Publications Available from the
(CENTER FOR CHEMICAL PROCESS SAFETY
‘of the
AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF CHEMICAL ENGINEERS
eee Saeco cee ret
Stee
‘Gitsioes fr Tene Panne er Ob Ste Eee
See renontoces
peepee
SESE recteee ecerahe comin
So Seca em oe
eee ay
Seite Rebs re cmt an
AE Eon ret mentee
cE Ee emrereemeram
foe el
SE i Re yee
SES estige tenes metry
See
SRE cote chan es caro
rotten pron
SRS SE meee eto
Farr a
en
Sp aie rie ee te
tenn epee
SS ee reece
Sr ceeece rece
tibetan yan Wig nd
ee eel
“Anas, Human Factors, a Homan Rey rcs Sey, 1992
eae eee ey
Tes org cto
rei Sampaio nr eon
GUIDELINES FOR
Evaluating
Process Plant Buildings
for External Explosions
and Fires
(CENTER FOR CHEMICAL PROCESS SAFETY
of the
‘American Institute of Chemical Engineers
345 East 47h Stet, New York, New York 10017{ho Come Cann iio Det
sole tr tn
‘This tok dete he memory of
Donald F. Other
einent chen engine nd enstanding conto chemi
cn human ogre He wat aos enctor and racer,
ncn nd Piet actin the ale tons of
the chemi scence
“Ths ook on making Pris plat safer isin pet of extending the
rns of nolege and entering racceContents
Preface
Acknowledgments
‘introduction
1st nd Spe
15 etl De ing Pato or as
12 ig it Sin etn
Sgcceaaee
Management overview
21 Eplnn adem
An ea
5. Initial Screening and Consequence Screening
£1. rod Pt Denon
2 al stg pel rem tan
‘thera Cnet ease
222 Sel oe ie oe ey
n
a
SL chem one Gen Dn Specie 3
3:22 ene nny Meg ea CodeineRisk Screening
{2 erent Use Rik Messe
43. Orton ohare pc
131 Pc a ating en
Sha nacy
2 tml leg Danan Pi Se
4.34 fap bt ge ain
Risk Assessment
5.1. Had eatin and Exon
13. ay Fats Corin ose Plan Blog Ro set
5:32 Slr Casement
‘4 Guten fk Aest
$42 aoe gemy i
5:5 Guat ik Aa
$51 Oceans meg ain
Risk Management
61, Rak Msseoneat Over
Sage Ra es Ban
(62 Ring Rok Buin Pos Pas
5
Bisessenze
7. Future Developments
4.2. Bemmanton csgnt Voce Punt
ttn Danse
Bement of oe en Deere
274. Dokpmt apy Spe isk Tales Crea
4S impened psa tisk Harion
‘Appendix A. Explosion and Fire Phenomena
and effects
A ios ae eens
12 Dalty Chana of Boson
21 Ee
‘3 es of aon 0 gs
‘Appendix B. Principles of Blast-Resistant Design
312 Amat Tange
Ww
a
109
DSC tts Ce
References
Glossary
Index
m
17
185Preface
“The Center or Chem Paces Seley [CCP was abe 1985
ye Ameen Inte of Cael Exner the epee pares
‘lasting day soning or maging atastopic smal es
‘dts Toschee th pal CoPS has oases week om ur areas
xablabing aol pulsing he lest seni engineering, and
fmonaemcn pass fr peventon and mig ices
[Sreling tne, fama andor reacte mate
Ecieapgthe ue of machines by doserminatin ee
neato seminar, mapas and comeing eluaos pro
‘pans renee
[ansing esate ofthe atin enpinceing pats ad tain
‘management eboagh esearch sr peweton abd mite
‘Berdopng a courant we of undergraduate ngnscing
‘Sura eto enpeore te Sty wed and onsccasess
Despite pean bulge hazardourpocetunacan presen
‘sco ak. Though these many dst pat orang Seip
‘nTsting they dbo aways appeal seco the inate to eneare
‘Stent vel sey Th practical Bakers sale alin hae
‘Sly sos he spectrum of tare and condos of at
‘Hike ire anelosion rls proces plane bulgs a eu
‘rents eral tebe
"Aer ring teckpoulon ean explosion phenomenon:
funanes on asesing ening. abd mang ks srs th
bling design ad sang Two appends ve etensve cove of
‘losin andre phenome ap elets apni of Hast ena
(ilign Aveta gary amen nthe era ae neAcknowledgments
‘The Caner for Chemial Poss Slr ofthe American Inte of
Chemical Eager ome 2 gest deaf thanks to the dei pror
‘Sal ences snd set howe wih dation onthe Vapor
{Choad Eplson Szram: drt derebpnen of this ueer
Hooke They ae
Join A Daveono nds! Rik oscar
{stn ¥ Barwa (Monsann Chek Company
Peter, Hotinan Hedist Celanest
intl © Kit [Union Cae Carportin)
Rote E Linney irri od Chemis, ec)
ober A anc Amaco Coes
[ney Noor [acy Mut Resear Corporation)
Gary age Amerzan Cyst Comps
Erlrasm A Scher [Medl esearch and Deropment Corton)
‘Reha Fh led Sil, ne
Gost Sis hob Resa ad Develpeent Corporatio]
“Thotiskolprpungthe tx eal ables, nd guste bok
‘was enti 0 EOE nonin San Franca The nial authors
David W foes
yosth Abu
Seven re
Stepien A hor
(Gate stocker
“hes whi exert i evident ought the bok, special in the
‘hk run Cher 6) and exlee snd Be phenomena and
Principles of bastretane gn (Append Asn
"Thc ethos ad Subeommaee ree wel served Ging tis flo by
‘ob GPa then deter of COPS, Wis | Ming povided COPS
lp ad ase,Per review for hs imporan volume was prove by
‘A.W. Bich Goode
44 blah
DA. Crow [ichigan Techslopal Unis
E.R Dancer Aiea)
ce,
=
1
Introduction
Catastrophic siden inthe pes indies ae uncommon events
‘Thon tha let bulldings tn meat proms ats ae even ess
{lege Tlie of seriou vet sang bards mats
‘te sd ase, fest eure rage plato proces
‘ay management Spesiealy se COPS Cusine or Tecnica lan
Srement of Chums Paces Set Rt, page 2 sates:
‘ee nal pe mes re etm acd wp
‘Seif we pe are nese oe me
(i Sar ey cme
oot ri hal kee cmc to pe
SE tc ded wn oe sere
Fronaay mnspa snaps abe oe
“These pres sey management stems ens that cies re
signal comarca prod snl masta ih spp ont
‘ne tose ses sxe Homecare puts ba
{Bp ln wo hasous pene ls Rae presented erie re
fone who workin tea Thicovenatnn pomp that some
Fling, bese of thor deen and cect, ate else wes
bjotel compactly eden mesenger
trio sbe ocipan, Coney, geen nats ht pone
ested atom andanny orc us fsbo tesame Dl,
‘ahve we lod a cs nyo aly
‘Oreste on asodents ve ose, prompngesmpeie, ns
‘ey ssi and sures to popes ling des or siting ads
Etna of topoving sey Therein stands Hower ea
‘Sealy ppb tall indy sone ano no enrte sna
{Rrelof sey Conseqasnty th pace ndarty gies he eed or
{Sana on ulm apps the dengn ad tang contra cme
Ender pln) Balding. The ndasy ao eos that ts
[ince pret fe pacha! and ces apne sto thespectrum of interested indi, and musta ny aunt the ce
(pera ad cndions earings any pars The ppse of
Uh tole Culine fr Evaluating rece Pan ings fr Exera!
xpos and Bes to adds this
‘Avie vatesy fehl pd poses sty managment atc re
reeeeal throughout these gulines Detaled coverage thse sues
Isotade the sepe of ths bok od tests eel oter CCDS
{hk formore infomation. These inde, npr.
+ Guidelines for Teche! Mangement of Chaical oc Saety
thet)
+ Plane Cullens fr Tec Mangement of Chemica Process
Sie Re 2
+ Guele jor Meza Bvluain Procedures, Senn tio, et,
‘worked examples Re 3
+ Geli for Chemical Process Quantative isk Anas Rel. 8)
2 Gautier Brotong the Chotacenisc Vopr Clad Exp
‘So: lash Pe and BLEVEs et 5),
Addon, de fillowing ern abo pov pidance:
“+ Ameran Pevleun Institute Recommendel Pac 752, Mon
ferment of Hazards ASsocited with Lacon of Process lat
‘igs Ret 6
1+ US Amy Sree to asthe Efecto dental Expos
(net 7
+ Chemica Manutsrers Aseitin, Rspomble Cae®, “Codes
‘ot Management Pate” el)
‘Ax American Soe of Chil Engeets (ASCE) document ted
"Desi Bs Resistant Blinn Petrocell” Rl 9) 5
remy bang deep
414. objective and Seope
“The shee af thee gudetine sto provide «pata apach to
‘enahing raluaing sd managing the pcs aly conserains
‘Slt wih proces lant lang dg nd sting Thr tok spe
false the explo adept pos plat bul,
‘ecpants and faction earns 4 oul of eet eter he
aiding, wah the primary oss on exons, Chaps 2 presents an
teri ofthis appeach, Chaps 34 and 5 dss ations seeing
nd sk asesment rebound tk manapemet, Te appes 1
recess plant building i reviewed In Caper
“histo does no species aes tne reste an theron
“ra during theoraatonedatingies Toners bythe,
‘Gotaomallyompromie thers ney aablngandon
11 ote ane spe s
scape ci e pote ont ets hah cantina of (I
tatdingvenlaion only (2 bing pesnurcaton and alin ok
peri [essen that pede oxapat thet wn
‘Frees pene pene oupmen ting beng Ps
Tata nd [3 omerncy eoponse procedures ad tazaing. cht
‘eaon posture Fr poco pln binge ested nes where
‘hepeentiafor stn dea ext teal actos other stop
{sor peeton or miso mest shold be cose Jet
‘Sunt of bling singevalston
in stew sell sus, ablngmay need toe cele ore
combi cao exon and one este Forme nthe cet
Sta exis, bulling may retain sufcentsacral ey
‘rotor bullingoccopantrom thelr yer rer damage ee pnt
{itisananlnge artist proesina fam stares ose
te conjgncun wt he exlasen.
fh deed daconn of he ccs of wi sca prepa
Inalng twine bys the spe of ts boa apd ser COPS
fleseaa ree oon tun to oalusngtine eames Thee
Itehde Gustine for Use of Vapor Gasd Dupri Model R10,
Godtinero Vaper Rela gon Ret ed Gaels be Chem
‘cu hte ik Arse). Rees 102 an 08 pe
‘lca pane nthe elects ee eleases on ling aps
Pro lant lis by indexed o roca ais
itn nit Boundaries wel lings men aren tha cul be
[epsced bys eo explosion t he pees pla. tn an ow ame
‘hemi leis, the odin pcs ae often contained wath
Le balding sd the coer rooms and other oxo ents are
‘Suman rbidngs wth, thems balding Tock ls
ee spaallysafsune thee statins, ay ao rode dance
‘leant othe
plots ad fins can acu in wile mange of poi For he
proof these pudclines proce of ence ice hse ih
ital oc roe cpdins ht hee the penal
* Rees of nme ocmbusle mates eating ia
“Aor cod expbsions (VCE)
Thott ines
Cndens. phase ealosions
‘Uncontechemseal actions fanaa scans)
Boling bs expanding apr expen (BLEVES
Prestreome UT rere.
Pha exploens|
Cond eons
{pst adsl more ea in Chapter ad in Appendix Afn evshuting cploson and ie nga w proce plant bling
scape es econ t tol the once of tk ncn ak
{say ger he cepa balding shoud tbe pled at
tinea vel of isk esa of th won ction Specialy the
Bailing by i existe sbold nx snngropoatlyinese the wo
"heooapents Inevakaing theo sk wan dtl the alia
may represent one factor ong any Tato eomebuting wo Hat ee
‘hin the prs lane In seme eae, te bang May pest
‘pnt cnehson tan indo oie wanting lo
(pec the ie Stl ith ther cy, the et lig onan ay
‘licen ado atin eure Chapter dees ainda
‘vention shuld bet fat onsieaton en entijng options
foe sting sks Pate i a tna thet coutrcing pe Bat
Iie ners st oe eistance ny not aay beet
Elective means eins Soe sntons tay easter ease
tee otental isto trh inborn outdone personne sk etn
Isest aches by peeing the even en ecu piel,
fed the eosin det
+12, Background
‘As scutes inthe inti to thi chapter, poe aecdents have
‘Suested the need fo an improved pooach in sessing he sk
res plat bsg apd ter ccapant Table 1) proves = woe
{ecafsome sero nies inring blings pte plats.
‘Whe suri ving tn prevent sch sce, they el ay
oscar However a ndatel bythe acidnt in Deve, Cad,
‘aden, Now Jey, popes deen apd sting o occ baie can
‘vunealy mac he ka fy
Torsten cas ant dng the potential lors
ilar bung capt the eras concern
nests ballings louse alcool apupeent per eps
Sasting yao epee det ae gts fe doe oo
frocss ctl well as sass intarapsn ot abd roget ss
From such eves
1.5, Evolution of Design and sting Practices for suldings in
Process Plants
Changing condos witha the procs industry hoe often aed de
‘sign and sen of lings This section cota s it woe of
nds peeis onthe des al sang process lant Dulles
15 etn en asta reste Bln oc es
1S euanneang mn
SS ie re
| wos eStore ce
Ga:
‘rors | potanas
age
fe | seascw, |,
ianoStet Actes vg Bung Process Pants
ae] ten | tees | =
‘Sed severe ast sn tre aaage fot
‘Sriaione Aleneus wet eae
[nctecrstg ne tac
ee
= |: Ease
waios Soca een ees te
1131. Brief story of Bung Desons
Aspraces lan desis and management pts hare tole, bing
fatons and cations ae change to eet the new operating ee
meats often Teng t an incase tthe numberof ulin aed
etsnnel hat were noe neat the ross unis. Ter amp ntl
Fectisesheve spay nen ested win oraacent the proces ants
toprorigectoae coral Otherbulngs such smite: as,
rain sometimes eae sian pane plant 9 ll peep
‘apg of operations
Ta conthuour pest inate soho petmleum refine pet
semaly inated demic aed etlieny the ang ane a
[ude hae Ben lena byt uch healing Rl 2
+ Tecreted uk cps edn Inger epupment. These wa
‘eal no one ena balding.
