Sheet1

First name ID number Eval Marks Asgn

PRANJAL CHOUBEY 2017A7PS0034G 134001 9 10
ISHAN SINGH 2017A7PS0948G 111410 8 10
MADHULIKA BALAKUMAR 2017B1A70527G 334555 25 60
SHENDE VALLARI VIVEK 2017B1A70699G 555155 26 60
RIYA DHAR 2017B1A70753G 334345 22 40
NAIK SHOUNAK SHESHADRI 2017B1A70835G 344555 27 50
HARSHITHA REDDY VONTELA 2017B1A70837G 334555 25 60
ADARSH ANAND 2017B2A70090G 453503 20 30
SANYUKTA JAIN 2017B2A70145G 155223 18 30
ABHINAV BASU 2017B2A70672G 543445 26 60
NRUPESH SURYA U 2017B2A70767G 234002 11 25
ARJUN AGARWAL 2017B3A70285G 534535 25 60
SHIVANG GUPTA 2017B3A70331G 535434 24 45
DHVANIL MILAN SANGHVI 2017B3A70379G 255013 17 25
YASH BAGRA 2017B3A70469G 534424 22 40
MUDIT AGARWAL 2017B3A70483G 553313 20 30
ANMOL AGARWAL 2017B3A70489G 355553 26 40
HARSHIT PRUTHI 2017B3A70493G 555555 30 60
AROHI DUREJA 2017B3A70531G 534535 25 60
HARSHIT SHAH 2017B3A70557G 555555 30 60
ISHA MAHESH AMONCAR 2017B3A70560G 553055 23 45
SAKSHAM AGRAWAL 2017B3A70581G 223333 16 25
ARSHIKA LALAN 2017B3A70620G 223333 16 25
VIDIT LOHIA 2017B3A70632G 555555 30 60
NAKHATE ANAND THEERTHA 2017B3A70660G 244323 18 30
SAMRUDDHI SHAILESH BOTHARA 2017B3A70766G 223333 16 25
B SUHAS SHANBHOGUE 2017B3A70769G 555555 30 60
ASADALI HAZARIWALA 2017B3A70774G 455555 29 60
PRIYA PARESH DESHPANDE 2017B3A70776G 355554 27 50
YAMINI JHAWAR 2017B3A70785G 253553 25 50
KSHITIJ ABHAY KAKADE 2017B3A71003G 555155 26 60
BADIYANI SAGAR ASHWIN 2017B3A71006G 553504 22 30
KARTIKEY HARIVANSH PANDEY 2017B3A71007G 255551 23 30
SARTHAK DWIVEDI 2017B3A71010G 255054 17 40
KOTHARI HARDIK DARSHAK 2017B3A71011G 333403 16 20
JAUHAR DHRUV AJOY 2017B4A70035G 555333 24 55
GUDE MANASI VISHAL 2017B4A70231G 523403 17 30
SHREYA MALLAMPALLI 2017B4A70313G 334553 23 40
PADMANABHAN MURLI 2017B4A70403G 544504 22 30
SHAH RAHIL HIMANSHU 2017B4A70446G 555555 30 30
VITTHAL P YELLAMBALSE 2017B4A70454G 253553 23 40
VINAYAK SHUKLA 2017B4A70465G 135302 14 20
KUNWAR RANANJAY SINGH 2017B4A70504G 453055 22 45
MAYANK CHATURVEDI 2017B4A70548G 234453 23 40
RAJAT GOYAL 2017B4A70570G 052052 14 15
AMANDEEP 2017B4A70576G 105003 9 25
CHETAN KHANNA 2017B4A70591G 003441 12 7
HARSHAVARDHAN K 2017B4A70601G 115502 14 20

