Impact of Clinker Cooling on Cement Quality
Impact of Clinker Cooling on Cement Quality
The cooling of the clinker influences its structure, the mineralogical composition, as well as
the grindability, and consequently the quality of the resulting cement.
Fast clinker cooling influences especially the behav ior of the magnesium oxide, and
therefore also the soundness of the resulting cement. The faster the clinker cooling, the
smaller the periclase crystals (magnesium oxide), which emerge by crystallization of the
liquid phase.
The American ASTM Standards on Cement [261], limit the expansion of Portland cement
(Types I-V) in the autoclave test to 0.8 %. Slowly cooled clinker with an MgO-content of
about 2.5 %, mostly fails the autoclave expansion test. Magnesium oxide solidified to glass,
does not impair the soundness of cement.
Rapid clinker cooling allows for a higher MgO-con tent in the clinker, whereas slowly
cooled clinker should have a rather low MgO-content. The cooling rate of clinker with up to
1 % MgO is not so decisive for the soundness than MgO-contents between 1 % and the
upper limit, which in cement standards is mostly 5 %, in the British standards 4 %.
Slow clinker cooling promotes the growth of clinker minerals. The size of alite crystals does
not only influ ence the clinker”s grindability (large crystals need additional energy for
comminution), but also affects hydration and cement strength. Alite crystals which by
proper burning and rapid cooling are kept small, result in higher cement strengths [265]. Of
two cements with identical chemical composition, the one with smaller alite crystals (15
microns), was stronger; its 28-day compressive strength was 391 kg/cm2, whereas the
compressive strength test of cement with 40 micron diameter crystals was only 293
kg/cm 2 [262].
Fig. 21.1. shows the expansion of two mortar rods, made from the same clinker containing
11 % C3A, and stored in a 5 % solution of magnesium sulfate. In one case- applying slow
cooling- the C3A crystal lized completely, whereas in the other case the clinker was cooled
rapidly [263]. The curves show the definite advantage of rapid clinker cooling.
Clinker coolers
To form an opinion on clinker coolers, the following criteria should be considered:
a)The thermal efficiency of a cooler designates the ratio of the heat reclaimed from the hot
clinker, and utilized in the burning process, to the total heat content of the clinker leaving
the kiln. The thermal efficiency (E) is expressed as :
The thermal efficiency of rotary kiln clinker coolers of all types of design is within the
range of 40 to more than 80%.
b)Another criterion for judging the cooler efficiency is the temperature difference
between the hot clinker entering the cooler and the hot secondary air leaving the
Furthermore, the best cooler is the particular cooler which, because of its general
efficiency, supplies the maximum amout of heat into the rotary kiln with the secon dary
air.
C)The degree of clinker cooling is designated as the temperature of the clinker leaving the
This temperature differs in the various types of coolers from 50 to 300 o C.
D)he specific energy requirement of rotary and satellite coolers is lower than that of all
other clinker coolers.
E)The cooling air volume of rotary, satellite and shaft coolers is limited to the air volume,
neces sary for maintaining the combustion process in the rotary However, the clinker
leaving these coolers has higher temperatures.
F)The lower temperature of the clinker coming from the grate cooler is a result of the higher
air vol ume used for clinker cooling. The hot surplus air is partially utilized for drying and
partially dis charged into the atmosphere; this necessitates dust collection which causes
additional costs.
These influencing factors hinder the evaluation of clinker coolers, since frequently an
advantage on the one hand must be paid by losses on the other.
The rotary cooler is the oldest type of clinker cooler, constructed to work in conjunction
with the rotary kiln. The rotary cooler consists of a revolving cylin der, following the rotary
kiln. Rotary kilns of 60- 90 m length, are supplied with rotary coolers of 2- 5 m diameter
and 20- 50 m length. The rotary kilns of the Kuybyshev cement plant (USSR) of the size 4.5 x
5 x 135 m, are supplied with rotary coolers of 5 m diameter x 15 m length. The slope of
rotary coolers is in the range from 4- 7° to the horizontal; they are mostly arranged in
opposition to the kiln’s slope, since they are frequently located underneath the rotary kiln.
Rotary coolers are mounted on two riding rings; the girth gear and pinion drive is inde
pendent of the rotary kiln’s drive. Rotary coolers are operated with revolutions in the range
from 0 to 8rpm.
About 70 % of the drum’s length is refractory lined. Rotary coolers are supplied with flights
for lifting and dropping the clinker to get a thorough contact with the cooling air, and thus
to increase the efficiency of the cooler.
The negative pressure in the rotary kiln induces suc tion of cold air through the open end of
the rotary cooler; the cooling air passes the rotary cooler in cross-current to the motion of
the clinker. When entering the rotary kiln, the temperature of the cooling air is about 400-
750 oc.
The clinker leaving the rotary kiln with a tempera ture of 2370-2460 °F, after passing a
transition shaft,enters the rotary cooler. When leaving the rotary cooler, the temperature of
the clinker is in the range of 150-300 oc.
Wet process rotary kilns with a specific heat con sumption of i600 kcal/kg of clinker, and
with an excess air rate of 1.3- 1.4, require a combustion air volume of 25 st.m3/kg of clinker.
At this rate more cooler air can be supplied into the rotary kiln; this improves the cooler
efficiency. The efficiency of rotary clinker coolers is: 55-75 % with the dry prod uction
process, and up to about 78 % with the wet production process.
The capacity of rotary coolers is 2.5- 3.5 t/m3 · 24 h of cooler volume; on the other hand, 1
ton of clinker capacity per 24 h requires a cooler volume of 0.4-0.25 m3. The LID-ratio of
rotary cooler drums is 10 : 1 to 12.: 1.
Because of the scoops which cause constant lifting and scattering of the material inside the
rotary cooler, the degree of filling is hardly comparable to that of the rotary kiln. For
calculation of the passage time through the rotary cooler, see section 4.15. The formula
quoted in this section is also applicable for calculating the retention time of material
particles in rotai:y coolers.
