Worker-Management Relations Study
Worker-Management Relations Study
In India, quite a large number of research studies has been carried out in various
23
States and industrial centres of the country. These studies, which invariably
deal with different aspects of industrial relations, have been conducted to meet
the needs of individual researchers and found providing agencies.
The study seeks to examine in realistic and comprehensive manner the state of
worker-management relations in Bhilai Steel Plant and probe objectively into
the fa'\ors that helps or obstruct the maintenance and development of harmonious
relations between worker and management in the industry .
.
2.
3.
4.
5.
, I
1.
examine the attitude and behaviour and assess the reaction and
, I
3.
4.
2~
1.
2.
The regional influence, the size of the work force, approach of the
management and attitudes of workers playa significant role in influencing the system of industrial relations in an industry.
3.
4.
Workers' job satisfaction, participation in decision making, union involvement and participation and their attitude towards various aspects
of
All parties to industrial disputes favour third party intervention and settlement through the machinery, such as, conciliation and arbitration both
compulsory and VOluntary, rather than direct negotiations or collective
bargaining.
"
2G
As stated earlier, the study has been restricted to Bhilal Steel Plant. Bhilai
Steel Plant has been selected deliberately for the purpose of present study for
the following reasons:
1.
The Steel industry is one of the largest industry in the entire manufacturing sector of the country, both in terms of the number of units and employment.
2.
3.
Research Approach.
With a view to substantiate the above hypotheses the following research approach
has. been employed:
1.
2.
.,
4.
27
"
, I
conC~~r1ed authorities)
workers and management personnel in one of the units under study in Bhilai
Steel Plant. The questions which were reported as inappropriate and difficult to
understand or which had poor responses were revised and reframed to meet
the requirements, Further, during the pre-testing stage, the respondents were
found hesitant to respond to open enti and direct questions, but highly responSive
"
28
Likert-type technique was used to prepare scales for selection of items to measure
attitudes of workers and management personnel towards various aspects of
worker-management relations. items which did not ,s.how a substantial correlation
with the total scores were eliminated to ensure that the questionnaires are
"internally consistent", Le., every item is related to the same general attitude.
Interview schedule for workers was designed to, s,eek data on the workers'
(inclusive of trade union leaders) socio-economic background, their per~eptionl ,
,
views regarding the nature and extent of industrial conflicts and settlement,
their aspirations and job satisfaction, workers' participation in decision-making
and trade union activities, etc.
29
as possible, there were inbuilt checks in the questionnaires, which pointed out
the wrong responses. On these items also repeated interviews were held after
clarifying the doubts and misgivings.
In order to secure their co-operation, ~he purpose of the study was explained to
them and they were assured that their views and personal information would be
kept strictly confidential. They were encouraged to express themselves as
honestly and frankly as possible. Every possible effort has been made to
supplement quantitative and qualitative data through the information received
by informal interviews as well as personal observations. Wherever possible,
inCidents and verbal statements of respondents have been used to support the
-.
Sample Design
Since the total number of employees in the sample unit was too large to be
covered by an individual researcher, it was decided to employ sample-method
of study. Keeping in view the characteristics of the population and the c)ariables
to be studied, the stratified random sampling procedure was used.
Sample size
The population was sratified as (1) workers and (2) management personnel.
With a view to give sufficient representation to each departme.nt studied and the
two classes of employees and to have a manageable one, the size of the sample
was restricted to 100 workers and 30 management personnel. Table 2.1 presents
details about the sample composition.
Workers for the sample include different categories of opl:ratives and non-oper-
, 1
3J
-atives and some office-bearers of trade unions and bipartite committees.
Similarly, the sample of management personnel includes top management
personnel, management personnel of all important functions at different
hierarchies, office-bearers of personnel departments, higher level supervisory
staff and also a few management nominees representing different jOint
committees/forums.
The data collected have been statistically analysed using, besides the absolute
numbers, the methods of percentage comparison, summary statistics such as,
averages, coefficient of variation, ranking based on overall scores and
comparison of mean scores based on the scoring depending upon the desirability
of different dimensions studied.
Since the study mainly focuses on the attitude analysis, the need was felt to
quantify the data which were otherwise qualitative in nature. In the present
study, summated Rating Scoring Scale developed by Rensis Likert (1932)
popularly known as Likert-type technique was applied for the purpose. In such
a scale the subjects were asked to respond to each item on a particular issue
under study in terms of several degrees of agreement or disagreement, for
example
(1)
completely satisfied,
(2)
considerably satisfied,
(3)
moderately satisfied,
(4)
(5)
..