Page 1
 Sheet1

ABHYUDAY SINGH 2017B4A70645G 000000 0 0

M S NANDAN 2017B4A70657G 253553 23 40
MOITRISH MAJUMDAR 2017B4A70750G 253553 23 40
RITIK NAWAL 2017B4A70886G 123112 10 20
ABHEESHT SHARMA 2017B4A71014G 545503 22 30
SHAH BHAVYA AMIT 2017B4A71022G 333403 16 20
BEDARKAR KIMAYA SUNIL 2017B4A71026G 415003 13 30
HARSHVARDHAN WALIA 2017B4A71027G 234553 22 40
RITHVIK TERENCE DSOUZA 2017B5A70200G 133502 13 30
SANJAY KRISHNAN 2017B5A70236G 553555 28 60
SHREESH PRASANNA KULKARNI 2017B5A70279G 333003 12 15
NISAL SHREYAS SHAILESH 2017B5A70310G 234233 17 40
DHEER MANISH JAIN 2017B5A70573G 453003 15 30
HEDAOO SHARVARI MANOJ 2017B5A70593G 553004 17 40
NIKHIL PRATAP SINGH BISHT 2017B5A70610G 253003 13 30
VANSHIKA KAPOOR 2017B5A70624G 544003 16 30
VAIBHAV CHAUDHARI 2017B5A70834G 553003 16 30
MURARKA UTSAV ANIL 2017B5A70854G 253003 13 30
RAHUL SAXENA 2017B5A71032G 123112 10 25
SHIVANSH JAIN 2018A7PS0013G 553223 20 40
NIKHIL SHISHODIA 2018A7PS0038G 553545 27 60
JAISWAL SARTHAK RAJESH 2018A7PS0087G 212013 9 20
AMAN GUPTA 2018A7PS0089G 033333 15 15
GARIMA SHARMA 2018A7PS0090G 455554 28 60
PULKIT PURWAR 2018A7PS0091G 133002 9 25
SHUBH PRAGNESH SHAH 2018A7PS0092G 353003 14 40
MANE DIGVIJAYSINH SUJAYSINH 2018A7PS0093G 135503 17 30
WANDAN TIBREWAL 2018A7PS0094G 133322 14 20
DHRUV NAGPAL 2018A7PS0095G 431002 10 20
AADETYA JAISWAL 2018A7PS0096G 555555 30 60
SHREYANSH JOSHI 2018A7PS0097G 355111 16 25
ADITYA SURAJ KRISHNAN 2018A7PS0098G 555133 22 50
PRANAV GAUR 2018A7PS0099G 455304 21 35
S GOWTHAM KRISHNA 2018A7PS0100G 353003 14 30
S SETHURAM 2018A7PS0101G 554055 24 55
MANAV JAIN 2018A7PS0102G 555555 30 60
RISHI JAIN 2018A7PS0103G 033431 14 10
ABHINAV SHANKAR 2018A7PS0105G 523003 13 25
BODDUPALLI NIKHIL 2018A7PS0106G 555005 20 60
KIRTIKAR ATHARV ASHISH 2018A7PS0107G 133412 14 15
PATEL RISHABH SUNIL 2018A7PS0108G 454504 22 40
SHAH VISHWA VIPULKUMAR 2018A7PS0109G 243453 21 35
HETH JAGDIP SHETH 2018A7PS0110G 455113 19 40
SHETTY KARAN KAVITA 2018A7PS0111G 353003 14 30
BHAVYAM KAMAL 2018A7PS0112G 555555 30 60
NANDISH HITENDRA CHHEDA 2018A7PS0113G 355054 22 50
MAYANK SHEORAN 2018A7PS0114G 455555 29 60
PRABHUTVA AGRAWAL 2018A7PS0115G 145553 23 40
WANI SUSMIT NITIN 2018A7PS0116G 555004 19 40

Page 2
 Sheet1

ADITYA MISHRA 2018A7PS0117G 213453 18 30

GONDHALEKAR KEYUR BHALCHANDRA 2018A7PS0118G 133412 14 15
AMAN AZIZ 2018A7PS0119G 555133 22 50
SHIVAM CHANDAK 2018A7PS0120G 123002 8 10
ROHAN AGARWAL 2018A7PS0123G 435513 21 45
AMEYA LAAD 2018A7PS0124G 355054 22 50
MUDIT AGRAWAL 2018A7PS0125G 134253 18 40
YASH KUMAR 2018A7PS0126G 124503 15 25
SHASHANK MITTAL 2018A7PS0127G 133002 9 25
PRATIK SANJAY BHIRUD 2018A7PS0128G 345453 24 40
DEVANSH AGGARWAL 2018A7PS0131G 354053 20 40
PARMESH KUMAR MATHUR 2018A7PS0133G 333113 14 30
JASHANPREET SINGH 2018A7PS0134G 455003 17 40
VIDISHA RAMA HEGDE 2018A7PS0135G 553003 16 30
APOORV SINGH 2018A7PS0136G 332113 13 20
AANAND S J 2018A7PS0139G 353003 14 30
ROCHISHNU BANERJEE 2018A7PS0140G 353054 20 50
SUBHJEET PATI 2018A7PS0141G 131001 6 10
MANAS MINNOOR 2018A7PS0142G 553003 16 30
PRATIK KUMAR BEHERA 2018A7PS0143G 114502 13 20
ROHAN AGARWAL 2018A7PS0144G 435513 21 45
MRADUL BHATNAGAR 2018A7PS0146G 555555 30 60
ROHITAAS BERI 2018A7PS0147G 304003 10 40
MEGH K PATEL 2018A7PS0148G 444444 24 50
ARCHISH DE 2018A7PS0149G 153053 12 40
YASH NARANG 2018A7PS0150G 245554 25 40
VYBHAV JAYASANKAR 2018A7PS0152G 533003 14 30
PIYUSH MAHESHWARI 2018A7PS0153G 355354 25 50
SIVA SHANKAR MANGIPUDI 2018A7PS0154G 203002 7 20
SOUMIK DHUA 2018A7PS0155G 234003 12 30
SATYANSH SINGH 2018A7PS0156G 253003 13 30
WANDHEKAR SAURABH SANJAY 2018A7PS0157G 553203 18 30
SHAH MEET KETAN 2018A7PS0158G 555354 27 40
ARKA NAYAK 2018A7PS0159G 234002 11 15
PRASHANTH SREENIVASAN 2018A7PS0160G 533334 21 30
AADITYA SINGH 2018A7PS0161G 554005 19 40
MHALGI NINAD SUNIL 2018A7PS0162G 533003 14 30
ARPIT RAY 2018A7PS0163G 005502 12 15
MANAV P MEHTA 2018A7PS0164G 133503 15 30
KARTIK KUMAR 2018A7PS0165G 55355 28 57
PRAVEEN SRIDHAR 2018A7PS0166G 333023 14 25
PATIL SMITESH VIPIN 2018A7PS0167G 455113 19 40
S SAI VINEET 2018A7PS0168G 444444 24 50
DESAI PRAKRUT SHETALBHAI 2018A7PS0169G 553304 20 40
KULKARNI SHREYA GHANSHAM 2018A7PS0171G 555353 26 40
ABICHAL GHOSH 2018A7PS0172G 553554 27 50
NITISH SILSWAL 2018A7PS0173G 253403 17 30
PARV BUDHIRAJA 2018A7PS0174G 433454 23 50
SOMESH KUMAR SINGH 2018A7PS0175G 154554 24 50