For maximum heat transfer in rotary coolers, an air velocity at the clinker inlet end of the
cooler of 3.8-4.3 m/sec should be applied.
These velocities apply to an excess air of 10 % (n = 1.1) and to a secondary air volume of 85
% of the total combustion air.
The heat losses through the shell of rotary coolers by radiation and convection are in the
range of 50- 80 kcal/kg of clinker.
After the grate cooler was introduced into the cement industry, and after the comeback of
the pla netary cooler, drum coolers for clinker cooling were only temporarily and not often
erected. However, in the meantime, further development of the drum cooler showed
advantageous operating results.
In 1972, space requirements in an Austrian cement plant demanded a 2000 t/24 h preheater
kiln with a rotary cooler, located underneath the rotary kiln; the size of this cooler is 4.4 x 46
m. The discharge tem perature of the clinker is reported to be in the rangeof 160-180 oc
[266c]. Supplier: KHD HumboldtWedag AG, Ki:iln, W. Germany, see Fig. 22.2. and 22.3.
The satellite cooler consists of several, mostly 10 or 11 sheet metal cylinders arranged
wreath-like along the circumference of the hot kiln end, forming an integral part of the
rotary kiln. The satellite coolers revolve together with the rotary kiln, without separ-ate drive.
The particular cooling tubes are refractory lined, up to about 25 0/o of their length; for
better heat transfer, the remainder of the length is supplied with chains or flights. Openings
in the kiln shell allow the clinker to enter the satellite coolers. Cooling occurs cross-currently.
The total cooling air enters the kiln as combustion air. The motion of the clinker in the
satellite coolers is mostly parallel to the motion of the clinker in the rotary kiln; however,
there are also satellite coolers supplied with internal construction, capable of conveying the
clinker in the opposite direction. The total weight of the 10 to 11 old type satellite coolers is
supported by the roller assembly located prior to the rear end of the satellite coolers.
Because of the excessive weight of the kiln head fur nished with satellite coolers, and the
resulting stress problems of the kiln’s shell, it was impossible to go beyond a certain size of
the kiln or the satellite cool ers respectively. The upper limit was reached with a rotary kiln
size corresponding to a capacity of 500- 700 t/24 h, and with a maximum dimension of the
satellite coolers of 1.25 x 7.5 m.
Fig. 22.4. shows a longitudinal section through a satel lite cooler of a wet process rotary kiln
of the size 3.6 x 3.3 x 3.6 x 150 m, with a capacity of 550 t/24 h.
As is shown, the length of the pictured satellite cooler is about 6 m; this length is not
sufficient for a useful heat transfer. The LID-ratio is 6 : 1, whereas the LID-ratio of rotary
coolers is in the range from 10 : 1 to 15 : 1. The efficiency of this satellite cooler is about 60-
65 %.
The satellite coolers described above belong to the original design of this type of clinker
cooler. Far more than 1000 rotary kilns were constructed with satellite coolers; the F. L.
Smidth Company alone manufac tured about 660 rotary kilns with old type satellite
coolers.
Satellite coolers -new design
In 1965 the F. L. Smidth Co. came out with the so-called new Unax-Satellite or Planetary
cooler, which represents a far-reaching improved design of the conventional satellite cooler.
Planetary coolers of new design are also supplied by other well-known cement machinery
manufacturers.
The substantial feature of the new Unax-satellite coler is the forward extention of the kiln
tube and the formation of an additional roller assembly for the support of the extended kiln
tube. Based on this design, it was possible to apply larger satellite cooler tubes, without
impairing the carrying capacity of the rotary kiln shell. Of course, a thicker shell plate is
applied for the additional weight of the satellite cool ers. The LID-ratio of the new satellite
coolers is approximately 12:1.
The burner floor is formed by a stationary tube which projects into the roller supported
lower end of the kiln shell. A rotary kiln with the dimensions 6.3 x 5.5 x 178 m has a 35 m
long stationary burner floor tube with a diameter of 4.5 m.
Fig. 22.5. shows the longitudinal section of a rotary kiln”s lower end with the new satellite
cooler. Up to the present time, the new satellite cooler was applied to rotary kilns with a
capacity of up to 4000 t/24 h; for this size of kiln, the size of the satellite cooler tubes is 2.4
m dia. x 29 m long.
Fig. 22.6. shows an access tunnel to the burner plat form of a kiln supplied with satellite
coolers. Inside the tunnel, the hot kiln end is closed by a fire shield, which is suspended on
two rollers and rails. For heat protection, the fire shield is lined with refractory. A counter-
weight device keeps the fire shield pressed against a sealing around the kiln opening. The
fire shield is provided with an opening for the burner pipe, and observation ports. A hinged
access door is located at the periphery of the fire shield.
Fig. 22.7. shows the clinker inflow funnels into satel lite coolers arranged around the kiln”s
circumference. Presently (1984) the F. L. Smidth Co. supplies satellite coolers up to a
diameter of 2.55 m, and 29 m length.
Fig. 22.8. shows the total arrangement of a clinker burning plant consisting of a twin type
cyclone raw mix preheater, rotary kiln with planetary coolers of new design, and the access
tunnel of the burner plat form.