The responses to various items were scored in such a way that a response
indicative of the most favourable attitude was given the highest score ~nd vice
versa (5 = High; 1
was used,a three-point or four point continuum was also applied wherever
necessary.
I"':. , 31
After determining the sample size for each departmen\, the technique of sratified
proportionate representative sampling has been used for drawing the sample of ,
,
workers from each department using job as the criterion for stratification, The,
universe was stratified according to the job status of its constituents because
the respondents displayed basic differences in terms of the degree and the
nature of skill possessed, sabry, task assignment and the managements'
perception of their job importance, For operational purpose, the departments
, I
performing different jobs have been used as different strata: The size of the
sample drawn from each stratum has been randomly selected from the list of
workers prepared for each department separately, The attendance roll of the
concemed departments, has been utilised for selecting the required number of
respondents, Similar procedure for selecting the sample of management
. ,
personnel has been adopted. The details of distribution of sample have been
shown in Table 2.1.
3':::
LlMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
Any study analysing human factor in the work setting cannot claim perfection in
view of the nature of the subject itself and the present one is no exception to it.
During the study a number of limitations and constraints were faced and it is
necessary to point them out at the very outset.
,
employment, job security and other personnel issues such as, promotion,
training, selection absenteeism, labour turnover, retrenchment, etc.
The main limitation of the study relates to the inadequate and incom~l::teness ,
,
of the statistical data. The general limitations of the kind of secondary dat~
originating from government offices, particularly their incompleteness and
inaccuracy, cannot be ruled out.
The non-availability of adequdte and reliable statistical information for some
years and for some vital issues has made it difficult to study all the important
".
, I
for the State as a Whole and no data regarding the sector-wise and industry.
wise disputes, their causative factors, their impact, collective agreements, the
implementation of settlements, participative forums, etc., are available. The
information about the arbitration and adjudication awards was not provided in
spite of repeated requests. All this has made the study of various vital"issues in
worker-management relations very difficult.
'1 -
33
In the present study it was envisaged to assess the degree of unionisation and
the extent of industrial conflicts, explain their growth factors and find the
relationship between the degree of unionisation and incidence of industrial
conflicts in the State and in the industry,under study. But again the non-availablity
"
of data relating to various variables have stood in the way of such an important
analysis. The statistical information regarding the union membership as used
in the study is claimed membership which is most likely to be exaggerated,
since they are based on voluntary disclosure and the concerned government
agency does not have any practice of verifying the union membership .
.The limitations of the primary data again cannot be ruled out. The general
limitations of such data, obtained through attitude survey, relate to partial and
n(ln-response of the respondents which owing to the factors, such as,
unwilingness to disclose certain information, particularly, pertaining to the
personal variables, must have occl;lrred in spite of the best efforts of the
investigator. Because human beings are wise enough to manipulate their answers
in consonance with the social values. Therefore, some element of bias in the
opinion/perception of the respo~dents cannot be ruled out. However, in spite of
the co-operative attitude of the management, at times in some departments
there was reluctance on the part of some workers to respond freely, but every
possible effort was made to find out the attitude/perception of the workers and
-.
.-
otherwise.
Ourg
Durg is one of the 61 districts of M.P. Ourg was called 'Drug' originally and was
attached with Shandara district. Initially Durg was tahasil of Raipur district and
previously the state was divided into 45 districts of which Durg was one. In
1907 four estates were transferred to it on 1st January 1948-49 with incorporation
, I
3G
"
Name of Department
management
workers
.-
----
01.
COKE OVEN
02.
SINTERING PLANT I
03.
SINTERING PLANT 11
04.
OS.
06.
07.
08.
09.
10.
.1
11.
MERCHANT MILL
12.
13.
14.
lS.
PLATE MILL
16.
17.
FORGE SHOP
18.
19.
MACHINE SHOP
20.
21.
22.,
23.
..
,1
MAINTENANCE DEPARTMENT
TOTAL
100
30
, I
SAIL
37
an Overview
,When
ttw Indian 'Governrr;ent decided to enter 'the field of Iron & Steel prod~ction, it
,
decided bro~ldly not to run ttlC firm as a departmental undertaking, Althougll initially steel
project ndll11f1istratiol1 \'Ins directly under a Ministry of the Central Government, Hindustan
"
Steel was formed as a Private Limite~ Company, with President of India owning the
shnres on behalf of tile people of India, Thus Hindustan Steel Private Limited was set up
on January 19,1954,
Growth Qf Hindustan Steel (1959-1973)
,
,
To start wjttl, Hindustan ~teel (HSL) was designed to manage only one pla,nt, that was
coming up at Rourkela. Por Bhilai & Ourgapur plants, the preliminary work was done by
ol1lcials in Iron & Steel Ministry, From April 1957, the supervision and control of the Bhilai
& Durgapur Plants were also transferred to Hindustan Steel. The registered office was
oflglnally in New ,Deltli, moved to Calcutta in July 1956 and ultimately shifted to Ranchi in
December 1959. Initially Bokaro Project also came under HSL.
