Filed: 05/25/2021 [Link]

Seventh Judicial District, Fremont County

Abbie Mace, Clerk of the Court
By: Deputy Clerk - Harrigfeld, Becky

Lindsey A. Blake, ISB #7920

Rob H. Wood [SB #8229
OFFICE OF THE FREMONT COUNTY
PROSECUTING ATTORNEY
22 W. I“ N.
St. Anthony, ID 83445
Tel: 208-624-4418
Email: prosecutorflco.t‘remontidus

Attorneys for the Stare

IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE SEVENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT OF THE

STATE OF IDAHO, IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF FREMONT

STATE OF IDAHO,
Case No. CR22-21- 1623
Plaintiff,

VS.

INDICTMENT
CHAD GUY DAYBELL AND
LORI NORENE VALLOW
AKA LORI NORENE DAYBELL
Defendants.

CHAD GUY DAYBELL AND LORI NORENE VALLOW, are accused by the Grand

Jury of Fremont County, by this indictment, as follows:

[NDICTMENT —
l
 COUNT l
CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT FIRST DEGREE MURDER
AND GRAND THEFT BY DECEPTION, a Felony
Idaho Code §§ 18-1701, 18-4003(a). 18-24030), 18-2403(4)(a), 18-2407(l)(b)(3)

The Defendants, C had Guy Daybell. Lori Norene V allow, and Alex Cox (deceased) and other
co-conspirators, both known and unknown, on or between the dates of October 26, 2018, and

continuing until January 15, 2020, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, and elsewhere,
including Fremont County, Idaho, and as pan of a continuing criminal transaction and common
scheme 0r plan in Madison and Fremont Counties, Idaho, did willfully and knowingly combine,

conspire, confederate, and agree to commit Murder in the First Degree of Tylee Ryan, and to
commit Grand Theft by Deception.

OVERT ACTS

In furtherance of the conspiracy to commit Murder in the First Degree of Tylee Ryan and

Grand Theft by Deception, and to affect the objects thereof, one or more of the following overt

acts were committed by one or more of the subjects of the conspiracy as part of a continuing
criminal transaction and common scheme or plan within Madison and Fremont Counties or
elsewhere in the State of Idaho.

1. On or between October 26, 2018 and June 9, 2020, Chad Guy Daybell (and Lori Norene

Vallow) did endorse and espouse religious beliefs for the purpose of encouraging and/or
justifying the homicide of Tylee Ryan.
On or about August 16, 2019, Lori Norene Vallow did change the deposit onylee
Ix)

Ryan’s Social Security benefits from Tylee Ryan’s J P Morgan Chase Account to deposit
money directly into Lori Norene Vallow’s personal BBVA bank account.
3. On or about September 1, 2019, Lori Norene Vallow did move from Chandler, Arizona
to Rexburg, Idaho with Alex Cox, Tylee Ryan, and Joshua J axon Vallow (hereinafter
“JJ Vallow”).

INDICTMENT - 2
 4. On or about September 8. 3019, Chad Guy Daybcll Googlcd "53w wind” and Visited a

website entitled "What is the definition of SSW wind direction?"

LII

On or about September 9. 2019, Alex Cox did g0 to 565 Pioneer Road. Apt. 175.

Rexburg, Idaho.
6. On or between September 9, 2019 and February 1, 2020, Lori Norene Vallow failed or
refused to contact the Social Security Administration as required bylaw to inform the

Social Security Administration of Tylee Ryan‘s death.

7. On or between September 25, 2019 and January 22, 2020, Lori Norene Vallow did

wrongfully continue to collect five monthly Social Security Survivor benefits on behalf
of Tylee Ryan.

