Language Stimulation For Children With Mental Retardation-An Activity Manual For Parents
Language Stimulation For Children With Mental Retardation-An Activity Manual For Parents
Language Stimulation for Children with Mental Retardation-An Activity Manual for Parents
Strictly as per the compliance and regulations of:
© 2013. Rajeev Ranjan & T. A Subbarao. This is a research/review paper, distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons
Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 Unported License http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/), permitting all non-commercial
use, distribution, and reproduction inany medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
Language Stimulation for Children with Mental
Retardation-An Activity Manual for Parents
Rajeev Ranjan α & T. A Subbarao σ
Abstract - The objectives of the Study: To develop training Mental Retardation is a disability characterized
activities and guidelines suitable for north Indian home by significant limitations both in intellectual functioning
settings in an activity manual and to field test the developed
Year 2013
and adaptive behavior as expressed in conceptual,
material on a group of Hindi-English speaking parents of
social and practical adaptive skills. This disability
mental retardation.
originates before age 18” (AAMR, 2002).
Method : 20 Parents and 20 Special educators
(Mental Retardation) were included in this study. Field Study “Five assumptions essential to the application
tool (Questionnaire) was developed on the base of coverage of the definition:
of content, use of language, style of presentation and 1. Limitations in present functioning must be 20
2
37
difficulties in home implementation. Questionnaire and considered within the context of community
M
ental Retardation (MR) is an idea, a condition, a arrested or incomplete development of mind of a
syndrome, a symptom and a source of pain and person which is specially characterized by the sub
bewilderment to many families. Its history dates normality of intelligence.
back to the beginning of man’s time on earth. The idea 2. National Trust for the Welfare of Persons with
of mental retardation can be found as far back in history Autism, Cerebral Palsy, Mental Retardation &
as the therapeutic papyri of Thebes (Luxor), Egypt, Multiple Disability Act, 1999: Mental Retardation is
around 1500 B.C. Although somewhat vague due to the significantly subnormal intellectual ability (as
difficulties in translation, these documents clearly refer measured on individually administered standardized
to disabilities of the mind and body due to brain psychometric tests) accompanied by subnormal
damage (Sheerenberger, 1983). adaptive (common sense, self-help and survival
skills, sometimes known as ‘street smart’) skills.
A range of problems of children with mental
Author α : MASLP, College of Speech and Hearing, Dr. M. V. Shetty retardation has been reported, among these, speech-
Memorial Trust, Manglore-575001, Karnataka, India, 2PhD Student in
Audiology and Speech-Language Pathology (Part time) from AYJNIHH
language problems are important because speech and
(Mumbai), C-164, F-1, Shalimar Garden, Extention-02, Sahibabad, language are an important component of commun-
Ghaziabad, UP-201005, India. E-mail : [email protected] ication. Communication is about the transmission of
Author σ : Professor & Principal, College of Speech and Hearing, information. Effective human communication relies
Dr. M. V. Shetty Memorial Trust, Manglore-575001, Karnataka, India.
E-mail : [email protected]
heavily on language, a system of verbal or gestural
symbols governed by rules in a sophisticated code,
though some simple forms of communication such as a retarded children showed that 45% of them had speech
hand clap to attract attention, is non-linguistic. defects. It was also observed that speech defects were
more common amongst a severely subnormal group
II. Literature Review than the subnormal group.
Subba Rao, (1992) while describing speech, An invaluable resource in evaluating and
language and communication problems of Mental treating children with mental retardation is the Childs
Retardation persons, has stated that, “There is no family. Trying to understand and include families in the
typical speech and language pattern of mentally decision making process can ultimately be rewarding
retarded persons. Mentally Retarded children exhibit a and beneficial for all involved.
wide variety of speech and language problem and the In Indian context only one guide for parents has
Year 2013
problems are highly individualistic in nature. That means been developed at National Institute for the Mentally
no two mentally retarded children show the same Handicapped (NIMH), Secundrabad, namely “Training
problems. The range is so wide that one child may not in Communication Skills for Persons with Mental
speak at all and understands very little of other’s speech Retardation (UTILITY GUIDE FOR PARENTS),” by Subba
where as another child has fairly good comprehension Rao & Narayan, (2003). The utility guide is divided into
20
2
38 for day to day living and has enough speech to express two sections, one dealing with details on how children
but the speech is unintelligible. Generally, it is accepted develop their speech and language skills. The other
that the speech and language development in mentally section involves 8 chapters, dealing with activities
Global Journal of Human Social Science (G ) Volume XIII Issue X Version I
retarded children is delayed as compared to normally related to preparatory skills, listening skills, expression
developing children. That means to say that mentally skills, etc. Each activity has information on material and
retarded children develop speech and language skills in context. This has general objectives and limited
the same sequence as do normal children and the activities and their examples in each category.
factors underlying development are same. However,
It is felt that the number of such parent utility
they develop skills more slowly and they have a lower
manual should increase and be available to all needy
ceiling of development than normal individuals. The
parents. It is also felt that there is a need to expand
available evidence suggests that mentally retarded
objectives and activities to suit different socio-cultural-
children are likely to show specific difficulties or delays
language speaking environments. The present manual
in the structural aspects of language particularly in
will include a larger set of activities in limited area /
respect of sentence length, syntax and sentence
objectives. The activities will be focusing on a general
complexity”(PP. 122-123).
The frequency of language disorder is about north Indian cultural set up.
