2009, Symposium
No one will, I think, disagree with the conclusion that Heidegger was mistaken in his expectations for National Socialism. He quite quickly came to the conclusion that Nazism, like Bolshevism and liberalcapitalism, was another form of the realisation of global technopolitics. Nonetheless, National Socialism was a much more complex phenomenon than commonly allowed for today. Heidegger was justified in holding, at least in 1933-34, when the political situation was quite fluid, that it did have positive possibilities, in the sense of an anti-capitalist and antiimperialist program. The appeal of National Socialism can only be understood in terms of its resistance to the imperialism of both East and West: resistance to the Treaty of Versailles, and resistance to communist terrorism and expansionism. The fact that National Socialism ultimately took an imperialist turn itself does not invalidate the fact that it began as a resistance movement against foreign occupation and exploitation. 1 The perceived positive possibilities of early Nazism found support among the proponents of the Conservative Revolution, giving Heidegger some reason to believe that they, rather than the more nihilistic elements of Nazism, could win the day to institute the renovation of the German polity. 2 Ultimately, these possibilities remained unrealised. In this respect Nazism resembles Marxism, another form of totalitarianism which also devolved, in every country where it gained power, into a complete humanrights disaster of mass murder. Dr. Rockmore makes the error of identifying National Socialism 1 National Socialism stressed that Weimar was in all essential aspects an illegitimate client state of Western capitalism. It offered a program of economic and cultural renewal that was attractive to many people who were by no means doctrinaire Nazis. We have to distinguish the appeal of Nazism for the general population from its appeal for the extreme Party membership and parts of the anti-Weimar intelligentsia. 2 Bernhard Radloff, Heidegger and the Question of National Socialism: Disclosure and Gestalt (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2007). Chapter 3 deals at length with Heidegger's relation to the ideas of the Conservative Revolution. Hereafter referred to parenthetically in the text as HQNS.