Roadmap Implementation Strategy 9192014
Roadmap Implementation Strategy 9192014
The LGU PFM Reform Implementation Strategy was developed under the European Union (EU) funded
project, “Support to the Local Government Units for More Effective and Accountable Public Financial
Management (LGU PFM 2 Project).”
©2014 by the LGU PFM 2 Project
While the Roadmap sets out the plan for LGU PFM reform from 2014 – 2022 by identifying the issues
to be addressed and laying down the related policy tools/interventions, the Implementation Strategy
provides the specific actions to carry out the policy tools/interventions that will, in turn, result to the
outcomes.
It also anticipates the risks associated with implementation of the reforms and how these are to be
managed and mitigated.
The Implementation Strategy guides the LGUs in preparing their respective PFM Improvement Plans
(PFMIPs). Based on the actions identified in the Implementation Strategy, LGUs can choose and tailor-
fit interventions that will suit the conditions and circumstances existing in their LGUs.
The Implementation Strategy also builds convergence among the Oversight Agencies (OAs) - Department
of Budget and Management (DBM), Department of the Interior and Local Government (DILG),
Department of Finance – Bureau of Local Government Finance (DOF-BLGF), and National Economic
and Development Authority (NEDA), by providing the measures for improving and harmonizing the
technical assistance they provide to LGUs.
Figure 1 below shows the relationship among the LGU PFM Reform Roadmap, Implementation Strategy
and PFMIP.
Figure 1: The LGU PFM Reform Roadmap, Implementation Strategy and PFMIP
1 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
2.0 OPERATIONALIZING THE LGU PFM REFORM ROADMAP
2.1 Core Approaches This section presents the broad strategies for achieving the
desired directions of the PFM reform based on the results of
to Implementation of extensive regional consultations with LGUs and OAs conducted
LGU PFM Reforms from October 2013 to April 2014.
These approaches were identified by the stakeholders as essential to the implementation and
sustainability of LGU FPM Reforms:
1
Refers to the European Union (EU) – funded Project, “Support to the Local Government Units for More Effective and Accountable
Public Financial Management,” otherwise known as the LGU PFM 2 Project.
2
Refers to the LGU PFM 2 Project Technical Working Group
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 2
National Inter-Agency Team (NIAT): Composed Regional Inter-Agency Teams (RIATs):
of representatives of the OAs at the National Composed of the Regional Directors of the
Level. different OAs.
Part of the sustainability strategy of the LGU PFM This shall be supported by a Composite PFM
reforms is to transition the functions of the PSC Team, consisting of technical personnel of each
to a NIAT. OA.
Being a high-level body, it is proposed
The RIATs will be tasked to support, and monitor
that this structure be supported by a NIAT
and evaluate the implementation of the PFM
Technical Working Group (TWG) composed of
reforms by their respective coverage LGUs.
representatives from the LGU policy units of the
OAs at the national level.
LGU PFM Teams: Composed of the Local Chief
Executives (LCEs) or their representatives, and
The NIAT, through the LGU policy units at the
Department Heads of the Offices of Planning
OA Central levels, shall prepare all the necessary
and Development, Treasury, Accounting, Budget,
capacity development interventions that will form
Internal Audit, General Services Office and/or
part of the LGU PFM reform agenda.
Bids and Awards Committee, among others.
3 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
2.2 The LGU This section presents the LGU PFM Reform Imlementation Strategies
which basically contain capacity development interventions for both
PFM Reform OAs and LGUs. The interventions were determined by the LGUs and
Implementation OAs themselves during the nationwide consultations on the LGU
PFM Reform Roadmap. The results of earlier studies done by the
Strategies
LGU PFM2 Technical Assistance Team (TAT) during the project 3
The Implementation Strategy Matrix articulates the systems approach used in addressing the factors
affecting the PFMAT scores obtained by LGUs that assessed their PFM system. The interventions
identified address the needs of both LGUs and OAs along seven (7) capacity pillars: management
systems, structure, competency, enabling policies, knowledge and learning, convergence and leadership.
