Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Some prehistory of New Zealand intensive care medicine

Profile image of Ronald V TrubuhovichRonald V Trubuhovich

2009, Anaesthesia and intensive care

Abstract

In taking 1960 as the foundation year for the practice of intensive care medicine in New Zealand, this paper briefly looks into the previous two centuries for some interventions in life-threatening conditions. With the help of descriptions in early 19th century journals and books by perceptive observers, the author focuses on some beliefs and practices of the Maori people during pre-European and later times, as well as aspects of medical treatment in New Zealand for early settlers and their descendents. Dr Laurie Gluckman's book Tangiwai has proved a valuable resource for New Zealand's medical history prior to 1860, while the recent publication of his findings from the examination of coroners' records for Auckland, 1841 to 1864, has been helpful. Drowning is highlighted as a common cause of accidental death, and consideration is given to alcohol as a factor. Following the 1893 foundation of the New Zealand Medical Journal, a limited number of its papers which are histori...

Figures (7)

Related papers

Medical practice in New Zealand 1769-1860
R. Lawrenson

Vesalius : acta internationales historiae medicinae, 2004

New Zealand was discovered by Captain Cook in 1769. Over the next ninety years, increasing numbers of medical practitioners visited and began to settle in what became a British colony. The first medical visitors were usually naval surgeons or served on board whaling ships. The major influx of doctors occurred at the behest of the New Zealand Company between 1840 and 1848, although Christian missionaries, army doctors, and individual medical entrepreneurs also emigrated and provided services. This paper describes the pattern of medical settlement in the colony's earliest years and relates this to the health of the population and the development of medical and hospital services.

View PDFchevron_right
Muddy Doctors and Mustard Poultices: Medical knowledge and practices in colonial New Zealand
Joanna Bishop

2010

This thesis examines health care in colonial New Zealand and sets about identifying and recognising the care which was given by women in their homes and communities. Based around four dominant etiological theories of the nineteenth century it explores the introduction, application and adaptation of medical knowledge in New Zealand. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my supervisor Dr. Judith Macdonald for her support, guidance and good humour and the Anthropology Department, especially Dr. Michael Goldsmith, for welcoming me into the faculty. Thanks to Janice Smith for her absolute dependability and ready smile and to all the staff at Waikato University who have assisted and supported me up till now. I would like to acknowledge and thank the University of Waikato and The Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences for their financial support and recognition. Many thanks to my friends and family for listening to me and maintaining complete faith in my abilities. Special thanks to Stan for his invaluable editing skills and to Lindsey and Shelley for the constant support and insightful conversation. Thank you Marcus for the frequent reality checks and motivation. iv

View PDFchevron_right
, ‘Colonial families and cultures of health: Glimpses of illness and domestic medicine in private records in New Zealand and Australia, 1850-1910’
Catharine Coleborne

This article draws on both published and unpublished private family writing to examine how European settler colonial families in southeastern Australia and New Zealand negotiated worlds of sickness and health between 1850 and 1910. It argues that personal writing is a neglected yet rich repository for shedding light on colonial cultures of health across families and households in colonial Australia and New Zealand. In examining challenges to well-being and gendered lay health care practices inside domestic spaces, we glimpse more than worlds of health and treatment. Through their management of health and illness in private domestic spaces, the sense of well-being colonial families created for their members tells us something both about their emotional lives and cultures of colonialism.

View PDFchevron_right
Rescuing the drowned: cardiopulmonary resuscitation and the origins of emergency medicine in the eighteenth century
Valentina Gazzaniga, Giuliano Bertazzoni

Internal and emergency medicine, 2011

The concept of a medical emergency, i.e., a time when immediate action is required to stabilize and restore the vital functions, is absent in the tradition of ancient medicine, which seeks to cure the sick. The theoretical and conceptual development of a prompt medical assistance definitely owes much to the refinement of instruments and surgical techniques that were develop in the early modern age, allowing the extension of therapeutic action to "healthy" individuals who are suddenly life-threatened due to an accident or to some external events that affect their vital functions. But it is especially in the eighteenth century that the epistemic basis of medical emergency is structured, when the Enlightenment gave rise to the ethical and political imperative of public assistance that required the planning of first aid at multiple levels, and medicine developed the concept of life-saving treatment. In particular, eighteenth century medicine, studying systems to assure immedia...