A new steel company
construct and operate the steel plant at Bokaro. The 1 MT phase of Bhilai & Rourk.ela
Steel Plants were completed by end ot'December 1961. The 1 MT pha::;e of Durgapur
was completed in January, 1962 after com,missioning of wheel and axle olan!. As a result,
the crude steel product!on of HSL went up from 108 Ylousand tonnes (in 1959-60) to 1.6
MT. The second phase of Bhilai was compl.etetl on 2 nd September, 1967 after
commissioning of Wire Rod Mill. The last unit of 1.8MT phase of Rourkela was the Tandem
Mill commissioned on 17'" February, 1,968 and 1.6 MT phase of Ourgapur was which was
completed on 6'" August 1M9 after commissioning of furnace in SMS. Thus, with the
completion of 2.SMT stage in Bhilai, 1.8MT in Rourkela and 1.6MT phase of Ourgapur,
the total crude steel output from HSL wiis raised to 3.7MT in 1968-69 and 4MT in
1972-73.
Steel Authority of India Limited
I.
Formation:
The Committee of Public Undertaking of the Fifth)-ok Sabha was the first Parliamentary
Committee to undertake a review of the question of setting up a Holding Company for
steel. It was first considered in the Department of Steel in 1971 with the following two
objectives -
..
,.
33
Rapid growth oi me industrial sector, of the economy, of the state as a leading agent
of the growth process;'and
Ability of the g'o~erii'ment to divert investment into areas which are strategic from the
point of view of future development.
i'n this context, it was recognized that the Public S.ector had to be made more eff:cient in'
order that it might be able to contribute fDr more than it had to the common pool of
investible surplus in the economy.
, .
Further, such a holding company could perform a number of other important functions
like coordination and control of constitutent units, checking out long term, programmes,
introduction of necessary technological changes, setting up of an R&D organisation and
training of managerial personnel for the Public Sector as a whole.
Based on the above considerations, the proposal to set up a holding company for Steel
and associated input industries was ~pproved by the Government in January 1972.
Accordingly, the formation of Steel Authority of India Limited was approved by the
Government in December, 1972. The company was incorporated on January 24, 1973
with an authorised capital of Rs. 2,000 crores. In 1978 SAIL: was restructured as an
operating company.
fl.
Present Status
Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) through its five integrated steel plants at Bhilai,
Bokaro, Burnpur, Durgapur and Rourkela accounts for major steel production capacity of
India.
Two special steel plants at Durgapur and Salem produce a wide range of special alloy
steels and stainless steel.
VISL, Bhadravati is ~n integrated compiex with an installed capacity of 0.18 MT, produces
alloy & special steeYs.
'
MEL, Chandrapur is one of the largest producer of bulk Ferro Alloys in the country.
\
Today, SAIL is one of the largest corporate entities in the country. Its innate strength lies
in its technologists and professionals and a trained manpower of around 1.86 lakhs
including subsidiaries. It had a sales turnover of over 16250 crores during 1999-2000 .
,.
38
Situated in Madhya Pradesh, this was one of the three 1 MT capacity crude steel plants
. set up in the Public Sector in the late fifties. Subsequently it was expanded to 2.5 MT
ingot capacity, and currently expanded \0 4.0 MT. With this, the saleable steel capacity
increased from 1,965 MT (2.5 MT stage) to 3,153 MT (4.0 MT stage).
The plant was the first in India to produce wide (3600 mm) heavy plates. A major exporter
'of steel products, Sllilai specialises in shaped products, such as heavy rails, 11eavy
structl/rals, merchant products and wire rods. Almost all units in this integratehteel
plant are armed with ISO 9002 certification. Plate Mill 01 Shilai Steel Plant has received
the ISO: 14001 Certification for its Environment Management System.
Product-mix
Tonncs / Annum
Somis
553,000
Rails
500,000
Hoav1 Structurals
250.000
Merchant ProdCcts
500.000
Wire Rods
400.000
--------
Plales
Total Saleable Steel
..
