorseful for whatever it is she has done, a question
was made to tell her story more delicately than she did at first. that will come up over and over again throughout the novel.
The first copy of Moll’s story was written in the language of
Newgate Prison, not as a remorseful woman, as she claims to
be.
For the one finishing Moll’s story, it was difficult to “put it into a Defoe’s claim that Moll’s story must be “put into a Dress fit to be
Dress fit to be seen.” Moll is a woman depraved from her youth seen” reflects the sexism that pervades most of the book. Society
and is the very “Off-spring of Debauchery and Vice,” but great expects women to be pictures of modesty and virtue, and Moll’s
care has been taken to avoid giving readers any “lewd Ideas.” It story—and by extension Moll herself—must be modified to fit that
is recommended that only those who will make good use of the ideal; that is, they must be dressed up in order to become
story read it, and such readers are likely to find they are more acceptable to polite society. Moll’s identity as one of “Debauchery
pleased with the moral than the actual story. As “the Advocates and Vice” and the “lewd Ideas” Defoe mentions suggest Moll’s story
for the Stage have in all Ages made this great Argument,” Defoe is one of sex and sin. In the 15th and 16th centuries, theaters and
maintains, there is something to be learned from wicked plays were often considered dangerous examples of vice that
stories. As such, there is something to be learned from every influenced people to sin. Those who supported the theater, however,
part of Moll’s story—if the reader wishes to make use of it. maintained that plays were valuable examples of what not to do.
Defoe suggests the same thing here and offers Moll’s story for moral
instruction, not entertainment.
MOLL’S CHILDHOOD
Moll’s real name is well known in the records at Newgate and Newgate Prison and London’s courthouse sat at the corner of
Old-Baily—and some things of significance are still pending Newgate and Old-Baily Streets; thus, Newgate and Old-Baily are
there—so she has concealed her identity. It is enough for the synonymous with crime and criminals. As Moll has concealed her
reader to know that some of Moll’s “worst Comrades” (who can identity over things pending there, it can again be inferred that Moll
no longer hurt her, as they have left the world “by the Steps and is a criminal, and perhaps a wanted one at that. Moll’s “worst
the String”), gave her the name Moll Flanders. This name will be Comrades” were obviously criminals, as they went out by “the Steps
used, Moll says, “till I dare own who I have been, as well as who I and the String,” which is to say they were hanged for their crimes.
am.” Moll’s comment as to who she was and who she is now suggests
that identity evolves and changes over time, and she isn’t the same
person she used to be. Furthermore, the name Moll Flanders is itself
highly suggestive. “Moll” is English slang for a low-class woman of ill-
repute, and “Flanders” carries connotations of sex and prostitution,
as London’s most prominent prostitutes for years were Flemish
women (that is, women from Flanders). As Moll’s name was given to
her by people who knew her, it must have special significance, and
this suggests that Moll is both a criminal and a prostitute.
In some European countries, when a criminal is ordered to Defoe implies that England’s failure to care for orphaned children is
prison, death, or transportation, any children they have are directly to blame for the “destruction” of Moll’s “Soul and Body,”
taken into the care of the government until the children are which indicates that Moll’s morals are destroyed, as well as her
able to provide and care for themselves. Had this been the case physical wellbeing. Defoe suggests here that Moll is more a victim
in Moll’s country, had she not been left to fend for herself, than she is a criminal, and the fault lies with society.
perhaps her story would not entail “the swift Destruction both
of Soul and Body.”
Moll’s mother was a criminal, convicted of a felony for stealing Punishment was harsh in the 17th century, as evidenced by Moll’s
three pieces of fabric, and she is sentenced to death. She mother’s death sentence for stealing fabric. Pregnant women were
“[pleads] her Belly,” however, and Moll is born seven months given a stay of execution if they “pleaded their Belly” (that is, asked
later. In the meantime, Mother’s sentence is commuted to to be treated gently due to their pregnancy,), or they were deported
transportation to the Plantations, and she leaves Moll at just six to the American colonies to be sold as servants. Moll is just an
months old. Moll is taken in by family for a time, but she infant, and she is completely neglected and left uncared for, which
somehow ends up in the care of a wandering group of reflects, as Defoe suggests, a major problem in English society.
Egyptians. The Egyptians leave Moll in Colchester, where she is London churches often cared for orphans if the children were born
taken to the church. The church provides for Moll, but she is into that parish, but Moll—born in a prison with no church
too young—only three years old—to do any work. The affiliation—slips through the cracks. Women of the lower class are
Magistrates place Moll under the care of a nurse, who makes expected to “go to Service” when they come of age, which means
her living keeping children for the church until they are old they are expected to work as maids, cooks, or in other service
enough to “go to Service, or get their own Bread.” positions, and this reflects the limited opportunities available to
women during Moll’s time.
All day long, Moll works and weeps, until the nurse asks her The fact that Moll is expected to go into Service at such a young age
why she is crying. Moll explains that she doesn’t want to go to underscores the oppression of women, especially lower-class
Service, where the other maids will surely beat her and make women like Moll, in English society. Those in Service are little more
her do difficult work. The nurse convinces the mayor not to than slaves, and they are clearly abused and exploited, as Moll fears
send Moll to Service until she is older, but for Moll, this isn’t violence and forced labor. While Moll doesn’t know it yet, a
enough. She never wants to go to Service. “What,” asks the “Gentlewoman” is a polite term for a prostitute, and the nurse
nurse, “would you be a Gentlewoman?” Moll explains she will; implies here that if Moll doesn’t go to Service, her only other option
she will make three-pence for embroidery and four pennies for is prostitution.
sewing. The nurse assures Moll that won’t keep her, but Moll
promises to work harder—and give all her money to the nurse.
Moved by Moll’s sadness and determination, the nurse agrees Clearly, Moll thinks being a “Gentlewoman” means not being poor
to keep Moll. The nurse relays Moll’s pleas to the mayor, who and going into Service. The mayor calls in his family to laugh at
calls in his wife and daughters to hear the story, and they all Moll’s story because, in her innocence, she has said she wants to be
laugh and laugh. A week later, the mayor’s wife comes to visit. a prostitute. The lady means just what she says—that Moll should
She asks Moll if she is the little girl who wants to be a work hard, since she only has a life of service ahead of her—but her
“Gentlewoman,” and Moll confirms she is. The woman smiles words take on new significance in the sexual context that Moll
warmly and gives Moll a shilling. “Mind [your] work,” the woman doesn’t yet understand. Furthermore, when she gives Moll a shilling,
says, “and learn to Work well.” Moll doesn’t realize, however, it creates a connection between sex and money that continues
that she does not have the same understanding of a throughout the book.
“Gentlewoman” as everyone else.
Moll continues her work, all the while talking about how she Clearly, the “Gentlewoman” Moll speaks of is the madam of a
will become a “Gentlewoman.” The nurse later asks Moll what brothel and a prostitute herself, since she is of “ill Fame, and has had
she means by “Gentlewoman,” and Moll explains that it is a two or three Bastards.” The nurse’s claim that Moll may soon be a
woman who supports herself without going to Service. Moll Gentlewoman just like the madam foreshadows Moll’s future life of
tells the nurse about a woman in town, who mends lace and crime and prostitution. This passage also reflects the limited
launders ladies’ hats. “She,” Moll says, “is a Gentlewoman, and opportunities of women, as Moll is stuck between a life of servitude
they call her Madam.” The kindly nurse explains. “Poor child,” or a life of prostitution, even though she dreams of simply working
she says, “you may soon be such a Gentlewoman as that, for she hard to support herself.
is a Person of ill Fame, and has had two or three Bastards.”
By the time Moll is 14, she has grown even more beautiful. She The lady is wealthy and of the upper class, and Moll was exposed to
continues working for the nurse, which, since Moll’s “Taste of this luxury during her “Taste of Genteel” living. The nurse, by
Genteel” living at the lady’s house, isn’t as easy as it used to be. comparison, is poor, and Moll finds it difficult to return to poverty
In short time, the nurse grows sick and dies. The nurse’s after a taste of high-class living. Defoe implies that the nurse’s
daughter, a woman with six or seven children, comes to clean daughter keeps Moll’s money even though she knows it didn’t
out the house; however, she refuses to give Moll the money the belong to the nurse, but her six or seven kids suggest she badly
nurse was holding for her. Alone and frightened, Moll is pleased needs the money and perhaps only keeps it to take care of them,
when the maid of the lady with whom Moll previously spent a reinforcing the idea that dire circumstances can push people into
week arrives to get her. The mayor’s wife also offers to take her immoral behavior.
in, but Moll is more than happy to live with the lady and her
family.
Moll is more confused with the money than she is with the love. Moll has been made to clean up her story, which is why she can’t
She is a young woman who thinks herself pretty, and she has no politely mention what she did with the older brother; however, they
reason to doubt the older brother’s love for her. He soon do not have sex, since they don’t reach “the last Favour.” There is
returns—there was no one coming, he says—and quickly takes again a connection between sex and money, and as the older
to kissing her again. He tells Moll that he loves her passionately, brother strings Moll along with marriage proposals and brings her
and that he wants to marry her. He kisses her again, and they closer to actually having sex, he pays her—which is sure to keep her
go farther than Moll can politely mention; however, it does not coming back and get him what he wants.
reach “that, which they call the last Favour.” Then, the older
brother gives Moll a handful of gold and exits.
Moll, full of “Vanity and Pride, and but a very little Stock of Defoe suggests that Moll’s “Vanity and Pride” are also a source of
Virtue,” thinks only of gold and the older brother’s words. her undoing. Had Moll not been so vain, she may have noticed the
Careful not to draw suspicion, Moll goes to great lengths to older brother’s true intentions and realized that he is only taking
ignore him in the company of others, until the day he secretly advantage of her and has no intention of marrying her. The way the
passes her a note in the hall. He says he will publicly order Moll older brother and his family order Moll around reflects her low
on an errand the next day, and then he will meet her on her way standing in their house and society. She isn’t a servant or a maid
to town. Sure enough, the older brother orders Moll to town exactly, but she is certainly treated like one.
the next day on some petty errands, after which a man comes
to the door in a coach. He needs the older brother on urgent
business in town, the man says.
Moll swoons at the sight of the older brother’s purse and the Moll swoons upon seeing how much the older brother will pay her,
sound of his proposal, and she does not resist as he has his way which suggests she is as attracted to his money and the financial
with her. With this, Moll forsakes her virtue, and she is left with security and social status he represents as she is to the brother
“nothing of Value to recommend [her].” Afterward, Moll and the himself. Presumably, Moll has sex with him on the condition he
older brother have many occasions to repeat their “Crime,” plans to marry her. In Moll’s time, a woman’s worth is judged by her
until the younger brother confesses his own love to Moll. He virginity and chastity—the description of sex as a “Crime” reflects
wants to marry her, too, the younger brother says, but Moll the immorality of sex before marriage—and Moll is now essentially
firmly resists him. They are an unequal match, she says, and it worthless.
wouldn’t be the right way to repay the lady for taking her in.
Moll doesn’t, however, tell him the truth.
To Moll’s surprise, the younger brother does not hide his Marrying outside of one’s social class was frowned on in the 17th
feelings like the older brother, and he makes it plain to the lady century, which is why the lady begins to resent Moll once she
and the rest of his family that he is in love with Moll. Soon, the discovers her son is in love with her. It is customary for women to
lady and her family begin to treat Moll differently, and one of come to their husbands with a dowry, which Moll obviously doesn’t
the maids tells Moll that she will soon be asked to leave. Moll have. Moll doesn’t bring any money to the table, and she will only
isn’t surprised. Plus, since she expects to be pregnant at any cost them money instead. This passage also portrays the desperate
time, she expects to have to leave soon. The younger brother nature of Moll’s situation, as she is likely to become pregnant and
tells Moll that he will tell his family that he intends to marry her. homeless at any time but can do little to change her situation.
They may resent it, he says, but he is a lawyer and can take care
of Moll himself.
Moll has “no great Scruples of Conscience,” but even she Moll has “no great Scruples,” which suggests she is of poor moral
cannot imagine “being a Whore to one Brother, and Wife to the fortitude since she began having sex with the older brother. Moll
other.” Still, the older brother hasn’t mentioned marriage since frequently refers to herself as a “Whore,” which she becomes the
they began having sex. Moll doesn’t know what to do about the moment she takes the older brother’s money and has sex with him,
younger brother. She is sure she will soon be put out on the but Defoe implies that her choice is understandable; without
street, which must be no secret to the older brother. She begins money, she has no real social standing or ability to take care of
to think seriously for the first time and decides to tell the older herself. The older brother clearly has no intention of marrying
brother that she will soon be kicked out of the house. Moll—he hasn’t even talked about it—and he likely knows she will be
kicked out but doesn’t care.
It is bad enough the lady knows the younger brother is in love The older brother’s kiss and gift of money again underscore the
with Moll, but it will be much worse when the lady finds out connection between sex and money. What Moll is really saying is
Moll denied him. The lady is sure to suspect that Moll is in love that she can’t marry the younger brother because she has already
with another if she is turning down such a match as the had sex with the older brother. If she marries the younger brother, he
younger brother. The older brother asks Moll to do nothing for may find out she isn’t a virgin, which would likely be detrimental to
the time being and give him time to think. Moll reminds him their marriage—and to Moll’s security.
that she can’t possibly agree to marry the younger brother
when she is already engaged to the older brother; she already
thinks of herself as married to the older brother. He kisses her
and gives her more money, and then he leaves.
