Natural Death
Natural Death
Naturalizing Death
For at least the past 2,400 years Western culture has death led inevitably to denying life, and the overvaluation
been engaged in the denial of death. The first part of this of the afterlife devalued this present life.
project was to deny the spiritual reality - the death of our The medicalization of death over the last century or so
individual consciousness - and to invent an imaginary has further alienated us from the realities. Surveys show
afterlife better than this life. The second part, which that seven out of ten Americans wish to die at home. In
progressively came to dominate the death industry over the fact only one person in four achieves that wish - half die in
last century, was to mask the physical reality of death. hospitals, and 20-25% in a nursing home.
The pantheist, reverent naturalist approach reintegrates The biological process has been taken out of the hands
these two aspects of death into the context of nature. of the dying person and their loved ones, expropriated by
Originally our Western root cultures in the Near East, medical professionals. The patient is taken from home and
Greece and Israel, all had a very placed in a sterile and alien hospital
negative view of the individual environment, then subjected to
afterlife for ordinary mortals. We are taught that death is an accident, a expensive medical interventions
Although our consciousness deplorable punishment for the oldest sin. designed to prolong life and avoid
survived death, life after death But let children walk with Nature, let lawsuits. Contact between the dying
was a miserable shadowy them see the beautiful blendings and person and their loved ones may be
existence in a dusty underground. communions of death and life, constrained and rationed. Death may
Homer’s underworld is a grim their joyous inseparable unity, as taught occur among total strangers in a
landscape. There is no judgement in woods, plains and mountains and dehumanized technological jungle.
of souls, no reward for virtue, no streams, and they will learn that death is The commercialization of death
penalty for vice. The common stingless indeed, and as beautiful as life. by the funeral industry adds a final
fate of all is to become gibbering wall of alienation. The body is
John Muir, Thousand Mile Walk
shades, as insubstantial as whisked out of sight, refrigerated
dreams. Only the faintest trace in a morgue drawer, pumped full
remains of perception and intelligence. When Odysseus of toxic embalming chemicals, and then reappears coiffed,
calls up the spirits of the dead, the ghost of Achilles tells painted with cosmetics, and immaculately clothed. The
him :`If I could live on earth again, I’d rather be a serf in funeral often follows a set pattern, conducted by a funeral
the house of a landless peasant, than king of all these dead or religious professional, with extremely limited time for
men who have done with life.’ grieving. It becomes difficult for survivors to attain closure,
One by one each of these cultures, during times of acknowledgement of and reconciliation with death and loss.
mass mortality, war, disease, famine or persecution, created There is a growing groundswell to reform each of these
the idea of a desirable afterlife far superior to life before areas, to reclaim ownership of death for the dying and their
death. Once adopted, this idea offered an attractive escape loved ones, to acknowledge the physical reality of death.
in times of individual or communal troubles, but denying Nature-reverent pantheism embraces all of these aspects in
Features Regulars
Imaging the Afterlife Almanac & Calendar
What do we tell the kids?
Funerals are for the living
Elemental Death News
Green Funerals Pantheist Meetup problems
Natural Caskets Using the UU path
Editor: Paul Harrison — Copy Editor: Rene Lawrence — Printing: Blessed Bee & First Image
1
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Preserving Memory
In the times of our ancestors portraits modelled in wax were arranged, each in its own
niche, as images to accompany the funeral processions of the family; and always,
whenever someone died, every member of the family that had ever existed was present.
The pedigree, too, of the individual was traced by lines to each of the painted portraits.
Their record rooms were filled with archives and records of what each had done.
Visions of the
Afterlife
All the major world religions have imagined an
afterlife that is in some way or other superior to this
life. Some, like the Christian and Buddhist afterlives,
present an end to suffering and a promise of
incorporeal bliss. Others, like the Jewish and Moslem
versions, suggest more physical states. Mark Twain,
who complained of the straight-laced Christian
heaven, may have found the Moslem version far
more interesting.
4
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
6
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
7
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
just left well alone and did not attempt to talk him around. attached to my memory from my conception to now and
And with a year or so so he did grow out of it and reverted see its path? I’m sure if we could we would be a little
to something similar to our way. Paul Harrison freaked out, and at the same time amazed.
One day my 2.5 year old will ask me about this, and I
will keep it simple for her, as one should for a young child.