View PDFchevron_right
Medical Instructions of the XVIII Century to Resuscitate the Apparently Dead: Rescuing the Drowned to Define the Origins of the Emergency Medicine
Valentina Gazzaniga, Giuliano Bertazzoni

The concept of a medical emergency, i.e., a time when immediate action is required to stabilize and restore the vital functions, is absent in the tradition of ancient medicine, which seeks to cure the sick. The theoretical and conceptual development of a prompt medical assistance definitely owes much to the refinement of instruments and surgical techniques that were develop in the early modern age, allowing the extension of therapeutic action to ''healthy'' individuals who are suddenly lifethreatened due to an accident or to some external events that affect their vital functions. But it is especially in the eighteenth century that the epistemic basis of medical emergency is structured, when the Enlightenment gave rise to the ethical and political imperative of public assistance that required the planning of first aid at multiple levels, and medicine developed the concept of life-saving treatment. In particular, eighteenth century medicine, studying systems to assure immediate relief to the victims of accidentsespecially to the drowned-allowed the development of specific and methodological systems of resuscitation and emergency treatment.

View PDFchevron_right

Related topics

  • Publishing
  • Traditional Chinese Medicine
  • Anaesthesia and Intensive Care
  • Heart arrest
  • Respiratory insufficiency
  • Medical and Health Sciences

    • Related papers

    A kind of ritual Pakeha tikanga'--Maori experiences of hospitalisation: a case study: a thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master …
    Pipi Barton

    2008

    Copyright is owned by the Author of the thesis. Permission is given for a copy to be downloaded by an individual for the purpose of research and private study only. The thesis may not be reproduced elsewhere without the permission of the Author. 'A kind of ritual Pākehā tikanga'-Māori experiences of hospitalisation: A case study A thesis presented in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of

    View PDFchevron_right
    The New Zealand Medical Journal
    derek dow

    2003

    Health Department folklore since the 1950s has attributed the rise of health education in New Zealand almost entirely to the efforts of one man, 'Radio Doctor' Harold Turbott. The historical evidence reveals, however, a more extensive commitment by the Health Department, dating back to its foundation in 1900. This paper examines the evolution of health education in New Zealand and concludes that Turbott's role in its development has been overstated, largely at his own instigation.

    View PDFchevron_right
    Cultures of Care in Irish Medical History, 1750–1970
    Maria Luddy

    Cultures of Care in Irish Medical History, 1750–1970, 2010

    List of Tables Women who killed an infant (age under one year) and found to be insane at the time of the crime 5.2 Women who killed a child (age over one year) and found to be insane at the time of the crime 11.1 Mean number of children born per 100 women with marriages of 20-24 years' duration 11.2 Life expectancy at birth in Ireland 11.3 Life expectancy at birth in various European countries 11.4 Major infectious diseases, 1940-44 vii The editors would like to thank the Centre for the History of Medicine at the University of Warwick for supporting the original workshop at which these papers were presented. We are also grateful to the Wellcome Trust which funded that workshop. We made use of a wide network of colleagues to review the articles in this book and we would like to thank them for their comments and support for this publication.

    View PDFchevron_right
    Intensive Care Med (2004) 30:1829–1833 DOI 10.1007/s00134-004-2350-1 E X P ER IMENTAL
    Peter Herman

    2004

    A novel approach for selective brain cooling: implications for hypercapnia and seizure activity

    View PDFchevron_right
    The Last Illness and Death of Hawai‘i’s King Kalākaua: A New Historical/Clinical Perspective
    Zita Cup Choy

    Hawaiian Journal of History, 2015

    View PDFchevron_right
    19th century pioneers of intensive therapy in North America. Part 2: Joseph O'Dwyer
    Ronald V Trubuhovich

    Critical Care and Resuscitation Journal of the Australasian Academy of Critical Care Medicine, 2008

    View PDFchevron_right
    May the People Live: A History of Maori Health Development, 1900-1920, and: Maori Health and Government Policy, 1840-1940 (review)
    derek dow

    Bulletin of the History of Medicine, 2001

    View PDFchevron_right
    MJA Centenary — History of Australian Medicine
    Milton Lewis

    2014

     The main medicopolitical struggle was with the mutualaid friendly societies, which funded basic medical care for a signifi cant proportion of the population until well into the 20th century. The organised profession set out to overcome the power of the lay-controlled societies in imposing an unacceptable contract system on doctors, even if, historically, the guaranteed income was a sine qua non of practice in poorer areas. In this supplement, all the articles except this one focus on the period from about 1900, when modern scientifi c medicine came into its own in Australia. Here, I provide an overview of medicine in colonial Australia, as well as background to the post-1900 articles. For reasons of space, I confi ne my account of the period after about 1850 to the colonies of New South Wales, Victoria and South Australia, where the new university medical schools were located. I do not cover psychiatry because in the period under consideration it was almost exclusively practised i...

