Money Market Analysis Project Report
Money Market Analysis Project Report
SUBMITTED BY
T.Y.B.F.M [SEMESTER V]
DIV.: A
ROLL NO.: 42
ACADEMIC YEAR
2016-2017
DATE OF SUBMISSION
7TH SEPTEMBER, 2017
A|Page
CERTIFICATE
____________________ ____________________
MRS. POOJA SINGH MR. PARAG AJAGAONKAR
BFM CO-ORDINATOR PRINCIPAL
PROJECT GUIDE
____________________
EXAMINER
i|Page
DECLARATION
____________________
ii | P a g e
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I wish to appreciate the SVKM management and Narsee Monjee College for
providing all the required facilities. I would like to thank the Principal, Dr.
Parag Aja for her dynamic leadership.
I would also like to thank the BFM Coordinator, and my Project Guide Mrs.
Pooja Ma’am for all her support and help. I also wish to thank her for guiding
me throughout the project and without whose support; the project may not have
taken shape.
I also appreciate all the support provided by the library staff and the teaching
and supporting staff of N.M. College for providing all the necessary academic
content and the entire state of the art infrastructure and resources to enable the
completion of my project.
Finally, I thank all my friends and family members who have directly or
indirectly helped me towards the execution of this project.
iii | P a g e
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A financial market is a market in which people and entities can trade financial
securities, commodities, and other fungible items of value at low transaction
costs and at prices that reflect supply and demand.
Money market being the component of the financial market is a market for
dealing with financial assets and securities which have a maturity period of up to
one year. In other words, it’s a market for purely short-term funds. The Indian
money market involves variety of instruments in which different participants
trade. It involves short term borrowing, lending, buying and selling with short
maturities periods.
The analysis includes in-depth study of Indian money market only thereby
allowing room to understand what Indian money market is all about.
This study can be used for further research and analysis to abstract different
point of views and come up with some other conclusions.
It can be used to analyze the development and reform pattern of the market.
It may help to develop new reforms or modification in the Indian money
market.
iv | P a g e
Limitations of the Study
v|Page
TABLE OF CONTENTS
vi | P a g e
XVII. Overview of International Money 60.
Market
XVIII. Primary Data Analysis 62.
XIX. Suggestions 65.
XX. Conclusion 67.
XXI. Bibliography 68.
XXII. Annexure 69.
vii | P a g e
INTRODUCTION
A financial market is a market in which people and entities can trade financial
securities, commodities, and other fungible items of value at low transaction
costs and at prices that reflect supply and demand. Securities include stocks and
bonds, and commodities include precious metals or agricultural goods.
There are both general markets (where many commodities are traded) and
specialized markets (where only one commodity is traded). Markets work by
placing many interested buyers and sellers (including households, firms, and
government agencies) in one "place", thus making it easier for them to find each
other. An economy which relies primarily on interactions between buyers and
sellers to allocate resources without government intervention is known as
a market economy in contrast either to a command economy or to a non-market
economy such as a gift economy.
MONEY MARKET
CAPITAL MARKET
Money markets and capital markets are parts of financial markets. Capital
markets may be classified as primary markets and secondary markets. In primary
markets, new stock or bond issues are sold to investors via a mechanism known
as underwriting. In the secondary markets, existing securities are sold and bought
among investors or traders, usually on a securities exchange, over-the-counter, or
elsewhere.
2|Page
History of Indian Money Market
Till 1935, when the RBI was set up, the Indian Money Market remained highly
disintegrated, unorganized, narrow shallow and therefore very backward. The
planned economic development that commenced in the year 1951 market an
important beginning in the channels of the Indian money market.
To implement the three objectives of Monetary Policy – growth, equity and price
stability.
To control credit flow according to policy priorities.
Providing an equilibrium mechanism for ironing out short-term surplus and
deficits.
To provide a reasonable access to users of short-term funds to meet their
requirements quickly, adequately and at reasonable costs.
To provide room for overcoming short-term deficits.
To enable the Central Bank to influence and regulate liquidity in the economy
through its intervention in this market.
To provide a parking place to employ short-term surplus funds by assisting in
mobilizing the savings.
3|Page
REVIEW OF LITERATURE
4|Page
These findings can enhance our understanding of the interaction between
policy announcements and money market microstructure and serve as a
useful guide in furthering money market reforms in India.
1. CA. Neetu Singhania (faculty), Ms. Ashruti Singh and Ms. Janvi Prajapat (students)
are from Thakur Institute of Management Studies and Research.
3. Saurabh Ghosh and Indranil Bhattacharyya are assistant advisers in the Financial
Markets Department and Monetary Policy Department, respectively, of the Reserve
Bank of India.
5|Page
FEATURES OF INDIAN MONEY MARKET
3. In process of such a match of demand and supply of funds, the money market
provides an avenue for RBI in influencing both the quantum and cost of
liquidity in the financial system. Price differentials for assets of similar type
will tend to be eliminated by the interplay of demand & supply.
4. The sub markets have close inter- relationship & free movement of funds from
one sub-market to another.
7. It is a wholesale market & the volume of funds or financial assets traded are
very large i.e. in crores of rupees.
8. In fact, money market is the first and the most important stage in the chain of
monetary policy transmission. It provides the RBI with all possible measures
to make changes in the monetary policy and stabilize the financial system.
6|Page
FUNCTIONS AND IMPORTANCE OF
INDIAN MONEY MARKET
2. Financing Trade:
Money Market plays crucial role in financing both internal as well as
international trade. Commercial finance is made available to the traders through
bills of exchange, which are discounted by the bill market. The acceptance houses
and discount markets help in financing foreign trade.
