See discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.
net/publication/338311131
A critical history of marine protected areas
Chapter · January 2020
DOI: 10.1016/B978-0-08-102698-4.00001-0
CITATIONS READS
5 567
2 authors:
John Humphreys Robert Clark
57 PUBLICATIONS 647 CITATIONS
Association of IFCA
28 PUBLICATIONS 114 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Fisheries & Aquaculture View project
Manila Clam View project
All content following this page was uploaded by John Humphreys on 06 April 2020.
The user has requested enhancement of the downloaded file.
0
1
1234542678495
3
634
3
5 2 56369
6)*+,
!"#$%$&' (
-,.,/01234-*/56-/*6/+78*-9/4+-,:01;04,+<0.,=7;04,+<0.,=78*-,/>?-*@>0<A
B50., =/4*)*+=04/C-+=/4-/+3*>D0*+/493,-0*E.,=04-,:7;00F/78*-,/>?-*@>0<
EG+,436,
HIJKLMNKOLPQRLOQSPTUVWPLJVXJVYSPVSZ[\H]KS^VV_TRJVYOLPJKV`VRJWSPJLOSXVUJMPabJKV`VNTUUTUNRLOS
QLYVPUNIL`SIQL^VQVUJXSU`VJPSXVYJLJKVcPRJdLPIYeLUNPVRRLUfSJTLUSI\SPgRTUhijklmLnV^VPUVn
TQWVJMRnSRWPL^TYVY`aJKVTUTJTSJTLUTUhiojLOSWPLXVRRnKTXKYVIT^VPVYV_XIMRT^VPTNKJRJLRL^VPVTNURJSJVR
L^VPSYpSXVUJnSJVPRMWJLkqqUQLMJlrKVOLIILnTUNYVXSYVRnVPVQSPgVY`aSNPLnTUN`LYaLORXTVUJTcX
V^TYVUXVLUJKVMJTITJaLO[\HRSUYSXXVIVPSJTUN[\HYVRTNUSJTLURlHOJVPJKVsTLtuSPJKvMQQTJwTUhiikS
NIL`SI[\HSPVSJSPNVJLOhqxnSRVRJS`ITRKVYlySTIMPVJLSXKTV^VJKTR`aJKVkqhqYVSYITUVnSROLIILnVY`a
TJRPVWISXVQVUJnTJKtHTXKTJSPNVJhhwPVzMTPTUNhqxXL^VPSNV`akqkqlvTUXVJKVUSXaXIVLOJSPNVJtNSQTUNw`a
RL^VPVTNURJSJVRKSRUVXVRRTJSJVYPVWVSJVYVOOLPJRJLJTNKJVU[\HJVXKUTXSIPVzMTPVQVUJRlHJVXKULXPSJTXSIIa
YPT^VUYTSIVXJTXSIRJaIVLOTUJVPUSJTLUSIWLITXaYV^VILWQVUJKSRWMJTUXPVSRTUNVQWKSRTRLURJPLUNVPQSU{
SNVQVUJSUYVUOLPXVQVUJRLIMJTLURbnTJKLMJRMOcXTVUJPV|VXJTLULUJKVRLXTL{VXLULQTXOSXJLPRnKTXKITV
`VKTUYJKVNSQTUNWPL`IVQl\PLWLRSIRJLTUXPVSRVJKVSPVSJSPNVJJL}qxSPVzMVRJTLUS`IVMUJTIRMXKJTQVSRS
QLPVXLURTYVPVYPLIVOLP[\HRTRVRJS`ITRKVYnTJKTUSXLQWPVKVURT^VNIL`SIXLURVP^SJTLURJPSJVNaSWWIaTUN
JLhqqxLOJKVQSPTUVVU^TPLUQVUJl
?/ :~04>+
HTXKTrSPNVJhhmTRJLPaLO[\HR[SPTUV\PLJVXJVYHPVSR[\HR[\H\LITXal
/9/F0</*,012;E0F-6:3*>/,/*,
HgVaV^VUJTUJKVQLYVPUNIL`SITQWVJMROLPQSPTUVWPLJVXJVYSPVSRZ[\HR]nSRJKVJKTPY
UTJVYfSJTLUReLUOVPVUXVLUJKV
SnLOJKVvVSZfe
v]nKTXKPSUOPLQ hiojJLhikl
HIJKLMNKfe
vTUXIMYVYXIVSPRJSJVQVUJRLUQSPTUVVU^TPLUQVUJSIWPLJVXJTLUbTJRQSTU
TQWSXJnSRJLOLPQSITRVSNPLnTUNTUXITUSJTLUJLV_JVUYUSJTLUSIpMPTRYTXJTLUROPLQ SJKPVV
QTIV`SUYLOXLSRJSInSJVPRJLSkqqUSMJTXSIQTIVtu_XIMRT^VuXLULQTXLUVwZuu]nTJKTU
nKTXKQSPTJTQVUSJTLURKS^VV_XIMRT^VPTNKJRL^VPQSPTUVPVRLMPXVRlHIJKLMNKULJTQQVYT{
SJVIaPSJTcVYbJKVVOOVXJnSRJLXLQWIVJVSJPSURTJTLUOPLQJKVRVSSR`VILUNTUNTUWPTUXTWIVJL
SIIUSJTLURZSUYJKVPVOLPVTUSRVURVULUV]bJLSUSPPSUNVQVUJnKVPV`aQMXKLOJKVXLUJTUVU{
JSIRKVIOXSQVnTJKTUJKVWMP^TVn LOTUYT^TYMSIRJSJVRlrKTRTUJMPUWPL^TYVYSRJPLUN
""
=,,+>0-04@00000 0
34 85¡¢£¢£79¤43¥5¦17734 859393¤¦
m Z[\]^_`_]abc_d`e^fegha^_ijk^e`j]`jla^jad
0123456713534816795671301
5 7060
18
5679
85
73
176567136113
73
7 16 6
7 6 534
13 7 7767
1085
7678
656
776 !"#$5 1
65 7
4
3
51 7 56713 01
50
25
473 6
85
73
397
138
36736
%7 $
5
134&&' (
12346
58
678
5)1
4!13
13 567135*5
+ ,6
-.57
!13
/05
401
6
731
1
567131085
73
76
73616
7 673 1
474
3
61
+
10,85736
6
750
16
6
45
5 ,)!*(12345146520
.76
6
3 71310 19
7 3
7 6 0
186
534615475
36
5 1 !"#$13 17456
4
6
74
56 566
567
104
7 35673 6
6
75
16
6
45
5 ,3562
9
13567135
81328
36 5345
+
60124 7875
57
456
5 6616
13673
365
0 8
.57
!13
59
6
2 7
6109*( 7
1:
736
3567135566
36713,;2 51466<0
8 7 7 31661 2
66 566
319*(
71
616
61
9
36 *1 7 6
5
7
6
41873536 2 =67459*(5 6
>1
6?