These pillars were mostly adopted from the SCALOG4 of the DILG, except for the convergence pillar,
which is determined as equally necessary given the recognized need for enhanced coordination among
OAs, and between OAs and LGUs.
3
The Technical Assistance Team (TAT) is a pool of technical experts established and provided by the EU to assist the DBM and other OAs in
implementing the LGU PFM 2 Project.
4
System on Competency Assessment for Local Governments (SCALOG) include tools which identify the organizations’ competency strengths to be
maintained and weaknesses to be addressed through capacity building efforts.
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 4
Policies Laws, ordiannces, rules and Have directions been set using the right
regulations, and guidelines on PFM policy instrument?
(e.g., appropriation ordinance, Have the target results, objectives,
executive issuance) strategies, and activites been defined?
Have adequate resources been provided?
Are enabling policies:
• In place?
• Sufficient/effective/with gaps?
• Up to date?
• Disseminated?
• Enforced?
Knowledge and Mechanisms for generating, analyzing • Are knowledge and learning
Learning and using PFM data and information mechanisms in place and effective?
as bases for decision-making and • Are data or databases accessible to
continuous improvement and used by stakholders?
• Are M & E data used?
• Are citizens/stakeholders engaged to
provide feedback on service delivery?
• Is there continuous benchmarking with
good practices (documenting and
sharing good practices?)
Leadership Mechanisms for defining and setting • Are there clear lines of accountability?
PFM strategic directions at the LGU / • Are leadership mechanisms in place
OA levels; Ensuring transparency and and effective:
accountability in the LGU’s/Oversight ƟƟ Partnership with other OAs?
Agency operations; Instituting ƟƟ Active support for the LGUs?
participatory mechanisms for PFM ƟƟ Active and visible involvement in
reforms; and visible support to PFM PFM reforms?
reforms
Convergence Mechanisms for establishing and • Is there collaboration among OAs?
institutionalizing collaboration among • Is there harmonized and coordinated
OAs and other relevant stakeholders technical assistance?
• Is there coordination among OAs on
PFM policy setting?
The Implementation Strategy also presents the risk register which contains both risks and mitigation
strategies for the PFM reforms as reflected in columns 6 and 7 of the Implementation Strategy Matrix
presented in the next section. It will help in minimizing the impact of possible adverse or unwelcome
circumstances should they arise during implementation by anticipating possible challenges and
identifying measures to reduce or manage such challenges.
There are four types of risks that may impact on the Roadmap. These are the following:
Risks that can hinder the partner organization from achieving its targeted
Development
outcomes and impact
Risks that have potential impact on the project’s ability to maintain the
Reputation
confidence of its stakeholders regarding fulfilling its mandate.
5 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
2022
• Institutionalized convergence of
technical support activities of
OAs to LGUs
B. SUSTAINABILITY 1. Institutionalize Policy Policy 2016 Delays in software Monitoring by DBM
OF PFM use of the • Continue making PFMAT • Issue Executive Order • PFMAT regularly used by development on the progress of the
ASSESSMENT PFMAT for a requirement for the directing conduct of PFM LGUs to generate basis for the Roll-out delays software developer
TOOL (PFMAT) monitoring Grassroots Participatory assessment using the preparation of the PFMIP and
LGU adherence Budgeting Process PFMAT for LGUs policy and decision making
to sound PFM (GPBP) Delays in Formal designation of
practices and Management Systems • Enhanced PFMAT Software consolidation and DBM LGU Policy Unit
processes Management Systems • Embed the PFMAT utilized by LGUs in conducting analyses of results to take charge of LGU
