Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
2004, Computer-Aided Design
Precision inspection has been widely used in manufacturing to measure the dimensional accuracy of parts and products to meet the quality requirements. For regular geometric features, coordinate-measuring machines (CMM) can be used effectively to assess the accuracy and tolerances. For parts with free-form surfaces, the inspection becomes complex. Therefore, numerous researches have been carried out to tackle both fundamental and application issues concerning free-form surface inspection. In addition to academic research, some commercial packages have also been developed. This paper provides a comprehensive literature review of methodologies, techniques and various processes of inspections of parts with free-form surfaces. The specific topics cover: measurement data acquiring methods including contact and non-contact measurement approaches; inspection planning; geometric description methods of design models or measurement data; and, the free-form surface localization and comparison techniques, which are emphasized in this paper and mainly include the establishment of corresponding relationship, 3D transformation solving, measurement data to design model comparison or surface to surface distance calculations. Other issues, such as the influence factors to the localization/registration process, definition and inspection of free-form surface tolerance, and discussions on the functions of some commercial inspection packages available on market, are also discussed.
Journal of Manufacturing Systems, 2006
With the increasing and extensive application of free-form surfaces in many fields, the inspection of manufactured freeform surfaces has become all the more important. To compare two free-form surfaces, the manufactured surface and the design model must be brought to the same coordinate system through localization. This paper introduces a featurebased method for the automatic localization and comparison of free-form surfaces for inspection. This method localizes the measurement surface to the design model through two steps. The first step is general localization based on the correspondence between the features extracted from both surfaces. The second step is fine localization that solves the point-to-point correspondence and localizes the surfaces accurately.The grid-subdivide method is proposed to improve the robustness and stability in searching for corresponding points. The free-form surfaces can have arbitrary positions and orientations in 3-D space.The entire process is automatic. Experiments have been carried out, and the results show that this automatic method is efficient and robust. A software prototype has been developed to demonstrate that this method can be applied directly to practical engineering inspections of parts with free-form surfaces.
International Journal of Production Research, 2002
Coordinate measuring machines (CMMs) are used to examine the conformity of the produced parts with the designer's intent. The inspection of free-form surfaces is a di cult process due to their complexity and irregularity. Many tasks are performed to ensure a reliable and e cient inspection using CMMs. Sampling is an essential and vital step in inspection planning. E cient and reliable approaches to determine the locations of the points to be sampled from freeform surfaces using the CMM were developed. Four heuristic algorithms for sampling based on the NURBS features of free-form surfaces are presented. The sampling criteria are equiparametric, surface patch size and the surface patch mean curvature. An algorithm for automatic selection of sampling algorithms performs complexity checks on NURBS surfaces, including the surface curvature changes and surface patch size changes, and selects the suitable sampling algorithm. Extensive simulations were performed using the developed methodologies to evaluate their performance using free-form surfaces with di erent degrees of complexity and compared with the uniform sampling pattern. The CMM measurement errors and manufacturing form errors have been simulated in these studies. The developed algorithms provide a useful tool in selecting the e ective sampling plans for the tactile CMM inspection planning of free-form surfaces.
International Journal of Metrology and Quality Engineering, 2012
This research work describes a novel approach for comparing different technologies for free form surface metrology: computerized tomography (CT), photogrammetry and coordinate measuring machines (CMM). The comparison has the aim of providing relevant information for the selection of metrology equipment when measuring free form components. Results demonstrate that there is the imperative need to assess the uncertainty and reproducibility of CT and photogrammetry measurements by applying some calibration procedures taking into account some recommendations for work piece alignment. This article also deals with costs issues, required standards, and necessary additional information when selecting inspection equipment.
Computer-Aided Design, 2014
h i g h l i g h t s • A method is developed for predicting variances of localized measurement points. • Robust rough localization is conducted by matching various geometric properties. • Robust fine localization is conducted by selecting the optimal coordinate system.
