Teaching Mathematics: Discovering vs Storytelling
ASLANBEK NAZIEV2018, BRAIN Broad Research in Artificial Intelligence and Neuroscience
Sign up for access to the world's latest research
checkGet notified about relevant papers
checkSave papers to use in your research
checkJoin the discussion with peers
checkTrack your impact
Abstract
There exist at least two approaches to the teaching of every subject, including mathematics. The first one is as old as the world (or, at least, as the education). According to this approach, to teach something means to outline what you teach. This approach is appreciated by the great majority of teachers. Because the realization of this approach in most cases reduces to the telling of stories about what is taught, I call this approach by «storytelling». There exists also another approach, which goes from the famous statement by Aristotle: «We learn something only when we do what we learn». From this statement, I think, was born the following idea by Herbert Spencer: «What does it mean to teach?-It means to encourage systematically the students to their own discoveries» (as it was formulated by George Pólya and Gabor Segö in the epigraph to the preface of their book "Problems and Theorems in Analysis" and repeated in Polya, G., (1981)). This approach to teaching is natural to call «discovering».
Related papers
The importance of using stories for teaching-learning of mathematical concepts
2020
Mathematics, being a discipline of facts and skills, is often memorized which creates mathematical phobia in students. (Teaching of mathematics, maths position paper, NCERT, 2006) “In maths classroom, where problems that require mental maths or processes are involved students lose interest and face many problems. It may be because of reading, comprehension, and difficulty in understanding which process is involved in the question.” (Zorfass J, n.d., 2014).During the teaching internship in one of the government schools of Hauz Khas in Delhi, It was observed that the learning level of primary grade students in mathematics was high. They performed problems that involve computation easily and with great interest. However, when it comes to word problems or the NCERT textbooks problems which involve stories, students lose interest and feel anxious. They face problems while reading and comprehending. They are not able to reach the level where they use processes. They have fear of solving w...
Embedding Mathematics In the Soul: Narrative As a Force In Mathematics Education
Opening address to the Third Mediterranean …, 2003
Teaching Mathematics: It's Time to Tell Some New Stories
Journal of Education and Christian Belief, 2005
A NUMBER OF mathematics educators have called in recent years for a ‘humanising’ of the teaching of mathematics and even of the subject itself. One important way in which this can be done is by recognising the importance of story in human life and understanding in general and in mathematics teaching in particular. Using as an example the story of Florence Nightingale and her rose statistical diagrams, three ‘stories within the story’ are identified: the ‘human-story’, the ‘mathematics-story’ and the ‘knowledge-story’. A way of making use of these within the mathematics classroom is suggested and areas for further research are identified.
Storytelling for Tertiary Mathematics Students
Invited Lectures from the 13th International Congress on Mathematical Education, 2018
This paper offers a narrative of ideas, events and opinions addressing the underexposed area of storytelling in tertiary mathematics. A short discussion on storytelling is followed by a brief account of the history of storytelling. Features of stories are discussed as well as options for when a story should be told and the requirements of a good story. The main thrust of the paper is a personal account of experiences of storytelling in a tertiary mathematics classroom. The study involves a large group of engineering students doing a calculus module. The storytelling discussed in this paper takes the form of a structured activity in a specific timeslot. Student feedback presents an unexpected angle, deviating from the intended purpose of entertain, inspire and educate, namely, giving a perception of caring from the teacher's side. Keywords Storytelling Á Mathematics Á Tertiary students Á Features of storytelling Mathematics stories 12.1 About Stories and Storytelling Storytelling is part of every culture: It is an ancient art that has been practiced through millennia of human interaction. It ranges from a mother telling her child a story to theatrical storytelling on a stage. Storytelling often relies on the imagination and speaking ability of the storyteller and the listening ability of the audience. Stories have travelled and still travel all over the world, and commonalities in different cultures abound. Stories come in many forms: they can be in written form, orally conveyed or visually depicted. Stories appear everywhere: in newspapers, on the internet, in magazines, on television and in discourse between people. Stories can be factual or fictional, stem from actual events or be the product of someone's imagination.
Rethinking Pedagogy Through Storytelling in School Mathematics
Journal of Transformative Praxis
This article focuses on storytelling as an alternative innovative pedagogical approach to teaching mathematics in response to a discipline-based pedagogy in the context of Nepali Mathematics Education. In Nepal (probably worldwide), mathematics teachers rarely teach mathematics for creating mathematics. Instead, they focus on teaching the steps to repeat someone else's creation without exploring how mathematics relates to students' life worlds. As a result, students feel mathematics as a dry subject, mathematics teachers as apathetic human beings and mathematics classrooms as a boring factory of producing passive learners. In this context, this paper explores how storytelling may become one of the many innovative mathematics pedagogies and help mathematics teachers rethink their pedagogical practices for teaching mathematics joyfully and meaningfully. We used autoethnography as a research methodology that portrayed the narratives of the first author extracted from his MPhil ...