Page 3
 Sheet1

PATADE ADVAIT SUDHIR 2018A7PS0176G 203002 7 20

SWAPNIL AHLAWAT 2018A7PS0178G 355203 18 30
ASHUTOSH SHARMA 2018A7PS0179G 145553 23 40
PRATEEK GOYAL 2018A7PS0181G 435513 21 45
ARJUN BAJPAI 2018A7PS0182G 534004 16 50
BHATT APOORVKUMAR ATULKUMAR 2018A7PS0183G 053402 13 15
DIVYANSH SINGHAL 2018A7PS0184G 255054 21 45
ALAN TOM JOSE 2018A7PS0187G 555055 25 60
JINIT SHAH 2018A7PS0188G 453004 16 40
RISHIT MAYUR PATEL 2018A7PS0189G 453003 15 30
PREEYAM SAHU 2018A7PS0191G 33003 9 10
ROHIT GARG 2018A7PS0193G 134022 12 25
ABHIGYAN UTSAV 2018A7PS0194G 131001 6 10
TANISHQ NANDAN 2018A7PS0195G 225053 17 30
AMIT CHAUHAN 2018A7PS0196G 555055 25 60
AALOK SINGH 2018A7PS0198G 123443 17 40
SIDDHARTH SHARMA 2018A7PS0199G 453454 25 50
AMAN PATEL 2018A7PS0200G 153002 11 25
VOOKA RAM KISHAN 2018A7PS0201G 355554 27 55
AGRAWAL TANISH RAJESHKUMAR 2018A7PS0202G 453004 16 40
RAMIT SHIVANSH 2018A7PS0204G 115001 8 20
DIVYAM BANKIMKUMAR SHAH 2018A7PS0205G 444444 24 50
ROHIT MITRA 2018A7PS0206G 053003 11 20
CHANDWANI NAMIT DEVENDRA 2018A7PS0207G 504054 18 40
MEGHAVI GUPTA 2018A7PS0208G 014002 7 10
VEDANT RAMESH CHAVDA 2018A7PS0209G 433504 19 40
ANJUM KATARIA 2018A7PS0210G 535003 16 35
PRANJAL SRIVASTAVA 2018A7PS0211G 234002 11 15
AETURI NAGA PAVAN KALYAN REDDY 2018A7PS0212G 355554 27 55
ABHIJEET JAIN 2018A7PS0213G 123502 13 15
RANKA SHARANYA MILIND 2018A7PS0215G 555555 30 60
ANIRUDH NAGARAJ 2018A7PS0216G 235003 13 30
PIYUSH RANJAN DEB 2018A7PS0217G NA 0 0
PARTH AGRAWAL 2018A7PS0218G 225053 17 30
NITIN K 2018A7PS0219G 554055 24 55
ATISHAY JAIN 2018A7PS0220G 13 25
CHALLA CHANDRASEKHARA SAI GOPAL 2018A7PS0221G NA 0 0
SUMIT KUMAR 2018A7PS0223G 234002 11 15
VISHISHT AGARWAL 2018A7PS0224G 555053 23 30
CHETAN GUPTA 2018A7PS0225G 133002 9 25
SAVIO JOMTON 2018A7PS0227G 555555 30 60
ATHARVA TRIVEDI 2018A7PS0228G 134112 12 20
PIMPARKAR PARTH AJAY 2018A7PS0229G 245053 19 30
JASKARAN SINGH BHATIA 2018A7PS0230G 123003 9 30
RATHI PARAG SHYAMSUNDAR 2018A7PS0231G 552553 25 50
MAHAK KOTHARI 2018A7PS0232G 455054 21 45
NILESH KUMAR GUPTA 2018A7PS0233G 115553 20 40
NACHIKET AGRAWAL 2018A7PS0235G 453004 16 40
SARTHAK AJMERA 2018A7PS0236G 555033 21 40