• Enhance the Software Software in the LGU’s their PFM assessments and PFM, including PFMAT
based on the revised/ financial management maintaining a database of PFM
updated PFMAT for information system results Close coordination
LGUs between DBM LGU
Structure • PFMAT results consolidated and Policy Unit, ROs and
Structure • Create and/or strengthen analyzed at regional and national LGUs
• Strengthen the LGU LGU PFM Team levels as bases for policy and
Policy Unit in DBM decision making
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 6
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
B. SUSTAINABILITY OF Knowledge & Knowledge & Learning • Analytical Framework linking Lack of consensus Pilot test production
PFM ASSESSMENT Learning • Share the results and PFMAT, LGFPMS and LGPMS among OAs on of the consolidated
TOOL (PFMAT) • Establish consolidated analysis of results developed whether to develop outputs to demonstrate
analytical linkage the PFM tools with the analytical linkage benefits of the analysis
among PFMAT / different departments in 2019
LGFPMS/ LGPMS the LGU, including the • PFMAT regularly used by LGUs to
Local Sanggunian generate basis for the preparation
of the PFMIP and policy and
decision making
2022
• PFMAT regularly used by LGUs to
generate basis for the preparation
of the PFMIP and policy and
decision making
7 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
Competency / People
• Capacitate Regional
OAs on how to
coach LGUs in
improving and
tracking their
PFMIPs
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 8
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
2022
• Grant of LGU PFM Leadership
Award encourage more LGU
officials to support LGU PFM
reforms
2022
• Grants or preferential
credit financing extended
to LGUs based on financial
performance
9 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
D. LINK BETWEEN 1. Strengthen linkage Policy Policy 2016 Capacities of Formal commitment
PDPFP/CDP-LDIP- between PDPFP/ • Enhance CDP/LDIP manual(s) • Issue policy reiterating • LGUs fully capacitated to technical personnel of OAs via
AIP1 AND BUDGET CDP-LDIP-AIP and including incorporation of GPBP compliance with the prepare and update their to provide TA enhanced JMC No. 1
Budget principles, and alignment of the updated / enhanced PDPFP / CDPs with matching support
CDP/LDIP with the PDPFP/PDIP CDP / LDIP manual(s) LDIPs from which AIPs are TA for capacitation
derived of OA ROs on PFM
• Issue policy mandating OAs Structure tools
(DILG, NEDA) to monitor and • Reconstitute the LDC 2019
review preparation of CDP/ based on the updated • PDPFPs / CDPs with Delay in BOM Constant
PDPFP and LDIP CDP / LDIP Manual matching LDIPs from which updating and roll- monitoring by DBM
AIPs are derived prepared out LGU Policy unit
• Issue policy making the PDPFP/ Management Systems and updated by LGUs
CDP and LDIP as requirements • Embed / integrate Absence of Provide support
in the preparation of the local the e-budget system 2022 technical team to and capacitate
budget in the LGU’s regular • Strong sustainable linkage capable of the RIATs to train a
financial information between PDPFP/CDP – LDIP capacitating the core group of PFM
Management Systems management system – AIP and budget ensured in LGUs teams across LGUs
• Revisit and harmonize planning, LGUs to do roll out to
budgeting, project prioritization Competency / People component LGUs
process and tools currently being • Cascade within the
used by DILG, DBM, BLGF, NEDA LGUs and roll-out
to component LGUs
• Harmonize BOM with the CapDev interventions
updated PDPFP/CDP and LDIP received from the
preparation process RIATs
• Develop e-Budget system based
on the enhanced BOM
Competency / People
• Roll out enhanced PDPFP/CDP/
LDIP manuals and provide inter-
agency TA support to LGUs
Convergence
• Develop and institutionalize
mechanisms at the OA regional
level to reinforce harmonization
of the planning-budgeting-
project prioritization process
1