8
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Phyllis Harrison
aged 4, 14, 25,
47 and 84
In her last months, after two falls and three months in When people die at a ripe old age, especially when
hospital and then nursing home, I knew the end was they clearly want to die, death is not so traumatic for
coming. On my very last visit I could see that she was the living. The whole process of the eulogy and the
very weak and might not last much longer. I thought placing of the ashes was a liberating therapy for the
it was important to say some last things while I still alienation that had existed between us for over forty
could. I told her of my love and gratitude. I told her years. I found that the very positive image of my
that if none of her close family were there when the childhood returned and the negative image dissolved,
time came, still she should imagine that we were I was left only with the puzzle of the difference
there in spirit, holding her hand. between the two. It was a tremendously healing
She had chosen cremation. I asked her where she experience for me and pulled back together parts of
wanted her ashes put. She said, somewhat typically: myself that were discordant. Paul Harrison
“I don’t care, chuck them in the bin.” I felt it would
help her to think in a positive way of death, so that
as she passed away she could have peaceful calming My father died almost two and a half years ago,
images as her last experience. I asked her to think of a two weeks before celebrating his 60th wedding
beautiful natural place she had loved all her life. anniversary with my mother, who lives on. I still
She entered into the spirit of the suggestion, and grieve. His funeral was Christian, in a conservative
thought of the English Lake District where she had Methodist Church in Conway, Arkansas, but there
spent many walking holidays as a young woman were elements of interest to Pantheists. A strong
full of joy and hope. She chose Watendlath, a little element was a celebration of his life, especially his
village above Derwentwater, with a pond and a rocky courageous and active fight for social and racial
stream. I suggested that she should imagine herself justice in his home area, the US South from the 30s
sinking into the earth and becoming part of the trees on. The minister said that “Tom Slinkard did what
9
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
we knew we should have done, but didn’t have the while announced recently that she too wished to have
courage to do.” From a pantheist perspective, the her ashes scattered over the Pacific. My sister called
connectedness of all life is elemental, and therefore me up and told me to go warn Dad that our aunt was
commitment to equal dignity and rights should be a coming to live with him! Connections...
cornerstone of our social and religious commitment. I Karl Slinkard
believe my father exemplified that connection, which
could be a point of connection with other faiths that
share the commitment to equality and justice. Since, I believe, my consciousness will permanently
My brother, Thomas, arranged a slide collage of cease when I die (or before when I enter a terminal
photos from his life which were shown with Benny coma, if that be my fate), what happens to my corpse
Goodman’s music playing in the background. The is no concern of mine. I won’t be waiting on the other
whole memorial service was a celebration of a life side, looking down on it with pleasure or displeasure.
well lived, and of my father’s connection to the I want my salvageable organs donated to help some
people and the life of his community. other human being. Organ donation, is a way seeing
His will indicated that he wanted his ashes to it that other humans suffer less and enjoy life
scattered in the Pacific, where he had been a sailor more. But it is not a way of somehow remaining a
during WWII, and felt an enduring connection. It little bit alive after death. A durable power of health
wasn’t until last July that we were able to get all of the care attorney and a living will are ways of seeing to
family together at the same time and on the Pacific it that I do not suffer a needlessly prolonged process
coast. The event was the sudden and unexpected of dying, or in the event I am completely unconscious
death of my brother Thomas. We held my brother’s and unable to suffer, that my financial resources
funeral in the afternoon and scattered my father’s are not being drained keeping a vegetable alive, but
ashes over the Pacific that evening, followed by rather that as much money as possible will be left to
a memorial dinner for both at a restaurant on the my heirs. Whatever form of disposal my heirs are
Berkeley marina. It was a sad time, but emphasized most comfortable with is fine with me. I won’t be
the connectedness of my father’s and his son’s life. around to experience it. Whatever is done with my
The whole affair had a profound impact on me, and corpse, the atoms that were me will persist, but they
probably most of the other members of my family. will no longer be me. Funerals are for the comfort of
An aunt who has been emotionally distraught for a the mourners, not for the dead. Walt Mandell
A Death in
Nature
There is a willow grows
aslant a brook,
That shows his hoar leaves
in the glassy stream;
There with fantastic
garlands did she come
Of crow-flowers, nettles,
daisies, and long purples.
There, on the pendent
boughs her coronet weeds
Clambering to hang, an
envious sliver broke;
When down her weedy
trophies and herself
Fell in the weeping brook.
Her clothes spread wide;
Millais, Death of Ophelia
Shakespeare, Hamlet
10
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Elemental death
Paul Harrison
11
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Traditional funerals are damaging including a directory of low-cost according to sound ecological
to the environment and Nature. and flexible funeral companies. At principles.
They use hardwoods, chipboard that time there was only one green • Members must guarantee the
and metals, toxic glues, stains and burial site in the UK. long-term security of the graves
embalming chemicals. Cemeteries In 1994 Albery started the and the wildlife, and have a
take up increasing amounts of land. Association of Natural Burial satisfactory plan for when the site
Petrol mowers and herbicides may Grounds to help farmers and reaches its capacity.
be used to maintain the • Members accept bodies
grounds. only in environmentally
Traditional practice acceptable biodegradable
is also out of tune containers such as shrouds,
with nature-oriented cardboard or wooden
spiritualities. One aspect coffins.
of the pantheist “afterlife” • Members will not
is the recycling of our require that a funeral
elements in nature, director be used. Clients
into new life forms. will be informed that they
That recycling is made may organise the funeral
impossible when the body and service themselves,
is embalmed and encased and dig and help fill the
in caskets that do not grave subject to safety and
biodegrade. landowners with problems training requirements.