Page 4
 Sheet1

SUGAM AGRAWAL 2018A7PS0237G 255054 21 45

MALI SHREYAS SHANKAR 2018A7PS0239G 534054 21 50
DEVANSHU SHAH 2018A7PS0240G 234444 21 40
ISHANT 2018A7PS0241G 355053 21 30
NISHANT SINGH 2018A7PS0242G 253033 16 30
ADITYA JAIN 2018A7PS0243G 245053 19 30
SHAH KUSHAL SNEHAL 2018A7PS0254G 225053 17 30
SANYA GARG 2018A7PS0261G 254554 25 50
SIDDHARTH S 2018A7PS0265G 554055 24 55
ARYAMAN SARMAH 2018A7PS0325G 253033 16 30
ABHINAV LALWANI 2018A7PS0352G 555555 30 60
MAYANK MITTAL 2018A7PS0375G 454504 22 40
ADARSH NANDANWAR 2018A7PS0396G 325555 25 60
[Link] 2018A7PS0413G 253033 16 30
SAUBHAGYA SHUKLA 2018A7PS0535G 123132 12 15
PHADNIS ATHARVA SHEKHAR 2018A7PS0541G 333333 18 30
SHUBHAM DALVI 2018A7PS0565G 133033 13 30
NUPUR FUNKWAL 2018A7PS0624G 453454 25 50
SOHAM SACHIN SARPOTDAR 2018A7PS0630G 355533 24 45
AJAY JAMES ALEX 2018A7PS0633G 555455 29 60
ARAV BHARADWAJ 2018A7PS0637G 123502 13 15
NIKHIL JINDAL 2018A7PS0664G 033431 14 10
PRANAV PATERIYA 2018A7PS0686G 553003 16 40
VISHNUBHOTLA SHANMUKHA ADITYA 2018A7PS0688G 254005 16 30
MUNAGA SAI VENKATESH PRASAD 2018A7PS0717G 2355004 19 30
ASEEM JUNEJA 2018A7PS0726G 145003 13 30
AAYUSH MATHUR 2018A7PS0729G 245553 24 40
M V SHASHANK 2018A7PS0734G 355554 27 55
AVDHOOT NITIN BHANDARE 2018A7PS0763G 053003 11 20
YASHU BHATNAGAR 2018A7PS0789G 153002 11 15
SATASIYA AKASH JAYANTIBHAI 2018A7PS0804G 145553 23 40
ADITYA BHANDARI 2018A7PS0805G 455304 21 35
ROHAN KUMAR 2018A7PS1013G 453503 20 40
MILI DILIP DOSHI 2018A7PS1014G 455054 23 50
VIVEK ARORA 2018A7PS1016G 553004 17 40
ISHA SETHI 2018A7PS1017G 254553 24 50
VISHAL AMBER REVANUR 2018A7PS1018G 153002 11 20
INDRAJITT VALSARAJ 2018A7PS1019G 355143 21 40
VAIBHAV KAMATKAR ROUDURI 2018A7PS1020G 333333 18 30
ATHARV YOGESHWAR SONWANE 2018A7PS1021G 355053 21 40
SHREYAS SARANGI 2018A7PS1023G 113002 7 10

ADITYA KRISHNA SANGINENI 2018A7PS1024G NA 0 0

Max 30 60
Average 18.71 36.28
Min 6 10

Page 5
 Sheet1

Comments
Procedural, brute force programming in javascript or java... submitted C++ code. The task at hand not at all addressed. Not m
is in your team
Confused or not, is unclear.
and inconsistent. The two report
Also Choubey Ishan contradictory T3group,
Singh alone or answers.
what’s the trick?
Fine
Excellent except confusion over Q17
Two implementations or integrated design? Some confusion
The meat is in the functions and not the data type definition. In this, you must have been modular, and I give credit for that.
Fine
more procedural modular than OO .
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Good design and refinement of the design later. Truly OO approach.
No OO approach anywhere. Just procedural, not even modular.
Very good design and readable code.
Good modular design and clarity about it. I didn’t like the non-parametrized functions. The state is just one “global” state.
Purely procedural design, no modularity.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural. Q17,19 confusion. Basic state type and container should be independently reviewed. But here the design m
Mixed with procedural approach.
Very good design and readable code.
Very good design and readable code.
Very good design and readable code.
Okay procedural.
Bad procedural.
Bad procedural.
Very good design and readable code.
Purely procedural design, no modularity.
Bad procedural.
One of the best designs. Exhibits understanding of all the paradigms and the task at hand, the right choices. The answers to t
Mixed with procedural approach. Bur the use of OO design is fine.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Procedural and modular, that’s all.
Excellent except confusion over Q17
Okay procedural.
State type not depicted. Apparently OO. But the search method submitted looks more assignment based procedural model. A
Procedural modular in Python, OO is only an outer form, no design. Functional is only that map which is a container.
Mixed with procedural approach. The particular application becomes a method of your state type, which is bad design in even
More procedural than modular or OO. But made a good final product.
Okay procedural.
More procedural modular than OO.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural.
more procedural modular than OO .
More procedural than modular or OO; doesn’t seem functional at all.
Pure procedural, okay coding.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural. And not at all functional. The assertion in the comments in your code
is wrong on several
Functional? counts.
It’s almost And
purely recursion does
procedureal, even not make your
modularity design functional. All your methods are non parametric. That m
is little.
Almost procedural, nothing more. Even the data structure for the state contains two states, with the parent (board, not a link) c
Pure procedural programming in Python. Not even modular. Most of the procedures are also like nonparametric macros. Even
One of the worst designs. Putting some functions in different files does not make the design modular!