+ Gur ction of pce unt or uipmet equi separate
‘cto bulge non init to doping
recs aie,
1 lon fnson ann ten fr adnan Proce Pons 7
+ Wort sae, singer units, sole with advances in stoma
fin ido the ur ofseremcianes rv pag postonine,
+ Siultraneminion latin af paca ctrl yes mae
‘Rescoaryto int the stnce brn he cnt Beas the
tester o conte vale As eu aly cota bowser wee
Teed wa rat the ig of he panes ui
+ The dowlopment a leant anor crputr coer made ¢
mew eonal seve poss nt om 4 ental cone
‘tr, lading wo connie eoncenuation of gent aed pe
‘Snel nent ee.
+ Spor set sachs iis, egicering and are
{or fctons were moved ser to prcesr ants to fate
‘ncttngs, Tex fancton wero lose the coal es
trim separate baling scent poe ee
Al any hatch process, such tose a Ue spay chemi
‘stay eg. pharmacctels prin, abd lsc cad potas, have
‘cal lcid the conte and soporte to the process
Im pi sttangeney, the press plat Duldng conta lor most
‘tthe pres, wih the sont faneon frequently hosed in cena
inetd oom within te Hat hung ov die ing
1152 Standard for sulting and Eauoment sting and Separation
‘Many companies, a wll indy insurer, rade asocaons, and
Standsdserancatons, hve veloped Seat cera for spacing be
‘ween plats bingy eget ad per ines. Thee ee re
‘eat sce the pct fens rer eo mains casgmst od
THclcy tno acess wn and buldings Tae 1 tats the
‘de atts of pacing enters tae up
“The wide anges inopcng terse Tale 1.2 eft the
very of poten Ras 25 wel a he rene ebjever the
‘nous ons ha developed dhe ten fe mera, sane
Uns anda are degclo pte propery ad mime bess
item inthe erent fs nedent RPA stds oe deg tp
Prevent the cure os fea due the pes fet act
rose Indian ompun tae oct sandals nay stamp
{ears oh of thse jects wel peso salty. The le
Sho demonstrates thet det hela vats inthe pes psig
feces, mater bonded, ad ojos (ke, equipment pcos
‘eros pmol prota osu spac sand appopte ke
Mapleatons
isan fe 27] pois vl cect or equipment and baling
stig ad yoo sy prpose rel are ee rt oe
ban deg Thexe chek ian eons conacotins ad ly
[popphaloestion teseasn layout stunt lo planing acon,tected ott Pm pia ct
Rosen sage es Seaton ier
orpnatgnerne neees
Sa TES?
1.33. standards ana tra for Bulang Design andthe Need
for'ste specme evauation
Desig stands for bldg in rcs plans hve alo ced ener the
‘eats apse to cents eto east a Table 1. These
‘slencs cal spel dhe deed Bulag espns to desi eens
ast sich as cs esl frm a TNT detonation o apo dtd
‘olson ofa assumed seed distance fom an cei tad, A
‘pec tnd for example, muh spc ht talingbe Seg >
‘uhstand a lst equraeat a on [900 of TNT 2200 (6)
Uhe Bat sure, Another tadard might rege that 2 bung be
‘Exige ora pal (1b lat onset t= dara 100 >
ipa le» apo oud elven
Many a ing dag td sing cera aba wp bod
Han dese piensa nt gona evan of pic mat,
Frese condos, or plant roger. Whe eee in any apes
tions is approach eam leads dens that ae ove ens some
fnntances otf to poi he deste degre protection in oer
fstanes The appecach proposed this bokllows the se of appton
‘tein desig an sting tapods ht have ved err te eats
‘hd aes to acount stespeale codons. Tes noe an ea
‘Sion ofthe matralsteing nde, pees endtons balding losin
sd ccapany, ting den and mater of coset, and f-
‘Seven pes ley management ote
"Te tpn appt lis procs plan owner abd operators
cutis sean pnt bug bcdonthae ate spericcsdons
‘Tales bling Sign ad sit sues wo be managed st he eal
lev witout nponng pesca ht nay tte prope
to's specie Seay. This spioach fas te eal es of prong
Iniomedco eect managment he he acted th Babs2
Management Overview
“This cape oes an over ofthe aproch ested in he bok
forse valuing and managing the cess say conser
‘coated wth clon pd escarole st
YVasour traning and sk stueement ons set help ene
Iuingy ht may preset» igneant nk o ocipnt rht may be
Slescer orate eens, sch pss snes nett es
Gide for spying the sla the ana 0 male nskbasel
‘hebions on lle dng ad sig ata dns
2.1. explosion and Fire Phenomena
‘An accident canbe ined a an waglanacd cen or seaenec a rete
that sus na undesablecomeequnce Po the pups ts ook,
“indesine conmgwenc deine an epson ore
ee an enon ie can oz, tain omtons mus cist.
and tht cand to epson oe es se be pee I ou
‘he tha means tht Hamma combust, o tact mate, ot
proccss apbldprofucag exlste ats, muse pest
‘Siecd, an tating event must ocr fo bein te en sequence
ample ste human err ad equipment far. Thi emer
‘Sens mut omar alvin the sent soqunce to poe ewan an
‘htc These intermediate een flint oro cae: parting
‘rents or popping lets, and mitting evens or gating aor
‘Mopwprn set or positing aso alow he asaet mae
to commun dain consequences tat re ubequenty ore seer
EsSape te ft of tlese-dton stems beth pene 5
‘enon sur
"Muigoting eens or mtn fctore act sped the scent
sequencing in ee soe consequences Eames inca dete
‘ian snson ofemespney shutdown ystems cpestrntnentn,
‘pllcootinment sgspment racing nation, sadreding tberue of gion thrgh the a of etc egigmnent
‘Tibbs ns pal tard and ohows examples ting rap
‘ng and mitigating erento fcr.
‘Ren event seqence cn peed to Yann ncdet une,
pending on the seq of tem vent a6 shaw y Table 2
renames tse o amma voe sould est apr cot
‘pls ls ie eo arlas Capesion rhe ice ut
‘Stes tht ths bak ass sey decried bel
For example the alent otcmes tat ld et en he eles
a anamable corn atrial as fll
+ the leas shin ited evaporation he Dama
‘oat oan the wound fit, lease the mate
tour above the ul sia athe oo sen in a el e
Hest fom the ie erste evaporation fo the ont snp
thet Damage tom poo es usually ea and esas
"aan ea and et ame cota
+ Ihe reese bans st he soe of the Fea an he system
‘peratingat sunt hgh pressures reat ite A
the etent of mae me to the sea the vy che
Mme Highyelcty jes fe lately unaleted by ind, whe
Tow sch scanbetid and shonenedby nd Fors
ewophuse spon ofthe gad ny na out the et
Stream, ng pa ie
411 the mene formes fapor lod that pei wih Boe
fants ccna trbulene eloped oe amy by the
‘hme tent propuesting tog poses sauce he Dane
seed ca acer scent to cause 9 Bast Ths eve
‘led o 2 Yoel explosion In on 0 st let
‘ant eat and ceatat lcs abo uc Fasc
‘hesouce may ease pol ser ete
+ tte release hms aor the mies sliced wh itt crete
2 smaller, and po inion tte i ne sue.
Turblone orsign o corte te ame al poe
Wists fs fe veut Damage gun eased by ada beat
And et Hae cea, bu the ated area ay Be moh get
than fora pao ee
+ Wain of fact iste osu the reese wl ur a 9
fb Burning wl cos primary i eke ater Ir of the
Fictnih cout As the fuoyacy ofthe ho aves see, Ue
‘wing ltrs epee and assumes phercalhape Dat
tesa ose det ane ont and raane en
Foc more complete dacs of thee events Reece 5
‘onl evens sncern tat my may ot ole Basra
oc combustible mates cndenaed pee explo acon
‘hemes ection, Ring hg expanding vapor exon BLEVES,
ae Be
"|
ew ee
Se
Freee | eee [ee
SS | =. SS |=
a | E-| S— | S—
—— (salsa | So
|=. | 0
= Some eetoee | See1" 2. Muroerentovnten
pressure-volume FV) rues, phys explosions, and coatned egh-
Sons These ae bey dsr below
+ Fare of ese sotsning hgld temperate sore
sumo fling pont may pofuce 4 BLEVE, wih seul
ase and apment sect If Oammable mater ole,
ALEVE my as proce ral
+ Unconile cheracal reactions es, polyetaton ean ese
sulicne enc to nun stare the connate Se,
iting to Bast nd ramen eins
+ Arp loss of containment of + prom pa oF wpa foe
ecsunlyfszmabe mstal, cled 2 PV pare (a Oe
Pystal expos may rode rpment les sla at
Inaveas the pil qn id ompsses the surouning a
Whe acne arab FV rsp ay ao be
Iaowel by ical
‘+ Amer Se of pyc! eosin can our pon pi spo
‘on of id when once wth sian he atria
{et water aed o vse containing ht ol Ths elered
{oa mpi phasetreaon epson. Inala las psd
‘cols cm also sence pent eh ntl eid
+ Sime snencs ean vleasenigean ew they deenposs.
Unie cenain soniions, thr dampotion can tans # oh
. Went nin ed emp cag tsp
penton pt orn org rt oe enc + eta
‘Shemp nt can ots te get AL,
‘hepnowlarsesposon camo cote ced TOS
‘haar an opsnigpecemes amp eae etre
ol Runt tae ming eer ero we ce
‘mmr ptelpnon ne ad cst en of
pening
is inched scr coul ei an pon
igang bing he Dlg san Gong rat
‘ape eases ery eps prem n pe
‘Sting ecuton ithe nts: Conry he pact
‘Sesiegccynttoms tr ewan, andrteeon
sree
auldbeompanaed t gulatcncan: esr s
aly nove fm Rte ora hve bg whe he
“Sar dus epee sper th ste ae
‘Sede, gan sues pert sey cs apo the
low cals ptt of NFPA Class IB mabe lil when banded
tude the conto aes.
5522, ouanttatwe Consequence Scroning Based
fn ste Spec conatons
‘Aguanstatie cnseurnc seening ean be permed by evoking the
Inherent propery the mates eng ha cjunction mah
Suite of the qoutes svi, sp casero ef the cule
Turion snd fayoat of the pene cgreent A caculton i hen
pele dctrmin penta stl, lang to acount te spe
‘Se eos conrtutng to ce mlagting the ott onseleess ee
orVCEs dee ofcotnemeat span layout and saci. The uke
‘Medien eds dtp which baking ae appro desig sd
Sed and wash quite fer evaton
Vapor Clo Exlsion Modeling
For VCE, consequence seein sperma in 2 mur of rent
‘way depending aon the level of decal Scd and he nl ovale
{he ane VCE cnseunce seeing Hed om an enim he
Ihe parameter tha cl esol cece gen coset oni
‘ns shout he gut and ature ofp se
Cabig the Mas in th laminae Ragin th Vp lo a
‘har mos gars om, VCE cleans se Stal dspion mode.