Days later, the older brother tells the younger brother that he The younger brother is convinced he will have Moll, which reflects
heard stories that the younger brother is in love with Moll. Yes, the overall sexism of the time. He wants her, so he plans to have her;
the younger brother admits. He loves her more than any how Moll feels about it doesn’t really matter. He doesn’t believe Moll
woman in the world, and he will have her. The younger brother will deny him because he is rich and she is poor, and Moll would be
doesn’t believe that Moll will deny him. Moll can’t believe it foolish to turn down such an offer. Still, the younger brother clearly
when the older brother tells her later. She must deny the loves Moll, since he is willing to endure the resentment that he will
younger brother, and she can’t imagine why he expects she likely experience for marrying outside his class.
won’t. The older brother says that he reminded his brother that
Moll is poor, but Robin claimed to love her still. Well, says Moll,
if the younger brother proposes marriage now, she will say no
and tell him that she is already married.
The older brother says that telling anyone about his An explanation will be expected from Moll, and her refusal to give
relationship with Moll is not a good idea, and she agrees. He one again reflects her resistance to the sexism of the time. It isn’t
asks Moll what she will say when she denies the younger anyone’s business why Moll turns down a marriage proposal, but
brother’s proposal. Moll doesn’t see why she owes anyone an society thinks otherwise. Society expects Moll to jump at the chance
explanation, but the older brother says offering no explanation to marry someone rich like the younger brother, but she isn’t
will be suspicious. Moll doesn’t know what to do, but the older interested—at this point, she still believes that that should be reason
brother says he has been thinking a lot about it. “Marry him,” enough.
the older brother says. Moll is shocked, but he says she should
at least consider it.
Moll reminds the older brother that even though they aren’t Moll considers herself married to the older brother because they
legally married, she is his wife just as sure as if the ceremony have already had sex. Since sex consummates a marriage, sex at this
had passed between them. She can’t possibly stop loving him time was considered just as important as the actual marriage
and consent to love the younger brother instead. She would ceremony, if not more so. Therefore, in Moll’s mind, they are already
rather, Moll says, be his “Whore” than the younger brother’s married. Of course, Moll truly loves the older brother, but he is just
wife. The older brother is obviously pleased with Moll’s exploiting Moll for sex and placating her with money. Moll again
affection for him, but he tells her he has done nothing to break calls herself a “Whore,” which reflects the sexist nature of society;
his promise to her. He says they can remain friends, and then he she’s doing what she thinks makes sense to secure her future and be
asks Moll if she is sure that she isn’t with child. Moll says she is with the man she loves, but society would view her as immoral for
sure, and he stands to leave. doing so.
Afterward, Moll falls ill with a fever. She is confined to bed for The older brother risks angering his family and losing his inheritance
five weeks, and her recovery is so slow that the doctor fears if his affair with Moll is discovered, in which case his reputation and
she will slip into a “Consumption.” The doctor claims that Moll’s status as a member of the upper class will be ruined. During Moll’s
“Mind [is] Oppress’d,” and he suspects that she is in love. The time, a “consumption” was known as a long, lingering illness, one
younger brother tells his family that if Moll were in love with that was often vague and nondescript. Consumption was often
him, he would gladly help her recover, and the older brother associated with depression and other forms of mental illness, which
begins to suspect that his brother knows about his relationship is why the doctor suspects Moll is in love.
with Moll. Moll assures the older brother that she has said
nothing of their affair, and she further says that she detests the
idea of marrying Robin and will never consent. “Then I am
Ruin’d,” the older brother says.
Weeks later, Moll is fully recovered, but she still suffers from Obviously, Moll isn’t being honest here. She cared nothing about the
bouts of melancholy and sadness. One day, Moll decides to tell lady’s consent when she agreed to marry the older brother. Moll is
the lady of the house about the younger brother’s proposals. clearly trying to manipulate the lady and get into her good graces
She tells the lady that Robin asked her several times to marry again, so she won’t be kicked out. Moll has little money and no way
him, but she resisted him each time, telling him that such a to support herself—unless she goes into Service, which Moll has
relationship cannot come to pass without the consent of the already said she absolutely will not do.
lady and master of the house. The lady is both shocked and
touched by Moll’s honesty. It seems, the lady says, that Moll has
treated them much better than they have treated her.
The older brother visits Moll in her room, where he gently Virginity and chastity are so important in society that Moll will be
kisses and hugs her. He tells Moll that she has the consent of ruined if she is found out. Here, the older brother puts a price on
the lady and the entire house to marry the younger brother. If Moll’s entire future and worth and basically pays her for potentially
Moll doesn’t, the older brother says, he fears that she will “be ruining her reputation. £500 is a lot of money (one could live in
sunk into the dark Circumstances of a Woman that has lost her relative luxury at £300 per year), but he insults Moll and reduces
Reputation.” He begs her to marry Robin, and then he gives her her worth to her body and sex—a common message in Moll’s sexist
£500. “To make you some Amends for the Freedoms I have society.
taken with you,” the older brother says. He adds that if Moll
refuses to marry Robin, their relationship can never be again
what it once was.
Afterward, Moll considers her life as “a meer cast off Whore,” Presumably, the older brother gets the younger brother drunk on
and she is terrified. She had never really considered the danger purpose, so he is less likely to notice that Moll is not a virgin. Moll
of her situation. If she is eventually dropped by both the older again calls herself a “Whore,” which society considers any woman
brother and the younger brother, she will be left to fend for who has sex out of wedlock to be, and this again underscores the
herself with nothing and no one to support her. With these extremely sexist and misogynistic nature of 17th-century England.
thoughts, Moll agrees to marry Robin, but she never loves him. This insulting view of women is so ingrained in society that even
On their wedding night, the older brother gets the younger Moll believes it about herself.
brother so drunk that he can’t remember whether their
marriage was consummated. Moll lies and assures him it was.
Moll lives with the younger brother as his wife for five years, Moll’s words suggest guilt over marrying the younger brother while
and they have two children together. Each time Moll is in bed being secretly in love with the older brother. Despite the slow
with her husband, she dreams of being with the older brother. deterioration of Moll’s morals, she clearly feels bad about her
“In short,” Moll says, “I committed Adultery and Incest with him decision to marry Robin (which she was forced to do by a sexist
every Day in my Desires,” which is just as criminal as actually society), and this suggests she isn’t innately immoral; she was simply
doing it. The older brother marries and moves to London, and doing what she had to do to survive. However, Moll also “happily”
at the end of five years, the younger brother dies. He was a kind abandons her children, which suggests that Moll’s morals are
man and a good husband, but Moll’s finances have not lacking. Conflicting actions such as these make it impossible to
improved by much. Hidden in her private bank, Moll still has decide if Moll is truly repentant at the end of the novel, or if she was
most of the money given to her by the older brother, about just an immoral opportunist all along.
£1,200, but that is all. The children are “taken happily off of
[Moll’s] Hands” by the lady and her husband, and she is free.
The linen-draper is arrested for his sizable debts, and Moll goes According to the law, the linen-draper’s debt are legally Moll’s debts
to see him at the Bailiff’s House where he is being held. He since she is his wife, and she could be thrown into debtors’ prison
apologizes for the state he is leaving Moll in and tells her to because of him. Moll keeps her personal bank throughout the book,
take whatever money and valuables are left and run. He wishes and the hidden stash of money is symbolic of security and Moll’s
her well, and Moll leaves, never seeing him again. Later, the ability to care for herself. 500 pounds is a lot of money, but it must
linen-draper breaks out of the Bailiff’s House and flees to last Moll her whole life. The only way for Moll to increase her
France. Moll is left with only £500 in her bank and nowhere to wealth is to marry again or go into Service, and since Moll doesn't
go. The only child she had with the linen-draper died in infancy, have a way to divorce the linen-draper, it will be hard for her to
but since she is still legally married, Moll’s options are limited. marry again.
Fearing creditors, Moll goes to the Mint, poses as a widow, and The Mint was a district in London so named because coins were
changes her name to Mrs. Flanders. She has little money, no once manufactured there. The actual mint was closed in the 1500s,
friends or family, and no idea what she will do. Moll sees but the area remained a jurisdictional interzone, meaning it was
nothing but “Misery and Starving” before her, and she vows to ruled over by a lord and the established law didn’t have jurisdiction
get out of the Mint, where the people and conditions are there. Criminals can’t be arrested at the Mint, so it is a sort of
terrible. Moll leaves the Mint and lives for a time with a kind sanctuary for wanted debtors like Moll. Moll’s circumstances are
widow, but the widow soon remarries, and Moll is again on her bleak—she has only “Misery and Starving” ahead of her—and she is
own. desperate to get out. Moll’s assumed name, Mrs. Flanders, connotes
sex and prostitution. At the time, it was said that London’s best
prostitutes were Flemish women (that is, women from Flanders),
and by calling herself Mrs. Flanders, Moll implies she is willing to
resort to prostitution to improve her circumstances.
Living in London, Moll discovers that marriage is “the This passage reflects the sexist and classist nature of Moll’s society.
Consequence of politick Schemes for forming Interests, and Marriage isn’t an expression of love; it is an expression of one’s
carrying on Business,” and it has nothing at all to do with love. wealth and place in society. Women are considered another piece of
She also learns that women don’t have “the Privilege” to turn property owned by men, only it is the women who must pay, either
down marriage proposals and should consider themselves in the form of a dowry or with their virtue, and always with the
lucky just for being asked. Women can’t question a man’s expectation of sex. A man can be poor and of little character, but a
character or fortune before agreeing to marriage, but men woman has no right to question him.
enjoy this right. The men go “Fortune Hunting” without
“Fortune themselves to Demand it, or Merit to deserve it.”
The plantation owner courts Moll and frequently professes his Writing sonnets and confessions of love on windowpanes with a
love to her. He promises to love her forever, and Moll pretends diamond was a common courtship practice during the 17th
to doubt his sincerity, claiming he only loves her for her century. Here, by writing on the glass, Moll tricks the plantation
fortune. One day, the plantation owner visits Moll in her room. owner into promising to love her even if she doesn’t have any
He takes off his diamond ring and uses it to write upon the money. He assumes she is just joking to make him prove his love; he
windowpane: “You I Love, and you alone.” Moll takes the ring. has no idea that Moll is deceiving him and really is poor.
“But Money’s Virtue; Gold is Fate,” she writes. He takes the ring
back. “I scorn your Gold, and yet I Love.” She writes again: “I’m
poor: Let’s see how kind you’ll prove.” The plantation owner
promises to love Moll even if she is poor, but Moll can tell that
he doesn’t really believe she is poor.
One day, Moll asks the plantation owner how and where they Moll equates going to the American colonies with criminal behavior,
will live if they are married. She has heard he owns an estate in which is why she calls moving there being “transported”;
Virginia, but Moll does not wish to be “transported.” He openly deportation was a common punishment for criminals at the time.
and easily speaks to Moll of his affairs and finances. He has The plantation owner is obviously wealthy, and he seems to be a
three Virginia plantations, he says, which provide him a decent and honest man. He isn’t trying to hide anything (like Moll
comfortable living of about £300 a year. But, he says, that is), and he doesn’t wish to force her into anything against her will.
number will obviously go up if they are married. As for Virginia,
he would not dream of making Moll live there unless she freely
chose to.
Moll gives the plantation owner £160, and a few days later, she This passage again speaks to Moll’s lack of morals, as she openly
gives him about 100 more in gold. A week later, she gives him admits to cheating the plantation owner into marriage. But Moll
£180 and £60 in linen. At last, Moll tells him that is all she also slips in a warning as to her poor moral choices, which supports
has—her entire bank. The plantation owner is so relieved that Defoe’s initial claim that Moll’s story is morally instructive.
Moll has any money at all that he never complains about the
sum. “And thus,” Moll says, “I got over the Fraud of passing for
Fortune without Money, and cheating a Man into Marrying me
on pretence of a Fortune.” However, Moll adds, a fraudulent
marriage is the most dangerous thing a woman can do, and it
opens her up to a host of problems and ill treatment.
In short time, the plantation owner begins to talk of returning The plantation owner’s claim that he is disappointed in Moll’s
to Virginia alone. Life there is pleasant and inexpensive, he says. fortune but not in Moll is meant in good humor, but it subtly
Moll is thankful that he accepted her fortune, and she knows highlights the fact that Moll has not lived up to expectations, and
that he is only looking to save money because of her, so she that she is somehow considered less because she doesn’t have much
agrees to go to Virginia. The plantation owner is overjoyed. He money. This again reflects the sexist and classist nature of the times,
may be disappointed with his wife’s fortune, he admits, but he as Moll’s worth as a woman and a wife is directly related to her
isn’t disappointed with his wife. He promises that his house in wealth.
Virginia is very nice and well furnished. His mother lives there,
as well as his sister, and they are his only living relations.
