The European Public Sphere: Myth, Reality or Aspiration?
Cristian Nitoiu
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
The discussion about the public sphere only began to have significant relevance within the setting of the European Union in the middle of the 1990s when a growing degree of attention was directed towards European integration and the role of national and transnational media in providing thrust for it. Since then, the notion of the public sphere has been seen as a central feature of European democracies, shaping the coherence of political systems and decision-making processes. There has also been a tendency in the literature to perceive the European public sphere (EPS) as having positive effects on the EU by endowing it with legitimacy and providing a space where its institutions and leaders can be made more transparent and accountable. What is disputed throughout this scholarship is the possibility of creating an overarching European public sphere that would act as a transnational discursive space uniting various communication fluxes and actors from all strata of society. However, the answers provided by scholars for this puzzle are at most ambiguous or undecided and seem to be torn between viewing the EPS as aspiration, myth or reality.Bee, C. and Bozzini, E. (eds) (2010) Mapping the European Public Sphere: Institutions, Media and Civil Society. Farnham: Ashgate.Fossum, J. E. and Schlesinger, P. (eds) (2007) The European Union and the Public Sphere: A Communicative Space in the Making? Abingdon: Routledge.Koopmans, R. and Statham, P. (eds) (2010) The Making of a European Public Sphere: Media Discourse and Political Contention. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.Risse, T. (2010) A Community of Europeans? Transnational Identities and Public Spheres. Ithaca NY: Cornell University Press.
Related papers
Ruud Koopmans and Paul Statham (eds), The Making of a European Public Sphere: Media Discourses and Political Contention
European Journal of Communication, 2011
This edited volume sets out to examine the Europeanization of media discourse vis-à-vis advancing European integration and to explore its relation to political practice and the 'European democratic deficit'. The studies presented investigate patterns of communication and interaction that emerge alongside institutional and policy regulation at the EU level and these are used to draw conclusions about how conditions of Europeanization, transnationalism and globalization affect the ways democratic politics is performed.
Transnational News Media and the Elusive European Public Sphere
Various initiatives to unite the people and the nations of Europe have often met resistance when trying to reach a level of integration that would comprise significant political and cultural components. European authorities have nurtured high hopes that mass media could play a decisive role in creating and securing a form of European public sphere driven by the development of a European media sphere. Despite daring and resolute initiatives, any significant European media sphere has remained as elusive as a comprehensive Europe-wide public sphere. Adding to the complexity of the matter, the articulation between regional, national, and European public and media spheres forms a range of complex configurations. Ultimately, while preserving the budding of transnational media spheres, attention should be shifted toward making existing public spheres more porous while interconnecting them to enhance mutual understanding and empathy among the peoples of Europe.
Global Media Journal
Having as theoretical basis the notion of the public sphere and its manifestations within the EU, the current paper seeks to trace similarities and differences in the public discourse developed in German and Greek news sites, regarding the financial and refugee crises. Our quantitative content analysis shows that there are both similarities and differences in the two distinct public spheres, regarding the evaluation of the EU, its policies on the aforementioned issues and the ways in which the public discourse is being articulated mainly on behalf of politicians and journalists, who appear to be the main carriers of the public discourse in the media under scrutiny.
The European Union and the public sphere: a communicative space in the making?