The new cooler tubes are lined with refractory along half the length. This is made possible,
since almost no weight limitations are necessary as with the old type cooler. Thus, heat
losses through the cooler walls are reduced by approximately 30 to 40 kcal/kg
Fig. 22.11. shows a longitudinal section of the new Unax-cooler and three related cross-
sections; as the picture shows, various lifter elements are applied for the purpose of lifting
the clinker in the cooler tubes [269]. The retention time of the clinker in the cooler tubes
lasts approximately 45 minutes. When entering the satellite coolers, the temperature of the
clinker is in the range of 1100-1350 °C; when leaving the satellite coolers of a dry
process kiln, the tempera ture of the clinker is about 120-200 o C. Here it should be
noticed that cooling of the clinker is performed only with such an air volume which equals
the quantity of the secondary air, which makes. 0.8-1.0 st.m3/kg of clinker and at a specific
heat consump tion of 750 kcal/kg. A grate clinker cooler operated with this air volume
would yield clinker exit temper atures of 250-300 o C. To this it should be added that the
planetary cooler loses about 25 % of the clinker heat by radiation through the shell. In
contrast to this, heat losses by radiation through the shell of the grate cooler are almost
nil; this allows the utilization of the grate cooler’s waste air. In the wet production process
with a specific heat consumption of 1400 kcal/kg of clinker, the volume of the secondary air
amounts from 1.3-1.5 st.m3/kg of clinker. The temperature of the secondary air leaving the
satellite coolers and entering the kiln, is in the dry process kiln 840- 850 o C. and in the wet
process kiln 600-650 oc. To cool the clinker in the satellite coolersfrom 1350 oc down
to 1000 oc takes not quite ten minutes, which equals almost the cooling time in the grate
cooler. In accordance with this, a large number of comparative measuremens on clinker
from plane tary coolers and from grate coolers have shown that there is no detectable
distinction in the quality of clinker from the two different cooler types. Consider ing from
the viewpoint of clinker quality and kiln operations, it is also presumable that cooling of
clinker which occurs already in the kiln tube, can be expedient [269a, 269b]. Since the
satellite cooler is operated without cooler excess air, no cooler dust collector is necessary.
Fig. 22.11. Longitudinal section through the new Unax cooler with the particular cross-
sections
Fig. 22.12. shows a heat balance diagram of an F. L.Smidth Unax-satellite cooler; this
heat balance is expressed in kcal/kg clinker, and 0 ac starting temperature. The heat content
of the cooling air is included.
Section 22.5.2. contains for comparison a heat balance diagram of a grate cooler (F. L.
Smidth Folax cooler). In both cases it was assumed that the heat content of the clinker in the
burning zone amounts to 400 kcal/ kg clinker, or 720 Btu/lb. It was further established that
in both cases, the distance from the burning zone to the cooler inlet (i.e. the length of the
kiln’s cooling zone) is the same. Therefore, the heat balances of both kinds of coolers are
perfectly comparable with one another.
Satellite cooler drive and power requirement
The satellite cooler increases the power requirement of the kiln and of the ID-fan.
The additional power requirement for the kiln can be determined with the following
formula:
Small kilns show an increase in the power require ment of about 0.3 kWh/t of clinker; the
4000 t/24 h kiln with a satellite cooler length of 27 m, has an additional specific power
requirement of 27 x 0.03 =0.8 kWh/t of clinker. The pressure drop through the satellite
cooler which amounts from 20- 40 mm W.G., increases the specific power requirement of
the ID-fan by 0.3 kWh/t of clinker in the dry process kiln, and by 0.5 kWh/t in the wet
process kiln. The total specific power requirement of the new satellite cooler is within the
limits of 0.6- 1.3 kWh/t of clinker.
Cement machinery building firms which manufac tured conventional satellite coolers now
also engage in construction and sale of rotary kilns with satellite coolers of the new design.
Here it should be mentioned that the following diffi culties were sometimes encountered
with the new type, large satellite coolers [270a]:
1. Static and mechanical overstress of the kiln shell, which resulted in cracks between
the clinker dis charge openings [270b].
2. Imperfect formation of the transition sockets from the kiln to the cooler tubes, which
caused spillage of the clinker into the kiln and on the burner nozzle.
3. Short-term durability of the refractory lining.
4. Increased wear of the cooler tubes due to their thermal overstrain, as well as short-
term durabil ity of refractory, metal linings and lifters; air and water cooling are
applied as a makeshift.
5. The problem of attaching the long cooler tubes to the kiln shell in conjunction with
their thermal expansion required special constructional arrangement.
6. Excessive noise pollution requires costly silen cers, such as sound-barriers on both
sides of the cooler tubes.
If should be further noted that the investment cost of a rotary kiln with satellite coolers of
the new design, equals that of a rotary kiln with a grate cooler included.
To compare the investment costs of both kiln sys tems, it is of importance to know the
limitations con cerning the discharge of particulate matter of the cooler exit air into the
atmosphere. This again depends on the local environmental regulations. In addition to the
above considerations, to run a plane tary cooler it is important to know the local noise pol
lution restrictions and the cost to comply with them.
According to the manufacturer, no caking occurs at this kind of cooling; also the heat
consumption is not appreciably affected.
The satellites consist of a transition piece, a double divided inlet elbow, satellite tube shell
with internal constructions, fixed and loose supports, and of the discharge arrangement.
The refractory lined transition sections consist of high temperature resistant cast steel; this
steel is in all temperature ranges free of embrittlement, and protects the sockets of the kiln’s
discharge openings against wear.
The inlet elbows are exchangeable and are fastened to the satellite tube by a clamp flange,
secured against turning. Their construction does not allow the clinker to return into the kiln.
The inlet elbow is fur nished with a high temperature and wear resistant lining. A packing
box gasket located between kiln and inlet elbow absorbs the axial heat expansions and
conractions of the inlet elbow.
The satellite tubes are double supported. The fixed support arranged close to the inlet
elbow, takes care for the axial fixing, and prevents at the same time dis tortion of the
satellite tube. The loose support ena bles without obstruction to absorb changes of the
tube length, caused by temperature variations. The required clearance between support
and satellite tube is adjustable according to the demand.
Corresponding to the decreasing clinker tempera tures from the inlet elbow to the
discharge opening, the satellite tube is divided into different refractory lining zones, as well
as in zones furnished with special internal constructions.
The discharge opening of the satellite cooler is sup plied with a special arrangement,
allowing a size clas sification of the clinker. Fine particles up to about25 mm in size, pass
the exchangeable grate and are led to the clinker conveyor. Coarse clinker is dis charged
through a side opening, and is conveyed through a chute to the clinker breaker.
Due to the downstream installation of the cooler combination, i.e. after the kiln, it is possible
to adjust inclination and speed to the kiln capacity.
