Dross Formation
Dross Formation
net/publication/343271279
Article in JOM: the journal of the Minerals, Metals & Materials Society · July 2020
DOI: 10.1007/s11837-020-04268-4
CITATIONS READS
0 81
3 authors, including:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Jan Steglich on 11 October 2020.
JOM
The Journal of The Minerals, Metals &
Materials Society (TMS)
ISSN 1047-4838
Volume 72
Number 10
1 23
Your article is protected by copyright and all
rights are held exclusively by The Minerals,
Metals & Materials Society. This e-offprint is
for personal use only and shall not be self-
archived in electronic repositories. If you wish
to self-archive your article, please use the
accepted manuscript version for posting on
your own website. You may further deposit
the accepted manuscript version in any
repository, provided it is only made publicly
available 12 months after official publication
or later and provided acknowledgement is
given to the original source of publication
and a link is inserted to the published article
on Springer's website. The link must be
accompanied by the following text: "The final
publication is available at [Link]”.
1 23
Author's personal copy
JOM, Vol. 72, No. 10, 2020
[Link]
2020 The Minerals, Metals & Materials Society
Herein, dross formation (D) in used beverage can (UBC) scrap bales was
investigated in laboratory-scale experiments to understand the reactions of
solid can coating residues with aluminum melts. The experimental conditions
were chosen according to a multi-chamber furnaces process, in which thermal
pretreatment and submerged melting of the scrap bales are combined. The
thermal pretreatment results show that the supply of oxygen should be con-
tinuously adjusted to meet the oxygen demand of UBC scrap bales for ther-
molysis. Moreover, it is necessary to maintain the UBC scrap bales at an
effective material temperature of 550–570C for at least 30 min. It is shown
that adhering carbon-containing pyrolysis char and oxidized can sheet sur-
faces decrease the coalescence of molten scrap, resulting in dross with a high
metal fraction. Further melting experiments with UBC scrap bales of different
densities (q) show that by lowering the q, the dross formation reduces.
3383
Author's personal copy
3384 Steglich, Friedrich, and Rosefort
Table I. Definition of k for different thermal pretreatments and the resulting reaction products
Combustion, exothermic k‡1 CO2 and H2O Metal oxides and inorganic pigments
Thermolysis, endothermic 0< k £ 1 CO, CxHy, H2O, and CO2 Inorganic pigments
Pyrolysis, endothermic k=0 CxHy Inorganic pigments and solid carbon residue
Author's personal copy
Dross Formation in Aluminum Melts During the Charging of Beverage Can Scrap Bales with 3385
Different Densities Using Various Thermal Pretreatments
Main impurity – Coating Coating, plastic, iron, copper Coating, plastic Visual
Density kg/m3 450 910 1110, 808, and 685 Weighing
Volatile organic wt.% 2.8 ± 0,3 8.4 ± 4.0 10.0 ± 2.6 Annealing at 450–550C
Moisture wt.% 0.9 ± 0,7 1.7 ± 1.1 0.9 ± 0.7 Drying at 105C
Porosity % 83 66 59, 70, and 75 Measuring
reaction in the pretreatment reactor, resulting in The comparison results of different scrap types
extensive metal oxidation and dross formation in with q < 750 kg/m3 in Fig. 1 obviously show that
subsequent melting experiments. After this obser- the stoichiometric thermolysis lowered the D to a
vation, the oxygen supply during de-coating was minimum value as compared to that of the initial
adjusted, and the experiments were repeated with scrap. Based on the previously measured carbon
UBC C. and oxygen concentrations in the scrap, a lower q
The oxygen demand of UBC C was roughly promotes the removal of organics and the effective-
calculated using the organic mass of the samples, ness of thermal pretreatment. As a result, low-
the molecular formula of epoxy, polyester, and PET density scrap has fewer contaminants and results in
monomers, and a simplified combustion calculation less D. A lower q also lowers D in the raw scrap
for thermolysis and combustion conditions. The without thermal pretreatment; however, the slope
calculation yielded the oxygen demand of 5–8 mol of the linear best-fit line is not very steep. As the
O2 per kg UBC scrap, which was supplied by argon atmosphere prevented the combustion of
ambient air into the reactor at 10 l/min over the organic contaminants during melting, the organics
reaction time of 50–60 min, following the ideal gas were removed as volatiles.
law. Herein, the balance of oxygen demand and
supply over the process time is defined as stoichio- g of UBC scrap bales
metric thermolysis. These conditions led to the best
The g of UBC A and B was not improved by the
decoating while simultaneously reducing the metal
applied thermal pretreatment. Unfortunately, the
oxidation.
melting of the initial scrap samples resulted in the
Note that the stoichiometric thermolysis condi-
highest g. Initially, the static process parameters
tion (k 1) was only fulfilled over the thermal
were not adjusted according to the scrap bales and
reaction time of 50–60 min. The limited but contin-
led to incomplete pretreatment or metal oxidation.
uous oxygen supply resulted in substoichiometric
Subsequently, the protective argon atmosphere
conditions in the reactor as most of the oxygen
used in the melting experiments prevented metal
reacted with organics. Supplying all the oxygen at
loss in the untreated scrap. This unexpected result
once into the heated reactor would result in an
is discussed in ‘‘Understanding the Organic Content
exothermic combustion reaction and metal loss.
as a Heating Value’’ section.