Ing with sums of cool sz, dou mes sh dstances the eens
‘wl wave Tis tft then eo determine the pote art
umes tht ca be shined bsed ons evasion Of step
‘tions, ng cer the TNT equnalecy met. he Mluety
tod the Bake Seblow mode Ret, toler alae odes ix
Steve cass, alter etal ispeion deli and sere othe
Tigo tay be ovale thatthe tee hate Say, exponen,
oat cus of the ck of eongetion or oninerent a he od
Danries oy made
Stespeincondons ” MOMs
acground
‘Mama ocation gs tats ye ha proces ata all
‘Sy An fice ig ated 731015 fom he proces
‘Sure Bn othe othe acy, mo perc oa
“Sulicay seedeqpmert are inte area at can ste conienent
“ngs a eee oc Furr he amma proceed tow
[were and amine angen= {tat Seng scone Sei
‘eer
circled td on dpnin mada the pe dd ae
Pcie rete elt ck
‘tings Spe be ie enn no eters war eae
In some css, deta perm modeling tal may aot be ease
orth ie sat wstated, Tocakite he softies prion
{nthe vapor cad eer ss pete, though suliccnly consestNe,
etd rane orc ssi omni,
‘Suid base toe ian explodon or fe Some conser oP
roaches tr determining the ans tera lesb
or a go vapor les, the potential amount of materi the ad
‘a be decried by one a the lang og
1 Mate leas ine rsuieo ope ek wher theme
ised stop the lak functn fslating potemes
fency ves, depesriag systems and ther mgation se
ty eke rate tie for eo achive delayed non)
«The ul invetry f mate as fied Wy a single rin
Ineneeyem or by an inerooeaed ys] of mara
For nonfsing ie ls, the mutes the cloud eu
tigi eeaporton rte [time for claw schieve delayed ition}
‘easel thatthe caption ate depends up the quay of mata
Spl the ster re, and torte condibas. The quay
‘pil promt by
[Rate of mlense] ee eguiedt stop the ek]
‘The tne meine to sop the Kak 5 fancton of ating pins,
fmergncy tales depending, er ini sae
Foca worse o asa as, he mate in he od ithe sera
2 taco vaporize fate fees] equed 0 stop
‘belek
1,1 aon vapor te of ese] x me fr dod ©
chev del easton
55 commence »
Delton vapor al inventoy of mateal
4 Toulinvenory
‘Noe The facto on tems scab secon for the esl
formation anensainment inte ahing lear Aso when determining
‘the mater in he sud sul fom» tm pha osha le
‘idration shoul be gen ode content the lo ih
ol wpa,
“Theres upper limit the mas ol math can onset»
explosion, etl oleae drat Ths pes ale
sprint, which due te Osianale mat st the dsl
ttedanes to coneratone below he lower Ramses
‘Gelade reba numero bugs on urease
‘tak cui the pony st ey hein of sng A Seed
{oleae ll baldings with sn pnt Below tha of Balding A sy
sh before, Akematvey s ucet concoct nth dt
‘repro the sk sone al, wer may wile bes
‘rom thereat nado he ofthe sega
4.1. Dertvation and Presentation of Ek
ik «mest of human injury or cmos vrs of bat
Ince Ilion’ Vequeny nd the ape of he sso ary
[eensemencs
"Todtemine the ik from paring een te eit
cutcome orci the rent ao heen ater“ | acs
timated The mune sk expel a the capes namber of
‘uid cums pr wnt ne Fer same fanning
(ret nist he creat ld ao sess nue every 150
‘ar he sk eaten 21503 10 enn per et
Tsk can be mare apd expel ina numberof me CCT:
‘Guilin or Chemical Pes asatie Risk Anas Rte
‘uber thee main tee ak meu Rak Indes, Indl Rsk
ed Sos Re
isk Indices express rk 6 singe numbers o auations, sully,
applied wo groups of poe eae i sao tle ate. Tw
thetmare common ends
+ Average Rae of Dea Re. 3), elie a he areas saber of
{aes eae might be expe pr ui ne fall pose
incfetsThe Average ate of eth i srntimes presented 2
Death ar, which repens the toa aero ee, fall
2ccents, er 10000 workers peat in a en yo work
‘Houp At split the chemical processing dusty fr expe
‘Meathrterskindexmipheespesthe tal aur deaths ovet
2 pei af time rach a ne Yer foe all ole wooing in the
Infos, inlting ar work and ocr who se no ry
{posed to pnt! precast saidents Depending apo the
‘rotk poup bing menue the death ate may may ct elles
“heat mist exposed segment the population nce ee
opi a high ak nay be sve wih any pone apa
Seek
Pe ite Act Rte ANI el 39) da he ae
false: per 10 exposure tous We spite acamulsed oo
sre hors fra poup of 1,00 pons na weng Meine! Agi,
‘pening pen th work ou eg meas FAR my
ote thesis to the met expose epee he OUP,
Indira Risk expenses the sik pero expos os haat
‘somal ate the urn af sr or npr per eat
Utter The of he ror eomtnon inde sk morte
+ Movi India ik eid he rl the mst eps
Indirdaia anexsnepopalton Inthe cre! prone ngs
ln bing, hs the eran aspen he ee
Inigo sy The ko thst excel
Causey einige eee uncer
‘hat ean eae sllcent bude danse oon seus o a
uy, muting the poy seas era ay an en
‘ulpping this vale y the psn facondeupancy [e,fe
‘mol tne enn the bulking, The ta ito tat exposed
{nda thes ofthe sealed fo each patie ent
“+ vragen! ik exposed pop), eine 4 the in
‘ln erage oe the option that sexes he ik
[eg cretody wo wnt a large plan) Th n= we sk
‘pet fmm eth ppalsten Pangea The
‘erage inal skis dcalypopruonltothe FAR kinds,
‘Tiepopaltins inzmeasued rete same Massed hat
the aagesqel aval present in th workle 2.00)
Bs inser the FAR most te mull bya ra 2000108
ee 10 determine wera neal
+ vero nda ak otal poplin eed athe india
fs over proletermined pupa, wheter or ht ppl ate
‘uly exposed the sk the population ie ar te
‘measure canbe desing 8 mt dpe very ow a wee
Timed pons othe ppulton nt exposed to gh
Slt lak meas the potenti for incidents wo aft many
ple Is histone ppd a ear ito the gh
Filipe othe ue tyatar sents Scala when ected
alegrncy dotsntnel maine cauay cetyl NING
Showin th equa of cents (ein to or more alien
Wie socal aks geal apie to cents at cam gut he
rable, major sede in chemi processing lt ay abo ave te
Fete wo allele noes of peple In arte sie mvor
ent eold leet mule Dulin aid mn dal nse each
‘ding Thay, he cnc of mca rak ca be apple Yo ort ak
‘altos al afte evstons
‘As wl shown in Socio 42, puishd data ae alse 0 he
plato of scl rl messes inning the cope 0 ik
‘Satya Neves Hower nos pandence hasbeen
‘Ecler chamctersing va to the secral ple and wold ot
‘smal be ecard a abso abcting raat eve Ferenc
Tes appopaae, thew to suggat sour ck mean a 8
‘aoc to soe oop pisos to rss lant bing
+ Aepept Rk isa meu lth ko prone wiki sing
Gr bailing or wits ey lepending wea the nk ng
alist who ae mpuctey the amecrenakingintosccunt
‘etal ume spent nthe Balding} aly.
aegis wed to measure the calletive sik o people in
‘acy wh sold be exposed fon event or eet I nests the
frsurney that aspen! number a ole wil ler pie ot
arm eg, death ast aie the cane aso skate cn
etapa in tems he eqoeny dntbaon of male camay
In general, consideration of iol kets the ee ase
hat each buldig ecg ot epesed oot tak Ageeisk addesses those situations whe, bea of sing eset many
{nding oecpant oul eat ak ete busine at» wile may Be
‘pose oan nora Bhindi ssp fk oye
‘ee cnndero when dass concerning balding at emake
‘42 Interpretation and Use of Risk Mestures
Inusing ny ie ess shoul be membered ht ik ness at
eat ateony exists lpi even fgueny an easeences All
‘uk menarements hue teres tone stunts the era
"scan be gh span The it het tk mearuemen pee
Should fe a cnscraton iy oy kbd decom making pecs.
{Chapter ol Reference pres hurr dacston of enn in ak
(con aking
Rak Asha it most tts eo compat lentes, With
compre te, wlsing the same mets sod suse
the unease naka ted to be eed Risk anaes
‘toes tht ae aot being sed compare teats can blithe
‘kevlomenu ese or melo again which he ata
icreseunbe luda There maybelimel aes underakingan abode
‘ksrolyunlesone knows ia sdenes aw oe willanesn the spose
ofthe reeling nck estnses
"his Guideline Gv sk othe cmt of whether o ot che
perce level of kerb Aste the Used Ree 10)
Fests ed ey Excatine HSE| t 26
ov paw cu Wa se aes ae ee ge
Shy dasa muerte cna ea
Recommending rik terane ceteris is bond he ope ofthis ok
Forte sk trance is eampenyspeciie ad ach company shoal
‘onsae esabshing eet that rer company pal and bjt
‘alc ra actance tte vrata teeming ste
seiaons, and ie mance antlale en tis tps Tha cos
‘Seo siktaeranc cient have ben ped ewe to pve
$ pepe thar might ast nual spans eth tak
421, Use of nal Rk Measures
‘When considering indivi sk, he commonly conse o be
‘per tound,aore which the jd oe see and fe which
Sato mat be ken to rr the lke Page taken th HSE
(Ret tartare thi concep fhe ie se he gn se the
Forze, the aces, cna, eased tea eee Re
sles ofthe Beit assist wth he sen, Hiedcton soul
Eepatamed
ori faling bow th ints might be made wo foter ace
thea oat ty a a ow enna petal (LARP) Tn the
Wosdssctves wik uk inthe ALARD gon stents farther
isk redcun oth estnt ssh ik ect can e sted By che
‘ihond era quel eoachevee Fre ps that hier
{isk aces nthe ALARP repo we ose t the lea evel
thay te appropiate to cmpend,propstly, more sous fr tk
‘ecto athe hover ks, AUsome pt tek Bee
pea,SOCIETAL RS
tobe dewesed
‘aos, bth in ems fk vs and slope of cue tan
‘kta Fret als showin nea hh ee ot
‘iE for ons persnnel han for lt pre
lic ofthe Sega cures fo he appropiate sta
‘hounds of tiie Soc event vg paces lan gs
‘rely ntl sins few ling any, wan pess lacs
‘ch ag cncenistos af pepe Angee isk camer sea eect
‘Nespecic ondtons so rate ro
Casto of zee sk rues the same cent een and
‘onsequene infomation st india nk does gee ak
‘ques defini ofthe population ats, lunges profs
Forthe pryoseof easing sro pic plat ug he wold
atleast as. ane
AGGREGATE RISK
to be decreased
i
é
In some insane, agit Hk might ot be elecely measured
ssing Neunes Foresamgle dabuldingean nf Berubjesedt ssi
‘rent oncer, sod the budig s t sbj fo complex cpa
{em A cae ul ea toons em ok
‘The tsk may be beter measured by other meaos (Re. SI). Vans
‘evton lage consequence inents, One etl used is eat
{Be estimate numb of tlie pe yeas By mulipnng each eat
{esocncy yi eapeced oom sais) aed summing this umber‘The company has develope ral saree ik rer. corpo of
ther cera halted apse peso occu
‘aera shown Fig 7 nents the lene appa cae
‘hove th pp ent of wry or hgh ese
‘On ml pein apps Bt he sponte aaa
‘eed be epany ts Howerr Fe en ee ak
‘cv tu age ma con tae
eed au ore abe gpk bongs
demining ogee une oases pyr oy el enh
Sermo et tee an show bye cones
For rening pps howe, the ans a shown tht ulin of
Lele eh py ats
re byte difere proces unt ay reser ane sage
‘tkand shoud be elated ber neers eonceson eel
ave been abou ut the nes esta the kee aa,
Secton 422 dacuzed he ofthe ter hin EN cies or
‘deeming agree sg ek enue ca be sed or
ple 10 by mutism caches fqn ye pred ante
io joes re Tess rt tes prot
Suing the expec aes ete natal of 646310? expctd
tie rte ere hs opr x
1.46.30" = 155 yas per tay
1 oe | mm |
se | SE S| Be |e
ne] |‘ | ht |
Tse) a] ayes]
TOE) ] FA ]IR) 2 Ris:
Panes] a Tg [eae [essa fuze
sane] gf [saa iene] fun
Sng] | 8 [SSR] iSsi) do | iocee
Teale 6460
5
Risk Assessment
(Chapters 3 and 4 deci srs ofscening ols that can ed wo
Svat the desig apd sng of bull In pos plants. The results
from ee mveing rs par ulin wil al to oe of te sk
1 Theil cmseqenes orrkscening ress inated hat the
Taldingwsdesgnsorsedsach hats otacooce ei
{ogling fe een Asa result the bulla wa scosed
‘ut seo nelig fer canst,
2. Theil cmsoqene, rik srcning reals dl ot tly
crm the the ing mas 2 mar concen, 9 cold Use
tune mone entree valu on the bss faa
the serene
2. Theil onsquenos rik seeningrenitsindeate the
ling dco pant giant cnc
-uiling i cata Irie no ational sen Beyond seecning
decried ia Chaps and Balding in eaten 2 ate cae
‘nie evasion, wing qlee unntte ik asessnent ech
‘igs tema, kreducion measures could be mpenented and
{he ily receened we conic that tbl el of ak hs bon
‘his Bulings in cnny# rue Seber ikem ad 7
‘taman ik mcion bee ondacng arte na Aa scl
(Chpes 2 npr, rary ung eel fen rte evan,
‘farce sy tanagement rams ke manta PSM dg
Fpensure hat tea om am eet of concer ein J.
"Fas chats pas nel intmation ox ering qitaive
equate isk scent on ings n poses plants For aed
fiancee nk sesame echniqus, the ser sted thes CCS
Erk this sub ncn Reerence , Gudelns or Hazard Ev
‘on cadres, on baton. aad Relea 4, Gudetines or Chem
fal Process Quant ik Anas15.1, Hazard Identfeation and Evaluation
‘The fn stpin a prceaplan bulingriskasesmet wo Men pci
scent nab dat enn bgt Asc in Chapter
2nd hated in Tae? scent ar soe et that
ied oan rae of enc The ci cate oer ete
tnnong canbe ores ht old ep bags in ps te
“The rk ascument procs eps by weting spec scent
scenarios tha pp the nay under eve Step snl
+ Went the ests of dmable and crise mies
etn the ces plat the cal coco under wih bey
{fecontained Sins sey oder materi crpecs cn
thotcan lea epnion cen icating conse paseo
‘tons, pha exisons, cuted ema acta
+ ethic et rast ong cos
+ Tent immediate vent that ther propaete omit the
eveopg scent sear.
+ eres intisting ent determine the was siden pathways
‘tne bythe ebb combate etter res
+ enaty the rane af pie nen tems afestng procs
FHsotbudingr sd the opt cng cls 0 cs
that an esl fo he varus eit pty
‘+ Document the had easton proc for tera determi.