COUNT II
FIRST DEGREE MURDER, a Felony
Idaho Code §§ 18-4001 18-4002,18-4003(a),18-4004

The Defendants, Chad Guy Daybell, and Lori Norene Vallow, on or between the 8‘“ and
9‘“ day of September, 2019, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, and as part of a common

scheme or plan or continuing criminal transaction between Madison and Fremont Counties in

Idaho were concerned in the commission of a first degree murder, and did aid and abet in its

commission, or, not being present, advised and encouraged its commission, or by command

compelled another to commit the crime and did so with malice aforethought and did so willfully,
deliberately and with premeditation, which resulted in the death of a human being, to wit: did either
kill Tylee Ryan and/or assist in the killing of Tylee Ryan, and/or did encourage the killing onyIee
Ryan and/or did command another to kill Tylee Ryan in violation of Idaho Code Sections 18-4001;
18-204; 18-4003(a).

INDICTMENT - 3
 COUNT [II
CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT FIRST DEGREE MURDER
AND GRAND THEFT BY DECEPTION, a Felony
Idaho Code §§ 18-1701, 18-4003(a), 18-2403(I), 18-2403(4)(a), 18-2407(I)(b)(3)

The Defendants, Chad Guy Daybell, Lori Norene Vallow, and Alex Cox (deceased) and other

co-conspirators, both known and unknown, on or between the dates of October 26, 2018, and

continuing until January 15, 2020, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, and elsewhere,
including Fremont County, Idaho, and as part of
'
a continuing criminal transaction and common
scheme or plan in Madison and Fremont Counties, Idaho, did willfully and knowingly combine,

conspire, confederate, and agree to commit Murder in the First Degree of Joshua J axon Vallow,

(hereinafter “J J Vallow") and to commit Grand Theft by Deception.

OVERT ACTS

In furtherance of the conspiracy to commit Murder in the First Degree of J J Vallow and Grand
Theft by Deception, and to affect the objects thereof, one or more of the following overt acts were
committed by one or more of the subjects of the conspiracy as part of a continuing criminal

transaction and common scheme or plan within Madison and Fremont Counties or elsewhere in

the State 0f Idaho.

l. On or between October 26, 2018 and June 9, 2020, Chad Guy Daybell (and Lori Norene

Vallow) did endorse and teach religious beliefs for the purpose of justifying the
homicide of JJ Vallow.

On or about September I, 2019, Lori Norene Vallow did move from Chandler, Arizona
k)

to Rexburg, Idaho with Alex Cox, Tylee Ryan, and Joshua J axon Vallow.
On or about September 23, 2019, Alex Cox did take possession ofJJ Vallow.
b)

4. On or about November 26, 2019, Lori Norene Vallow provided a false and/or misleading

physical location ofJJ Vallow to law enforcement during a lawful investigation.

On or between September 23, 20-19 and February 2020, Lori Norene Vallow failed or
UI

1,

refused to contact the Social Security Administration as required by law to inform the

Social Security Administration of JJ Vallow’s death.

INDICTMENT - -1
 6. On or between the dates ofSeptember 9, 2010 and February 1. 2020. Lori Norene

Vallow did wrongfully continue to collect four monthly Social Security Survivor
benefits on behalfofJJ Vallow and four monthly Social Security Child-in-Care

payments.
COUNT IV
FIRST DEGREE MURDER, a Felony
Idaho Code §§ 18-4001 18-4002,18-4003(a),18-4004

The Defendants, Chad Guy Daybell and Lori Norene Vallow, on or between the 22nd and

23rd day of September, 2019, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, and as part of a common
scheme or plan or continuing criminal transaction between Madison and Fremont Counties in

Idaho, was concerned in the commission of a first degree murder, and did aid and abet in its

commission, or, not being present, advised and encouraged its commission, or by command

compelled another to commit the crime and did so with malice aforethought and did so willfully,
deliberately and with premeditation, which resulted in the death ofa human being, to wit: did either
kill JJ Vallow and/or assist in the killing ofJJ Vallow, and/or did encourage the killing ofJJ Vallow
and/or did command another to kill JJ Vallow in violation of Idaho Code Sections 18-4001; 18-