00
13 56713591328
3673>1
7451
$(1
65 7
45
5
5 46@<53419
73 19
4515<3 510
5,;2 51466<A?13
1
234B0 C346D26
:
6)1
4!13
13 567135*5
+ 54
188
34
4 19
38
36
61-
5873
5 58566
102
36
1 7 77610
5673 85
73
5
+ 1
9
/
534 46E36
5
544459*( 5 1756
476 2E1236
7
,$795
65 1465D0
.6
87446E3 .71
+234,46EB05 5
61
1
6
173 736
6 19
38
36 73
6673 5 74
85
73
9
1316
5 673(2 6
575 1
328
12 7 534
9
136
;
56.5
7
F
0124
18
2 28
4736158571
85
73
567135*5
+136
5 7
10
7 567135
47346E4
&
53
5
=125671376 7
4
065
56 5653 67
3736
136732
4781
653
108
5 2
1
7 735673 76 6
-!139
3671313)
6534 10C36
35=
67135C81
653
&
755 )56
01%5 7656/,F58 5
!139
36713146E405346
&2=
1
53 3713 .7
4 G7
679
1 1
2
1
13 -8
!13
956713 10.7
4 /5
65 7
47346E6,&&!146E60 .16 106
58
65 7
4
16
6
45
5 7315 65
534
625
73
6
8 534
87:
4 5 6
7613
95671381679
73 567585
73
16
6713
8
01
56 12 6
9*(
01
!"#$5346
.57!13
16
61
737675679
85
+
46
567131053
17
397
138
3676 73 7 6
8167956713
706
40
18 HIJK9*( 5 547236 616
6
75
9
1
01
6
16
6713100
5 7
1
05 64
5473 534106
3713785
73
76
1619*( 5 51
36 1 585
73
13
95=
6713 6
56
76 6
15105 7
973 5
365679
6
8109*( 17301
8
4 7
3=
67:
974
3
.465<6
: 2
54
1
6
4
1361B@39*( 5
1 D61236
7
,$795
65 1465D076 5 7875
328
533
45345E1236
7
73919
4 C6 124
316
4 1
9
6 566
: 2
7324
46
6
75
16
6
45
5 76 15 65 1
$73
6
31 7
732 79
101367 212 6
6
755
5 16
6
8 9*( 7
5
4
45
573
6
6165
55
5
4 6 56106
5341
36
55
5
16
6
4
7 20:7
3673 7L
61
5 7:
47376 13
7 65 539*( %1
9
8737828 7L
01
9*( 5
316
7:
4,M
146660 5 73
46626
81 6 7 37:536 1 59*(
65
6 59
3
45
365
G2
73 6
4663 176 73
5 73
1 376713106
3
401
7
3
= 5
44
7 713 ,"2 =
31
65 1466405345
173 1
2 1076
562
136
26776109*( ,
F1
6 534
*1237314664016
:
65
565
65 01
857
4506
6
F71-&5
6 $28876/, 146620
8 7 13
65 7
46
!139
3671313.711 75G79
76,!.G0 7 7362
34
9
=
1
4 15 732473 85
64 4NOPPQRS JKIJPITJHUKJJVKVJWKPXY
pqrqstuvwxytwyquzvtw{t|}~vwqutzqyzq~q~
01234564789
9 !"
#
$ ! % &
'' ()* +),-
) .* $,)/&)) )9)
9 0
9) 1,$ 8(*,$&
2&
''3#
) ) ! 9) 9 .4)9)5! 6
1
,$ /#87)))#&
''8#1%) % "
9
9 *:; &%- )))# #; )
8 2
1,$ < )
8 21,$%- #+)
*:;"
!
9 98*:;&
&
) 9 ) )!)))! )
#
6 ,) * :) );
9 & 9) 9
)
9 %) )
)9 .4==40>?64@AB274CD?>BE@AFB2BG47H401@1G?0B@@A54I54342>B>?64
B27J4@@012240>473A3>4F31=I51>40>47B54B3B271>K454==40>?64B54BLEB3470123456B>?12F4B3D543M
8*:;&
9&$
#
9 0 % 9 0 )
)
N+6 9);)!4) &) %!0 ))"
& &-
8O)&
'& ) #
P
QN+ ) !)R 1,$ 9)
% 9
S9 )T "
% !%1,$&8#S9 )8N+&
Q#U%"
$
1,$
%
9 % )&% 0 )9)
1,$
#5!V V)
N+9-W15@7XB>BEB3412Y51>40>47Z54B38(;,$ )
!Z>@B31=[B5?24Y51>40>?1281,$) # & 9
N69 1*"
P &+4\%T V)V )
%
"
)
! ))
!)1,$ #* 0 )
6))#8
2
!V S#]9 )9) !%.B0>?64@AFB2BG47M1,$ #N"
)
^ ! )! ! 1,$%
R ))% #
+% )) &9
QN+ )9)).>54F42L
71D3I51G5433/& %&%9% )
9
N+9 & )
9 %
8N+&
Q#P
)9)R 1,$ 9 ))
!%
% 9.!