3. Financing Industry:
Money market contributes to the growth of industries in two ways:
7|Page
a. Money market helps the industries in securing short-term loans to meet their
working capital requirements through the system of finance bills, commercial
papers, etc.
b. Industries generally need long-term loans, which are provided in the capital
market. However, capital market depends upon the nature of and the
conditions in the money market. The short-term interest rates of the money
market influence the long-term interest rates of the capital market. Thus,
money market indirectly helps the industries through its link with and
influence on long-term capital market.
4. Profitable Investment:
Money market enables the commercial banks to use their excess reserves in
profitable investment. The main objective of the commercial banks is to earn
income from its reserves as well as maintain liquidity to meet the uncertain cash
demand of the depositors. In the money market, the excess reserves of the
commercial banks are invested in near-money assets (e.g. short-term bills of
exchange) which are highly liquid and can be easily converted into cash. Thus,
the commercial banks earn profits without losing liquidity. Also it becomes
convenient for the banks to maintain the statutory requirements of CRR and SLR.
8|Page
a. The short-run interest rates of the money market serves as an indicator of the
monetary and banking conditions in the country and, in this way, guide the
central bank to adopt an appropriate banking policy.
b. The sensitive and integrated money market helps the central bank to secure
quick and widespread influence on the sub-markets, and thus achieve effective
implementation of its policy.
9|Page
STRUCTURE OF INDIAN MONEY MARKET
Structure Of
Indian Money
Market
ORGANIZED UNORGANIZED
DHFI Primary
dealers, Devp. Nidhis and Chit
Banks funds
10 | P a g e
2. Unorganized sector- Those institutions which fall completely outside the
purview of the central banking regulations, make up the unorganized sector.
This is the sector where the regulations have evolved by the customers and
the practices of trade. It is largely made up of indigenous bankers, money
lenders, traders, chits and nidhis.
3. Cooperative sector- After Indian got its independence in 1947, with the
advent of the planning process cooperatives became an integral part of The
First Five Year Plan. As a result, they emerged as a distinct segment in our
national economy. Different States drew up various schemes for the
cooperative movement for organizing large size-societies and provision of
State partnership and assistance. It consists of state cooperative bank, state
land development banks, etc.
11 | P a g e
MERITS OF INDIAN MONEY MARKET
The following are Money Market advantages, that are available to their
purchasers:
1. Liquidity:
Money Markets are highly liquid instruments, in that you can withdraw from
them at any time, usually without any sort of interest penalty. There are no finite
terms associated with a Money Market instrument. In contrast, a CD (Certificate
of Deposit) requires a minimum amount of duration before you can touch the
principal, and imposes interest penalties for early withdrawal.
4. Minimum Deposit:
Today's internet-based Money Markets very often do not require any sort of
minimum deposits. That means, you can open an account with as little as $ 1.
5. Higher Yield:
Internet-based Money Market Instruments generally offer higher yields than their
brick-and-mortar (e.g., banks) counterparts. This is largely due to the reduced
overhead necessary to administrate an internet-based instrument.
12 | P a g e
DEMERITS OF INDIAN MONEY MARKET
However, since 1969, and more so after 1992, branch banking has been speeded
up. It is to be noted that the banking system is lacking in the rural areas due to
the problem of overheads or the problem of maintaining branches. Considering
the size of rural areas in India, the percentage of branches must be higher.
2. Shortage of Funds:
The Indian Money Market is characterized by shortage of funds. Demand
for short term funds far exceeds the supply. This results in high interest rates.
However, of late, banks are flush with funds, especially in urban areas, as people
prefer to keep their money in banks rather than investing in shares or keeping as
deposits with unorganized sector.
13 | P a g e
However, RBI attempts to reduce the seasonal fluctuations in the money market
by pumping money in the money market during the busy season and withdrawing
the same during off season.
14 | P a g e
MONEY MARKET ACCOUNT
A money market account is a financial account that pays interest base on current
interest rates in the money markets. Money market accounts have a high rate of
interest and require minimum balance to earn interest or avoid monthly fees.
Professional money managers will take your cash and invest it in government t-
bills (aka "treasuries"), savings bonds, certificates of deposit, and other safe and
conservative short term commercial paper. They then turn around and pay you,
the owner of the money market, your portion of the interest earned on those
investments.
Most banks offer money market accounts to their customers, although the amount
of interest paid will vary by account size. Generally, the highest interest rates are
paid to those who invest larger amount of money.
Money market accounts are frequently used to park cash between investments.
15 | P a g e
Furthermore, we'll take a look at how the interest on money market accounts
works.
Interest rates paid by money market accounts can vary quite a bit from bank to
bank. That's because some banks are trying harder to get people to open an
account with them than others -- so they offer higher rates.
Another difference you'll sometimes find with money market accounts is that the
more money you have in the account the higher the interest rate you get. Always
check with the bank about how the interest rate may change.
16 | P a g e
INSTRUMENTS IN INDIAN MONEY MARKET
17 | P a g e
1. TREASURY BILL
In the short term, the lowest risk category instruments are the treasury bills.
RBI issues these at a prefixed day and a fixed amount. These are four types of
treasury bills.
14-day T-bill maturity is in 14 days. Its auction is on every Friday of every week.
The notified amount for this auction is Rs. 100 crores.
91-day T-bill maturity is in91 days. Its auction is on every Friday of every week.
The notified amount for this auction is Rs. 100 crores.
18 | P a g e
364-Day T-bill maturity is in 364 days. Its auction is on every alternate
Wednesday (which is a reporting week). The notified amount for this auction is
Rs. 500 crores.
* If the day of payment falls on a holiday, the payment is made on the day after the
holiday.
The usual investors in these instruments are banks who invest not only to part
their short-term surpluses but also since it forms part of their SLR investments,
insurance companies and FIs. FIIs so far have not been allowed to invest in this
instrument.