‘event fequency a consucn
5.2, Techniques Used to evatuae Hazards to Bullngs In
Process Pants
“he COPS pobliton Cidlines fo Hes Bratton Proedres
cod taken Ih 3) ponder snide ination on ais
‘sur cauaton hes at yb tng. roseng herds
ain ling poco anes my ped pa of eee
‘ocelot sage oranges rc compenae
‘ve tne ey nl vs iy bcd
“ha pea pes ass rating may ee fi
‘ake nfo ta eve uty eel aps at
so pce pat gs na
153. Key Factors to Consider in Proces Pant Bullding Rsk
‘Assessments
Aldous qualia and quanitatie sk seamen technique der in
proach they hate rome ste ncn, Reale echae
mi the wershoul ease udemtandingof hex common for
“Th scan pest eer ifrmaton abst eonseqencs of pres
lant eps snd es and the cos hae might ts te eoency
‘tau eens
551. Selecting Scenarios for stuay
Using he ehnigues loreal in Seton 6.2, a detalles of poten
‘eden stone con be peared Ths tear then refined a ge he
‘iin numberof cane eat acd tobe seu to adage
‘lt te spctrom of posible cident ant say the eget
(the sey The eps vad may le:
+ entiying tal ls hat do ot req fre vation
1 Gittings inoent ino abate nen pies placing
‘hem with oe equivalent eee
Factor that wilinuncete oping ae smarts in inventories,
comps daha ne splash esto Note tht by OUP
Samir axe the fequency of aecarence of pouped sec
‘ecm ofthe nal feqnenoe ofthe opel ent
552. Explosion Consequence Evaluation
Chapter 3 oles guidance om evhing the charac fe, pa
‘Sco overpressure, drat) of pteatal exbsion rie nomena
‘Addiuoalilormasn i bel sumatardin Append Ao this
‘Stument informs on pring more Sai evasion ofthe
“onojcnce tse pene on bingy scr, cmt
‘eeupants prs low
fxclodon Effects on Buin:
‘An apeson euler sevenl sectrlingetets which an pone
“estcie nosoqucncntobuldsaodequpnent Thee consent
ting minor dope oct clap, depending onthe
‘hres ay so wien the ing eet Tale 5 artis ae
‘Rect oa that lm anor explain cet
Difiraction and Drag Lowding, Following an alsin, Hast wave
pape trough chal ora fren teem soured produces
Elen wesc inthe lst waves path. The ape ofthe ast,
servedepnds onthe nature and steno the explosion andthe distance
‘Eom beeper eis gona staed to ee} a el shock
srwvelpestoreeeananey es om abet ote mam ae)
Torandensed pase, prsuaesoane [PV ropes, or vey ong por
{lod emlsinns [VEE ca) pre wae with sian se ime
lrweakee VeEe The bse ding on = soseae chads fo cosenh transient ree att indy dct and tte
‘remreure nc lol) and) dag fees alt ae
‘City sci wiht at oe agi) Reng
{nebo wih sana tcl mensions bang ry
tremely nee en al spel tre On
Ses an rk as ks ly ol ean to
‘repress Be lnding on senda is ly permed by the
oid end eet ce wre Ako ae hate ep
‘are amiss fb tv hase a ope pase The mse
‘Bhs recs ad dng te sur hoe
embed with ponte pce owod case Appendices
Spee nda inane iarton anos sting
Impact Loading a ation to ase waves an explosion may aoe
ln thecretan of apment ls ding props by ths Hae pee
ae along the pound ssce, dbs maybe ke ep cared lens
i Set fei i wi el wer ci hn
fgmentsesuking aed rm he epson The pinay conse
spec or ragment ads eae aap to walls ors och
{s spling sang, o petro. Pond eomsevenes node et,
ime ofthe stractare and dmapeweiment orn terion
Inside the ulin rents pace na he wl or with
‘lotrel eo.
Inertial Loading, When a expanion ncaa the rd lace,
poruon ofthe lat energy it tanned dct othe ound and
pats cura oud shock Also, a6 the lst wave poppet
{rough the stmoepere aco the ound ss an poate
dos! pond min wave chat propagates thug the ol or rckeo
ibeloaton of Bulling, Goud mevenent Bach buking esl by
the pune ofa pound shock wave wil indie seerstons trough
the bang whch an um wl cine ln foes on te bung nd
(mms sed in the bldg Ground shock es the bing
ST ny be insane compre o Bax prsmarenaing. However
[pound sok nde Ln tens inside tebulingbat ot spore
Este maybe amportant nd in some sittin, may epee
{He mon niguicant lee on hee eme Pontial consequences of
‘fplonnnace pound sh nce prog Kesardssch et
‘urs nrling!iling bjecslingeobeles and equipment beng
‘neuro ter ence nce te eects on sae sensitive
‘pment ea, + ay orate hanging state or png, The contents
{a lwemalcimpenenes of the balding can alo be feed by tea
{ees coed by te mtn fhe bing rrr fel 3 ape
{Obit pesur, espa hese pm se atch wo he suc ot
{icone pron the wills the srt
plein eects on Peone
[A int wanes dsr eects om people sndule damage to ngs and
‘and The sunday eas fexlosins vole ie conequencsal
Ffanens and Gens fe 61) Tse may cade penta aps,
Ferme fuling debne ring rom damage orcolspe pero
the nut bug eng subjected ola were ating a
Ientcan pence ohn, whe aomcweang fagmenecanleal ant
Tums oo npc
"Tony els of emasions ar those inhi rales cased a,
eopl an Lach don or thrown by hes nts stator obs.
Fees LO povies sonal pidanee oa cxplsi ets on Peon
1555, Fre consequence Evaluation
Convent le depend upon the intensity and dation ofthe fi
‘Deeepatn dans, he tema expose that eeepc
‘than Forsch eve the eer ha wl ete wed or
Uther comb materiale wil dead the sen of mater sh
Sal Rennes 3 pve ging tera to mith le ls.
ines forthe Unger prove ater OOPS pl
‘St, Celine or Chemie! Proce Quanta Rsk Anat (el
‘3. Clns for tema dation eects on peopl ay be found
eksenees 62 an Thermal aio dap cena gion
ates nd pone ae provided in References 0, 3, and
"As duced in Chapter’ mevaluang ie conseoenee pee,
consideration shuld be pen tothe sly of bag sepa 1
‘Some andthe pene fr pesoanelerpsure dung easton,‘aking imo acount the fi, rant st an stoke ngs pats
{he bling an pteaalymiatng fa, sich 8 fae poten
‘ystems andthe we of personne race gupmene NEPA TO), ie
Sie ale, pron sel ncn de proton bl
554. Frequency Evaluation
Allisassesomenttchniaes wht qulatverguantatire ie
‘timate of fequncy of ew cceutence Ths iegueny, whieh
‘remy sie pec can aes! by any face
Factors intueeing Event Frequency
Aen of Relerence # presets ist (hich des noe presume wo be
nn se on sce pone ies
+ Oversea sponse rel cnet en
(Orting vessel orkut dan
(peng ols mainenans cna dsing operation
Major as tpn salve term aang lange gaskets te
Excess apr Mow no ven craps dap yer
‘Terps he chung
‘Pract af process ese, sing leas contents
Le rp a procs ping stern
Paleo vee cele
Breaking off small oe ie sch an instrument oat
Dra ov vent vale sree et pen
‘Condens se phoerena
Altes vet, long with the ott in Reference 4, ve
‘cated inte hemi ndstyastos ocr when Sterna
‘rent equeny dade he ling
+ Hitory of previous incidents. equates, especialy sos
‘ney ndets below ape aly manage mate.
‘Theale athe cy y moe cyte a
ince uns the rng cass hve ee tei and
‘Sec tons hae bn lane to ree tr meee
"eval event fey, post dent can prove ab
septic Forampl fs paop salir a endear
hs pcental lees ave dou lene and eos pump sea
laure five osu eet might be seb to oad
‘hac sok a cena ie. Ths eoohsn say be valid een
‘hough rear pam nal tater did noel vor la
S., koraci cansein roc in Bung Reser 1
+ Proce operating condons. Some press cndtons thet many
‘anh ogy cane nae rey ih angers
(eps ete) bw egal ee rea
the tes handing iy mate ree, tle mate
tops abet eae po emp ean
‘Caner nes that notamment
es pd pester yk sty te a et 3
{ultofsemion rs pcs ao
+ Dp abwaneor deg inet. Akbudh processing cies
Se designed snd ball to spp ces an std, any
ces chal es hve sonal conaeest Palen
{Ein hi can ke de fom of one wall tices pane
Speaded metals oreren atonal meen capac) sch at
{Eaten oll for more equcne mates Any these
{Geos might decease the iced an event of ont.
+ Opennecomplesty. Complex opettons may intoce the 0
‘chal for oedoning ales ac inthe desig phate nd
‘hay al present challenges opettrst acute ad guckly
{Sate lant opts and esp wih appro ac,
+ Haman fst Frequene mama oferations may Increase che
ect bea vento as Even ser peu cicamatanc,
Be pabaiy of human er can be hg An earner a
Section ele the ented dri of es owe vee
‘Shraning byob. ee dean anes of ute duran
{Bache operator tmp to levee ea vale open whe
Moding fo ther dsr the oer cl fone Yo eu and
‘ne the ve leading s deco ese
+ ae footy. Older eqipneat paral eqipment sbi 0
foe thermal or mechanical eng may ave higher fe
{oe of are Adduoaly, nee elmer ny incrporate
Ipnvemente dene ofr the potent or epee fa
‘The cmderao can be aid ot nlf naa
‘equipment to eae pace units
Inspr tote that ae dosnt ayes hho
logue nr Ppt deed inspec andmantaned qe
Inia may hare alow kc Yar fot expences
‘ote vluble natin sacha he rans a ghosts
‘Rasta pnng snd ay ala bang abt pt deg snes
"+ Oveal eevee of pretest an emergeney conta
Prec sytes chat lm shtdown stems and ene!
‘ros conta oe he aya nent even and ely
‘peor esponae Protects that are poet desioned
‘Sra sad well maitined can folce the feqoeny of event
‘Sourence Contents ae atest ad manana
tna esa high fgueney of een cencee 5: ache
+ Htesivenes of race sey management ses. The be
tas a alee though 2 eye cer ey manage
‘ems. The CCPS Gusdeies or Teche Management of Cher
{dlPmeces Sty fet Il Guides or mpementng Pc Sey.
Menger Sams Re 68 apd Pant Cte Tend
Management hema Pros Sat et 2 dnb eee
teas of manazemen act ons hy oc the Heed
‘Sols’ and em The cecenear these anaes
‘Saylor in anesthe neal scan et
Tacs sch shone ane may at independ fone acts: A
alton event eqs shold nider sls tos pao
Speen
Ste-spectc Nature of Evnt Frequency and Managements Role
Isla rom te are discussion tht determining event seis is
‘elton by ste set tr, since bah chlo apd an
sent graces tay vty esl Hoa Ste to Stein he exe of
technology the vane and cent of pres lant pesos dad
‘hac hse theese Ao dein son at mayb por Jess
‘tote, depending on the aplication,
Bsc eh ppp technolo the ettvenes of ys ess
‘sey managenent systems maybe the ey fcr alec the Been of
‘Suet Freep wo sires srt ay hare
eee rss for sung pss nd ent a Oe may
hive an ce mechan teat atm, nclading 2 ppg coro
‘toning program, with «htc ror of iipsion Hn sad
Sem or aden en enon pene Thee iy)
Nie altel comson pga ands hyo uct corse al
“Thellchoalcfan un ine compaon ale would esate
{ote peters the send nity Sonar snipes canbe ood ay
leant al component ef oe tay manapemere
Pros sf) management stems are Sumie ad can Become
increasing elective or meee wh tne In the xm sre, the
ES with te clive consi niring program ay hares
‘Gy eded the pte eueny ol eae she ime he ga
\waracvelympemente Ache in prions or esol ld eat
Insrelucion of ecsary sours ore esoston en ga
Tits eens the ogra ene Cold tseae. Inara,
‘stablhinent ofan ef coeson maining peor te esd
{lity ov time cau decree the equen) a canon fae The
Samic naar of proces sey manage pte eae ma
‘nent conn monitor he eteenes of tee ses ese
that plant ke are cone ery aw eve
Refence 6, OCP Guener for Autn Process Softy Manage
‘ment ad Relerenr 2, ant Gueine for Tochneal Manse of
Cheat rca Sofa ler sslanaeo align actos.
‘Altooal erence mater canbe found ln COPS Gude for
‘Tesh Management of Chal Pees Sf Ret.)
‘Arana ote, istry ee operation and ete css
salary managenent sens no pst ances npectg as
‘lho buns wl ot Ine th station tpn ht Khe
‘teen ace: ne i apne ad til wth kod
tan net os ant th omens oop en the et
‘ecune pose say management sc aye So ow ie
{ine acy Sige bling tae eel eapropesey,c
tr ont ben weld sn vlan xls
[chewable ol sl be ols ih
5.4, Quateative Risk Assessment
uals sk sessment uses experienc, janet, al engineering
‘Smt the aun deeming even consequences and ec.
‘Gunster semen are ral the este cll ade
tent of amici te of qld idl. The epee
‘eps team ness Hk Bllings procs ln mht
Ince operons pron engecing consequence modeling fe Bist
(etn dot beat an eilaocaral egies
"The ean appach pedo, cacangecpansns anche,
whe reing te ony one nan pan sei he sa
“Te abvntag os quate appac tht an ually be a
sed or url tas quae stay, ah er ore se
Fehustncts nade, aaa nays mele aes mil
[eltoc! thn ate ghaazi metas ts resg the lhe
eciveand enn steed secur a hans, Quatre nays
then contest a, esting po, quate ses.
Memb thea ed toes od papa icone kt
‘make sone alge Wes unetkng a quate ak sessment,
the team sud be canal ated on he specs pote pela
‘Thteansaucnendrkcnbe moe pam ese
eoguney nt seit A tear mii ata eyo et
SieSstne dace var omens This wood ruts
sic, poly ang to dota ak Uy cy be
nant Coc Ihe tum a deat at he val 1
‘S2oShen pr rome gana sk alas sould be tse
‘Boman th nies quency, cosegence, oneal kena.
