A five-year fixed-rate mortgage is a mortgage where the borrower pays a fixed and unchanging interest rate on the loan for a mortgage contract length (known as a term) of five years.
Once that term expires, the borrower can choose to renew their mortgage with the same lender for the same or a different term length and try to renegotiate a better interest rate than they were offered for the duration of the previous mortgage term. The borrower may also sign a mortgage contract with a different lender for the same or different term length and a better interest rate, once the previous mortgage term expires. If the borrower tries to break their mortgage contract before the expiration of their mortgage term, they can do so but they will be subject to a financial penalty.
What Flexibility Does a Fixed-Rate Mortgage Offer?
Many mortgages come with prepayment privileges. As a result, you’re allowed to make larger regular or lump-sum payments without paying a penalty.
The increase in regular payments or lump-sum payment amounts are often capped at a certain percentage annually. The percentage amount varies by lender. Some lenders may not allow prepayments at all or force you to pay a penalty if you do make a prepayment.
While fixed-rate mortgages offer some flexibility, variable-rate mortgages tend to be more flexible because there’s usually an option to convert to a fixed-rate mortgage without paying a penalty. With a fixed-rate mortgage, there isn’t an option to switch to a variable rate.
How are Canadian 5-Year Fixed Mortgage Rates Determined?
Canadian five-year fixed mortgage rates are determined mainly by two things, the bond market and the borrower’s personal financial situation. Since government bonds are some of the most secure financial instruments to borrow money against because they are backed by the government, banks invest in them to keep their profits stable. Therefore, when the price of bonds decreases, banks lose money. As a response, you’ll often see them raise interest rates on fixed-rate mortgages in particular.
Bonds going down in price may influence fixed mortgage rates in general, but the actual rate a borrower is offered depends on personal financial factors like their credit score, the down payment amount they were able to put on the home they purchased and their debt-to-income ratio.
If their credit score is high, their down payment is 20% or more and their debt to income ratio is low, the borrower will likely receive a pretty good interest rate on their 5-year fixed rate mortgage.
Is a 5-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage Right for You?
A five-year fixed rate mortgage is right for you if you are looking for stability in how much your mortgage will cost from month to month for a period of five years. They are beneficial in high interest rate environments if you can lock in a lower rate before interest rates are expected to go up. You can also expect fixed mortgage rates of all terms to be lower than variable rates in high interest environments.
That being said, if interest rates drop lower than the interest rate you received on your fixed-rate mortgage and you still in the middle of your five-year term, you will not be able to take advantage of the lower interest rate and save money until your five-year term expires and by then, interest rates may have gone up again.
Is it Better To Choose a 2-Year or a 5-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage?
If you are trying to decide between a 2-year fixed-rate mortgage and a 5-year fixed-rate mortgage, you’ll need to evaluate what is important to you.
If you choose the 5-year fixed-rate mortgage, you’ll know what your payments are for the next five years, which will make budgeting easier for a longer period of time. However, you won’t be able to take advantage of any drops in interest rates over the next five years, which are widely predicted to begin in June or July 2024.
If you choose the 2-year fixed-rate mortgage, you’ll have set mortgage payments for a shorter period of time and the interest rate may be higher or it may be lower at the end of the two years. (Though as rates are at the higher end of the historical spectrum, they are more likely to be the same or lower.)
While the 5-year fixed-rate mortgage has traditionally been the preferred option, some homeowners are choosing a shorter term to take advantage of drops in interest rates. They plan to lock in for a longer period once rates have fallen below their historic highs.
Pros and Cons of a 5-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage
Like most things in life, five-year fixed-rate mortgages have their advantages and drawbacks:
Pros
- Expected cost for a stated period of time. You’ll always know what interest rate you will pay over the life of the term and your monthly cost will stay consistent. This is great for budgeting and you won’t have to worry about changes in interest rates for the term of your mortgage contract.
- Straightforward. How five-year fixed-rate mortgages work is relatively straightforward and easy to understand.
- Widely available. Most lenders offer five-year fixed-rate mortgages, so it’s easy to shop around and find a better rate when your term expires.
- You’ll continually pay off your loan each month. That means a larger amount will go towards paying down the original amount borrowed each time you make a mortgage payment, even if rates rise.
Cons
- Missing out on a drop in interest rate. You won’t be able to take advantage of a lower interest rate until your five-year term expires. Your lender might offer mortgages with lower rates, but you’ll be stuck paying a higher rate for the duration of your five-year term.
- Prepayment penalties. If you try to break your mortgage before the five-year term expires or if you pay more than your monthly mortgage payment, you’ll be subject to expensive prepayment penalties. The amount will vary based on the amount borrowed and changes in interest rates.
- Lack of flexibility. Life circumstances are not anything we can predict, especially five years from now, so you may have no choice but to break your mortgage contract in the middle of your term, which will be expensive, but might be necessary. f you have a variable-rate mortgage, you’re usually able to switch to a fixed-rate mortgage without paying a penalty.
Alternatives to a 5-Year Fixed-Rate Mortgage
Choose a 5-year variable-rate mortgage: If you’re comfortable with fluctuating mortgage payments, a variable-rate mortgage allows you to take advantage of falling interest rates. If you decide you later want to switch to a fixed-rate term, the penalties are usually lower than with a fixed-rate mortgage.
Choose a shorter fixed-rate term: If you like the predictability of a fixed-rate mortgage but don’t want to lock in your interest rate for the next five years, you could choose a shorter term, such as the commonly offered one or three-year fixed-rate term. However, the interest rate for a shorter term may be higher than the 5-year term. For example, these are the fixed-year rates currently offered by Nesto Inc. on insured mortgages (as of March 2025):
2-year fixed rate: 4.63%
3-year fixed rate: 4.19%
4-year fixed rate: 4.44%
5-year fixed rate: 3.94%
Learn more: Nesto Mortgage Rates 2025