100% below the I.Q-20, around 90% between the IQ 21- III. Methods
50, and about 45% in the mild retarded group (Carrow-
wool folk and Lynch, 1982). In a retrospective analysis of The Present study aims:
300 mentally retarded children done at NIMH (National 1. To develop training activities and guidelines suitable
Institute for the Mentally Handicapped) SubbaRao and for north Indian home settings in an activity manual.
Srinivas, (1989) found that, 81.24% had speech and 2. To include modified and new activities based on the
language deficits. It was noticed that 30% of them had skill areas of prelinguistic skills, listening
no speech and about 60.67% spoke a few words only. comprehension of words and word level expression,
All the children had delayed speech and language which are selected from the work of SubbaRao &
development, articulation defects were 52%, voice Narayan, (2003).
defects were observed in about 39.33% and 13% 3. To field test the developed material on a group of
showed fluency defects. Bharat Raj, (1987) reported that Hindi-English speaking parents of mental
the percentage of speech and hearing defects were retardation.
37% in mild, 21% in moderate, 16% in severe mental a) Material
retardation groups. The most common disorder was Objectives were planned and activities were
delayed speech, which increased with severity of mental written under each objective.
retardation. Speech and language defects were more Selected Objectives under each section are
prevalent amongst males than in females. Shah et al written below.
(1970) reported that 82% of the 133 cases of mentally
retarded from a chronicle population were found to have Section 1. Pre-linguistic skills (Attention):
speech defects and a male-female ratio of 2:1 was 1.A. Helping the child to participate in making and
observed. Gupta, (1970) analyzed 300 cases of breaking towers.
intellectually retarded observed that speech defect was 1.B. Helping the child to match the picture.
one of the main reasons for psychological consultations. 1.C. Encouraging the child to attend to puzzles.
Prabhu, (1968) covering a sample of 320 mentally
Section 2. Listening and comprehension: special educators were from various places of Ranchi
2.A. Helping the child in responding to verbal (Jharkhand) and very few from the Mangalore
sounds. (Karnataka), India. All Parents were Hindi speakers and
2.B. Helping the child to develop name recognition. had a working knowledge of English. The activity
2.C. Helping the child to following simple manual and Questionnaire which contains a set of 15
instructions. questions, in which question no 1 is excluded from the
Section 3. Word level expression: analysis because it generally tells about the previous
3.A. Helping the child to say meaningful single experience/ familiarization about the manuals in general.
words such as /mamma/, /papa/. Question numbers 2 to 9 & 15 are multiple choice
3.B. Helping the child to say his name, or questions which were rated on a 4 point rating scale.
introducing self by name. Question number 10 to 14 are open ended/ descriptive
Year 2013
3.C. Helping the child to name parts of the body. questions that focus on coverage of content, use of
language, style of presentation and difficulties in home
Under each objective, three principles were
implementation. Questionnaires were given to the
taken, namely: Creating a need to communicate in the
parents and special educators for one week reading at
environment, Role reversal and Hiding objects. Under
the end of which Questions were answered. In order to
each principle three activities were listed, which was 20
2
39
analyze the data, the rating points were scored as
based on home environment/ home based.
follows: 1 - No, 2 - Very limited/ little, 3 - Mostly suitable/
IV. Results
For this study 20 parents and 20 special
educators were selected and most of the parents and
© 2013 Global Journals Inc. (US)
Language Stimulation for Children with Mental Retardation-An Activity Manual for Parents
Table 3 : Mean, Standard deviation and t-value for the two groups i.e. Parents (P) and Special Educators (SE)
Year 2013
P 2.85 .74 -2.284NS
Q.6. SE 3.3 .47
P 3.05 .22 .000NS
Q.7. SE 3.05 .60
P 3.35 .48 .000NS 20
2
41
Q.8. SE 3.35 .74
P 3.05 .51 -.273NS
Table 4, shows the comparison between two noted that the language is very easy. It can be
groups for coverage of the content of the activity manual concluded that language level was found to be easy or
among both groups. Relevant questions 2 to 4 are very easy.
included in this table. The results clearly indicate that in Table 6 shows the comparison between parent
both the groups the agreement is in the most suitable and special educator groups regarding the style of
category. While 80% of parents and 75% special presentation in activity manual as judged by the
educators ratings are obtained Q.No.2, for Q.No.3. 80% subjects; these aspects were included in Q.No.8 & 9.
of parents and 70% of special educators agree that the The results indicate that both groups were in agreement
manual has very good suitable content. For Q.No.4, that the style of presentation is useful or very relevant.
55% of parents and 60% of special educators say
Question number 10 to14 were open ended
mostly stable, which indicates the coverage of content in
Year 2013
Year 2013
Making the child to listen is difficult 1
Beginning stage is quite difficult 1
How to teach the language in profound MR children 1
14. P No suggestions 4
The manual should be well explained 1
SE No suggestions 2 20
2
43
Social skills should be included 1
Suggestions for the siblings should be added 1
for her support, encouragement Ms Punam for helping (1995). New Delhi: Ministry of Social Justice &
in data collection and all the participants for their Empowerment (Govt. of India), Press.
participation in this study. 12. National Trust for the Welfare of persons with
Autism, Cerebral palsy, Mental Retardation and
VII. Conflict of Interests Multiple disabilities Act (1999). New Delhi: Ministry
of Social Justice & Empowerment (Govt. of India),
This research was not funded. This research Press.
work was a part of Master Thesis and has been
submitted to the Library of College of Speech and
Hearing as well as Mangalore University in 2006. During
research, First Author was a student of Master in
Year 2013