PDPFP – Provincial Development and Physical Framework Plan; CDP – Comprehensive Development Plan; LDIP – Local Development Investment Program; AIP – Annual Investment Program
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 10
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
E. VIABILITY OF 1. Promote financial Management Systems Policy 2016 Delays in the development, Develop policy consensus
LOCAL ECONOMIC self-reliance of • Develop a detailed • Issue policy on the • LGUs fully capacitated on pilot-testing and roll-out of
ENTERPRISES LEEs and PUs LGU guide for creation of LEEs/ setting-up and managing LEE guide
(LEEs) AND the setting up, PUs, making the LEEs and PUs
PUBLIC UTILITIES operations and conduct of feasibility
(PUs) divestment of LEEs studies a mandatory 2019 Absence of technical team Provide training / coaching
requirement • Only viable LEEs and
capable of providing training / to OAs to increase level of
• Roll-out guide with PUs are established /
inter-agency TA TA to LGUs knowledge on LEEs
Competency / People maintained
support to LGUs • Cascade within the
LGUs and roll-out 2022
Competency / People to component • Culture of good business
• Provide technical LGUs CapDev adopted in most LGUs
training on all interventions
aspects of the LEE received from the
Guide RIATs
11 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
Driver of change
Competencies
Roll-out enhanced PDPFP/CDP/LDIP
manuals and provide inetr-agency TA
Structure
support to LGUs
Create inter-agency teams at
Capacitate Regional OAs on how to coach
national and regional levels
LGUs in improving and tracking their PFMIPs
Create and strengthen the LGU
Provide technical training on LEE/feasibility
Policy Unit in DBM
studies based on the enhanced LEE Guide
Clarify and clearly delineate the roles
of RIATs and LGU Policy Units at the
national level in the validation and
monitoring of PFMIPs
Knowledge Management
Establish analytical linkage among
Policies PFMAT, LGFPMS and LGPMS
Enhance JMC No. 1 Systems
Enhance CDP/LDIP Manual Align PDPFP/CDP-LDIP-AIP with the
Mandate DILG and NEDA to Budget
monitor and review CDP/PDPFP Revisit and harmonize planning,
and LDIP preparation budgeting, project priortization
Institutionalize the PDPFP/ processes and tools used by OAs Convergence
CDP as requirements in the Harmonize BOM with the updated
preparation of the local budget Strengthen convergence mechanisms
PDPFP/CDP and LDIP process through the CCD
Develop and institutionalize
mechanisms at the OA-RO to reinforce
harmonization of the planning-
budgeting-project prioritiization
process
Crucial to this cluster is the strengthening and institutionalization of convergence and coordination
among the different OAs as planning and budgeting policies and tools fall under the coverage of not
just one but three different OAs. The enhancement of JMC No. 1 provides a very good starting point
for harmonizing the technical support being provided by OAs to LGUs.
Linking budget planning to policy priorities will be actualized by aligning the development plans
(PDPFP/CDP, LDIP and AIP) with the annual budget. This entails the development and roll-out of
an enhanced CDP/LDIP manual, which adopts a new planning paradigm, and recognizes the unique
characteristics of each LGU.
To sustain the gains of policy-based budgeting, the use of the PFMAT and PFMIPs shall be institutionalized
in the LGUs by continuing to make the conduct of PFM assessments using the PFMAT, and preparation
and implementation of PFMIPs as requisites for entitlement to funds under the Grassroots Participatory
Budgeting Process (GPBP).
Moreover, to gain more support for PFM reforms, appropriate policies on the adoption of PFM Leadership
Awards as well as performance-based incentives shall be developed and issued.
Finally, to ensure that the establishment and operation of LEEs and PUs become an integral part of the
LGU’s development and investment programming, a detailed guide on the setting-up, operation and
divestment of LEEs and PUs shall be developed and rolled-out to LGUs.
