Women and
Islam
Week#1
By Dr. Monia Mazigh
Summer, 2016©
2
Historical Context
The events of today are the reflection of
history
Todayin Canada, can we speak about
the women mouvement without knowing
the Famous Five or the suffragettes?
3
Map of the Middle East
4
Our Main Reading
“Women and Gender in Islam: Historical
Roots of a Modern Debate” by Leila
Ahmed, Yale University Press, 1992
5
Leila Ahmed
Leila Ahmed, born 1940, is an Egyptian
American writer on Islam and Islamic feminism
as well as being the first women's studies
professor at Harvard Divinity School. Ahmed
was the recipient of the 2013 University of
Louisville Grawemeyer Award in Religion for her
analysis of the 'veiling' of Muslim women in the
United States.
6
Questions
How were women rights around the world
before Islam?
How were women rights in Arabia before
Islam?
What did Islam brought to women in the
7th century?
7
Main Points
Study Mesopotamia, Greece, Egypt, Iran
Judaism and Christianity and
Zoroastrianism were the prevailing
religions in the Byzantine and the Sasanian
empires: the two major powers at the rise
of Islam.
8
Main points
Subordination of women in the Ancient
Middle East appears to have become
institutionalized with the rise of urban
societies and with the rise of the archaic
state, by Lerner
Mesopotamia: first cities.
Class- based societies
Codification of laws
Paternity of property-heirs
9
Main Points
Control women sexuality (more children,
more free labours, more land, better
status)
“Respectable” women vs. “disreputable
women”
The harem of Assyrian king (12 century
BCE) consisted of 40 women. Just before
the Muslim conquest Khusrau 531-79 CE
consisted of some 12,000 women.
10
Main Points
Veilwas a sign of respectability. Married
women should wear it
Slaves and prostitutes can’t wear it
Upper class women had property rights,
managed their affairs. They had
privileges.
Their privileges came from their male
connection ( father, husband, sons…)
11
Main points
Mesopotamian, Persian, Hellenic and
Christian cultures shared the same
traditions and attitudes toward women:
veil, seclusion
Diminished role: sexual and reproductive
being
12
Sasanian Empire
Prevailed in Iraq-Iran region
Large harems
Zoroastrianism: patriarchal family, total
obedience of the wife to her husband
13
Rare gold Dinar of Khusrau II
14
Byzantine Empire
Religion: Christianity
Prevailed in Syria and Turkey
Main aspect: chastity of women, virginity
Many Christian women died in martyrs for not
willing to renounce to their vows of chastity
Important to note that the celibacy notion
constituted a big threat to male authority and
to the socioreligious order of the time and of
the region
15
Gold Solidus of Heraclius and
son
16
Mediterranean Region
Boy birth is greeted with cries of joy but
not for the girl.
Early marriages for girls
Women seclusion
Veil is the sign of respectability: honest vs.
prostitute
Using the eunuchs to enforce the
separation and guard the women space
17
Ancient Greek
The qualities admired in girls were silence
and submissiveness
Socrates, attributed the fall of Sparta to
granting freedom to women, a freedom
that pushed women to prostitution.
Aristotle: “the purpose of marriage and
the function of women was to provide
heirs”
18
Ancient Egypt
Same rights as men to terminate marriages.
No polygamy for men…
Woman had the right to own property and to
inheritance.
She maintained the family during her
husband's absence.
But, she depended on man who was the
master.
Women were offered as sacrifice to the Nile
River and to the gods.
19
Ancient Egyptian Marriage
The purpose of marriage among
Egyptians was the shared life and the
pleasures and comforts it offers.
The more Greek and Roman laws spread
the less rights for Egyptian women.
20
Judaism, Christianism and
Patriarchy
Patriarchal ideas and regulations
regarding women in Judaism were
influenced by Mesopotamian laws.
Polygamy, concubinage, unrestricted
divorce for men were allowed in Judaism
Some aspects were later accepted by
Christianism but not polygamy for
instance
21
Other civilizations in brief
InIndia female were excluded from
inheritance. A female is always
dependent of a man.
Old Chinese say: “Women is like a ball,
the harder you kick it the higher it goes”
22
Arabia Before the rise of Islam
No right to inheritance
Different types of marriages: patrilineal,
matrilineal, uxorilocal, polyandrous and
polygamous.
Infanticide reserved mainly for girls. Woman
was considered as shame and disgrace.
Some women were ‘naditum’ or priestesses.
They enjoyed high social status
23
What Islam Brought to Women
in the 7th century?
There is no original sin attributed to
woman in Islam.
The message of the Quran is universal: to
men and women
Woman is Equal to man in reward and
punishment.
24
Verse about equal reward
"If
any do deeds of righteousness, be they
male or female, and have faith, they will
enter Heaven and not the least injustice
will be done to them." S. 4, A. 124.
25
Verse about equality
"O mankind! Fear your Guardian Lord,
who created you from a single soul,
created, out of it, his mate, and from
them twain scattered (like seeds)
countless men and women; Fear Allah,
through Whom ye demand your mutual
(rights), and be heedful of the wombs
(that bore you); for Allah ever watches
over you." S. 4 A. 1.
26
Verse intended for Men and
Women
"For Muslim men and women, for believing
men and women, for devout men and
women, for true men and women, for men
and women who are patient and constant,
for men and women who humble themselves,
for men and women who give in charity, for
men and women who fast, for men and
women who guard their chastity, and for men
and women who engage much in Allah's
remembrance, for them has Allah prepared
forgiveness and great reward." S. 33, A. 35.
27
Quranic text about Adam and
Eve
"And we said: 'O Adam! Dwell thou and
thy wife in the Garden; and eat of the
bountiful things therein as (when and
where) you will, but approach not this
tree, or you run into harm and
transgression.'" - S. 2, A. 35,
"Then we said: "O Adam! Verily, this is an
enemy to thee and thy wife: so let him not
get you both out of the garden, so that
thou art landed in misery." S. 20, A. 117.
28
Islam gave women rights
Right to inheritance
Right to divorce
Right to financial independence
Polygamy was limited to four wives with
the strong condition to limit to ONE wife
29
The Issue of Inheritance
Inheritance for woman is half of a man
But:
Woman in Islam do not to spend on their
family. They keep their wealth for
themselves
30
The Issue of stoning
The Quran speaks about lashes to the
adulterer and the adulteress. Nothing
about stoning
“The adulteress and the adulterer, each
receives a hundred lashes” S.42:2
Today in Iran and Pakistan only women
are stoned, why about men
31
The Issue of “Qiwama”
Qiwama is being in charge of ( protector
and maintainer)
“Men are the protectors and maintainers
of women, because God has given the
one more [strength] than the other, and
because they support them from their
means. Therefore the righteous women
are devoutly obedient and guard in [the
husband’s] absence what God would
have them guard”S.4:
32
Shared obligations
Men are responsible for protecting
women from harm and providing food
and shelter for them.
Women should remain faithful to their
husbands
If ONE of the TWO fails to fulfill the
obligations then punishments ensue for
BOTH.
33
The Issue of Polygamy
Allthe Muslim scholar agree that the verse
about polygamy was received after the
battle of ‘Uhud’ where large number of
Muslim men were killed.
The patriarchal interpretation of the verse
embraced the possibility to take FOUR
wives and didn’t insist on the the
condition of Equality and Justice.
34
Your thoughts…