)/8; )
)#&
2. /84- )#&
2 #
_`a`bcdefghcfh`diecfjcklmnef`dnci`hi`omn`m
6!!) ! "9 ! )"
!& ) 9
!))) )!)
#
+)( )8 Q 9 ! 1,$ #P
T ABCDEFGFDHIJFKGLEMLNOHEFPQRELGQDGQSHEQHK
012345607489539
6539 7
17
10238210
838897
2404
19723
37
49
128734942819371917 91 80 1139 7
1 178 3
19747
1 3
891
873498 !82"#$% &'
3
4128467('
84839 82391
828
71237
7
1
7871506204174)02112189502471
742156
87349'3903287349'21
218734989519*4197
+,-
11
49501234524(74 8
828
71231573 39712480238
4
49
1287349'6737
421
31973
8 51915
491287349 48 21 8739 421 80 174
1 1873
01
31'
2373
8
83787'1
4 4 3
8 024
11895 34531237%39
17
1
41128982 68 421024469539.619
1497
1
49
1073494/!
8
1197
139
21839 693128 48 4)678398 1511 40197,
3
3
49351215
627
121 4
0127
1012345467 39158418234601
3
7014
491287349473871508738
51 39187158239121723
7349112 1514217
1 19123
712 )8239102471
7158218,8
351 800 31511042715 7
10
28182761556239 7
12327342 54491219
149
873498 !82"395# 41 895313 1 '5(& 8 48
878 4 614/! #%3 8
178 ' & 37159391749153121977014513 987349'39
6539 86 730 3
374
82387349497
19473494082"'21121'89
768231'216 1895496197%6
5194
787349 82 1 5123124 712217238 02471
7158218701'178 3
15142116638 1978
23913711 3715-
3
40 1 374/! 9419
8762137
1216 749612465312197
9873498 89560289873498 41291978 42 8938734917739 60/! 497
1834
895312197 1 3 873139726197'
4391537
82387349397
198762147
183
89521723
7349'8 49 37
89 1412731397
102183 39 614712394 4 782346
1427
8111985174958 19128 51937349
3
19
40817
189513 987349'
89574 4
8718 /! 39745191502471
7349
871 4231
478 8997
1897129873498 $93494244912873494 87621#34! '5 &178
3
15871 43
871 4231402471
7158218800 3
8 17447
712217238 89582391
193249197895815023823 49898 11974*1
731:723
702471
7349;1
471
02471
7349;987628 187621
491287349;8
731898 119742
837874201
31;02471
73494218
801;21
2187349;898 1197427
1678398 1614987628 21462
1#11
<1 1
12'&=41127
11
871 42318219476768 1
63189551037141
853937287313042789
142
493719
483 9197397
14
38 21042739 4024 21'
89587710774
8237
132800 3
87349#1 >65 1'5 &'7
111
402431588
216 747
1 1 8
47017
182111"39 7471873189582 68 898
249373
39
3
7442121
1977
39"39 491
471 800248
174
491287349
?668 2118 39 47
153
6 7314397129873498 04 3
895028
73
142/! 821 19
128 51937349895
47
182895511 408
42539 747
1023423731895
32
6789
1
47
10140 189542 893873490240439 7
1 78147462
1
8139
4497
1
4 439 51939 87723671#=60
21895=12127'5 &
@ 14 280
3
8 8218482391
828
7124239.619
137
5191546958231'39
6539
47
8712
4 69895197
3
4049197
@3
3
302471
7157
246
1 8 4247
121 0 3
37189
@2427
10620414
491287349401
3151876214271'895
@/898 1537
7
139719734948
3139 8
3
12 11 402471
73497
897
8747
1
622469539 8218
bcdcefghijkfikcglhfimfnopqhicgqflcklcrpqcp s
01234567895
79 55
535
482375
7986 5389843574 538 4784535
7
8
536753
377353889
3
5
57
5 3
715
7 473574 57
3 77
74!"""# 7
7$
747%3
&'()*+,-+./0)1-,102+3.,456102+31-,,+0)71.8-19-,
:019014.;-,3*0)8:+1-,+)2+44.<0+1-2=.,+7/+5)+79041.,0<+3+)2<5315,+3/-+15,-47:90<99+46--)
,-4-,;-26*3+:.,.19-,-//-<10;->-+)41.?,.1-<1?+,1.,+33./19--)<3.4-2-);0,.)>-)1@A
0657
35735
73538 578437
B CD!E9755
777587278 3CD!C
86 7
6775 4163 7 B CD!ECD!C #
7 3 185
7 437 3 F
538895
734
3G774 4857 57 47 578437
%H
73473
5 57753 675
7
988$3 875
&'I10410>-1.41.??,-1-)20)8>.,-./19-.<-+)04?,.1-<1-219+)01+<15+33*
