Step 9 The Backhand Groundstroke Part1
Step 9 The Backhand Groundstroke Part1
Step 9
© Mark Papas
mark@[Link]
I doubt lyricist Rida Johnson Young was writing about finding her backhand when she penned her
insightful song. But the sweet mystery in everyone's tennis life is the backhand, and yet you hear
it's more natural than a forehand, or that its motion is simply like throwing a Frisbee. Hmm.
To solve this mystery you're told to turn (more, more) the shoulders and hips, to lean into the ball,
lift up with the legs, step to the net post, rotate the back hip, straighten the arm or extend it to hit,
hit out in front, and lift and extend.
You're also told to “slide your racket hand down toward your thigh” and maintain “a rigid hitting
arm” when you swing. Or to stroke like “a pendulum” as if you were “bowling with the back
side of the hand.”
You try what you're told but it doesn't help your backhand. The mystery remains.
Something's missing, something's not there. You know it, but you can't put your finger on it.
Everyone tells you to do the same thing, but why doesn't it work? That's because it's a case of the
Emperor's New Clothes. Time for a revolution.
Let's start this time with the stroke, even though it's the body's attitude that makes the stroke
hum.
Straightening the arm to swing, or swinging with a straight arm, dooms the backhand. The arm is
working in a reverse direction than on the forehand, yes, but it still needs to be flexible to retain
leverage. On your backhand the forearm “flexes” laterally around the biceps and elbow, a reverse
direction from the forehand. After all, this is how your throw a Frisbee, isn't it?
[The word “flexes” is in quotations because this image helps your stroke, and the terms folding
and unfolding of the arm help as well. In reality I’m told when the arm is bent and “flexes,” it’s
really external rotation of the shoulder, but then if you were to simply straighten the arm and
swing away from you it’s horizontal abduction of the shoulder. A proper backhand stroke
combines both movements, that of the bent arm (external rotation), and of the arm swinging away
from your body (horizontal abduction).]
Photos 1-4, reading right to left, show how this works. In the “racket back” position, your hand
is back by your rear pocket, yes, but what it noteworthy is that the arm is bent, or folded, across
your stomach. (Two handers could straighten the front arm at this point, though it's best not to
because of how it ends up.) Photos 2, 3, and 4 show how the arm “flexes” laterally around the
elbow/biceps. The arm is folded across yourself or under your chest muscles in the backswing
and then it unfolds for the forward swing.
Photo 4 exaggerates to show how the forearm “flexes” laterally around the elbow/biceps, the
issue that is the mystery to the stroke itself. The forearm acts independent of the biceps and
elbow and does not work in lock step with them during the forward swing.
Practice this motion yourself right now. Tuck your elbow against your side, bend the arm at the
elbow, hold your forearm away from your body at waist level - a typing position -and turn your
hand straight up and down. Your forearm is at a right angle to the biceps, the hand is aligned
straight in front of the elbow.
Keep the elbow still and move your forearm and hand to your left (for righties), making an arc,
stopping it when your forearm is across your stomach or parallel to your hip line. The arm is now
folded across your stomach. Unfold it in the opposite direction until your hand is aligned straight
in front of your elbow again and then continue moving it past the elbow, while the elbow remains
still.
This extra bit of motion shows the (fore)arm's “flexibility” in this reverse direction, it shows how
the forearm acts independent of the biceps and elbow and does not work in lock step with them
during the forward swing. This (forearm movement independent of the biceps) is how your throw
a Frisbee.
[I'm aware when you throw a Frisbee a lot of reverse wrist action is used. This is not analogous
in any way to a backhand stroke. There is no reverse flick of the wrist. Only the “flexibility” of
the forearm to the biceps in throwing a Frisbee is useful in understanding a backhand tennis
stroke.]
The arm does not straighten at all to swing, and it's not a matter of semantics. The arm
If you keep the elbow too close to your body, “elbow in,”
photos 2 and 3, the arm loses strength at contact for the
one handed backhand, though for a two hander this is the
position the front arm is in (photos follow). Photos 4 and 5
show how the elbow needs to extend a little from the body
toward the side fence for a one hander while at the same
time the stroke, or arm, as a whole unfolds forward out in
front towards you, the reader (which is really saying
towards the ball).