Page 6
 Sheet1

Nothing worthy of evaluation. Actually, without designing a state type you show a driver program that is like cheating.
more procedural modular than OO .
more procedural modular than OO .
More procedural than modular or OO.
Okay procedural.
Mixed with procedural approach. The particular application becomes a method of your state type, which is bad design in even
Very very confused. Data structure design, driver program, modules, functions, all mixed. Your state struct is actually a game
carefully see (and
Using a canon almost
to swat build
a fly, andand run)a the
that’s badentire code
idea in databefore I could
structure detect what is what in the design. Reporting here is also
design.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional.
Very good design and readable code.
Purely procedural design, no modularity. Ultimately you don’t design a data structure at all. Why certain procedures are there,
State type not depicted. Seems almost purely procedural.
more procedural modular than OO .
Okay procedural.
More procedural modular than OO or functional. Assignment based computation.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural.
More procedural modular than OO or functional. Assignment based computation.
More procedural than modular or OO.
Okay procedural.
State type not depicted. Apparently OO. But the dfs driver looks more assignment based procedural model. Also in your answ
Modularity taken to such an extreme that it loses any structure, and almost every function is a module. And then your claim is
design. Shows
State type extreme confusion.
not depicted. Seems purelt procedural. Also screenshots of a run not available, so don’t know if it works.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO.
Procedural only; but in that too, your main driver will only take one move paths only, and when all possibilities from the initial s
uniform
Very goodprobability for the
design and random
readable tile generation, this is not probable.) This was not what was sought, and your data structure
code.
Just procedural design, little modularity.
Good OO design. The procedural driver part is in fact not well done, redundancy and unnecessary complication is there. You
Somewhat OO, but only for a type. Some assignment based procedural tasks at the driver level mixed into the type.
more procedural modular than OO .
Fine procedural modular. You exhibit consistency and rigour and understanding of the paradigm you chose.
Fine procedural modular. You exhibit consistency and rigour and understanding of the paradigm you chose.
You don’t know what’s procedural or OO or functional! Other than cin cout, you don’t use any ++ in C++ at all! And yet use ‘sy
want any emotional
True OO. [Link] return a bool? Anyway that’s a side issue.
But why move
Very good design and readable code. Answers to repetition avoidance and containers are wrong, inconsistent.
Almost procedural, nothing more. They have classes only because the language is Java. Otherwise, there is neither encapsul
and
Mixedflags
withwould be equally
procedural good.
approach.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural. Plus modular. Nothing functional here.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Procedural and modular, that’s all.
OO functional fine
Not much functional
Mixed with procedural approach. I guess because your focus remained on the application part. Commenting out GUI part doe
More procedural than modular or OO. Using available libraries and modules does not make your design like theirs.
Okay procedural.

Page 7
 Sheet1

A lot more procedural than the declared goal.

Almost procedural, nothing more. They have classes only because the language is Java. Otherwise, there is neither encapsul
and
Goodflags
OO would
[Link]
equally good. driver part is in fact not well done, redundancy and unnecessary complication is there. You
procedural
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO. There is no need for the state type in the main function, because half the
Mixed with procedural approach.
Not much functional
Appears procedural more. OO design should show up at the top level. It doesn’t.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural.
More procedural than modular or OO.
State type not depicted. Apparently OO. But the dfs driver looks more assignment based procedural model. Also in your answ
Okay procedural.
More procedural than modular.
You did exactly what people were saying they had done on 20 Nov, and didn’t change anything, during the extra time taken. T
Good modularity but not OO or functional
Pure procedural and dirty coding. The claim of functional is meaningless.
Okay procedural.
haphazard procedural. Not mpdular.
Mixed with procedural approach. Why are there submissions by Rohan Agarwal separately without mentioning the team?
Okay procedural.
A lot more procedural than the declared goal.
The effort is sincere and development rigorous. But mixed understanding of different concepts is your main handicap. The doc
changes during the
More procedural development
modular than OOfrom your answers to the quizzes.
or functional.
More procedural than modular or OO; doesn’t seem functional at all.
Mixed the state type with the application.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO. Functional? You don’t understand that at all.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural.
Mixed with procedural approach. The driver code has an apparently unending loop. The methods do overlapping work.
Purely procedural design, no modularity.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural.
Pure procedural and dirty coding.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Very good design and readable code.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Mixed with procedural approach.
No state data type definition given. Looks like okay, OO.
Okay procedural.
Okay procedural. Your idea of aggregate needs revision.
Okay procedural.
more procedural modular than OO .
OO design is there, but still it is called modular, not much OO in terms of reusability.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.

