Spencer Sporting Goods Case
Spencer Sporting Goods Case
Exhibit 2
Income Statements
(000 omitted)
Cash $ 36 $ 33 $ 25 $ 15
Accounts receivbable, net 402 624 898 1,196
Inventory 198 306 448 594
Total current assets 636 963 1,371 1,805
Fixed assets, net 57 63 66 75
Deferred charges 12 15 22 31
Other assets 33 37 51 59
Total assets 738 1,078 1,510 1,970
Page 1
Analysis
Ratio Analysis
Profit Margin 0.03 0.02 0.01 0.01 Margins declining fairly drama
Asset Turnover 3.3 3.3 3.6 3.7 Turnover improved slightly
Leverage 1.66 2.25 2.92 3.50 Leverage is increasing
Levbop 2.43 3.15 3.80
Retention Rate 50% 50% 49% 50% Paying out quite a lot in dividen
g* 0.08 0.08 0.09
g 0.49 0.50 0.33 Sales growth is a long way ove
Detail Ratios:
Current Ratio 2.16 1.61 1.38 1.28 Declining
Days sales in cash 5.448 3.349 1.688 0.761 Cash being eaten up by the inve
DSO 60.8 63.3 60.6 60.7 Collections are flat, but they are
Inventory Turns 9.98 9.76 10.13 10.18 Inventory Turns have actually i
Fixed Asset Turns 42.32 57.10 81.91 95.96 Fixed Asset turns are improving
Payable Period 41.00 59.54 68.04 75.29 Marked decline in Payable Peri
Misc Accruals/Sales 0.01 0.02 0.01 0.01 Flat as a % of Sales
Debt/Assets 0.03 0.04 0.03 0.02 Notes Payable from the Bank h
Interest Coverage: 57.00 43.00 45.00 54.00 Lots of Interest Coverage, at lea
Page 2
Analysis
Other Ratios:
Purchase Discounts Taken/Purchases 0.68% 0.78% 0.45% 0.29%
Deferred Charges Turnover 201 240 246 232 Somewhat better but pretty flat
Other Assets Turnover 73 97 106 122 Also better
misc. accruals ### 0.01529 0.01480 0.01251
Tax Rate 42.11% 44.19% 44.44% 44.44%
Assumptions:
Sales Growth 33%
COGS % 84%
Interest Expense (Flat on existing loan) 7.50%
Purchase Discounts Taken/Purch 0.68%
Note Payable 40.00
Days Sales in Cash 0.76
Days Sales Outstanding 60.7
Inventory Turns 10.2
Fixed Asset Turns 96.0
Deferred Charges 232.2
Other Assets 122.0
Payable Periods 45.0
misc accruals: ###
Capital Stock 375
Tax Rate 44%
Retention Ratio 50%
Loan on Receivables: 60%
Loan on Inventories: -
Projections:
Page 3
Analysis
Cash (required) $ 36 $ 33 $ 25 $ 15 $ 20
Accounts receivbable, net 402 624 898 1,196 1,591
Inventory 198 306 448 594 941
Total current assets 636 963 1,371 1,805 2,551
Fixed assets, net 57 63 66 75 100
Deferred charges 12 15 22 31 41
Other assets 33 37 51 59 78
Total assets 738 1,078 1,510 1,970 2,771
Funding Requirement: 10
Collateral: 1998
Receiveables: 954
Inventory: 0
Total: 954
Interest Coverage:
EBIT/Int. Exp 3.4
Leverage:
D/A: 36.3%
Sustainable Growth:
ROE: 0.16 0.16
Page 4
Analysis
Page 5
Analysis
Page 6
Analysis
Forecast
1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004
Page 7
Analysis
Basically flat
Paying out quite a lot in dividends, but this is his source of income and the absolute amount isn't much
Sales growth is a long way over g*, cash is being eaten up and leverage is increasing
Cash being eaten up by the investments in A/R and Inventory needed to support the sales growth
Collections are flat, but they are not particularly fast
Inventory Turns have actually improved slightly, but are basically flat
Fixed Asset turns are improving. Is this efficiency or, in the face of fast growth are CAPEX being avoided ?
Gross Profit has fallen from 18% to 16%, appears to be some evidence of discounting/price competition
SG&A is flat
Page 8
Analysis
Page 9
Analysis
$ 27 $ 35 $ 47 $ 62 $ 83 $ 110
2,116 2,814 3,742 4,977 6,620 8,804
1,251 1,664 2,213 2,943 3,914 5,206
3,393 4,513 6,002 7,983 10,617 14,121
133 176 235 312 415 552
55 73 97 129 172 228
104 139 185 246 327 434
3,685 4,901 6,518 8,669 11,530 15,335
Page 10
Analysis
Increas ret.
Page 11
Analysis
ng avoided ?
Page 12
EVA
Senarios 3: With margins improved to around 19% and collections improved he can now grow, at
his sustainable growth rate, or even faster here sales growth is 20%
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002
Net sales 8,636 10,364 12,436 14,924 17,908
Cost of goods sold 6,995 8,395 10,073 12,088 14,506
Gross profit 1,641 1,969 2,363 2,836 3,403
Operating, selling and
administrative expense 1,206 1,447 1,737 2,084 2,501
Interest expense (on existing note) 3 3 3 3 3
New Interest Expense: 81 96 114 136 162
Purchase discounts taken (145) (171) (206) (247) (296)
Profit before taxes 496 594 714 859 1,033
Income taxes 220 264 318 382 459
Profit after taxes 275 330 397 477 574
AT profits before interest 322 385 462 555 665
Capital Charge 303 364 437 524 629
EVA-asset 19 21 26 31 37
Page 13