2007
The public sphere is a central feature of modern society. So much so that, even where it is in fact suppressed or manipulated, it has to be faked. (Taylor 1995: 260)
The Making of a European Public Sphere: Media Discourse and Political Contention. Edited by Ruud Koopmans and Paul Statham. New York: Cambridge University Press, 2010. 356p. $93.00 cloth, $30.99 paper
Perspectives on Politics, 2012
Journalists Imagining the European Public Sphere: Professional Discourses about the EU news in Ten Countries
Javnost-The Public, 2006
JourNalists imagiNiNg the europeaN public sphere professioNal discourses about the eu News practices iN teN couNtries abstract This article aims to analyse journalists' professional imagination in connection to EU news. A special attention is paid to the variety of ideas about European public sphere that inform (or fail to inform) journalists' work. The article is based on 149 semi-structured qualitative journalist interviews conducted in the home offices of mainstream news organisations in ten European countries. The article takes up Charles Taylor's idea that public sphere belongs to the key social imaginaries of modernity and treat journalists as important carriers of these social imaginaries. These professional imaginaries are traced by looking at how journalists perceive the locus of news, how they define their professional role vis-à-vis their audience, and finally, how they would describe the political and communication problems within the EU. From this reasoning three relatively coherent lines of thought were derived: classical professionalism, secular discourse, and cosmopolitan discourse. As a conclusion the article attempts to map out these different discourses in connection to modes of political communication. The three discourses detected in the article can be seen as contemporary versions of professionalism in European news organisations. As such, they do not give much ground to assume that a European public sphere would emerge out of national journalistic cultures. Given the emergent nature of publics and public spheres, this does not mean that such practices may not be developed outside journalism. heikki heikkilä risto kuNelius heikki heikkilä is research fellow at the department of Journalism and mass communication, university of tampere;
Review Essay: John Erik Fossum and Philip Schlesinger (eds), The European Union and the Public Sphere: A Communicative Space in the Making? London: Routledge, 2007. 312pp. (incl. index), £70.00, US$125.00, ISBN 978 04153 8456 8 (hbk
European Journal of Social Theory, 2008
It is an impressive group of authors from many disciplines and countries that Fossum and Schlesinger have brought together is this very timely book with theories, models and analysis of the many aspects of Europeanization and communication inside Europe and the European Union (EU). The history of post-war Europe, the EU and the European generation is in many ways a success story, compared with the past bloody and national history of a strongly divided Europe. However, the development right now, as the editors also reflect upon in the introduction, seems to be at a crossroad where the expansion of the EU demands new structures and procedures, but where at the same time the public support for a grander and more ambitious vision of a unified and expanded European democracy does not seem to produce popular support on a national level.
Debating the European Constitution: On representations of Europe/the EU in the press
Journal of Language and Politics, 2005
An elusive European public sphere: the role of shared journalistic cultures
2009
It has been widely accepted that media (and consequ ently journalistic values and practices) play a crucial role in the creation of a public sph ere and this applies to a shared European public sphere as well. This chapter explores issues linked with the existence of a shared European journalistic culture, and, based on empiri cal data collected in eleven EU member states for an EU-funded research project (EMEDIATE: Media and Ethics of a European Public Sphere from the Treaty of Rome to the ‘War o n Terror’, project no.CIT2-CT-2004506027), the authors argue that we can hardly ident ify such a shared European journalistic culture. There are, however, shared expectations of the role of the media in European societies such as representing the public and promoting socia l values, as well as shared professional values (such as objectivity, factuality and balance , often reflected in codes of ethics) and underlying Enlightenment values that inform journal istic cultures.
Related papers
The Development of a European Public Sphere: A Stalled Project?
European Political Science, 2008
The editorial to the symposium briefly contextualises current debates on the European 'public sphere' and/or on absence thereof. In light of concern with the EU's so-called 'democratic deficit', the issue of how to create a polis without a demos has focused, in part, on the role of the public sphere (O ¨ffentlichkeit) with respect, for example, to the mass media, law, and organisations within civil society. The editorial introduces the individual papers and seeks to identify their potential contributions to academic and policy debate within and beyond the EU.
The European Public Sphere – Barriers and Limitations
Zeszyty Prasoznawcze, 2018
The European public sphere appears only incidentally and temporarily and even then, European issues are presented through the prism of national benefits or loss. All of this is not conducive to the creation of a European identity, nor the legitimization of EU. Should the media and the journalists be blamed for this state of affairs? How do they perceive their role in the process of European integration? Where, in their opinion, are the causes, which render the creation of a European public sphere impossible? This article will present the results of individual depth interviews (IDI) conducted with German press journalists (16).
Grounding the European Public Sphere
Abstract The gold standard for discussing public spheres has long been established around mass media, with the prestige print press given a privileged place.