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 12
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 2 : DEVELOPING RELIABLE AND PREDICTABLE BUDGETS
13 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
2022
• Institutionalized
culture of budget
transparency
3. Electronic 2016
submission of • Barangay financial
consolidated statements
Barangay electronically
financial submitted by cities /
statements municipalities to DILG
2019
• Barangay financial
statements
electronically
submitted by cities /
municipalities to DILG
2022
• Institutionalized
culture of budget
transparency
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 14
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 2 : DEVELOPING RELIABLE AND PREDICTABLE BUDGETS
15 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 2 : DEVELOPING RELIABLE AND PREDICTABLE BUDGETS
• Develop casebooks on
best practices of LGUs
with good collection
strategies
Leadership
• Develop rewards
system for
improvement in
revenue collection rate
I. CASH FLOW 1. Improve cash flow Policy Policy 2016 Unclear delineation of Delineate
FORECASTING forecasting and • Issue policy / • Issue directive • LGUs capacitated on responsibility for the responsibilities
management guidelines on adoption mandating the use cash flow forecasting development of tolls between DBM and
of the cash flow of the cash flow and templates for BLGF
forecasting tool forecasting tool 2019 cash inflows and cash
• Increased accuracy of outflows forecasting
Management Systems Structure cash flow forecasts of
• Develop standard • Institutionalize LGUs
templates for cash inter-departmental Absence of technical Strengthen LGU
flow forecasting coordination and 2022 team to assist LGUs in Policy Units of OAs
information sharing • Improved cash the areas of cash flow and RIATs
• Develop Software for amongst local management of LGUs forecasting, analyzing
cash flow forecasting finance offices revenue assignments
template and fiscal incentives
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 16
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 2 : DEVELOPING RELIABLE AND PREDICTABLE BUDGETS
• Embed software
for cash flow
forecasting in the
LGU’s IFMS
Knowledge &
Learning
• Share the LGU’s
cash flow forecast,
including updates/
revisions, with
the different
departments in the
LGU, including the
Local Sanggunian
J. COMPLIANCE 1. Enhance Competency / People Policy 2016 Resistance of LGUs Information
WITH RA NO. procurement • Capacitate DBM ROs • Issue policy • LGUs capacitated on Communication
9184 AND ITS capabilities in the use of the APCPI directing the the APCPI as basis for Education (IEC) to
IRR through training of assessment of preparing Procurement mobilize LGU leagues
trainers (TOT) compliance with Improvement Action as champions of the
the procurement Plans (PIAPs) APCPI
• Specific training support law and guidelines
for the Head of Procuring using the APCPI 2019 Lack of capacity Technical support
Entity (HOPE) and Bids • LGUs implementing of LGUs to prepare to LGUs to enable
and Awards Committee Knowledge & PIAPs plans on time and in production of PIAPs
(BAC) Members and LGUs Learning accordance with the according to the
on procurement policy, • Share the results 2022 required standard standard required
process and procedures and analysis of the • Compliance with RA No.
APCPI assessment 9184 as a result of PIAP
• Specific training with the different implementation by LGUs
support for staff (LGU departments in the
departments) in preparing LGU, including the
the Annual Procurement Local Sanggunian
Plan (APP)
17 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 18
Competencies
Leadership/Change management
Implement competency improvements
Structure Provide rewards for improvement in focused on revenue and expenditure
revenue collection rate forecasting to all critical stakeholders
Institutionalize interdepartmental
coordination and information sharing Roll-out tools and manuals and
among local finance officers provide TA to LGUs
Strengthen LGU capacity to raise
revenues
Capacitate DBM ROs in the use of the
Systems APCPI
Policies Specific training support for LGUs
Develop a laymanized system of
Define role of CSOs in enforcing reporting under the FDP on procurement policy, process and
the Full Disclosure Policy (FDP) procedures
Monitor compliance with FDP
of the DILG Specific training support for staff (LGU
Enhance existing rewards System of OAs departments) in preparing the Annual
Policy on adoption of a
for compliance with FDP Procurement Plan (APP)
standard revenue and cash flow
forecasting tools and the MTEF Develop system for consolidating Advocacy and communication
Barangay financial statements at the LGU programs to show that recently
Amend RA 7160 to expand tax
level introduced enhancement measures
base of LGUs (provinces)
Develop a uniform revenue forecasting have improved quality of CSE
Update Local Revenue Code &
tool
Schedule of Market Values
Update the BOM to include MTEF and
Review BLGF’s Revenue
capital expenditure planning
Mobilization Manual(RMM),
Local Treasury Operations Harmonize reporting requirements Knowledge Management
Manual (LTOM), Manual on among oversight agencies relative to
Examination of Local Treasury Develop an automated database
expenditure management
Operations (MELTO), and system on revenue collections and
Assessment Examination/ Implement local treasurer’s performance expenditure management
Evaluation Manual (AEEM) rating standard along with a competency
Link databases among revenue offices
build-up programs
Formulate guidelines on awards and among LGUs (Province and
and incentives for increased Implement innovative revenue collection Municipalities) and the OAs (including
local source revenue collections strategies including tracking performance BIR)
of actual revenue collections of LGUs
Mandate creation of more Develop casebooks on best practices
strategically located PS depots Develop standard templates for cash flow of LGUs with good collection
for ease of accessibility forecasting strategies
The development of reliable and predictable budgets requires increased revenue generation and sound
expenditure management, complemented by full disclosure of and access to financial information.
