Academia.edu no longer supports Internet Explorer.
To browse Academia.edu and the wider internet faster and more securely, please take a few seconds to upgrade your browser.
2006
In the past two decades, a significant amount of research has been conducted into the performance of composite steel-framed structures in fire. However, the same level of development has not taken place for other forms of construction. In terms of reinforced concrete construction, design is still based on simplistic methods which have been developed from standard fire tests that do not necessarily represent real building behaviour. This makes it very difficult, if not impossible, to determine the level of safety achieved in real concrete structures, or whether an appropriate level of safety could be achieved more efficiently. In this study detailed analyses of a reinforced concrete structure subject to a standard fire regime are carried out. The building is designed to Eurocode 2 and represents a commercial office building. In order to study the interactions between the cool and hot zones of the structure, a series of analyses has been carried out for different extents and positions of localised fire compartments. It is clear that adjacent cool structure provides considerable restraint and continuity, increasing the fire resistance of the structure within the fire compartment. Relatively small areas of tensile membrane force are formed within the concrete slabs, and large areas are subject to compressive membrane action during the fire. As a result the downstand concrete beams experience enhanced tension during the fire, especially in the early stages, which is mainly carried by their tensile reinforcement. It is therefore very important to keep the temperature of beam reinforcement within certain limits. Eventual structural collapse in the studies is always due to column failure, and it is clear that the performance of columns is vitally important to the survival of reinforced concrete buildings in fire.
Civil Engineering and Architecture, 2023
Concrete structures have a favorable position in the building industry with regard to their performance of fire resistance. The understanding of their behavior is essential for reliable analysis and design. This paper is mainly concerned with concrete building performance subjected to localized fire arrangement. Special attention has been given to the finite element model of a seven-story concrete building representing a typical commercial office building designed to European Standard. Very large displacements happened on horizontal direction of the floor slabs due to thermal expansions. The large displacement induced lateral movement of the floor slabs and created additional moments to external columns. Design engineers should ensure that the external columns have ability to accommodate lateral displacements during fire. Although, the thin external columns of the model can withstand these movements due to beneficial effect of membrane action developed to the floor slabs. Present analysis indicates that the performance of the whole structure is substantially different from the single isolated structural member behavior during fire. Although the current design procedures are conservative, design engineers have to consider the detrimental and beneficial effects of lateral slabs' thermal expansion in complete structure.
Computers and Concrete, 2018
Numerical approach using finite element method has been used to evaluate the behaviour of reinforced concrete frame structure subjected to fire. The structure is previously designed in accordance with Eurocode standards for the design of structures for earthquake resistance, for the ductility class M. Thermal and structural response are obtained using a commercially available software ANSYS. Temperature-dependent nonlinear thermal and mechanical properties are adopted according to Eurocode standards, with the application of constitutive model for the triaxial behaviour of concrete with a smeared crack approach. Discrete modelling of concrete and reinforcement has enabled monitoring of the behaviour at a global, as well as at a local level, providing information on the level of damage occurring during fire. Critical regions in frame structures are identified and assessed, based on temperatures, displacements, variations of internal forces magnitudes and achieved plastic deformations of main reinforcement bars. Parametric analyses are conducted for different fire scenarios and different types of concrete aggregate to determine their effect on global deformations of frame structures. According to analyses results, the threedimensional finite element model can be used to evaluate the insulation and mechanical resistance criteria of reinforced concrete frame structures subjected to nominal fire curves.
This paper provides a 'state of the art' review of research into the effects of high temperature on concrete and concrete structures, extending to a range of forms of construction, including novel developments. The nature of concrete-based structures means that they generally perform very well in fire. However, concrete is fundamentally a complex material and its properties can change dramatically when exposed to high temperatures. The principal effects of fire on concrete are loss of compressive strength, and spalling – the forcible ejection of material from the surface of a member. Though a lot of information has been gathered on both phenomena, there remains a need for more systematic studies of the effects of thermal exposures. The response to realistic fires of whole concrete structures presents yet greater challenges due to the interactions of structural elements, the impact of complex small-scale phenomena at full scale, and the spatial and temporal variations in exposures, including the cooling phase of the fire. Progress has been made on modelling the thermomechanical behaviour but the treatment of detailed behaviours, including hygral effects and spalling, remains a challenge. Furthermore, there is still a severe lack of data from real structures for validation, though some valuable insights may also be gained from study of the performance of concrete structures in real fires.