54.4, Quattatve Consequonce valuation
‘Qualaciveconequeceerlton ives dfning bral cater
‘Thich ne based othe eal lol of npry and damage hat coudo 5. cane
seatnaly be expected orl fan aident event Table 6.2 presen
‘camped qualtae consyuene steps
pls coseqbncsin tenn of erpresurand other eliect may
Seco anit md hth ect i Ree
snd Append k in ahsing te oases ol tel es,
Alle eto sun forth eyo the api, the at a
{he exon soos, and tsa xpos cts with danse
fromthe explosion tour Frm auch an yaaton, saan Blast
wunctrscan be determinants ines Elution eas
fate apical exresedby Horingcontourselualastonepesie
te lana a aie, aston Fg
Petal ling amp and dee of ecupnt inary reskin fom
Mast were diced in Chapt 3 and «The cose to bang
and peopl ro sts esl fm tots en ans
ba number fiestas bse on fence emul tne
nd Dolan fe 32 provide dita esingeonegacnrs tls let es
‘near explosions These data se suminaiad ppende Bal Reeence
Sandi fence 6 Ta aon ores Yer dae oestion
‘provided in Rekrence 67nd Gk AcntatonSerween oer
kind econ mun prea nce sas aaa
“Sf on hep infmation nd tht gen in Table 35, 2
simple and snseistive rltonship between gua dneriptons ot
(pls eonseqraces and Wat oerrmuemay be devpel Tate
‘SSesentsan empl lated tom Appa Beeler 5,
“he ovpesmure-ensepecertnsup i Tate 5.3 6 gn for
‘il ullingsoforknarycnsntin Lae lastest deta Ts
{tale caracterzasn of eases does no xls or
thespec sttl carers fs panel plant alg on es
itacaunt othe spac o duration of te last wave Asa rl be
ue 52
‘ramet ovate Desenton of Coneauences
baooe evel Ascenso ula, eri a Pat
free ig wi oti
SSE Serres yet
(Shbirs tect hung Sone Brow aay ot
Se
See
Js masr lng ey rag ay at ey
Soe tuner ane Sere ovr nw
[sceesrone puking deseo Mo st may, tee owt
ristontip bowen sansequntes and reresute must consreatve
‘encapse the characteris ma pose pes lane baling
"Fan's may te used im comjncon wh he imate of lst
cxeprue emu dvcuoed prerian tocndhct = quastie
‘Sleumnen forthe desig and sting of baling on pos ans
542, quattatwe Frequency Evaation
‘ulate guy evalu cn be wed ten ot vents ha ae
‘Sormely unl oom ave sacha remote chanc ofecarng
‘hat farder evalu uae) Ths mtd parca ape
rte for ea conjuction wh aati onsguenc craton
ene of eking aka
“Qualia suey celation aes dling bad caters of
vet qurny eich ean teed to sss he hod fossa
‘aspen nednoutrme amseqen). These ates cove fall
Sposa ol teqoensen, fom tone eesti vats tht ae il ©
thon thacareighy nie Defense aeons vary, at
"Tai 6 reset eal at and datos
‘Asdinsnnedin Stan 53, ste secticendtons neluding vows
incident sty, st conse when siping nod cate.
‘The sucnnnt ta mst have shoe wong kode of plat
‘prc a pest make essa agent tt ikelboed.
“Erampte S-on overpressure consequence for Reresntatve
“Seer eeteton oe
Denar ur on gas rake,
|. cassie conection stucar mie SB G02)545, Quatatve RekEvauation
Rik sdetemind gules by combining the gata assessments
‘ofthe onseqcncs td hood. gale ask assent ay
‘complied apt of Uoough proces crs alas PHA such
{hs hazand and operat study (HAZOPL where the team aes
{Guat the conquers ad Ulead of cenanios ta hate the
ential or impacting bullings. Depending von the knw abd
‘perience ee ofthe PHA tum an he nate ofthe scan Beng
‘alte the PTA tam may beable ach sad ces con
seh sng ae a or ing
ln uate nick decison mang vas wate wling the ua
thefequency and eonseuence tps rvs dese igre 1
Presents an empl fark mat
‘By plant the nk Fo enh ena cnt the ik sti
‘rot manag va al kang pose xen Ua
‘dais fr ik elton, fe move dae quant sk ase
‘ment Fer cmp; ek mate Pe 51s 8-4 mat wh ik
oortyrauerrnpingtoml tol ance hx castphmecen
"lng and lly 0s fue ey ees sk py
‘Thos avery gh mk ene and woul be sae rmebcin
‘On thet ere tyents tat eon mecenc cae 1,
ss dsted in Tate 53 oe rece a skp Vag thy
tay be Mit occur Beta oth kw sey te ome,
Fir essa aed no be scsi”
‘ning ol euch ts quate kaki rseixcanbe ery seal
ln dotting lowest ngs Por hee ent tt hae potently
major ot extastonie eansequnces 0 balngs and that top,
FRoweve, uate ek sate not abvays be at propia
‘att For events hat are potently ores eres
ramet Quateatve Freuency cteooes
peso
a Toa beraten __Feguey eYe|
Fra ikey toteieianvemeneiooe a
2 vovaneoy — noagecectoenrmcet wot?
omen ey oomarnienines | 110?
‘eos
Js ey tayo ou cine sot
of aig Welton, farther anlisisnendel. Cation shuld be
‘erase ene tit bingy portly sat fo mab or eat
‘opis eomseucnet ar not prematurely sen Hed abt
‘td gular mene
5.5, quanetestve Risk Analysis
‘aaneative sk nai (QRA) laolies the determination of rent
‘onequene apd quences Using deed eapeeiag elton sed
‘Stntes Tc ow of costing sQRA cn be sean Sach ote
‘aye sted when the oe fk reaction ey igh and he el
‘hk spent be margaaliy tolerable on Pes ana of
ion die However RA may beat ited value he ironing
Dr qulative analy eat ins n sskracton menses ae
red ath a rato bases hve ben enti. The RA
‘nitty ons hi onlin, wh the perl st ening and
omg the ences bythe cost of pring the OFA.
gue presenta Dei whichcah asst in dee fQRA
isnt rs specie balding Apppng the econ Honcho
Folding sul on of dee ocomes
1. The pnt bulla under consiin wil whan the ev
‘Mines scent with oro dame
2 Locos mifetion of eistingbuldings my rede renin
(hv occupant
2 No nent mditions that rice isk to the bing to
toe evel can be ented,
tn oatcome 1, no ned exists to srt ik rettion or QRA, fn
‘use he mar oneibtos toh aac ent nda
‘emeicd stesonsblecrny sagan GRA soeneesay Inoue
[ster the cmtratarto hes ot welll orth cst relace
‘thas nace hgh nica theinsu periedby ORAS
‘veal gaan in making ie aed dese
155.4. quantitate Consequence Evaluation
‘Qounsiatve omeguene clon requis determination ofthe Mast
‘temresus and ber exoston ot els hat can paca oes
lan ing ands dead sala ofthe lig spon
"Ths seton pets Heston of the mecha Sxmining
‘thetic tenlns and ow nee at eps es
‘emaaquncas he buling Append Beontain eal ison
the anes of ling dei so cant for exlsion eleSia
Increasing Lksthood
‘Consequence Category
Ineoasing Severity
ample Ris Ranking Caepres
[te] coer
pedo
7 [sre [ets mgd th grate
Jarauaac adage cans plone
fm ome
Ww [aeaieue—[oeatavea rnd moon hae
free penned
Feure tant ute tk mar cata em et 3
‘anand tg Seen A LRA
ere 52 5a ree
‘porte Bast ang Sructure haactnses
7
coe eS
Y
Tae
7?
unre othe bat wave and dhe Roetua charcet the
Iukingebmponats The pmary as wave and staal actor als Wave Facts
easton rereading be ose sof the as we
1 Impolseo dart thease impo eke res unde he
pessureine curve Durston the lenth of ine of ie reper
fre pas ofthe as wave
Shape aise ne ofthe onesie wave shack ere
time usualy the worst ce
Suen Rbiy of xh rl compost of the balding 0
‘withstand ores ad imple nde
Mason sons hse late the natal prin of ibe ot
‘acral gurney athe camponents: The elspa
Asami cherie fhe arent egueney abd
thedmumiccmmcerstes dt bade, dust orp)
cts th api esta rape at peste
Duc. Adit ofsratsal components toabobthe Haste
‘whut calapro exes doen sad daa
+ Shape and contguron,Onestory, rectangle shaped lings
‘ai bce estar torres an mln Fier
[ieahaped ing
Sat loadings fer an eosin se of short ration a have
led nce content Evan oman stl ese 9 se
iesureloadings ders om dag paces rcanventnel stations
Inthe te tene-varyang charset the lading the sel sd
‘ator carters of he stor, ed stl reponse Been
"ste hms must be cided eee othe sorta, et
Energy characters of at alin sgt oust inelastic)
‘sponse of suture abected to steading wl tres si
fr damage aslngsthesrctehasern dst fo ductile behave
‘Ava msulysonienr dyoaml sponse anlses ate uss eed to
opeievaut darnapeo baking lee olin om explosions
se clan anayr al no poi ele oaforbukng sponse
tobias lading
redo aed modeling the building andthe oerpeere eros
‘ume aig the bang pao cn eet by dams nolest
Struct ase at dane hove ApeniB dc th ppl
fochalacs Bublngropensts dace terms csacturd tet
Aisplcements and sesse. gcd anacqunens fo tems ef bale
ce damage fc varus fs of tng constuction leg,
‘enka once masa) a gen i ny res, thing Ree
hers 7, 6 and 72 though 75. Append Bdscsss wise cated
‘esting rape tvs level stctral damage using sch ren.
Consens of intrest or QRA ca dtr fm the a
led Builing dslucements andthe corespondig pete damage
lee The contort ithe pak of sexo ny oF
feos ay dae so Chaperone scnung Relationships
over ling map vs and pay of esos nyo ey
‘lnbe dlope inthe se mange otha done for ak ern Sich
‘lnuonship se developed asung tba eccopant suvaley
{lone of map eel sine of before stem hace
‘he damage Prof seus inayat vers bung damage
{fn then Be dread bern of at ets Rel 5,56 20d
57 as dscssd i Aen
Fm th cleat bang damage rer respons lationship and
‘he ezpa baby o eno ary italy vers damage els
‘ons dst’ aor, the rataip teen agin epee
(er otes ef and prtebey of sees ur or fly may be
‘Sostredn anncr hat scout rhe dae tact hare
‘etc. plan hai The eps nvled stat tok sean
[Cheer withthe sion dad quant sacral evaluation
‘Sf pot bangs and dete uote fequency sessment as de
‘Stbedin the est oc,
1552, Quandtave Frequency Evaluation
Ina quanta eqiecy crt, he pes plant usualy se
ted nto dlnbi molmer oe invent vet scenario piel
‘rd on rents ete and evan ss dics in Secon 5
‘kine Fae rte ita pray, bt ae ec especie se
“oped othe process pag vase chin, a other equipment
‘Guna ewe tequenes are aso» pen net ae Fe,
‘hefgueny of te went can becca using other wel sich a a
{icant cre ee nave Pequcney ssmate together ih
‘funtion of the consquenos Fouling er the ene mena,
(Eins lk Onset teqoeny andthe mapas ofthe send
‘Sent soa ac how, thet cat fe smb wit nration ot
Stespesievabl, sich salty to at, wou of wton, and
‘Shuey sponse to cate the patty tse al ead >
tecrem of coo,
Reronoes 4 and dns rer dtl on quanta fequency
secsument 8 wel ste advantage ad initatons of the hae,
‘Ste specie eminatine eo Be made sso Tamms mst
‘ab might nde the flowing
+ requency of ze [determined by ppopiate meted ncuing
ie tane much endl te)
Probst af cveprtcie lation
Probably of ble mang wth
Probation
Probl of fame propagation ny camino congested ares+ Pobaiiy of pease! seta prs lat binge
‘+ Probability of personnel evacuation Mi
Gusta on peeing una ec entation eyed
teppei bk Reap dose
oe,
555. quantiatve Rk Determination
Population and ind con be termi in the seme manera
‘Soran Chapter These tekmestucnents on te fe cared
‘wah earalerne eens, ordsaton mehodlogescanbe sc tos
making risk reducoondeosbas bout proces an Buds
"Ae GRA ivales an xl onedecton ofboth he eqoeny and
‘onsquenes of acetal evens, promot Balmer perp
thesssosment and onal af uirhusre HA aac i comc
Ing deat upon that may ate bere he ho, eet
‘ensues, tend die the ko he pune o tr rte
Sud hone wo ted wo concantetecn the possible cnsagencs ip
‘ef ir iio ecu,
sc Unceranty
‘The unary nik ctimate es to be oid pa ik
assessment I is unpofacive teary out eens, comple fk
‘Secomens i the umcranty i the nl sawer sigh Ban se
‘kestintes wal be ree re
‘Use ste nak estates fe, compar api 2 pet rik
ale} bore sestveto acces lates ie, nk)
Tet ‘The enon for da tat ath late span be sae
‘methodology and asus are ually wl ocala the Yves
temas, Ava esl comparative ikea se sje wo Sst
“he smpest and most apogee way ovate woeraing is by
‘sing sensi analy the iskassesomens Sens oa paaoe
ters dln tthe change in ik esse per sine chang: in thet
mete et 76)
‘Stussy stair albw timation ofthe ctr of varus
inne the al ncn in there = RA Sch sees
a dentiy majrcontbuss oneal aks el cients ade
en wich modes, ssumpany, a dt ane moran to the sl
siesta,
6
Risk Management
Capers § 4, and 5 dese vais meth of erasing baad
onsen aod isk asset with lags in poss plans Ba
{nr nr whch there mains sconce ollowing est ty be
giean sk om aplosin or fire haar Ae scien Chapter 8,
‘es uldings maybe andres for ik ection
“Tis hep eon an cree of fk management and sts
rose wats der to budge a proce ana
isk Management overview
‘As dscussed in Chap sme raed deishon making can beat
‘rene dvlogment of tlrance een forte rar pes et
‘thi ung cunts maybe espe When ened is eget
‘hun whit can be dermel trae they abode cmiated or eo
‘mene the cmpanys le experie The prose of me ene
Indeonluston, compa tlre: rer spdclminaon eae
‘no incl ight known atk mansperment Tiga
Shae hs potas Applica ol aceon cea dp pvc
Tellingoonpens nrc tht resus spot spc.