04J@ 'I),-<-)1*-+,4?,-445,-1.2-30;-,45<<-4441.,0-49+4,-4531-20)/+34-<3+0>4./;+41+,-+4
./19-.<-+)6-0)8?,.?-,3*?,.1-<1-2AI10410>-1.6-,-+30410<+6.51.5,2-K)010.)./LM(4@B
CD!ECD!C#%H
7
7 875
948
7384 89 3
36
54 5785
5
7
33 7
39 6537
89
7 647173
453 6 419845
7648
7
89'19-)5>6-,48+>-NO 9F
987175 %CD!P#
8 3 57$35
538 827475
77Q358965
734 835F
75
6743574 538 47775
%
6
34 6
5 7
5
773 5543657
89
2785
R6
3F7 8353
33 7%
H
7'674
7N3
473 5 7 8
7R67 789R6 535 532763
7 5845 475
7553 2 4386
984
89 37
23864
2777375373 635
7'5
47
8
7997 5N3$
3
5
7R6 35189 865657 87
333
73847458 G33
75
7
3727F
7589 R6 535 53275 475
77S88CDDT#%
74 7327487 675835
7 CD!C#
5 5775$
7G47
7
7
347
'J U.>+V-01>5<99+,2-,/.,+<10.)419+10);.3;--W?3.01+10.)745<9+4K49-,0-471.6-<3+0>-2+4
LM(4JNH
3
875
337
5
7 8575386
47 538
375$777 883 7 88F
3
7 5
895
7
7 5
55
737 89
6
5 3 77278758
57
3147 8 37
%
H
7 8 7589
6
5 3 7727875$
35486 73585
73574 538 83 1 47
15
7B84 83
388X234875 Y7278753!"EP H
70465
Z7845B XY!"EP#
3 7$
735
7 8763R63586
%[6
5 3 77278758
39974948
543 5 8
742 5388
35
5 754 473
7895
7984743
5
55
74777
857 54 7F89975$777 883 48$5
5
77234875 4574CDDP\84571
CD!]#% 8
7R67515
7774
7789
372385
8
742 538 7 883
7G835 53835
7 43772348753
75 5 8353 727
948 8 538
827475
58 ^843574 538 547 5184 3
538
%
_8 !`895
7 357 538
[6
5 3 7Y727875_8
3
58' 8
7427
6
5 3F
16
75
78 7
7
43747
864 7
984
6
5 3 7727875NH 475!`%]7
F
5 3
7
5
7!Da5 475#%B
37_8 !`3
947R6751R6857
8$74964 538 7984
7997 53277
3 538
353
818789 67489_8
$
3
5
86
85343F
37 854 3 5841 87
3845 534 53 73574 53
6
$ 1
587 2787
^8483 1 7753574475 538
347 53858
% 453 6 4_8 !
77Q
5878274513 35
984
_8 !D58476 737R6 351$35
3 8 865437
CD!P#%H
7
78
47
8 397
5383 37
5 538 8 727
%
H
735486 53889
6
5 3 772787583 1
773Q758
39537
3
948
74847
543 514857 57 47
58 8 753889 474653F6
7
3$
3
' 83 5
$747 3713
533 453 3 532748 7
64 351898
JN&
7 883 7 883
8 3 % 87 B737CDDP#% 574 53273574475 538
5
70465 Z7845 7
77
5
7
77948 $
3
3 47
3 85753882745
7
O <=>?@ABA?CDEAFBG@HGIJC@AKLM@GBL?BLNC@LCF
01234565788946
47 47482 27
1285 2
9
4
819779
624
9194
46
21257
912
57822
47
2519 75
52
41297
9174
59746893217 27
25 249
457462 232690 27
4
8124
4002464
5
46
69
912979 54
535
47 57 22 819
4
46285
5 4
29 09727
997
2134
597
57 578 7014
52
22 578
9452329
97
2134
59747 2979 52
14
5975
57
41572019
2
2 4124
4
209
27
546
945232725
21321 22
5326 762
4 2
96 21
41257
28146
914
21
47465274
2 19
20192
!25 0654
597
9
2
2
27
597
469785
4001942
912
963578
2 41212091
2 57 47 9
240
21
57
5
396 2
7"### $%&5 27
52
94
92
465
578
2
'25
214
47 1264
5326
466
5
2
24
15
6 019
2
2 914
4264182 6
5062
24124
597
457
15
6
019
2
2 4124
5
57
2 ()266221"###* 7
5
12
02
5
5
957
212
4
2124
5979
6
5062
24124
400241
9
27
92015915
5
2 9321
15
6 019
2
2 4124
74
59746
893217 27
(+1588
2
46,-".* 747 2327
572"###4
27
5974
22785327
9819578
293214662
27
9
1989
72
91
(/4962 ,--.*47 64
26
19864182
462
(/25
2
46,-"0*+9
14
2852
432227
2
6571
212
27 578
869469321482192321
5
2047
5974
198
222
597945235789 04
5565
2
2272969854647 2979 58946
57
957124
5786
4109
9
0965
5466
47 91 474821
47 9
21014
5
59721
74
2
05
2 47 466
912
27
532
4
4129 65 5
9
578(283921
2
46,--4*
2124
69782274
45
420
4729
25 24
4
4
22
27
9
819
4
297
91297562
27
597
2
22797
2134
59747 20695
4
597
5
5797 4152
'
9
9 29 4 2
2 9 04
562!24
0
59757)266221
("###*
4
641821
96 25972 57
9 6
5062
247
15