Journal of building engineering, 2020
Reinforced concrete (RC) structural members generally exhibit a fairly good fire resistance due to their low thermal conductivity and high thermal capacity. However, under prolonged duration of exposure, RC members experience loss of strength and stiffness. An experimental investigation is carried out to examine the influencing factors affecting the structural performance of the RC beams of different strength grades exposed to standard fire. Specimens were heated as per standard fire curve. Different grades of RC beams (i.e. M20, M30, M40 and M50) are tested under two-point loading. The effect of standard fire on the load-deflection response, first crack load, ultimate load, temperature in rebar, yield strength of rebar and moment of resistance are investigated in the RC beams. Temperature in steel at specified locations of a RC beam is also measured to determine the extent of damage. It is observed from the investigation that the mode of failure is dependent on many material parameters (w/c ratio, density, porosity) and structural factors (compressive strength of concrete, yield strength of rebar). Damage level of concrete with lower grade was higher up to 120min duration of heating and after that loss in strength of concrete with higher grade is significant. Water-to-cement ratio, compressive strength, temperature level in concrete or steel and rebar area are some of the key factors affecting the loss in strength of RC beams at elevated temperature.
2016
Increasing fire accidents in buildings and structures are of major concern these days. The extensive use of concrete in buildings as a structural material has led us to study the effect of fire on concrete. Concrete is proven to have a high degree of fire resistance. It is non-combustible and has a high thermal emissivity and low conductivity which significantly slows down the penetration of heat through concrete elements. In most fires, the outer layer of concrete with a thickness of 3-5 cm is damaged. Therefore, many concrete buildings that experienced fire can be simply restored and reused. However concrete remains a complex material, made up of several constituents which show different behaviour when exposed to fire. Several physico-chemical transformations take place in concrete resulting in a decrease of strength and stiffness. Therefore, the fire resistance of concrete structures should not be taken for granted. This can be done by studying the behaviour of different structur...
Structures Congress 2008, 2008
After the 9-11 attack on the World Trade Center, interest in the design of structures for fire greatly increased. Some engineers have promoted the use of advanced analytical models to determine fire growth within a compartment and have used finite element models of structural components to determine temperatures within a component by heat transfer analysis. Following the calculation of temperatures, the mechanical properties at various times during the period of the fire must be determined. This paper provides structural engineers with a summary of the complex behavior of structures in fire and the simplified techniques which have been used successfully for many years to design concrete structures to resist the effects of severe fires.
The present work looks into the developments related to understanding the impact of extreme heat on concrete and concrete-based forms of different nature. Being made of this material implies that any building should naturally resist fire; yet, concrete is, in eessence, is very complicated complex and likely to shift in terms of features when experiencing extreme heat. Fire, basically, reduces compressive strength, as well as spalling in concrete-the latter being described as forced removal of substances from the surface of any piece of fabrication. Despite vast amounts of data on these two effects, better structured investigations are to be carried out. The way buildings react to such fires in actual scenarios, in itself, is a different issue because of the interactions occuring among various components, effect of complicated small-scale events in theri entirety, and also the spatial and temporal changes in heat such as the cooling stage after the fire recedes. There have been advancements in the field of simulating thermo-mechanical patterns; however, how to handle intricate behaviours like hygral effects and spalling remains a question. On top of all this a major shortage exists in the amount of infoirmation related to actual structures for the purpose of validation, while precious other data can be obtained if we focus on behavior of concrete formations in such actual fire events.
Journal of structural engineering, 2004
This paper outlines experimental research on the behaviour of reinforced concrete columns with restrained thermal elongation subjected to fire. The high temperatures developed in a fire lead to the thermal elongation of the structural elements, but other parts of the structure that remain at lower temperatures will impose restraints on that elongation, resulting in additional stresses on the heated members. It is therefore important to analyze the influence of the thermal restraint on the behaviour of reinforced concrete columns subjected to fire. Fire resistance tests were carried out on reinforced concrete columns with restrained thermal elongation to study this phenomenon. The influence of several parameters on the behaviour of the columns subjected to fire was tested, including the longitudinal reinforcement ratio, the slenderness of the column, the restraint level, the load level and the load eccentricity.