The term “elbow in” means don't stick your elbow out in
the direction of the net prior to contact, it doesn't mean
keep your elbow close to, or against, your body.
The arm is bent, or bending, when the racket's back, and it unbends when swinging the racket
forward, it does not straighten. While at contact the arm can appear to be straight, that has
neither been its objective nor the path taken to reach the moment it appears straight.
Two handers do keep the elbow in closer to the body than one handers since they're using two
arms. And it's easier for them to prevent the front shoulder from lifting at contact. The photos
show a two hander's form: front arm bent, back arm straighter, and the back shoulder doesn't dip.
[Hingis photo by Ron Angle, Tennis Magazine, 11/99; Moya photo by Ron Angle, Tennis Magazine, 9/99.]
Is the wrist used on the backhand? Of course it is. It's our dirty little secret.
Take a breath, calm down, and put your eyes back in their sockets. And if you're a tennis
literalist, don't read any further.
Rod Laver talked about using his wrist on his backhand, and the phrase “turn of the wrist” is
The wrist is the point of least resistance on all strokes, and on backhands it's especially weak
because the hand breaks back, or inwards, against itself unlike forehands. To prevent this you
could adopt an extreme eastern backhand, which is like holding your racket with a forehand grip
and then using the same side of the racket facet to hit a backhand.
Sounds like a problem solver, but changing your grip like this creates problems, too. The
problem is it becomes harder to get the head of the racket around to make contact ahead of the
hand. The ball's at an angle, remember, and to hit it head on the racket head should be ahead of
the hand, when viewed from the side. Using an extreme grip leads to hitting the ball with inside
out spin. It takes extraordinary hand strength, and athleticism to make this work.
An easier way to get the racket head around first is to avoid the extreme backhand grip. The ball
may pop up on you but if it goes straight that's a good sign you're getting the racket head around
well. To avoid the pop up, adjust the angle of the face at which the ball hits the racket. You can
change the grip slightly, though not extremely, and/or rotate the wrist and forearm clockwise
during the forward swing.
In order to bring the racket face around while the arm both unfolds laterally around itself and
extends, or expands, laterally around the body, the wrist has to help out. Sometimes the wrist
starts moving the head of the racket first (and then stops) before any part of the arm begins to
unfold. Sometimes the wrist dramatically brings the racket face into the ball right before contact,
often done when the player has been indoctrinated in straightening the arm first for the forward
swing.
From the August 1998, ITF Coaches Review (International Tennis Federation).
In this study the authors investigated the wrist kinematics (flexion/extension), grip pressures and
wrist muscle electromyographic (EMG) activity in novice and expert tennis players performing the
[1 handed] backhand stroke. Results showed that expert players hit the backhand with the wrist
extended (neutral alignment of the forearm and hand dorsum) and that their wrist was moving into
extension at impact. In contrast, novice players struck the ball with the wrist more flexed while
moving their wrist further into flexion. Expert players also displayed greater wrist extension in
the follow through. Novice players eccentrically contracted their wrist extensor muscles during
Blackwell, J.R. & Cole, K.J. (1994). Wrist kinematics differ in expert and novice tennis players
performing the backhand stroke; implications for tennis elbow. Journal of Biomechanics, 27,
5, 509-516.
Commentary. Bending your wrist inward is called flexion, bending it backwards is extension.
Notwithstanding just who and how "expert" the "expert" tennis players were in this study (6
collegiate tennis players) it notes how the wrist is not held immobile or locked during the stroke
but "was moving into extension at impact." That is the wrist was moving in the backwards
direction. The novices moved their wrist inward even prior to contact and then some more at
impact. Hence the wrist is to be used correctly on one handed backhand strokes.
The point is the teaching establishment feels none of this happens, or even should happen, in a
backhand. But Revolutionary Tennis wants you to experience the freedom that comes from
tapping into your body's natural gifts as so designed by a higher power. To instruct a backhand
stroke that restricts and limits you smells like fundamentalism. Tennis freedom is a good thing.