950.000
3153.000
February, 1959_
Situated in Orissa, it was the first integrated steel plant in India {Jt;lsigned to produce
only flat produCts and the first in Asia to introduce basic oxygen furnace (BOF) process at
a time when this process was yet to receive recognition from the established steel
producers at home and abroad. The plant produces a wide range of flat steel products
like plates, hot and cold rolled coils and sheets, galvanized sheets, electrical steel sheets,
el~ctrolytic
tin-plates and large diameter electric resistance welded (ERW) and spiral
welded (SW) pipes. The plant was expanded in the late sixties (1965-68) from 1.0 MT to
1.8 MT per annum ingot steel capacity. Continuous technological innovation has led to
_ greater diversification in this plant's product range. The new units for producing cold
rolled non-grain oriented (CRNO) sheets, cold rolled grain orienteg (CRGO) sheets has
also been commissioned to meet the market needs.
.
..
40
Its Blast Furnace, Steel Melting Shop-I, Continuous Casting Shop-I, Oxygen Plants-I&II,
Hot Strip Mill, ERW & SW Pipe Plants, Galvanising Lines and Silicon Steel Mill are
accredited with ISO 9002 Certification. The silicon steel mill has been accredited with
tSO 14001 Certification for its Environment Management System.
Tonncs t Annum
Product-mix
Semis
553,000
299,000
HR Plates
150,000
HR Cpils
340,500
ERWPipes
75,000
SW P"lpes"
55,000
433,000
160,000
85,000
73,500
16,71,000
-.-.
Tannest Annum
-.
Merchant Products
260,000
Structurals
160,000
Skelp
230,000
40,000
Semis
Total Saleable Steel
898,000
,
1588,000
41
Bokaro Steel Plant 'brings out before ono's eyes the vision of a
maklllg'. As tho fourth steel plant in the Public Sector, conceived in 1959, it actually
st.:lrted taking shape in 19G5 with the signing of an agreement with the Government of
USSR on 25" January, 19G5. Envisaging a capacity of 1.7 MT in 1" stage and 4.0 MT in
2 OJ st.:lge, its construction st.:lrted on G'" April, 19G8.
[30knro Steel Plant was originally incorporated as a Limited Company on 29'" January
, 9G.1, iJut nfter the formation of SAIL in 1973, it became a wholly owned subsidiary of
SAIL and on 1" May 1978 it was eventually merged with SAIL in terms of Public Sector
Iron & Steel COliJpimies (resfructuring) and Miscellaneous Provisions Act 1978.
Tile plnnt was conceived as the country's first 'Swadeshi' steel plant, to be built with
maximum indigenisation going into. the equipments, materials and know-how. Thus, this
project has been a radical shift form the earlier dependence on foreign sources 6f knowhow and consultancy, design and equipment, engineering, supervision and erection to
almost a full measure of self-reliance and confidence.
Gokaro Steiels first phase of 1.7 MT commenced on 2"d October, 1972 with the
commissioning of 1$I blast furnace and completed on 26'" February 1978 with the
commissioning of 3'd Blast Furnace.
o
All units of 4.0 MT stage have since been commissioned. The plant facilities and layout
took into account the provision tor further expansion to an ultimate capacity of 10 MT.
Bokaro is geared to provide a sure and strong raw material base for a host of modern
engineering industries like motor vehicles, pipes and tubes, cold rolling units, barrel and
dru;rn making and lately, LPG cylinders. Galvanized plain and corrugated sheets are
finding use in industrial and domestic applications. The black plates (being:lmported
earlier) are helping_'In conserving scarce foreign exchange. The industries which are
served by Bokaro are not only essential !or economic developm';lnt but also for raising
the standard of living of the pe,9ple in the country.
The plant has recently been modernised by introducing continuous casting facilities and
updating the Hot Strip Mill, a major step towards providing state-of-the-art technol'ogy for
producing quality steels of international standards. A range of special steel products like
SAIL COR, SAIL PR'OP, SAIL MEDS, SAIL RIM, API Grade Steel, HRVO, SAILMA, ~
WICR etc. have been introduced after modernisation in the plant.
Product-mix
Tonnesl Annum
2,120,000
1,390,000
GP I GC Sheets
170,000
100,000
TotalSaleable Steel
3,780,000
4. Steel Melting
Shops
3. Blast Furnace
c) Sintering
Plant NO.3
Plant No.2
b) Sintering
a) Sintering Plant
NO.1
2. Sintering Plant
1. Coke Ovens
DEPARTMENT
SF Complex
Plant
1738 T/day
5 blast furnace,
3 of 1033 CU.m each
with a hearth size of 7.2m
and 1135 T/day 2 01
1719 cu.m each with a
hearth size of 9.1 m &
1 Blast Furnace of
1719 CU.m with a
hearth size of 9.1 m
and 1738 T/day
1 Blast Furnace of
1 sintering maChlf'ie of
312 sq.m hearth area
of 75 s-q.m. hearth
machir,e
each 01 75 sq.m
hearth area.