2004
A computer program VULCAN has been progressively developed for some years at the University of Sheffield, with the objective of enabling three-dimensional modelling of the behaviour of composite buildings in fire. In this paper the theoretical basis of the non-linear layered procedure used to model the reinforced concrete floor slabs, which includes both geometric and material non-linearity, is briefly outlined. Several of the full-scale fire tests carried out in 1995-96 on the composite frame at Cardington, representing cases in which different degrees of in-plane restraint are provided by the adjacent structure, are modelled to evaluate the influence of tensile membrane action in the concrete slabs on the structural behaviour in fire. In order to illustrate the influence of membrane action and its relationship with boundary restraint, all cases have been analysed using both geometrically linear and nonlinear slab elements. A series of parametric studies has been carried out as an initial investigation into the characteristics of steel reinforcement which allow this action to take place. It is clear that the influence of tensile membrane action of concrete slabs on the behaviour of such composite structures in fire is very important, and should be accounted for in later additions and amendments to structural fire engineering design codes.
2011
Concrete has an excellent intrinsic behaviour when exposed to fire, especially when compared to other building materials. However, its fire resistance should not be taken for granted and a proper s ...
Advances in Computational Design, 2016
The objective of this work is to study the restraining effect in fire resistance of framed structures and to evaluate the global response of reinforced concrete frames when exposed to fire based on advanced finite element method. To study the response a single portal frame is analyzed. The effect of floor slab on this frame is studied by modeling a beam-column-slab assembly. The evolution of temperature distribution, internal stresses and deformations of the frame subjected to ISO 834 standard fire curve for both the frames are studied. The thermal and structural responses are evaluated and a comparison of results of individual members and entire structure is done. From the study it can be seen that restraining forces has significant influence on both stresses and deflection and overall response of the structure when compared to individual structural member. Among the various structural elements, columns are the critical members in fire and failure of column causes the failure of entire structure. The fire rating of various structural elements of the frame is determined by various failure criteria and is compared with IS456 2000 tabulated fire rating.
Advance Researches in Civil Engineering, 2019
The effects of firebreak in high-rise buildings seem essential to be investigated cautiously since world trade center towers incident. Consequently, many technological advancements were achieved and numerous researches were performed. Nevertheless, in 2017, Plasco building in Iran also was set ablaze and the consequence was the full destruction of the building, claiming lives of at least 20, injuring 70 and loss of thousands of jobs. Therefore, it is crucial to investigate the effects of fire in high-rise buildings more thoroughly in order to prevent progressive collapse, a phenomenon that caused the destruction of the two landmarks. Ordinarily, to achieve this goal, methods of analysing fire effects are developed. So by choosing a logical fire scenario, design fire is extracted from time-temperature relations of design codes. After determining the firing temperature at various times, effects of temperature increase on the material's mechanical properties are investigated. Important characteristics such as concrete compressive strength, concrete and steel modules of elasticity, tensile strength, the coefficient of thermal expansion and steel rebar yielding stress are affected by alterations of temperature. Finally, by analysing structural behaviour utilizing modelling programs and comparing results of different fire temperatures and stories in which fire occurs with the initial design of the building RCC frame, it can be concluded that axial forces increases in columns are the critical condition in fire situations and in case of fire break in distinct stories, lower floors will experience a sharper surge of axial forces.
International Journal of Solids and Structures, 2005
The paper describes a two-step finite element formulation for the thermo-mechanical non-linear analysis of the behaviour of the reinforced concrete columns in fire. In the first step, the distributions of the temperature over the cross-section during fire are determined. In the next step, the mechanical analysis is made in which these distributions are used as the temperature loads. The analysis employs our new strain-based planar geometrically exact and materially non-linear beam finite elements to model the column. The results are compared with the measurements of the full-scale test on columns in fire and with the results of the European building code EC 2. The resistance times of the present method and the test were close. It is also noted that the building code EC 2 might be non-conservative in the estimation of the resistance time.