Moll and the plantation owner’s trip to Virginia is long and The trip from England to America during this time was extremely
dangerous. Their ship is hit with two big storms, and they are dangerous and often took well over a month to complete. Illness and
even robbed by a pirate. Finally, they arrive in Virginia, and Moll weather often claimed lives, and pirates were common as well. Here,
finds the plantation owner’s mother delightful. She often tells Mother means to differentiate between people of color sold as
Moll stories of the Colonies and their people, and she even tells slaves and white people transported to the Colonies as criminals
old stories of England. Mother claims that very few people and sold as servants. Transported criminals were sold under similar
come to the Colonies of their own accord as Moll did. Most conditions as slaves, but they often had the chance to better their
people are brought to the Colonies by shipmasters and are as lives, which was rarely the case with people of color sold as slaves.
“Servants, such as we call them,” Mother says, “but they are
more properly call’d Slaves.” Other people are transported
from Newgate Prison or other places after being found guilty
of a felony that is otherwise punishable by death.
Mother begins to tell Moll terrible stories of Newgate Prison, Defoe again implies that society is to blame for criminal behavior,
which, she says, is a dreadful place that “ruin’d more young just has he previously implied that it is responsible for Moll’s
People than all the Town besides.” She claims more “Thieves destruction because she was abandoned and neglected as a child. It
and Rogues” are made by Newgate than by all the criminals in is Newgate, the very solution to criminality, that leads to crime in
England. During one story, Mother has occasion to tell Moll her society. In this way, Defoe implies it isn’t wicked books and staged
name, and Moll is instantly struck. Mother notices Moll’s plays that cause depravity, but rather society itself. Obviously, Moll’s
change in demeanor and asks if she is all right. Moll assures her demeanor changes because she realizes the plantation owner’s
she is just overcome with sadness by her story, and Mother mother is her mother, too—which means Moll is married to her own
tells Moll not to fret. Her story may be sad, but she ended up in half-brother.
a good family. After her Mistress died, the Master married her,
and together they had the plantation owner and his sister.
Mother’s husband is dead now, but he gave her a good life.
Moll knows without a doubt that she is looking at her own Moll’s little reminder that she is in a foreign country with no way to
mother. By now, Moll has two children with the plantation get home again underscores her restrictions in society as a woman.
owner, and she has been sleeping with her half-brother the As far as the law is concerned, Moll is a married woman, and she
whole time. Moll has never been so unhappy, and she wishes can’t leave the Colonies without her husband’s permission.
Mother had never told her the story—it isn’t a crime to lie with Furthermore, even if she does leave, she has nowhere to go and no
one’s brother if one knows nothing about it. Moll fully expects money to support herself (she gave her bank to her husband/
to lose her husband; the plantation owner is a good man and brother), so she is forced to stay and compromise her morals.
will never agree to live with his sister as his wife. Moll doesn’t
know what to do, and she takes a moment to remind the reader
that she is in a foreign country with no way to return home.
Moll lives “in open avowed Incest and Whoredom, and all under It is not a coincidence that the plantation owner grows unkind once
the appearance of an honest Wife.” The sight of the plantation Moll stops having sex with him. As his wife, Moll is expected to have
owner makes her sick to her stomach, but she thinks it is best sex—sex is, so to speak, how Moll earns her keep. Sex is a form of
to keep the truth hidden from him. Moll conceals the truth for currency for Moll, and, Defoe thus implies, for all women.
three years, but she has no more children with the plantation Meanwhile, Moll is tormented because her marriage to the
owner. One cannot expect any good to come from “the worst plantation owner isn’t legal. He is Moll’s brother, and Moll is still
sort of Whoredom,” and Moll’s life indeed becomes most legally married to the linen-draper, which makes Moll guilty of
difficult. The plantation owner grows unkind and frequently “Incest and Whoredom”—though again, there’s not much she can do
argues with Moll. She reminds him that he made a promise to about it at this point.
return to England if Moll didn’t like Virginia, and says that she
would like to go back as soon as possible.
Even though Moll knows the plantation owner is right, she can This passage, too, reflects the sexist nature of Moll’s society, as she
no longer look at him as her husband, and she vows to be rid of is immediately considered “unkind” and “unnatural” for not wanting
him. Moll asks him to let her return to England alone; that way, to fill the traditional role of wife and mother. Of course, Moll has
he can remain on the estate and work. She brings the idea up good reason for wanting to leave—she isn’t trying to up and leave
repeatedly until the plantation owner explodes in anger, asking her family on a whim—but the law is against her for any reason. As a
her what kind of “unkind Wife” and “unnatural Mother” looks to woman, Moll is not allowed to freely travel and needs her husband’s
leave her family. Moll doesn’t want to see the plantation owner permission to leave.
or their children ever again, but she knows he will never let her
go, and she cannot think of leaving without his consent—“as any
one that knows the Constitution of the country I [am] in, knows
very well,” Moll says.
Moll and the plantation owner fight all the time, and their life During the 17th and 18th centuries, it was not uncommon for
together grows increasingly tense. She refuses to go to bed husbands to place their wives in insane asylums, or madhouses, as
with him, and he accuses her of being “mad.” He tells Moll that if an alternative to divorce or simply to be rid of them. Again, the
she doesn’t change her behavior immediately, he will “put [her] plantation owner is angry because he is denied sex; he considers sex
under Cure; that is to say, into a Madhouse.” Moll is terrified. If something Moll owes him as a woman and his wife.
the plantation owner puts her into a Madhouse, she will never
get back to England, and any word she speaks of the truth will
not be believed.
Months pass, and Moll and the plantation owner find During this time, a husband legally had the same control over his
themselves in an explosive argument. He pushes Moll so far wife that he had over his children, which made it legal for husbands
that she nearly tells him the truth outright, but she thinks to beat their wives. He threatens to beat Moll to force her to her
better of it. The argument begins with the plantation owner “Duty,” which is to say he will beat her if she doesn’t start acting like
calmly pointing out Moll’s urgent desire to return to England. his wife again—in the bedroom and everywhere else. In short, he
She treats him more like a dog than a husband, he says, and she tells Moll to shape up and consent to sex, or he will beat her and
doesn’t treat the children much better. While he isn’t very fond throw her in a mental hospital.
of violence, he finds it is necessary now, and he will certainly
resort to such means in the future to “reduce [Moll] to [her]
Duty.”
In the meantime, the plantation owner enlists his mother to get When the plantation owner enlists his mother to discover Moll’s
an explanation out of Moll. Mother presses Moll, who finally secret, it recalls the lady in Colchester and her efforts to persuade
tells Mother that the secret “[lies] in [Mother] herself”; Moll Moll to marry the younger brother. The circumstances are decidedly
has only suppressed it out of respect for her. It is in Mother’s different, but both situations illustrate the dismissive way in which
best interest, Moll says, not to insist. Mother, however, persists, Moll is treated. Moll doesn’t want to tell her secret, just like she
and Moll agrees to tell her—provided she doesn’t tell the didn’t want to marry the younger brother, but no one respects what
plantation owner without Moll’s permission. She agrees with Moll wants. Moll’s secret “lay in Mother herself” because Mother is
hesitation, and Moll tells her the entire story, beginning with the source of Moll’s problem with the plantation owner.
her own birth in Newgate Prison. She tells Mother that she is
indeed her daughter, and Mother is shocked. Moll’s story
seems at first unbelievable, but she soon takes Moll in her arms.
Mother laments Moll’s unhappy circumstances and the horror
of having three children—two living, one dead—with her own
brother.
Mother promises not to tell Moll’s secret to the plantation As a woman, Mother stands to lose just as much as Moll if Moll’s
owner, but neither Mother nor Moll knows what to do. They secret gets out. Mother’s reputation will be ruined in society as well,
don’t know how the plantation owner will receive the truth, but and it is sure to cause an embarrassing scandal. Mother would
they are both convinced that if the truth gets out publicly, it will rather have Moll live in misery and sin than face the devastation of
ruin the entire family. Mother wants Moll to bury the secret their secret. Mother’s willingness to live in such a way underscores
and continue living with the plantation owner as husband and the desperation of Moll’s situation as a woman in a sexist society.
wife until a better opportunity arises to tell him the truth. She Moll has no money and few options, other than to pretend she
promises to provide for Moll and, upon her death, to leave doesn’t know her husband is her brother.
money for Moll to separate from her son. Then, if Moll wishes
to leave after Mother is dead, she will have the means to do so.
Moll refuses; it is impossible to continue living as her brother’s
wife, and she can’t believe Mother is asking her to.
It is one thing, Moll argues, for Mother to confirm Moll is her As a woman in a sexist society, Moll’s word is considered less than a
daughter, but her secret will hardly be believed if it comes to man’s, and if Moll is put in a madhouse, anything she
light after Mother is dead. And, Moll adds, the plantation owner says—especially the truth that her husband is really her
has already threatened her with the madhouse. Moll suggests brother—will appear to be the ranting of a madwoman.
Mother help her convince the plantation owner to send Moll
back to England with an adequate amount of money and an
understanding he will later join her. Then, in Moll’s absence,
Mother can tell him the truth in any way she sees fit. In the end,
Moll and Mother can’t reconcile their difference of opinions.
Moll insists she cannot sleep with her brother, and Mother
insists she cannot convince her son to allow Moll to return to
England alone.
Moll tells the plantation owner that she will reveal her secret if This section, in which Moll makes the plantation owner put his
he will make her a few promises in writing. He immediately promises in writing, mirrors the part of the novel when the
agrees and grabs a pen, and Moll tells him to write the plantation owner etches his promises of love on the windowpane.
following: that he will not blame her, insult or injure her, or Just as she did then, Moll makes the plantation owner promise
make her suffer in any way. He agrees that is reasonable and something before divulging the truth. In this way, Moll manipulates
writes it all down. She further makes him promise not to the plantation owner, but, as Moll always points out, she does it for
divulge her secret to anyone, except his mother, without Moll’s a good reason, not because she is an inherently bad person.
consent or permission. Again, the plantation owner agrees that
Moll’s demand is reasonable and writes it down. She then
makes him promise that he will receive her secret with
composure, and after he agrees, she begins to talk.
Moll tells the plantation owner that they are brother and sister. Presumably, the “easie” way in which the plantation owner plans to
Mother, Moll says, is her mother as well. The plantation owner keep Moll from having to return to England is by killing himself. The
grows pale, and Moll must get him a glass of rum to calm him. plantation owner obviously can’t live with such a taboo and morally
After he composes himself, he tells Moll that he has a solution reprehensible truth, suggesting that rigid moral strictures can be
that does not involve her going back to England. Moll says that painful for men as well as women. Plus, he truly loves Moll as a wife,
isn’t likely, since she can’t see how she can possibly stay, but he but now he must think of her as a sister, and he is clearly
promises to “make it easie.” In the following days, the plantation heartbroken.
owner grows depressed, and Moll thinks he is beginning to lose
his mind. He even makes two attempts on his own life, and if
not for Mother catching him and cutting the rope, he would be
hanging dead.
The plantation owner falls into a long consumption, and Moll Moll behaves quite selfishly here. She thinks her brother is dying, but
knows he is dying. She supposes she can stay in Virginia and she only worries about herself and marrying again once he is gone.
marry again once he is dead, but she badly wants to return to This self-interest again suggests that Moll’s moral fiber really is
England. Finally, the plantation owner and Mother both agree lacking, which somewhat complicates Defoe’s argument that Moll
to send Moll back to England. They decide that in due time, the only makes immoral choices because her poverty and oppression
plantation owner can claim Moll has died in England, and he can force her to.
marry again if he likes. In the meantime, he urges Moll to
correspond as his sister. So, after eight years in Virginia, Moll
leaves her brother—as she may now call him—and boards a ship
to England.
Moll decides to go to Bristol anyway, but she stops in Bath Bath is a fashionable tourist destination known for its public spas,
along the way. Bath is a “Place of Gallantry” and is “full of but it is also known for its vice, which is reflected in Moll’s
Snares,” and since Moll is still a young woman, she decides to description of the city as “full of Snares.” There is much temptation
take her chances there. But, Moll says, Bath is where men go to in Bath—men, money, and likely alcohol and gambling. Moll implies
find a Mistress, not a Wife, and she has little luck finding a that her landlady isn’t running a brothel (“an ill House”), but she
suitable man. She befriends a landlady, who lets Moll lodge at suggests the landlady herself is a prostitute, as she doesn’t have “the
her house. The landlady does not “k “keep
eep an ill House,” but she best Principles.”
doesn
doesn’t’t ha
havve “the best Principles” either. Moll is sad and a bit
lonely living in Bath, but it is inexpensive, so she stays.
Moll tells the landlady that she lost her fortune at sea, which Again, it was common during this time for husbands to place their
indeed cost Moll nearly £500. She has written to her mother wives in mental hospitals just to be rid of them. The gentleman
and brother in Virginia, Moll says, and she is waiting for them to turns his wife’s care over so it doesn’t appear as if he had her
send more goods for her to the port in Bristol. The landlady committed just so he could see other women. This again reflects the
takes pity on Moll and reduces her rent to an even cheaper sexist nature of society.
rate, and then she introduces Moll to a gentleman. The
gentleman believes Moll is a widow, and she knows that he has
a mad wife, whom he left under the care of her family so he
wouldn’t be accused of “mismanaging her Cure.”