The strategies for increasing revenue generation by LGUs include the following:
1. Development and roll-out of a standard revenue forecasting tool;
2. Enhancement and roll-out of revenue generation tools by the DOF-BLGF;
3. Issuance by OAs and adoption by LGUs of guidelines on the updating of Local Revenue Codes
and Schedule of Market Values;
4. Implementation of the Local Treasurers’ Performance Rating System; and
5. Formulation of policies / guidelines on awards / incentives for increased local revenue generation.
To ensure that funds will be used as intended in an efficient and sustainable manner, the adoption of
the Medium Term Expenditure Framework shall be considered and included in the enhancement of
local budget policies and tools (e.g., BOM). Tools for expenditure forecasting and cash flow forecasting
shall be developed and rolled-out to the LGUs.
Procurement improvement measures shall likewise be adopted and implemented. These include:
1. Capacitating DBM ROs and LGUs on the use of the APCPI;
2. Provision of specific training support to LGUs on procurement policies and procedures, including
the preparation of the Annual Procurement Plan (APP); and
3. Establishment of more PS depots to increase LGU access to CSE.
19 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 3: INTEGRATING TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY INTO FINANCIAL AND PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 20
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 3: INTEGRATING TRANSPARENCY AND ACCOUNTABILITY INTO FINANCIAL AND PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
• Public access to
database via portal
on DILG website
21 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
Convergence
Issuance to be presented and discussed at
CCD
Draft “Handbook on CSO Participation in Management System
the Budget Process“ to be presented and Develop a “laymanized” system of
discussed at CCD reporting under the FDP
Structure
Establishment and
maintenance of national
database of accredited
CSOs participating in
LGU PFM
Knowledge
Learming
Establishment
Policies of database on
good practises
Harmonized policy on CSO of LGUs on CSO
Competencies accreditation participation
RIATs to orient CSOs on the ”Budget “Handbook on CSO Participation in Public access
Operations Manual” for LGUs to database via
the Budget Process” designed for portal on DILG
TOT of RIATs to orient LGUS and use by both CSOs and LGUs. website
CSOs on the “Handbook on CSO
Participation in the Budget Process” Policy on the role of CSOs in
enforcing the FDP
RIATs to orient LGUs and CSOs on
the “Handbook on CSO Participation
in the Budget Process”
Support to LGUs to intensify
awareness of the policy on CSO
participation and the importance of
its implementation
To complement strategies for increasing disclosure of and access to financial information, full and
genuine CSO participation in the planning and budget processes shall be nurtured as the primary
means of integrating transparency and accountability into financial and performance management.
2. Issuance and roll-out of the Handbook on CSO Participation in the Budget Process;
3. Capacity Development support to both CSOs and LGUs on the budget process and the extent
of CSO participation in the same;
