Interpreting Unexpected Events

and Transitions in DSC Results

TA039

INTRODUCTION

The purpose of this paper is to assist DSC users with

interpretation of unusual or unexpected transitions in DSC
results. The transitions discussed in the paper are several
of the ones that most frequently create problems for the
new user, and which can also fool even an experienced
thermal analyst.

By applying some of the recommended procedures and

solutions, most laboratories will be able to improve the
overall quality and interpretation of DSC results.

BACKGROUND

Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is a thermal

analysis technique which measures the temperature Figure 1: Artificial DSC curve
and heat flow associated with transitions in materials as
a function of temperature and time. Such measurements
provide quantitative and qualitative information INTERPRETATION OF EVENTS AND TRANSITIONS
about physical and chemical changes that include
endothermic/exothermic processes or changes in heat Event 1: Large Endothermic Start-up Hook
capacity. Specific information that can be obtained
include: Causes

• Glass transition temperatures At the beginning of a programmed heating experiment,

• Melting points & boiling points there may be significant baseline change (usually
• Crystallization time & temperature endothermic) which occurs primarily based on
• Percent crystallinity differences in the heat capacity of the sample and
• Heats of fusion and reaction reference. Since heat capacity is directly related to
• Specific heat weight, an endothermic shift indicates that the reference
• Oxidative stability pan is too light to offset the sample weight. This effect is
• Rate of cure heightened by faster heating rates.
• Degree of cure
• Reaction kinetics When operating subambient, the thermocouple
• Purity junctions in the DSC cell base may get cold as cold
• Thermal stability is transferred from the cell cooling head. This effect
increases as the temperature is lowered and/or the time
Because of the wealth of information provided and at lower temperatures is increased.
because DSC is easy-to-use, DSC has become the
most commonly used thermal analysis technique. Effects on Results
Ease-of-use in this case refers to sample preparation
and experimental setup, as well as interpretation of the A large “start-up hook” or a sloping baseline make
results. There are, however, some common DSC events/ detection of weak transitions difficult. In addition,
transitions that can be the cause of less than optimum during the first 2-3 minutes of the experiment, transition
results and/or misinterpretation. This paper describes temperatures and measured heat flow (DH) may not be
several of these events with causes and solutions. Figure reproducible.
1 is an artificial DSC curve which was generated to
illustrate these events/transitions. The curve is artificial in Solutions
the sense that all of these events would not occur in the
same real world DSC curve. Using aluminum foil or additional pan lids, make up

1 TA039
a series of reference pans of different weight (2 mg.
increments).When running a sample use a reference pan
that weighs 0–10% more than sample pan. Figure 2 shows
results with an epoxy prepreg sample. Best results are
achieved with 1.5 lids. 2 lids results in overcompensation
and an exothermic start-up hook. Figures 3 and 4 show
how the glass transition results are affected by correct
compensation. Note: these results are obtained heating
at 20°C/minute from a 100°C isothermal hold.The impact
of the start-up hook can also be reduced by initiating
the heating at a temperature that is at least 2-3 minutes
below the range of interest at the heating rate chosen
(ie. at 20°C/minute, start experiment at least 50°C below
the first thermal event of interest.)
Figure 4: Start-up hook and Tg with correct reference pan

If operating below 0°C, use 50cc/minute dry nitrogen

purge gas through the cell base VACUUM PORT plus
the normal purge gas. Figure 5 illustrates the typical
improvement obtainable.

Figure 2: Effect of reference pan weight

Figure 5: Proper gas purging improves subambient baseline

performance

Event 2: Transition(s) at 0°C

Causes

Figure 3: Start-up hook and Tg with no reference pan Weak transitions around 0°C indicate the presence of
water in the sample or the purge gas. These transitions
are usually endotherms, but may appear different than
a melting peak. Since water can condense on both the
sample and reference pans, the transition often appears
as shown in Figure 6. Furthermore, the peaks may appear
slightly lower than 0°C due to impurities dissolved by the
moisture from the cell and pans.

Effects on Results

If water is in the sample, results may not be reproducible

because it can act as a plasticizer and reduce transition
temperatures. The water will also volatilize during the run,
causing an endothermic peak and a shift in the baseline.

2 TA039
If water is in the purge gas, it causes a perturbation in the
baseline that makes it difficult to detect real transitions Stresses built into the material as a result of processing,
near 0°C. handling or thermal history are released when the
material is heated through its glass transition. The reason
Solutions this occurs at Tg is that the molecule goes from a rigid
to a flexible structure and thus can move to relieve the
Keep hygroscopic samples in a dessicator and load stress.
them into pans in a dry box.
Effects on Results
Weigh the complete sample pan (with sample) before
and after the run. A change in weight could explain an Molecular relaxation usually appears as a weak
unexpected transition. endothermic transition near the end of a glass transition.
As shown in Figure 8, this behavior can be pronounced
enough to either shift the measured glass transition
temperature several degrees or lead to misinterpretation
of the Tg as an endothermic melting peak.

