Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Indian Muslims on the margins.docx

Abstract

Muslims are the largest religious minority in India and constitute 14.4% of the total population. The socio-economic backwardness of the Muslim community was first documented by the Gopal Singh committee of early 1980s and then the Sachar Committee report, barring some yet genuine criticism, in 2006 has brought out extensively the varied facets of its backwardness and acute marginality. Even before the Sachar Report, there were a lot of other studies as such Shariff (1999), Shariff and Azam (2004), Reddy (2002) and Ali and Sikand (2006) which showed that Muslims are socio-economically and educationally backward community. The community faces marginalization partly due to indifferent attitude of the government and partly due to the growing influence of the Hindutva propaganda against Muslims (Ali & Sikand, 2006). The so-called ‘appeasement politics’ which the majority Hindu group accuses the secular government of, have not even worked to the progress of the Muslim community (Reddy, 2002). That Muslims are benefiting off the fruits of ‘state appeasement’ can well be refuted by looking at relative position of the community on the socio-economic indicators like literacy, landholding size, employment statuses, unemployment rate, income and their political participation.

Key takeaways

  • That Muslims are benefiting off the fruits of 'state appeasement' can well be refuted by looking at relative position of the community on the socio-economic indicators The Sachar Report discusses the problems faced by the Muslims relating to security, identity and equity, and their problems as a combination of those faced by all poor people (Muslims are largely poor), minorities and exclusively by Muslims.
  • However, the marginality of Muslims is seen even in the labor market.
  • Studies which have documented lower monthly per capita expenditure (which is often taken as a proxy of income in empirical literature) and higher incidence of poverty among Muslims in general than all other groups except STs/SCs (Basant and Shariff, 2010) give us some indication that preponderance of Muslim workers in self-employment do not seem to improve their socio-economic conditions., and moreover a higher proportion of In pursuit of mainstreaming the community:
  • The cornerstone of inclusive development discourse ought to frame the deprivation faced by Muslims in India as a state development subject, rather than treating it as a minority problem.