The grate cooler
The clinker grate cooler with air quenching effect, which is generally known as the Fuller-
cooler, was developed by the Fuller Company in Bethlehem, Pa., to be operated in
conjunction with the rotary kiln. Operation of the first Fuller cooler started in August 1937 in
the Valley Forge Cement Plant in Valley Forge, Pennsylvania; this cooler was developed to eli
minate the detrimental effect of cement expansion which was caused by recrystallization of
the magne sia.
The self-contained construction of the Fuller cooler provides the means to keep the cooler
area clean. Compared to the rotary cooler, the Fuller cooler as such requires about 20 % less
space. The Fuller cooler enables complete control of the secondary air and the clinker
temperature. The heat losses of this cooler by radiation and convection are extemely low.
The Fuller cooler develops a fast initial cooling of the clinker; this fact is of great importance
for the forma tion of tricalcium silicate. This cooler allows for clinker input temperatures of
about 1360- 1400 o C, which increases the thermal efficiency up to 72- 75 %. The
application of excess cooling air results in cooling of the clinker down to 65 °C; this tempera
ture allows an immediate grinding of the clinker to finished cement.
In contrast to the rotary and planetary coolers where cooling of clinker is predominantly
performed by transverse air current, the Fuller cooler, cools with a combination of cross-
current and counter-current air.
Originally, the Fuller cooler was constructed with 15 o slope, modelled on the Seyboth
grate for boiler firing. To reduce headroom the slope of the grate was first lowered to 10 o,
and later to 5 o; at the end of this trend the horizontal grate cooler was finally devel oped.
The reciprocating grate cooler consists of alternating rows of immobile and mobile grates.
The grates are driven by variable speed motors; the number of grate strokes varies from a
minimum of 4 to a maximum of 22/min. The size of the grate plates is 300 x 410 mm. The
thrust length of the mobile grates is 120 rom. The undersize clinker particles passing the
grate plates enter the air compartments, from where they are dis charged by motor
operated airtight double tipping valves; in most cooler constructions usually a drag chain is
applied to remove the spillage from the cooler housing. The cold grate end discharges the
clinker to an inclined grid, from where the main part of the clinker, after passing the grid,
drops to the clinker conveyor. A clinker breaker located at the end of the inclined grid
serves the purpose of disinte grating larger chunks of clinker; it projects the clinker back to
the end grates for further cooling and size reduction.
With the progressive increase in size of rotary kilns, the horizontal Fuller cooler encountered
new prob lems. It happened that larger rotary kilns with capaci ties of 1000 mt/24 h and
more, had a tendency to produce clinker of finer particle sizes. The hot bed of fine clinker on
the horizontal grate became fluidized from the rapid expansion of the upcoming cooling air
in such a way that the horizontal grates would reci procate without advancing the clinker
through the hot zone, thus causing a dangerous height of the clinker bed.
The first section fo the feed end of the Fuller combi nation cooler is constructed on a so
slope. Simulta neously, the height of the pushing face of the grate was increased from
S to 8.3 em. These provisions helped to overcome the fluid bed effect [271]. The remainder
of the cooler length consists of a horizon tal reciprocating grate. Both grates have separate
speed controlled drives. In further persuance of this concept, a combination cooler with
three reciprocat ing grates was designed. The slope of the first two grates is 3°, the third
grate is horizontal. This combi nation cooler is of a special construction that allows for
numerous hot air takeoffs, i.e. flash furnace, raw material dryers, coal mills, burners, waste
heat boil ers, etc.
In connection with the definition “center exit air” of the cooler, reference is made to Fig.
22.14.; this sketch shows the different kinds of clinker cooler air. The duotherm-air or
duotherm circuit is explained in sec tion 22.4.3.
1. a sloping grate
2. a short horizontal grate
3. a clinker breaker
4. a long horizontal grate.
The advantage of this arrangement is that after crush ing the large clinker chunks, the
material is then cooled to the required temperature.
Together with the introduction of the preheater kilns with their low heat consumption for
clinker burning, there was a growing increase in the demands pertain ing to the heat
economy of the grate cooler. Now it was imperative to introduce more heat into the rotary
kiln With a lower volume of secondary air. For this purpose the height of the clinker bed was
increased up to 4SO- 760 mm, thus producing a higher temperature of the secondary air.
This was achieved by narrowing the width of the inclined grate as well as by lowering the
grate speed. The grate width at the clinker feed end equals approximately half the kiln
diameter measured on the refractory.
The horizontal grate is 60- 90 em wider than the inclined grate, with higher grate velocities
and a thin ner clinker bed for lower pessure of the cooling air.
Fig. 22.15. shows the longitudinal section and the lay out of a Fuller combination cooler with
7 air compart ments.
Fig. 22.15. Fuller combination and reciprocating grate cooler; view of both sides
Underneath the cooler grates, the length of the cooler is divided into individual air
compartments; each air compartment is equipped with its own air fan.
A Fuller cooler with a capacity of 2000 mt/24 h is equipped with 7 air compartments. The
partitions are installed from the floor up to the grate, and are sealed on the stationary grate
supports. The purpose of the air compartments is, to let the cooling air flow only upward
through the bed of material in the desired bed area. Thus, along the cooler length the
clinker bed is divided into 7 fields of different temperatures. The expansion and the velocity
of the cooling air decreases with the declining temperature of the clinker bed; concurrently
with this, the required air pressure for penetration of the clinker bed drops pro portionately.
Counting from the clinker inlet (the static pressure of the fan for the first air compartment is
600- 760 mm W.G.), each following air chamber is supplied with a fan of lower static
pressure. The fan of the coldest section has a static pressure of 200- 250mmW.G.
The diagram in Fig. 22.16. shows material tempera tures and undergrate pressures for a
typical combina tion clinker cooler, producing about 1700 mt/24 h of clinker from 1360 oc
initial temperature to 65 oc discharge temperature.
To calculate the temperature of the secondary air the following empirical formula can be
used:
The cooler’s clinker inlet cross-section is sized for a velocity of the ascending secondary air
of 4 m/sec.
The capacity of the cooler fans is designed for a spe cific air volume of 3-3.15 st.m3/kg of
clinker.