The gentleman treats Moll with the utmost respect, honor, and It was not uncommon for platonic friends to receive each other in
virtue, and even though he occasionally visits her in her room, their bedrooms, or in bed for that matter, and at this point the
he never offers more than a kiss. One day, he asks Moll how she gentleman appears to be a genuinely respectful person. He treats
manages to live and cover her expenses, and she assures him Moll well and doesn’t make any sexual advances toward her, even
that she manages well enough while she waits for goods from when he has the opportunity. He appears to want to help Moll with
her family in Virginia. He tells Moll that he asks not because he no strings attached, but she isn’t interested. Moll likely denies him
is curious, but because he wishes to help her, if she needs it. because the gentleman isn’t free to marry, since his wife is still alive.
Moll says she is not looking for his assistance, but he makes her
promise that if she should find herself in need of money, she will
ask him for help as freely as he has just offered it.
The gentleman begins to spend lots of money on Moll, buying While the gentleman does seem sincere, it is possible his sincerity is
her new clothes and lace, and he even hires her a maid. His just a ploy to get Moll to let her guard down and invite him in, at
kindness is a gift, the gentleman says, and he does not wish for which time he will more easily be able to take advantage of her. Like
Moll to pay him back. Soon, he falls ill, and Moll cares for him the older brother, the gentleman equates his affection for Moll with
for five weeks with as much attention as a loving wife. Once he money, so it isn’t a stretch to imagine that he might equates sex with
is better, the gentleman presents Moll with 50 Guineas for her money as well.
care and tells her he has the sincerest affection for her. He
claims he will always preserve her virtue as if it were his own,
and even “if he was naked in Bed with [her],” he would not
violate her virtue.
Moll soon has reason to go to Bristol, and the gentleman offers Again, Moll equates unmarried sex with being a whore, which
to travel with her. When they arrive at the Inn, the innkeeper reinforces the sexist nature of her society. Furthermore, the fact that
only has one room with two beds. When they’re alone in the the gentleman so quickly gives in to Moll’s desires suggests that he
room, the gentleman tells Moll that he has occasion to prove to isn’t so concerned with her virtue after all. If he were, it is likely that
her that he can lie with her without violating her virtue. He he wouldn’t allow Moll to endanger it, no matter how badly he
climbs into bed with her and holds her all night long, without wanted her.
the least inappropriate touch. They return to Bath and live
together for two whole years, until, after a bit too much wine,
Moll offers to give him her virtue for one night. He takes her
immediately, and with that, Moll becomes, in her words, his
“WHORE.”
Both Moll and the gentleman regret their decision, but there is During the 17th century, the sight of pregnant women was
no going back, so they continue their sexual relationship. Moll is considered obscene (pregnancy, after all, is evidence of sex), so
soon pregnant, and the landlady helps her to find a midwife and women were expected to remove themselves from society in for a
nurse. As Moll gets closer to giving birth, the landlady period of time that was called “lying in.” Churches would assume the
convinces the Parish Officers that there is a woman “Lying Inn” cost of unmarried pregnant women and automatically take charge
at her residence, but the woman’s husband is a wealthy man of them, but the landlady convinces them that Moll is married and
from London and has covered all expenses. The Parish Officers covered financially. Both the need for “lying in” and the church’s
are satisfied, and Moll saves as much of the gentleman’s money interference further highlight how tightly constrained women’s
as she can. She gives birth to a handsome boy, and the rights are at this time.
gentleman relocates both Moll and the baby to London.
One day, Moll comes home to a letter that says the gentleman Pleurisy is a painful respiratory illness that was often fatal during
has again fallen ill. He is at home with his wife’s family, and it Moll’s time, and it further reflects how precarious Moll’s situation is.
isn’t appropriate for Moll to come to him. Time passes without Without the gentleman, Moll is destitute, and she won’t be entitled
word, so, out of curiosity, Moll disguises herself as a servant to any money upon his death since they aren’t legally married.
and goes to his house and inquires as to his condition. A maid Moll’s life has been going well, but it is still just one disaster away
tells her the gentleman is suffering with pleurisy and a fever, from completely falling apart and leaving her on the street.
and he isn’t expected to live. Moll returns home and soon learns
that his condition is slowly improving. She writes him several
letters, and after much time, he finally writes back.
The gentleman writes that being so near death has made him The gentleman’s sudden attack of conscience underscores the
genuinely reflect on the time he has spent with Moll, and he immorality of his relationship with Moll, which aligns with Defoe’s
now sees the sin they have committed. He encloses £50 so claim that Moll’s story is useful moral instruction. By pointing out
Moll can return to Bath, and he says he can no longer see her. the sin Moll is guilty of, it warns readers away from making similar
She is free to take their child or leave him; if she leaves the choices. In giving Moll money to go away, the gentleman again
child, the gentleman says, he will care for the boy. Moll is equates sex with mone; it’s as if this final sum is his last payment to
heartbroken. She is aware of their sin herself, and she has often her for the relationship they’ve had.
thought it would have been a lesser offense to stay in Virginia
as her brother’s wife. And all this time, Moll has been married
to the linen-draper too, which means she has been living as a
“Whore and an Adultress” since he left.
Moll has no intention of returning to Bath, but she doesn’t Moll’s son with the gentleman is just one of the 12 children Moll
know what to do about the child. The thought of leaving him abandons, which makes her appear immoral; however, Defoe
causes her pain, but so does the thought of trying to care for implies that Moll isn’t entirely to blame for this awful situation.
him on her own and being unable to, so she leaves him. She Birth control doesn’t exist, and Moll has few options to support a
again writes the gentleman and asks him to send her £50 more, child. Plus, she is forced into sexual situations in order to survive. In
so she can go back to her family in Virginia, even though she has this way, children can’t be avoided, and Moll can only do her best to
no intention of leaving England. He agrees, and Moll again finds take care of them for as long as she can.
herself alone. With the additional £50 from the gentleman, she
has nearly £400 in her bank, including some silver, clothes, and
linen.
Moll lives as frugally as she can and decides to move to the During this time, paper money and bank receipts (now known as
North Country, where a neighbor talks her into moving again to checks) were a relatively new concept, and Moll has a hard time
Liverpool. There, Moll must decide what to do with her money. trusting them. Plus, if Moll puts her money in a bank and it goes
She considers the bank, but she has no one to help her, and she bankrupt, she will lose all her money. Keeping her money on her isn’t
doesn’t trust “Bank Bills” and “Talleys.” Still, she worries she may realistic either, it is heavy and bulky, and she might get robbed.
be robbed or murdered for her gold, so she decides to go the Despite the risk, putting her money in a bank is her safest option.
bank anyway. Moll tells the man at the bank her situation, and
he directs her to a second banker, who he is sure will be able to
help Moll manage her money and affairs.
The banker’s wife ran off and had two children with a linen- Here, the banker, too, implies that women are often forced into
draper’s apprentice. The banker tells Moll that his wife “is a performing sex for money and security, which is why he calls it the
Whore not by Necessity, which is the common Bait of [Moll’s] “Bait” of Moll’s gender. His wife, however, is a “whore” because of
Sex, but by Inclination, and for the sake of the Vice.” He asks desire and not need, which suggests she is innately immoral;
Moll what he should do to get justice, and she suggests getting whereas Moll, who is a “whore by necessity,” does it to survive and is
a divorce. It won’t be difficult, Moll says, if the wife has really thus not innately immoral. The banker’s forwardness is again
done as the banker says. The banker admits that he would like evidence of their sexist society. He is more concerned with making
to marry again, and then he asks Moll if she would have him. Moll his wife than in helping her with her problem, proving her point
“No,” Moll replies sternly. She has come to him for help with her about how vulnerable women without advisers are.
finances, and she is appalled that he has been so forward.
Moll tells the banker that she will leave her money in his hands With an income of 1,500 pounds per year, the Irishman is seriously
while she travels, and he agrees. Moll has been in Lancashire wealthy, and he is willing to give Moll a dowry, instead of the other
for about six weeks when she meets the Irishman. According to way around. The Irishman seems too good to be true, which
Moll’s friends, the Irishman is very rich—his estate is valued at suggests that he probably is. His fortune is in Ireland, and he can
£1,000 to £1,500 yearly—and he is very handsome. He is tall easily lure Moll to Ireland on the pretense of money, and by the time
and shapely, and he speaks often of his estate in Ireland. He she discovers the truth, she’d be trapped there.
never asks Moll about her own fortune, but he promises to give
her a £600 dowry if she agrees to go with him to Ireland.
The Irishman is shocked to discover that Moll doesn’t have any Moll is lying about her money (she has over 400 pounds with the
money, and she is quick to point out that she never led him to banker), which seems immoral; however, Defoe implies she doesn’t
believe she had any wealth at all. He claims she looks like a have much of a choice. If the past is any indication of Moll’s future,
“Woman of Fortune,” and, he adds, he heard from mutual she will soon be alone and expected to support herself, and she can
friends that Moll was very wealthy. Then, the Irishman admits hardly be blamed for covering herself on her end. And unlike the
that he, too, is poor and doesn’t really own an estate in Ireland. Irishman, Moll doesn’t openly lie about having money; he just
It appears, Moll says, they have been married “upon the foot of assumes she’s wealthy, and she doesn’t initially correct him.
a double Fraud,” for she has no estate. Moll is incredibly
disappointed. She knows the Irishman can make her very
happy, but his finances are certainly a problem, and she can see
nothing before them but ruin. She pulls a Bank Bill from her
purse worth £20 and 11 Guineas, which, she says, is all the
money she has in the world.
Moll and the Irishman spend the night together, and once Moll Presumably, Moll and the Irishman have sex, and he too pays her for
falls asleep, the Irishman slips out. He leaves her a letter, in it, albeit in a more indirect way. This is the first time Moll uses
which he begs for her forgiveness and claims he has left money James’s real name. James’s identity as, variously, the Irishman,
in her pocket to cover her expenses back to London. When she Jemy, and Moll’s Lancashire husband again underscores Defoe’s
wakes, Moll is devasted. She looks in her pocket and finds 10 argument as to the fluid nature of identity.
Guineas, along with a gold watch and diamond rings. She begins
to weep, calling him by his name. “James, O Jemy!” Moll cries,
wishing he would return to her. Moll spends the whole day
crying, and near nightfall, James returns.
When James arrives, he goes directly to Moll and takes her in Referring to their “extasies” is a polite way of saying Moll and James
his arms. When their “Extasies” are over, James tells Moll that have sex, and it is an example of the modest language Moll was
he didn’t get 15 miles away before he heard Moll calling to him. forced to write her story in. James’s connection to Moll, and his
Hearing her voice in his head, he knew he had to be near her for ability to sense her calling for him, again suggests that James truly
a bit longer. There is no need for her to travel back to London loves her. But because of his poverty, he is forced to deny his feelings
alone, James says. He can accompany her to the city, or close to and keep looking for a wealthy woman, just as Moll must look for a
it, at least. Molls is miserable without him, so she agrees. His rich man.
good nature and manners—and the fact that he left Moll what
little money he had—make him quite attractive to Moll.
James and Moll travel as far as Dunstable, about 30 miles Moll only offers to spend all her money on James because she
outside London, and James refuses to go on. Circumstances, knows she has more money with the banker in London. While Moll
which James doesn’t explain, won’t allow him to go on to clearly likes James, she is careful to still ensure her own security.
London. Moll convinces him to stay a week or so in Dunstable James’s refusal to go to London is suspicious and implies he is hiding
to delay their inevitable parting, and they rent rooms in a from something or someone, and it further suggests he isn’t exactly
private house. Moll asks James to live with her in Dunstable who he says he is.
until her money runs out. She will not let him spend a bit of his
own money. If she isn’t likely to see him again, Moll says, it will
be money well spent.
James is so insistent on his plans for Ireland that Moll finally Moll is still scheming to get the richest husband possible, which is
agrees to go to London and wait. They part at last—with great why she continues corresponding with the banker even when she is
reluctance on Moll’s part—and she heads off to London. Moll with James. Again, this implies Moll is of loose morals, since she
takes lodging near Clarkenwell and discovers after a short time strings one man along while pregnant with another’s child; however,
that she is pregnant. Moll isn’t pleased with this unexpected she can’t very well go out and get a respectable job and support
interruption, and she isn’t quite sure how to handle her lying in. herself in the manner she is accustomed to, which again reflects
She has kept up correspondence with the banker during her Moll’s limited options as a woman in the 17th century.
time away, but she hasn’t had the need to remove any money
from the bank. She knows from his letters that he has started
divorce proceedings; they are going well, but they are also
difficult and long.
In short time, the lady of the house where Moll boards sends a A “midwife” during Moll’s time is often used as an umbrella term for
midwife to see her. The woman seems to be an experienced women who deliver babies and are also prostitutes. The midwife is
midwife, and she has a different calling as well, “in which she [is] an “expert” more than “most women,” and she is a “Mother
as expert as most women, if not more.” Moll’s “Mother Midnight,” both of which imply prostitution. Moll understands she is
Midnight” begins to explain. She knows Moll needs assistance a whore in the midwife’s house because the midwife is literally
for her “Lying Inn,” and she can help. The Midwife tells Moll that operating a brothel.
