Menstrual Hygiene Management Report 2018
Menstrual Hygiene Management Report 2018
MANAGEMENT OF
ADOLESCENT SCHOOL
GIRLS AND NUNS
2018
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This survey is a byproduct of the Department of School Education (DSE), Ministry of Education in partnership
with the UNICEF, Bhutan.
The DSE would like to acknowledge M/S Bhutan A2Z Statistics, Economics & Environmental Consultancy, all
institutions and individuals at various capacities who contributed to the successful completion of this study:
Menstrual Hygiene Management of adolescent school-going girls and nuns 2017. The department in particular
would like to acknowledge the following individuals and institutions:
Page | i
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
PREFACE
Page | ii
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
ACRONYMS
CSPro Census and Survey Processing
SPSS Statistical Package for Social Science
PSU Primary Sampling Unit
SSU Secondary Sampling Unit
CSS Circular Systematic Sampling
PPS Probability Proportional to Size
NSB National Statistics Bureau
FDG Focused Group Discussion
DSE Department of School Education
MoE Ministry of Education
MHM Menstrual Hygiene Management
KAP Knowledge Attitude Practices
SHND School Health and Nutrition Division
PS Primary School
LSS Lower Secondary School
HSS Higher Secondary School
CS Central School
Page | iii
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Contents
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................................................... 1
Background and Objectives ...................................................................................................................... 1
Key Findings ............................................................................................................................................. 1
Recommendations:................................................................................................................................... 2
CHAPTER 1:INTRODUTION AND METHODOLOGY ................................................................................... 4
Background ............................................................................................................................................... 4
Significance of the study .......................................................................................................................... 4
1.4.1 Sampling Design ....................................................................................................................... 5
Field Operation ..................................................................................................................................... 7
Response rate ....................................................................................................................................... 8
Limitations of the study ............................................................................................................................ 9
CHAPTER 2: SOCIO-DEMOGRAPHIC CHARACTERISTICS ...................................................................... 10
CHAPTER 3:KNOWLEDGE ON MENSTRUAL HYGIENE AND MANAGEMENT ....................................... 13
CHAPTER 4:ATTITUDE TOWARDS MENSTRUATION .............................................................................. 17
4.5 Menstruation as taboo to adolescent school girls ...................................................................... 20
CHAPTER 5: PRACTICES OF MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT IN SCHOOLS .......................... 22
5.1 Type of menstrual absorbents used ........................................................................................... 22
CHPATER 6: SUMMARY FINDINGS FROM NUNNERIES ......................................................................... 27
6.1 Socio-demographic characteristics of nuns ................................................................................ 27
6.2 Socio-economic Characteristics of parents and guardians ......................................................... 27
CHAPTER 6.1 KNOWLEDGE AND INFORMATION ON MENSTRUATION ...................................... 29
6.1.1 Awareness on menarche and its causes ............................................................................ 29
6.1.2 Sources of information on menarche ................................................................................. 30
6.1.3 Awareness on menstrual related infections ....................................................................... 31
CHAPTER 6.2 ATTITUDE ON MENSTRUAL HYGIENE .......................................................................... 33
6.2.1 Misconceptions and taboos ................................................................................................ 33
6.2.2 Physical impacts of menstruation ...................................................................................... 34
6.2.3 Emotional impacts produced by menstruation .................................................................. 34
6.2.4 Social impacts produced by menstruation ......................................................................... 36
6.2.5 WASH facilities to counter menstruation hygiene management ...................................... 38
CHAPTER 6.3:PRACTICES ON MENSTRUAL HYGIENE ....................................................................... 39
6.3.1 Sanitary facilities at nunneries ............................................................................................ 40
6.3.2 Practice of Menstrual Hygiene at nunneries ...................................................................... 42
6.3.3 Empirical Analysis ............................................................................................................... 44
6.4 Comparative Statics of Schools intervened by SHND on MHM and the control group (not
intervened by SHND with MHM) ....................................................................................................... 45
CHAPTER 7: KEY FINDINGS AND DISCUSSIONS ..................................................................................... 47
i) Key findings for adolescent school girls: ........................................................................................ 47
7.1 Socio-demographic, Economic and Educational Characteristics ............................................ 47
7.2 Girls’ current knowledge and information on menstruation ................................................... 47
7.3 Menarche—knowledge and information ................................................................................ 47
7.4 Source of information regarding menstruation and menstrual hygiene ................................. 48
7.5 Attitude towards menstruation ............................................................................................... 48
7.6 Social Impacts produced by menstruation ............................................................................. 48
7.7 Physical Impacts of menstruation .......................................................................................... 48
7.8 Emotional Impacts .................................................................................................................. 49
7.9 Menstruation as taboo to adolescent school girls .................................................................. 49
Page | iv
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | v
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 1
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
followed by Yoga and meditation (3.1%) • This they do since the school did not have
and prayers (1.7%). capabilities to render help to those special
• Similarly, close to half (46.4%) of the children during menstruation; and
adolescent nuns took rest during • All the participants of FDG unanimously
menstruation followed by 19.6 percent of agreed that they didn’t have enough
them who underwent medication. On an WASH facilities to combat menstruation in
equal proportion, about 7.1 percent of their schools.
them reported that they said prayers or
meditated j) Efficacy of SHND’s interventions of MHM
programs in schools and nunneries.
g) WASH facilities at schools to combat The study revealed a vast difference between
menstruation schools with SHND’s intervention MHM
• The survey revealed that close to half programs and those that did not have the
(45.9%) of the school girls agreed that intervention. The comparative statics revealed
they took half body bath during that more than three quarters (80.6%) of the
menstruation due to lack of hot water. adolescent girls in those schools intervened by
• More than two-thirds (78.6%) of the the MHM program of SHND had correct
adolescent nuns agreed that they missed knowledge on menstruation. Interestingly,
classes or activities during menstruation after the intervention of the program, none of
since the toilets were dirty and them believed that menstruation is a curse.
discouraged them to change. However, there are still about 4.4 percent who
still considers that menstruation is a disease.
h) Social Impacts produced by menstruation Around 5 percent of them reported of not
• About 43 percent of the adolescent knowing what menstruation is all about. The
schoolgirls reported having missed study has also revealed that only around 38
school during menstruation because it percent of the adolescent girls in those
made them uncomfortable. The study schools, which did not receive MHM program
has also revealed that about 9.7 percent knew about menstruation. About 9.5 percent
of the boarding schools girls missed of them still consider menstruation as a curse
school as opposed to 31 percent of the followed by 2.2 percent of them considering
day scholars, About 59.3 percent of both menstruation as a disease. About half (50.4%)
the day and boarding schoolgirls missed of them didn’t know about menstruation. This
classes. clearly indicates the efficacy of the SHND’s
• More than two-thirds (76.8%) of the MHM awareness programs in the schools.
adolescent nuns reported that it was
important to buy sanitary pad without Recommendations:
being seen. ✓ Every school and nunnery need to enhance
their WASH facilities;
i) Physical Impacts of menstruation ✓ Every school and nunnery need to enhance
• Close to half (48.1%) of the respondents their sanitary facilities viz. sanitary pad disposal
agreed that they missed school during bin, facility to dry improvised sanitary pad,
period since it was painful. renewable materials to wrap the disposable
pads and etc;
j) Emotional Impacts ✓ Enhance sexuality education programs in
• More than half (57%) of the respondents every school and nunneries;
agreed that they got easily upset during ✓ Education Ministry to bring the adolescent
pre-menstrual and menstrual periods nuns into mainstream in terms of sexuality
than at other times. education and any other forms of education
• More than two-thirds (82.2%) of the imparted to the mainstream adolescent girls
respondents reported that they “just for their overall development;
have to tolerate” with menstruation ✓ The School Health and Nutrition Division to
spearhead the development of spot-check and
i) Menstrual case of special children: Observation checklist to account the existing
• It was found that teachers advised parents WASH facilities for each school (inclusive of
to keep their child at home during nunneries) and compute ratio of users to
menstruation. (Suggested) WASH facilities;
✓ Ministry of Education to closely liaise with
Ministry of Health on their public health
Page | 2
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
development facilities and endeavor to realize ✓ MoE to liaise with relevant coordinating
WASH facilities in schools and nunneries; partners to promote MHM program in all the
✓ Schools needs to enhance the MHM service schools and nunneries; and
providers in their schools; ✓ Ministry of Education to liaise with the Ministry
✓ Ministry of Education to ensure the of Health to reach out MHM programs beyond
establishment of disable-friendly WASH schools and nunnery.
facilities in each school and duplicate this
process in nunneries as well;
Page | 3
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 4
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
1.4.3 Sample size determination fpc (finite population correction): n1 = n/[1+ (n-
1)/N]where, n1 is the new sample size and N = total
The sample size determination formula for households
proportion is adopted as depicted below.