The installed power of a grate cooler with a capacity of 2000 t/24 h, including the drive for
the cooling air fans, the reciprocating grates, and the vent air fans, is 1050 HP; from this
amount, 700 HP is apportioned to the cooling air fans with the grate drives, and 350 HP is
for the drive of the vent air fans.
This consumption can be drastically reduced by designing coolers with higher clinker
discharge tem perature. Power consumption can also be reduced with the utilization of
variable speed drive fans.
Since the cooling air as well as the velocity of the reciprocating grate can be controlled
independently of the operation of the rotary kiln, the grate cooler is able to temporarily
accept throughput fluctuations ranging up to 50 % above the normal capacity. This is
considered to be routine overload.
Duotherm circuit
At the duotherm circuit of the grate cooler, part of the hot cooler excess air is led back as
recirculating air into the first and second air compartments. This reduces the cooler excess
air and thus the heat losses by about 25 kcal/kg of clinker, improving the cooler’s efficiency.
At the duotherm circuit the consumption of fresh air can be reduced to 1.3-1.8
st.m3/kg of clinker. This procedure however, results in a higher thermal load of the grate
plates. This alternate is becoming more acceptable with the advent of heat exchangers for
protection and the demand for fewer plant dust emission points.
Where allowable, multicyclones are applied to clean the cooler’s excess air. Mostly however,
the cooler’s dust is recovered in fabric filters, gravel bed filters or electric precipitators. The
dust load before entering the filter is 10-15 g/st.m3; the dust load after leaving an electric
precipitator is 0.115 g/st.m3.
Cooler efficiency
The efficiency of the cooler calculated in the table is a result of the relatively low volume of
secondary air, as well as of the center exit air and the cooler excess air. If the center exit air
in the production process is utilized for raw material drying, then this position can be
counted as a heat input; in this case the cooler efficiency would be 85.6 %. In connection
with this, it should be considered that a low specific heat con sumption for clinker burning
(in the table 750 kcal/ kg), requires less combustion air and therefore the kiln consumes less
secondary air, if the volume of the excess air is kept constant. In this case the calcula tion
results in an apparent lower cooler efficiency. Ifthe kiln would require 850 or 950 kcal/kg of
clinker, more hot secondary air would be transferred from the cooler into the kiln; this
would, of course, increase the cooler’s efficiency. Since the thermal efficiency of the cooler is
expressed by the ratio resulting from the heat content of the clinker and the recovered heat,
the cooler center exit air used for drying, is also a position of heat recovery, which should be
consid ered when calculating the thermal efficiency of the cooler.
In the Comecon-countries, grate coolers are manufac tured: in the USSR by the UZTM-
Machinery Works, in the German Democratic Republic by the VEB Cement Machinery
Manufacturers in Dessau, a subsi diary of the Heavy Machinery Construction Trust Ernst
Thalmann in Magdeburg. Grate coolers are also manufactured by the Pi’erov Machinery
Works in Czechoslovakia. The Polish Cement Machinery Works PZBM-“Makrum” in
Bydgoszcz manufactures grate coolers model “Wolga” based on a Soviet license.
The grate cooler of the Claudius Peters Company, Hamburg, W. Germany, has been
manufactured under Fuller license up to 1973. The Peters-cooler (also called Combicooler)
is constructed with slope of 3o, as shown in Fig. 22.18. The cooler can also be con structed
with a continuous of 3°, or continuously hor izontal with no inclination at all.
KHD Humboldt Wedag AG manufactures inclined grate coolers with a continuous slope of 5
%, accord ing to the functional principle of the thrust grating with one or more thrust
grates arranged successively, or also as step coolers with intermediate comminu tion of the
clinker.
The inclined grate cooler shown in Fig. 22.17., cools the clinker from e. g. 1350 oc down to
about 65 oc above ambient temperature. For heat recuperation, the heated cooling air is
utilized by the burning pro cess as secondary air. According to the plant require ments, e. g.
of the Pyroclon-process, one part of the secondary air can be led through a duct as tertiary
air directly to the preheater. The excess hot air can be utilized for drying of the raw material.
To increase the temperature level of this hot air, the circulating air process can be applied,
which is parti cularly recommended for the step cooler.
The remammg air is discharged to the atmosphere after passing a dust collector.
The heat recovery is achieved in the first part of the grate surface of the recuperation zone.
This is accom plished by a high, uniformly distributed, slow travell ing and revolving clinker
bed, as well as by the cool ing air volume, which is required as secondary air for the burning
process.
The low final clinker temperature is achieved by the application of an appropriate air
volume, as well as by a lower height of the clinker bed in the second part (cooling zone).
The control arrangement continuously regulates the height of the clinker bed, the travelling
velocity of the grate, the air supply to the particular compart ments, and in extreme
situations, also the rotary kiln’s revolutions.
The clinker leaving the rotary kiln falls directly to the grate system, located in the lower part
of the cooler housing. The conveying of the clinker is per formed by the grate system, as
described in chapter22.4.1. Since the travelling direction of the thrust frame deviates from
the angle of the direction of tran sportation, the clinker acquires a revolving
motion(relative movement). This results in an intensive heat exchange with the air.
The material quality of the grate plates is graded according to the thermal and mechanical
stress. The grate plates of the recuperation zone consist of a special CrNi-steel casting; the
grates of the cooling zone are CrNi-cast steel products, and those of the after cooling zone
consist of Cr-steel casting.
For special requirements, KHD Humboldt Wedag AG supplies various patented types of
grate plates.
Through a coupling with overload protection, the thrust frame is driven by a variable speed
motor over a hollow shaft gear unit. This gear unit is manufac tured as an oscillating drive, i.
e. the drive motor is mounted directly on top of the gear. A load transmis sion connects the
hollow shaft of the gear with the drive shaft. Both eccentric drives are located on the drive
shaft, thereby connecting the gear with the thrust frame. The frequency of the thrust is
adjustable by a variable speed controller.
To compensate the coefficient of fluctuation, gener ated by the non-horizontal direction of
motion of the thrust frame, shock absorbers are installed between the thrust frame and the
lower housing part.