Journal of The Institution of Engineers (India): Series A, 2016
Fire resistance is one of the crucial design regulations which are now mandatory in most of the design codes. Therefore, a thorough knowledge of behaviour of structures exposed to fire is required in this aspect. Columns are the most vulnerable structural member to fire as it can be exposed to fire from all sides. However, the data available for fire resistant design for columns are limited. Hence the present work is focused on the effect of crosssectional shape of column in fire resistance design. The various cross-sections considered are Square, Ell (L), Tee (T), and Plus ('?') shape. Also the effect of size and shape and distribution of steel reinforcement on fire resistance of columns is studied. As the procedure for determining fire resistance is not mentioned in Indian Standard code IS 456 (2000), the simplified method (500°C isotherm method) recommended in EN 1992-1-2:2004 (E) (Eurocode 2) is adopted. The temperature profiles for various cross-sections are developed using finite element method and these profiles are used to predict fire resistance capability of compression members. The fire resistance based on both numerical and code based methods are evaluated and compared for various types of cross-section.
Applications of Structural Fire Engineering
In the scope of a new industrial building, an R60 fire resistance criterion was requested by the local fire brigade for the steel structure supporting non-structural EI60 concrete walls. On the basis of an investigation conducted after an actual fire in 2008, it was presumed possible to satisfy this R60 criterion using this type of unprotected steel frame. A 2D thermo-plastic model was set up, taking into account the thermal contribution of concrete walls, to limit excessive steel temperatures of the bearing elements. A void was considered between the concrete and the web of the middle columns to simulate real construction works as much as possible. The nominal ISO-834 fire was applied separately in each bay on the exposed parts of the elements. By using fixed column bases in case of fire, the structure can withstand up to 120 minutes of ISO fire i.e. far beyond the collapse of the primary structure subjected to fire. To avoid discussions about the local impact of a real fire, the i...
2013
In the prescriptive approach, the evolution of the gas temperature in the compartment is considered to be continuously increasing. However, performance-based design is now more and more used for assessing the fire resistance of structures. Performance-based design uses a more realistic representation of the fire which comprises not only a heating phase but also a cooling phase. The influence of realistic fire scenarios is a key issue in the evaluation of the fire resistance. Modelling the cooling phase of the fire, although it is not of current practice in design office, is required for assessing the risk of delayed collapse of a structure. This paper presents the results of numerical simulations of the structural behaviour of reinforced concrete walls during and after the cooling phase of fire. The simulations were performed with the finite element program SAFIR. It is found that failure during the cooling phase of a fire is a possible event and, more dangerous, that a failure of t...
Journal of fire protection …, 2006
2014
In this work, the probability of failure with time of reinforced concrete columns subjected to a high temperature is investigated. This study is of great concern, because under the effect of high temperature, the material properties of steel reinforced concrete degrade drastically. Different columns are taken under consideration by varying a fixed s et of parameters; these parameters include: the cross-section of the column, arrangement of the steel bars, diameter of the steel bars, distance of steel-bar center from column center, number of bars used in one column, reinforcing ratio (As/Ac), surface emissivity, and fire temperature. The technique of finite element analysis was used to calculate the temperature distribution with time over the column’s cross-sectional area using suitable computing machines. Rising temperature in the column leads to a decrease in the load-carrying capacity, which leads to a probable collapse of the building at a critical strain of e = 0.3%. Out of the...
Soil Dynamics and Earthquake Engineering, 2020
Large earthquakes may cause a chain of events, and one of which can be fire after an earthquake. The effects of fire after earthquake on urban areas can be even worse than the effects of the earthquake itself. Buildings are not adequately designed for fire after an earthquake since most standards ignore that possibility. The aim of the work is to evaluate the consequences of the damage introduced due to the seismic events on the fire resistance of reinforced concrete elements. Several numerical analyses were performed to reinforce concrete elements using the program SAFIR, considering the thermal and mechanical analysis of the structure. The main variables in the analysis were the type of damage in the elements and the type of loads. The thermal analysis was performed using the standard fire curve ISO 834. The results show that the damage imposed by earthquake on reinforced concrete structures reduces the fire resistance, especially if the cover of the elements is removed and the reinforcement is exposed to fire.
Fire Safety Journal, 2004
Explosive spalling of concrete elements under fire is still an important issue within the research community. In particular the effect of structural boundary conditions on performance of concrete in fire is still an area of interest. This paper represents the results of a major research executed on 99 high and normal strength concrete elements. The parametric study investigated the effect of restraint degree, loading level and heating rates on the performance of concrete columns subjected to elevated temperatures with a special attention directed to explosive spalling. The paper includes a useful comparison between the performance of high and normal strength concrete columns in fire. The paper illustrates a method of preventing explosive spalling using polypropylene fibres in the concrete. The paper ends with valuable conclusions drawn from the research. r
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.