Therefore, the new sample size after adjusting for
n =(zα/2)2p(1-p)/e2, where n = sample size for fpc is 383 as illustrated below:
proportion, zα/2 = 1.96 @ 95% confidence level, p
= proportion of picking 50-50 right answer and e = n1= 384/[1+ (384-1)/166,550] = 383. Nonetheless,
5% confidence interval/margin of error. This
the domain is kept both at the areas of residence
requires the sample size of only 384 at the national (urban & rural) and regional (eastern, central &
level reporting, which is up to 95% level of western) levels and finally the sample size
confidence. However, to minimize the width of tantamount to 1,560.
confidence interval, so as not to misguide the
probability of estimating the true answers in that
wide margin of error afpc needs to be computed.
Page | 5
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 6
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
1.5 Quality Control Process A probability sampling was adopted to select the
required number of students from each school
The quality control process spans from based on the determined sample size. To capture
development of sampling frame to the final the relevant variables based on the objectives of
analysis of the enumerated data from the field. The the study, a well-structured questionnaire was
sampling frame was developed based on the designed and pre-tested. After incorporation of the
administrative statistics maintained by the Policy missing variables and other relevant information,
and Planning Division of the Ministry of Education the questionnaire was finalized and presented to
in their Education Monitoring Information System the Technical Working Group comprised of officials
(EMIS). The data pertaining to adolescent from UNICEF, SNV, Bhutan Nuns Foundation,
schoolgirls (aged 10-19) were extracted for all the Ministry of Health, and Ministry of Education as a
schools of Bhutan and treated that as a sampling part of the simulation exercise.
frame for the KAP study of Menstruation Hygiene
Management (MHM).
Finalization of quetstionnaires
Pre-testing of the Launching of the field
Sampling plan and after incorporating the comments
questionnaire and training of surveys and conduct of
computation of weights and suggestions from the
enumerators FGDs with relevant
simulation exercise with UNICEF,
stakeholders
SHND, PHED & BNF.
Exporting the
Data entry into the Report writing and
Computer well processed Data analysis
Manual data well designed content analysis
Editing/Batch datasets into (both descriptive
editing interface in CSPro referring to various
Editing SPSS version 22 and empirical)
version 6.0 official documents
and Stata 13
Incorporate the
Draft presentation of comments and
the report suggestions
Production of the
final report
Page | 7
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 8
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
believed if men see menstrual blood, misfortune Discrimination in South Asia (Bangladesh Country
will befall on them. Women on their period are not Report) 2009).
allowed to visit temple or the mosque. Some
The study, Issues in Managing Menstrual Hygiene
women do not leave their homes for seven days
in Rural Schools of Sri Lanka (2014) depicted that
each month during her period. Others observe
many school does not have facilities of getting
dietary restrictions or refrain from reading the
sanitary napkins, changing and washing sanitary
Koran. They are even not allowed to touch food,
napkins and safe disposal. Appropriate disposal are
cooking utensils or the kitchen gardens (Soap
not recommended and practiced by schools and
stories and toilet tales: 10 Case studies
this has led to environmental problem as well. The
Bangladesh: tackling menstrual hygiene taboos
promotion of menstrual hygiene in school is still
(2012)).
challenging though schools provide the facilities.
Many girls prefer to stay home during their Adolescent girls and female teachers should be
menstruation due lack of adequate facilities at empowered in taking the lead and managing
schools, which is effectively one quarter of their menstrual hygiene with dignity, safety and
school time that has direct impact on the student’s personal hygiene. The behavior and attitude
leading to dropping out school. When girls choose change in children is needed for positive effects on
to go to school while they are menstruating, they menstrual hygiene components of school water,
often do not change their menstrual pad for a sanitation and hygiene programs.
whole day which affect their concentration due to
concerns of overflow and staining of clothes lest it Limitations of the study
might lead to deep embarrassment and All the WASH facilities and the menstrual hygiene
uncomfortable (Equity in School Water and management practices reflected in this report are
Sanitation - Overcoming Exclusion and purely based on verbal report and no spot-checks
were carried out.
Page | 9
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
%
This chapter deals with the socio-demographic
characteristics of the respondents who took part in 5.0
this study. The analysis in this chapter begins at
the national level and then delves into 0.0
disaggregated information. Figure 1 shows that 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
most of the respondents covered in this study Age
were from the Central Schools (35.6%) followed
by Primary Schools (20%) and Lower Secondary Figure 4: Grades of the respondents
Schools (14.9%). Going by the areas of residence,
around half of the respondents were from rural 20.0
schools and close to half (49.7%) from urban
schools. 15.0
Page | 10
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
About 9.6 percent of them with single parent 2.1 Educational and Economic Characteristics
(mother). The lowest is the 2.2 percent of them
who live with lone parents (fathers). Amongthe This sub-section deals with the educaitonal and
adolescent respondent girls, maximum were economic characteristics of respondents’ parents
Budhist (81.5%) followed by Hindu (13.3%) and and guardians. Around eight in every ten (77.6%)
Christain (4.7%). Less than one percent belongs to of the respondents’ mothers have no education.
other faiths. Similarly, figure 10 has revealed that almost six out
of every ten (65.5%) fathers lack education.
Figure 7: Respondents by reliogus
background FIgure 9: Mother's education
No education 77.6
Buddhist 81.5
Classes 1-12 17.2
Hindu 13.3 NFE 3.6
Page | 11
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Similar to the educational background, parents and Figure 14: Guardian's occupation
guardians of the respondents are mostly farmers.
There are almost equal proportions of fathers Don't know 45.4
(58.5%) and mothers (55.6%) whose are farmer. Farmer 36.2
Less than half of the respondents reported that Others 7.5
their guardian’s occupation is farmer and on the [Link] 5.9
contrary, close to half (45.4%) did not know the
Bussines/trade 2.4
occupation of their guardians.
Pvt. Employee 1.6
[Link] 1.0
0.0 50.0
Page | 12
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
0.0 [Link].0100.0
Page | 13
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 14
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 20: Knowhow on the organ from Figure 22: Duration of normal
which the menstruation come menstruation (days)
Figure 21: Age at which most girls Figure 23: Interval between two
usually get their first period menstrual cycles
16 0.4
15 2.4 47 - 54+ 0.7
14 4.1
13 12.0 29 - 37 33.9
12 50.7
11 10.1 20 - 28 10.4
10 5.6
9 1.4 11 - 19 2.6
8 0.4
5 0.1 <= 10 52.6
Don`t know 12.7
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0
When asked about the duration of normal The survey also sought to know the sources of
menstruation, a majority of them were not aware information regarding menstruation to adolescent
of the same. Around six in ten (58.8%) are of the girls. More than two-third (86%) of them have
view that duration (days) of menstruation for a reported that they heard about menstruation from
normal person lasts between 1-4 days. On the someone. Figure 24 revealed that mothers (42%)
contrary, there are about 1.3 percent of them who often provided them with information after
believe that menstruation lasts for about 13-31 menarche is reached followed by teachers (27.1%)
days in a normal person. About 20.3 percent of the and sisters (15.6%). Around 14 percent of the
respondents have reported that the menstruation respondents reported that they received
lasts between 6-12 days. There are only around 21 information on menarche from their friends. About
percent who has reported that the menstruation 1.8 percent of them availed information on
lasts for about 5 days in a normal person. The menstruation from other sources viz. books, TV,
survey found that about 18.2 percent of the Radio and etc.
adolescent girls have reported that the interval
between two menstrual cycles comprised of 28
days. There are more than half (52.6%) of them
who reported that the interval between two
menstrual cycles is less than 10 days. On the other
extreme, less than 1 percent has reported that the
interval lasts between 54 days and above.