Through a grease distributor, the central lubricating device, lubricates all grate cooler
bearings, the drag chain, and the clinker breaker.
The upper part of the housing is appropriately fur nished with the necessary, large sized
openings for the particular air streams, to keep the dust content of these air streams low.
For access to the grates, the upper housing is supplied with several doors. The lin ing of the
upper housing consists of the side walls and of a simple arched roof. In the area of the mate
rial bed, the side walls are furnished with high wear resistant fire clay bricks. Furthermore, a
stretching device is installed for adjusting the tension of the arched roof. The refractory is
protected by a baffle plate with a heavy chain curtain from the larger clinker chunks
reflected by the clinker breaker. To reduce radiation losses, insulation is applied.
For removal of fine clinker particles passing the grate plates, two drag chain conveyors are
directly installed in the lower part of the housing. This results in a reduced construction
height of the cooler and simplifies simultaneously the cooler’s control arrangement.
The cooling air fans are equipped with: dynamic bal anced rotors, guide vanes for
adjustment of the required air volumes, and with a calibrating nozzle.
Behind the grate system a grizzly is located to separ ate the fine clinker, so that the clinker
breaker is fed only with coarse material.
The working width of the breaker is the same as the total width of the grate system. This
guarantees an even feeding of the clinker breaker.
The control arrangement depends on the process requirements; the dust collection system
must com ply with the local environmental protection require ments, and/or with the
customer’s specifications.
The clinker falls upon a chute, which is covered by a water cooled steel plate. The function
of the cooled chute is to prevent depositing of hot clinker, i. e. the formation of the so-
called snowman. For an even dis tribution of the clinker, the slope of the plate is adjustable
in two directions: horizontally as well as laterally to the cooler.
During the cooling process, the clinker rests upon the travelling grate plates. After dropping
the clinker at the discharge end, the grate plates are cooled on the return route, and are
only transiently exposed to the hot clinker in the area of the cooler inlet.
A clinker breaker covering the total width of the cooler grate, crushes larger pieces of clinker
and returns them back into the cooler for aftercooling. A chain curtain protects the
refractory lining.
The cooling of the clinker is performed in two zones. In the precooling area, air injecting and
pulsating nozzles transform the clinker layer into a state simi lar to a fluid bed, thus
improving the cooling effect. This also results in an even distribution of the clinker over the
width of the grate.
Due to lower aeration pressure in the secondary cool ing area, the clinker bed calms down,
causing an accumulation of fine clinker particles in the upper part, and of coarse clinker in
the lower part of the clinker bed. This particle separation is considered of particular
advantage for secondary cooling.
The flow chart of a Recupol cooler working in con junction with a 3630 short t/24 h capacity
Lepol kiln is shown in Fig. 22.21.
Waste air in the amount of 1.5 st.m3/kg of clinker is branched off from the low cooling area
of the cooler, and -after cleaning in cyclones -led via pulsating blowers, back into cooler
compartments No 1 and 2. Two fans, one on each side of the cooler, supply the remaining
10 compartments with fresh air. About 1.0 st.m3/kg clinker with a temperature of 290
oc, the so-called center exit air, is led into the predrying compartment of the Lepol-
grate.
At a capacity of 3630 short t/24 h, the aerated area of the Recupol cooler is charged with
39.4 t/24 h · m2
The thickness of the clinker bed on the cooling grate is approximately 200 mm. In the
precooling area, the pressure of the cooling air is about 350 mm W.G. In the low cooling
area, the pressure drops down to about 150 mm W.G.
The cooler is provided with separate quenching grates and blowers. The quenching grate is
followed by a 3o inclined grate; then again follows a horizontal grate. As an alternative the
first grate can be supplied as a horizontal grate, which is standard for larger coolers. This
arrangement in conjunction with the 85 mm high pushing faces of the grates, help to over
come the fluid bed effect of the clinker. Any follow ing horizontal grates are placed 600 mm
lower for each subsequent stage; see (5) on Fig. 22.22. If neces sary, the cooler can be
equipped in stage (5) with a clinker breaker, in front of the final horizontal grate.
A high economical dry process kiln with a heat con sumption of 750 kcal/kg is supplied
with secondary air from the air quenching and from the first grate blowers. It is also
possible to divide the secondary air between the kiln and a precalciner arrangement (6).
The surplus air is extracted at (7) and can be condi tioned by water (8) before cleaning in an
electric pre cipitator. The extraction of hot air for other purposes can be effected at point
(6).
The Folax grate cooler is designed for a throughput of 30-32 t/m2 · 24 h; when working in
conjunction with a large flash calciner, the specific capacity of the cooler amounts up to 40
t/m2 · 24 h.
The amount of air normally required for cooling from 1350 acto 60 ac above ambient
temperature is in the range of 2.4- 2.8 stan.m3/kg of clinker. To ensure maximum
operational reliability and to cope with kiln upset conditions, the coolers are designed for a
blower capacity of 3.4-3.8 stan.m3/kg of clinker. For the air quenching and inclined grate
section, the blowers are designed for a pressure in the range of 750-600 mm W.G. After-
cooling on the horizontal grates is carried out with blower pressures in the range of 550-
260 mm W.G. Large coolers working in conjunction with flash calciners, require in the
quenching and first grate section, air pressures 1000-800 mm W.G.
The capacity of the cooler shown in Fig. 22.22. is 2200 shtons/24 h; it is supplied with one
inclined and two horizontal grates. The effective length is 22 m. The inclined grate is 2.4 m
wide, and the throughput capa city is 833 t/m · 24 h; the thickness of the clinker bed is
approximately 500-600 mm. The width of the hori zontal grates is 3.2 m.
Large size coolers with five horizontal grates show a specific throughput capacity of 2000
t/m width · 24 h. The thickness of the clinker bed is increased to 600- 1000 mm.
The particular compartments of the cooler housing are supplied with collecting hoppers
for spillage; this material is released through discharge valves (10) into a drag chain trough
{11). Oversize clinker particles are comminuted in a clinker breaker (12), and returned to the
grate for after-cooling. The cooler insulation is protected by a chain curtain (13).