Page 8
 Sheet1

Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO. Functional? You don’t understand that at all.
Trite, and more procedural – using std templates doesn’t make the design automatically OO
More procedural than modular or OO. Using available libraries and modules does not make your design like theirs.
Mixed with procedural approach. Why are there submissions by Rohan Agarwal separately without mentioning the team?
Very good design and readable code.
Pure procedural and dirty coding.
Procedural and modular, that’s all.
Good, you used the true power of the paradigm and the language you chose.
more procedural modular than OO .
Somwhat OO in the state type; but the mixing of the driver with the game and the aggregate container is an eyesore... and th
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional. And it seems it is not even working cod
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO. Functional? You don’t understand that at all.
Pure procedural and dirty coding. The claim of functional is meaningless.
more procedural modular than OO .
Very good design and readable code. The choices and consistency with them is commendable. One of the best.
More procedural modular than OO or functional.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional.
Mixed with procedural approach.
more procedural modular than OO .
One of the worst designs. Instead of a state type, a player class is made, and this specific application is made in a purely proc
The effort is sincere and development rigorous. But mixed understanding of different concepts is your main handicap. The doc
changes
Functional? during the development
It’s almost from youreven
purely procedureal, answers to the quizzes.
modularity is little.
Okay procedural.
Bad procedural. At times nonparametric functions alter the global state of the game, and at times they take the board as the p
Mixed with procedural approach.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Mixed with procedural approach. The driver code has an apparently unending loop. The methods do overlapping work.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Why is the Game class a subclass of game_logic? Apparently no relation or relevance. The design thinking is quite hodgepod
Very good design and readable code.
More procedural modular than OO.
ABANDONED ATTEMPT.
more procedural modular than OO .
Fine procedural modular. You exhibit consistency and rigour and understanding of the paradigm you chose.
more procedural modular than OO .
NO ATTEMPT
Mixed with procedural approach. The driver code has an apparently unending loop. The methods do overlapping work.
State type not depicted. Apparently okay procedural.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Very good design and readable code.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO. Functional? You don’t understand that at all.
State type not depicted. Apparently OO. But the search method submitted looks more assignment based procedural model. A
Very little functional. Mostly procedural.
Okay procedural.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO.
more procedural modular than OO .
Good procedural design. Answers to Q17 and Q19 are inconsistent with each other.

Page 9
 Sheet1

Procedural and modular, that’s all.

In the full code sent on mail, I could see the modularity, and encapsulation as well (in the incomplete Q20 answer). Q17 answ
Not much modular.
You did exactly what people were saying they had done on 20 Nov, and didn’t change anything, during the extra time taken. T
more procedural modular than OO .
State type not depicted. Apparently OO. But the search method submitted looks more assignment based procedural model. A
more procedural modular than OO .
Not much functional
Fine procedural modular. You exhibit consistency and rigour and understanding of the paradigm you chose.
more procedural modular than OO .
Very good design and readable code.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Functional is not seen but OO is fine.
more procedural modular than OO .
State type not depicted. Seems almost purely procedural.
Okay procedural.
Almost procedural, nothing more.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Okay procedural.
Very good design and readable code.
Why is the Game class a subclass of game_logic? Apparently no relation or relevance. The design thinking is quite hodgepod
You don’t know what’s procedural or OO or functional! Other than cin cout, you don’t use any ++ in C++ at all! And yet use ‘sy
want any emotional
After comparing withbhel.
others, his design is far better than many others.
Nothing functional.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional.
Just procedural design, little modularity, and no OO and not even remotely functional.
More procedural modular than OO.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Functional? It’s almost purely procedureal, even modularity is little.
Late submission on mail. Proecdural and lightly modular. OO is like salt in the recipe.
More procedural than modular or OO. Using available libraries and modules does not make your design like theirs.
Somewhat OO, but only for a type. Some assignment based procedural tasks at the driver level mixed into the type.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Mixed with procedural approach.
Okay procedural.
more procedural modular than OO .
Pure procedural and simple coding.
Somewhat OO, but really assignment based procedural.
haphazard procedural.
More procedural modular than OO.
Perfunctory answers here. He submitted a C++ program, that has a class containing two 4x4 arrays but again for the moves h
procedural, nor modular, nor OO.
NO ATTEMPT

Page 10
 Sheet1

First name ID number

PRANJAL CH 2017A7PS0034G .
ISHAN SINGH2017A7PS0948G .
MADHULIKA 2017B1A70527G .
SHENDE VALL 2017B1A70699G .
RIYA DHAR 2017B1A70753G .
NAIK SHOUN 2017B1A70835G .
HARSHITHA 2017B1A70837G .
ADARSH ANA2017B2A70090G .
SANYUKTA JA2017B2A70145G .
ABHINAV BAS2017B2A70672G .
NRUPESH SU2017B2A70767G .
ARJUN AGAR2017B3A70285G .
SHIVANG GU 2017B3A70331G .
DHVANIL MIL 2017B3A70379G .
YASH BAGRA2017B3A70469G .
MUDIT AGAR 2017B3A70483G .
ANMOL AGAR2017B3A70489G .
HARSHIT PRU2017B3A70493G .
AROHI DURE 2017B3A70531G .
HARSHIT SH 2017B3A70557G .
ISHA MAHES 2017B3A70560G .
SAKSHAM AG2017B3A70581G .
ARSHIKA LAL2017B3A70620G .
VIDIT LOHIA 2017B3A70632G .
NAKHATE AN2017B3A70660G .
SAMRUDDHI 2017B3A70766G .
B SUHAS SH 2017B3A70769G .
ASADALI HAZ2017B3A70774G .
PRIYA PARE 2017B3A70776G .
YAMINI JHAW2017B3A70785G .
KSHITIJ ABH 2017B3A71003G .
BADIYANI SA 2017B3A71006G .
KARTIKEY HA2017B3A71007G .
SARTHAK DWI 2017B3A71010G .
KOTHARI HAR2017B3A71011G .
JAUHAR DHR2017B4A70035G .
GUDE MANASI 2017B4A70231G .
SHREYA MAL2017B4A70313G .
PADMANABHA 2017B4A70403G .
SHAH RAHIL 2017B4A70446G .
VITTHAL P Y 2017B4A70454G .
VINAYAK SHU2017B4A70465G .
KUNWAR RAN2017B4A70504G .
MAYANK CHA2017B4A70548G .
RAJAT GOYA2017B4A70570G .
AMANDEEP 2017B4A70576G .
CHETAN KHA2017B4A70591G .
HARSHAVARD 2017B4A70601G .

