April 23, 2020
From Prof. Fe Becina-.Macalino
Memo To UST Law Section 2D – Negotiable Instruments Subject
THRU CLASS PRESDENT – MS. KRYSTALYNNE AGUILAR
SUBJECT : LAST BATCH OF CASES FOR SUBMISSION PRIOR TO
FINAL EXAM ON MAY 23, 2020
This is the last batch for submission of your case digests and analysis to
be submitted on May 8,2020 together with the April 20 memo on case
digests which was for submission on April 30 , 2020 but I am extending
to May 8, 2020 in compliance with the latest memo of Dean Divina dated
April 21, 2020.
Additional Covered Topics for Final Exam
A. Material Alteration .
NIL ; Sections 124- 125
Case law:
1. PNB vs Court of Appeals , G.R. No. 107508, April 25,1996
2. International Corporate Bank Inc, vs Court of Appeals , GR No. 129910.
September 5, 2006
3. Metrobank and Trust Co vs Cabilzo ,GR No. 154469, December 6, 2006
B, CHECK
NIL ; Sec 185-186
Case law
4. Bataan Cigar & Cigarette Factory vs CA , GR No.93048 March 3, 1994
C. Failure to Make Presentment
NIL : Sections 143-151
Case law :
5.. PNB vs Concepcion Mining Company et al GR No.L-16968 , 30 July
1962
6.. Perla Compna de Seguros Inc, vs Court of Appelas , GR No. 96452,
May 7, 1992
7. Deleon vs RFC , GR No. L-24571 , December 18 , 1970
8. People vs Romero , GR No. 112985 , April 21, 1999
9.. Astro Electronics vs Phil Export , GR No. 136729, Sept 23 , 2003
10. International Corporate Bank vs Gueco , GR No. 141968 Feb 12, 2001
11. PNB vs Benito Seeto, GR No. L-4388, Aug 13,1952
Instructions :
1. For each highlighted topics , state your analysis of the
doctrines laid down by the Supreme Court in the Court’s
application of the particular sections of the Negotiable
Instruments Law to the cases decided. Your case digests and case
analyses will form part of 50 % of your final grade.
2. Submit thru email the case digests and analysis of the following
additional cases decided by the Supreme Court in the following format :
Font : Times New Roman
Font size : 14
Line Spacing : 1.5 spaces
No. pages : Maximum of two (2) pages per case .
3. For submission on MAY 8, 2020 .
4. On May 15, 2020 , I will send to your Class president a taped
video lecture together with an over-all summation of the
course. Included in this lecture is a Reviewer for your Final
Exam to prepare you with the format of questionnaires for
your study.
Stay Safe and pray hard for God’s grace this time .
Thank you, Atty. Fe