204;is—4003(ai

COUNTV
CONSPIRACY TO COMMIT FIRST DEGREE MURDER
Felony, LC. §§ 18-4001, 18-4003(a), 18-1701

That the Defendants, Chad Guy Daybell, Lori Norene Vallow, and Alex Cox (deceased)

on or about October 1, 2018 —

January 15, 2020, in the County of Fremont, State of Idaho, and

elsewhere, including Madison County, and as part of a continuing transaction and common

scheme or plan in Fremont Counties, Idaho, did willfully and knowingly combine, conspire,

confederate, and agree to commit Murder in the First Degree ofTamara “Tammy” Daybell, did

combine or conspire to commit murder, and one or more ofsuch persons did an act to affect the

object of the combination or conspiracy.

INDICTMENT - 5
 OVERT ACTS

In funhercmce of the conspiracy to commit Murder in the First Degree ofTamara “Tammy"

Daybell, and to affect the objects thereof, one or more of the following overt acts were
committed by one or more of the subjects of the conspiracy as part ofa continuing criminal

transaction and common scheme or plan within Madison and Fremont Counties or elsewhere in

the State of Idaho.

On or about or between the dates ofOctober 26, 2018 and June 9, 2020, Chad Guy

Daybell (and Lori Norene Vallow) did encourage and espouse religious beliefs for the
purpose of justifying and/or encouraging the homicide of Tamara “Tammy” Daybell.

l, 2019, Lori NoreneVallow did move

Ix)

On or about September to Rexburg, Idaho with

Alex Cox, Tylee Ryan, and Joshua Jackson (hereinafter J J ) Vallow.
Text messages between Chad and Lori regarding death percentages for Tammy and J J in
DJ

messages on July 30, 20 I 9.

Chad Daybell obtained a burner phone on September 18, 2019.
Alex Cox obtained a burner phone on October 9, 2019.
Text messages between Chad Guy Daybell and Lori Norene Vallow about Tamara

“Tammy” Daybell being in Limbo, and Tammy being possessed by a spirit named
Viola.

September 8, 2019, Chad Guy Daybell signed application along with Tamera “Tammy”

Daybell to increase her LifeMap insurance to the maximum allowed under her policy.
Alex Cox attempted to shoot Tamera “Tammy” Daybell on October 9, 2019.
Alex Cox conducted multiple intemet searches between the dates ofOctober 8, 2019

and October 12, 2019 including searches related to Grendel drop and shooting through a

Dodge Dakota.
lO. Alex going to gun range in the months before October 9, 2019 when the attempted
shooting of Tamara “Tammy" Daybell takes place.

INDICTMENT - 6
 l 1. Alex traveled from Sportsman‘s Warehouse to the vicinity of the Daybell residence on
October 9. 2019.

12. Alex was in the church parking lot approximately 2.5 miles from the Daybell residence

on the night of October 18, 2019.

COUNT VI
FIRST DEGREE MURDER
Felony, I.C. §§ 18-4001, 18-204, 18-4003(a)

That the Defendant, Chad Guy Daybell, on or about October 18-19, 2019, in the County

of Fremont, State of Idaho, was concerned in the commission ofa first degree murder, and did

aid and abet in its commission, or, not being present, advised and encouraged its commission, or

by command compelled another to commit the crime and did so with malice aforethought and

did so willfully, deliberately and with premeditation, which resulted in the death of a human

being, to wit: did either kill Tamara “Tammy” Daybell and/0r assist in the killing ofTamara

"Tammy" Daybell, and/or did encourage the killing of Tamara "Tammy” Daybell and/or did

command another to kill Tamara "Tammy” Daybell in violation of Idaho Code Sections 18-

4001; 18-204; 18-4003(a).