All grate plates (14) are identical in design, but their heat resistance is different. The thrust
length of the mobile grates is approximately 125 mm.
To avoid the problematic sliding seals, used in trans mitting the motion of the mobile grates
through the cooler shell, a special type of membrane has been developed, which absorbs
the motion through defor mation. Mechanical or hydraulic drive for the mova ble frames is
applied.
The conveying capacity of the grates is 100-300% higher than the nominal requirement.
This, together with the overcapacity in cooling air, enables the cooler to overcome all kiln
upset conditions.
As in all grate coolers, the cooling efficiency of the Folax cooler depends on the kiln’s heat
consumption; thus e.g. when working in conjunction with a prehea ter kiln, a cooling
efficiency of 65- 70 % is quoted
Fig. 22.23. shows a heat balance diagram of a Folax grate clinker cooler; this heat balance is
expressed in kcal/kg clinker, and 0 o C starting temperature. The heat content of the
cooling air is included in the bal ance.
Section 22.3.4. contains for comparison a heat balance diagram of a satellite cooler (F. L.
Smidth Unax cooler). In both cases it was assumed that the heat content of the clinker in the
burning zone amounts to 400 kcal/kg clinker. It was further established that in both cases,
the distance from the burning zone to the cooler inlet {i.e. the length of the kiln’s cooling
zone) is the same. Therefore, the heat balances of both kinds of coolers are perfectly
comparable with one another.
This design incorporates an air-cooled clinker breaker, located between the last two grates.
The intermediate size reduction, comminuting the clinker particles to approximately equal
size, results in a more intensive final clinker cooling on the last grate. Coolers of this design
have already been supplied, and are in service worldwide since 1969.
The clinker leaving the grate cooler, or the so-called recuperator, shows a temperature of
400 oc. Then an air cooled clinker breaker crushes the particles to a size< 35 mm.
A bucket apron conveyor feeds the clinker into the Peters g-cooler, cooling the clinker
indirectly, i.e. absolutely dustfree, to below 100 oc.
This type of arrangement as shown in Fig. 22.25., and similar ones are in service since 1972.
The g-cooler is continuously maintained full of clinker which drops at a low speed along the
lentil shaped cooling tubes. There is never any contact between the clinker and the air
passing through the cooling tubes. The pressure drop in the cooling tubes ranges between
80- 240 mm W.G., depending on the particular design and the desired temperature drop.
The specific power requirement of the combined recuperator g-cooler is approximately 5-7
kWh/t clinker.
Of course, the g-cooler can also be used as an after cooler, working in conjunction with
other kiln or cooler systems. Basically, the transfer points of this system are connected with
dust collectors.
The absolute control of the grate and bed tempera ture has led to the design of a grate
cooler with drag chain conveying
The shaft clinker cooler developed by E Bade, is manufactured with capacities up to 3000
metric t/24 h, by the Walther-Beratherm Company in Koln Dellbriick
Since a fluidized bed creates the most useful heat transfer conditions, Bade exploited the
concept to combine the counter-current cooling process in the shaft cooler with a fluidized
bed.
However, in reality, the requirements of the fluid bed do not always materialize without
some reservations, since such physical conditions as: equal particle size of clinker, constant
quantity of clinker, and uniform air distribution, are not always attainable.
The shaft cooler consists of the following main com ponents: the refractory insulated shaft
housing, the roller grate, the discharge hopper, the airtight three compartment discharge
gate, and the blower for the cooling air. Pipe and duct connections, as well as measuring
and control devices, represent the auxil iary equipment. The upper part of the shaft has a
smaller diameter, to increase the velocity of the cool ing air, thus to create, in this area,
conditions for a fluidized bed. Due to the fluid bed effect, according to which the material in
the upper part of the shaft behaves like a liquid, the clinker entering the cooler from the
rotary kiln is immediately evenly distri buted over the total cross-section of the shaft.
Each of the grooved rolls of the roller grate has a separate drive; when necessary, the rollers
can be operated with different revolutions, to withdraw the material column with various
speeds. Pieces of clinker which are larger than 25 mm, are disinte grated by the crushing
action of the rollers.
The cooling air entering the shaft cooler is distri buted as follows: 35 % of the air volume is
introduced underneath the grate, 45 % enter at a point of the shaft’s half height, and the
remaining 20 % is blown into the constricted part of the shaft. Specially formed pipes and
nozzles which penetrate the clinker column, distribute the cooling air uniformly over the
shaft’s cross-section.
Depending on the quantity of the cooling air, the temperature of the clinker leaving the
cooler is about 250-280 oc above ambient temperature. The temperature of the secondary
air is in the range of 900- 1000 oc
The static pressure of the cooling air blower is 1120 mm. The quantity of cooling air is
1.1 st.m3/kg clinker.
The specific power requirement is about 8 kWh/t of clinker compared to 5.5-6 kWh/t for the
grate cooler; the latter figure includes also the power requirement for the grate drive.
The Research Institute of the German Portland Cement Association determined the thermal
effi ciency of the shaft cooler equal to 83 %.
Since there is no excess air, no dust collector is required for the shaft cooler. The headroom
of a shaft cooler is 10% higher than that of a grate cooler.
Clinker conveying
Previously, for clinker transportation shaker troughs or vibrating chutes with a high
frequency oscillation amplitude were used. However, these troughs or chutes could. be used
only for horizontal transporta tion of clinker. For vertical transportation it was necessary to
transfer the clinker into bucket eleva tors or into swing bucket conveyors. These clinker
conveying machines developed much dust not only during horizontal transportation, but
also during transloading in vertical conveyors. These drawbacks motivated the cement
machinery manufacturers to develop new-styled transportation arrangements, so-called
bucket apron conveyors, which are able to convey the clinker not only horizontally but also
on inclinations (mostly 40- 45 a, in exceptional cases even up to 60 °) almost without
generation of dust.
One of the presently most used clinker transporta tion arrangement is described as follows.