6 019
2
2 4124
120
12
27
2 129875
5979
2722
94 12
2
2572127
27
597
+
57014
52
2 4
21
12 457
2
62
9
2159
97
27
59747 24
257525
2 5
57
57
212
64
19 74
597460965
198
96946 47482 27
62326
%97
2227
6 4 978
240
01942
9 4157297
2134
597
2 2
5874
59794019
2
2 4124 9
9466827214
2
197857
214
597
2
227
95462979 547 296985465 0214
532
47 2457 535 46
064
9
57 5199
2827214646627829
457462 232690 27
57
2 41572
2735197 27
(7 012
47 72121
,-".*
!212912 2
05
24
197897
27
5
57
297
2134
597
2
91574391957124
578
27 2147
5529
25122
53272
47 23276285
5 4 412
56622
5972
(%91 521 8462 ,-"9*47
2:
150629
9 6572;(322
2
46,-".*92979 5 232690
27
2735197 27
46
4574565
47
9546576
59747
22 566
91 91466
4 296 21
912321 6285
5 4
215
5229
2:04021041
;8271252 04
5
2
25 091
4729
:79
4 25972
;91:7586 19
2
2 41572124
;
2125
41264
5326 201532 94
46
97
57479
215
2427
97
1 91409919 75
4
15
94
96
209321
919
20695
578
2
245
041
9
25165326599 91
5
272 7
5
97
2
4
21
597
4
4
212
457462464722
22797
2134
59747 12
9122
14
5974722
465
2
57014
52 4 20965
5466 202 527
9 2
5 2
527
5466 22
597462(7
012
47 72121
,-".* 747 2327
5797
14
9
15
019
2
59791645
25451220695
4
5975
5
4466278578
578
9 2653218
2227
40
21
57
5
396 2
2
5
4
97
27
597 9
12227
6 91
2
227
57857
212
(19
5
272
198
941
5
474647 57
154622
*47 893217 27
46482752
556226644129
2
rstsuvvwtvxtyxz{|yuy{tvu}~
011230452678079287
71084
12
564 24676220
57
520 0
52
4507
4
70 4507
6
552227672 20
6545260562216545484
64 24507
602065625 22
5262309
8
552
607
64
352 46284016 0852 !" 2 24540
657
5465757#7 22
50606
75527
$4857 8 2450
3068 24
8026% !" 64 07
684 084507
4
3
034
82
378
12
56&'(()'(*'4+ 2 20
80
2357455 0
52 27 50
2 7 657106
32 654
30
6
0
524084507
7520 32
0507
64
38452 7 026"22 522660562216824 545 050
72
12
510
065 0264
3520 4 2
802652 266
270
52
4507
454 2564687
5 09
523570
52 254507
6 0887
2
02
5$72 9654523520 4802212
56
4
$22
527 56$52 !" 3217
65 45287
50
0
87
82
64 508
4 $7
52
252
557 083260
452364 2228502$14
4 2352 7$0
752465 71
",-67
522848$722
57626 087652
60$
52 2.
0 238 052 04
!" 703234
52 84 084507
08247 452660 2662
50484 4852 065086 7
60
8
30
/012345/44 07 05$78
67
87
62 4507
4
3524404005$7 267
826
4
3844805$57228502$01212
54
2080514
4 212
54
!"4646784 023
7528523 24654
34 36 & !"78!'(*)4+$87
6703450
207
6$684552 23
034
824
39 0 6254&'(*)+42322723 287112
34507
67
8466084507
4
3
27 50
464 574 07
627 5657 64 2
7
78
6 &"2 6'(*:+
;0687
50
0
27
507
752528
0844
332
0
245
26760614
0265
75
<
650
!"708$
5 050
4=
2
50
52
4507
4",-6 762106607
4
37$0
06
40123576575232 434507
75224 5 6
45
42
0 7
12
5#2
82432
0507
7
6$5287 380302>
388>& 08 23452352 !" 684 084507
6+46
?@324AB2A/C0412B40B2DD2E1/F25GH404C2B1IJ3I12E1H43/022EIAGA12HAKJ3IE2AA2AKL4M/141A40BAJ2N
E/2AKOL/ELE40EI013/MP121I1L232A1I341/I040B32J520/ALH201ID32AIP3E2ADI3AIE/45K2EI0IH/E40B
EP51P345203/ELH201Q&R2
80
9#
2
75S4
38T2
S02'(*U+
57
2080514
4 212
54
64
352 267
826 2.
0 235701212
5521 4 2
7 87
6032 23462662
504245
26766712 7717 14
72
27 72
12
56 29
140
64652 2068
2
5$
70
52
4507
470 4507
572 0$522 7 14
82760
52 !" 6 27 50
2 012;0644 2
57106607
14$
7522
50 2$ 057
5 4507
42
60
820
8 2460
65 0
2
8$0
52 2.
0 212
567 !"14$424 243$ 248232$7
3
52844805$767127 2 0
8712
4507
6573202 0
52462
8270
52
4507
4403
VWXWYZZ[XZ\X]\^_`]Y]_XZYabcdef
#7 1
8062
7
gh
82
87254&'((i+3268 023506.
