Kinema: A Journal for Film and Audiovisual Media
Spring 2006 Issue of KINEMA THE CINEMATIC "ARAB": FROM THE LONG SHIPS TO HIDALGO IMAGES of "Arabs" have been perennial staples of both Hollywood feature films and US television. The degree to which these are stereotypical has been examined in studies by several critics. In spite of their admonitions, however, they remain fixtures of America's dream factory. The recent film Hidalgo reveals the reproduction of these tried and not so true representations, but also seeks to address some of the criticisms and to make redress for transgressions visited upon the two principal groups depicted within it, "Arabs" and Native American Indians. In the course of doing so, it takes on North American "racial" formation, historical relations between the New and Old Worlds and British imperialism. Finally, Hidalgo is a curiously complex tricolour tapestry of racial binaries, the antinomies of "White" vs "Red," "Black" vs "White," "White" vs "Arab" and "Red" vs "Arab." If it may be argued that several of these oppositions have novel elements, it is also evident that they bear comparison to earlier scenes in both the recent and distant celluloid past. Embedded within this set of representations is the understudied signifier of "Afro-Arab." That racial diversity exists and has existed within the Arab world has long been a subject of Arabists, Islamicists and Africanists. Such scholars as Bernard Lewis and John Ralph Willis have addressed it directly, principally in terms of links between "race" and slavery. Until their compulsory introduction into Kuwait and Saudi Arabia with the onset of the Persian Gulf and Iraq wars, however, most Americans had not taken note of this. Since the emergence of al-Qaeda and the spate of bombings directed at US installations and interests inside the Middle East, Eastern Africa and North America, culminating in the September 11 th attacks, the largely unspoken factor of "race" has formed an undercurrent in the discourse on "Arab," "Islamic" and "fundamentalism-inspired" terrorism which has provoked much heated debate within a terrified American populace and the resort to military expedients to combat a perceived "Islamic threat.