Agents of transnational debate across Europe: The press in emerging European public sphere
Javnost the Public, 2008
This article aims at assessing the theoretical and empirical role of the national press in the emerging European public sphere. The study draws on Europeanisation as the emerging framework for transnational communication across European nation states. It assumes that the press itself may perform as a political actor and make a substantial contribution to Europeanisation by advocating European integration and by broadening its scope to include the perspectives of all EU member states and the EU itself. In order to discern the infl uence or role of the media-its "voice"-this study analysed the content of editorials of 28 newspapers in seven European countries along two dimensions. First, the receptiveness of the press towards European perspectives is investigated by measuring the degree to which its editorials feature European scopes. Second, the study examines newspapers' attitudes about European integration as a political project. The overall fi ndings point to a remarkable representation of European perspectives, and substantial support for EU integration, by the national press in Germany, France, Italy and Spain. The newspapers in the Netherlands and Switzerland were somewhat more parochial, but still supportive. We also see that the United Kingdom (UK) media deviate substantially from these patterns. This study concludes that, in contrast with the fi ndings of earlier studies, the press must be regarded as a signifi cant agent of Europeanisation fostering transnational linkages of public debate.
Towards a European public sphere?
Innovation: The European Journal of Social Science Research, 2004
In this paper we address the alleged communication or public sphere deficit of the EU. We develop a systematic approach to the Europeanization of public spheres, which distinguishes three forms of Europeanized political communication: supranational, vertical and horizontal. We propose that the spatial reach and boundaries of public communication can be determined by investigating communicative flows and assessing the relative density of public communication within and between different geopolitical spaces. We apply this model to data on political claim making in seven issue fields in German print media in the year 2000. We find that the degree and forms of Europeanization of political communication vary considerably among policy fields. These differences are strongly linked to the extent and type (supranational or intergovernmental) of competencies of the EU in these fields. Contrary to the hypothesis of a public sphere deficit, the German mass media seem to quite accurately reflect the Europeanization of policy making, at least in those policy fields where a clear-cut transfer of competencies to the supranational EU level has taken place.
Discussion on a European public sphere: the role of mass media and the EU's support
This short paper presents a various theoretical approaches of the European Public Sphere that emphasizes on the role on European integration and European identity. It discusses the extent to which the EU’s institutions are involved in building process of a European Public Sphere by financing a various projects. The aim of this paper is to analyze the arguments presented by various scholars who have developed the concept in the context of the EU and its policy. Furthermore, the purpose is to discuss to what extent does mass media and projects function as a European public sphere in the EU. The paper comes up with a current picture on how the EU supports the media outlets together with the projects that aim to foster the emergence of a European public sphere as well as to improve the image of the EU.
The European Public Sphere: Media and Transnational Communication in European Integration, 1969-1991 - By J.-H. Meyer
JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies, 2011
Meyer, Jan-Henrik 2010. The European public sphere. Media and transnational communication in European integration 1969-1991. (Studies on the History of European Integration Vol. 10). Stuttgart: Franz Steiner.
2010
The traumatic failure of the European constitution seems to underpin doubts about a European public sphere that effectively interacts with the European Union and holds it to account. Is a European public sphere truly impossible? Has it been emerging as many social scientists have claimed – however only on the basis of more recent observations? This dissertation provides the first long-term historical analysis of a political European public sphere and its development over time. Starting out from a thorough consideration of the theoretical, conceptual and methodological innovations provided by social scientists in recent years, the study focuses on how British, French and German quality newspapers covered major European Council summits from The Hague in 1969 to Maastricht in 1991. Findings - based on quantitative and qualitative analyses of both reporting and commentary using a variety of methods - suggest that major events of European integration have long been accompanied by a vivid debate in the media. Moreover, the European public sphere underwent a notable structural transformation. The growth of a more developed European political system since the 1970s has led to a more politicised, more differentiated, more inclusive – and hence potentially more democratic – European public sphere in terms of participation in the debate and the range of issues covered. There was a notable increase in transnational communication. A discourse analysis of the commentary demonstrates changes in European identification – from a rather uniform association of Europe with progress to overcome the nation state towards a greater pluralism in European self-understanding, including Euro-scepticism, but also a sense of greater European responsibility in the post-Cold War world. The study suggests that an emerging European public sphere was much more responsive to the development of European integration than has previously been assumed.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.