26507
4652 jI5Gk34/5 7
14 0
2 7528507
4
3 287
0623545432
05024
6 2 46
75$2544042
887 30
578067
&'(*l+8
2
5 4526707302 605$7660
3084525450506
282664 $57
62546032U(m75224 546 262 267 03022 607
75065$27 424 5 67
507
40235762464
37824
614$
75246 217524 762857 64605 65424 6
;2 24 25 7 2467
67 506%;2 65 2452657 282
5410507
6 287112
34507
67
4 244
3526287
3574
43<
6512
577 4 249462314 0
287
62 4507
14$
21246
23
'(*n52 !"87 34 6!7
266 287112
32357% P3C2015G/0E324A21L2IE2404324
o /02EI5IC/E455G32J32A20141/F240BO255EI002E12BAGA12HAIDpq@AI3I1L232DD2E1/F2EI0A23F41/I0
x efghijkjhlmnjokpiqprslijtuvipkuhkuwliulo
012345136789
9
1313
4413 5 75 1 125123
2 204 2 123
9 12
0251
26 2 2251336
6153 721373 1031513 !"#$%&'%('&)*+,
&'-%..'/01)+%/+,21-3'024+/56'/)+1789:,,6-*1,;<'6-*7+/=>6?'/*%7)@1/0
$-A'/@+' B"C
D,'-%/0E1-)%&-%/)&+26)+/?)%)*'E'1,+2+7+)4%E*+?*'&1&'1=21,'0-%('&1?'&'71)',)%)*'
F*&1,'G
1511 13152 01236&',H+/)*'12%(' &'-%..'/01)+%/CI*+,+,&'.+=
/+,-'/)%EJ%&0+/?+/)*''K+,)+/?D+-*+I1&?') %E)*' %/('/)+%/%/L+%7%?+-17M+('&,+)4
N)&1)'?+-71/ LM 2"+/J*+-*)*' O)1&?').6,)2'-%/,'&('0)*&%6?*,4,)'.,%E
$D,1/0P
1511 12512Q62313152 01234513#R1EE%7'4')17C S"*1,&'F%&)'0
)*1))*+,F*&1,'J1,171,)=.+/6)'100+)+%/)%)*' D+-*+)1&?') 1/0*'122&'(+1)',
)*'F*&1,')%:T $ J*+-*F'&*1F,/%)-%=+/-+0'/)1774-%6701FF74'U61774J'77)%)*'P
15
11 13152 01234513&'E'&&'0)%+/)*'V O &'-%..'/01)+%/C
R1EE%7'4')17C S"*1,17,%0&1J/1))'/)+%/)%)*'+.F%&)1/-'%E:T $,+/?7%217+.F7'=
.'/)1)+%/-%..'/)+/?)*1)+/)*'-%/)'K)%ED+-*+I1&?') 10'W/+)+%/%E:T $,+,%E
+..'0+1)',)&1)'?+-1/0F%7+)+-17+.F%&)1/-'CX/)*+,-%/)'K)R1EE%7'4*1,,%6?*))%'76-+01)'
J*1))*'F*&1,'.+?*)+/F&1-)+-'.'1/1/0*1,+0'/)+W'01/6.2'&%E'.'&?+/?F&+/-+F7',
1/0'K-76,+%/,)*1)*'7F)%-71&+E4J*1).+?*)2''7+?+27'E%&-%6/)+/?)%J1&0,)*'D+-*+
)1&?')6/0'&)*':T $ -1)'?%&4C
D.%/?,)F&+/-+F7',&'71)'0)%)*'1-*+'('.'/)%E7%/?)'&.Q3 4-%/,'&(1)+%/%E2+%0+=
('&,+)4 1FF7+'0)%10'W/127'1&'1J+)*1-)+('?%('&/1/-' R1EE%7'4+/-760',)*'F&+/-+F7'
)*1)1/:T $ G32 2 1Y3 Z5 1 1251213Z2 3HI*+,GF&+/-+F7'H&'F&','/),
1-1)'?%&4,*+E)E&%. )*'%)*'&,1/0 24(+&)6'%E)*'/''0)%+/-760'+) &1+,',)*'U6',)+%/
%EJ*')*'&-6&&'/)0'W/+)+%/,%E$D,-%6701--%..%01)')*'-%/-'F)%E:T $ .13+/?
)*'71))'&)'&.+/06'-%6&,'&'06/01/)CX/1/4'('/)J*+7':T $,/''0)%2'6/0'&F+//'0
2410'W/+)'-%/,'&(1)+%/%2['-)+('1/01FF&%F&+1)'.1/1?'.'/) )*'+&%&+?+/17F6&F%,'.14
2'0+EE'&'/) ,6-*1, 1522-7%,6&',&%6/0*+,)%&+-J&'-3,J*+-*12 *1('$D)4F'
-%/,'&(1)+%/2'/'W),C
N+/-'R1EE%7'4H, S"F1F'&1,62,+0+1&42%04%E)*' %/('/)+%/%/L+%7%?+-17M+('&=
,+)4*1,10%F)'01&'-%..'/01)+%/)*1):T $,2'0'W/'01,E%77%J,\P2Z1Z52
27
1]12512
15
22^5 1 1_512`
3Z1512022Z134
`273
2 2
11
3 12343 21ZQ 1504 0135
1Q3 43152 6153 7a`
233Q
2 11373 104 32315132a`
1512261a4 452a35 42a2
1527
5112 2413HC
X/)*+,0'W/+)+%/+)+,F%,,+27')%0+,-'&/1/6/0'&,)1/0127''EE%&))%F&'('/))*'+0'1%E
:T $,2'-%.+/?1I&%[1/>%&,'E%&)*'/6.2'&,?1.'%E%('&=-%6/)+/?C>%J'('&+/
)'&.,%E'-%7%?+-17F&%)'-)+%/ 1/0/%)J+)*,)1/0+/?&'-'/)0')1+7'0'EE%&),)%0+,)+/?6+,*
2')J''/$D,1/0:T $,Xb 8c D d2" )*'0+EE'&'/-',1&'1&?61274,62)7'
1/0+).+?*)2',6??',)'0)*1) ,62['-)'0)%(1&+%6,+/)'&1-)+/?F&',,6&',%F'&1)+/?%('&
4'1&, 126&'16-&1)+-F&%-',,*1,-%.'-7%,')%0'W/+/?1/:T $ 1,1/$D)*1)0%',/H)
17&'104'K+,)C:&)%F6)+)1/%)*'&J14 1/$DJ*+-*+,/%)-177'01/$DCX/1/4'('/)
)*+,0'W/+)+%/J*+7'2'+/?+.F%&)1/)+/&'71)+%/)%)*'D+-*+I1&?') 17,%*1,+.F7+-1)+%/,
E%&J*1).14-%6/))%J1&0,1V O)1&?')C
]^_`abcd^_ e
0123456712
89
9
9
99 9 9
9
9 9
9
9 99 9
9
!