    View PDFchevron_right
    “A health resort for consumptives”: tuberculosis and immigration to New Zealand, 1880–1914
    Linda Bryder

    Medical History, 1996

    In his memoirs, the prominent New Zealand surgeon, A Eisdell Moore, described his parents' decision to emigrate from Britain to New Zealand in 1885: Father, who had been a chemist in Clifton, Bristol, had had several severe haemorrhages from his lungs. A consulting physician in Harley Street had told him that his only hope of survival was to come to New Zealand. My mother often recalled that as they were embarking at Plymouth she overheard the first officer say, "There's another to go over the side during the voyage."1 In this case the officer was mistaken-Moore's father not only survived the voyage but lived almost fifty years more. Not all were so lucky. In 1901, Dr James Mason, New Zealand's first Chief Health Officer, wrote in relation to tuberculosis cases: Any medical man in practice in the colony could, from his case-books, collect many cases of people who when they landed had no possible chance of recovery, and the only part of New Zealand they ever saw was the inside of a ward of a general hospital.2

    View PDFchevron_right
    A subtle containment: women in New Zealand medicine, 1893-1941
    Michael Belgrave

    The New Zealand journal of history, 1988

    WOMEN entered New Zealand medicine with little fuss and few impediments. Eliza Frikart's registration in 1893 went unnoticed and has since been all but forgotten. Frikart's brief New Zealand career as an advertising doctor peddling abortefacients did little to hinder the path of the better known figures of Margaret Cruikshank and Emily Siedeberg who followed her later in the decade. Yet, having penetrated the profession and soon comprising around 10% of new registrations, women remained at this level until well after the introduction of social security, their numbers rising only temporarily as a result of the Great War. By 1941 women made up 8.6% of all those doctors registered since 1867 but despite their late start were still only 10.3% of that year's registrations.' Women were also far less successful in achieving the high incomes medicine offered their male colleagues. 2 With a few exceptions, the comparatively large number of women in the Health Department remained at its lower levels. In a profession where full-time private practice with an honorary hospital appointment was the confirmation of professional accomplishment, women were more likely to be salaried and part-time. While a few gained positions as visiting consultants these were usually in less fashionable specialities. Surgery, which offered the highest incomes, remained a gentlemen's club. Still, in medicine, compared with other high status, high income professions, women were well represented. 3 In 1936 there were 83 women doctors, two women school inspectors, fourteen dentists, four architects and no university professors. 4 Why were the barriers preventing women from entering the medical profession so much more easily overcome than were the more subtle obstructions which frustrated women from competing in the medical economy on an equal footing with their male colleagues? While the New Zealand situation was similar to that of other societies, the relatively small size of the New Zealand profession allows a view of the experience of all women doctors rather than just of those whose strength of character, determination and good fortune allowed them to become successful medical practitioners. 5 Women became doctors, as they became teachers, because medicine, like education, was compatible with current stereotypes of women's role in society. The terms 'lady doctor' and 'medical man' were more than simple labels: they carried with them much of the sexual ideology of Victorian respectability. 'Medical man' was commonly used to denote the medical practitioner as entrepreneur. Whenever the profession as a whole described doctors as actively engaged in the medical economy-developing practices, or pursuing their careers-it tended to make the doctor masculine. 'Lady doctor', on the other hand, had very different connotations. The term implied that women doctors remained 'ladies', and as such continued to fulfil social roles consistent with late nineteenth-century norms of behaviour acceptable for middle-class women. Many values attributed to this feminine mystique were also part of the developing professional ethos. Doctors, too, were advancing themselves as compassionate, serving healers, more concerned with preventing suffering than amassing fortunes. In return for being accepted, even in a limited role, women lent medicine the virtues of their sex. Doris Gordon's professional and political role was, for instance, that of a pragmatic defender of the private practice economy in midwifery, but she was able to present herself as no more than a dedicated woman 'fired with a compelling ambition to serve as a medical missionary, a decision which later circumstances altered to service for country mothers'. 6 Nonetheless, precisely because feminine virtues contrasted with the masculine economic and scientific characteristics of the 'medical man', women doctors, once over the considerable hurdle of getting a medical education, then faced even more challenging obstacles to professional equality within the medical marketplace. New Zealand women were saved the political battles over entry into medical schools and the right to registration and academic qualifications

    View PDFchevron_right