‘Rak mangement sa cmnus poss esi i Caper
5, ecnasunns ad equ lancer hil cod Sede
‘Asa roult nang sk rus tht coon tht ase eet
‘Sect oie ste equate cotobed For age, ate ey
rapams en be he rue f ecienceo oped ks oF
‘eed canes my nore This eu stn abt cease
‘ikon fe and marl lease
Hevesi unapment regures not fat an undetunding of
rl riya an endemanding ofthe wenger
taht One thew onsite sree manag an nal,
‘ppopats simian or engined sens to cvu tat he co
‘Ghote ec adegsty cotaso
Pere imagen oct
(6.44. Managing Risk to Process Plan Buangs
ahaton fk tounge plant wl aly tly wide
ange of posse ak ales This bao the we ng falling
‘pe cetupancy, nto, and cat, a well acevo poet
{nd mates ue maybe nate, hse bangs ae eet apt
16x anager Ove *s
fitra during azar, oosapany enseuene or sk seni ordain
‘le aartment a ose apopiae for heir inended pore ad
‘Snot requ dak recton Hees nengeent mes rope dat
‘Gungngonitne oud ulin ncn ta woe bangs nthe
‘tie ad shold eke mesure appropiate ol sacri
‘ewes Pures, i etl to tate diene posers hy
‘anageent sens wo ent th efletnencs penton fons
‘oes tha tbe undying sponse screening or semen
procee remain va
‘ung for wich sk intel high te candats fr sik
+ unconal—Asesing the wok atvtes and the amber of
poplin the paced Bulling and cimingtng the sctes or
‘eotcing he number of pol esd
Froventve—Aoping meses rece the eqns a wc
+ ep appyng measur ote thn fanctonal het rece
the sew fon cee Thee Can sade menus that eee
the mapa f+ potent eaplosion or ie, or that ee the
Impact heen on ie buig
sing which sik retaton med towered. many
instances, spor deci canbe nade without eating to nt
tie echatgue Howeey, nse cases purus wen the opens
‘Sosy, quate rk ands (Aland s-bsed esto making
Srposses maybe a ellie bass measuring th poreent
Sat arsng tom te oped ptt. These apes a ako be se
‘poring sty ngovanent sl alarang st and pda Sse
Repl othe type af deen ming pes ed en Make
+ Thelndul or seater operon i plant lings
{Comparing dal hk fo personnel isle the Buldig an
‘oe he baling
+ Rasen analy of proposed changes that ae expected wo
‘ic nse onde
6.12. Decang When to Use 084
‘Where possible i preerable wo demonsteate safety waht te apis
‘ono advance ssaument cna such 26 OR, wich cm be
‘our stra tine sntuming and con The detion pec
‘rth QA sald tel on estimate he bens to edie os
Tic stdy, Managment shoulders tbe eget cot of poring
Slt ein the cos of conding 4 Sted QRA to determine cere
‘Spoteaualbeneew peroemiagORA the expected bones of pee° 6 ecnspnset
‘GORA fg song an unneeded and cnt mit exec the
exested cost ofthe say, ay be prado peed withthe sty
However ithe cnibuters to ak Have een uate Stemi
ithe conden: dung sceing study the owls ied
Byrom ha nat
For erample, sume the sk baling termined lily
xc the lel ak Bed on nate acest. making
Some lw cst mets to segten the bug tik ea
cn lesa bythe same gaat samen Stag an co
Sewatnetoleree enter. Tha means the QRAG aed fo sen
‘was to see the reuied bung moan cso a aout
futicleady ler than he only ented modcatons pe o
the ORA. This mph be asp y beter defining he conor
to nak tha ca be eftey minted at lower cote than einai
bets: Piemor, the QRA migic deine that the ko de
lings tolrae widow fhe diston a atona inns
‘on site speci condos evel estat tect a
‘heey nee eas stable remeabd at ORA sean a
‘ci note olen when senna se
feck abou RA sould pace ued aster dons
races and elie proses sy manent. ee
‘Ass practi mate tk olan od away conse bebe
receding with GRA. ithe onto ropondsredcon messes
5h ead GRA maybe sii nes vet, varios isk ed
tins an be ean deremine whch oon pe he pests
eit atthe lowest cost Adonal uae mn nko dein
‘aking avn the CCP Toul for Making Act ask Dons
‘wth Chemical Pcs Aptos Ret 7),
(6.2 Reducing Risk to Bullaings in Process Pants
“This cto disuse sme ofthe messes aa for redig ko
voces plant bling xapans Deming wach acs take an
‘erative poss. Propel kre measure shoe east
‘ont Rasy and demine that sk wl nlc eed.
1524. Functional Rk Reduction Mesures
As disused in Chapter 1 oneal peronal cing seta,
Intra and ening snd manogeent wok a sete
lected car pees ses Bulg tht spore ot ay uc a
Iantenance shops instrument aed era shops snd puch aed
ore may aloe ral doc chong he proses unite oy
esd by an event fons
Risk can fen be sigiicanly edd by ress sti ing
‘ac in rea the prowess es a eosin hae acts snot
Felon the mums pre nee. Avante thi sporach 0
‘oor tne ep penn the paced ling Th appronch my
‘Stet one of the mst ene meaner ak to poss
ant bing oceans
Tabi ean fncons win baiting an somtimes
‘ote the eonsqienee fom tadng damage Forexmpe hsm
[las mowing pore snd ital operations sway fom the sue of &
Iki cing proces aes
622, Preventive Rsk Reduction Measures
seca mm er gr pen
{rata ears are
secant fcr ada
SS ee ccc nd ed
Se
ita en stn ses ne
+ Hen nares
Sea er pa
csr saat Toee cea
fetta
« ephedra ers
Eee genset Sac
« Spteog ayaa omin
Improve instrumentation and crs conc
Lea meet ce
ieee cgatsraceen ta
serch teat
sept ree nih
snltdcgit uuerrener penta:
Sacre emcee
tihapastgtarenatnenet
febrboescgee Sree ted
Sica iat er acoso stnarmca
eer domes
Site acct me tah
ra tanec et ah
sre ee anton re
citrine pu Wc is
sei ir eB
iaro 6 macussnont
625, misgatve Rik Reduction Mesures
Maigatire rtrd messes inde system designs or pred
‘hot ep bmi the maid ow svety ofa event Earp
+ Gay detectors apd other monsting etramentaton 0 povide
‘iy warming of cdo tal eee
+ tomatic or eel tated sate ves poi t nit
Guanine that ead
+ Reducing hsardous meal veto lic the amount of
Imateil svatewbe aed
+ Hnrgncy sbtdowns and doesn ons
1 ern) pune plans an pcedzes
Other mite mesure inode tafitingtpeaing the bulngs
x snsring new balding ded to withstand an cation ase
‘eat Braue ofthe eet iver ding ppd one cae
thn, sack mation measure aera bet ae lowing cara
‘stent ert [eton 6 In adon tang ung a
‘toa shouldbe rank in oer of skid ppd sie such hat
‘isos protis may be cabled Deosoe a wih mutton
eases to udeake wil be inflarnrd by cose teal ably a
Dopod skredacton measure and impute 00
‘ons and on othe nes cnsrcnton
etronting Bulngs to an crossed Lvs of Bas.
andor re Resstance.
Depending on the maids of he evince Bast, 2 numberof
Dliingupeedenorretatsmay te pe Hse aca owing
+ Coe wit sy fs. amy, tl tai sae
1 acres the Bstestancr captions nn by lng
as wth poteonate or aia sy gle aad wie
{cst epring me deg snd tsb ale
Eisen are ling nor mine or st
nro he wily a ed me omens a clus
thease odd yee
plc dean a tl hf Ha ans ontneton
Schaef (ee, nadie TV moi) so ae
ide hb ret aes
+ Frown es rast wl a shvs hy wl
Ege tebe
+ Badia bree pte shel at cocpis the
bullding ws
+ Retorehey upmen fu uppers
6, Reser et uss ree ans »
Constructing New Base Resistant Bung
Inte same Pace as the 0 Buna
‘Gaetiaknduction oon rt oats new ae eae budagn
{heme ato the ing baling Tho sates demolhing the
‘Shing baling which may nase signe Sarton pro an
Constructing New Bung nocstons Recuting
es st or Fie Resstance
“The consnicin cnt ein arable by cating uliings a ows
‘he arene of gna Bat overpressure es us be weighed
Sains tence stor msrentandeleta caine hee
‘terion dna oer uch ss ieee eiponse ines psoas!
‘ured prom emegency sons win the prune Recon
‘Mbuldagy nay gue te csrcton atin acre net he
pieces mtr to allow euca pear monitoring ofthe pos ants
{th cpanel s sulfite cone or eh ling oases
supine etal o lat operation these stele strcrares ny eed
{S°He Ele or fie setae Since sine baling se slr ha
‘Serena onl bung, the eo ung eet ually
{Swern that for lager bang Pal NFPA TO, Lie ale Cale
[Rel #2) movin ationalreuement sensi rr
frei bang ccspant
16.24. Ctra for migatng Rsk rom Bas Enects
lore Mast nigting meats can be vated for anew balding ot
Soe that eng otic perormence ps for the baling mus be
(Hiatal Thee depend on the ccapaney ad foncon ofthe bullig
‘Chal digs may be oie eo wihstnd an valgaton-ase tet
Swe stning oly minor damage Less etl ulngs ut be
Tete to sur an caatin ce event bt the Baling wee at
{hencol inept ad wouldnt sable ant nage
Inu wet pernanc ul for al coped porate
"The dementstastesistant esa and singe wl oraly
include 1} etllatzent of function peomaace epaatns for
inl huldig inthe crt olan epson planet snd spain
‘eertuns seston of eon inated desig las over
‘esr, mice, shk), 2 fad combinaton res felon
blr oh cancaret las) easton of buing spose dein
{indy crac specing alla deformations or sen 2od 7)
‘icoasntan design comers including struct onion,
‘Staal sate a eemenes, contraction tea, dein deta ot
‘oe beavor and guay surance even Each tra cent
‘sGhnoned in Append |‘0 6 managers
1625. Uporacing Bulings to nerease Bast Restance
Upgrade measures ight include adlingsupating members to nease
‘estat and rece uuuppo span, snebacking wale for
ind with st ratant clean Messrs or sna
‘ning aod upreding lings for enanoel pesto a ss >
measures fr ugating seme resistance amples of baling arate
nd stragcning mesure for eathgake onsets se pov i
Referenoe
“A option or apa Hat resican of nein bulking sy be
to pride situa eam ems, oral sengthensl with ma
fone peumatialy pote a high Vly onto «sac. The
‘cee is plac on cage af enorement, which i dowel nt
‘ements othe exiting eine
‘One method rong pretense hing om ceain
types f explssns sto pe» wal arerberween the erp
‘Sure and he bling Tad wall oe ell for PY rps ot
etna ats nia aang so prove mse ptt tt
building To bem feces areade wall niet belated one tt
[olsin source so arp nce mse cain the stony Ble
‘ell which ae tend to poet the balding apne he empl
Uremic mast be nar he potted balding he eee. With
easing distance foo he lt wal the presare and impale react
sound rover the val and ret eves hat wel cer withthe
se wal Th esany stony he sation Hast walls vy
‘expensive and inpracte
‘nut sptach hr peng lt poten fr an cing aliig,
psilay it sal eben a deeded ota
icrincencbning nti Sch ct le ed
rin of icpent fade tlutinase explo seman pel
Shug devas co cola damage posted bang
63. choosing among Rist-Reduetion Alternatives
Section 62 disused vais options to reduce sk wo poss ant
Baldi ad zips Some ofthese option, indore
maybe applicable to open ing nde sty
"in imany eae, Yarous secon seas wel eu i &
tolerble fel fk Cont bane nap can be stl linea
sting alternative posses Cats ar goer sephora snd ey
‘estimate here, sitting bene maybe more dal ing
‘Ssspracs ac alies obec ng sa se
‘hall menctay
Propo maize mst auc the ko evel that consis:
tent wth managements ean eter ad ths sul be esse
for elosienen, Modest that fl wo sufilendy luce te ik
Should be ambinedwih dbe ops o minted fo the ist of
‘pion ie prong oan comomi valuation of the aes
ep mind that the modiesuoas themselves may inode new aks
Aharoed tobe elon
“The costo iatoninhies one-time capital costs and any
eri at ha ac seul of he tafeton. Capital cost
{Belade thane fords, fast, abd costocon. Pte ess
{icles sh teed anal untenance or opetig ct,
‘Bers propey tes, and erection
“Phe bos os masaton ince tos indy elated tte
sede sk 0 procs lat balding and czupants. An exposon oe
‘Sn eutin loses none ome fhe lowing tei
+ Serio nur ora,
1 mage to per ings, or euiment
{Lone econ [pic pocepon of sik, pul stron wo
ovens nfng enous nay or ay
+ Increase iran cos
1 sation a iy ese
The total oe the sum of he ses nce in each of tse
‘eter A rei ofthe cates inate thatthe ttl ot may be
‘Shuttcandy her than the cots of pang or replacing damaged
‘Bling and pan equipment an ompenestn pero
‘Detcomunag the val of ena bone om ection
lal signee fr angie loser ich 2 propery damage,
‘Cot ete ana ores «demain fhe css in
cue om nent ted ates, Rute i niu itl
‘ope ye eo cmponent ik oteltd wh bulking pes
bins One methtof determining thou oft scents tose
‘he amouneo ney da sty mah pec a esol ope
‘tom n event of a scent
‘Once valcrbee been ane rts aden oach po
‘lesndton median sartorial cis
{used to come he mn tac cpon These hme ce et
Deent wy dened ca lw eof ream snd at bene 3
ieee, Mt compan ave «lene meted or rae
‘anomie which cin be wed wih ite ono mdeuon Chapt Sal= 6 anspor
efenc 77, which roi addtional ass oncont-bneit analysis,
slo indude an extent of and tens thi abe.
BaMPETT
actground
Te paca acy under ee nt prodigies
toma ih-brng ey carton he ep hs tbh
inca cine sg cco tale ttwe Spee,
\Senied evloso ade ™
Approach
1. tat Seening eu eticatian of Mae and Coons Prt
{ike Species Son 3.2.