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2011
Precision inspection of manufactured components having multiple complex surfaces and variable tolerance definition is an involved, complex and time-consuming function. In routine practice, a jig is used to present the part in a known reference frame to carry out the inspection process. Jigs involve both time and cost in their development, manufacture and use. This paper describes 'as is where is inspection' (AIWIN), a new automated inspection technique that accelerates the inspection process by carrying out a fast registration procedure and establishing a quick correspondence between the part to inspect and its CAD geometry. The main challenge in doing away with a jig is that the inspection reference frame could be far removed from the CAD frame. Traditional techniques based on iterative closest point (ICP) or Newton methods require either a large number of iterations for convergence or fail in such a situation. A two-step coarse registration process is proposed to provide a good initial guess for a modified ICP algorithm developed earlier (Ravishankar et al., Int J Adv Manuf Technol 46(1-4):227-236, 2010). The first step uses a calibrated sphere for local hard registration and fixing the translation error. This transformation locates the centre for the sphere in the CAD frame. In the second step, the inverse transformation (involving pure rotation about multiple axes) required to align the inspection points measured on the manufactured part with the CAD point dataset of the model is determined and enforced. This completes the coarse registration enabling fast convergence of the modified ICP algorithm. The new technique has been implemented on complex freeform machined components and the inspection results clearly show that the process is precise and reliable with rapid convergence.
the present paper will present problems connected with accuracy inspection of free-form surfaces, performed with coordinate measuring machines equipped with touch measurement probes. The most important among them are, apart from the number and distribution of measurement points on a surface, errors caused by the probe radius compensation and determining the coordinate system. A theoretical analysis as well as the results of tests on the influence of compensations errors and errors in fitting the data to a CAD model on the results of computation of the points on the milled free-form surface will be presented. Considering any of these factors separately makes it impossible to obtain the complete picture of their mutual dependence. It turns out that applying compensation, leading to errors in determining measurement points, influences the uncertainty of the position and orientation of the coordinate system determined by fitting the compensated data to the CAD model.
Geometric inspection of non-rigid (flexible) parts in free-state can aid manufacturers to automatically and inexpensively improve quality by detecting defects on manufactured parts. Non-contact optic data acquisition devices (scanners) are used to measure point clouds on the boundary of manufactured part in free-state and compare it with its nominal computer aided design (CAD) model in a common coordinate system. In the case of non-rigid parts, deformation during free-state inspection, mostly due to weight and to residual stresses, causes specific problems since this deformation has to be distinguished from defects. In this study the generalized numerical inspection fixture (GNIF) method is applied to generate a prior set of corresponding sample points between CAD and scanned models. These points are then used to deform the CAD model to conform to scanned data, through finite element non-rigid registration. Corresponding sample points generated using GNIF are evenly distributed over...
In order for manufacturing companies to thrive in an era of globalization, market pressures and technological developments, quality control is key. Without this aspect, it is not possible to ensure the functionality and quality of products. Due to errors that occur during the manufacturing process, manufactured parts have deviations from their nominal geometry. Therefore, one of the important aspects of the quality control of mechanical parts is geometric inspection. With the help of automated inspection, costs can be reduced during process. In our research project, we have focused on the profile inspection of non-rigid (flexible) parts. In fact, several mechanical parts used in the aeronautic and automotive industries can be considered non-rigid. This category of parts may have significantly different shapes in a free-state condition than the design (nominal) model due to gravity loads and residual stress. Generally, to solve this problem, special inspection fixtures are used in industry to compensate for the deformations of such parts to simulate the use state to perform geometric inspection. These dedicated fixtures are very expensive and the process is very time-consuming which reduces competitiveness. We aim to develop a nonrigid inspection technique to eliminate the need for specialized inspection fixtures by using a non-contact measuring system such as optical scanning and comparing the obtained point cloud from the distorted part with the nominal model to identify deviations. Using a nonrigid registration method and finite element analysis, we will apply a virtual (numerical) inspection fixture instead of a physical fixture. The simulated displacement will be performed with improved boundary conditions for simulating unfixed parts.