Page | 15
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 25: Fungal Infection due to poor FIgure 27: Urinary Tract Infection
menstrual hygiene due to poor menstrual hygiene
Yes Yes
24.9
No No
43.8 42.2
Asked whether those adolescent schools girls The adolescent girls were also asked about the
knew about menstrual hygiene, around 61 percent four menstrual phases. This study has revealed
of them reported ‘Yes’. The survey also delved into that more than half (52.3%) of them are not aware
finding whether those girls knew about infections of the menstrual phases.
related to poor menstrual hygiene. Four types, viz.
Figure 28: Menstrual phases
fungal infection, reproductive tract infection,
urinary tract infection and infertility related to
menstrual hygiene were asked. Figure 25 reveals
that close to half (42.2%) have reported that they Don`t know 52.3
are aware of the fungal infection due to poor
Day 14 (Ovulutary
menstrual hygiene. On the contrary, about 57.1 21.1
phase)
percent of them have reported that they are not
aware about reproductive tract infection (figure Day 15-28 (Luteal
14.0
26). When asked if they knew about Urinary Tract phase)
Infection (UTI), more than half (58.9%) said no. Day 1-5 (Menstrual
Only around 25 percent of them have reported that 8.3
phase)
they were aware of UTI.
Day 6-13 (Follicular /
4.3
proliferative phase)
Page | 16
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
The Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) was applied 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
to factor out the sub-factors contributing to the
attitude of adolescent schoolgirls on menstruation. Figure 30: Women in menstruation are
Considering or restricting the factor loadings more susceptible to get possessed by evil
than 0.5, a sum of 12 sub-factors had been spirits
identified as factors contributing towards the Don`t know 34.0
attitude of adolescent schoolgirls on menstruation.
Following are the sub-factors identified by the EFA: Disagree 24.6
a) I can tell my period is approaching because of Strongly disagree 20.4
the breast tenderness, backache, cramps or
other physical signs; Agree 15.6
b) It is important to talk about menstrual period
with men; Strongly agree 5.4
c) It is important to discuss the topic of period at
school with boys and girls; 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
d) We women wish that the period would last for
a few minutes; The survey had revealed that close to two-third
e) It is important to buy sanitary pad without (65%) of the adolescent school girls have agreed
being seen; the approaching of their period signals with
f) Women wish that we do not have our period; varieties of pains viz. breast tenderness, backache,
g) I miss school during my period because am cramps or other physical signs. Around two-third
afraid of staining my clothes; (67.7%) of them have again agreed that the only
h) I miss school during my period because am good thing about menstruation is that they know
afraid of others making fun of me; they are free from pregnancy.
i) I miss school during period because it can
cause pain; Figure 31: I can tell my period is
j) I miss school during my period since it can approaching because of the breast
make me feel uncomfortable or tired; tenderness, backache, cramps or
k) I miss school during my period because there other physical signs
are no places for girls to wash and change at
school; and
l) I miss school during my period because there Agree 38.2
is nowhere to dispose-off sanitary pad. Strongly agree 26.8
4.2 Social Impacts produced by menstruation Don`t know 24.6
Close to one-third (63.5%) of the adolescent
Disagree 8.1
schoolgirls reported that during menstruation, a
woman must not enter the shrine or temple. Strongly disagree 2.3
Further augmenting this superstition, about 21
percent of the respondents agreed that women in 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0
menstruation are susceptible to get possessed by
an evil spirit.
Page | 17
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 32: The only thing good with Figure 34: I miss school during my
menstruation is that I come to know period because it cause pain
that I am not pregnant
Agree 32.7
Strongly agree 44.0 Disagree 26.4
Agree 23.7 Strongly agree 15.4
Don`t know 20.3 Strongly disagree 14.1
Disagree 7.6 Don`t know 11.3
Strongly disagree 4.3 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Page | 18
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 36: I miss school during my Figure 38: I am more easily upset during
period because there isn't anywhere pre-menstrual and menstrual periods than
for girls to wash and change at school at other times of the month
Page | 19
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 40: Men have real advantage of FIgure 43: Women are more tired than
not having monthly period usual when they are menstruating
Strongly agree 39.9
Strongly agree 45.5 Agree 38.4
Disagree 8.3
Agree 33.1
Strongly disagree 1.6
Strongly agree 26.0
0.0 50.0
Disagree 16.4
Figure 42 Shows that about 38.3 percent of the
adolescent schoolgirls agreed that women Don`t know 13.2
complaining of menstrual distress are just using it
as an excuse. Almost equal proportion (78.3%) of Strongly disagree 11.3
the respondents agreed that women are more
tired than usual when they are menstruating (figure 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
43).
Figure 42: Women complaining of
Figure 45: It is important to discuss the
menstrual distress are just using
topic of period at school with boys and
that as an excuse
girls
Page | 20
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Disagree 23.4
Page | 21
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Cotton 0.4
Tampon 0.2
Page | 22
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 50: Reason adolescent girls Figure 52: Method of drying cloth pad
perferring the main abosrbent material
during menstruation (%)
Sunlight 75.2
Easy to use 38.1
Inside the house 9.6
Easily available 32.1
Page | 23
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 53: Types of pad wraps used Figure 55: % share of adolesecent
for disposing it girls coming to school during
Papers 62.9 menstruation
Others 7.2 No
No wrap 3.1
Yes
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0
90.7
Figure 54: Number of times changing
underwear during menstruation in a day
0.1
6 0.3 FIgure 56: Mentrual problems interfering
1.7 with attendance during school
4 3.5
14.9 Others 55.3
2 52.4
19.9 One day every cycle 26.8
0 7.2
Three days every cycle 6.7
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0
Four days every cycle 5.6
This study attempted to assess the complete
practices of menstrual hygiene straddling from Two days every cycle 5.5
knowledge and information to practices and
disposal of sanitary pads. Figure 53 reveals that 0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0
close to two-third (62.9%) of the adolescent school
girls used papers as pad wraps for disposing the Menstrual hygiene practices interfering with
kind of sanitary pads they used. It is also revealed school attendance is one of the most common
that more than one-quarter (26.8%) of the phenomenon most of the related studies have
adolescent girls have reported that they use plastic revealed. When asked whether the adolescent
bag or polythene bag to wrap the sanitary pads and schoolgirls remained absent from school during
dispose it. On the contrary, there are about 3.1 menstruation, nine out of every ten (90.7%) of
percent of them who do not use any pad wraps in them have reported that they come to school
disposing the pads. Quite interestingly, the survey despite menstruation. Figure 56 had revealed the
has revealed that more than half (52.4%) of the frequency of interference with school attendance.
adolescent school girls changed underwear during More than half (55.3%) of the adolescent
menstruation twice a day. It was also revealed that schoolgirls have reported other categories of
around 15 percent of them changed underwears attendance counts. This was specified by each one
during menstruation thrice a day. Around 20 of them and on an average, the most common
percent of them have changed underwears during reason was that most of them did not fit into our
period only once a day. The survey revealed the proposed category of question. However, about
two extreme situations whereby about 2.1 percent 44.7 percent of them have reported that they
of them have changed underwears during the missed school ranging from one day to four days
period between 5 to 7 times a day. On the other during every cycle.
extreme, about 7.2 percent of the adolescent girls
have reported that they did not change their
underwear during the period at all.