Moll’s circumstances are of no concern to her—in other words,
she doesn’t care if the baby’s father is Moll’s husband—and
Moll understands that she is a “Whore” here.
Moll soon moves to the midwife’s house, where Moll is pleased The midwife’s business of selling babies is certainly an immoral
to find the house clean and quite luxurious. The midwife has practice, but she views it through more moral terms. She says the
several businesses and one such business is finding people who, babies would likely have been aborted or neglected had she not
for a bit of money, will take children after they are born and found them appropriate homes, which makes her work seem more
provide for them. Moll questions what happens to the children morally sound. She still offers Moll an abortion, though, which
after they are gone, but the midwife assures her she takes suggests she isn’t looking to judge Moll regardless of her decision.
great care in all her business. Furthermore, the midwife says,
she has saved the lives of countless children, who otherwise
might have been destroyed by their desperate mothers. The
midwife also offers to provide Moll with something to make her
miscarry, if she wants to be rid of the problem that way, but
Moll refuses.
During Moll’s time with the midwife, Moll is comfortable and If Moll wasn’t sure before that the midwife is a prostitute and her
well cared for. It is obvious to Moll that the midwife has a house a brothel, Moll certainly knows now. Moll’s morals are clearly
thriving business, which is clearly a “whoring Account.” The offended by being in the brothel, as being there makes her sick to
Midwife has 12 “Ladies of Pleasure” and a number of other her stomach. Moll’s response to the brothel again implies that she
women “Lying Inn.” Living in such a place “shock’d [Moll’s] very isn’t innately immoral; she is simply a poor woman in a sexist society
Senses,” and she feels sick to her stomach. However, Moll and is without other reasonable options. Moll doesn’t really doubt
admits, she never sees anything indecent take place there. the legality of the banker’s divorce; she simply must string him along
Before long, Moll receives a letter from the banker. He has for a little longer until her lying in is over.
divorced his wife, and Moll is pleased, but she writes back and
claims to doubt the lawfulness of such a decree.
By mid-May, Moll gives birth to another son. Soon after, she Moll is again scheming to ensure she gets the banker and she is
again receives a letter from the banker. He has obtained a willing to give up her child to do it, which again suggests Moll has
divorce from his wife, and after she was served with the papers, rather loose morals. Furthermore, both the banker and Moll seem r
she committed suicide. With his cheating wife out of the pleased that his wife is dead. This rather heartless response is likely
picture, the banker invites Moll to come to London and be with in response to the wife’s status as a whore, but since Moll considers
him. Moll is pleased, but she isn’t sure what to do with the child. herself a whore too, this makes her appear even more heartless and
In search of advice, Moll tells the midwife all about her immoral. But still, Moll remains motivated by concerns for her own
predicament—her marriage to James, his inability to go to safety; Defoe implies that she probably wouldn’t do or feel any of
London, and his blessing for Moll to move on—and she says that these things if she weren’t desperately trying to avoid poverty.
she has found a good offer in the banker. The problem, Moll
says, is the child. If she returns to the banker with the boy, the
banker will know that Moll has been with another since she left
London for Lancashire.
Afterward, Moll begins to write the banker in a more friendly Presumably, the banker wants to meet Moll in Brickhill because he
tone, and she tells him that she will be in London come August. wants to marry her before taking her back to London. That way,
The banker suggests instead that they meet in Brickhill, a town when he brings Moll home, she is already his wife, and he won’t
just outside London. They find lodging and go to dinner, and appear to be fooling around with a woman he isn’t married to,
Moll gets the feeling that the banker is going to propose to her. which, in the eyes of society, would reflect poorly on his own
She knows that she will not deny him. The innkeeper asks to morality. However, the banker makes his plans without consulting
speak to the banker alone, and Moll overhears the men talking Moll, which again illustrates how little agency women have in their
about a minister, who is willing to serve them as discreetly as society.
they like. After dinner, the banker begins kissing and sweet-
talking Moll, and then he takes out several official documents
and places them before her.
The banker presents Moll with documentation of his divorce The banker’s “violent” kisses and his refusal to let Moll up until she
from his wife and proof of her crime as a “Whore,” and he marries him again implies that he has control over her as a man and
further presents Moll with proof of his wife’s death and burial. she is powerless to resist him. He doesn’t know that Moll has no
Moll can see he has yet another document, and she asks him plans to resist him, and he is willing to force her, which is evident in
what it is. “Ay,” he says slyly. He then produces a box, which both his violent force and his preparation. He goes to a lot of trouble
contains a very nice diamond ring. Moll is so happy that she securing documentation to ensure their marriage because he has no
can’t refuse. The other document, the banker says, is a intention of taking no for an answer.
marriage license, and he begins to “violently” kiss her. He
knocks Moll to the bed, all the while kissing her and professing
his love, and he refuses to let her up until she agrees to marry
him. She won’t refuse him, Moll says, so he might as well let her
up.
The banker is so happy that Moll has accepted him, there are Since Moll is still legally married to the linen-draper, Moll is
tears in his eyes as he stands. Moll must turn from him, because technically a whore, just like the banker’s first wife, and Moll’s guilt
there are tears in her eyes, too, and she begins to feel remorse over this fact again reflects her sexist society. Moll’s husband left her
for the wicked life she has led. She briefly wonders how her life through no fault of her own, yet she is supposed to take a vow of
would have been had she met a nice, loving man like the banker chastity and wait for him to come back—which is unlikely to ever
earlier. She starts to feel bad that she has deceived him as to happen. Moll’s question as to how her life would have been had she
the full truth of her past. Little does he know, Moll thinks, he not been poor again suggests that her immorality is a product of her
has gotten rid of one “Whore” just to take up with another. poverty, not of some innate depravity.
What will the banker think if he ever finds out that Moll is the
daughter of a thief, born in Newgate Prison?
Moll and the banker’s marriage is kept completely secret, and The banker keeps their marriage a secret, which implies that he is
they return to their room as husband and wife, where they ashamed in some way. Likely, the banker isn’t ashamed of Moll per
“enjoy’d [themselves] that Evening compleatly.” The next se, but he does seem to be ashamed that he wasn’t married before.
morning, they remain in bed until nearly noon, at which time This shame reflects the importance of marriage in society, and it
Moll rises and goes to the window. She looks outside, and to also implies that he doesn’t want to be seen with a woman who isn’t
her absolute surprise she sees James go into a house across his wife. Moll’s claim that she and the banker enjoyed themselves
the street with two other men. She panics. The banker cannot completely again suggests sex and is another example of the modest
see her so undone, and she quickly thinks about her options. language Moll must use to tell her story.
She wants to know what James is doing there, but she doesn’t
want to see him—running into him could ruin her life with the
banker. Two hours later, Moll watches as James and the two
men exit the house and head out of town.
The next day, as Moll and the banker are getting ready to Obviously, James is a highwayman—a thief who robs travelers and
return to London, excitement breaks out all over town. Three stagecoaches—which is likely why he can’t return to London. The
highwaymen robbed nearly £560 in money and goods from reader can infer that James is wanted in London for some sort of
travelers, and three strange men have been seen in the area. crime, probably robbery, which also implies James has loose morals
Moll tells the constable that she indeed saw the men in himself—but again, that may just be because he’s impoverished and
question, and one of them she knows very well from has few options. Moll and the banker don’t leave for London right
Lancashire. He is an honest and good man, Moll says, and he away because with known highwaymen in the area, they stand to be
can’t possibly be one of the highwaymen. The constable tells his robbed on their way back.
men they are mistaken; the three men seen in town have
nothing to do with the robberies. The excitement delays Moll
and the banker’s departure, and they finally head back to
London four days later.
Moll returns to London a married woman and she moves The “safe Harbour” of Moll’s marriage and her subsequent financial
directly into the banker’s house, which she finds well-furnished security again imply that Moll only resorted to the wickedness of her
and more than adequate. There, Moll lives a very happy life. She past out of desperation and a need to survive. This implication
has “landed in a safe Harbour,” and she “sincerely” repents her underscores the connection between poverty and vice, and it
wicked past. But, Moll points out, as “Covetousness is the Root suggests vice isn’t necessarily a choice that is freely made. Poverty is
of all Evil, so Poverty is, I believe, the worst of all Snares.” Moll “the worst of all Snares,” in which one is bound to break the law and
lives an easy life for five years, until the banker loses a large commit other immoral acts just to survive—especially as a woman
sum of his money to a dishonest business associate. The banker with few options otherwise.
grows depressed and lethargic after losing so much money and
promptly dies, leaving Moll alone with two children.
Back in her room, Moll opens the package and finds it full of Moll seems sincerely remorseful for stealing the package, and she
valuable linen and lace, various silver mugs and spoons, and also appears to regret the way she has been forced to live in the
money totaling 18 shillings and six pence. As Moll goes through past—multiple illicit affairs, “whoredom,” and abandoned
the contents of the package, she is struck with fear. She is a children—which all point to Moll’s moral fortitude. Sinning and vice
thief, and such things can get her sent to Newgate and hanged. aren’t easy for Moll, and she truly regrets her choices, but she has
Moll goes to bed, but she can’t sleep. She reflects on her sin, had to choose between staying moral and staying alive.
but she knows that she won’t starve now. Still, she has sincerely
repented the sins of her life only to be “driven by the dreadful
Necessity of [her] Circumstances” to thievery. Moll falls to her
knees and prays to God for deliverance.
The next day, Moll goes out walking in the street and The fact that Moll steals indiscriminately even from children
encounters a young girl walking home alone. Moll notices a complicates her claim that she isn’t innately immoral. Moll could
handsome gold necklace around the girl’s neck, so she offers to choose to target an adult, but she steals whatever is available, even
see her home safely. The girl agrees, and Moll leads her into an if she must take from a child. Moll rationalizes her choice to steal
empty alley, where, pretending to fix the girl’s shoe, Moll slips from the child, and even tries to tell herself that she is helping the
the necklace from the girl’s neck without her noticing. Moll child in the long run by teaching the parents a lesson. Moll’s
turns the girl in the direction of her house and leaves her. As rationalization suggests that she is morally bothered by her decision
she walks, Moll reflects on her crimes. She isn’t too concerned to rob a child.
with the girl. After all, Moll didn’t hurt her, and she indeed
taught the girl’s parents a valuable lesson about leaving their
daughter unattended.
Luckily for Moll, the midwife happily receives her and reveals Unlike Moll, the midwife is a hardened criminal. In addition to being
that she also works as a pawn broker, so she can help Moll turn a prostitute, the madame of a brothel, and a procuress, the midwife
her goods into money. Moll moves into the midwife’s house and is also a pawn broker who can turn jewelry and silver into spendable
tries to survive on only quilting work, but it isn’t long before money. The midwife has clearly been at her life of crime for a long
Moll steals again. While having a drink in a bar, Moll steals the time, and this again illustrates the limited options of women in
silver cup she drinks her ale from. When she returns home to society. The midwife isn’t married, and she certainly isn’t
the midwife and tells her what she has done, the midwife begs independently wealthy, so she must piece together several illegal
her not to take the cup back. The punishment for theft is harsh, jobs to provide for herself.
the midwife reminds Moll, and they will hang her without
thought. The midwife melts down the silver cup so no one will
recognize it, and Moll tells her that she is running out of money
and isn’t a very good thief.
The midwife sets Moll up with a “Comrade” and experienced Moll and the midwife refer to their criminal acquaintances as
thief, who teaches Moll to shoplift and pickpocket without “Comrades.” They aren’t exactly friends, and they never have names,
getting caught. Moll puts her new skills into practice, and it isn’t which helps them to maintain their anonymity. With 120 watches
long before she grows rich. At one point, Moll and her and 200 pounds saved, Moll is no longer stealing just to stay alive;
comrades have 120 gold watches between them. Moll has over now Moll is stealing to get rich, which again suggests she isn’t as
£200 saved in her bank, but she continues to steal. “As Poverty moral as she pretends to be. Moll decides to stop stealing because
brought me into the Mire,” Moll says, “so Avarice kept me in.” she’s scared of being hanged and isn’t as poor as she once was—her
Before long, two of Moll’s comrades are arrested and sent to decision seems to have nothing to do with morals.
Newgate Prison, where one is sentenced to death and hanged.
The other comrade is granted a reprieve, but watching a
comrade hang is traumatic for Moll, and she vows to stop
stealing.
Not long after, Moll wakes in the middle of the night to sounds Moll’s stealing spree during the fire again suggests that her moral
of yelling and distress. Part of the neighborhood in which she compass is faulty. She doesn’t need the money to survive, and she
lives is engulfed in flames, and the midwife tells Moll that the preys on fire victims, who are already under stress and in danger of
commotion of the fire is the perfect opportunity to rob the losing all their valuables. In Moll’s defense, however, she only seems
surrounding houses without notice. Moll agrees and manages to run into the fire to steal because the midwife tells her to. Still,
to steal some silver from a nearby house, and when she returns Moll doesn’t at all object to stealing from victims, and she appears
to the midwife with their booty, she tells Moll to go out and get to relieve them of their goods easily enough and with no thought as
more. She runs out to a new house, which she finds even more to the moral implications.
lucrative, and she returns with a considerable amount of gold
jewelry and a purse containing £24.