! "
9"
#$8
!
9
!
9
!9
9 99
%9 "
#
99!
! 9
9 9
&
9
"9
!
9
"
!
9
9
!9
9
'99 9
9
9
("
!
)
!
9 9
"% 9
9
!
9
" !! 9% 99
9
9
&
9
9!
99
9
9"9 9
9*
9
! 9
99
%9 9
9
!
9
% * 9
&9 ++
! 9
,
9 99
9
9
-
9
!
9
9
*
)
.
!
.
9
!99 /0
'../0
(%
!"
9
9
#
9
%
9
9
9
9 99 9
9%9 1
9
9
9 99
9
9
'&99 9 %23+45
( &
9
9"
"
9 9
99)
"
% 99
!
9
9
" !
9)
%
)
!
&
9!
"9
)9
9 9
9
9
'
9
67.8(%9
9
9
9
"
89:
% 9
9)
%9
9 1
!99
&
"
#
"9
9
)
!
% * $ 9
!
! 9
9
9
.
9
6
-
9 9 ;<=>?@AB>CDEFGC@<FH<D@EI 9 !!
9
!
9 9
!
9
9 9 9
%
9)
9
9
" !!
9 9
!5 )
1
! 9 , 9 9#
- 9
99 9 9
!
,
9# J
- &
!
9
*
9 $K
'23+L(9
67.8-
23+L
9 2M89:
9!
M3N
!
"
-
9
!
!
9
!
! *
9
23M3
O!
9
%0
9 '23+4%
(
9
99
)
" 9
9
9
)9
!9 "
#
"9 9
P 9
!9
9,
-9
9
9
)
9
9
%
9 9
"
9
99
!9
9
*
!
& 9
" 9
9 !!
9
9
*9 Q R9
9 '23+M("
9
! 9
99 99
!
#
!
ST=@U>=VW?XA@CYW>E<D<Z
YW>=D<Z[\/ * 9 '23+4(9 9
*9
!! 9 \R
9 9
1
!9
cd PQRSTUVUSWXYUZV[T\[]^WTU_`aT[V`SV`bWT`WZ
012314156789
427
76 7 7 23
8537995
427
85542
2
424
427
5
2
87
95
485 425 87453456879 415379542
857
83559
732
423537
358
41 4 852958 4252
5678
427
758
95
47956
8415829 23 427
76
412 7 7 235
427
8537
25855 5015852
4127
95
9185
8
!"#
$159
24
5763
885
48 45762725824 7
7 31
5 85
85355
45
2
354155
76415 854 357
5827
6%325
467841574
427
76415
50&
4187
735
55731 8
4'5
#(45
2 4153 57641587 59 29 255589785)*&
85 3758 5
415856785
784+,
-, 7 .
6 34415325
42%38 427
678
317 2 3 2
70
4 240 678/
315
372
+0524574173
37
4545
56678447
426 8423
8 7 85 4 854(1/5 854 !234124554 !5# 415 85
55
42 8248 8%
85825
584
55285477795412
47874534
415735
378
76325
42%3 2458 4
851702
41 42
3584 2
537 723
9
5
95
43283
94
35)*&3
15
.
37
3
27
05 8
541 4 4531
738 423 825
2 53423 4 5762
458
427
7
2387351 4187
1 85733
427
0241 8248 8 85 4 854 385 45 3 23 92
85 3427
$15857
547012311 55
47
42
385 2
591 27
487
58)*&9
595
4
5
6783595
47
427
02417
48758 8565342
7
852
415
6 347801231 25512
415 92
87 59.
41595
429529 24233 6789785
)*& 85
487
589
595
43 884157784
24374 732 45024138702
7
441555 795
476 3798515
25 7 48 456789 82
537
58 427
02412
01231)*&3
978537
2585 84
.
55
4415 335 58 42
8704176)*&3758 5 2637
42
52
41537
457476415
482 2
978576 7 85 87453427
4 854 02 479572
429
31 37985
15
25 7 9 82
548 45 2
67895
415276)*& %158
74158325
42%3
878 995
4 23 547! ,764159 82
585 9
89:9;9<=9>
?78
). !"5@&3125595
42
9 82
537
58 427
.) 82
5* 8 A
287
95
4 7
58 427
!+# !"5
- +
?82 B ? 5' C 0 07
$ D7 58 ? !EF537995
427
47.G H47.9875) 82
5*8745345&85
2%3 427
F57842
8458 H 5$15*7 242376415A
287
95
4 .5 &34229 *7 23 9825G
25824*85
?0 ! .
IH50J227
F5
285474 576608 9 423?2725824/7 GHF5784*85F5 5 5!41
) 7
5
427
7
?27 723 025824)7
485
?0 ! (*! 053227
KL I$1548 4523*
678?2725824 !!M
415&2312?2725824$ 854
G
245H 427
A
287
95
4*878 995 H 7 B
789258 59 ) !@* 84232 478758
35769 82
58745345 85 I 7 2423 31 5
5
54123
2958 425 266585
448 5347825
85
*5853425.
458 42
A
287
95
4
732545 N!M +
8
4'5
*B D57 7769
2
H 4
85@!- +MNO
05
47 A 54 !+)22
9 82
58745345 85 )* 854I170415
1678
24
5892
5
4 2
2 24
732
4235B7
8
76A
287
95
4 )
595
4! @ !+5M!@2
0
5 HA# ED
25 2
5678& 2
*8745345&85 )
595
4 457825.G HD
024'58
0
85
2 ) ?75858 C ?