The properties ofthe proces trish and ir conn of use pos the
potent fora vapor ud explosion (VC) nd ves pr nthe
{towing proces ae
reson radu tag eel
1 Reg ptt scone
{Feed gs pana and apeton a
2, itl Sreing tag ping Cres of Conc. Stn 3.22)
The company pdt einen oscapnd ang a one whee an
elon pets moe tan So her ie 9 Bling es hn
{ited proces swith an acapanc ad aeagigone han
200 person hows per meek. The company alin eos
ing forscrenng pres, i pes
[sae =
[2 forearms ae
ump anarmcgg
laces na
Tt one
Tee ung were ete 8 ce ings pcos
Tag wore eid oad bigs pe copary
Cont room 3 Type 3b
1 Matmenance dtr ut Type bali
1 Adminataton alg» Type bang
£5, ching nore Raeeacton MRerstes 0s
2 Corequnce Senin by Comgarin to Dsn and Spc andar,
Baton 33.1
Pr pln cin i ier a ctw neg
{oehc penal expen eno ate fom eel pe,
‘Seton pis loon conned par ing expos, oF VE
‘he company seh TNT eqnece mee eng poss and
‘hota Sushi mebadsegyo model ec or more pth
‘Sidi he bazar caer re ow:
flash, 3 (14g, 208, 14g TNTaguatncy
D hase Sapih vig,40oin (0 Ap TNT eqrncy
1D ehise >So 40g, 42.000. 10 TST equatency
J eiierd 520001 10g TNT enaleny
or Cs haa the cmp it ined th alan case vet
‘Seer te ts rete ri
olson ues conpherone ar deine a ser vet se
‘Slum cae Fora CE raion tartrate ese
Shope of 0,000, 300 of ody bras, he
‘fea nd eae 60 B00 a est bring teas
mans ang ely 22 ue 20 ere with 5 ines
the tne ge corset take vesel soe (Ona TNT tas
These ssurfae bun a appt 2s 800 TMT
SunSoft else fer dn don oF 663
‘Reso for a bring mts
Anita eho dterined hat 6600, (000 ast uring
tera coul else wn rants eth pot rage eel
[Ter bveidentng ta Cas azar proces pieation the
‘Simp deh and cng guelnes eld a al ie cep
non wee coe pod song esl
‘he ess ofthis seeing sh hat al res bung coud experience
Sioa dager a eve te pod trage res wh ptetal
SBicantimpnct toting octagon On he be oven es
‘Teer conta that te pdt sage vet shoul be etd
“Teme rel the cy or Qe pore and any mecsay
‘longest mde ace ttle kh or ae»
‘hewn ether move te treo aciee 9 oleae ef
‘el econpncson ih he lg.ang la for este
“he eae oh conan reign dg ing
“nda wont cc eh aero pros ate There
‘Saedstind conte dee ersence ei
4 Consequence Sarening Bus n St speci Cantons. Seton 33.2
The liwing vert cra of concen wee identi ings oh
FOP rv tht was pesca pa ir semen108 5 canoe
(yee Gas Compressor
«Scena 1” Compresorpngepanson jt lire, wth VE con
+ Sat Sa ction ao ping ree in cones
+ Steno pie
Feed Pricaton ed Vapoiatin
Seen ttl piping are ith VCE comegueces
1 Scena Packing oe age sk
Fach cena was modeled a dete mete epinn overesire atthe
‘vee bung under sw, The eat oes ard
“sponge ese ee ao ch
oes reeecarecear
sce [Rms [Hees | ca,
The verity estes, angi om 0.1.0, fr foe th
seta: suger eat ul be pred
5. aoe Rsk Assent tin 54
‘cau few yn equney ata were salable on VCE nile
less si ning er Chaps of a ook ws Pot prlomed
tact ont ep, Be decon war mae pear ane ek
fac capi big untae acting equa
‘onsen erase 37 an abl Camcmce g ev ad
ton be ke he presen cond conse sabre
Feu ster we pn oor erates OP
team oki woe hon tered pes pe
ana Bing, The cor eteg he ining aie akg
‘Theat ann were sed pron fallow consideraons
+The petal consequences te contol bull reing fom
Scednot mee snc, ining at prt tet
Sythe ig Th ota opr col ed
‘haope sy ithe conto breed ments eae
sheath ad nolere ek e slywthna
Stent migaton Buses erpton resi fom bs ol he
‘ootenmen ata began Fortheseesons consequence
«Does pte fe pra ype of es conpeson at the
fey, 2 opin ace of yer, ugh Rey ay,
oul nt be cdma equency coef font rey
‘Spc toon” Forte any, te quae semen ea
‘hed te sean on 42" fequncy. was at RA woud
tricot or evo
+ Xtreme hatin Sema 1 he mat seen fr te gee
(pecimpreon cn evel aking dee
+The potent comequenc to he conta bag resaing. om
‘Stora where an Sea , wees nbc and
tated onequence rang
4 Thequcane sonst entied mile opprniies o ek
‘edison in he ed paicton ad poeta, The
‘Sid rong ge daca hee mack ih atom
‘Soon Upon deecton a gs az Oe yam ve et
‘Soe spy edn the san of doco ht be
‘nice tebe tnd fs damaging evploson ae
“rsd ht wa hep detec an sharon conan he
lrsjuency fet Seta woul bere mata?
«+ Ere th improvements ine een ag the eel ak
‘aragtrSenat sheen eee senator ed pricaon
‘See wena
ed on eet of te guste assent te dco as made
ot nw anol ting sess sgn wth respon
dance se rend el tn at
Conan few cool ans Bnet port
‘yuan cee corel agp and Sgn wre omer ot sre
y= anoipherc per = 10300 Pate
1 p= 85 Pascale
‘(02 or 013 br = 2468951101300 = 0.013
| (0.0 0.069 bart = 1.096, 8854101300 = 0.069
"(0p 0.207 bw = G.ay,85)101300 = 020,
‘(50 po 0345 br ~ .046,8951707,300 = 034
Step 4 Deine Cmtusion Foy Sed stare Fan Fie 7.28
tom Reece) ing ene Cane #10.
Ro2 pa v0
Roopa= 30
oops 17
Roopa 12a 6. ascent
Step 5 Detwmine Osan Overs Epi \
[Usngeqanton 7 from eer 3
R= eur"?
Sing fr and nosing hat whee st ney, oe) = Hx
Ratt tah
= Rx 463105 Yn N01, 20 Pca”?
aig with th stances othe edit
(02 pu = 577m = 1.9008
Roopa = 129m = «29
Reopsi=s77m= 108
RGop=400m= 148
eat the posite duration ofthe Hast tte endo tne. Ling
‘Necomburion see tance lee np 4 te, aon? 50
de 7 25 Berne test erator can be late,
‘Enuing gre? 25 tthe omburton eld dance ech edt
rere, dss ste he ton a ond
Ro2rpi=70 205
Roop 38 aos
Raom= 17-03
Risopa= 12 t,<035
se oqaton 75 fom Refrence 5 adhe vases Hand Par
‘deeng he postive duran ofthe as
oe
loa pines xf C0047
. 10100 psc)
= ambient tmprtre spt of nd n= 30 me,
“amon
1, 02 pad = 0.050 seconds = 50 mace
1, (1.0 pe = 0040 scons ~ 40 mee
1 Bop = 0030 second = 30 nce
10 pt = 0025 econ = 25 mee
For recs Unt, the dances othe oes ent of, 3, and
{pg tom PY rec beak ng th macs
Reteece Scion 925, sample Prem Cada Vet nit
‘cape the dtncen oveprenae enon rectus te Bi
65. cmsng arog on Atma co
‘he prams ese ath in te mfereced arp blr,
‘hc, nr example we a detmnng he dance fasted
‘repre ete ferent se ee the represen
‘sme tances hve bon aed Nomenelateabd UN ne
‘Siwy eqntoe rs pe Rersce 5
Thee eed tobe unt, orzo ae ee,
‘incl reste weal wha volume of 7060 20). The ves
eThearat te pig 02s 650 0° anda Mima
Desig eal Tenperioe DMT) of Caines ema of
teralee st natal Dunn prosa ontons neste por 2
rss te veel, 090 pei bar he vests metal epee
Spproumaey 907 LY), Wen he eal pesca 1.08 po
‘ircasophcdy The dances owerprenre endoi (3, and
i a ne lor
Sep 1 Cae
po sec pee = 10120 pak
‘neato pit hes rte 78140
The we bea 20
Step 2 Aj enero br Geom sf Vase Oration
Fin cls dimen vrs Pt ep coer,
‘thot romenyadrtment ong Egon 6.3.17 fom efor
B= e.-palbo
(ops) = 0008
R= aps=020¢
Fe tpn = 010
Ung Tate 61a Rel 5 ide Fy eit asm
(os h'3) whutment ac in get eqn Pua the prom
‘es cate lng ace te py npn overpreste cnns
Ria (t pad = 0068/16 = 0083
R= a pin~o20016= 0.128
Fy pa =0mo16=0213
Step: tere Dens ge om ge 6.2. ere
Ra panas
Rapa -20
Rs peo=14
Since 43> 2.5 hada cfr 7p rom Table 114 at
teconec The perl eb
Fa p= 00604-0000; Ri pale at‘Step 4 Determine tance pt te Bas Mth de R > 2 pe i
ge 22 neler 5 sddsonay determine the dean 3p
shee = 2 compar widened mee eis.
(Cte eer of expos ng Equson 63.15 Reference 5
(Pr=par2_(3,0147%6809 - 1013001220
eh aa)
a= 69% 10 jes
[pr= 101300 Peak boa ambient pres) .
eg eso: 0 147 p= LOT pe
okie dtc, epi ng etn 6:3 60 foc Sand
‘he ae demmined inp :
Sobing fore
vk a
“BE Tora.
2 remam= wth
TI m= 2554
ors pk
Step 5 Deeie Osan 5a 5s pos Us dea
Sees psa pee eined mtd in Sep 5 per Pie
1625 n efeece 5. Cale empresas sing on
63 20in erence 5 Py) (ase)
ake ranimensons eng ace, Ring oqstion 62.21 in
Releeces " -
y= ropa”
R, = 212 «0101, 200/69% 108" = 0192
Determine pe shock pee, Pa, tent ig Fig 6269
eee 5th
Po ~ 1.0147 + 68951/ 101,300 ~ 69.06
oo)
Lo 96 Sonya and aes 6OF
Fie 626 Relonce 5 iP = 48
loca aig pit on ori acanein Fie 621 of Releen5
65, Crosing mera incecton Aten a
sng == 0112 sed ts =F = 48,
Use? fom Step? forthe 3 an 5 pends fad the conepaing
‘onthe ure seleted aboe ronan ep patel Ce ng the
Soveg pom bated above
021, Ro pst= a
‘Cae dsance wendpots srgthe eed Mead a Sp 4
Comparison of Refined Meth ad ase Meth for 3 (162 ver
121M mpgs the ined Mths pcs a dane coset wah he
expected atenaton othe pee fom 3 Pa
16 ps = e107, 300/695 109
16 ps
Datacenters unmafed blo:
Tp 777 m= 2558
Spe r77m= 028
The np fr hes pes a cat wing te eon
instep bette wore exp con 92 a elect 5 Scr
angi adg cee sned re sag te ware,
Imp ard pthc Suaion a eae nec hemp a
100i onnpe the tan he gy dey
ean ner one he pean
represen yt don eu to tn ey
Fievrerepesinan me
Fie 62 shows the cake is coro
ug pote ube aps 0.5 a ore overs fom
Process Unt wth 25m st ro, by es, can watt
‘he explson There, ro te eaton Neder Busing
‘Ae Fig 62 show, Balding pom st 32 ba from
Process Unt 2 ap Dba om races Unt, Se Bung =
‘tot deegned orb rertace, nat Tate 35 accpat cou
Sebeeedty pate ry Tha, ot mgs
‘Sey by comping thea cntours mig 62 wth Tale 35,
‘Scart Bulg, nd sb oq terest
fcr ung wl jo aprons 1p tt on beth
Process Uns and? ulin, the arco, para1 6 anspor
concen sinc ts asl sme ecapanc and cou be ict
tobe parame tated clase bing Based onthe
areqiene seeing the dco wa ae omer tetas a
‘Spr cate pr sea te yy om
‘The conaquence rer hoped mange ke nee
eins one ato a degre enone ti ey te
tebe raed wan he et commun hay wt be spp
hig ststance See ts atc eee cc Une
“dotnet estes he doco wos de eae he
‘ew engrengbigbeyonhe.2 oma, or 90 2100
A161 mt wher gas treba woah nt te ance
aly, Fee 6.2 hows tht ling the MCE cold be pei
itn are he ans Shane
‘oul hye nant args o he nie prs in
Igy shutdown for recandrcton Ins sta, hee wed be
i ied vale esrb CC vs ot anagem te 2
‘sl. uiting 5, hereto nt cone father eeakaton.
5: Rok Scmening ection 3)
lng 2 and req ter vation ete consequence screening
‘Seampleed ik screening can be pero by clang he
‘macmom ia in thn by String te age ior
‘rear ote bag.