Page | 24
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figue 57: Remedies taken during Figure 59: % share of adolscent girls
menstruation cleaning their genital area during
menstruation
Take rest 52.5
8.7
Thoroughly involve in
21.1
activities
Others 15.2
No Yes
Yoga / Meditation 3.1
Disagree 19.2
Others 15.5
Strongly disagree 10.2
Only on
12.5
second day 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0
Only on first
10.0
day Asked whether adolescent schoolgirls clean their
genital area during menstruation, this survey had
Do not bath revealed that nine out of every ten (91.3%) of the
3.9
any time adolescent schoolgirls clean their genital area
during menstruation. Figure 60revealed that close
0.0 50.0 100.0 to half (45.9%) of the respondents agreed that they
take half body bath during period due to lack of hot
water. Figure 61 shows the affordability of sanitary
Figure 57 reveals one of the most important pad. More than two-thirds (73.8%) of the
factors responsible to encounter the menstrual respondents reported that they could afford
pangs of the adolescent schoolgirls. When asked sanitary pad during menstruation. On the contrary,
what remedies they took during menstruation to there are around 8 percent who cannot afford and
overcome pangs, more than half (52.5%) reported similarly, about 4.2 percent of reported
that they take rest. It has been also revealed that unavailability of sanitary pad.
close to one-quarter (21.1%) of them have
reported that they thoroughly involve in activities
to forget the pangs and discomforts while 6.4
percent resort to medication followed by Yoga and
meditation (3.1%) and prayers (1.7%). Similarly,
when asked whether they take bath during period,
more than half (58.1%) reported that they do so.
Around 13 percent of them reported that they take
bath only on second day followed by 10 percent of
them who bathe on the very first day. Around 4
percent of them do not bath any time.
Page | 25
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 61: % afforded to buy sanitary The survey also delved into finding out the facilities
pad during menstruation available at schools for menstrual hygiene
practices. Figure 63 reveals that more than half
Can afford 73.8 (55.1%) of the adolescent school girls reported
that they dispose pads into pad disposal bins
Don't know 14.5 followed by around 18 percent of them who
dispose into pit. About 14.2 percent of the
Cannot afford 7.5 respondents reported that they dispose off the
pads in burning place. However, around 9 percent
Not available to buy 4.2 of them reported that there is no disposal facilities
at at schools. Figure 64 shows the perecentage
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0 share of place for drying clothes. About 43.2
percent of the respondents have reported that
Figure 62: Materials used to clean there are no place for drying clothes.
gential area during menstruation
Figure 65: % share of toilet/ bathing
Water and soap 68.6 facilities enough for adderssing issues
related to menstruation
Only with water 27.6
Others 3.0
36.0
Towels 0.8
No Yes
Page | 26
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
CHPATER 6: SUMMARY FINDINGS FROM Figure 69 reveals that only around 57 percent of
the nuns received the yearly pocket money. The
NUNNERIES nuns have received the yearly pocket money
Concurrently, the adolescent nuns in nunneries ranging from ngultrum 100 to 10,000. Figure 70
were also surveyed using the same questions. Out reveals that most of the adolescent nuns have
of the sampled 202 nuns in the three regions viz. received the yearly pocket money ranging from
estern, central and western, only around 30 ngultrum 100 to 1,200.
percent of the adolescent nuns were covered. This
is due to the lack of proper sampling frame for the Figure 69: Yearly pocket money
nuns and those sampled nunneries felt short of received by nuns
adolescent nuns falling in the age bracket of 10-19.
However, for a pocket study a fairly representative
sample of 56 nuns were covered and upon
applying the weights, it has been extrapolated to Yes
202 sampled nuns. No
43.2
6.1 Socio-demographic characteristics of nuns
A majority of the participants of this survey were 56.8
aged 12, 15 and 17. Figure 68 shows the grade
wise distribution of adolescent nuns. They call their
grading system a “Zindra.” More than half (57.3%)
of the respondents are in Zindra one followed by
close to one-quarter (22%) of them in Zindra two.
About 12 percent of them have no grade so far.
Figure 70: Yearly pocket money received
by the respondents
Figure 67: Percentage distribution of
age of respondents 45.0
40.0
16.0
35.0
14.0 30.0
25.0
12.0
20.0
10.0 15.0
8.0 10.0
5.0
6.0 0.0
4.0
2.0
0.0
10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
6.2 Socio-economic Characteristics of parents
Figure 68: Grade wise distribution of and guardians
respondents (Zindra)
Almost on an equal proportion (more than two-
thirds) of the adolescent nuns’ parents do not have
5 1.8 modern education. On an average, close to quarter
4 2.4 of their parents have education ranging from
classes 1-12. Very few have non-formal education
3 4.6 and monastic/shedra.
2 22.0
1 57.3
No grade 12.0
Page | 27
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Farmer 75.0
NFE 0.9
Don't want to report 10.7
Monastic/Shedra 2.4
Bussines/trade 7.1
Others 1.8
No education 76.3
[Link] 1.8
0.0 50.0 100.0
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0
NFE 2.4
Farmer 82.1
Monastic/Shedra 0.9 Others 7.1
Bussines/trade 5.4
Classes 1-12 23.1
Don't want to… 3.6
No education 73.7 [Link] 1.8
Don't want to
87.5
report
Farmer 10.7
[Link] 1.8
Page | 28
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 76: Definition of menstruation Figure 78: The organ from which
mensturation come
Curse 7.1
Others 2.2
Disease 5.4
Birth canal 2.2
Others 1.8
0.0 50.0 100.0
0.0 [Link].050.0
Page | 29
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
5.0 20.0
0.0
10.0
9 11 12 13 14 15 16 18
Page | 30
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 82: Did anyone tell you Figure 84: Do you know about
about the menstruation menstruation hygiene
No Yes
No Yes 16.1
46.4
53.6
83.9
Figure 83: From whom you got Figure 85: Menstrual blood perceived as
information about menstruarion unhygienic
Sister 7.8
The survey also revealed that more than half 6.1.3 Awareness on menstrual related infections
(53.6%) of the nuns are aware of the menstruation
hygiene. Asked how nuns perceive menstruation The survey also sought to learn the level of
blood as, figure 85 revealed that more than one- knowhow of nuns on menstrual related infections.
third (67.9%) of them perceived it as unhygienic. Figure 86 revealed that equal proportion (28.6%) of
When questioning the nuns’ knowhow on the nuns were aware and unaware of the
menstrual hygiene management, they reported infections related to menstruation. Figure 86 as
the followings: well revealed that close to half (42.9%) ‘don’t
know at all’ about the infections resulting from the
• We need to clean our genital area with hot poor menstrual hygiene. Similarly, to check
water; awareness on other forms of infections, nuns were
• We need to change our pad from time to time; asked about RTI (Reproductive Tract Infection).
• We have to take bath regularly; Only around 36 percent of them are aware of the
• We have to wash our hands with soap after same and almost equal proportion of the remaining
changing the pad; nuns reported as either ‘don’t know’ or No
• We need to keep our body clean during period; awareness on infections related to menstruation.
• We need to change underwear regularly; and
• Apply perfume to avoid bad smell.
Page | 31
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
28.6 19.6
42.9
53.6
26.8
28.6
30.4 16.1
35.7
42.9
41.1
33.9
When further asked about the awareness on the When asked about the susceptibility of infertility as
infections like UTI (Urinary Tract Infection), figure a result of poor menstrual hygiene management,
93 reveals that more than half (53.6%) of the nuns only around two out of every ten (16.1%) are
are unaware about UTI. aware of the same. Remaining two-thirds (84%)
are unaware of the infections related to
menstruation.
Lastly, in this section, four phases of menstruation
were asked to the respondents. Figure 90 reveals
that one-quarter (25%) of them don’t know and
remaining three-quarters have defined in various
ways.
Page | 32
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
CHAPTER 6.2: ATTITUDE ON MENSTRUAL More than half (51.8%) of the adolescent nuns
agreed that they should not sleep with a man
HYGIENE during their periods since it will pass on the
This chapter focuses on the attitude towards negative energy to man. And one-quarter (25%) of
menstrual hygiene and menstruation. Many them unanimously believe that drinking tea will
studies have shown the taboos and the beliefs increase the menstrual flow.
created around menstruation.