4. IEC activities for CSOs and LGUs on the benefits of citizens’ participation in local governance;
and
5. Issuance of a policy on the role of CSOs in enforcing the FDP of the DILG.
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 22
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
2022
• Timely bank reconciliation
23 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 4: HOLDING MANAGERS TO ACCOUNT
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 24
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 4: HOLDING MANAGERS TO ACCOUNT
2019
• IAU / IAS operationalized
2022
• IAU / IAS operationalized
Convergence
• Present and discuss
draft Internal Audit
Manual at the CCD
25 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 4: HOLDING MANAGERS TO ACCOUNT
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 26
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 4: HOLDING MANAGERS TO ACCOUNT
Competency /
People
• Cascade the rules
and regulations
on settlement of
COA disallowances
to all critical
stakeholders in the
LGU
X. UACS FOR LGUs 1. Establish UACS Policy 2016 Delay in policy Policy dialogue
for LGUs • Issue policy on • UACS established and rolled-out decision on at CCD level
adoption of UACS adoption of
and/or Chart of 2019 UACS for
Accounts for LGUs • UACS adopted by LGUs LGUs
Convergence 2022
• Present to and • UACS adopted by LGUs
discuss issuance
at CCD
27 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY MATRIX
CLUSTER 4: HOLDING MANAGERS TO ACCOUNT
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 28
Competencies
Coach LCEs and local officials on PFM basics Knowledge and Learning
and accountabilities, particularly on liquidation Conduct regular dialogues amongst
of cash advances local financial officers with Regional
Conduct TOT for the DBM ROS on the Internal Inter-Agency Teams (including COA)
Audit Manual Share information on audit rules and
Capacitate LGUs on the Internal Audit Manual guidelines / processes / procedures
Structure
Establish IAS as
Policy a Unit attached
Systems to the Office of
Issue policy for regular review of the LCE
bank statements and guidelines Strengthen M & E mechanisms
on reporting discovery of irregular on grant and liquidation of cash
transactions advances
Review and harmonize OA reporting Reengineer PFM systems at both the
requirements national and local level and harmonize Convergence
Develop and issue Internal Audit financial reporting requirements of OAs and
development partners including linking of Present to
Manual for the LGUs
financial databases and discuss
Issue policy on adoption of UACS / issuance on
Chart of Accounts for LGUs Develop mechanisms to ensure stakeholders’ IAS at CCD
access to timely, accurate and external audit
Issue policy institutionalizing budget findings Present and
performance monitoring through the discuss Draft
BOM Update the Budget Accountability Internal Audit
portion of the BOM to integrate Manual at the
the framework and mechanics CCD
for budget performance
monitoring
Cognizant that an excellent accounting system becomes ineffectual if internal controls are not in
place, the strengthening of internal and external audits are likewise primary policy agenda in the
Roadmap. To operationalize these policy agenda, the following strategies are provided:
29 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
2.3 PRIORITIZING THE
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGIES
With the state of LGU PFM reflected by the PFMAT results, the proposed implementation strategies
for the Roadmap will have to be prioritized (what is most important) and sequenced (in what order
should priorities be implemented) in terms of the potential contribution of each strategy to improving
PFMAT ratings for each of the seven (7) critical dimensions.
Having identified the required activities, tasks should be categorized into long-term (2022), medium-
term (2019), and short-term (2016).
The next step is to identify what is feasible and will have the highest value in terms of visible impact
in the shortest time.
1. Do we have the resources to implement and sustain in terms of people, time and expertise?
Not everything can be done at once as this will result in administrative overload. Strategic
choices, therefore, have to be made.
2. In what order do actions need to be taken? What should we do first, second, third and so
forth?
3. What are the dependencies in our clusters? and
4. What is the local capacity to absorb change? If the pace of a particular activity is a
function of capacity development how long will the proposed activity take before it yields
visible benefits? What is technically most important may not be tactically feasible.
The prioritization and sequencing will have to balance technical with tactical considerations. The
following will therefore have to be taken into weight:
• Technical aspects – what needs to be done to improve PFM, as established in terms of core
LGU PFM issues presented in the Implementation Strategy and the details as to the degree
of importance to potential change in PFMAT ratings.
• Political demand – what is wanted and can be supported by key stakeholders most notably
Local Chief Executives and Oversight Agencies Regional Offices.
IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 30
DEPARTMENT OF BUDGET AND MANAGEMENT
31 IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY
LGU PFM 2 PROJECT ORGANIZATION
PROJECT STEERING COMMITTEE
Administrative Assistant
Mr. Lemuel Dizon
Administrative Assistant
Ms. Ma. Gina C. Manuel IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY 32
The roadmap includes several strategies for improving the competency and management systems of LGUs in handling PFM reforms. These strategies encompass capacity development interventions, such as providing training and technical assistance to LGUs on procurement policies. Additional initiatives include enhancing revenue forecasting and expenditure management capabilities, updating local budget policies and tools to incorporate the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF), and streamlining reporting processes under the FDP. Furthermore, it involves cascading knowledge through RIATs, strengthening convergence mechanisms, and institutionalizing the use of management systems like PFMAT for continuous PFM assessments .
