Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Latinas and Religion: Subordination or State of Grace?

2000

Abstract

This Essay addresses how religion simultaneously subordinates Latinas while serving as a source of strength. More specifically, it focuses on Catholicism and how the same church and religion have a fragmented and varied impact on Latinas, particularly Mexican-Americans, with whom I am most familiar. 3 When using the term "religion" in the context of Latinas, I normally refer to Catholicism and sometimes to Christianity more generally because even though not all Latinas/os are Catholic, at least sixty-five percent selfidentify as Catholic. 4 In spite of the high numbers of Latina/o Catholics, an increasing number of Latinas/os are turning to evangelical and other Protestant churches. "While firm statistics are lacking, local religious leaders agree there has been a dramatic increase in evangelical and Pentecostal churches that serve Latina/o immigrants. " 5 Catholicism's hold on Latinas/os is weakening, demonstrating that the Church, for various reasons, is not fulfilling the needs of many Latinas/os. Even though this Essay focuses on Latinas and the Catholic Church, it is not meant to diminish the experiences of non-Catholic or non-Christian Latinas, and even among Catholic Latinas, the experiences are anything but homogenous. Nonetheless, there is enough common experience to justify exploring the paradox of how Catholic Latinas use religion as a source of strength, as a survival and resistance strategy, and as a way to build community, on the one hand, while experiencing it as a subordinating and oppressive force, on the other. I broach this controversial topic for the important reasons expressed by Professors Valencia, Iglesias and Valdes. Professor Valencia stated that: 3 Although it is more accurate to call this group "Mexican-American Latinas," that phrase is cumbersome, so I often use the phrase "Latinas," with the understanding that my reference point is frequently the Mexican-American Latina. 4 See BARRY A. KOSMIN & SEYMOUR P. LACHMAN, ONE NATION UNDER GOD: RELIGION IN CONTEMPORARY AMERICAN SOCIETY 137-38 (1993) (noting that two-thirds of Mexican Americans identify as Roman Catholics). A different source finds "that 85 to 90 percent of Mexican Americans are Roman Catholics." Kyriakos S. Markides & Thomas Cole, Change and Continuity in Mexican American Religious Behavior: A Three Generation Study, in THE MEXICAN AMERICAN EXPERIENCE: AN INTERDISCIPLINARY ANTHOLOGY 402, 403 (Rodolfo 0. De la Garza et a. eds., 1985). Interestingly, although a majority of Latinas/os identify as Catholic, that does not equate with high levels of church involvement, illustrating the paradox of low levels of institutional participation and high levels of religiosity.