Figure 93: Sleeping with a man
6.2.1 Misconceptions and taboos
during your periods will pass on the
This sub-section deliberates on the "drip" to man
misconceptions and taboos that surround the
psyche of nuns. This survey had revealed that Strongly agree 26.8
there are many adolescent nuns who are not
aware of menstruation and menstrual hygiene. Agree 25.0
Figure 91revealed that one-quarter (25%) of the
adolescent nuns don’t know whether they must Don`t know 21.4
enter shrines/temples while having periods. About
21.5 percent of them agreed that they must not Disagree 14.3
enter the shrine/temples during period. About 33.2
percent on a similar note have reported that Strongly disagree 12.5
women in menstruation are susceptible to get
possessed by evil spirits. 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0
Disagree 21.4
Disagree 25.0
Agree 17.9
Don`t know 25.0
Strongly disagree 16.1
Agree 12.5
Strongly agree 7.1
Strongly agree 8.9
0.0 20.0 40.0
Page | 33
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 96: Women are more tired than Strongly agree 35.7
usual when they are menstruating
Agree 33.9
Contrary to more than half of the adolescent nuns Strongly agree 39.3
who reported that they feel more tired than usual
during period, figure 97 unfolded that close to half
Don`t know 14.3
(44.6%) of them have reported that menstruation
does not affect their usual activities.
Disagree 3.6
Page | 34
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Many nuns have reported their disgruntlement for Figure 102:Menstruation allows
being female. Figure 100 reveals that close to half women to be more aware of their
(44.7%) of them have reported that men have real body
advantage of not having monthly period. On the
other hand, figure 101 has revealed that more than
two-thirds (76.8%) of the adolescent nuns have Don`t know 39.3
reported that the only good thing with
menstruation is that they come to know that they Agree 26.8
are not pregnant.
Strongly agree 21.4
Figure 100:Men have real advantage Disagree 10.7
of not having monthly period
Strongly disagree 1.8
Don`t know 26.8 0.0 50.0
Agree 26.8
Figure 103: The recurrent monthly
Strongly agree 17.9 flow of menstruation is an external
indications of women's general
Disagree 16.1 good health
Strongly disagree 12.5 Agree 44.6
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 Don`t know 26.8
Strongly agree 23.2
Figure 101: The only good thing
with menstruation is that I come to Disagree 3.6
know that am not pregnant
Strongly disagree 1.8
0.0 50.0
Strongly agree 39.3 Close to two-thirds (64.3%) of the nuns are aware
of the pre-menstrual phenomena through physical
Agree 37.5 symptoms like breast tenderness, backache,
cramps or other physical signs. Figure 105reveals
Don`t know 21.4 some of the emotional aspects of menstruation.
About 50 percent of the adolescent nuns agreed
Disagree 1.8 that a woman who attributes her irritability to her
approaching menstrual period as neurotic.
0.0 50.0
Figure 104: I can tell my period is
Contrary to earlier assertions by the adolescent approaching because of the breast
nuns, close to half (48.2%) of them reported that tenderness, backache, cramps or
menstruation allows them to be more aware of other physical signs
their body followed by 67.8 percent of them who
reported that the recurrent monthly flow of Agree 41.1
menstruation is an external indications of women’s Don`t know 23.2
general good health.
Strongly agree 23.2
Disagree 8.9
Strongly disagree 3.6
0.0 50.0
Page | 35
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
This sub-section deals with the social impacts 0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
produced by menstruation. Around 38 percent of
the adolescent nuns disagreed with the statement Figure 109: We women wish that
that ‘I barely notice minor physiological effect out the period would last for a few
of my menstrual periods.’ Figure 107 has revealed minutes
that close to half (46.4%) of the adolescent nuns
reported that women complaining of menstrual
distress are just using that as an excuse. Disagree 33.9
Agree 25.0
Disagree 23.2
Page | 36
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Agree 39.3
Strongly
23.2
disagree
Strongly agree 37.5
Agree 23.2
Agree 33.9
Disagree 23.2
Disagree 26.8
Around 35.7 percent of the respondents reported About half (50%) of the adolescent nuns reported
that they miss classes or other activities for the
that it is uncomfortable for them to talk about their
periods. Close to half (42.8%) of the respondents fear of being ridiculed by others during period.
About 41.1 percent of them missed classes or
reported that they miss classes or other activities
other forms of activities at nunnery for fear of pain
for fear of staining their clothes during period.
during menstruation.
Page | 37
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Disagree 26.8
Disagree 28.6
Agree 25.0
Strongly disagree 26.8
6.2.5 WASH facilities to counter menstruation Around close to one-quarter (21.5%) of the
hygiene management adolescent nuns reported that they missed classes
or activities since they don’t have sanitary pad.
This sub-section deals with the WASH facilities Figure 119 has revealed that more than two-thirds
available at nunneries to combat MHM. More than (78.6%) of the respondents agreed that they
a quarter (26.8%) of the adolescent nuns reported missed classes or activities during period since the
that they missed classes or activities because of toilets are too dirty and don’t feel like to change.
lack of privacy for girls to wash and change. More
than half (53.6%) of the respondents again
reported that they missed classes or activities
during menstruation since there is no place to
dispose-off sanitary pad.
Page | 38
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Disagree 30.4
Sanitary pad 87.5
Strongly
26.8
disagree
Page | 39
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 123: Method of cleaning cloth Figure 125: Number of times changing
pad pad in a day
Water 55.4
Others 1.8
On the method followed in drying the cloth pad 6.3.1 Sanitary facilities at nunneries
besides washing, about two-thirds (66.1%) of the This sub-section deals with sanitary facilities at
respondents reported that they dry it inside the nunneries. When asked about the place of disposal
house followed by one-quarter (25%) of them who of pad, close to half (46.4%) of them reported that
dried them in sunlight. Again, quite a sizable they dispose into pad disposal bin followed by
proportion of adolescent nuns have dried the cloth equal proportions (23.2%) of them who reported
pad by hiding beneath another cloth (7.1%). The that they dispose it into toilet and drain. Around 2
study also sought to learn how frequently percent of them reported that they disposed the
adolescent nuns changed their absorbent material. absorbent material into routine waste and an equal
Figure 125revealed that more than two-thirds proportion of them said they threw in open field.
(71.4%) of them changed only once a day. The
remaining 28.6 percent of them changed twice a
day.
Page | 40
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
No wrap 16.1
94.6
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0
Figure 127revealed that close to half (48.2%) of the Asked how many times the adolescent nuns
respondents reported that they used papers as pad changed their underwear during menstruation,
wraps followed by 35.7 percent of them who used more than two-thirds (67.9%) reported to have
plastic bag. About 16.1 percent of them have not changed only once a day. However, figure 128 had
used pad wrap at all. revealed that around 20 percent changed twice a
day followed by around 11 percent of them who
reported to have changed thrice a day. About 1.8
percent of them reported that they changed even
five times a day. When asked their attendance at
nunnery during menstruation, about 94.6 percent
of them reported ‘Yes.’ So, only around less than
one out of every ten (5.4%) missed the session.
Page | 41
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Others 48.2
Daily 80.4
Four days every
25.0
cycle Others 12.5
One day every
14.3 Only on first day 3.6
cycle
Three days every Do not bath any
7.1 1.8
cycle time
Two days every Only on second
5.4 1.8
cycle day
Figure131: Remedies di you take Figure 133: Do you clean genital area
during menstruation during menstruation
Others 10.7
Thoroughly involve in
8.9 67.9
activities
Prayers 7.1
6.3.2 Practice of Menstrual Hygiene at nunneries Figure 134shows that close to two-third (63.6%)
cleaned the genital area with only water followed
This study has revealed that eight out of every ten by about 18.2 percent who used water and soap.
(80.4%) take bath on a daily basis during Around 13 percent used towel. About 67.9 percent
menstruation. Figure 132 shows that around 4 of the adolescent nuns reported that they have
percent of the adolescent nuns took bath only on burning place for sanitary pad followed by pit
the first day. About 1.8 percent of them have (23.2%) and pad disposal bins (8.9%).
reported that they do not bath at all. The survey
had also revealed that more than two-thirds
(67.9%) of the adolescent nuns clean their genital
area during menstruation.
Page | 42
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Figure 134: Method of cleaning Figure 137: Does your nunnery have
genital Toilet/ bathing facilities for
addressing issues related to
menstruation
Only with water 63.6
Towels 12.7
Others 5.5
78.6
0.0 20.0 40.0 60.0 80.0
No Yes
Figure 135: Which one of the following
sanitary pad facilities does your nunnery
have Figure 138 shows the bathing habits during period.