École de technologie supérieure for the years of support and encouragement of my academic work, for his trust, caring, patience, and for his for his countless contributions. Many thanks to the president and jury members of my PhD examination committee for reading my thesis and offering their valuable time and constructive feedback. I would like also to thank CRSNG for their financial support. I would like to thank my wife Vajihe for her support and unwavering patience, my children Yashar and Yasmin providing me with unlimited happiness and pleasure. Last but not least, I would like to thank my parents Hussein and Aghdas and my younger sister Lida, for their endless love, spiritual supports and many years of patience. A mere expression of gratitude clearly does not suffice. For any errors or inadequacies that may remain in this work, the responsibility is entirely my own. FIXTURELESS GEOMETRIC INSPECTION OF NONRIGID PARTS USING "GENERALIZED NUMERICAL INSPECTION FIXTURE" Hassan RADVAR ESFAHLAN RESUMÉ Aujourd'hui les pièces mécaniques de forme libre et qui sont souples (non rigides) sont fréquentes dans les industries automobile et aéronautique. Ces pièces possèdent des formes significativement différentes à l'état libre que leurs formes nominales, telles que définies dans un modeleur numérique, en raison de leurs variations dimensionnelles et géométriques, l'effet de la gravité et les contraintes résiduelles induites par le procédé de fabrication. Pour l'inspection géométrique de ces pièces flexibles, des appareils d'inspection spécialisés tel que les gabarits de conformation, en combinaison avec les machines à mesure tridimensionnelle (MMT) et/ou des dispositifs d'acquisition de données optiques (scanners) sont utilisés. Ce qui se traduit immanquablement par des coûts et des délais additionnels qui se traduisent par une carence de compétitivité pour l'industrie. L'objectif de cette thèse est de faciliter l'inspection dimensionnelle et géométrique des composants flexibles à partir d'un nuage de points sans l'aide d'un gabarit ou autre opération de conformation secondaire. Plus précisément, nous visons à développer une méthodologie pour localiser et quantifier les défauts de profil dans le cas des coques minces qui sont typiques pour les industries aéronautique et automobile. La méthodologie présentée est basée sur le fait que la distance géodésique entre deux points d'une forme demeure invariante au cours d'une déformation isométrique (absence d'étirement, stretch). Cette étude développe donc la théorie générale, les méthodes et outils pour une métrologie des pièces non rigides en se basant sur l'hypothèse d'une déformation isométrique. Nous avons ainsi développé une méthode originale que nous avons nommée 'Gabarit d'Inspection Numérique Généralisée (GNIF)'. C'est une méthodologie robuste qui utilise les découvertes et technologies récemment développées en géométrie métrique et algorithmique. Les techniques de réduction dimensionnelle non linéaire sont employées pour VIII identifier les meilleures correspondances entre deux sets de points (CAD et nuage mesuré). Finalement, la méthode des éléments finis est employée en post-traitement pour 'caler' les deux nuages de points et produire un état numérique 'virtuel' d'une opération de conformation pour atteindre le but du projet qui est de développer une approche générale de l'inspection géométrique sans gabarit pour les pièces non rigides. La validation et l'exploration des performances métrologiques de notre approche sont réalisées sur des composants typiques de l'industrie. Mots-clés: Inspection assistée par ordinateur, inspection géométrique; pièce flexible, calage nonrigid par éléments finis; distance géodésique, les techniques de réduction dimensionnelle non linéaire, calage.
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2017
Dimensional inspection is an important element in the quality control of mechanical parts that have deviations from their nominal (CAD) model resulting from the manufacturing process. The focus of this research is on the profile inspection of non-rigid parts which are broadly used in the aeronautic and automotive industries. In a free-state condition, due to residual stress and gravity loads, a non-rigid part can have a different shape compared with its assembled condition. To overcome this issue, specific inspection fixtures are usually allocated in industry to compensate for the displacement of such parts in order to simulate the use state and accomplish dimensional inspections. These dedicated fixtures, their installation, and the inspection process consume a large amount of time and cost. Therefore, our principal objective has been to develop an inspection plan for eliminating the need for specialized fixtures by digitizing the displaced part's surface using a contactless (optical) measuring device and comparing the acquired point cloud with the CAD model to identify deviations. In our previous work, we developed an approach to numerically inspect the profile of a non-rigid part using a non-rigid registration method and finite element analysis. To do so, a simulated displacement was performed using an improved definition of boundary conditions for simulating unfixed parts. In this paper, we will improve on the method and save time by increasing the accuracy of displacement boundary conditions and using automatic node insertion and finite element analysis. The repeatability and robustness of the approach will be also studied and its metrological performance will be analyzed. We will apply the improved method on two industrial non-rigid parts with free-form surfaces simulated with different types of displacement, defect, and measurement noise (for evaluation of robustness).