Competency development programs improve PFM implementation by equipping LGU staff with the necessary skills and knowledge to manage financial tasks effectively. These programs focus on various competencies, such as planning, budgeting, and evaluation, ensuring that staff are proficient in their duties. Additionally, they cover change management and technical competencies crucial for adapting to and implementing reforms, ultimately leading to more efficient and effective governance .
The roadmap addresses the need for improved competency among staff involved in PFM reforms by providing comprehensive training programs and capacity development interventions. It deploys the System on Competency Assessment for Local Governments (SCALOG) to identify gaps in technical and managerial skills, enabling targeted capacity building. Additionally, enhanced manuals and guidelines are provided to staff, focusing on key areas such as budgeting, procurement, and financial management. This systematic approach ensures that staff are knowledgeable, motivated, and proficient in handling their PFM responsibilities .
Challenges in implementing PFM reforms in LGUs include resistance issues, lack of coordination among Oversight Agencies (OAs), and insufficient technical capacity among personnel. These challenges can be addressed through capacity development interventions, harmonizing the oversight agencies' support, and capacitating stakeholders on change management . Moreover, building consensus on coordination structures and issuing executive directives can facilitate smoother implementation .
The challenges in implementing PFM reforms include resistance from OAs and LGUs due to structural changes, delays in technology roll-outs, and inadequate harmonization of oversight agency guidelines. There is also skepticism towards convergence efforts given conflicting assignments of OAs. Addressing these challenges through strategic coordination, establishment of inter-agency teams, and continuous capacity building is expected to lead to improved fiscal accountability, enhanced transparency, and streamlined governance processes at local levels. Ultimately, successful reform implementation would institutionalize best practices across all levels of government, aligning with national policy priorities .
The institutionalization of the PFMAT (Public Financial Management Assessment Tool) within LGUs supports better financial management by providing a standardized method for monitoring adherence to sound PFM practices. This tool helps generate data for PFMIP (Public Financial Management Improvement Plans) preparation and decision-making, ensuring that LGUs follow a structured approach to budgeting and planning, thereby enhancing their financial accountability and policy-based budgeting .
The identified risks in the LGU PFM reform include resistance issues, financial risks, development risks, and reputation risks. Mitigation strategies involve strengthening coordination among oversight agencies, institutionalizing the use of the PFMAT for LGU adherence checks, and ensuring timely release of information to CSOs to enhance transparency. These strategies are coupled with regular dialogues among OAs and the enhancement of software tools for PFM assessments. Additional measures include roll-out support for the implementation of policies and the establishment of guidelines to sustain stakeholder confidence in LGU PFM processes .
Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) play a crucial role in the LGU budget process by advocating for transparency, accountability, and community priorities. Their participation is ensured by standardizing the accreditation process, providing orientation on the budget operations manual, and establishing a laymanized system of information disclosure. Additionally, LGUs support CSOs by developing handbooks and databases of good practices, thus enhancing their capacity to engage constructively in the budget process .
Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) are pivotal in the LGU PFM reform process, providing oversight and ensuring transparency and accountability. The roadmap facilitates their participation by adopting measures to standardize CSO accreditation and mandating their inclusion in budget processes through facilitated orientation using a specifically designed handbook. Policies are issued to compel LGUs to comply with CSO integration, and databases of CSOs are maintained for transparency. The roadmap also establishes IEC campaigns to demonstrate the value of CSO participation, aiming for their institutionalized involvement in budgetary processes by 2022 .
Aligning LGU budget planning with policy priorities requires structural changes like creating inter-agency teams for enhanced coordination and procedural updates such as adopting the Medium Term Expenditure Framework (MTEF). Revisions to the Budget Operations Manual and the development of new forecasting tools for expenditure and cash flow are essential. Harmonizing planning processes across different agencies and emphasizing transparency through standardized reporting mechanisms also ensure that policies are well integrated into budget planning .