More than half (51.8%) of the respondents have
reported that they take half body bath during period
Burning place 67.9 due to lack of hot water. When asked whether they
could afford to buy sanitary pad, about 33.3
percent of them reported that they do followed by
Pit 23.2 equal proportions of them (20%) who reported that
they couldn’t or its unavailability.
Not available
85.7 20.0
to buy
Cannot
20.0
afford
Yes No
0.0 20.0 40.0
Page | 43
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
6.3.3 Empirical Analysis: To assess the relative respondents and their mothers have positive effect
contribution of educational status of respondents and on the menstrual hygienic practices. To establish
this causal effect, a probit regression is employed
their mother’s on the likelihood of using unhygienic as follows:
practices during menstruation.
One of the core objectives of this study is to
assess whether the educational status of
Table 3 depicts the probit regression results. The explanatory variables. The result of probit
probit model is nonlinear model and, therefore, we regression revealed that age is one of the highly
differentiate it and generated the results of dprobit. significant factors up to 95% level of confidence.
The dependent variable is the adolescent girls’ On an average, if an adolescent girl grows older by
knowledge on menstrual hygiene management. one more year, there is a probability that her
The independent variables taken under knowledge on menstrual hygiene would be
consideration were age and grade of adolescent enhanced by 18.8 percent, holding other factors
girls and their religious backgrounds. The main line constant. However, it also revealed that as the age
of inquiry is the relationship between girls’ keeps increasing there is a probability that the
knowhow on menstrual hygiene management as a knowhow on menstrual hygiene amongst
result of their own and the parental educational adolescent girls would keep growing till the
status. The yearly pocket money received from the tangency (point of no change) point and then starts
parents is also considered as one of the declining by 0.52 percent on an average, holding
Page | 44
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
other factors constant. Similarly, if an adolescent 6.4 Comparative Statics of Schools intervened by
girl lives in a boarding school, on an average, there SHND on MHM and the control group (not intervened
is a probability of not learning menstrual hygiene
management declining by 25 percent, holding
by SHND with MHM)
other factors constant. The main factors like an Tables 4 and 5 illustrate the comparative statics of
adolescent girl’s own education and her parental schools intervened by SHND with MHM program
education have no effect at all in menstrual and their outcomes on the knowledge on
hygiene management. On the other hand, the menstruation and superstition associated with it.
yearly pocket money received by adolescent girls Five schools intervened by MHM programs were
has tremendous effect on the menstrual hygiene
selected by chance in this study for which we
management by the girls. The regression result
took five others who were not intervened by the
has revealed that, on an average, if an adolescent
girl receives pocket money from their parents, same program.
there is a probability enhancing the menstrual
hygiene management knowledge by 0.8 percent.
Page | 45
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Table 4 revealed that more than three quarters table 5 revealed that only around 38 percent of the
(80.6%) of the adolescent girls in those schools adolescent girls in those schools which did not
intervened by the MHM program of SHND had receive MHM program from the SHND knew what
correct knowledge on menstruation. Interestingly, menstruation is all about. About 9.5 percent of
after the intervention of the program, none of them them still consider menstruation as curse followed
believed that menstruation is a curse. However, by 2.2 percent of them considering menstruation
there are still about 4.4 percent of them who still as disease. About half (50.4%) of them don’t know
considers that menstruation is a disease. Around 5 what menstruation is all about. This clearly
percent of them reported that they don’t know indicates the efficacy of the SHND’s MHM
what menstruation is all about. On the contrary, awareness programs in the schools
Page | 46
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 47
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 48
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 49
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
• Nine out of every ten (91.3%) of the the contrary, there are about 13.3 percent who
adolescent schoolgirls clean their genital area said ‘don’t know’.
during menstruation. Close to half (45.9%) of • About 2.2 percent of the nuns reporte'd that
the respondents agreed that they take half menstruation comes from the birth canal.
body bath during period due to lack of hot Around 36 percent of them also reported that
water. menarche begins at the age of 12 .
• More than two-thirds (73.8%) of the • Close to one-quarter (21.4%) of adolescent
respondents reported that they could afford nunsreported that menarche ranges from age
the sanitary pad during menstruation. On the 9 to 11. On the other extreme, more than one-
contrary, there are around 8 percent who quarter (26.9%) of the respondents reported
cannot afford and similarly, about 4.2 percent that menarche begins from the age of 14-18.
of them said that the sanitary pads are not
available. Sources of information on menarche
• More than two-thirds (68.6%) of the • Mothers are the first and main source of
respondents reported using water and soap for information for the nuns. More than half
cleaning genital area during menstruation (54.9%) of the nuns received information on
folowed by only water (27.6%). Less than one menstruation from their mothers. This is
percent have reported that they use towels. followed by about 35.3 percent who said
teachers as their source of information on
8.3 WASH facilities available at schools to combat
menarche. About 7.8 percent reported the
menstruation source as their sisters followed by 2 percent of
• More than half (55.1%) of the adolescent them who cited friends as their source.
school girls reported that they dispose the pad
8.6 Adolescent nuns’ knowledge on menstrual hygiene
into pad disposal bins followed by around 8
percent of them who dispose into pit. About • More than half (53.6%) of the nuns are aware
14.2 ercent of the respondents reported that of the menstruation hygiene. Similarly, more
they dispose off the pads in burning place. than one-third (67.9%) of them perceived it as
• However, around 9 percent of them reported unhygienic. Checked against the nuns’
that there is no disposal facilities at their knowhow on menstrual hygiene management,
disposal at schools. About 43.2 percent of the they reported the followings:
respondents reported that there are no place ✓ We need to clean our genital area with hot
for drying clothes. water;
• The study revealed that only about 64 percent ✓ We need to change our pad time to time;
of the respondents reported having adequate ✓ We have to take bath regularly;
toilet/bathing facilities enough for addressing ✓ We have to wash our hands with soap
issues related to menstruation. The survey after changing the pad;
also revelaed that close to half (45.9%) of the ✓ We need to keep our body clean during
respondents agreed that they take half body period;
bath during period due to lack of hot water. ✓ We need to change underwear regularly;
and
ii) Key findings of adolescent nuns: ✓ Apply perfume to avoid bad smell.
8.4 Awareness on menarche and its causes Awareness on menstrual related infections
• Only around 43 percent of the nuns reported • Only around 36 percent of them are aware of
correctly that the menstruation is a ‘natural the infections related to poor menstrual
shedding of blood on a monthly basis.’ hygiene management.
• About 7.1 percent of the nuns said that • Close to half (42.9%) don’t know at all about
menstruation is a curse followed by 5.4 infections resulting from poor menstrual
percent of them considering it as a disease. hygiene.
• Only about 41.1 percent of them reported that • More than half (53.6%) of the nuns are
it is the hormones that cause menstruation. A unaware about UTI. Only around two out of
substantial share of percentage (37.5%) of every ten (16.1%) are aware of the same.
nuns considered the cause as curse of God
followed by about 7.1 percent who considered Misconceptions and taboos
it as a disease. • One-quarter (25%) of the adolescent nuns
• A large majority (82.2%) of the nuns reported don’t know whether they must enter
that menstruation comes from the uterus. On shrines/temples while having periods.
However, about 21.5 percent of them agreed
Page | 50
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
that they must not enter the shrine/temples • About 60.7 percent of the adolescent nuns
during period. have perceived menstruation as dirty and
• About 33.2 percent on a similar note reported annoying.
that women in menstruation are susceptible to • About 39.2 percent of them have wished that
possession by evil spirits. period would last for a few minutes in women.
• More than half (51.8%) of the adolescent nuns • More than two-thirds (76.8%) of the
agreed that they should not sleep with a man adolescent nuns reported that it is important to
during their periods since it will pass on the buy sanitary pad without being seen. On the
negative energy to man. other hand, around 60 percent wished that
• And one-quarter (25%) of them unanimously they did not have to menstruate.
believe that drinking tea will increase the • Around 35.7 percent of the respondents
menstrual flow. reported that it is uncomfortable for them to
talk about their periods. Close to half (42.8%)
8.9 Physical impacts of menstruation of the respondents reported that they miss
• Close to half (48.2%) of the adolescent nuns classes or other activities at nunneries for fear
agreed that repeated changing of clothes or that they would stain their clothes during
pads might aid the flow of blood. period.