The table shows that the primary dealers are the most major holders or purchasers
of the treasury bills. As they are permitted directly purchase the securities from
19 | P a g e
the market to enjoy the benefits of short term investing. This is followed by banks
who invests in order to meet their liquidity. Also, state government have also
invested in T-Bills but at a much lesser extent than the other two holders. Among
the three prevalent bills 91-day T-Bills are most preferred by all of them.
The returns on T-bills are dependent on the rates prevalent on other investment
avenues open for investors. Low yield on T-bills, generally a result of high
liquidity in banking system as indicated by low call rates, would divert the funds
from this market to other markets. This would be particularly so, if banks already
hold the minimum stipulated amount (SLR) in government paper.
The call market enables the banks and institutions to even out their day-to-day
deficits and surpluses of money.
20 | P a g e
Commercial banks, Co-operative Banks and primary dealers are allowed to
borrow and lend in this market for adjusting their cash reserve requirements.
It is a completely inter-bank market hence non-bank entity are not allowed access
to this market.
Interest rates in the call and notice money market are market determined i.e by
demand and supply of short term funds. In India, 80% demand comes from public
sector banks and remaining 20% from foreign and private sector banks.
In view of the short tenure of such transactions, both the borrowers and the
lenders are required to have current accounts with the Reserve Bank of India.
It serves as an outlet for deploying funds on short term basis to the lenders having
steady inflow of funds.
As seen in Table 1, the call money market has grown double i.e. from Rs. 179.9
billion to Rs. 314.5 billion during the last week of 2016. Hight liquidity has played
a dominant role in the participation in this avenue. The notice and the term money
market combined have however seen a down swing in the turnover since 2015. This
shows the tendency of reduced preference by the participants in this market.
21 | P a g e
3. COMMER CIAL PAPER
CPs is negotiable short-term unsecured promissory notes with fixed maturities,
issued by well rated companies generally sold on discount basis. The participants
are primary dealers, all India financial institutions and corporates that have been
permitted by to raise short term resources as fixed by RBI. CP’s have a minimum
maturity period of 15 days and a maximum of 1 year. The special feature of this
instrument is that the issuer can buy back its own security. They are issued in
multiple of 5 lakhs and the minimum size of each issue is 5 lakhs.
For example, Companies can issue CPs either directly to the investors or through
banks /merchant banks (called dealer paper). Merchant bankers and IPA are
appointed and a resolution from the BOD is to be obtained along with approval
by credit rating agencies like CRISIL, ICRA, etc. The issue process should be
complete within a time span of 2 weeks. These are basically instruments
evidencing the liability of the issuer to pay the holder in due course a fixed
amount (face value of the instrument) on the specified due date. These are issued
for a fixed period of time at a discount to the face value and mature at par.
Issuer
Company
Investor
Bank/Company
22 | P a g e
Ideally, the discount rates on CPs ought to be determined by the demand and
supply factors in the money market and the interest rates on the other hand
competing money market instruments such as certificate of deposits(CDs),
commercial bills and treasury bills. It has been noticed that in a comparatively
stable and low rate conditions in the money market, the discount rates in the CP
markets do somewhat soften whereas in the tight money market situation it may
not be possible even for a best rated company to issue CPs at lower rates than the
lending rates on its banks lines of credit. This is partly for the reason that banks
could also firm up the lending rates during such periods. The maturity
management of CPs should also affect the CP rates. It has been observed that in
a period of prolong low and steady money market rates there is no significant
different between the discount rates if CPs for 90 and 180 days.
Advantages of CP’s
The advantage of CP lies in its simplicity involving less paper work as
large amounts can be raised without having any underlying transaction.
It gives flexibility to the company by providing an additional option of
raising funds particularly when the conditions prevailing in the money
market are favorable.
CPs facilitate securitization of loans. As a result a secondary market for
the efficient movements of funds is created.
For the company, the cost of capital is reduced considerably because it can
raise 75% of its working capital limit through issue of CPs at somewhat
lower interest rates, thereby enables it to reduce the overall cost of short-
term funds.
The borrowers effective interest cost is lower than the prescribed lending
rate as this system affords flexibility to borrowers to reduce the outstanding
as and when surplus funds accrue to them.
A well rated company can raise funds from different investors like banks,
NRIs, individual investors, etc.
23 | P a g e
4. CERTIFICATE OF DEPOSIT (CD)
CD is a negotiable money market instrument and issued in dematerialized
form or as a Usance Promissory Note, for funds deposited at a bank or other
eligible financial institutions for a specified time period. Banks can issue CDs
for maturities from 7 days to one a year whereas eligible FIs can issue for
maturities 1 year to 3 years. Due to their negotiable nature, they are also
known as Negotiable Certificate of Deposit (NCD). After treasury bills, the
next lowest risk category investment option is the CD.
CD should be issued in denomination of 1 lakh of maturity value or face value.
They are to be purchased for a minimum of Rs. 1 lakh or in a multiple of Rs.
1 lakh. Bank CDs are usually issued at a discount to the face value, whereas
FIs issue coupon bearing security.
A CD is issued at a discount to the face value, the discount rate being negotiated
between the issuer and the investor. Though RBI allows CDs up to one-year
maturity, the maturity most quoted in the market is for 90 days. The issue of CDs
reached a high in the last two years as banks faced with reducing deposit base
secured funds by these means. The foreign and private banks, especially, which
24 | P a g e
do not have large branch networks and hence lower deposit base use this
instrument to raise funds. They may be referred to as a receipt for funds
deposited in a FI for a specific time, for a specific interest rate. The rates on
these deposits are determined by various factors. Low call rates would mean
higher liquidity in the market. Also, the interest rate on one-year bank deposits
acts as a lower barrier for the rates in the market.
6. REPO MARKET
The major function of the money market is to provide liquidity. To achieve this
function and to even out liquidity changes, the Reserve Bank uses repos.
