Introduction
◦ Aims of Criminal Law
◦ Pre-Trial; Trial by Jury
◦ Proof Beyond a Reasonable Doubt
◦ Presumption of Innocence
◦ Owens v. State
Theories of Punishment
◦ The Queen v. Dudley and Stephens
◦ MPC s 1.02
◦ People v. Superior Court (Du)
◦ People v. Du
◦ Ewing v. California
Principle of Legality and Statutory Interpretation
◦ Commonwealth v. Mochan
◦ In re Banks
◦ Desertrain v. City of Los Angeles
Actus Reus
◦ Voluntary Act
◦ Martin v. State
◦ State v. Utter
◦ MPC 1.13(2); 1.13(3); 2.01
◦ Omissions (“Negative Acts”)
◦ People v. Beardsley
◦ Barber v. Superior Court
Mens Rea
◦ United States v. Cordoba-Hincapie
◦ Regina v. Cunningham
◦ MPC 2.02; 1.13(10)
◦ Transferred Intent
◦ Willful Blindness
◦ Strict Liability
◦ MPC 2.05; 1.04(5)
◦ People v. Conley
◦ State v. Nations
◦ Staples v. United States
◦ Mistakes (of Fact and of Law)
◦ People v. Navarro
◦ People v. Marrero
◦ MPC 2.04
Causation
◦ Actual Causation
◦ Proximate Causation
◦ Velazquez v. State
◦ Oxendine v. State
◦ People v. Rideout
◦ Velazquez v. State
◦ Magnolia Hypo
Substantive Offenses
◦ Criminal Homicide
Homicide: Intentional --- Murder
State v. Guthrie
Midgett v. State
State v. Forrest
MPC 210.0; 210.1; 210.2; 210.3; 210.4
Homicide: Intentional --- Manslaughter
Girouard v. State
People v. Casassa
Homicide: Unintentional --- Murder and Manslaughter
People v. Knoller
State v. Williams
Homicide: Felony --- Murder
People v. Fuller
People v. Howard
People v. Smith
State v. Sophophone
◦ Rape and Related Sexual Offenses
The Traditional Approach --- the Requirement of Force and
Resistance
State v. Alston
Rusk v. State
State v. Rusk
The Modern Approach --- Abandoning “Force,” Embracing Mens
Rea
State of New Jersey in the Interest of M.T.S.
MPC 213
Defenses
◦ Justification Defenses
Categories of Defenses
Structure of Justification Defenses
Self-Defense
“Reasonable Belief” Requirement
People v. Goetz
MPC 3.09
State v. Wanrow
State v. Norman
State v. Norman
United States v. Peterson
MPC 1.12, 3.04, 3.11
Necessity (“Choice of Evils”)
MPC 3.02
◦ Excuse Defenses
Excuses
Duress
United States v. Contento-Pachon
MPC 2.09