Two handed backhands use a variety of grips on the front hand, but the back hand is the one that's
the boss during the forward swing. The back hand's wrist plays a part in helping start the swing
similar to the way the wrist is used on the forehand.
As an interesting aside, I participated in a tennis elbow study in 1987 for Dr. Michael Morris at
the Kerlan-Jobe group at Centinela Hospital here in Los Angeles. They reported in their paper
“the highest muscle activity during the [forward phase of both] groundstrokes was in the muscles
that control the wrist.” And in one of the establishment member's own backhand Ph.D. thesis, it's
noted how there is a larger amount of wrist angular acceleration and displacement in a one hander
than a two hander.
A dirty little secret it is, but I'm not going to tell you about it if I teach you. Even when you're not
hitting on time. Why not? First, it's a measure to be used as a last resort only if you're doing
everything else right. Second, it's very likely you'll do some of this on your own in your own way.
And third, it's a delicate movement, like holding a butterfly by its wings.
You first need to control the use of your arm, keep it in, unfold it well, lock your wrist, get the
head of the racket out in front, look at the ball well. You can't fix your
timing by using your wrist, you'll just snap it backwards into the ball and
you'll hate it.
The point is, you see this, you absorb this, but somewhere in the back of your mind you're
thinking, "yeah, all right. But..." You feel something's missing, it's all not there. You're right,
you're absolutely right. You need to trust your instincts.
You need to listen to that little voice inside your head that talks to you about tennis form. It's
most always correct, no matter what anyone else says.
Now Revolutionary Tennis breaks new ground in how the body works for efficiency and stroke
support on a backhand. It's a lot of fun, and hopefully it makes you go, “Hmm, that makes
sense,” and, “Yes, I can do that.”
Why is your forehand stronger and easier to hit than your backhand? Because your forehand
works with your dominant side, while your backhand works with your non-dominant side. And
with that a whole bunch of stuff just comes together all by itself: You move better, see better,
balance better.
Athletes favor one side over the other, and are always stronger when coming at you from their
dominant side. Strong side, weak side; dominant, non-dominant.
Which begs the question: how can you make your weak side work like your strong side? It's
simple. You apply a symmetrical, or mirror, image from your strong side to your weak side.
SYMMETRY
This idea of applying the feet, the body, and the eyes in symmetrical fashion from forehand to
backhand does not exist in tennis, until now. And this is what eliminates the weak backhand. It's
wild.
FOOTWORK
Step 2 introduced the concept of symmetrical footwork for precisely this reason, to empower the
backhand. In fact, preceding Steps show how it is the back foot that first moves you, it is the
back foot that keeps you moving in a forward direction, the back foot gets you close to the ball,
the back foot holds your balance, the back foot prevents you from stepping across and/or turning
sideways, the back foot directs your body's momentum into the ball for power.
In short, the back foot rules. And on forehands the back foot is your dominant foot. The strong
side. Nice coincidence.
But on backhands this coincidence doesn't exist. On backhands the back foot now coincides with
No wonder everything feels so different. No wonder you often move to the side fence, are slow,
wind up turning your back to the ball, lose your balance, get miss-hits, hit with no power.
On forehands you move normally because the back foot moves normally, but on the backhand the
back foot drags behind the front one, it doesn't step forward normally. Mistakenly on backhands
the lead foot (front foot) steps, the trailer (back foot) drags.
The back foot on the backhand must become the “dominant” foot on the stroke. It takes you to
the ball, it holds your balance, it prevents you from turning sideways. It covers distance, not the
front foot.
All you have to do is follow the footwork pattern outlined in Step 2 to train your non-dominant
foot and empower your stroke. It'll be a little clumsy at first, but it's not difficult to do or a
game-changing thing.
In diagram 9A, the left half shows what the Forward Stance looks
like for a backhand, and the right half shows the common
weakness for us all, stepping across. The bottom half is merely a
flipped version of the top because you often see the pros from this
perspective. When you step across the angle of the feet relative to
the ball's flight line means the player has not been moving forward
into the ball but off to the side. Without the body's momentum
going into the ball, the contact will be less than stellar.
