Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Facing Wilde; or, Emotion's Image

2015, Publications of the Modern Language Association of America

Abstract

It is not the least important of the lessons of endocrine analysis that there is no soul, and no body, either.-Louis Berman, MD, he Glands Regulating Personality (1922) Perhaps it isn't given to man to express all his emotions on his face, especially when we consider the many diferent emotions that have been named and arbitrarily classiied by the philosophers.-Guillaume-Benjamin Duchenne de Boulogne, he Mechanism of Human Facial Expression (1862) I N HIS 1862 STUDY MÉCANISME DE PHYSIONOMIE HUMAINE (THE Mechanism of Human Facial Expression), Guillaume-Benjamin Du chenne argues that "emotions, sentiments, and passions" are only genuine when their "image" appears in "muscles" of the face (28). If the emotion is not visible in "isolated contraction[s] ," it has no "image" and thus has been arbitrarily classiied by philosophers (28). Duchenne's charge here is to Plato, Aristotle, Cicero, Descartes, and Hobbes, but his complaint anticipates more recent inquiries into the relation among the face, afect, and expression. he psychologist Silvan Tomkins, for example, has argued that our faces do not merely express our afects but deine them, since "afect is primarily facial behavior" (114).1 If facial behavior can be thought of as the transmission of an image, I am interested here in the fate of emotion's image and what a face-speciically, a particularly well-known face-can show us about the meaning of expression, especially when that image is elusive, leeting, or simply unknowable. Whether one understands expression as physiological-as surface facial behavior-or psychological reveals a great deal about how