8
544 C& *8755 F 4789 ? !EA 5 4548 0 2
2
258745345 85
58
92
537
58 427
7
437952
7 %12
17474325
35+2 !@+M!@5
AA !"5" 7
32 028534255"L@"LAA 7
58 427
7642 ?28A
875
A37
7923 799
24
IJKJLJMNJO PP
012345267897
966236352426331223524236234511229
5627!16"#$9%7&62632432'62$24214 (&2 239$12267)*69
+" 789723197
,9-23.442/.162/ 62 6324326242634233
26 2432906326&628424207
19533 22962 911,
2 69
,9
19
+789#$9%7
09&62632432'629!5 ( 11739
167-97
49&62263 22 6235 63243953620107
67
49
7!97812'3
49+ 3623613523623 6453 96351482642914
' 363-229
5627897!16"7-97
98 242:242 14 31326 62 63243262 2 239
5627!16" #$9%7&62632432 '6284242714 &2 239$12267)*67
9 6
7 049
5627897 262637-989 97
,9&62 6324326242427 14 2 239$3627!31
852184242
07
07
,9
;!57
4
90636142624231 6"9 6422!26242)62 352 ;!51 35
82<81=35
4
9
;!57
,
9531 6"74263221 239 ;!5! 5316"632432
'62642235291!629
;!57
69!64'4319 ;!566 2632432'627+1783>2619
;!57
,9+2126' 1632432'62&2 23!32629 ;!57+1783>2619
;!57
9+2126' 1352 ;!5&2 23!32623&62632432'62#8 12 236
3352
,+212%9 ;!57+1783>2619
;!57
9?52&62632432'62-211 &62632432'627,3582 32 26&28332 239
;!57+1783>2619
;!52?!'7
,9' 1 ;!5@+11!2638363&62632432'62#&'%9A21<
26$2432!263'433565&'7382462)42 2135(8312A221 239B26
9 9+1783>26196 9
;!52?!'7
,9#A63%+2126-24-2 63)3526$2432'62<92!263
&2629B26 9 ;!5783>2619
827887
69+26&62632432'629-31227'9
C21125267+97
9+2126&62632432'629 ;!57+1783>261! 627;C9
+62396626-22&626"'35637?619"7 ;!59619 C21125267+97912"17!97?2112789
#$9%7
09'+11-2 6223328 32 &62632432'629
3127A9#$9%7
,9D65236"&62632432'629D52&''4316 ;!5@?61
! 632432'629 ;!57?!'7+1783>2619
3127A9723197
=9' 36433.35262243262<24263 262/26'45D623
352!239141A26367326 62332 264229':34!26<
3&620625326$432
=#8 %7 1 7 1=9
32 2*789723197
9 35264234522'45D623 41E2 6>2352224324263<
263 !29&6214
71
71
19
32759723197
=93628412&62632432'62+2126A2&2 239 ;!57+1
83>2619
34524789723197
9D52312 52623322414162264529$41 =
71= 76
9
34524789723197
191512352423522 264242 62622629$4141' 1<
43 1# % 98178=9D52$41418423 ' 2649
&'527
9&'52
#0%) 2!5219) 2! 436352)42#)!D)%9
521789<097?221789<F97
=9&62 632432626 42633312221 239 32631
8618312A221 23 #1%7
117
0 9
)G326799!97
49$2432!262D6236)42632439!263323326
#4%71
,76 69
6327C9$97
0983139& D627&452339
- 6!237
= 9D52!23?231 32631 6342$ 2411 ?3261 33
#- 67 6
= %9
-2278973 7897032675973 27)97+6H357!97012345267897857A97'336117&97
,996352
241<241414526242 62 63243262236"29':34!263&62
0625326$432
,#1%7=067=419
-2451< 2513>7$97&4C2>27$97
09&62632432'628 63 23 23)42 21359?61
?1120#??0%7+1783>2619
VW CDEFGHIHFJKLHMINGONPQJGHRSTGNISFISUJGSJM
0123456789
97 1
799897943434363436335333514336 3436 033 6 6
1 1!7"#$9
0123456789
97% &67'9 97( 7 9097)**#9+ 341 31434363436 36
652 36 34369 161, -
+4651615 301! .135! /"*7)/$/)9
0103 719 9735 97)*9236! 303 1 636 343605 3435106,314163451943%
, 43!67
8 4&5606977
43 41535304363.337 1 !0
33596 63347891409
. 7.97:
2 317'97(414
0-81 3457;9713 789701234567897.
729097)*<96636643 ,41436651-
406335313,4153519
43 1 !7$/9
. 7
9697(53 !769
97136 36547497<"9 2 14, :6518165 0
43 41535304363
( 12 .
43!9+3 03,145=%84-<"-9=1106%1 38314, 4655
517=1106%1 37
9
+4 7 9735 97)*9+ 3.1
5 84&3!6 066 3 43,415353043351 4065 33652 6 3516,5
,41535153451 5346943%
, 43!678 4&5606977
43 41535304363.337 1 !0
-
33596 63347891409
27)9+ 30113 4511641350133 1,35925305167=6 519
27)*>9+ 3.
652 3133 1,35(1 603,145)*>9253051673 ?14&9
=8617<>98
4811
5
43903,14515 3=14 0816611641350133 1,3554
05-
08166172530516(334 6632 !11
35@A)@A)>53979
= 537'9=97&1 67;9'97 1561407:9=97)*>9036,163518B:34!35 3
6
631
103 6:30651
6
03081-
634510313051698163451:355346*5)77)"$)>*9
= 61769897)*"9% -645 98
4 356 514:39:34 57:1019
=14 0 4&68143667)*A9+ 3 41631.!03!9428=14 0 4&68143667.!03!7
654 9
View publication stats