• More than half (53.6%) agreed that women are • About half (50%) of the adolescent nuns
more tired than usual when they are reported that they miss classes or other
menstruating. activities lest they would be ridiculed by others
• Close to half (44.6%) of the adolescent nuns during period. About 41.1 percent of them
reported that menstruation does not affect missed classes or other forms of activities at
their usual activities. nunnery for fear of pain during menstruation.
9. Emotional impacts produced by menstruation 11. Sanitary facilities to counter menstruation hygiene
management
• More than two-thirds (69.8%) of the
respondents agreed that they are more easily • More than a quarter (26.8%) of the adolescent
upset during pre-menstrual periods than at nuns reported that they missed classes or
other times of the month. activities since there isn’t privacy anywhere for
• More than two-thirds (82.2%) of the girls to wash and change at nunnery.
respondents reported that they just have to • More than half (53.6%) of the respondents
tolerate menstruation. again reported that they missed classes or
• Close to half (44.7%) of them reported that activities during menstruation since there is no
men have real advantage of not having place to dispose-off sanitary pad.
monthly period. On the other hand, more than • Around close to one-quarter (21.5%) of the
two-thirds (76.8%) of the adolescent nuns adolescent nuns reported that they missed
reported that the only good thing with classes or activities because of lack of sanitary
menstruation is that they come to know that pad. More than two-thirds (78.6%) of the
they are not pregnant. respondents agreed that they missed classes
• Contrary to earlier assertions by the or activities during period since the toilets are
adolescent nuns, close to half (47.2%) of them too dirty and discourages them to change.
reported that menstruation allows them to be
more aware of their body followed by 67.8 Practices on menstrual hygiene by adolescent nuns
percent of them who said that the recurrent • Almost nine out of every ten (87.5%) use
monthly flow of menstruation is an external sanitary pad followed by around 11 percent
indications of women’s general good health. who used napkin/cloth or towel.
• Close to two-third (64.3%) of the nuns are • On an equal proportion, about 33.9% of them
aware of the pre-menstrual phenomena preferred tampon and sanitary pad. Around 14
through physical symptoms like breast percent of them preferred napkin/cloth or
tenderness, backache, cramps or other towel and about 3.6 percent preferred
physical signs. menstrual cup. Around 13 percent preferred
reusable sanitary pad.
10. Social impacts produced by menstruation
• More than two-thirds (71.4%) cited that they
• Close to half (46.4%) of the adolescent nuns are affordable.
reported that women complaining of • Around one in every ten (10.7%) of them
menstrual distress are just using that as an reported that those absorbent materials they
excuse. preferred are easy to use.
Page | 51
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
• About 7.1 percent of the adolescent nuns reported that they have toilet/bathing facilities
reported that it is easily available and hence for addressing issues related to menstruation.
they preferred it. • More than half (50.8%) of the respondents
• More than half (55.4%) of the adolescent nuns reported that they take half body bath during
reported that they use water alone to clean the period due to lack of hot water.
cloth pad followed by one-quarter (25%) of • About 33.3 percent of them reported that they
them who used both water and soap. can afford pads followed by equal proportions
• Around 18 percent of the adolescent nuns hide of them (20%) who reported that they cannot
and dry the cloth pad beneath other clothes. afford and at the same time not available to
• About two-thirds (66.1%) of the respondents buy.
reported that they dry it inside the house
followed by one-quarter (25%) of them who Empirical Findings
dried them in the sun. • On an average, if an adolescent girl grows
• Again, quite a sizable proportion of adolescent older by one more year, there is a probability
nuns have dried the cloth pad by hiding that her knowledge on menstrual hygiene
beneath another cloth (7.1%). would be enhanced by 18.8 percent, holding
• More than two-thirds (71.4%) of them other factors constant. However, it has been
changed their pads only once a day. The also revealed that as the age keeps increasing,
remaining 28.6 percent of them changed twice there is a probability that the knowhow on
a day. menstrual hygiene amongst adolescent girls
would keep growing till the tangency (point of
WASH facilities at nunneries no change) point and then starts declining by
• Close to half (46.4%) of them reported that 0.52 percent on an average, holding other
they dispose pads into pad disposal bin factors constant. Similarly, if an adolescent girl
followed by equal proportions (23.2%) of them lives in a boarding school, on an average, there
who reported that they dispose it into toilet is a probability of declining, by 25 percent, of
and drain. not learning menstrual hygiene management
• Around 2 percent of them reported that they holding other factors constant. The main
disposed the absorbent material into routine factors like an adolescent girl’s own education
waste and an equal proportion of them and her parental education have no effect at all
reported to have thrown in the open. in menstrual hygiene management. The
• Close to half (48.2%) of the respondents regression result also revealed that, on an
reported that they used papers as pad wraps average, if an adolescent girl receives pocket
followed by 35.7 percent of them who used money from their parents, there is a probability
plastic bag. enhancing the menstrual hygiene
• About 16.1 percent of them have not used pad management knowledge by 0.8 percent.
wrap at all.
Page | 52
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 53
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 54
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 55
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
REFERENCS
1. Sommer M, Sahin M. Overcoming the taboo: advancing the global agenda for menstrual hygiene
management for schoolgirls. Am J Public Health 2013;103:1556–9.
2. [Link]
3. [Link]
709x&year=2011&month=October&volume=5&issue=5&page=1027-1033&id=1522
4. [Link]
b#q=Nepal+menstrual+hygiene+management+study
Page | 56
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Annexure I: Questionnaires
KAP Survey on Menstrual Hygiene Management in Schools of Bhutan
2016
Dear Respondents,
The School Health and Nutrition Division of Ministry of Education would like to request for your kind
cooperation to smoothly execute this survey assigned to M/S Bhutan A2Z Statistics, Economics and
Environmental Consultancy to collect information from you to assess the level of knowledge, attitute
and practices related to menstrual hygienic management amongst the girls in your school.
Q4.1. Type of school: Q12. What is your parents'/Guardian Highest Educational level?:
1. Govt. Father Mother Guardine
2. Private 00. No education
Classes 1-12 ……….. ……. ………..
Q5. Status of school: 13. Diploma
1. Boarding 14. College & above
2. Day school 15. Monastic/shedra
3. Both 16. NFE
Page | 57
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Q27. There are four phases of menstrual cycle namely menstrual phase, Proliferative/ follicular phase, ovuluyary phase
and luteal phase. Of which phase the chances of getting pregnancy is high?
1. Menstrual phase (day 1-5)
2. Follicular/proliferative phase ( day 6-13)
3. Ovulutary phase (day 14)
4. Luteal phase (day 15-28)
5. Don’t know
Page | 58
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
D. ATTITUDE
Don't Strongly
Sl# Strongly Know Disagree disagree
Item agree (1) Agree (2) (3) (4) (5)
28 Women must not enter shrines/temples while having periods
29 Women in menstruation are susceptible to get possessed by evil spirits
30 Women are more tired than usual when they are menstruating
31 Menstruation does not affect my usual activities
I am more easily upset during pre-menstrual and menstrual periods than at
32 other times of the month
40
I barely notice the minor physiological effect outof my menstrual periods
41
Women complaining of menstrual distress are just using that as an excuse
42 It is important to talk about menstrual period with men
43 It is important to discuss the topic of period at school with boys and girls
44 The period is dirty and annoying
Don't Strongly
Sl# Strongly Know Disagree disagree
Item agree (1) Agree (2) (3) (4) (5)
45 We women wish that the period would last for a few minutes
46 It is important to buy sanitary pad without being seen
47 Women wish that we do not have our period
48
It is uncomfortable for us women to talk about our periods
49
I miss school during my period because am afraid of staining my clothes
50 I miss school during my period because am afraid of others making fun of me
51 I miss school during period because it can cause pain
52
I miss school during my period can make me feel uncomfortable or tired
I miss school during my period because there isn't anywhere for girls to wash
53 and change at school
I miss school during my period because there inowhere to dispose off sanitary
54
pad
55 I miss school during my period because I don't have sanitary pad
Q56 Are there any other reasons your period makes you miss school?
