Design Economics and Cost Planning
Optional Competency at Level 2 / Core Competency - Level 3
Luay N. Azzam, FRICS FAIQS ACIArb
Executive Director
Nabih Elias Azzam & Partners (NEA & Partners)
www.iiqsglobal.org
Indian Institute of Quantity Surveyors
IIQS-Matrix
Competency Requirements
At Level 1
Demonstrate knowledge & Understanding
At Level 2
Apply your knowledge
At Level 3
Give advice & prepare reports
Page 2
Agenda - Design Economics and Cost Planning
Definition of Pre-contract Cost Planning & Cost Management
Objectives
Design Stages
Source of Cost Information?
Life Cycle Costing
Page 3
Definition of Pre-Contract Cost Planning & Cost
Management
The Surveyors Construction Handbook published by the RICS defines Pre Contract
Cost planining & Cost Management as follows:
Cost Planning:
..is the technique by which the budget is allocated to the various
elements of an intended building project to provide the design team with a
balanced cost framework within which to produce a successful design.
Cost Management :
..is the total process which ensures that the contract sum is within the
client s approved budget or cost limit. It is the process of helping the
design team design to a cost rather than the quantity surveyor costing a
design.
Page 4
Objectives
To ensure that the client obtains an economical and efficient project in accordance
with the agreed brief and budget
To make the design process more efficient
To ensure that all requirements arising from the clients brief to the design team are
included in the cost planning process
Page 5
Design Stages
The RIBA Plan of Work refers to the main stages through which a project design
typically passes: (also refer to NRM1 Published by RICS)
Design Stage
Quantity Surveyor
Stage B: Feasibility
Prepare feasibility studies & determine
the budget
Stage C: Outline Proposals
Consider with client & design team
alternative strategies and prepare cost
plan
Stage D: Scheme Design
Carry out cost checks & update cost plan
Stage E: Detailed Design
Cost Checks
Stage F: Production Info
Carry out cost checks
Stage H: Tender Action
Prepare reconciliation statement
Page 6
Design Stages (Contd)
The UAE industry mainly follows the following design stages (note the terminology
may defer but the overall methodology is similar):
Design Stage
Quantity Surveyor
Concept Stage
Prepare cost estimate for the project
from the Concept design drawings, this
should be derived from unit rates for
construction and calculation of square
meter areas.
Schematic Stage
On completion of Scheme Design,
prepare a Scheme Design cost
estimate. This type of estimate will be
priced based on approximate quantities
and elemental unit rates for the
measurable building elements
Page 7
Design Stages (Contd)
The UAE industry mainly follows the following design stages (note the terminology
may defer but the overall methodology is similar) Contd:
Design Stage
Quantity Surveyor
Detailed Development Stage
On completion of Design Development
Stage, prepare a detailed design cost
estimate. This type of estimate will be
priced based on more accurate
approximate quantities and elemental
unit rates.
Pre-tender Estimate
On completion of the Bills of Quantities,
price all items to arrive at a final budget
estimate to be compared with the
submitted Tenderers during Tender
stage.
General
Estimates will be regularly updated as
and when more information is made
available
Page 8
Design Stages (Contd)
Information Required:
At each design stage of a traditionally procured project, information should be
provided to the quantity surveyor to enable him/her to prepare the required cost
estimates etc. Generally Information would be obtained from the following:
a) the client
e.g. location of the site, the brief etc
b) the design team (all disciplines)
e.g. schedule of areas, drawings, specs. The level of information provided by
the design team would vary at each stage. More details will become available as
design progresses
Page 9
Design Stages (Contd)
Information Provided:
Generally the information provided by the Quantity Surveyor at each design would
include as a minimum the following:
- a statement of cost
- indication of specification
- statement of floor areas
- cash flow forecast
- assumptions & exclusions
- contingencies
- inflation
Page 10
Design Stages (Contd)
Factors affecting the preparation of the cost estimate:
There are many factors that should be considered while preparing a cost estimate.
These should be carefully looked into before submitting any estimate. Some of these
factors are listed below:
- location of the site
- ground conditions type of foundations, green/brown fields etc
- structure & MEP systems
- any demolition works
- extent of external works
- grid size
- program
- etc..
Page 11
Sources of Cost Information
Elemental Cost Analysis
e.g. BCIS, in house cost analysis of previous projects
Unit rate Information
e.g. in house priced boqs, specialist suppliers quotations, pricing
books, magazines
Published Indices
e.g. BCIS however not very common on Middle East & Gulf Region
The following points should be considered carefully when using any of the
published information:
- inflation
- regional variations
- initial quotations from specialists are likely to be low
- special project requirements
Page 12
Life Cycle Costing
The life cycle cost of an asset is defined as the present value of the total
cost of that asset over its operating life (including initial capital cost,
occupation costs, operating costs and the cost of benefit of the eventual
disposal of the asset at the end of its life)
Life cycle cost techniques can be used, for example to:
Evaluate design options at the elemental level
Determine optimum maintenance strategies
Evaluate total building options for example refurb Vs new build
Page 13
Main Reading List Design Economics and Cost Planning
Economics of design: Site density, Wall / floor ratio, Storey heights, Room sizes
Lettable / Non-Lettable
Sources of cost data - BCIS / in-house database / other external
Market inflation (tender / construction)
Location factors
Estimating
Cost Plans
Cost Planning
Life cycle costing - capital / running costs
Value Engineering & Value Management
Risk Management and Analysis
Contingencies
State of the construction market and Economy generally & Interest rates
Recession time effects on Cost Planning
Page 14
APC Questions will be based on following:
Design Economics and Cost Planning
Level 1 :
The main factors that affect design economics over the whole life of the building including capital and life cycle costs
How cost planning assists in the financial control of projects during the design development stage
The various stages of cost planning
Sources of cost data
Adjustments that may be required for factors including location, specification, time and market forces
Level 2 :
Producing estimates and cost plans
Carrying out life cycle costing exercises
Applying value engineering processes
Preparing cost reports
Preparing and submitting cost data to in-house and/or external data collection agencies
Level 3 :
Preparing and presenting reports with reference to cost, time, quality and buildability, including qualifications and exclusions
Evaluating building design efficiency
Assessing/evaluating market factors and trends in construction costs
Analysing the accuracy of predicted cost using benchmarking techniques
Interrogating historical cost data
Using value and risk management techniques.
Page 15
Model APC Questions : Design Economics and Cost Planning
THANK YOU AND WISH YOU ALL THE BEST
Page 16