80 sq.m. hearth area.
sinten~g
hearth area.
hearth area
2 sintering machines
1 Sintering machine
each of 50 sq.m.
chamber volume of
21.6 cU.m & 4.3 m high
sintering machine
each 01 50 sq.m.
, battery of 67 ovens
2 batteries of 65 ovens
6 batteries 01 65 ovens
Under 2.5 MT
mm
Ingot Steel
Pig Iron
Hot Metal
Saleable
sinter
-do-
fluxed
Super
, coke (dry)
+25
Product
327
2361
1520
905
2969
1500
2040
2511
Complex
2.5
2198
Under 6th SF
Under
2400
630
4080
3200
3137
2040
3303
4 MT
Under
[\.)
..-..
"
em,,! 101111
t.1al
bJ
Mill
5. noHi~g Mn($
8) BlOOming
v) SMS'I!
DEPAflTMENT
3 Reheating tumaces o(
Reversing Mill 01
1150 mm. size.
teCu~Jati"~ S08~ing
14 gr4uP' Of
SF Complex
Plant
E:tp<1os1on
..
l1nder
Under tth SF
Un".cf'
Rs&
He ..,.
SlruCtural
750
31S
(TOtal)
Ot wf1ic1l
lor sale
.26:)
21'2
6ii1~t
810<)m
BlOOms
S1;lbs
LiQvi<! Steel
2.5
750
:)15
12&3
2142
Complex
750
553
lS0 1
21'9
~<5
Ilea
4 1&1"
------- -----------
-----~-------------~.-- ..
Unde' 2.S.MT
..--
d) Merchant Mill
DEPARTMENT
specification.
1 rehe'ating furnace of
120 Tlhr capacity. Mill
comprises of 37 stands
(7 of 450 mm size &
2 of 350mm size) First
Intermediate stand
(Six of 300 mm size,
rolling in four stand).
Two second Intermediate
stand (each rolling in 2
400m.m size)
4 Intermediate stands
(3.2 Hi horizontal & 1
vertical of 400m.m.
size) 3 Finishing stands
(2.2 Hi Horizontal of
400 & 350m.m size &
1 vertical of 350mm size)
of total 12 stands
having 5 Roughing
Stands (4.2 Hi
Horizontal of 500m.m.
.,
3 Reheating furnaces
of 60 TIhr capacity
Under 2.5 MT
Plant
Wire Rods
Bars &
Rods
Merchant
Products.
Product
400
500
Under
2.5
400
500
Under 6th SF
Complex
400
500
Under
4 MT
... '
.......
Blooming Mills
x 1800 Ml Modernized
-Soaking Pils
-10 nos. Bottom Fired, 100 Teach
-10 nos. Side Fired. 120 Teach
42" TwoHi Reversing mill
13 Passes Ordinary steel
19 passes Special Steel
.32" Two Hi Reversing mill 7 passes
-1 X 1323 M3 Reconstructed
1 x 1323 M3 Down, Under Modemization
-Casl House Slag Granulation in B.F. No.4
2 x 120 TlHr. Pig Casting
-1 x 160 T/Hr. Pig Casting
-1
-, x 1400 M3 Modernized
Blast Furnace
.-
- Sintering machIne
- Sintering area: 2x 143 M2
-lxI98M'
Sinter Plant
- Mechanised Naphthalene
- Crystallisation Plant
B.O.D. Plant
- Benzol Plant
Coke Ovens
Coal Washery
"
Principal Units
(Description)
Plant/Shop
,
.'
20
51',
2 Sa\h (2x120 t)
1
Number at
1.876 MT
Naphtha
Blooms (12"x101
Blooms/slabs
~Jlngot
8T-Rectangular ingot
nuted ingot for wheel
& CC billetsz
Hot metal
1.80~
MT
(3 Furnace Operational)
1.92 MT
2.7MT
(Sk,p S,nter)
-2x70k.l:rlbatch
+2x25kltr/batch
lOT/day
Benzol
Sinler for BF
- 100 Tlr:!ay
-2.IC1:!5 Tlday
0- 10mm
<201Tlr:1
'.'55 t.n
(Reccrd Perf.)
1.14 MT
(Reccrd Perf.)
Rated Capacity
(Annual)
AmmOnium Sulphate
Crude Tar
. SF Coke
:2Cmmto -80mm
Nul Coke
Pea~ Coke
Coke Breeze
Wa3hed Coal
Principal
Products
UI
.........
Principal Units
Skelp Mill
Merchant Mill
Section Mill
Principal
slab
2.4.mm- .c.S mn
\VheeI & AJde
Wheel Mill
-Mechanical descaler
-63/12 MN combination press
-Holding Fumace
ThCkness:
-2 Coilers
Wodl!l:
256mm -147mm
Narrow stnp
B~let.