One day, the comrade couple asks Moll to break into a house Moll clearly doesn’t think her actions during the fire count as
with them, but she refuses. Breaking into houses is something breaking into a house. In Moll’s mind, her crime is worse if she forces
Moll won’t do, so they go ahead without her. The couple are her way in; however, if she just wanders in and doesn’t break a
arrested and hanged, and Moll, having so narrowly escaped window or a door, she considers the crime less immoral—or at least
joining them, again grows hesitant to continueas a thief. The less risky. While the midwife’s plan to call the police about the illegal
midwife tries to talk Moll out of quitting and tells her about a lace isn’t stealing, it is still immoral, as she is willing to give up
nearby house where she knows some illegal lace from Flanders someone else just to make a little money.
can be found. If Moll were to tell the police about the fabric, the
midwife says, they would certainly give her a reward.
Moll goes to the police and tells them about the illegal lace, Again, Moll’s behavior is far from moral. Moll’s neighbors will likely
which is indeed valued at nearly £300. Moll negotiates a £50 get into trouble for having illegal lace, and since the punishment for
reward and steals a piece of lace worth about eight or nine stealing a even bit of fabric is death, the consequences are probably
pounds when no one is looking. Moll divides her profits with severe. Moll easily gives her neighbors up for 50 pounds and a piece
the midwife and goes back to work. She decides to lift a gold of lace, which isn’t the behavior of an innately moral person. Moll
watch off a woman on a crowded street, but as Moll grabs the claimed earlier that she wasn’t a good thief, but that is obviously
watch, it doesn’t at first release from the woman’s arm. Moll is changing. Her quick thinking helps her pull off a robbery and avoid
worried the woman will discover her attempt, so, just as the being caught. Moll is officially becoming a seasoned criminal.
watch breaks free, Moll screams at the top of her lungs that
someone has tried to pick her pockets. Someone tried to grab
her watch, Moll lies. The woman, standing nearby, is shocked to
discover that she has been robbed. Her watch is missing, the
woman says.
Suddenly, there are cries from elsewhere in the street, and as The young man who is arrested as the pickpocket is obviously
the crowd parts, Moll watches as a young man is arrested as innocent, but he will likely be sent to Newgate and hanged. Moll
the alleged pickpocket. Moll continues down the street, the knows this, and she lets it happen without a thought. Again, Moll’s
woman’s watch in her pocket, and decides it is best not to steal actions don’t seem like those of a moral woman, since at this point
anymore for a while. In the meantime, the midwife tells Moll a she doesn’t need to steal to survive. Defoe seems to suggest that
bit of her own story. The midwife was born a pickpocket, but small, necessary acts of immorality (like the ones Moll once
she was arrested and ordered to be deported years ago. She committed out of desperation) can grow into larger ones over time.
bribed officials to send her to Ireland instead of the Colonies, According to the midwife’s story, she began working as a prostitute
and she lived there for years, working as a “Midwife and (a “Midwife and Procuress”) because it wasn’t safe to steal, which
Procuress.” She left Ireland before her sentence was up, and again underscores the limited options available to women.
upon returning illegally to England, she thought it best if she
didn’t return to pickpocketing.
Moll and the male comrade work several jobs together. They Obviously, Moll is dressed as a man, so her comrade and the
stick mostly to robbing distracted shopkeepers, and Moll’s concerned citizens looking to turn her in as an accomplice all believe
comrade never once suspects that she isn’t a man. One day, they are looking for a man. Moll’s slick actions and ability to disguise
Moll’s comrade notices a preoccupied shopkeeper turn his back herself are more evidence that she is becoming a hardened criminal.
on several pieces of valuable silk. Moll tells him it isn’t a good She isn’t just stealing to survive anymore. For Moll, theft is now her
idea, but the comrade won’t listen. He snatches the fabric and career, and she is very good at it. Or, she is very lucky, which means
runs down the street with the police in hot pursuit. Moll runs her luck will have to run out at some point.
back to the midwife’s house and slips inside, a group of
concerned citizens chasing her. When the citizens bang on the
door and claim a male thief has run inside, the midwife assures
them there is no man there. If they want to come in and look,
she says, they will have to bring the constable.
Soon after, a constable knocks on the midwife’s door, and she Presumably, Moll is in her underclothes because she has just ripped
allows him inside. He looks the house up and down for the man off her male disguise. Again, it is Moll’s quick thinking—evidence of
the citizens witnessed running in, but he finds nothing. When her skill as a thief—that keeps her out of Newgate and in business.
he gets to Moll’s door, he finds her inside, wearing only her Moll appears to easily lie and deceive her way out of trouble, which
nightclothes and surrounded by mounds of embroidery and further indicates that her long history of immoral behavior has
quilting. Assuming Moll has been hard at work all day, he closes made it easier and easier for her to continue acting immorally.
the door and goes downstairs. There is no man, the midwife
says again, and if there was, he is long gone now. The constable
agrees and leaves.
After the excitement with the constable, Moll refuses to let the While it isn’t explicitly stated, the reader can infer that the male
midwife dress her up as man again. The male comrade is comrade is hanged for his crimes. Just as she did with the young
arrested and agrees to inform on Moll for a reduced sentence. man in the crowd, Moll must know her comrade is going to die, but
He tells the police his accomplice is a man named Gabriel it doesn’t even seem to cross her mind. This selfishness implies that
Spencer, which is the false name Moll gave him at their first Moll’s moral character is continuing to deteriorate.
meeting. The police look everywhere for Gabriel Spencer but
come up emptyhanded. The authorities accuse the male
comrade of lying about his accomplice to get his sentence
reduced, and they punish him severely.
Moll has almost £500 in her bank, which she could live on for The fact that Moll won’t retire even when she has the means to
quite some time, but she has no intention of retiring just yet. again proves she isn’t stealing just to survive. If Moll were truly
She goes on a job with a new momrade and manages to lift a concerned about her morality, she would steal only the bare
large piece of quality damask fabric from a shop and hand it off minimum, but instead she goes to excess. With the arrest of her
to her comrade without drawing any attention. They leave the latest comrade, the authorities at Newgate now know her name.
store and go in opposite directions, and Moll watches as this Ironically, Moll was just bragging that no one at Newgate even
comrade is arrested, too. Moll sneaks into a nearby shop and knows her name. Moll was arrogant, and now she is paying the
even buys some fabric to look like a regular shopper. The price.
comrade is taken to Newgate, where she claims the damask
was originally stolen by a woman named Moll Flanders.
In time, Moll’s name is known at Newgate and Old-Baily, but Again, it is remarkable that Moll won’t “break” into a house, but she
they don’t know her face. Moll’s comrade is eventually will walk in through an open door in the middle of chaos. Moll
deported, and Moll again grows paranoid. Soon, however, appears to think the crime is somehow less if she doesn’t have to use
another fire breaks out, and Moll attempts to rob another force, which may be a symbolic echo of the way she didn’t originally
house in the chaos. Just as Moll is about to enter a house, a choose to be a criminal; she just did it because it was the only door
featherbed comes flying out of a window overhead and falls open to her. The featherbed, meanwhile, seems to be a sign that
directly on top of her, pinning her to the ground. Her bones are Moll should stop breaking into house.
not broken, but she is bruised and banged up, and she must
wait for someone to lift the bed before she can limp away.
The midwife goes to a friend and asks about the drunk man, Obviously, Moll didn’t beat up the drunk man. Presumably, he made
and the next day, the midwife’s friend finds him. The friend says up a story that he was beaten and robbed so no one will think he
the man is very ill and has recently been violently robbed. He was robbed by a prostitute, like the midwife says. As a married man
has been beaten up, too, she says, and he suffered several looking for a prostitute, the drunk man clearly has loose morals as
injuries. The midwife says she is sure the man just got drunk well and is another example of the “moral instruction” Defoe speaks
and found a whore, who probably took advantage of him, but of in the preface.
the friend claims that is unlikely. The man, she says, is an
aristocrat and of the finest moral standing. The midwife takes
word of the drunk man’s condition back to Moll, who assures
her that he was just fine when she left him.
Ten days later, the midwife goes to visit the drunk man. Even Obviously, the midwife has some sort of angle. She isn’t visiting the
though she is a stranger, the midwife says to him, she has come drunk man out of the goodness of her heart to console him—she
to do him a service. She promises that their dealings will remain wants something from him. The drunk man is angry because he
a secret, and he is at first shy and says he knows nothing that doesn’t want anyone to know he was robbed and humiliated by a
requires such secrecy. The midwife tells him that she knows all prostitute, which would likely be bad for his own reputation and his
about the misfortune that befell him recently, and he looks marriage.
suddenly angry, claiming not to know what she is talking about.
The midwife promises that she wants nothing from him and did
not come to bribe him or reveal his secret.
The drunk man tells the midwife it is very unfortunate that a When the man says Moll didn’t “prompt” him, what he means is that
stranger should know all about the worst day of his life. As for Moll didn’t proposition him, so he takes full responsibility for their
the woman, the man says, whoever she may be, he takes full sin. Presumably, the man is mostly worried that Moll has given him
responsibility for what transpired between them. “She a venereal disease, and the midwife tries to convince him that Moll
prompted me to nothing,” he adds. He doesn’t know for sure if is safe; however, her choice to refer to Moll as a “Gentlewoman” is
the woman is the one who stole from him, but what he lost is less than convincing, since it is another word for prostitute.
the least of his present concerns. The midwife begins to
understand what the man is hinting at and assures him the
woman is a “Gentlewoman,” and she has been with no man
since the death of her husband eight years ago.
The drunk man tells the midwife that he very much wants to Presumably, the midwife had no intention of giving the watch back,
the see the woman, as he would like his gold watch back. If the and she only does it because he offers to pay her. Of course, the
midwife can’t arrange a meeting for him, he asks if she might be midwife is pleased because he is generous, and her job as a pawn
able to get his watch back for him, at which point he will pay her broker is little more than a convenient story to cover up her ill
what the watch is worth. The midwife promises to try and intentions. What exactly the midwife’s intentions are is never
leaves. She returns the next day with the watch, and he pays revealed, but it may be that she is subtly offering her own services as
her 30 Guineas, which is much more than they would have a prostitute.
been able to sell it for. He asks the midwife how it is that she
knows so much about his misfortune, and she tells him a long
story about being a pawn broker and coming into possession of
his watch, which she resolved to return to him as she has.
Moll has serious reservations about seeing the drunk man Again, it isn’t stated that the midwife visits the drunk man as a
again, but the midwife goes to see him often. Each time she prostitute, but since she always comes back with money, it is
sees him, he is exceedingly kind and gives her money. On one certainly implied. The drunk man is always drunk when he
occasion, he again asks the midwife to arrange a meeting approaches a prostitute, which suggests he thinks it is wrong and
between him and the woman who robbed him, and she needs some motivation and courage to go through with it. Such
promises to try. The midwife goes home and tells Moll all about behavior goes against his own moral compass, so his story is again
her visit with the man, and Moll finally agrees to meet him. On an example of the kind of moral instruction that Defoe claims to
the day of the meeting, Moll takes great care in readying offer his readers.
herself, and when the drunk man arrives, she can tell he has
again been drinking.
The drunk man is very happy to see Moll. He apologizes for The drunk man makes excuses for his sins and immorality and
their last meeting and tells her that had it not been for the blames the alcohol, which further suggests he feels guilty. His
wine, he would have never taken such freedoms with her. He suggestion that repeating their sin won’t matter because it was
has been long married, the man says, and has not been with already committed once underscores how, after time and repetition,
another woman since he met his wife. Moll tells him not to a crime can become easier to commit. Moll’s own experience as a
worry. She hasn’t suffered any from their first meeting, and she, thief underscores this as well—stealing was difficult at first for Moll,
too, has not been with another man since her husband died but now it is easy.
some eight years ago. Yes, the man says, the midwife has
already told him that Moll is a widow. Finally, the man tells Moll
that since they have already committed the sin once, he doesn’t
see the harm in doing it again.
Several months pass, and Moll continues to see the drunk man. Moll still doesn’t openly admit that she is working as a prostitute.
He doesn’t keep her as a mistress, but he pays her more than Instead of calling it what it is, she says only that she isn’t the drunk
enough money, and she does not have to return to stealing. man’s mistress. Moll choice of words again reflects modest
After about a year, the drunk man stops calling on Moll as often, language, but it also suggests that Moll can’t admit it because it she
and then he quits coming all together, without so much as a is ashamed; it seems that prostitution goes against her moral fiber.
word. Moll lives on her savings for a few months, and when she Moll calls herself a whore when she behaves promiscuously, but she
begins to run out of money, she knows she must go back to doesn’t when she works as a prostitute.
work. Moll dresses herself up in various disguises—a widow, a
woman in an apron and straw hat, a beggar, etc.—and goes out
looking for opportunities to steal.
Soon, a woman approaches with a small child. She is holding a Again, Moll steals indiscriminately. She doesn’t care if she steals
large package, and she tells Moll that she is looking for a coach from women or children, and she is getting increasingly bold in her
for two passengers. Moll shows her to an empty coach and approach. Ironically, the woman is worried about her package
helps the child in. Moll asks the woman if she would like to put getting stolen and unknowingly gives the package away to the thief
her package in the coach, but the woman says no. She is directly.
worried that the package will be stolen out of the coach with
only the child to watch it. Moll offers to hold the package for
her, and the woman agrees, passing it Moll. The woman goes
about loading the coach, and when she isn’t paying attention,
Moll quietly slips off with the package.
