Decidable classes of documents for XPath

2004

In this paper, we investigate the complexity of deciding the satisfiability of XPath 2.0 expressions, ie, whether there is an XML document for which their result is nonempty. Several fragments that allow certain types of expressions are classified as either in PTIME or NP-hard to see which type of expression make this a hard problem. Finally, we establish a link between XPath expressions and partial tree descriptions which are studied in computational linguistics.

2001

XPath is a W3C standard that plays a crucial role in several in uential query, transformation, and schema standards for XML. Motivated by the larger challenge of XML query optimization, we investigate the problem of containment of XPath expressions under integrity constraints that are in turn formulated with the help of XPath expressions. Our core formalism consists of a fragment of XPath that we call simple and a corresponding class of of integrity constraints that we call simple XPath integrity constraints (SXIC). SXIC's can express many database-style constraints, including key and foreign key constraints speci ed in the XML Schema standard proposal, as well as many constraints implied by DTDs. We identify a subclass of bounded SXIC's under which containment of simple XPath expressions is decidable, but we show that even modest use of unbounded SXIC's makes the problem undecidable. In particular, the addition of (unbounded) constraints implied by DTDs leads to undecidability.

2001

XPath is a W3C standard that plays a crucial role in several in uential query, transformation, and schema standards for XML. Motivated by the larger challenge of XML query optimization, we investigate the problem of containment of XPath expressions under integrity constraints that are in turn formulated with the help of XPath expressions. Our core formalism consists of a fragment of XPath that we call simple and a corresponding class of of integrity constraints that we call simple XPath integrity constraints (SXIC). SXIC's can express many database-style constraints, including key and foreign key constraints speci ed in the XML Schema standard proposal, as well as many constraints implied by DTDs. We identify a subclass of bounded SXIC's under which containment of simple XPath expressions is decidable, but we show that even modest use of unbounded SXIC's makes the problem undecidable. In particular, the addition of (unbounded) constraints implied by DTDs leads to undecidability.

IEICE Transactions on Information and Systems, 2013

In this paper, we consider the XPath satisfiability problem under restricted DTDs called "duplicate free". For an XPath expression q and a DTD D, q is satisfiable under D if there exists an XML document t such that t is valid against D and that the answer of q on t is nonempty. Evaluating an unsatisfiable XPath expression is meaningless, since such an expression can always be replaced by an empty set without evaluating it. However, it is shown that the XPath satisfiability problem is intractable for a large number of XPath fragments. In this paper, we consider simple XPath fragments under two restrictions: (i) only a label can be specified as a node test and (ii) operators such as qualifier ([ ]) and path union (∪) are not allowed. We first show that, for some small XPath fragments under the above restrictions, the satisfiability problem is NP-complete under DTDs without any restriction. Then we show that there exist XPath fragments, containing the above small fragments, for which the satisfiability problem is in PTIME under duplicate-free DTDs.

We study the complexity of two central XML processing problems. The first is XPath 1.0 query processing, which has been shown to be in PTime in previous work. We prove that both the data complexity and the query complexity of XPath 1.0 fall into lower (highly parallelizable) complexity classes, while the combined complexity is PTime-hard. Subsequently, we study the sources of this hardness and identify a large and practically important fragment of XPath 1.0 for which the combined complexity is LogCFL-complete and, therefore, in the highly parallelizable complexity class NC 2 . The second problem is the complexity of validating XML documents against various typing schemes like Document Type Definitions (DTDs), XML Schema Definitions (XSDs), and tree automata, both with respect to data and to combined complexity. For data complexity, we prove that validation is in LogSpace and depends crucially on how XML data is represented. For the combined complexity, we show that the complexity ranges from LogSpace to LogCFL, depending on the typing scheme.

Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 2015

Jose Meseguer is one of the earliest contributors in the area of Algebraic Specification. In this paper, which we are happy to dedicate to him on the occasion of his 65th birthday, we use ideas and methods coming from that area with the aim of presenting an approach for the specification of the structure of classes of XML documents and for reasoning about them. More precisely, we specify the structure of documents using sets of constraints that are based on XPath and we present inference rules that are shown to define a sound and complete refutation procedure for checking satisfiability of a given specification using tableaux.

Extreme Markup Languages®, 2003

Journal of the ACM, 2008

We study the satisfiability problem associated with XPath in the presence of DTDs. This is the problem of determining, given a query p in an XPath fragment and a DTD D, whether or not there exists an XML document T such that T conforms to D and the answer of p on T is nonempty. We consider a variety of XPath fragments widely used in practice, and investigate the impact of different XPath operators on the satisfiability analysis. We first study the problem for negationfree XPath fragments with and without upward axes, recursion and data-value joins, identifying which factors lead to tractability and which to NP-completeness. We then turn to fragments with negation but without data values, establishing lower and upper bounds in the absence and in the presence of upward modalities and recursion. We show that with negation the complexity ranges from PSPACE to EXPTIME. Moreover, when both data values and negation are in place, we find that the complexity ranges from NEXPTIME to undecidable. Furthermore, we give a finer analysis of the problem for particular classes of DTDs, exploring the impact of various DTD constructs, identifying Extended abstracts [Benedikt et al. 2005; Geerts and Fan 2005] of this work were presented at the 24th 8:2 M. BENEDIKT ET AL.

Lecture Notes in Computer Science, 2005

We study the satisfiability problem for XPath fragments supporting the following-sibling and preceding-sibling axes. Although this problem was recently studied for XPath fragments without sibling axes, little is known about the impact of the sibling axes on the satisfiability analysis. To this end we revisit the satisfiability problem for a variety of XPath fragments with sibling axes, in the presence of DTDs, in the absence of DTDs, and under various restricted DTDs. In these settings we establish complexity bounds ranging from NLOGSPACE to undecidable. Our main conclusion is that in many cases, the presence of sibling axes complicates the satisfiability analysis. Indeed, we show that there are XPath satisfiability problems that are in PTIME and PSPACE in the absence of sibling axes, but that become NP-hard and EXPTIME-hard, respectively, when sibling axes are used instead of the corresponding vertical modalities (e.g., the wildcard and the descendant axis).

2008

Abstract. In this paper we consider a powerful mechanism, called Regular XPath, for expressing queries and constraints over XML data, including DTDs and existential path constraints and their negation. Regular XPath extends XPath with binary relations over XML nodes specified by means two-way regular path queries. Our first contribution deals with checking satisfiability of Regular XPath constraints.