Products
-5-13' Oia. HS
Number at
1.876 MT
(Description)
Bmet Mill
PlanVShop
58.000T
0.250 I.IT on 3
0.281JT
0207 .fT
0'9, IJT
s.....~
R.ted C.PKlty
(Annu.l)
(..")
.:,
&
Base-mix,
I
,.,.
us (DF Grade)
va (Lump)
:Ier
I
SL-J.
...
Coke
Crude Steel
...
ISMS-III
~1b
ICC~I-1I1
Oxyget
US
yean
.r<:Gil
Slab
leer
t
I
]
Crude Steel
...
I SMS-II _Oxygen
----+-
ERWp;pcs
51'1']
ISSM]
Tm plates
CRsbeets
CR coils
CRNO
---
...
Armou~.fgradc
'~ Galv.shcc:ts
plates
ISWI'I'] _.SWp;pcs
1"1<11'1'1']
il'M]~1
-+HReoil
..
L _ _ _ _...
-r
..
CO gas
~
Mixed Gas for Fuel
',l I
~-
ITEl
Naptha
I
Raw CO gas
Clean DF Gas
VO(f)
...
~ll'llec]
Coking Coal
1 ~ ~ h."O. "r'
lQ!!!!tJt
limestone Dolomite
...
MR.
Ore
Iron Ore
(L&:F)
.;
--.l
...-.
Blast Furnace
5.
6.
7.
'""-
Plant -II
Sinterin~
0.305 MTlYr
1.44 MTlYr
100 T/Hr
0.36 MTlYr
1.355 MTlYr
5000 T/day.
Normalising Furnace.
Certffied as per ISO 9002 OA ~ystem
Ca~city
of 0.4 MTlYr
4 Blast .Furnaces
1.57 MT 01 sinter I Yr
sint~r/Y(
Special Features
1.5 MT of
5 MTlYr
Capacities
Bledning Plant
4.
5 Batteries
3 .. Sintering Plant-I
2.
1. Coke Oven
Facilities
Department
5.4
......
00
..
...
2 units x 60 MW
120 MW
9002 OA System
Special Features
-.:........
Thickness 5.56-9.52 mm
0.0375 MTfY
0.036MTfYr
0.16 MTfYr.
0.15MTfYr.
0.428 MTfYr.
HR coil as input
0.748 MTfYr. of
Capacities
.........
O.65mm thick
2 Pickling line
Two Cold.Reversing Mill of 4 high stand.
Width range 6301540mm & 6001040mm
5 Stand tandem Mill 1420mm , 4 high
3 Skin Pass ~;iII , 4 high
Facilities
Ccpartmcnt .
..-..
c:.::>
50
Sinter Plant
Dry Coal
4,004
- l I n d . 2,40'2
limp. 1,602
COk'e ?vens
6,~72 SF Sinter
'
,.
2,7.03 SF Coke
COk~.
SF
r-r'---3-00-7-~l~
lJ!l<lst Furnace
3]934
574
1,965
1,969
~------,I
~~--,
2,250 LS
555
2,25P LS
2,200 InQot
..
CCD-21
2,160
4,060 Slab
.lSteel
Iron
Cold
Scrap
Scrap
PIG
405
73
50.7
,
1,245
HRCF
L--_--,--o---.!
3,955 HR Coil
Steel
Iron
Cold
S9ra p
Scrap
PIG
382.5
73
50.8
920
CR
Sheet
980
GPtGC
Sheet
170
TMSP
100
C9
-0
~-
r-
~~
... ~
~
~=-
-I~
"'....-
=
=
....
-I
Slabbing Mill
.....
2
1
Shearing line
Sitting Une
'"'
,..
;-..
0I..L ' -
r/ c
~ ..
~~~ "..
/.:
J;-/
~I
.tI :,
!\ \
':-.,
,. \
.1-"
. h-tl'i
~~ :-"
'\. ......,,~- -
:!l
"At~ (
-1/ _
..
~.. '!I'?
2 ~I Oft'"
1.:1 '"If
...........A-'.
,.
3
12
furnaces inciicated
-2000 mm wide
-Charging rate 260 T/hr.