A mob gathers around Moll, and she finds herself seized and Moll’s treatment again demonstrates the sexist nature of 17th-
dragged back to the shop, where the shopkeeper confirms she century English society. The men have no reason to suspect Moll,
is not the widow who robbed him. The shopkeeper tells the other than her gender, and like Moll says, they have no right to
mob to let Moll go, but one man says it is best to detain her detain her. The men assume power and control over Moll simply
until a constable arrives. Moll grows increasingly angry. The because she is a woman, and they hold her against her will. Moll has
shopkeeper has already said she is not the offender, and they every right to be angry with her treatment; however, given her
have no right to detain her, Moll says. Two men arrive with the criminal history, going anywhere near the law seems ill advised.
real offender, and a constable arrives, too. The shopkeeper tells
the constable that Moll is not the offender in question, and he
apologizes for any inconvenience. Moll, however, is furious, and
she wants the men who detained her to go before the
magistrate so she might be compensated.
A fight breaks out between the shopkeeper’s men, the mob, and “Second Mourning” is a reference to the second year of a widow’s
the constable, so they all head to see the magistrate. When mourning, in which a widow typically wore softer and lighter shades
they arrive, the magistrate asks Moll her name, and she says of black. Presumably, Moll is hoping to be rewarded money for her
her name is Mary Flanders. Moll claims to be a widow whose inconvenience, but it seems a terrible risk for little reward. Moll
husband was killed at sea. She says she went shopping this must have known she would have to give a name, and Flanders
morning to buy new clothes for her “second Mourning,” but seems a poor choice, as one of her comrades has already informed
before she bought a thing, she was accused of stealing by the on Moll to the authorities at Newgate. Moll is getting greedy and
mob. Even after the shopkeeper said she wasn’t the offender, looking for money wherever she can grab it.
two men detained her and treated her very badly. The
magistrate apologizes for Moll’s poor treatment, but he tells
her it isn’t his place to award her reparations. He does,
however, send one of the men to Newgate for assaulting Moll
and the constable.
Moll goes home and tells the midwife all about her eventful The midwife again influences Moll to behave in an immoral way, but
morning, and the midwife laughs heartily. She asks Moll if she Moll agrees easily enough. Moll’s lawsuit is further evidence that she
even realizes how lucky she is and tells her to sue the is looking for money schemes everywhere. Her crimes and
shopkeeper and make him pay her £500. Moll hires an attorney, dishonesty are getting easier, and her greed is getting out of control.
who tells the shopkeeper that Moll is a wealthy widow with a
great deal of resources at her disposal, that she and plans on
suing him to the greatest extent. Moll’s attorney demands
£500 from the shopkeeper and he offers £50, so they make
plans to meet and negotiate.
After the ordeal with the shopkeeper, Moll decides to go back Moll doesn’t need a horse—she doesn’t even know what do with a
to work dressed as a beggar. The first night she tries the horse—but she steals it anyway. Moll’s greed and increasingly bold
disguise, she just wanders around without any opportunities to actions (she can’t hide a horse) seem certain to get her caught
steal, but on the second night, she comes upon an adventure. before long, but she doesn’t appear to be slowing down. With Moll’s
Moll is standing outside a tavern dressed as a beggar, when a bank at 700 pounds, she doesn’t ever have to steal again in her life,
man approaches her and hands her the reins of his horse. He and everything she does from here is just an unnecessary risk.
tells Moll to hold the horse awhile, so he can go into the tavern.
As soon as he goes inside, Moll walks off with the horse. She
takes the horse home to the midwife, who is very confused. She
doesn’t know what to do with a horse or how to sell it, so they
decide it is best if Moll leave it at a stable.
Moll again dresses as a beggar and goes out to work, and she The “Coiners of Money” are counterfeiters, and punishment for
meets two “Coiners of Money,” who offer to take her in on their forging and counterfeiting money during Moll’s time is death by fire,
enterprise. Moll refuses, wanting nothing to do with their which is enough to deter Moll. But what few rules Moll had are fast
business, for which the punishment is “to be burnt to Death at a disappearing: She used to refuse to break into houses, but now she
Stake.” She meets other comrades, mostly those who break into occasionally does it, which further reflects the deterioration of
houses. Moll doesn’t like breaking into houses either, but she Moll’s morality.
does it for a bit and quickly grows tired of it.
The next day, Moll dresses as an upper-class lady and goes to The Mall at St. James Park is a park in central London, and in Moll’s
the Mall at St. James Park, where many ladies are walking in the day, it is fashionable for wealthy ladies to walk in the park. Moll goes
park. There, Moll sees two young girls, about nine and thirteen to the park looking for high-class targets, and she again proves
years old. The older girl is wearing a gold watch, and the herself an indiscriminate thief when she targets children.
younger girl has a gold necklace with pearls. Moll asks a
footman who the girls are, and he tells her they are the
daughters of wealthy aristocrats. Moll falls into step with the
older girl as she walks and begins talking to her as if they are
old friends. Suddenly, the king arrives to attend a meeting at
the Parliament-House, and all the people clamor to get a look.
Moll helps the girls get closer, and as she does, she steals the
girl’s gold watch.
Moll returns home and shares her winnings with the midwife, Moll is definitely getting too greedy; even the midwife is telling her to
who is indeed happy to have them. She commends Moll on her slow down and eventually stop. Moll is so greedy that she even
ability to secure money, but she warns Moll about visiting disregards the rules of a successful criminal, like staying away from
Gaming-Houses. Moll understands the danger of “the Itch of gambling, which, with “the Itch of Play,” can quickly become
Play” and decides not to place any more bets. The midwife addictive and rob her of all her money. Furthermore, Moll is drawing
suggests Moll stop stealing and be happy with what they have attention to herself, which suggests she will soon get caught.
made so far, but Moll has no intention of stopping. Moll’s
success grows and she becomes a notorious thief, and her
name is now even more common at Newgate and Old-Baily.
Moll begins to travel under various disguises. She goes to the Moll is expanding her area and stealing more and more. She goes to
spas in Tunbridge and Epsom, and then she moves on to a fair in neighboring towns to steal and comes up with new schemes. Moll
Suffolk. Moll secures a gold watch, and then she moves on to doesn’t appear to have any moral reservations or difficulty in
Cambridge, where she gets some new linen. She arranges for a breaking the law so frequently and brazenly. Just like her “crime”
linen shop to deliver goods to her rented room and after the with the gentleman, repetition makes Moll seemingly numb to the
delivery boy arrives, she skips out on the bill. From there she immorality of her career as a thief.
goes to Ipswich and on to Harwich, where she encounters
many foreigners and little of value. She does manage to lift a
large suitcase, which is too big to move, so she leaves it where
she found it.
Back on the road, Moll is stopped by Custom-House officers in Moll’s realization in Colchester reflects her evolving identity. Moll is
Ipswich, and they break open her suitcase when she claims not nowhere near the same person she was then, and anyone she knew
to have the key. Thankfully, there is nothing incriminating in is dead or gone. Lewd or promiscuous books were considered
Moll’s suitcase, and the officers let her go. She moves on to inappropriate and taboo in the 17th and 18th centuries, which is
Colchester, where she lived her early years as Robin’s wife. why Moll, and therefore Defoe, implies that her story is an example
Moll realizes she knows no one in Colchester anymore, and of how not to behave and a reminder to readers to arm themselves
after a few days, she moves on. She returns to London and tells against the evil of the world. But of course, Moll isn’t qualified to
the midwife all about her travels. Moll claims her story is most “preach” the moral of her own story, because she herself is immoral.
useful to honest people, as it reminds them to guard
themselves against the dishonesty of others. Moll leaves the
moral of her story to be decided by the reader; she isn’t
qualified to make judgements or “preach.”
Three days later, Moll walks by a house and notices the door is Again, Moll seems to think that walking into an open house is less of
open, so she goes inside. She picks ups two pieces of silk, and as a crime than breaking into a locked house. Moll has never liked
she is walking out the door, two women run from across the breaking into houses, and the featherbed that dropped on her head
street and detain her. A constable arrives, and when Moll can’t the last time she tried should have served as a warning to her, but
bribe him, he takes her before the Justice. Moll pleads with the Moll’s greed is her downfall. She walks into the house without
Justice and tells him that she didn’t break anything to get into thinking, almost like it is a compulsion, which again reflects her
the house and she has taken nothing, so there is no harm done. deteriorating morals; theft is now like second nature to her.
The Justice is about to let Moll go, but then he learns that she
was detained with fabric in her hands, which she would have
stolen had she not been stopped. Moll is immediately sent to
Newgate Prison.
Soon, word spreads around the prison that three highwaymen Moll seems to be more concerned with James’s sentence than her
were brought in the night before. Out of curiosity, Moll goes to own. She is a hardened criminal, and she expects to die for her
investigate and discovers that one of the men is James, Moll’s crimes. Moll has committed a slew of crimes—prostitution, incest,
husband from Lancashire. She is shocked and doesn’t at first adultery, fraud, robbery—and she doesn’t think she deserves to
know what to do. He doesn’t seem to recognize Moll, and she is repent now, after all this time and all her crimes. Moll’s inability to
thrown into deep thoughts about her love for him. She grieves repent highlights just how deeply her life of crime has affected her.
for him, as he will surely be hanged, and Moll soon learns that
she will certainly be tried for her own life. Learning of her
impending death, Moll again tries to repent, but she is still
unable.
Moll is arraigned on Thursday for stealing two pieces of silk Moll is sentenced to death for stealing fabric just like her mother
worth £46 and tried the next day. She pleads not guilty, but she was, which reflects the harsh punishment of the time but highlights
isn’t optimistic. The witnesses testify first and maintain that how disadvantage (and hence criminality) can run in families. Moll’s
Moll entered the house and would have stolen the fabric had mother was a thief, and so is Moll. This connection again highlights
she not been detained at the door. Moll listens as they all the role of poverty in their lives and the lack of legal and reasonable
recount the truth, and then it is her turn to plead her case. She opportunities for women to make a living. Moll’s mother had few
insists she broke nothing and stole nothing. She did not break a choices, just like Moll, and so they suffer the same fate.
door to enter, and it cannot be positively concluded that she
intended to steal the fabric. The Justice is unconvinced, and
Moll is found guilty and sentenced death.
Upon hearing her sentence, Moll begs for her life and “Bedlam” is a reference to Bedlam Royal Hospital, a psychiatric
reiterates that she broke nothing and took nothing. The Justice hospital in London that was built in 1247 and still exists today. The
says nothing, and Moll’s sentence stands. The midwife is term “Bedlam” has long since been synonymous with insanity and
inconsolable. She vacillates between anger and mourning, and chaos. The description of the midwife as a “mad Woman in Bedlam”
she appears to be “as any mad Woman in Bedlam.” The midwife further reflects the sexism and misogyny of the time, as it employs
again repents for the sins she has committed, and she is popular stereotypes of women as innately hysterical and insane.
devasted by their misfortune. For Moll, there is nothing before
her but death. The names on the death warrant will come soon,
and the execution will take place soon.
The midwife sends a minister to see Moll, and he begs Moll to Moll’s story suggests that even the most hardened criminal can
repent and see the error of her ways. He praises Jesus and repent if they turn to the Lord, which reinforces Defoe’s message of
quotes scripture, and then he kneels before Moll and prays. For morality and moral instruction. Moll again addresses the reader
the first time, Moll is moved to repent. She thinks back on her directly. She admits that giving lectures on morality would be
life with disgust and hate, and she thinks about Eternity. With hypocritical for her, but she still reinforces the importance of
the highest sincerity, Moll asks forgiveness for her sins and reflecting on one’s own morals, and this also aligns with Defoe’s aim
reflects upon her life of crime. Moll interrupts her story and of moral instruction.
tells the reader that she is not fit to read “Lectures of
Instruction,” but she hopes her story causes others to “make
just Reflections” on their own lives.
On Wednesday, Moll’s name is on the death warrant. The This part is “most Advantageous” and “most instructive” to readers
minister tries to comfort her, but he leaves that night and does because it is the exact moment Moll is redeemed and returns to
not return until late the next day. When he finally arrives at the moral living again. Moll is careful to reiterate that her story of vice
door of Moll’s cell, she is overjoyed to see him. The minister isn’t meant to be entertaining; it is meant as moral instruction.
immediately tells Moll that he has received a good report from Readers who are reading Moll’s story for the wrong reasons, or as
the Justice serving on Moll’s case, and he has obtained her a Defoe says, in the wrong way, are drawn to the “wild and wicked”
reprieve. Moll will be transported instead of executed. The parts, but both Moll and Defoe remind readers that this is not how
minister reminds Moll not to let her happiness and relief Moll’s story is intended to be read. The minister’s warning suggests
remove the “Remembrance of [her] past Sorrow” from her that surest way to avoid sinning again is to remember the pain and
mind. Moll again interrupts her story. She understands that disgust she feels for her sins now.
readers who are “pleas’d and diverted” by the “wild and wicked”
parts of Moll’s story with be dissatisfied with this part of her
story; however, the reader must know that this is the best part
of Moll’s life and is “most Advantageous” to her and “most
instructive” to readers.