Figure 6: DSC transition due to moisture in the purge gas

Dry the purge gas by placing a drying tube in the line.

Figure 7 shows an epoxy sample after loading at -100°C.
The absence of any transitions at 0°C indicates that
Figure 8: Molecular relaxation can cause Tg to appear as a melt
with proper precautions water condensation in the cell
can be eliminated even under conditions which favor
condensation. Note: Loading a sample at temperature
Solutions
below 0°C is only possible when using the liquid nitrogen
cooling accessory (LNCA). Samples should always be
Relieve the internal stresses in the material by heating it
loaded above 0°C with any other cooling accessory.
to at least 25°C above the Tg and then quench cooling it
to a temperature below the Tg. Figure 9 shows the same
material as in Figure 8 after curing at 200°C and then
quench cooling to 25°C.

Figure 7: Quench cooling samples at subambient temperatures

Event 3: Apparent “Melting” at Glass Transition (Tg)

Figure 11: DSC scan of PET after quench cooling
Causes

3 TA039
 When comparing thermoplastic materials, give the
materials a common known thermal history by either
quench cooling or program cooling from above
the melting temperature. ASTM D3418-82 defines
recommended procedures for giving polymers a known
thermal history.

Figure 10: Effect of cooling rate on shape of Tg

Event 4: Exothermic Peaks Below Decomposition

Temperature While Heating

Cause Figure 11: DSC scan of PET after quench cooling

Exothermic behavior results during curing of a

thermosetting resin or crystallization of a thermoplastic
polymer. The amount of heat associated with these
transitions can be used to determine degree of cure
and % crystallinity respectively provided scans of suitable
standards are available.

When an exotherm is obtained in a polymer’s DSC profile

at a temperature which the operator suspects is too low
to be a decomposition, running the material in the TGA
aids evaluation. The absence of a TGA weight loss which
coincides with the DSC exotherm indicates that the
exotherm is crystallization or curing.

Effects on Results

The presence or absence of exothermic crystallization

Figure 12: DSC scan of PET after slow cooling
peaks in thermoplastic materials is very dependent
on thermal history. Therefore, DSC results will not be
reproducible if thermal history of the sample is not tightly
Event 5: Baseline Shift After Endothermic or Exothermic
controlled. Figures 11 and 12 illustrate the different results
Peaks
obtained for PET after quench cooling and programmed
cooling at 10°C/minute respectively. The quenched
Causes
material has a well-defined Tg indicating significant
amorphous structure which rearranges on heating to
Baseline shifts are caused by changes in sample
a crystalline structure before melting at about 235°C.
weight, heating rate, or the specific heat of the sample.
The DH of crystallization is slightly less than the DH of
A change in specific heat often occurs after the
melting which indicates that the initial structure is mostly
sample has gone through a transition such as curing,
amorphous. The slowly cooled material has a weak
crystallization, or melting. Sample weight often changes
Tg, indicating an initial structure that is almost entirely
during volatilization or decomposition.
crystalline. Since it is crystalline at the start of the DSC
experiment, no additional crystallization occurs prior to
Effects on Results
the melt at 235°C.
Since ΔH is calculated on the basis of sample weight
Solutions
(J/g, BTU/lb, etc.), any calculation of DH after a weight
change will be in error.

4 TA039
 Reduce the temperature limit of further experiments if no
Integration of a peak which has a baseline shift is difficult useful information is obtained because of the volatilization.
and typically less accurate because of operator subjectivity
in setting integration limits and baseline type. Use a Pressure DSC cell.

Solutions By Leonard C. Thomas

Weigh the sample before and after a run to determine if For more information or to place an order, go to
weight loss has occurred. http://www.tainstruments.com to locate your local sales
office information.
If crystallization or melting is the cause of the transition,
compare the DH of the transitions, using different limits and
types of baselines. Figure 13 illustrates an example where use
of sigmoidal baseline is required.

Figure 13: DSC scan of PET crystallization and Tg on cooling

Event 6: Sharp Endothermic Peaks During Exothermic

Reactions

Causes

Sharp peaks similar to those in Figure 1 above 300°C, are

usually the result of experimental phenomena rather than
real material transitions. For example, rapid volatilization of
gases trapped in the material can cause sharp peaks, as
can rapid volatilization of gases trapped in a partially sealed
hermetic pan.

Effects on Results

Erroneous interpretation of these sharp endotherms as

melting peaks associated with minor components is possible.

Volatilization can be detrimental to obtaining accurate

quantitative results since sample mass changes. If the
volatiles are corrosive, such as halogenated flame retardants,
DSC cell damage can occur with extended operation.

Solutions

Weigh the sample before and after the run to determine if

weight loss has occurred.

5 TA039