When you step across the stance itself becomes too narrow, and
your base of support is undermined. A too-narrow
stance never happens on a forehand. Stepping across
results from both by a poorly used back foot and
adherence to the teaching mantra of “turn, turn, turn.”
Vision. On a backhand you'll turn your head to the side much more than on
a forehand because either you turn too much anyway or your arm turns you
when you take the racket back. The result is you won't time the ball well if
your vision is impaired. You have to really work at seeing the ball well on
the backhand, you have to open your own face to the ball.
There's a popular and oft repeated tip that if your opponent could read your
name printed on the back of your shirt you've achieved a good turn of the
shoulders when taking the racket back. Well, you might really be turned, but with your head
turned so much you won't be able to keep both eyes looking straight forward at the ball. What,
then, to do? Why, develop the world's most flexible neck and shoulder, which Gustavo Kuerten
remarkably displays on the right. Yikes! [Tennis Magazine, 12/00, photo by Brian Bahr/ALLSPORT.]
The fact some pros appear to be doing this is a tribute to their body's flexibility, a flexibility
developed since age 5 or 6 and enhanced over hours of practice. So don't turn your back.
Instead focus on looking at the ball well, Step 7, start the process of taking the racket back, and
the turn will take care of itself.
Here are the photos of Gottfried and Smith again with a line
drawn showing how Smith's leaning over too much, he's off
balance compared to Gottfried. The line has been placed
right on the front toes.
Don Budge was a master. Even though on the [Link] clip he is not moving forward into
the ball, he had great heart, great strength, great vision, and above all, a great gentility. With his
thumb up the handle to produce his feared topspin, no wonder his follow through was so
exaggerated. But his playing elegance indeed showed his mastery over his body's balance.
Body balance is a simple thing, but too often you don't see this in how-to articles. And what you
see, is what you'll do.
Dennis Van Der Meer instructs how to “step forward and lean
into the shot” so you can “hit it a ton,” Tennis magazine, 11/88,
photos by Dom Furore. The model “leans” into the shot like
Dennis wants him to, but he's way off balance in the first one, and
still off balance in the second, which shows this little but most
important detail that defines your body's strength has been
completely ignored. The model's feet are right-on in the Forward
Stance, but this seems to be merely a coincidence because the
whole package isn't coming together.
In the next photo, both the Van Der Meer student and Tennis
Magazine's 101 tennis tips model are off balance as well. Though
the feet are good on the left and passable on the right, the balance
is off. On the left, ignoring the harmful imagery of the
stick-straight arm, the right hip and buttocks stick out to the rear,
and the head is turned way, way too much to the
side. On the right, well, it's obvious. [Van Der
Meer male student, left, Tennis Magazine, 07/00, photo by
Peter Lamastro; 101 tips model, right, Tennis Magazine,
10/99, photo by Caryn Levy.]
The solution to the high bouncing ball on the left, by Van Der Meer, though not
alone, advocates keeping the body farther away laterally from the high backhand
ball so you can straighten your arm and swing away. Of course, straightening the
arm denies its leverage capacity, but “as you make contact with the ball,
straighten your arm” has been the common mantra on all tennis backhands.
BALANCE ON A BACKHAND
On a forehand your arms spread out on either side of your body when you move and prepare the
swing, sort of like you do when walking a line. But on a backhand you are imbalanced from the
get-go. Both arms are on the same side of your body and you are constantly losing your balance.
You lean over, bend at the waist, and get in a crouched position before swinging, all of which are
counter productive. And you still lose it on the forward swing since the arm swings away from
the body altogether.
Even two handers easily lose their balance. What to do? Watch Gustavo Kuerten's magic.
Yes, Kuerten seems imbalanced, his back seems to be “facing his opponent,” and his back foot is
turned too much to the side. It is a testament to Guga as the perfect student that he displays what
the establishment has asked him to, and it is a testament to Guga's superb athleticism that he has
developed techniques to help compensate for their inherent inconsistencies, one of which is his
extraordinary neck and shoulder flexibility seen earlier. [Tennis Magazine, 04/01, photo by Ron Angle.]