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2010
Nonrigid part could be subjected to significant distortion after the removal of manufacturing forces. This condition, known as free-state variation, is principally due to weight and flexibility of the part and the release of internal stresses resulting from fabrication. The present work deals with the inspection of freeform surfaces belonging to nonrigid parts. A manufactured aeronautic component, named Mid Cowling, is considered as case study. The design of an appropriate fixture equipment will be firstly presented: it enables both to simulate the mating part interface and to locate the part in coordinate measuring machines working volume. Then, a method for evaluation of a freeform surface with respect to the nominal one will be presented. This evaluation is based on Euclidean distance between actual and nominal surfaces. Finally, an analysis of the part deformation presented in order to evaluate the measurement process in terms of interaction of the measurement system with the inspected part will be proposed. The adopted method, based on a finite element analysis, was proposed in order to evaluate the interaction, due to the measuring force, between the touch probe and the inspected surface and thus its effect on the measurement result.
Nowadays products having complex freeform custom-made shapes can be fabricated without any tool by means of additive manufacturing processes. Additive manufactured parts must be inspected for quality to verify that they meet dimensional and geometrical specifications among other requirements just as any other product. Contactless inspection carried out with optical 3D scanners is preferred to traditional pointwise measurements because of the higher amount of data retrieved in short times. A key step of the contactless inspection process is the definition of the part reference frame for the alignment of scan data. This paper considers different 3-2-1 alignments and analyze their influence on the inspection results, putting in evidence that an inattentive or inaccurate definition of the part reference frame can lead to incorrect evaluations of real part deviations.
Journal of Mechanical Engineering and Automation, 2012
The paper presents research on the improvements over an autonomous non-contact device with a vertical spindle for free form measurement which the authors developed previously. The fundamental ideas in the previous work include combining two displacement sensors with a servo motor, keeping the position of the sensor to directly measure the surface at the central value of the sensor's measuring range by controlling the motor rotation and performing scanning motions with NC functions of a MC. The inspection is entirely independent of the NC apparatus of the MC. Taking into account both the measurement accuracy and efficiency, three major improvements have been made retaining the advantages of the device. These improvements include 1) introducing a new sensing method for reference position along a scanning line to separate the reference position detection from the contour profile measurement, 2) accepting an AC servo motor controlled by a speed rule to raise the capability of autonomous movement following the contour profile to be measured, and 3) adopting a new laser displacement detector to widen the applicable range for both the shape and material of the surface to be measured. To assess the performance of the improved device, verification experiments are carried out on a machining center with several samples made of different materials. The experiment results demonstrate the effectiveness of the improvements made on the device.
This work addresses the problem concerning the reverse engineering of physical parts having complex freeform surfaces, starting from the shape measurement, data processing and part machining. The study was carried out with a small model of a sports car in scale 1:18. The model was measured using a CMA (coordinate measuring arm) with contact probe and a three-dimensional laser scanner. Data was processed using a CAD (computer-aided design) software and NURBS (non-uniform rational B-splines) curves and surfaces were fitted. The generated CAD model was adopted as reference to create a CAM (computer-aided manufacturing) program for the reconstruction of a prototype of the original part. Aluminum and wood were used as materials to produce the prototypes in a NC (numerically controlled) machining center. The produced part was measured following the same methodology initially applied with original model and a comparison of produced and original model was carried out. The prototypes obtained by different techniques of measurement, non-contact (laser scanner) and contact (CMA), were also compared to determine the most efficient method concerning the accuracy, repeatability and costs. It was found that both measurement techniques are complementary and fusion of data obtained would be desirable in order to increase the accuracy and reduce the cost.
International Journal of Production Research, 2012
Inspection and dimensional measurement of machined parts plays a vital role in manufacturing. Machined parts are inspected to much tighter tolerances in order to achieve the highest quality finished products. The dimensional inspection process of discrete components has been developed and automated with time and has come a long way, from the early use of gauge blocks, dial indicators, micrometers to today's computer controlled coordinate measuring machines (CMMs) with touch trigger probes. Despite this rapid advancement, bespoke inspection methods are used for dimensional measurement of machined parts either on a CMM or a CNC machining centre have touch trigger probes. A generalised dimensional inspection framework is required and to achieve this STEP and STEP-NC standards provide a convenient plate-form. In this paper the concept of a framework which gives a generalised feature-based inspection and measurement plan for prismatic machined parts based on STEP and STEP-NC is presented. This generalised STEP-NC compliant inspection plan could be a direct input to an intelligent controller of a CNC machining centre through an interface or can be interpreted into an inspection code for a CMM. The inspection framework uses the information regarding manufacturing features of a machined part and touch probing as given in ISO14649 (STEP-NC).