Page | 59
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Q58. If you are using cloth as pad, how do you clean it? Q65. If 'No' in Q64, cite at least three reasons:
1. Water
2. Water and soap
3. Others (Specify):…………………….
Q66. If your menstrual problem interferes with
Q59. If you are using cloth, how do you dry the cloth? attendance, how often does it so?
1. Sunlight 1. One day every cycle
2. Inside the house 2. Two days every cycle
3. Others (Specify): ……………………. 3. Three days every cycle
4. Four days every cycle
Q60. How many times do you change cloth or pad in a day? 5. Others (Specify): …………..…………………
1. Once
2. Two and more Q67. What remedies do you take duriong menstruation?
1. Medication
Q61. Where do you dispose your pads? 2. Yoga/Meditation
1. Pad disposal bin 3. Prayers
2. Drain 4. Thoroughly involve in activities
3. Toilet 5. Take rest
4. Open field 6. Others (Specify)………………………..
5. Routine waste
6. Others (Specify): ……………….. Q68. How often do you bath during period?
Q62. Types of pad wraps used for disposing it: 1. Daily
1. Papers 2. Only on first day
2. Plastic bag 3. Only on second day
3. No wrap 4. Do not bath any time
4. Others (Specify): ………………………. 5. Others (Specify): ……………………..
Q63. Number of times you change your underwear during Q69. Do you clean genital area during menstruation?
menstruation in a day: ……………………………… 1. Yes
2. No (>> Q70)
Q64. Do you come to school during menstruation?
1. Yes
2. No
Q70. If 'Yes' in Q70, by what? Q73.1. I have a half body bath during my period due to lack of hot water
1. Water and soap facilities at school?
2. Only with water 1. Strongly agree
4. Towels 2. Agree
5. Others (Specify): …………………………. [Link]'t know
[Link]
Q71. Which one of the following sanitary pad disposal 5. Strong disagree
facilities does your school have?
1. Burning place Q74. Do you afforf to buy sanitary pad or any other substitues to
2. Pit be used as sanitary pad during menstruation?
3. Pad disposal bins 1. Can afford
4. Others (Specify): …………………….. [Link] afford
3. Not available to buy
Q72. Does your school have place for drying clothes? [Link]'t know
1. yes
2. No Q75. Any other comments:
Page | 60
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Q14. From which organ does menstrual blood come from? Q20. Do you know about menstrual hygiene?
1. Uterus 1. Yes
2. Birth canal [Link]
3. Bladder
4. Abdomen Q21. If 'Yes' in Q20, what do you know about menstural hygiene?
5. Others (specify):……………………..
6. Don't know
Q15. At what age do you think most girls usually get their Q21.1. Do you think menstrual blood is unhygenic?
first period? 1. Yes
1.……….. (years) [Link]
2. Don't know
Q21.2 Are you aware of the following infection due to poor menstrual
Q216. What is the duration of normal menstruation for Hygiene: [1=Yes, 2=No, 3=Don’t know]
normal person? [Link] Infection
1.…………(days) 2. Reproductive Track Infection (RTI)
2. Don't know 3. Urinary Track Infection (UTI)
[Link] to infertility
Q17. What is the interval between two menstural cycles?
1.………………(days) Q22. There are four phrase of menstrual cycle nsmely menstrual
2. Don't know phase, Proliferative/follicular phase, ovuluyary phase and leutral
phaes. Of which phase the chances of getting pregnancy is high?
Q18. Did anyone tell you about menstruation before your 1. Menstrual phase (day 1-5)
onset of menstruation? 1. Yes 2. No 2. Follicular/proliferative phase ( day 6-13)
3. Ovulutary phase (day 14)
Q19. From whom you got information regarding menstruation? 4. Leutral phase (day 15-28)
1. Mother 5. Don’t know
2. Teacher
3. Friends
4. Books
5. Media (TV, Radio etc)
6. Others (Specify):…………………….
Page | 61
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
D. ATTITUDE
Don't Strongly
Sl# Strongly Know Disagree disagree
Item agree (1) Agree (2) (3) (4) (5)
23 Women must not enter shrines/temples while having periods
24 Women in menstruation are susceptible to get possessed by evil spirits
25 Sleeping with a man during your periods will pass on the "drip" to man
26 Drinking tea will increase the blood flow
27 Changing often/ staying clean will increase the blood flow
28 Women are more tired than usual when they are menstruating
29 Menstruation does not affect my usual activities
I am more easily upset during pre-menstrual and menstrual periods than at
30
other times of the month
31 Menstruation is something that I just have to put up (tolerate) with
32 Men have real advantage of not having monthly period
The only thing good with menstruation is that I come to know that am not
33 pregnant
38
I barely notice the minor physiological effect outof my menstrual periods
39
Women complaining of menstrual distress are just using that as an excuse
40 The period is dirty and annoying
41 We women wish that the period would last for a few minutes
42 It is important to buy sanitary pad without being seen
43 Women wish that we do not have our period
44 It is uncomfortable for us women to talk about our periods
Don't Strongly
Sl# Strongly Know Disagree disagree
Item agree (1) Agree (2) (3) (4) (5)
I miss classes/activities during my period because am afraid of others making
46
fun of me
47 I miss classses/activities during period because it can cause pain
I miss classes/activities during my period can make me feel uncomfortable or
45 tired
Page | 62
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Q51 If you are using cloth as pad, how do you clean it? Q57. If 'No' in Q8, cite at least three reasons:
1. Water
2. Water and soap
3. Others (Specify):…………………….
Q52. If you are using cloth, how do you dry the cloth? Q58. If your menstrual problem interferes with
1. Sunlight attendance, how often does it so?
2. Inside the house 1. One day every cycle
3. Hide and dry it beneath other clothes 2. Two days every cycle
4. Others (Specify): ……………………. 3. Three days every cycle
4. Four days every cycle
Q53. How many times do you change cloth or pad in a day? 5. Others (Specify): …………..…………………
1. Once
2. Two and more Q59. What remedies do you take duriong menstruation?
1. Medication
Q54. Where do you dispose your pads? 2. Yoga/Meditation
1. Pad disposal bin 3. Prayers
2. Drain 4. Thoroughly involve in activities
3. Toilet 5. Take rest
4. Open field 6. Others (Specify)………………………..
5. Routine waste
6. Others (Specify): ……………….. Q60. How often do you bath during period?
1. Daily
Q55. Types of pad wraps used for disposing it: 2. Only on first day
1. Papers 3. Only on second day
2. Plastic bag 4. Do not bath any time
3. No wrap 5. Half-body bath everyday
4. Others (Specify): ………………………. 6. Others (Specify): ……………………..
Q56. Number of times you change your underwear during Q61 Do you clean genital area during menstruation?
menstruation in a day: ……………………………… 1. Yes
Q58. Do you come to school during menstruation? 2. No (>> Q64)
1. Yes
2. No
Q62. If 'Yes' in Q70, by what? Q66. Do you afforf to buy sanitary pad or any other substitues to
1. Water and soap be used as sanitary pad during menstruation?
2. Only with water 1. Can afford
4. Towels [Link] afford
5. Others (Specify): …………………………. 3. Not available to buy
[Link]'t know
Q.63Which one of the following sanitary pad disposal
facilities does your nunnary have? Q67. I have a half body bath during my period due to lack of hot water
1. Burning place facilities at nunneries?
2. Pit 1. Strongly agree
3. Pad disposal bins 2. Agree
4. Others (Specify): …………………….. 3. Don't know
4. Disagree
Q64. Does your nunnary have place for drying clothes? 5. Strongly disagree
1. yes
2. No Q68. Any other comments:
Page | 63
MENSTRUAL HYGIENE MANAGEMENT OF ADOLESCENT SCHOOL GIRLS AND NUNS
Page | 64
x