Guga could remain imbalanced (leaning over/butt sticking out), but witness how his torso changes
its position/angle over the lower body. At first the torso's a bit hunched over the lower body, a
result of turn-turn-turn and disregard for the back foot, and then the torso rights itself above the
lower body as the lower body's weight shifts onto his front foot. While Guga's lower body
continues its forward journey into the contact his upper body has gone in the opposite direction to
achieve balance. This is his compensatory technique, he pulls that torso back, and his head, too,
before he swings the racket.
Most players continue their hunched position into the shot, but Guga achieves a strong backhand
by not doing so. Guga's upper body appears to float above the lower body, allowing the lower
Shifting your body's weight to empower the stroke means shifting it into the ball. This weight
shift is linear, not rotational, for the same reasons as explained in Step 8, The Forehand, and Step
4, Your Power. This linear movement for your body's power source is a small movement, and as
with all things small that make a big difference, it often gets lost in
the shuffle. It isn't even recognized on the forehand side, where
large body rotation is, which is why I guess the “lean into the ball”
business developed for the backhand.
When the back leg swings around to embrace the contact spot it
does not step more forward into the court than has the front foot.
Guga's back leg is in the process of coming around during the the
forward swing to help align his body's power (body center) with
the hit, and this back leg does not wind up farther ahead of the
front leg into the court after the hit. This swing-around of the
back foot during contact when you're turned too much to the side
prior to contact produces excellent results only when it's gentle
and doesn't step toward the net and ahead of the front foot.
I know for a fact Vic would say he has groundstroke shots of Federer with a slight bend in the
elbow as well as shots with a fairly straight arm, and that Federer's choice for these different
approaches is an interesting question open for answer.. I'm sure you all would add it depends on
the situation, the shot, the spin, the time, those kinds of things, and you'd be absolutely correct,
but the thing to note is we can have both endings, slightly bent or fairly straight, and yet each
Federer backhand clearly begins with the bending, unbending arm.
It is crystal clear here the arm is bent and unbends throughout the stroke.. In no way does
Federer straighten his arm to swing the racket down or up into the ball from the nadir of the
swing, and neither does the butt cap go straight to the ball.. This evidence confirms
Revolutionary Tennis' description how the arm works to produce this stroke.
But there is much more here to enjoy.. When you view the clip for yourself you will see many
things, including an interesting twisting of the racket, validating wrist movement.. But a large
gem shown in the stills above uncovers the cornerstone to all one handers, either flexible like
Federer's or straightened like Robredo and Gasquet: the hand turning the racket face into the ball,
no matter if you hit up the line or crosscourt.. Photos 5 to 6 the body remains the same and the
arm has moved imperceptibly, but what has occurred is the racket face has been turned into the
In this manner all one handers share the same element - the hand turning the racket head into the
ball - and it's a process that's being setup from the beginning.. Some may actually straighten the
arm to swing the racket or straighten it halfway through the upward/forward swing itself while
retaining stroke fluidity as you see in some pros (giving the false impression the butt cap or a
straight arm plays a central role), but this places a heavier load on that final turn than does
retaining flexibility in the arm.. As a teacher I try to counsel arm flexibility instead of rigidity for
this, and as a player I never try to straighten, or even think about straightening, the arm when
swinging at the ball.
If you have a severe backhand grip, like Robredo, or Kuerten, that is the hand is really behind the
racket handle unlike Federer, this will force the arm to straighten in order to turn the racket face
into the ball.. Is this a better way to do it? In my opinion it's not, the demands and limitations for
execution increase even more.. If a student evolves into that grip position then it's inevitable the
arm will straighten during the swing, but if that same student is looking to improve some advice
would include either moving away from that grip and learn to use the wrist to achieve the same
purpose or think about being a touch more flexible in thought with the arm instead of going
rock-rigid-solid throughout the stroke.