This approximation should be further developed in
For UBC C, stoichiometric thermolysis conditions
future research.
were applied. The g results are shown in Fig. 2.
It is summarized that industrial thermal pre-
After adjustment, the thermolysis pretreatment
treatment should not be operated under static
conditions simultaneously maximized the g of the
process conditions; however, the oxygen supply
scrap and minimized D (see Fig. 2). The theoretical
should be continuously adjusted to meet the oxygen
g of UBC C was 87.4% based on the measured
demand of the scrap. Therefore, the organic content
organic content of up to 12.6%. This g was achieved
of the scrap in the reactor should be determined.
in one of the samples with a medium q after
Additionally, the treatment time needs to be
thermolysis at 550C in air (thermo mid). Even
adjusted according to the q, gas flow, and degrada-
though the theoretical metal yield cannot be met in
tion kinetics of different organic contaminants for
industrial processes, the results show that thermol-
successful decoating.
ysis maximizes the performance of submerged scrap
melting and subsequent dross processing.
Impact of q on D
An increasing g trend with decreasing q is also
The D results of UBC C1–C3 are plotted versus observed in Fig. 2 for all pretreatment conditions. If
their q in Fig. 1. The results are displayed in groups UBCs have to be recycled as bales, the q should be as
based on the pretreatment. A linear best-fit line was low as possible to minimize metal loss and as high as
plotted through the results, and the correlation required for economic transportation and storage.
coefficient rxy used to rate how well the variables q
and D fit to the trend. Finally, the D results of UBC
A and B were added. DISCUSSION
The results in Fig. 1 highlight that pyrolysis leads Dross Formation Mechanisms
to a constantly high D over the entire range of q. As
previously shown, pyrolysis leads to a film of In an industrial multi-chamber furnace, scrap
adhering carbon-containing coating residue, lower- bales are pushed into the melt after thermal
ing the coalescence of molten sheets in the metal. pretreatment. All remaining coating residues are
Therefore, D is constant with respect to the can submerged with the scrap into the melt. In contrast
sheet surface area. Compared to the case of to a reverberatory hearth furnace, the scrap does
pyrolyzed scrap, D in the initial beverage can not melt in the hot burner atmosphere, but is
increases with q. submerged in the melt.
Author's personal copy
Dross Formation in Aluminum Melts During the Charging of Beverage Can Scrap Bales with 3387
Different Densities Using Various Thermal Pretreatments
Fig. 1. Dross formation (D) results of UBC as well as comparison of the linear dependence of scrap density q with D and the corresponding
correlation coefficient rxy.
Author's personal copy
3388 Steglich, Friedrich, and Rosefort
Fig. 2. Metal yield g of UBC C with the bale densities of 1110 kg/m3 (dense), 808 kg/m3 (mid), and 685 kg/m3 (low), without pretreatment (raw),
after pyrolysis in argon at 550C (pyro), and stoichiometric thermolysis in air at 550C (thermo).
The melting of untreated UBC scrap bales with D and maximized the g. Only fractured oxide films
coating led to large amounts of dross. This dross had of beverage can sheets were detectable as non-
a high metal content with honey-like viscosity. Even metallic inclusions in the dross layer, showing that
though there were no solid coating residues from coalescence was achieved. The dross formation
pretreatment in the initial scrap, the metal was mechanisms are summarized in Fig. 3 and
trapped in oxide films, generated by gaseous decom- explained in further detail in Ref. 7.
position products of the organic contamination.
Melting of scrap bales with pyrolysis pretreatment
increased the D compared to that of the untreated Dross Formation by Metal Inclusions Caused
material. This is caused by the adhering of pyr- by Solid Coating Residues
olyzed coating char residue to the metal sheets.
The influence of the above described solid coating
Consequently, pyrolysis leads to reinforced compos-
residues and oxide films on dross formation, caused
ite ‘‘bi-films’’,8 supporting the structure of scrap
by the thermal history of the scrap, is quantified in
bales. Melting of scrap bales after adjusting the
Fig. 4. The molten metal, trapped in the solidified
thermolysis pretreatment conditions minimized the
Fig. 3. Proposed dross formation mechanisms of coated can sheets with and without thermal pretreatment based on metallographic results.
Reprinted with permission from Ref. 7.