The Beumer Co. (Beckum, W. Germany) manufactures apron type steel bucket conveyors for
clinker tran sportation, having noncontacting overlapping cells, and a special stiffened chain.
With this design, the clinker dust which enters the first overlapping line is held back by a
raised rear edge of the cell. The cells are modified in such a way that the side plates do not
open up when passing over the return station. For inclinations from 28- 45 o each second
cell is equipped with an intermediate web plate, and for inclination from 45- 60 o each cell
has such web plate.
Fig. 22.27. and 22.28. show this type of clinker conve yor for applications from horizontal
transportation up to 28 o inclination and then for gradients of more than 28 o with
intermediate web plates.
Fig. 22.29. shows the condition of the steel cell clinker conveyor while passing the return-
station.
For open and box type cells, a chain of 250 rom pitch is used, and for bucket type cells a
chain of 400 rom pitch is applied. To avoid sagging of the 250 rom chain it was stiffened by
adding a projection on the outer side bars which rest on a bead on the inner side bar.
Fig. 22.30. shows the chain (250 mm pitch) with the projection and bead to avoid sagging.
The drive chain wheels are equipped with exchange able, flame hardened sprockets (for 250
mm pitch) or tooth shells (for 400 mm pitch) respectively. To reduce the wear on the
sprockets, an uneven number of teeth was chosen. This way each sprocket is in act ion only
once at two full revolutions of the wheel. Fig. 22.31.a. (250 mm) and 22.31.b. (400 mm) show
the form of the two types of sprocket wheels with replaceable teeth
The rollers are running in two grooved ball bearings which are sealed at the inside by
lamellar rings. The short roller axle is kept in place by a clamping device with bolts, which
allows for a quick exchange of the rollers
Fig. 20.32. shows the wheel arrangement with ball bearings and the clamping device by
which the axle is kept in place.
should not run at speeds exceeding 0.30 m/sec. Therefore, when comparing conveying
capacities, the chosen speed must be taken into account.
When planning a clinker conveying installation, a filling level of 75-80 % should be
considered. When locating the steel cell conveyor directly underneath the clinker cooler, the
conveying capacity should cor respond to the normal kiln capacity at a 40-50 % cell filling
level to prevent overfilling in case of possi ble kiln ring breakage. However, drive capacity
should be set as for 100 % cell filling level. Further, it is important that capacity reduction
factors are applied when considering inclined conveyors as com pared to horizontal
conveyors. Thus e.g. a horizontal conveyor including an inclination up to 28 o, at a con
veyor width of 1400 mm has a conveying capacity of 438m3/h. At an inclination of 60 o
however, the con veying capacity drops to 245 m3/h, i.e. to 60 % of the original capacity
(Beumer brochure No 55, Hot Material Conveyors).
Standard steel (St. 37.2, DIN 1050) is used for the cells up to a material temperature of 500
°C, that is in the majority of cases. The base plates of cells are 5-6 mm thick, and the side
plates are 5 mm thick. The cell height is normally 300 mm.
In the following some pictures of clinker conveying arrangements, and of clinker silos
supplied with installations by the Aumund-Forderbau Co., 4134 Rheinberg, W. Germany, are
shown.
Fig. 22.34. shows an Aumund steel pan clinker conve yor for discharge underneath the
clinker silo. The dis charge capacity is controlled by the material height on the clinker
conveyor.
Fig. 22.35. shows a clinker silo with a storage capacity of 230,000 t (metric). This silo is,
according to Aumund, the largest clinker silo in the world. The conveying arrangements to
this silo were supplied by the quoted company.
Fig. 22.36. shows a modern cone shaped clinker silo constructed of precast concrete parts.
Clinker con veying installations for loading and discharge of the silos were supplied by
Aumund Co.
Fig. 22.37. shows a detail photograph of modern clinker silos constructed of precast
concrete parts.
Fig. 22.38. shows modern clinker concrete silos. In each head part are two large dust
collectors for col lecting the dust from the silos as well as from the clinker transfer points.
Clinker conveying installa tions are from Aumund Co.
Fig. 22.34.- 22.38. are from the Aumund Conveying Technique Co.
Fly-ash silos
The manufacture of modified Portland cements through the addition of fly-ash during
finish grinding has-been accepted worldwide. Such types of cements are described in
volume 2, section 9.1.3. of the Cement-Data-Book. Also technical periodicals report about
quality research of such cements
Fluctuations in the sale of fly-ash cements as well as seasonal and regional fluctuations in
the operation of power generating stations, require large storage capacities, located either
at the power station or at the cement plant.
Cold fly-ash which compacts itself after long storage, loses its useful flowability; therefore,
storage silos with special installations were developed. The Clau dius Peters Co.
developed in cooperation with the Nils Weibull Co. a so-called “Pneumechsilo” in which
mechanical and pneumatic conveying equipment is used, and this not only for filling but
also for dis charge of the silo; see Fig. 22.39. (Claudius Peters Co.).
The silo is equipped with a central column, around which a bridge crane moves underneath
the silo roof. This bridge crane lifts and lowers a reversible trough less screw conveyor and a
circular pneumatic conve yor with a telescopic spout to distribute the incoming material.
Instead of a cyclone, the top of the central column is equipped with an expansion
compartment, out of which the material flows to the circular pneumatic conveyor. This
conveyor moves the material to the telescopie duct, which in turn brings the fly-ash directly
to the screw conveyor which distributes it equally as a selected layer over the silo surface.
To discharge the fly-ash from the silo, the operation of the screw is reversed, and the
material is fed to the mechanical circular conveyor which operates around the central
column. This conveyor empties into open ings of the column, and at this point the fly-ash is
pre-fluidized. Pre-fluidization, togehter with aeration at the bottom of the column generate
a central flow zone within the center duct, and thus conditions the fly-ash for a trouble free
discharge.
The effective silo area in use, as well as the degree of discharge are exceptionally
advantageous due to the forced mechanical discharge. The speciiic energy consumption is
approx 0.25 kWh/t, even at com pacted fly-ash