5 Roughing stands +7 finishing
stand of tandem type
No. of coilers
soaking pits
casting machines)
HR iSheetsIPlate
HR Slit Coil
HR Co~ (Total)
Steel Slabs
Concast Slabs
-do:
liquid Steel
1. LO Converter
Steel Melting
-100/130 T Capacity
2 (a). LO Converter -3001
350 T Capacity
Hotmetzl
B F.Coke (.2Smm)
Annual Capacities
Mod
4.0MT
N~mbcr' at
Sintering Machine
1.7MT
Blast Furnance
Sinter Plant
Coke Oven
Principal Units
(Description)
Plant! Shop
5.5
0.880
1.43
1465
1.7
2.735
3.7
209
1.7 MT
"
1.200
0.920
1.100
3.955
1.90
0.400
3.363
3"9
2.16
225
22S
2.5
1.5
4.585
62
3 <8
MO<1.
4.585
62
3 .. 8
Million Tonncs at
4.0 MT
.,
c...'
.....
f) Plate Mill
DEPARTMENT
Saleable steel
Cold Rolling
Plant
Under 2.5 MT
Million Tonnes
CR SlitCoi!
(2+t)
0.475
1.7MT
Principal Units
(Description)
Plan V Shop
.,
t
t
(5+3)
1.390
1
1.390
Mod
3 Reheating furnace of
~t
4.0MT
Numbers
0.495
Annealed Coil
Annealed Coil
Skin Passed Coil
Black Plate
CR sheet. CR coil &
Plate
Product
3.160
3.780
0.170
0.100
0.100
0.170
1.510
0.05
1.728
1.729
Mod.
1.5tO
0.05
1.728
1.729
4.0MT
Million Tonncs a1
2.5
Under
Under 6th SF
Complex
950
4/.1T
Under
1.355
0.495
0.496
1.7 MT
Pickled Coil
Annual Capacllics
[-.;)
c."
53
5.7 Product Mix of SAIL Plants
FnelllUcs/ProduCIs
I.
liol MOlol
; 2,
CrudolLlQuid Siool
Bokaro
Durgapur
Rourkela
liSCO
4080,0
4000,0
4585,0
4500,00
2088.0
1876,0
2000.0
1900,00
670,0
380,00
3, Saleablo Stool
b) Flnlshod SloeI'
I) FIOIt Product
0,
299,0
490,5
950,0
2120',0
180,0
CRCoilS/Strip/ShoOIS
TMBP
1390,0
100,\)
433,0
17.0,0
160,0
73.5
75,0 .
55,0
Galvanised .~heolslcoils
Silicon Steel
ERW Pipes
Spiral Welded Pipes
950.0
Bhllil
Structural
Merchant Products
Wire Rods
Rails
:. ",
3780.0
180,0
,'.
250,0
500.00
400,00
500,00
166.0
111.0
56,0
16.0
Spocial Sections
3150.0
"
293,0
545.0
1650.0
1671.0
207.0
260,0
'.
3780.0
1586.0
1671.0
305.0
3. saleable,pi
lron
. 2. Saleable Steel
_Blooms/Billets/Cuttings
- Siabe for Sale
- Rails & Strls
_ Merchant Products
- Wire Rods
- Plates
Total
.. Products
"
332
3153
630
3615
750
500
400
950
553
798
347
700
530
440
800
450
200
101
103
233
232 .
223
3383
3500
3307
3450
3352 .
3500
3411
680
440
164
663
461
522
626
334
695
500
475
640
877
839
-267
300
594
716
450
500 .
482
460
/637
685
962
358
478
495
458
660
951
189
688
502
950
270
568
464
440
660
946_
3967
4100
3837
4025
3745
3810
4150
4250
4000
856
2368
1599
2340
1760
2278
1559
2340
1685
2207
1538
2200
1610
2524:
1626
2001-02
Target Actual
Original
2400
1850
2000-01
Target Actual
Original
Qty:(,OOOT)
2500
1500
1999-00
1998-99
Target Actual Target Actual
Rated
. Original
Capacit y Original
c:.1l
.......
103
4133
2983
2926
2713
2445
2458
2399
200102
3008
1990-91
1991-92
1992-93
1993-94
1994-95
1995-96
1996-97 .
1997-98
1998-99
1999-00
2000:01
1989-90
430
504
457
544
534
389
314
202
297
322
96
175
135
300
278
272
243
324
232
223
200 .