A Reverse Repo is the mirror image of a repo. For, in a reverse repo, lending of
funds against buying of securities with an agreement to resell the said securities
on a mutually agreed future date at an agreed price which included interest for
the funds lent i.e. securities are acquired with a simultaneous commitment to
resell.
It can be seen from the aforementioned that there are two legs to the same
transactions in a repo/ reverse repo. The duration between the two legs is called
the ‘repo period’. Hence whether a transaction is a repo or a reverse repo is
determined only in terms of who initiated the first leg of the transaction. When
the reverse repurchase transaction matures, the counter- party returns the security
to the entity concerned and receives its cash along with a profit spread. One factor
which encourages an organization to enter into reverse repo is that it earns some
extra income on its otherwise idle cash. The difference between the price at which
the securities are bought and sold is the lender’s profit or interest earned for
lending the money. The transaction combines elements of both a securities
purchased/sales operation and also a money market borrowing/lending operation.
26 | P a g e
These mutual funds would invest exclusively in money marketinstruments.
Money market mutual funds bridge the gap between small investors and the
money market. It mobilizes saving from small investors and invests them in
short-term debt instruments or money market instruments.
The above table reflects the fact that the money market MF have performed better
than the deposits of a bank due to its diversification into a large number of money
market securities. The 1-year return of the MF has been 8.26% as against 7.25-
7.5% returns of the bank deposits for the financial year 2015-2016.
8. COMMERCIAL BILLS:
Commercial bill is a short term, negotiable, and self-liquidating instrument
with low risk. It enhances he liability to make payment in a fixed date when
goods are bought on credit. According to the Indian Negotiable Instruments
Act, 1881, bill or exchange is a written instrument containing
an unconditional order, signed by the maker, directing to pay a certain amount
of money only to a particular person, or to the bearer of the instrument. Bills
of exchange are negotiable instruments drawn by the seller (drawer) on the
buyer (drawee) or the value of the goods delivered to him. Such bills
are called trade bills. When trade bills are accepted by commercial banks, they
are called commercial bills. The bank discounts this bill by keeping a certain
margin and credits the proceeds. Banks, when in need of money, can also get
such bills rediscounted by financial institutions such as LIC, UTI, GIC, ICICI
and IRBI.
The maturity period of the bills varies from 30 days, 60 days or 90 days,
depending on the credit extended in the industry.
(1) The schemes was announced under section 17(4)(c) of RBI Act enables it to
make advances to scheduled banks against the security of issuance of
promissory notes or bills drawn on and payable in India and arising out of
bonafide commercial or trade transaction bearing two or more good signatures
one of which should be that of scheduled bank and maturing within 90 days
from the date of advances.
28 | P a g e
(2) The scheduled banks were required to convert a portion of the demand
promissory notes obtained by them, from their constituents in respect of
loans/overdrafts and cash credits granted to them into usance promissory notes
maturing within 90 days, to be able to avail of refinance under the scheme;
(3) The existing loan, cash credit or overdraft accounts were, therefore, required
to be split up into two parts viz., (A) one part was to remain covered by the
demand promissory notes, in this account further.
They are issued in order to finance the fiscal deficit and managing the temporary
cash mismatches of the Government. All entities registered in India like banks,
financial institutions, Primary Dealers, firms, companies, corporate bodies,
partnership firms, institutions, mutual funds, Foreign Institutional Investors,
State Governments, Provident Funds, trusts, research organizations, Nepal
Rashtra bank and even individuals are eligible to purchase Government
Securities. They are generally by banks and institutions with the Reserve Bank
of India in Subsidiary General Ledger accounts. They can be held in special
accounts known as Constituent Subsidiary General Ledger (CSGL) accounts
which can be opened with banks and Primary Dealers or in dematerialized form
in demat accounts maintained with the Depository Participants of NSDL.
29 | P a g e
Zero Partly Bonds with Capital
Dated Floating
Coupon Paid Call/ Put Indexed
Securities Rate Bonds
Bonds Stock Option Bonds
Interest rate
is fixed as a
Interest or Interest or percentage
Interest rate
coupon rate is coupon rate is over a This bond is
is fixed as a
fixed at the fixed at the predefined due for
percentage
time of Do not carry time of benchmark redemption
over the
issuance, and any interest issuance, and rate which in 2012 and
wholesale
remains rate remains may be carries a
price index
constant till constant till Treasury coupon of
at the time
redemption of redemption of bill, bank 6.72%
of issuance.
the security the security rate etc at
the time of
issuance
This bond
The tenor of The tenor of The tenor of The tenor has been The tenor of
security is security is security is of security priced in security is
fixed fixed fixed is fixed line with 5- fixed
year bonds
30 | P a g e
The The
The security is The security The security is security is This bond principal
redeemed at is redeemed redeemed at redeemed at has been redemption
par (face value) at par (face par (face par (face priced in is linked to
on its maturity value) on its value) on its value) on line with 5- the
date maturity date maturity date its maturity year bonds Wholesale
date Price Index.
The PC is an instrument whereby a bank can sell to a third party a part or all
of a loan made by bank to a client. Within a span of a decade PCs became very
popular after which the RBI advised the banks to achieve a significant and
31 | P a g e
lasting reduction in their recourse to PCs. Thus, the PC scheme was replaced
with Inter Bank Participation (IBPs).
32 | P a g e
PARTICIPANTS IN INDIAN MONEY MARKET
The major participants who supply the funds and demand the same in the money
market are as follows:
2. Banks:
Commercial Banks and the Co-operative Banks are the major participants in the
Indian money market. They mobilize the savings of the people through
acceptance of deposits and lend it to business houses for their short- term working
capital requirements. While a portion of these deposits is invested in medium
and long-term Government securities and corporate shares and bonds, they
provide short-term funds to the Government by investing in the Treasury Bills.