Page 11
 Sheet1

ABHYUDAY S2017B4A70645G .
M S NANDAN 2017B4A70657G .
MOITRISH M 2017B4A70750G .
RITIK NAWAL2017B4A70886G .
ABHEESHT S2017B4A71014G .
SHAH BHAVYA 2017B4A71022G .
BEDARKAR KI2017B4A71026G .
HARSHVARDH 2017B4A71027G .
RITHVIK TER 2017B5A70200G .
SANJAY KRI 2017B5A70236G .
SHREESH PR2017B5A70279G .
NISAL SHREY2017B5A70310G .
DHEER MANIS 2017B5A70573G .
HEDAOO SHA2017B5A70593G .
NIKHIL PRAT 2017B5A70610G .
VANSHIKA K 2017B5A70624G .
VAIBHAV CH 2017B5A70834G .
MURARKA UTS 2017B5A70854G .
RAHUL SAXE2017B5A71032G .
SHIVANSH JA2018A7PS0013G .
NIKHIL SHIS 2018A7PS0038G .
JAISWAL SAR2018A7PS0087G .
AMAN GUPTA2018A7PS0089G .
GARIMA SHA 2018A7PS0090G .
PULKIT PUR 2018A7PS0091G .
SHUBH PRAG2018A7PS0092G .
MANE DIGVIJ2018A7PS0093G .
WANDAN TIB 2018A7PS0094G .
DHRUV NAGP2018A7PS0095G .
AADETYA JAI2018A7PS0096G .
SHREYANSH 2018A7PS0097G .
ADITYA SURA2018A7PS0098G .
PRANAV GAU2018A7PS0099G .
S GOWTHAM 2018A7PS0100G .
S SETHURAM2018A7PS0101G .
MANAV JAIN 2018A7PS0102G .
RISHI JAIN 2018A7PS0103G .
ABHINAV SH 2018A7PS0105G .
BODDUPALLI 2018A7PS0106G .
KIRTIKAR AT 2018A7PS0107G .
PATEL RISHA2018A7PS0108G .
SHAH VISHW2018A7PS0109G .
HETH JAGDIP2018A7PS0110G .
SHETTY KARA 2018A7PS0111G .
BHAVYAM KA2018A7PS0112G .
NANDISH HI 2018A7PS0113G .
MAYANK SHE2018A7PS0114G .
PRABHUTVA 2018A7PS0115G .
WANI SUSMIT2018A7PS0116G .

Page 12
 Sheet1

ADITYA MISH2018A7PS0117G .
GONDHALEKA 2018A7PS0118G .
AMAN AZIZ 2018A7PS0119G .
SHIVAM CHA 2018A7PS0120G .
ROHAN AGAR2018A7PS0123G .
AMEYA LAAD2018A7PS0124G .
MUDIT AGRA 2018A7PS0125G .
YASH KUMAR2018A7PS0126G .
SHASHANK M2018A7PS0127G .
PRATIK SANJ2018A7PS0128G .
DEVANSH AG2018A7PS0131G .
PARMESH KU2018A7PS0133G .
JASHANPREE2018A7PS0134G .
VIDISHA RAM2018A7PS0135G .
APOORV SIN 2018A7PS0136G .
AANAND S J 2018A7PS0139G .
ROCHISHNU 2018A7PS0140G .
SUBHJEET PA2018A7PS0141G .
MANAS MINN2018A7PS0142G .
PRATIK KUM 2018A7PS0143G .
ROHAN AGAR2018A7PS0144G .
MRADUL BHA2018A7PS0146G .
ROHITAAS BE2018A7PS0147G .
MEGH K PATE2018A7PS0148G .
ARCHISH DE 2018A7PS0149G .
YASH NARAN2018A7PS0150G .
VYBHAV JAY 2018A7PS0152G .
PIYUSH MAH 2018A7PS0153G .
SIVA SHANKA2018A7PS0154G .
SOUMIK DHU2018A7PS0155G .
SATYANSH S2018A7PS0156G .
WANDHEKAR2018A7PS0157G .
SHAH MEET 2018A7PS0158G .
ARKA NAYAK2018A7PS0159G .
PRASHANTH 2018A7PS0160G .
AADITYA SIN 2018A7PS0161G .
MHALGI NINA2018A7PS0162G .
ARPIT RAY 2018A7PS0163G .
MANAV P ME 2018A7PS0164G .
KARTIK KUM 2018A7PS0165G .
PRAVEEN SR2018A7PS0166G .
PATIL SMITES2018A7PS0167G .
S SAI VINEET2018A7PS0168G .
DESAI PRAKR2018A7PS0169G .
KULKARNI S 2018A7PS0171G .
ABICHAL GH 2018A7PS0172G .
NITISH SILS 2018A7PS0173G .
PARV BUDHI 2018A7PS0174G .
SOMESH KUM2018A7PS0175G .