Mathematical story: a metaphor for mathematics curriculum
Educational Studies in Mathematics, 2015
This paper proposes a theoretical framework for interpreting mathematical content found in mathematics curriculum in order to offer teachers and other mathematics educators comprehensive conceptual tools with which to make curricular decisions. More specifically, it describes a metaphor of mathematics curriculum as story and defines and illustrates the mathematical story elements of mathematical characters, action, setting, and plot. Drawn from literary theory, this framework supports the interpretation of mathematics curriculum as art, able to stimulate the imagination and curiosity of students and teachers alike. In doing so, it is argued, this framework offers teachers and other curriculum designers a conceptual tool that can be used to improve the mathematics curriculum offered to students in terms of both logic and aesthetic. Biographical note: Leslie Dietiker is an assistant professor of mathematics education at the School of Education, Boston University. Her interests include understanding and improving written and enacted mathematics curricula in order to inspire student curiosity and increase their desire to make sense of mathematics.
Suggestions for Sustainable Mathematics Teaching: Storytelling of Elementary School Mathematics Topics
International Journal of Curriculum and Instruction, 2021
In the age of change, rapid changes occur in the education and teaching process as in every field. The changes have brought new insights and practices to the mathematics teaching process, just like any other lesson. One of these changes is teaching with storytelling method. Learning with this method can be envisaged to warrant a more permanent, fun and sustainable structure. The stories always have a significant place for the educational process of children from past to present due to their vital texture. Recently, using stories in mathematics teaching has been considered as a fairly new understanding since the effective mathematics teaching process and academic success in mathematics are a quest that has been going on for many years. This quest has been the main driving force in the emergence of different applications. In this regard, this study aims to examine how the pre-service classroom teachers can transfer elementary school mathematics topics to students through stories for sustainable academic and life skills. Having a qualitative research design, the study employed a phenomenological design. The pre-service teachers were asked to turn a topic they chose from the elementary school mathematics curriculum into a story in accordance with the grade level. The participants consisted of 94 pre-service teachers studying at classroom teaching department. Based upon the results obtained from the stories, the stories written by the pre-service classroom were noted to cover all learning domains and sub-learning domains. 94 stories were identified to include each of the 229 objectives available in the Elementary School Mathematics Curriculum.
Eliciting beliefs with a narrative activity in mathematics teacher education
2010
In a teacher training course for mathematics teachers, a narrative activity was assigned to elicit participants’ beliefs on proof. Proof is a very important topic in mathematics education, crucial to develop mathematical thinking, and therefore worth special attention. Individual narrations of one’s relation with proof were collected, posted on the web and discussed. This allowed a number of different aspects and views to emerge and to be compared, providing a good opportunity for the trainees to become aware of their own beliefs and shortcomings. The positive outcomes of this experience suggest that narrative can be a suitable tool to address beliefs in teacher education.
When the Problem Is Not the Question and the Solution Is Not the Answer: Mathematical Knowing and Teaching
American Educational Research Journal, 1990
This paper describes a research and development project in teaching designed to examine whether and how it might be possible to bring the practice of knowing mathematics in school closer too what it means to know mathematics within the discipline by deliberately altering the roles and responsibilities of teacher and students in classroom discourse. The project was carried out as a regular feature of lessons in fifth-grade mathematics in a public school. A case of teaching and learning about exponents derived from lessons taught in the project is described and interpreted from mathematical, pedagogical, and sociolinguistic perspectives. To change the meaning of knowing and learning in school, the teacher initiated and supported social interactions appropriate to making mathematical arguments in response to students’ conjectures. The activities students engaged in as they asserted and examined hypotheses about the mathematical structures that underlie their solutions to problems are c...