They employ the short-term surpluses in various money market instruments.
5. Corporates:
Companies create demand for funds from the banking system. They raise short-
term funds directly from the money market by issuing commercial paper.
Moreover, they accept public deposits and also indulge in inter- corporate
deposits and investments.
33 | P a g e
6. Mutual Funds:
Mutual funds also invest their surplus funds in various money market
instruments for short periods. They are also permitted to participate in the Call
Money Market. Money Market Mutual Funds have been set up specifically
for the purpose of mobilization of short-term funds for investment in money
market instruments.
34 | P a g e
ROLE OF MONEY MARKET IN CONTEXT TO GROWTH
OF INDIAN ECONOMY
Indian Financial Market helps in promoting the savings of the economy - helping
to adopt an effective channel to transmit various financial policies. The Indian
financial sector is well developed, competitive, efficient and integrated to face all
shocks. In India, financial market there are various types of financial products
whose prices are determined by the numerous buyers and sellers in the market.
The other determinant factor of the prices of the financial products is the market
forces of demand and supply.
Indian money market has seen exponential growth just after the globalization
initiative in 1992. It has been observed that financial institutions do employ
money market instruments for financing short-term monetary requirements of
various sectors such as agriculture, finance and manufacturing. The performance
of the India money market has been outstanding in the past 20 years.
Central bank of the country - the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has always been
playing the major role in regulating and controlling the India money market. The
intervention of RBI is varied - curbing crisis situations by reducing the cash
reserve ratio (CRR) or infusing more money in the economy.
35 | P a g e
liquidity risk. The banking system and the money market represent the exclusive
setting monetary policy operates in. A developed, active and efficient interbank
market enhances the efficiency of central bank’s monetary policy, transmitting
its impulses into the economy best. Thus, the development of the money market
soothes the progress of financial intermediation and boosts lending to economy,
hence improving the country’s economic and social welfare.
Risk Sharing:
One of the most important functions of a financial system is to achieve an optimal
allocation of risk. There are many studies directly analyzing the interaction of the
risk sharing role of financial systems and economic growth. One importance of
risk sharing on economic growth comes from the fact that while risk-avers
generally do not like risk, high-return projects tend to be riskier than low return
projects. Thus, financial markets that ease risk diversification tend to induce a
portfolio shift onwards projects with higher expected returns show that cross
sectional risk diversification can stimulate risky innovative activity for
sufficiently risk-averse agents. The ability to hold a diversified portfolio of
innovative projects reduces risk and promotes investment in growth-enhancing
innovative activities.
Liquidity:
Money market funds provide valuable liquidity by investing in commercial
paper, municipal securities and repurchase agreements: Money market funds are
significant participants in the commercial paper, municipal securities and
repurchase agreement (or repo) markets. Money market funds hold almost 40%
of all outstanding commercial paper, which is now the primary source for short-
term funding for corporations. The repo market is an important means by which
the Federal Reserve conducts monetary policy and provides daily liquidity to
global financial institutions.
Diversification:
For both individual and institutional investors, money market mutual funds
provide a commercially attractive alternative to bank deposits. Money market
funds offer greater investment diversification, are less susceptible to collapse
than banks and offer investors greater disclosure on the nature of their
36 | P a g e
investments and the underlying assets than traditional bank deposits. For the
financial system generally, money market mutual funds reduce pressure on the
FDIC, reduce systemic risk and provide essential liquidity to capital markets
because of the funds’ investments in commercial paper, municipal securities and
repurchase agreements.
2. Bank’s ability to make loans (asset of the bank) depends on its ability to
mobilize deposits (liability of the bank) as total assets and liabilities of the
bank need to match and expand/contract together.
3. Banks’ need to hold balances at the central bank for settlement of claims
within the banking system as these transactions are settled through the
accounts of banks maintained with the central bank. Therefore, the daily
functioning of a modern economy and its financial system creates a demand
for central bank reserves which increases along with an expansion in overall
economic activity (Friedman, 2000).
Financial reforms in India began in the early 1990s. However, various segments
of domestic financial markets, viz., money market, debt market and forex market
underwent significant shifts mainly from the 1990s. Earlier, the Indian money
market was characterized by paucity of instruments, lack of depth and distortions
in the market micro-structure. It mainly consisted of uncollateralized call market,
treasury bills, commercial bills and participation certificates.
39 | P a g e
Withdrawal of interest rate ceilings in the money market.
Introduction of auctions in treasury bills.
Gradual move away from the cash credit system to a loan-based system.
Maturities of other existing instruments such as CP and CDs were also gradually
shortened to encourage wider participation.
5. Prudential limits on exposure of banks and PDs to call/notice market in April 2005
7. Transformation of call money market into a pure inter-bank market by August 2005
8. Widening of collateral base by making state government securities (SDLs) eligible for LAF operations since April 2007
9. Operationalisation of a screen-based negotiated system (NDS-CALL) developed by CCIL for all dealings in the
call/notice and the term money markets in September 2006. The reporting of all such transactions made compulsory
through NDS-CALL in November 2012.
10. Repo in corporate bonds allowed in March 2010.
11. Operationalisation of a reporting platform for secondary market transactions in CPs and CDs in July 2010.
Most importantly, the ad hoc treasury bills were abolished in 1997 thereby
putting a stop to automatic monetisation of fiscal deficit. This enhanced the
instrument independence of the Reserve Bank (Table 4). More importantly,
efforts were made to transform the call money market into primarily an inter-
bank market, while encouraging other market participants to migrate towards
collateralised segments of the market, thereby increasing overall market stability
and diversification. In order to facilitate the phasing out of corporate and the non-
banks from the call money market, new instruments such as market repos and
collateralised borrowing and lending obligations (CBLO) were introduced to
provide them avenues for managing their short-term liquidity. Non-bank entities
completely exited the call money market by August 2005. In order to minimise
40 | P a g e
the default risk and ensure balanced development of various market segments,
the Reserve Bank instituted prudential limits on exposure of banks and primary
dealers (PDs) to the call/notice money market.