Page 13
 Sheet1

PATADE ADVA 2018A7PS0176G .

SWAPNIL AH 2018A7PS0178G .
ASHUTOSH S2018A7PS0179G .
PRATEEK GO2018A7PS0181G .
ARJUN BAJPA2018A7PS0182G .
BHATT APOO2018A7PS0183G .
DIVYANSH SI2018A7PS0184G .
ALAN TOM JO2018A7PS0187G .
JINIT SHAH 2018A7PS0188G .
RISHIT MAYU2018A7PS0189G .
PREEYAM SA2018A7PS0191G .
ROHIT GARG2018A7PS0193G .
ABHIGYAN U 2018A7PS0194G .
TANISHQ NA 2018A7PS0195G .
AMIT CHAUH 2018A7PS0196G .
AALOK SINGH2018A7PS0198G .
SIDDHARTH 2018A7PS0199G .
AMAN PATEL2018A7PS0200G .
VOOKA RAM 2018A7PS0201G .
AGRAWAL TA2018A7PS0202G .
RAMIT SHIVA2018A7PS0204G .
DIVYAM BAN 2018A7PS0205G .
ROHIT MITRA2018A7PS0206G .
CHANDWANI 2018A7PS0207G .
MEGHAVI GU2018A7PS0208G .
VEDANT RAM2018A7PS0209G .
ANJUM KATAR 2018A7PS0210G .
PRANJAL SRI2018A7PS0211G .
AETURI NAGA2018A7PS0212G .
ABHIJEET JAI2018A7PS0213G .
RANKA SHARA 2018A7PS0215G .
ANIRUDH NA 2018A7PS0216G .
PIYUSH RANJ2018A7PS0217G .
PARTH AGRA2018A7PS0218G .
NITIN K 2018A7PS0219G .
ATISHAY JAIN2018A7PS0220G .
CHALLA CHA 2018A7PS0221G .
SUMIT KUMA 2018A7PS0223G .
VISHISHT AG2018A7PS0224G .
CHETAN GUP2018A7PS0225G .
SAVIO JOMT 2018A7PS0227G .
ATHARVA TRI2018A7PS0228G .
PIMPARKAR P2018A7PS0229G .
JASKARAN SI2018A7PS0230G .
RATHI PARA 2018A7PS0231G .
MAHAK KOTH2018A7PS0232G .
NILESH KUM 2018A7PS0233G .
NACHIKET A 2018A7PS0235G .
SARTHAK AJ 2018A7PS0236G .

Page 14
 Sheet1

SUGAM AGR 2018A7PS0237G .

MALI SHREY 2018A7PS0239G .
DEVANSHU S2018A7PS0240G .
ISHANT 2018A7PS0241G .
NISHANT SIN2018A7PS0242G .
ADITYA JAIN 2018A7PS0243G .
SHAH KUSHA2018A7PS0254G .
SANYA GARG2018A7PS0261G .
SIDDHARTH S2018A7PS0265G .
ARYAMAN SA2018A7PS0325G .
ABHINAV LAL2018A7PS0352G .
MAYANK MIT 2018A7PS0375G .
ADARSH NAN2018A7PS0396G .
[Link] 2018A7PS0413G .
SAUBHAGYA 2018A7PS0535G .
PHADNIS ATH2018A7PS0541G .
SHUBHAM DA2018A7PS0565G .
NUPUR FUNK2018A7PS0624G .
SOHAM SACH2018A7PS0630G .
AJAY JAMES 2018A7PS0633G .
ARAV BHARA2018A7PS0637G .
NIKHIL JINDA2018A7PS0664G .
PRANAV PAT2018A7PS0686G .
VISHNUBHOT2018A7PS0688G .
MUNAGA SAI 2018A7PS0717G .
ASEEM JUNE2018A7PS0726G .
AAYUSH MAT2018A7PS0729G .
M V SHASHA 2018A7PS0734G .
AVDHOOT NI 2018A7PS0763G .
YASHU BHAT2018A7PS0789G .
SATASIYA AK2018A7PS0804G .
ADITYA BHAN2018A7PS0805G .
ROHAN KUM2018A7PS1013G .
MILI DILIP DO2018A7PS1014G .
VIVEK AROR2018A7PS1016G .
ISHA SETHI 2018A7PS1017G .
VISHAL AMB 2018A7PS1018G .
INDRAJITT 2018A7PS1019G .
VAIBHAV KA 2018A7PS1020G .
ATHARV YOG2018A7PS1021G .

SHREYAS SA2018A7PS1023G .
ADITYA KRIS 2018A7PS1024G

Page 15