To detuning mma nil he ery data eid
iexpsen cen Pres Uns and rs ne
«2s were ube om te nt heer det ee epson
Spengler xn eyo
20% 1 per yea Fer Proce Unt uh ee lr Be open
“ese bie care eet ha sen cn spt conned
Project That sy conc atthe fete of
Srtogzn apr sage eal war 3 Hy
ForBuig2, cht mpi oct eae expe
teal ahr pene ar ston stn GB =e
For Bulg, exchof te nt pod acpi ab hath ae ee
teeth pres a exer sane e808
ing te infrmaon fom Tate 4.8, Fg 46, he da rindi
‘iceanbe pesred ina ube nara Tae 810
|r| tit let] vi | Tt | tad
PRs Set | ey | Tye | sateen
Tp] pe [Te tom [aan
ef oat [e [oe [oa Prense™
Tp fo pase oe [or [or ose
For ocapans fing 2, the manning the sum fhe
enwibug 2 fom ath oes eit
ox ni sk, Big
“Moos staeios Tass"
For capa of Bling 3, the mannii i the sum fhe
‘Senge om ath proces unt
axa indi Buin
fan ype undo 1° ape or masini i fe
Sige toe then copa of Bing 2 ae egy above. the
pels se occupanse ug apres mon of
‘Sadek Aa tom ipso of dt apn he ia
tocar of beh aes ilo 30 tne ser om Process Unt 2
anf Pres Ut
To detemine appeal te ees cake thine tacton of
‘ach eceopane er the blige cnieaon. or ulin 2,
{tts termed at he out opert enti col om rom
ean tm Senge conn apr eti
SJ am a eey dy. Tesh spessr spree fm 80am
{oso pn hay reg Fay. The erie he contol om
From dO ato 1 0 rand 120 pn 0200 pn Monday ah
Fly Fina, ono corning meg takes pc betwen
1200 oman 19 pn Moray Bog Fy.
Fer Buling3, te 10 pine occupant ae in the bli om 8:0 am
to r000 a a am 1200 pn 00 pon Monday rag oy. The
ruimerance supa peer om 8:0 am 0.0 Pan
Ton pmo #0 pmsenen days week
$7104 on 75104capa) oe can cane ok dou nar hat amt
‘shown below for Building 2, a
ota ts Bing 2(Weetene)
‘capi ton an then be determin a flows
‘can Tine Frictions or Baing 2
panpmacopmay % o
“The tie acs sth same aap lee can Beaded, ga tt
Aine cone ethocapaey eve, ows
Cantina Ccapanoy Tine Combined Osan Tine
Facts br 6alng? Tetons fr tg
ao cer alaem0 4 emcnscenet
‘As diced in Capt 4 one approach demining gee ok
15, cmonganong i tuto Aerts am
‘mies rar ate us natal alone pavers
‘Determination of Outcome Frequenis and Number of Serious ries an
ae Soe Oa hi Sor
tng Fy iy OTN in ny Seow
1a awe a cont te dew
Hob met ar oe amt sont
ee er ee st
12 det a ate 10 coat
12 awh on mt Gant as eae!
eo oe 7 * Was ouxw amo
peta) arta " cares
22 sew 1 ase w psrwwxt ant
Fk sews pe zona Invevewng Figs 6.3 and 64, on wih the above able fom wich he
22 samt ke sont FN ce ae dered 5 that he erga sk rom Baling 38
Be eee tone tan at rll 2, wo tog Bg 3 ar he pea
a " ‘cepa. may Eon at ges con Bung
set 19 wont wo ‘ect ke om sn explosonn Process Ui. Thr event which ht
23 sawt or msn at {Nagi enate eqn of occurance than a esploion nce
eee ‘Unt ese inte ihe amber peal te
Py sewt at oooh asawe at ner company ik three tea a been abled pr
5 4 ring cee, When Fae 63 an 6 were compared 2
22 swt er em sews a0 Nettles tne a Bag pa
23 suet atom tani? ote ‘icon rot cpa tobe of corer whl alo eraaston wat
Tala dia prior FN canes atone: am aranged dering
‘al umutve tnt fennel arg sar at
ttf heal. The us ae shown nt lowe nd eg
[65 and Ga Nett fgnes ant agp range
‘nd, pect, both bare nae pops recon ai,
{6 uate ik na etn 55)
A dete uate hazed acumen was peed for Poet Unt 2
Darn th een, twas detrei vlton es eer
tol rte ctr eng vr ves wa hw event
‘nce fo pce pl buldngsor Pees Unt 2 Whie oe eenstS ete
re 63 tarantino un? et LEN.
“t
=
re hep rst eit fg SOA e Merekrecaon|
ste orb tes nvhed mal st waco armen
Sigia Totes te acted ter cqapmcntceion
leapt sare nn ane, sce ntegen nat cones. tena
coos, nun cooson unde vt, rah mere 5
rth cy mechan tg progam. Boca of tere
‘chan ime srr exer coon would ot og ak
‘aherthens casper
Sine te agg ri am Pes Ui ae gel teefsge
‘ert focure~the oa had asst der
cn deg that col be pt npc peer le ace
‘Srcurece vas decid at he et open woud be tl an
‘Srepecy shown yen a Poe Unt 0 pret sung the
‘gen stp vel a eld tempers anton pst
Porton shown ye, howe fa we an nas
Dome on ie proposed madsen From bse wa once
{hate nen queef te acre was weed tn $3 10S
{20 foramen Ligh new eqn te calelon or
“apepe rk woudl eat ed cocomefequenessnd EN data
pn show bw
Revied Calton of Dt Point or FN Cures
ese sity Ontos “y
* vee conte?
2 ona? pew
2 ent fe)
2 ni eae?
5 oenst net
1 aoa? pon
7 7 Gis eune® rea
w Ussae? none?
ae ussaet —— goxte
" Imioeaaet sane
1 eset? santo?esd etnaton ef come Freuences ad Number feos
nes ado oe Feuer pb es
estes Wate chee nee Osan “igac |
it ates rege by tee” een Pa |
ee ee en
yb mat ane me tat
es
ee
Figs 6: and show the adhd FN cas Wh hs keen
the company pepe rete wou ene Tere, he
‘crugecy shan to sal nN the ach as
7. ces Sty Manage gence
‘The eed we nguceyofccarenc of 510" acurencyen)
‘crt tacts pete one cone efecoens oe
{rece ty mengetent tenn place npr, hme
(ira mercy Shaw ye rst oncom wh deg of
‘tin tatces or eco comedy ned he ee
‘Ghize' tha eores the emergency shown ym ta be ted
‘Mou, fort component nemo be mane, fra
‘Munerine and ope penones be appropri and ardor
{Tico change yequpment or cea: at col eter
ict evens te an ose pein y te gua hazard
"unen or itcoud compro egy oe ston ste,7
Future Developments
Mostfthesrceningtas snd sessment methods dscosedinthis isk
‘aly upon estimates of vet consequent Heques, oe oth
‘Thee enimatey in tame bse poo ierttatonsf aeectic
dons ws wll ee dcterinatin of wich event tay Pole
‘ent aro be cose ahs at een Fah spi te
‘alton pros har the pte! induce snes it the
(perl balding arent he diced in Reece 87
‘hen ay dessins lng proces plat baling ar tobe ma,
‘us important tat de uncertain inthe wk assent process Be
ley undestocd and ht these uberis be cnr te
‘tba make
"ening and sling improve tol to es weenie ae
‘one boa nea wht te each can benef bldg easton,
‘ther areas incu
+ Deion nd we of bldg copay ceria
1 Deerminaon of caiant ules fabio of aig
dap
+ Devlpneat alnenc fen) stato mg kerning ke
1 Development ofompan specie skate eters
1 Impeted ntons or isk edoeuen
7, Definitions and Use of ullaing Occupancy Criteria
Daring the scening pos, uiingcxupany crea help ai
‘hone bing ith suthcent rupangy to bealsonsr. This al
‘Eecrninaon Balding ht do ot exe the oxpancy ees cn heled fom fre vt. the asspancy ceria ar to ih,
ndings maybe exe that cul rset sent saat ok,
should sx exposian or ie oes On the ser bande sane)
“merit ti comida ot could beget ae mame
‘ow ecapny baling, th ede eds nthe eal ak
‘heading oospants wikia» prces acy
‘As Gacoeod in Chaper ech faci may wish to determine
ccpangy ete esi company apo conscteoas. At preset
{se aonalgsdnce wala fos compants ndings.
172. Determination of Occupant Vunerabittesa¢ 2 Function
‘oF Butaing Damage
‘Occupant uinerbiis ron ofthe key lacs in deeming heel
tots india and asept tak o ng csipets Opt
‘ules are sed in ereening sco in Chap a
(Solin detailed vk neuen.
“The srspane vulnerable pesente in Table 48a ia Fg 66
sue lagi edo dats oie fr sli eats. Phe dts, wl
‘hey epee be normation salable seh une, Phe,
the tse vl nly or erent raatng in la ets op to he ps
‘of bulingeallape For Hine cee scanty peter then Sse
ees to cae baling lla, deta ate sable tat an
{ana the atonal frees upenpned on the sacar to Fos
‘hss feat or ects ay to bldg eospants,
Tis ancpated thts ast agate noses, the probity of
aay or eis inj to bling cca wuld ieee Bosal
the iueasel cea the biking clap ulin he eet of
Inisies or ther rapoention tht ean impact bling ocapats, Ea
Incl ably vo ped scopant ln fr al anges oD
fics wil impor the abi to peo isk seeing and wil adn
‘more Sala ssessent a el
173. Development of Geneke Frequency Data to Improve
Rk-Sereening Tools
Risk crcning relies upon pci fapecy data provide cmsesatine
sroroiations of ind and gps rks. Table 9 fics an
Shp of gece legume major explosions for enaiatpe
‘fiery protest. A methodol sal eed to pet epee
‘re euencs where enere data ae not salable
‘Additonal rete econ date froth daria segments woul
‘np improve ik seeing. Seley, sipeoved dats Table 9, 6
25 rosters for asain oy
‘wel as sim data for diferent yes of chemi recesses, woud ep
opctatons por isk ees or elt,
7.4 Development of company-specifl isk Tolerance Criteria
Fo copa to make ik bed econ rik sein oF qua.
tative ik scien compen aksernee crt meth
topes soul be develope rb dal rk pd agate ale
‘Chapter «pes duce ok ceria and metodo, nd
‘lo piace for eapanies to conser in devoping his ow ap
‘aches tok lai
‘Rhktoereiey i acomlecsbest Rktalerane in soe gneraly
ss changed over tne a al sano od 0 Toleranos ei ay
ay hom capey temper. Rube tc eco forthe venation can,
{ites cmpany wo company. May compan, i ace ae not
‘teloped ext ak trace ce
“The menos eed inthis nk low sre deo ing
‘yaistion wibout the development of ei tsk erance enter
However, adda! dance the deyopmet and section of ra
teleane ites il ene tos companies tht ws ly tie Fa
Srcning and quantitate rskasesment as etalon toe.
75. improved Options for Risk Reduction
Chaps 6 eases users educton mesures that an Be tke,
‘erin determin hata ctlston-asecene coal eset sult
‘kw balding ocpants to ofc. Many of thse ops, up
‘Sodinduding replacing the bulking wihane having mores estat
‘Eien, can be extemely cst Improved metinds fr cst lve
‘enrening of bung eo wtheand expected Rast il elp reduce
‘ike to bldg czpantsin tne stuaton where theco-fenefraio
'Stao hgh to sy tat more expensive measures be kenAPPENDIX A
Explosion and Fire Phenomena
and Effects
Poca explosion phenomens inde vapor coud exorons [VCE
‘onfined erosions condensed hase csns, extern chemi
‘eatin, olin nud expndig Yar exons [BLEVEs, snd pre
‘Breaume (PY) apr Potental ie pheneneh near fis
‘nr, et ie, and rhe Gunns for evaluating th chars
‘etic of VCE BLEVEs snd fash fires ne poe in aeter COPS
‘ableton [Rel 5} The base ences fm Rese fr aang
‘harasses of thn enomens rey suman th pe
‘da Inston, he bate poncper be aanting charset
‘ther explosion and ae phenome Led sone rel summanicd
{nd reeeoes or deal rau chances a red
‘AA. Explosion and Fire Phenomena
A414, Baesions
“An epson maybe ined a phenomanin wher ast (pesueoF
‘Sock waves pneatedi al by ai lean of ecg Ts ergy
‘Bay have ogy ben se nthe men in wey offer es
‘dear chemea eea orp nergy) Tobe ere cae
iret leaf enn mist fe ap enh aid concrete eo
{Droce spree wate hat cane ard Tolan blast wee
[egy ropa re damage that rascal 4 Bldg ay
1 damaged ad pore may be ul yh lst ws, wth sal
‘dc sits Stn miele pencrton, ter omnis Bound sock,
fire General the Hast wae tel ater sayin the enter
‘le eploson lagen so he magia former and
‘lt experienced su othe st wave Screnes the ance
Incees fom the epson Source. The eyo oer oughlyVapor Cloud Exptsions
‘Averell explosion (VCED rss fo the ition of aramable
‘ere of vapor, sco or ms which fame ses alate to
‘ccnly high vlc 6 produce gan repre (Ret 2
{YCEs ar ently smite with the neo scat Quay
arumabi pu ce vponsns Dating) gl om stra ta, poess
‘oc tranepr eel ing sytem In neal Ee cindioas must be
‘het eres VCE wth dmagng orp ea ocur Rls nd 85)
1 Theskasd mts musth fammabieandat abe condone
{oom 1 vapor cud Some pron a the ean oul must
‘nix with airsuch that onsen ae win the Dame
‘geo the matena
2. Amipition sce eed tone the xlosion. The presence
‘fan igtin sources vase assumed tees explnsons
‘hl ies hive ceed where moos gti source nl be
‘MSc Higieceneny gi sures caniealeo amore severe
‘plinth do lower ene sou.
2. Union ofthe rmabevapocloud muse dled uta oad
(aden ss be formed. ton rue a he Mamma
‘aerial escaping lat i,t Dane o ical igh oa,
Rica VCE tunity The pbabisy of pana her than ic
Sseeses wi the soeof the d,sce the amity ofthe
‘are within he ammatierangncease, Praline
‘Sly meoures that cumin sures canbe canta
torte oat ery gel ous wth tbe
Peter vey seve expla
4 Tsuen equted forte fame nto acdert tothe speeds
Feguoed fra VE, eer fas ew rst Thi tab
[Etc ply ome yt ntact Mee Got
vobuades sch sr proces scr rupee Tubulence
{yess rom maternal sed espa ri esse
‘Te bint ts pracedly VCEscan vary pela testongy