Supporting Prospective Teachers’ Development of Relevant and Authentic Mathematics Stories
2019
Recommended Citation Stehr, E. M., & Keazer, L. M. (2019). Supporting prospective teachers’ development of relevant and authentic mathematics stories. In S. Otten, A. G., Candela, Z. de Araujo, C. Haines, & C. Munter (Eds.). Proceedings of the forty-first annual meeting of the North American Chapter of the International Group for the Psychology of Mathematics Education (pp.1131-1135). St. Louis, MO: University of Missouri. Retrieved from https://www.pmena.org/pmenaproceedings/PMENA%2041%202019%20Proceedings.pdf
Related papers
Towards a narrative-oriented framework for designing mathematical learning
2004
Actually, it is half the art of storytelling to keep a story free from explanation as one reproduces it. [...] The most extraordinary things, marvelous things, are related with the greatest accuracy, but the psychological connection of the events is not forced on the reader. It is left up to him to interpret things the way he understands them, and thus the narrative achieves an amplitude that information lacks. Walter Benjamin, The storyteller
Teaching mathematics through storytelling: Engaging the 'being' of a student in mathematics
2015
The paper draws from a hermeneutic phenomenological research study, which aimed at exploring the meaning of teachable moments from the lived experiences of grades 6–8 mathematics teachers. A primary and important stage of hermeneutic phenomenological study is for researchers to begin their research with a personal story. This paper presents the results of this primary stage, which focused on one of author's experiences of storytell-ing in a grade 6 to 8 mathematics classes for the purpose of humanizing mathematics as a way of engaging both the 'being' of mathematics students and their cognitive faculties. Data was collected from personal teaching stories of one of the researcher/author. The paper argues that teacher's storytelling humanizes mathematics in ways that engages both the 'being' and cognitive faculties of a student.
Mathematics and Teaching
Notices of the American Mathematical Society, 2015
A Little-Used Art of Teaching: The Case of Storytelling
The Mathematics Teacher
How many students would agree with the statement “My math teacher fails in the area of creativity” when asked if their teachers try to enliven their classroom? So, where is the fun in our teaching of mathematics? In Principles and Standards for School Mathematics, the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics clearly recognizes the need for lively classrooms by stating, “Teaching mathematics well involves creating, enriching, maintaining, and adapting instruction to move toward mathematical goals, capture and sustain interest, and engage students in building mathematical understanding” (NCTM 2000, p. 18). We suggest incorporating storytelling as a means of introducing students to new concepts and working through the solution of several problems before the students even know they are investigating them.
The mathematics textbook as a story: A novel approach to the interrogation of mathematics curriculum
Building stories in order to reason and prove in mathematics class in primary school
CERME 9 - Ninth Congress of the European Society for Research in Mathematics Education, 2015
As a part of a multidisciplinary research lead by a team from the S2HEP Laboratory, the aim of our work is to explore the potential functions of stories in Scientifics and Mathematics learning. In this paper we focus on the potential connections between the mathematical space and rhetoric space during problem solving activity. We first characterized theoretically, and then tested experimentally, thanks to a didactical engineering, a didactical environment. We characterise a processes-transferring space between the narrative activity and the problem solving activity. Our results show that the narration act supports the student's mathematical reasoning.
Using Storytelling to Teach Mathematics Concepts
Australian primary mathematics classroom, 2006
Development of Unconventional Pedagogies: Integrating Mathematical Narrative in Upper Primary Grade Mathematics Education
Mathematics has been viewed as an epistemological enterprise characterized by absolute truth, certainty and objectivity. This legacy of absolutism turned mathematics into a subject of study which was very distinct, highly specialised and an esoteric curricular action. Absolutism has been the dominant perspective that has informed teaching-learning of mathematics in school education. Elementary school mathematics teachers seldom attempt to relate to the student's psychological and social needs. This can happen by integrating the literary aspects with motivations which drive society to encourage learning of those concepts among young children. This research is a three-phase pedagogical study that aims to explore spaces within the present tightly structured primary mathematics curriculum for creative possibilities of its integration with other disciplines through mathematical narratives. It attempts to develop unconventional pedagogies for use of conversations, stories, and narratives within such pedagogical spaces while integrating affective, cognitive and cultural aspects of student's needs. It was conducted with a sample of 42 children studying in class V in a government primary school in New Delhi. This research demonstrates the roadmap of an unconventional possibility integrating mathematical narrative into the school mathematics classroom at the upper primary level.
Efforts to Increase Ability to Make Solutions of Mathematical Stories Through Discovery Learning Model on Elementary School Students
JMIE (Journal of Madrasah Ibtidaiyah Education)
This study to improve the ability to solve word math through discovery learning model in the elementary school students. This research method using Classroom Action Research method. The result showed that students’ ability to solve word problems through a model of discovery learning has increased. Increase students ability to solve word problems can be seen in the first cycle obtained 68,6 and an average increase incycle II to 83,5. Incerased ability to sove word problem are also characterized by increased activity of the students, the average of the first cycle of 70,8% of the student activity increased by 15,7% in the second cycle becomes 86,5%. The positive response of student towards learning discovery learning model in the first 71,2%, also an increase of 13,5% from 84,7% in the first cycle to second cycle.
Loading Preview
Sorry, preview is currently unavailable. You can download the paper by clicking the button above.