41 | P a g e
In the development of various constituents of the money market, the most significant
aspect was the growth of the collateralised market vis-à-vis the uncollateralised
market. Over the last decade, while the daily turnover in the call money market either
stagnated or declined, that of the collateralised segment, market repo plus CBLO,
increased manifold (Chart 2). Since 2007-08, both the CP and CD volumes have also
increased very significantly (Chart 3). Furthermore, issuance of 91-treasury bills has
also increased sharply (Chart 4). The overall money market now is much larger
relative to GDP than a decade ago.
42 | P a g e
Alongside, the rates of return on various instruments in the money market have
shown greater co-movement. Such co-movement can be identified especially since
the introduction of LAF (Table 5 & Chart 5).
43 | P a g e
2005-06 6.2 5.6 5.3 5.4 5.7 6.0 6.7 6.1
44 | P a g e
MONETARY OPERATING PROCEDURE
45 | P a g e
Along with the multiple indicators approach, operating procedure also underwent
a change following the recommendation of Narasimham Committee II (1998).
The RBI introduced the Interim Liquidity Adjustment Facility (ILAF) in April
1999, under which liquidity injection was done at the Bank Rate and liquidity
absorption was through fixed reverse repo rate. The ILAF gradually transited into
a full-fledged liquidity adjustment facility (LAF) with periodic modifications
based on experience and development of financial markets and the payment
system. The LAF was operated through overnight fixed rate repo and reverse repo
from November 2004, which provided an informal corridor for the call money
rate.
First, the weighted average overnight call money rate was explicitly
recognised as the operating target of monetary policy.
Second, the repo rate was made the only one independently varying policy
rate.
Third, a new Marginal Standing Facility (MSF) was instituted under which
scheduled commercial banks (SCBs) could borrow overnight at 100 basis
points above the repo rate up to one per cent of their respective net demand
and time liabilities (NDTL). This limit was subsequently raised to two per
cent of NDTL and in addition, SCBs were allowed to borrow funds under
MSF on overnight basis against their excess SLR holdings as well.
46 | P a g e
Fourth, the revised corridor was defined with a fixed width of 200 basis
points. The repo rate was placed in the middle of the corridor, with the
reverse repo rate at 100 basis points below it and the MSF rate as well as
the Bank Rate at 100 basis points above it (Chart 6). Thus, under the new
operating procedure, all the three other rates announced by the Reserve
Bank, i.e., reverse repo rate, MSF rate and the Bank Rate, are linked to the
single policy repo rate.
The new operating procedure was expected to improve the implementation and
transmission of monetary policy for the following reasons. First, explicit
announcement of an operating target makes market participants clear about the
desired policy impact. Second, a single policy rate removes the confusion arising
out of policy rate alternating between the repo and the reverse repo rates, and
makes signaling of monetary policy stance more accurate. Third, MSF provides
a safety valve against unanticipated liquidity shocks. Fourth, a fixed interest rate
corridor set by MSF rate and reverse repo rate, reduces uncertainty and
communication difficulties and helps keep the overnight average call money rate
close to the repo rate.
47 | P a g e
Let me now turn to a brief evaluation of the experience with the new operating
procedure. In the implementation of the new procedure, the Reserve Bank prefers
to keep the systemic liquidity in deficit mode as monetary transmission is found
to be more effective in this situation (RBI, 2011). The Reserve Bank also
announced an indicative liquidity comfort zone of (+)/ (-) 1.0 per cent of net
demand and time liabilities (NDTL) of banks.
Since May 2011, the liquidity conditions can be broadly divided into three
distinct phases. After generally remaining within the Reserve Bank’s comfort
zone during the first phase during May-October 2011, the liquidity deficit crossed
the one per cent of NDTL level during November 2011 to June 2012. This large
liquidity deficit was mainly caused by forex intervention and increased
divergence between credit and deposit growth. The deficit conditions were
further aggravated by frictional factors like the build-up of government cash
balances with the Reserve Bank that persisted longer than anticipated and the
increase in currency in circulation. Accordingly, the Reserve Bank had to actively
manage liquidity through injection of liquidity by way of open market operations
(OMOs) and cut in cash reserve ratio (CRR) of banks. This was supported by
decline in currency in circulation and a reduction in government cash balances
with the Reserve Bank. As a result, there was a significant easing of liquidity
conditions since July 2012 with the extent of the deficit broadly returning to the
Reserve Bank’s comfort level of one per cent of NDTL (Chart 7).
48 | P a g e
Since its implementation, the systemic liquidity has been in deficit mode, which
has helped in better transmission of policy rate to various segments of money
markets. First, the overnight interest rate has been more stable since its
implementation (Chart 8).
Second, the repo rate and weighted call rate are far more closely aligned under
the new operating procedure than earlier; implying improved transmission of
monetary policy in terms of movement in call money market interest rate (Chart
9).
49 | P a g e
Third, the call money rate in turn is observed to be better aligned with other
money market interest rates after the implementation of new operating procedure
than before (Chart 10).
50 | P a g e
On all the points being accounted, the researcher concludes that the development
of money market and refinements in operating procedures of monetary policy
have moved in tandem. Financial sector reforms along with Reserve Bank’s
emphasis on development of various segments of financial market enabled shifts
in operating procedures based on direct quantity-based instruments to indirect
interest rate-based instruments. The Reserve Bank has been able to better transmit
monetary policy signals in the money market through a single policy repo rate.
Evidence so far suggests a significant improvement in monetary policy
transmission under the new operating framework.
