Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Should Soda Lime be Abolished

Abstract

have the elongase and desaturase enzyme systems needed to synthesize arachidonic acid from linoleic acid. Therefore, arachidonic acid is not found in vegetable oils. It is true that production of proinflammatory and antiinflammatory metabolites may be responsible for the effects we reported, but these metabolites are synthesized within the animal tissues from their precursors: arachidonic acid from linoleic acid of the omega 6 family and eicosapentaenoic acid from-linolenic acid of the omega 3 family. The oils we gave to the rats could not contain these anti-inflammatory metabolites. Thus, these metabolites and their possible effects on pain behavior were not reported in our article. 3. Our behavioral results were criticized on two grounds: a. No significant difference of either intervention (i.e., the hyper-algesic versus hypoalgesic oils) in comparison with control: This is not exactly true. We are showing marginally significant differences in heat hyperalgesia between rats supplemented with water only compared with hemp oil-fed rats (P 0.07) and corn oil-fed rats (P 0.06). b. The selective analgesic effect of dietary fat on thermal, but not mechanical, hyperalgesia: Several lines of clinical, anatomical, pharmacological , and molecular evidence support the notion that the physiological basis of thermal and mechanical hypersensitivity states is considerably dissociable (4). For example, the percentage of injured fibers after partial nerve injury could dictate the development of thermal versus tactile hyperalgesia (5); N-methyl-d-aspartate antagonists suppressed thermal but not mechanical hy-peralgesia (6), whereas gabapentin alleviated mechanical but not cold allodynia (7) in nerve injured rats; midrange plasma levels of phytoestrogens were associated with reduced mechanical, but not thermal, pain after nerve injury in rats (8). Therefore, our results that specific intervention is capable of suppressing thermal but not tactile hyperalgesia are well supported.