Author's personal copy
Dross Formation in Aluminum Melts During the Charging of Beverage Can Scrap Bales with 3389
Different Densities Using Various Thermal Pretreatments
Fig. 4. Impact of trapped metal mM in oxide films on the dross formation D of UBC bale scrap compared to data of Ref. 11 determined via pilot-
scale experiments with sheet scrap.
dross, was recovered by remelting under salt flux. Understanding the Organic Content
This metal fraction mM is set with respect to the can as a Heating Value
sheet surface area and plotted on the x-axis. The
The melting of UBC A and B without pretreat-
according D results of UBC A and C are plotted over
ment resulted in an approximately 60% dross and
the y-axis as they have a low q, whose influence can
90% g although the organic contaminants in UBC B
be excluded here. The UBC masses and surface
were three times those in UBC A. Contrary to the
areas were comparable and constant in all the
case of industrial furnaces, the laboratory melting
melting experiments with mUBC = 0.1 kg and
experiments were conducted in argon. It is hypoth-
A = 0.5 m2. In addition, these values are compared
esized that an inert gas effectively prevents the
with the D results of Ref.11, which were conducted
reaction of organic content. To verify this hypothe-
on a pilot scale with 200 kg uncoated Al and
sis, melting experiments were repeated in air
AlMg4.5 sheets. The scrap had a total surface area
instead of argon with all three UBC types. The
of 973 m2 and was melted in a gas-fired reverber-
impact of organic content on D and g was then
atory furnace. The comparison in Fig. 4 shows a
compared with that assessed by previous experi-
correlation between the mM in oxide films and D. In
ments in argon.
these laboratory-scale experiments, the scrap bales
Figure 5 compares the D and g of UBC scrap bales
were molten under inert gas, limiting molten metal
plotted against their organic contents. The rxy was
oxidation. The D is therefore mainly influenced by
also used to evaluate the fit of the variables to a
trapped metal in the carbon or oxide-reinforced can
linear trend. It is confirmed that melting in air
sheet oxide films.
results in a functional correlation between D and
From Fig. 4 it is summarized that pyrolyzed
the organic content, whereas this is not the case for
UBC produces comparable or even more dross
argon. Melting in air resulted in visually observable
than the initial scrap without any decoating. The
combustion of the organic content and immediate
carbon-containing coating residue on the can
metal oxidation. Metal oxidation leads to increased
sheets was found in the solidified dross even after
D and reduced g.
a 35-min reaction in the liquid melt at 750C.
The g obtained by melting the UBC scrap bales in
Metallographic investigations of the dross metal
argon and air is also compared in Fig. 5. As
interface revealed that the carbon layer effectively
expected, melting in air leads to a lower g because
prevented metal coalescence, trapping 70–90% of
of the uncontrolled combustion of organics, creating
the can alloy in the dross layer. Note that the
temperature peaks at the can sheet and resulting in
laboratory-scale D results are not directly trans-
metal loss. The rxy shows a smaller difference than
ferable to the industrial scale. Upscaling effects,
previously as the argon atmosphere does not pre-
such as the metallostatic pressure of liquid alu-
vent reactions of the liquid melt with gaseous
minum in the dross layer of industrial furnaces,
decomposition products of the organic
led to less mM and therefore less dross.
contaminants.
Author's personal copy
3390 Steglich, Friedrich, and Rosefort
Fig. 5. Comparison between D and g of UBC A, B, and C2 by submerged melting in argon and air with the correlation coefficient rxy.
Consequently, the relationship between the supply required oxygen during the process. This
organic content and D can be understood via the appears quite challenging for state-of-the-art pro-
calorific value (Hi) of organics under these experi- cess-control techniques, thus requiring further
mental conditions. Herein, the Hi in combination improvements.
with the oxygen-containing furnace atmosphere led
to the uncontrolled combustion of scrap bales.
CONCLUSION
Due to the different behaviors of scrap bales
under similar process conditions, the organic The D and g of UBC recycling are the result of the
removal should be distinguished in the cases shown two-step process of thermal decoating and sub-
in Fig. 6. During pretreatment, UBC B was burning merged melting. The results show that the thermal
in over stoichiometric atmosphere, while UBC A pretreatment of UBC scrap bales effectively reduces
had a too low carbon content (or Hi) to ignite. It is D if stoichiometric thermolysis is applied for a
decisive that the Hi of organic contaminants (mix- holding time long enough to achieve a material
ture of polyethylene/polyester) is similar to that of temperature of 550–570C for at least 30 min. The
fuel oil with Hi = 10 kWh/kg.12 The cases in Fig. 6 use of shredded or loose UBC is recommended as a
show the different behaviors of UBC scrap bales and larger specific surface area will promote heat trans-
conditions to avoid uncontrolled combustion. port to the material and thermolysis gas transport
Regarding thermal decoating, Hi should be out of the scrap. The laboratory results indicate that
removed without exothermic combustion, which is UBC scrap bales with a low q (< 450 kg/m3) should
achieved by limiting the oxygen availability to a be used because a higher q negatively influences
stoichiometric ratio over the pretreatment time. For mass loss and D. This result needs to be verified in
an industrial process, it is necessary to measure the industrial-scale furnaces with submerged scrap
organic load, calculate the oxygen demand, and melting.
Author's personal copy
Dross Formation in Aluminum Melts During the Charging of Beverage Can Scrap Bales with 3391
Different Densities Using Various Thermal Pretreatments
Fig. 6. Conditions of organic removal from UBC scrap bales with different calorific values expressed as a simplified stationary process.