1. The lending and deposit rates have been, considerably opened up and freed.
Deposit rates beyond one year have been freed, and deposit rates less than one
year linked or pegged to the Bank Rate. All re-finance; the OMO operations
and liquidity to the Primary Dealers (PDs) have been linked to the Bank Rate.
To that extent the Bank Rate has been emerging as a kind of reference rate in
the interest rate scenario.
2. The second interesting aspect has been that the borrowings by the
government (since 1992) have been at market rates i.e., the rate of interest are
presently determined by the market forces of demand and supply.
Integration of Markets
The other important aspect of the fixed income market is the close inter-linkage
between the money and debt segments. The Call, Notice & Term money markets
51 | P a g e
are to be made purely inter-bank markets. The non-bank participants are being
shifted to the Repo market. However, the existing players have been allowed to
park their short-term investments till they find other avenues. The corporates
have the facility of routing their call transactions through the PDs.
Primary Dealers
In order to make the government securities market more vibrant, liquid and to
ensure market making capabilities outside RBI a system of PD’s was established.
The PDs have been allowed to operate a current account and along with a
Subsidiary General Ledger (SGL) account. RBI has provided them liquidity
support facility. In order to facilitate their continued presence in auctions the RBI
invites bids for underwriting in respect of all auctions. Routing of operations in
the call money market is allowed through PD’s. They are allowed the facility
of funds from one centre to another under RBI’s Remittance facility scheme. The
number of PDs has been increased from 7 to 13. In fact, the introduction of PDs
has added to the liquidity in the market.
Term Rate
Inter-bank CRR, other than minimum 3% has been done away with. In this
direction the Interest Rate Swaps (IRS) have been introduced for the participants
to hedge their interest risks. For benchmarking we have the 14, 91 & 364 T-Bills.
Also we have the CPs. Now it is to the participants to use this opportunity.
52 | P a g e
Many Mutual Funds have started funds which specifically focus on money
market. This is due to increasing preference of the investors towards mutual funds
and the consolidation of the mutual fund industry. They have also been permitted
to invest in rated corporate bonds and debentures with a residual maturity of up
to only one year, within the ceiling existing for CP.
Others:
The securities have been revalued. Banks have been required to mark 70%
of their portfolio to market from the year 1998-99 and 75% from 1999-
2000.
FIIs have been allowed to trade in T. Bills within the overall debt ceiling.
They now have access to all types debt instruments.
53 | P a g e
MEASURES TO IMPROVE INDIAN MONEY MARKET
The major drawback of India Money Market is its high volatility. Gradually the
money market transaction is increasing. But, on the recommendation of the
Sukhmoy Chakravarty Committee (on the review of the working of the Monetary
System) and the Narasimham committee (on the Report on the working of the
financial system in India, 1991), following are some of the measures undertaken,
54 | P a g e
3. Relaxation of interest rate regulations:
The all types of interest rates like lending as well as deposit rates of the banks
and financial institution are controlled and regulated by RBI. But, gradually the
interest rates of the bank loans are controlled by the market forces which result
decontrolled of it.
55 | P a g e
STCI was set up in 1994 to provide a secondary market in government securities.
It operated only in respect of T-Bills and money at call and short notice. Post
2011, Finance Ltd. was added to its name and was the first and most prominent
PD in India. Currently it undertakes lending and financing activities along with
trading in corporate securities, government bonds, money market and derivative
instruments.
Transparency
56 | P a g e
RBI has embarked upon the technological upgradation of the debt market. This
includes screen-based trade reporting system with the use of VSAT
communication network complimented by a centralized SGL accounting system.
It shall also facilitate logging bids in auctions of dated securities and T-Bills. This
will broaden the participation in the auction system. The participants would be
required to provide two-way quotes. The system will be integrated with the
regional current account system. Nothing seems to have been finalized as of now.
Anyway this system may not really be effective enough to substitute the
telephonic mode of operation. The system as has been planned does not provide
for a participant to withhold his identity. Now this factor alone could lead to
inefficiencies in Price discovery, as in the case of a major participant having to
reveal his buy/sell interest. In fact, the market participants seem to be divided
over this issue. Some believe that the system as planned is proper while many
others believe that there would be no significant improvement. Anyway the RBI
seems to have decided to eliminate the brokers from the system. The banks feel
that the brokers would remain. The brokers maintain that this system would not
lead to the best price discovery. It is not very wise for the participants to release
their identity and interest.
Awareness
The government along with the RBI has decided to do some publicity work.
Market Microstructure
To develop the primary and the secondary markets the following points need
careful evaluation.
1. At present the PDs underwrite a sizeable portion of the market loans and also
quote an underwriting commission. It has been suggested that it be made
compulsory for them to bid for a minimum percent for a minimum percent of
the notified amount. By increasing the number of PDs the total bids should be
brought upto 100% of the notified amount.
2. The RBI should try and move out of the primary auctions but this transition
could take upto 20% of the notified amount. In case of the issue being not
fully subscribed the RBI should have the option of canceling the entire issue.
3. Gradually the RBI should move out of the 14-day and 91-day T-Bill auction
and then the 364 -day auction and then finally from the dated of securities.
The RBI should have a strong presence in the secondary market by means
of providing two-way quotes.
58 | P a g e
Standardization of Practices
Standard practices in the market need to be evolved with regard to the manner of
quotes, conclusion of deals, etc. It has been proposed that the Primary Dealers
Association and FIMMDA quickly setup a timeframe for CP. The minimum the
documentation and market practices, minimum the lock in period. If needed RBI
will come forward and indicate a time frame. Most importantly the code of
conduct will have to be compatible with the contemplated dealing screen and the
technological upgradation.