It is 15 weeks before Moll is ordered to a ship for deportation. Obviously, the highwaymen didn’t rob Moll in Dunstable, and she
In the meantime, she learns that James has been moved to the has no intention of turning James in for anything. Identifying James
other side of the prison. James found a way to bribe the is just an excuse to see him. Moll is still disguising herself, even in
witnesses in his case and there is little evidence to convict him. prison, and while her lies here are harmless, she is still guilty of
Moll disguises herself and tells the authorities she can provide dishonesty and is technically sinning. Moll’s instant return to lying
evidence against the highwaymen in question because they again suggests she isn’t as remorseful and penitent as she claims.
robbed her in Dunstable. Soon, rumor spreads that Moll
Flanders will turn in the highwaymen to reduce her own
sentence, and she is taken to identify them. When Moll is
brought into the room with James, she throws back her hood
and reveals her face. She weeps, as does James, and he asks her
how she can betray him so.
James listens closely to Moll’s story, and when she gets to the James knows Moll isn’t trying to betray him when he discovers she
part in Brickill, where she lied to the police about seeing him was the one to save him in Brickill. James’s crimes in West Chester
leave town with the highwaymen, he is incredibly thankful. He and Lichfield make it clear that James couldn’t go to London with
has always wondered who saved his life in Brickill, and he is Moll because he has been a wanted criminal for many years.
very glad that it was his very own wife. He says he is now
greatly indebted to her and will do whatever he can to deliver
her from her current circumstances. James tells Moll a little
about his own history, including crimes he pulled in West
Chester and Lichfield, and Moll suddenly understands why
James wouldn’t go to London with her years earlier.
Moll attempts to persuade James using “Womans Rhetorick,” Moll’s reference to “Womans Rhetorick” again underscores the
which is to say she cries and pleads with him to volunteer for sexism of her time, which even Moll herself perpetuates here. This
transportation. There is a great deal of money to be made in the reference relies on popular stereotypes that women are hysterical
Colonies, Moll says, and he can later buy his freedom. James and over-emotional, and she uses this trope to try to manipulate
says he doesn’t have much money, and Moll assures him he can James’s feelings.
start over in America with very little. She claims their shared
troubles are enough to convince them both to leave this part of
the world and start new. James agrees, and they part with love,
just as they did years earlier.
Two days later, the midwife delivers Moll’s goods to the ship at Again, Moll claims to be penitent, but she is already scheming to get
port. She brings a trunk full of things that will be useful and money and goods to America, which is obviously prohibited. It is
needed when Moll arrives in America, along with a portion of part of Moll’s punishment that she must go to America with nothing
Moll’s “Bank of Money.” Once Moll is established in America, and work off her debt to society in the form of indentured servitude,
she will send for the rest of her money to be shipped to her. The but Moll clearly has no intention of sticking to her punishment. If
midwife is heartbroken at the sight of Moll, and she hates the Moll were truly penitent, she would likely accept her punishment,
idea of being separated from her. The midwife also brings with but she doesn’t.
her a response from James, in which he says he has voluntarily
asked to be transported. Unfortunately, James says, it is
impossible to get on the same ship, and he will have to meet
Moll in Virginia.
Moll and James pool their resources. James had a fair amount Moll seems to be back to her old ways. She doesn’t tell James about
of money when he went to prison, but the cost has been all her money, and she continues to keep her secret bank in case she
considerable, and he is down to £108 in gold. Moll puts in the is left alone and destitute. Again, Moll’s limited opportunities and
money she has on board—£246 and a few shillings—but she vulnerability as a woman are the source of her dishonesty; however,
doesn’t tell him about the £300 bank she left safe with the she is back to bribing and scheming, which implies Moll’s morals are
midwife in London. Their main problem at present is that their still flexible.
stock is all in money, except for the clothes and linens Moll has
in the trunk from the midwife, which is useless in the Colonies.
Moll bribes a member of the crew, and for 15 Guineas, she and
James are allowed a nice room and a seat at the captain’s table.
Before the ship sails, however, the midwife finds occasion to Despite getting caught for her crimes and technically being
befriend the captain and inquires what kind of equipment one punished, Moll is right where she wanted to be years ago—on a ship
would need to become a planter in America. His lists off goods with James on her way to America. In this way, Moll’s punishment
totaling around £100, and the midwife quickly secures them. isn’t much of a punishment at all. In a roundabout way, Moll is
She boards the goods on the ship in her own name and getting exactly what she wants, which makes Defoe’s claim that her
endorses them over to James to be collected when the ship story is instructive seem a bit insincere.
gets to America. By the time the ship sails and all expenses are
covered, Moll and James have £200 in money and the contents
of two trunks secured by the midwife—more than enough to
start a good life in America.
It is in this happy state that Moll and James set sail from Again, Moll is right where she wants to be. She has purchased her
Bugby’s-Hole. Their journey begins easy enough, but they are freedom and is able to start a new life with James. Moll and James
delayed by bad weather later in the trip. When they arrive in seem to be rewarded for their immorality and crime, not punished,
Virginia, Moll and James are sold as servants to a planter, and which sends a conflicting message in a book supposedly aimed at
he offers them their freedom for a large amount of tobacco. “moral instruction.”
Moll and James immediately secure the tobacco, along with 20
Guineas for good measure, and settle in Virginia, near the
Potomac River. Moll receives their goods from the ship and
stores them in a warehouse, and they secure lodging in a small
village.
According to rumors, when Moll’s mother died, she left her Moll is still misleading James because she thinks he won’t accept
estate to her Moll, to be collected if she ever made herself her when he finds out about her incestuous past. Defoe implies Moll
known. Moll is pleased to hear it but secretly laments her luck. has good reason for holding out on James—he might very well leave
Clearly, her secret is out, and if she makes herself known, she her if he knew—but again, this reason highlights how impossible
will be ruined. She debates her choices day and night for some Moll’s circumstance as a woman are. She’s forced to lie because
time, until James notices her preoccupation. She tells James as society wouldn’t understand that the events of the past were never
much of the story as she must—that she has relations living really her choice.
nearby and that her mother has died and left her money—but
she claims she is hesitant to reveal herself to them because she
doesn’t want them to know she is a transported criminal.
James tells Moll that he is willing to go and do whatever she Moll’s claim that her story is intended for the “Improvement to
wants. He will relocate to another part of the country or go to a every Reader” again recalls Defoe’s argument that wicked stories
whole new country if she wants, but Moll is torn. She wants her can be put to good use through moral instruction. Moll’s desire to
mother’s estate, but she doesn’t want James to know about her see Humphry after all this time further suggests that she loves and
past with her brother. And, Moll says, she wants to at least see cares for him and didn’t abandon him because she is a heartless and
her brother and Humphry before relocating. Moll again immoral woman. Moll had little choice in abandoning her son, and
interrupts her story and reminds the reader that the she clearly regrets it.
publication of her story is meant “for Instruction, Caution,
Warning and Improvement to every Reader,” so they should not
look too harshly on her for keeping secrets from James.
Moll and James decide to relocate to a new part of the country, It has already been established that it is not frowned on or
where they will be just a couple looking to farm, not considered taboo to be a transported criminal in the Colonies, but
transported criminals. Moll selects Carolina, the southernmost Moll and James are determined to conceal their identities as former
colony, because she detests the cold, but she can’t decide criminals. This suggests that they are ashamed of their criminal past
whether she should send James on without her and visit her and don’t want to appear immoral to others. The constant back and
brother’s plantation first, or if she should settle in Carolina and forth between Moll’s remorse and her continued signs of immorality
then return to Virginia. She decides to first go to Carolina, and leave it ultimately unclear whether her penitence is genuine.
the trip is 200 miserable miles. Moll and James arrive at a place
called Phillip’s Point and learn that the ship to Carolina sailed
three days earlier. Exhausted and unwilling to travel further,
they decide to settle right where they are.
Moll sends the letter to her brother, and when it arrives, Just as Moll lies to James, she lies to Humphry, and she is further
Humphry intercepts it. Soon after, Humphry arrives at Moll’s rewarded by Humphry’s willingness to forgive her and seek a future
lodgings in town. Moll is pleasantly surprised when she opens relationship as mother and son. Moll has little reason to lie to
the door to Humphry, who is ready to receive her as his loving Humphry. It could be argued that Moll doesn’t want her son to know
mother. He is overjoyed to know she still lives, and he goes on she is living with a man in an unlawful marriage—such a thing
to say that he did not show his father Moll’s letter. His father is reflects badly on her morals. But Moll’s marriage to her brother
old, he says, and quite senile. He asks Moll how she has come to wasn’t legal either, and Humphry doesn’t know about the linen-
be in the Colonies, and she tells him that she is staying on a draper, so her marriage to James wouldn’t necessarily appear
friend’s plantation across the bay. Humphry immediately insists inappropriate to Humphry.
that Moll live with him. His father won’t even notice her,
Humphry says, but Moll can’t conceive of leaving James.
Humphry comes to visit Moll again, and he brings with him the Moll’s sudden shame over her criminal past implies she feels guilty
will of Moll’s mother, which leaves Moll a plantation on the and doesn’t think she deserves her sudden good fortune. But
York River. The plantation has been kept in operation and nonetheless, Moll’s main concern is still money, and her shame over
maintained by Humphry, who visits a few times a year. There her wicked past seems to be secondary.
are a stock of cattle and several servants there, and Moll asks
how much it is worth. Humphry says she would get £60 per
year if she let the land out, but living on the plantation, she
would likely garner upwards of £150. If she lives in England or
across the bay and hires a steward to manage the land, she can
expect somewhere around £100 per year. Moll is silently
thankful for her good fortune, and she is never more ashamed
of her wicked past.
Moll tells Humphry that he is her only child and sole heir, and The watch that Moll gives Humphry suggests she hasn’t left her
she says the plantation will go directly back to him upon her criminal past completely behind her, and she is still benefiting from
own death. Moll then gives Humphry the only thing she has of her stolen goods. What’s more, Humphry isn’t Moll’s only child, and
value—a gold watch—but she doesn’t tell him how she got it. she has nothing to gain by lying to him and claiming he is.
Moll signs the appropriate paperwork and takes possession of Humphry’s honesty and willingness to pay Moll all the money she is
her land, and then she hires Humphry to live there and manage owed makes her dishonesty appear all the worse.
it. He draws up a contract promising Moll £100 profit per year,
and since she has a right to the current year’s crops, Humphry
gives her £100 in gold. Moll stays for over a month, settling her
affairs and visiting with her son, and then she returns to James.
CONCLUSION
Over the next year, James and Moll build up their plantation Moll finally spends her bank, which suggests she is finally secure in
with much success. They build a large house and buy more her life and no longer needs to worry about losing everything and
servants, and then Moll writes the midwife and asks her to take being put out on the street. James’s comment is clearly meant to be
Moll’s remaining bank in England—£250 or so—and spend it on lighthearted, but it also carries an element of truth. James obviously
supplies and send them to Moll and James’s plantation. When loves Moll, but he still bases at least part of her worth on material
the supplies arrive, James is caught off guard and is little wealth.
nervous. How will they pay for all this, he asks, without running
into debt? Moll smiles and tells him it is all paid for. “Who says I
was deciev’d, when I married a Wife in Lancashire?” James asks.
“I think I have married a Fortune, and a very good fortune too,”
he concludes.
The next year, Moll goes to see Humphry on her plantation to Moll seems to wait for her brother to die before she tells James and
collect her earnings, and she learns that her brother has died. Humphry the truth. His death seems to release Moll from obligation
She tells Humphry that she will likely marry her friend, who in a way, and she is free to move on, even though their marriage
owns the plantation where she lives. Moll immediately tells wasn’t legal; it’s as if the change in her circumstances changes her
James all about her past with her mother and her brother, as ability to be truthful as well. However, while Moll’s sentence is over,
well as Humphry and her plantation. James responds with good James isn’t supposed to ever return to England. Moll claims they live
humor and suggests they invite Humphry for a visit. They live their lives in “sincere Penitence,” but they break the law the moment
an easy and pleasant life for the next several years, until Moll is they go back to England, and this further casts doubt on the
nearly 70 years old. Her sentence is long over, so Moll and sincerity of Moll’s remorse, leaving open the question of her true
James return to England, where they vow to live “the moral character.
Remainder of [their] Years in sincere Penitence, for the wicked
Lives [they] have lived.”
To cite any of the quotes from Moll Flanders covered in the Quotes
HOW T
TO
O CITE section of this LitChart:
To cite this LitChart: MLA
MLA Defoe, Daniel. Moll Flanders. Penguin. 1989.
Rosewall, Kim. "Moll Flanders." LitCharts. LitCharts LLC, 12 Feb CHICA
CHICAGO
GO MANU
MANUAL
AL
2020. Web. 21 Apr 2020.
Defoe, Daniel. Moll Flanders. London: Penguin. 1989.
CHICA
CHICAGO
GO MANU
MANUAL
AL
Rosewall, Kim. "Moll Flanders." LitCharts LLC, February 12, 2020.
Retrieved April 21, 2020. [Link]
flanders.