COUNT VII
GRAND THEFT, Felony
I.C. §§ 18-24030), or 18-2403(4)(a), 18-2407(1)(b)(3)

That the Defendant, Lori Norene V allow, on or between the dates of October 1, 2019 and

January 22, 2020, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, did, as a common scheme or plan or

continuing criminal transaction between Madison and Fremont Counties, Idaho, by deceit and with
the intent to deprive another of property or to appropriate the same to herselt‘or to a third person,

wrongfully take, obtain or withhold, 0r aid and abet another to take, obtain or withhold, the
property of another, to-wit:

INDICTMENT - 7
 Social Security Survivor benefits allocated for Tylee Ryan and JJ Vallow, and
Social Security child—in-care benefits allocated for Lori Norene Vallow, in an
amount exceeding $1,000.00, which said funds Lori Norene Vallow was not

entitled, and which did belong to the Government of the United States of

America.

COUNT VIII
INSURANCE FRAUD
Felony, LC. § 41-293

That the Defendant, Chad Guy Daybell, on or about October 19, 2019 — October 30,

2019, in the County of Madison, State of Idaho, did with the intent to defraud or deceive an

insurer for the purpose of obtaining any money or benefit, presented or caused to be presented to

an insurer, or other person, a statement as part of, or in support of, a claim for payment or

benefit, knowing that such statement contained false, incomplete, or misleading information

concerning any fact or thing material to such claim, to wit: did present and/or cause to be

presented an Insurance Beneficiary Form to LifeMap Assurance Company in violation of Idaho

Code Section 41-293.

COUNT IX
INSURANCE FRAUD
Felony, LC. § 41-293

That the Defendant, Chad Guy Daybell, on or about October 19, 2019 — October 31,

2019, in the County of Madison or Fremont County, State of Idaho, did with the intent to defraud

or deceive an insurer for the purpose of obtaining any money or benefit, present or caused to be

a claim for
presented to an insurer, or other person, a statement as part of, or in support of,

payment or benefit, knowing that such statement contained false, incomplete, or misleading

information concerning any fact or thing material to such claim, to wit: did present and/or cause

INDICTMENT - 8
to be presented 3 Claimant Statement to Primerica Life Insurance Company in Violation ofIdnho

Code Section 41-393.

TRUE BILL

Presented in open court this 1 '7‘ day of May, 2021.

B od’fih‘fl/LLQLJ‘
DEPUTY PRESIDING’GMND JUROR
ACTING PRESIDING GRAND JUROR
FREMONT COUNTY, STATE OF IDAHO

INDICTMENT - 9
 WITNESS LIST
MONDAY MAY 17, 2021
NAME
Ray
Ron
Randy Reese
Stubbs
*Joe Powell
*Bruce Mattingly
Vinnie
Rylene Nolen
Tara Martinez
Angela Yancey
Hailey
Taylor Ballard

TUESDAY MAY 18, 2021

NAME
Katie Dace
Chuck
Mark Sari
Joe Powell
Bruce Mattingly
Helania Kaaiakamanu
Colter Cannon
Garth Daybell
Joe Murray
Melanie Pawlowski
David Warwick
*Zulema Pastenes

WEDNESDAY MAY 19, 2021

NAME
Zulema cont.
David Warwick
Melanie Gibb
Steve Daniels
Gary Lu
Brenda Dye
Erik Christensen
THURSDAY MAY 20, 2021
NAlVIE
Ricky Wright
Garth Warren
Melanie Pawlowski
Ian Pawlowski
Audrey Barattiero
Ben Dean
BYU — I Lane
Kinghorn
Emma Moss
Heather Daybell
Sandra Briggs
Shanna Miller
MacKay Abeglan
Ricky Wright (cont)
Jarrod Willrnore

MONDAY MAY 24, 2021

NAME
Audrey Batterio (recall)
911 Dispatcher Chris
Ally Greenhalgh
Cammy Willrnore
Ray Hermosillo
Brenda Dye
Vinnie K.
Mike Douglass
Doug Hart