The growth of environmental of planning, reassuring local The Natural Death Centre now
awareness and nature-centered neighbours, getting funeral supplies lists 200 working or planned
spirituality is now creating and so on. natural burial sites in the United
dramatic changes in funeral The Association has a Code of Kingdom – many more than the
practices. A crucial driver of Practice that enshrines several of rest of the world put together. The
this shift has been the UK-based the key aspects of green burial: reasons for this phenomenal growth
Natural Death Centre. It was set up • Members agree to take all lie partly with the profound British
in London in 1992 by a visionary reasonable steps to conserve love for animals and nature, but the
social innovator, Nicholas Albery. local wildlife and archaeological speed is explained by the catalytic
Albery died in a road accident in sites and to manage their projects and educative effect of the NDC
2001, aged only 52, but the itself.
Centre is still providing When I die, Of these burial grounds,
inspiration and information I want to be buried no less than 115 are run by
to a growing and world- under an apple tree. local authorities, 57 are run
wide movement. I think of death as as businesses by farmers
like a leaf falling off
The NDC began its or private individuals, and
a tree.
activities in 1993 with a ten are run as charitable or
comprehensive handbook Nicholas Albery non-profit concerns. Others
(1948-2001)
on death, worldwide founder of the
are still on the drawing
funeral practices, grieving, Natural Death Centre board.
burial, and cremation, The Natural Death
12
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Centre also encourages people renewable energy sources such as advantages. The materials used are
to complete Advance Funeral natural gas are used. Increasingly biodegradable and from sustainable
Wishes and Advance Healthcare stringent emission standards sources. The sites are managed
Directives, and provides online demand more complete combustion as nature reserves and so increase
forms for these. – and much higher energy rather than decrease wildlife
The concern for sustainability consumption. At present better habitats. However, many of them
embraces the preparation of bodies local air quality is being bought at are situated in rural areas a long
and the materials used for caskets the cost of increasing greenhouse drive away, so the energy savings
and coffins. Green burial sites gas output. Because a crematorium over cremation may be eaten up in
will not accept bodies that are is not financially viable if it serves greater petrol consumption for the
embalmed, or housed in toxic or only a small niche market, it’s not funeral and for later visits.
non-degradable containers. likely that we will see thoroughly The ethos of the green burial
A small number of companies “green crematoria” for a long movement is already changing
now offer green coffins and while. conventional funeral practice.
caskets. The Natural Funeral Green burial offers many Funeral directors are increasingly
Company in the UK sells
woven bamboo coffins with
organic cotton shrouds lined
with a biodegradable plastic
derived from corn and potato
starch. They also sell the
“eco-pod” – a container
shaped like a seed pod made
from recycled paper and
natural earth minerals. Other
suppliers sell coffins made
of unfinished pine, woven
willow or recycled cardboard.
One interesting issue
is whether cremation
or green burial is more
environmentally friendly.
Conventional burial is very
environmentally damaging:
The impact of each individual
burial may be on the decline,
as there is a trend towards
re-suing graves or “stacking”
burials one on top of another.
On the other hand many
people may be unhappy with
the idea of their remains
being dug up or stacked and
those who can afford it may
prefer more expansive luxury
memorial parks.
At Brocklands Woodland Burial site in Lancashire, UK, a tree is
Cremations do not require land,
planted on each grave. No vases of flowers, statues or other artificial
but in other respects they seem to objects are allowed. “This is not a cemetery,” say the owners, “it is a
be more damaging. Mostly non- place where graves become a part of the landscape.”
13
Pan Magazine Spring 2005
Name
Address 1
Address 2
City
State etc
Zip code
Country
New? Yes No
Change it? Yes I’ll do it
Direct hit: On July 4th, Comet Tempel I collides spectacularly Membership level:
with NASA’s Deep Impact probe at 23,000 miles per hour, Basic ($30) Family ($60) Low Income ($12)
throwing up a cloud of fine powdery material and leaving a
250 meter wide crater. The comet is about three miles wide Other amount
and seven miles long. When the data is analyzed, Deep
Please mail this form with your check (US $ only) to:
Impact will provide information about the composition and
formation of the early solar system. The rocket was launched World Pantheist Movement
in December last year. Photo © NASA P.O. Box 103, Webster, NY 14580, USA
July September
11th World Population Day 8th International Literacy Day Autumn equinox
12th Birth of Henry D. Thoreau 21st International Peace Day September 22 22;23
14th Storming of the Bastille 23rd Good Neighbor Day
20th Moon Landing Winter solstice
December 21 18;35
16