2041
2115
2130
1837
1925
1890
1526
1657
1917
19H
2074
2156
2323
2395
2415
2352
23e9
2455
2524
2207
2278
2368
34175
70
429
650
754
1080
1236
1352
1517
1542
1558
1636
1721
H93
1768
1626
1538
1559
1599
371
367
352
232
338
345
362
352
372
411
406
423
393
428
370
330
414
453
441
458
482
522
413
.413
368
341
384
362
335
401
375
411
453
469
479
494
500
512
512
579
2146 1148
639
2143 la78
601
2163 1101
491
972
1847
542
1982 1051
551
950
1931
491
812
1588
515
958
1749
611
1916 1022
565
1983 1158
554
2041 1213
604
2153 1311
614
2209 1361
646
2283 1455
668
2400 1494
682
2340 . 1452
691
2350 1490
637
,
2303 1607
2376 1675
5E 8
2380 1693 . 478
595
2257 1761
663
2338 1873
,,
464
495
450
461
500
4362
7307
2041
2115
2130
1837
1995
2319
2176
2411
2997
3153
3426
3673
3865
.3953
4051
4073
4187
4223
.4150
3745
3837
3967
(Oly in OOO'T)
12
50
294
374
381
574
597
651
674
660
621
669
818
772
712
660
660
637
626
27656
1818
455
1819
400
1838
517
.
1574
498
496 .. 1810
2055
503
2150
588
. 2173
524
2542
610
2594
610
2795
731
3104
934
3118
972
. 1146
3335
3409
1202
3495
1153
3582
1193
3524
1222
3352
1219
3411
1320
3308
1144
3383
1110
6447
TOTAL
Wire
MM
.Rails!
Ingot
Rolled Billets Strls. Products Rods Plate S Semis S!STEEL
Crude Steel
S1I1S- 1 SMS-2 Total
2214
2377
2330.
2124
2339
2604
2510
2556
3306
3486
3549
3861
4045
4251
4336
4383
4397 .
4517
"377
'P956 .
4072
Iron
Pig
2066
2197
2093
2027
2033
2192
2087
2110
2484
2621
2772
2872
2841
3001
3042
UPTO
1979-80
FOR
1980-81
1981-82
1982-83
1983-84
1984-85
1985-86
1986-87
1987-88
1988-89
YEAR
Hot
+25mm
Coke Dry Metal
UI
c....
56
5:8-
Raw Materials
AI 2 0 3 content in iron ore is high (2.5%) and AI 20jSi0 2 ratio is adverse (1.5-2.5)
The washing and Beneficiation facilities are inadequate at mineq.
,
Size range of raw material is wide and oversize and undersize fractiohs are high. The
crushing and screening facilities at mines as well as at steel plant are insufficient.
Fluctuation in chemical analysis of raw materials is high. The bedding and blending
facilities are inadequate and inefficient.
The fluxing materials are high and acid insoluble. The beneficiation of fluxes is nonexistent.
The sizing,_beneficiation and blending facilities vary from plant to plant. The capacity
utilisation of the facilities provided is very low.
Agglomeration (Sintering)
Fuel and flux crushing indices are low;- (-) 3mm is less than 90% in all the plants.
Inconsistency in chemical composition and :Sinter mix proportioning.
57
Poor sealing system of machines does not allow suction more than 800mm WS.
,
Smelting capacities provided at ASP, DSP are inadequate and there ip no sinter plant
at liSCO.
Use of lime, blue dust and other metallurgical waste in the sinter mix is very low.
; Blast Furnaces
'.
Sinter % in the burden in liSCO blast furnaces in zero, in DSP less than 5'; .7%in RSP
40%. It is 52<;;' in BSP and in BSL it is 75%.
Blast temperature is less than 800C in all plants except BSL & BSP (900-950 0 C)
Only Bhilai and Bokaro biast furnaces are provided with high top pressure.
Screening facilities for sinter at high lines are not provided for all blast furnaces.
Blast Furnace'r'Jo. 5,6,7 at BSP ~nd Blast furnace No.5 of BSL the only furnaces
equipped with cast house slag granulation.
The burden and gas distribution facilities are inadequate. The movable throat aimors,
bell-less charging, gas temperature probes are now under consideration. At Bokaro,
Blast furnaces are now having Bell-less-Top charging system.
Coal Dust Injection (COl) system is installed in Blast Furnace No.4 at BSL to replace
coke in 1:1 ratio.
Blast Furnace No.5 at BSL is equipped with hydraulic mudguh.
Steel Making
The quality of hot metal as well as flux is poor.
The open-hearth process of steel making has become uneconomical. Out of 1~.4MT
of Steel Making capacity at present only 7MT is planned through LD converters.
The lining life of LD converters is less than 200-600 heats due to constraints posed by
poor quality of hot metal, flux and refractories.
The heat time in LD converters is very high (60-100 mines).
Application of ladle refining process in all our steel plant~ is missing except a few
facilities at RSP, BSP and ASP.
The ingot casting practices employed are old.
The track time is very high.
Rolling Mills
Poor yield in primary mills.
Due to aging of equipments in plants like liSCO and obsolete technology of rOiling. the
quality and dimensional tolerances of product~ are inferior.
Miles availability is low due to poor maintenance practices.