Procedia CIRP, 2013
Tolerances for freeform surfaces are specified using profile tolerance that controls form or combination of size, form, orientation and location of a feature(s) relative to a true profile. Freeform surfaces are generally inspected by using fixtures on a coordinate measuring machine (CMM). The combination of fixtures and the CMM enables the establishment of correspondence between points on the machined and nominal surface for tolerance verification. To respond to the market quickly, it has become inevitable to use 3D scanners that can scan an object rapidly and provide dense unorganized points as an output without maintaining any correspondence with the nominal CAD model. Current state of art uses the shortest distance criterion to establish correspondence and verify the profile tolerances. This results in acceptance of parts that ought to be rejected and vice versa. A novel, alternative approach is proposed to overcome this deficiency and verify tolerances specified on a free-form surface. The technique establishes the correct one to one correspondence between the machined surface and CAD model using the Medial axis transform (MAT). The MAT of both the nominal surface and the measured points respectively, are discretised to obtain grids. Corresponding points on the two grids are then used to verify the deviation of the machined surface from the nominal surface. Results of preliminary experiments with simulated data are presented.
2017
Quality control is an important factor for manufacturing companies looking to prosper in an era of globalization, market pressures and technological advances. Functionality and product quality cannot be guaranteed without this important aspect. Manufactured parts have deviations from their nominal (CAD) shape caused by the manufacturing process. Thus, geometric inspection is a very important element in the quality control of mechanical parts. We will focus here on the geometric inspection of non-rigid (flexible) parts which are widely used in the aeronautic and automotive industries. Non-rigid parts can have different forms in a free-state condition compared with their nominal models due to residual stress and gravity loads. To solve this problem, dedicated inspection fixtures are generally used in industry to compensate for the displacement of such parts for simulating the use state in order to perform geometric inspections. These fixtures and the installation and inspection proces...
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2016
Computer aided inspection (CAI) of non-rigid parts significantly contributes to improving performance of products, reducing assembly time and decreasing production costs. CAI methods use scanners to measure point clouds on parts and compare them with the nominal computer aided design (CAD) model. Due to the compliance of non-rigid parts and for inspection in supplier and client facilities, two sets of sophisticated and expensive dedicated fixtures are usually required to compensate for the deformation of these parts during inspection. CAI methods for fixtureless inspection of non-rigid parts aim at scanning these parts in a free-state for which, one of the main challenges is to distinguish between possible geometric deviation (defects) and flexible deformation associated with free-state. In this work the generalized inspection fixture (GNIF) method is applied to generate a prior set of corresponding sample points between CAD and scanned models. These points are used to deform the CAD model to the scanned model via finite element non-rigid registration. Then defects are identified by comparing the deformed CAD model with the scanned model. The fact that some sample points can be located close to defects, results in an inaccurate estimation of these defects. In this paper a method is introduced to automatically filter out sample points that are close to defects. This method is based on curvature and von Mises stress. Once filtered, remaining sample points are used in a new registration, which allows identifying and quantifying defects more accurately. The proposed method is validated on aerospace parts.
The International Journal of Advanced Manufacturing Technology, 2015
Quality control is an important factor for manufacturing companies looking to prosper in an era of globalization, market pressures, and technological advance. The functionality and product quality cannot be guaranteed without this important aspect. Manufactured parts have deviations from their nominal (CAD) shape caused by the manufacturing process. Thus, geometric inspection is a very important element in the quality control of mechanical parts. We have focused here on the profile inspection of non-rigid parts which are widely used in the aeronautic and automotive industries. Non-rigid parts can have different forms in a freestate condition compared with their nominal models due to residual stress and gravity loads. To solve this problem, dedicated inspection fixtures are generally used in industry to compensate for the displacement of such parts for simulating the use state in order to perform geometric inspections. These fixtures and the inspection process are expensive and time-consuming. Our aim is therefore to develop an inspection method which eliminates the need for specialized fixtures by acquiring a point cloud from the displaced part using a contactless measuring system such as optical scanning and comparing it with the CAD model for the identification of deviations. Using a non-rigid registration method and finite element analysis, we will numerically inspect the profile of a non-rigid part. To do so, a simulated displacement is performed using an improved definition of boundary conditions for simulating unfixed parts. In this paper, we will apply an improved method on two industrial non-rigid parts with free-form surfaces simulated with different types of displacement, defect, and measurement noise.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.