Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Filling the void. Copies of Bosch’s 'Ecce Homo'

2023, Jheronimus Bosch. His workshop and his followers.

Abstract

Bosch’s Ecce Homo (ca. 1475-1485) is a fascinating work, not in the least because it contains a substantial number of devotional portraits. Before they were overpainted, the portraits of the fifteen family members filled the better part of the lower half of the painting. When the orants on the Bosch’s principaal were no longer visible, their absence left the composition unbalanced. The several artists who copied the work had to deal with this problem, even those who had never seen it or had no knowledge of the original composition. This paper discusses the solutions several artists came up with to ‘fill the void’. The location of one of the most interesting copies was long unknown, but fortunately the work resurfaced in 2017. It is now in a private collection in Belgium and has been studied and photographed. A dendrochronological analysis was made by Peter Klein. This paper focuses especially on this ‘lost copy’ and the information it provides, about both the principaal as well as the practice of copying in the sixteenth century.