Risk Management
Investors in debt instrument face three major types of risks namely credit risk,
interest rate risk and foreign currency risk. In case of the government securities
the credit risk is zero. For the domestic investors the foreign exchange risk is
none. Investment in all debt instruments is exposed to interest rate risk.
Introduction of rupee derivatives will go a long way in providing investors an
opportunity to hedge their exposures. IRS and FRA have already been
introduced. Also there is a need for the dealers (especially in PSU banks) to be
provided with more freedom to make decisions. Finally it remains on the
willingness of the participants to trade. This indeed would provide the needed
fillip to the market.
59 | P a g e
OVERVIEW OF INTERNATIONAL MONEY MARKET
The International Monetary Market (IMM) was introduced in December 1971
and formally implemented in May 1972, although its roots can be traced to the
end of Bretton Woods through the 1971 Smithsonian Agreement and Nixon's
suspension of U.S. dollar's convertibility to gold. The IMM Exchange was
formed as a separate division of the Chicago Mercantile Exchange, and as of
2009, was the second largest futures exchange in the world. The primary purpose
of the IMM is to trade currency futures, a relatively new product previously
studied by academics as a way to open a freely traded exchange market to
facilitate trade among nations.
60 | P a g e
in January 1976. T-bill futures began trading in April 1986 with approval from
the Commodities Futures Trading Commission.
61 | P a g e
Asia and the E.U. would go on to share not only an explosion of trade but also
two of the most widely traded world currencies on the IMM.
For this reason, the Japanese yen is quoted in U.S. dollars, while Eurodollar
futures are quoted based on the IMM Index, a function of the three-
month LIBOR. The IMM Index base of 100 is subtracted from the three-month
LIBOR to ensure that bid prices are below the ask price. These are normal
procedures used in other widely traded instruments on the IMM to insure market
stabilization.
After interviewing certain participants in the Money Market these are few of the
important things that the researcher has concluded by the responses of the
respondents:
62 | P a g e
Many new regulations have come up including:
There are few changes that should be incorporated in the money market which
are as follows:
Commercial Papers are one of the instruments that are strongly recommended
by the respondent to invest in. Also, there should be an amendment to bring
down the minimum deposit of the commercial papers. They comparatively
give higher returns. Only banks and private companies are allowed to issue
these papers.
63 | P a g e
While differentiating the Global Money Market with the Indian Money
Market, following differences can be noticed:
The respondent feels that individuals should not be allowed to invest in the
money market. There are about 12 million retail investors which accounts in
Indian stock market. It’s been difficult to stem present investors due to lack
of infrastructure and technology, so if individuals were to be allowed in the
market, chaos shall be the outcome to be expected. Also, this market requires
large amount of minimum investment which is outside the purview of
individuals.
After acknowledging the requirement of the market and issues faced the
respondents have suggested an instrument whose features are as follows:
64 | P a g e
Only Qualified Institutional Buyers should be allowed to as there would
be less participants and it would be easier to get hold over them.
The increase in rates should be issuer specific on their credit rating.
SUGGESTIONS
Following are some of the suggestions and opinions with respect to Indian Money
Market:
1. The LAF is not the appropriate instrument for managing the liquidity of more
enduring nature. As the system is expected to be in deficit, there is a need to
develop term repo to minimize daily requirement of liquidity.
2. The lock-in period of CDs and CPs should be completely removed in a phase
manner.
4. Non-bank segment should be brought under the same regulation on par with
the banks early as possible.
65 | P a g e
5. Transparency should be ensured in money market transaction. There should
be screen based trading with two-way quotes for each money market
instruments.
[Link] should be a mechanism to make the call range bound which may reduce
uncertainty and provide confidence to the bankers for lending/borrowing. In
the context, it is emphasized that Repos and Reverse Repos conducted by RBI
has the potential to set the floor and ceiling in the call money market.
66 | P a g e
CONCLUSION
The Indian money market was controlled by tight controls and administered interest
rate structure up to late 1980s. However, following the policy measures during the
early 1990s the money market has become broad based with the enlargement of
participants and instruments, and change in liquidated conditions is quickly
transmitted. The reform measures have greatly contributed to the development
of inter-linkages; increasing liquidity across various segments of the money market.
The market determined interest rate is gradually emerging as an important
intermediate target with the ultimate objective of achieving price stability and
economic growth.
Radical measures are taken to transform the Indian money market from a closed,
inward and narrow domestic space to open, outward-looking. Interest rates have
been freed at certain level of bank deposits and lending, FFIs have been allowed to
invest in domestic market.
Recently, to overcome the liquidity crunch in the Indian money market, the RBI has
released more than Rs. 75,000 crores with two back-to-back reductions in the CRR.
The average turnover of the money market in India is over Rs 40,000 crores daily.
This is more than 3% of the total money supply in the Indian economy and 6% of
the total funds that commercial banks have let out to the system. This implies that
2% of the annual GDP of India gets traded in the money market in just one day.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
68 | P a g e
[Link]
[Link]
ANNEXURE
The primary data was developed by interviewing few people who are well
conversant with the Indian Money Market.
Firstly, from Mr. Rajinder Gupta who is the founder of First Investment Advisors
(which focuses on Financial Literacy) holding degrees of MBA and Diploma from
NMIMS. Secondly, the name is kept anonymous on the request of the respondent.
He is a MBA in Finance, Financial consultant and a Social Entrepreneur. He is also
co-founder at Vikaas which also primarily focuses on Financial Literacy.
69 | P a g e
What are the loopholes in the Indian Money Market and changes that you
recommend?
One instrument that you would strongly recommend an investor should invest
in?
Your views about global Money Market.
What is the difference between the Global and Indian Money Market?
Should individuals be allowed to invest in money market instrument? Please
give reasons for your perception.
Any new instruments that you have thought of that shall be developed in the
Indian Money Market?
70 | P a g e