1998, The Journal of African History
Anthony Barker's study of slavery in Mauritius focuses on the dynamic interaction between humanitarian concern and economic exploitation in the aftermath of the British conquest. During this period, Mauritian society was grappling with the prospects of the transition to British rule, economic stagnation, and the spectre of amelioration and the proposed emancipation of slaves. Those familiar with these aspects of Mauritian history will be seeking answers in this book to a number of questions that have thus far not been adequately researched, such as the internal nature of Mauritian slavery, the demographics of the slave population, and the transition from a household-type slave economy to plantation slavery. In chapters -, Barker analyses the antislavery movement in Britain and its critics in Mauritius. He criticises British officials, including the governor himself, for failing to enforce British amelioration and anti-slave trade policies more effectively, although he does not answer the nagging question of why an antislavery movement never arose in Mauritius, the only British slave colony in which this was the case. Barker's concentration on events in England and on British officials in Mauritius, and his downplaying of important events and developments in Mauritius itself, results in an inadequate and rather static analysis of the activities of Governor Farquhar and his secretary, Charles Telfair. Although Barker may be right in criticizing Nwulia for failing to recognize Telfair's crucial place in politics, the latter's activities must be seen in the context of more virulent, albeit more powerful, forces and personalities on the Mauritian political scene. For example, the Comite! Coloniale, which had been formed specifically to resist amelioration and abolition, is barely mentioned despite its immense significance in local politics. Farquhar's policies need to be seen not only in the context of the anti-slavery movement, but also in the context of overall British policy in Mauritius, Madagascar and the Indian Ocean, and their interplay with local forces. It was not until the s that Farquhar became convinced that the future of Mauritius was to be closely tied to sugar. Barker also spends much time trying to prove not only the complicity but the participation of British officials in the illegal slave trade, although the Commissioners of Enquiry report never produced more than circumstantial evidence to support this claim, to which Barker adds nothing new. Nevertheless, these chapters represent pioneering advances in Mauritian historiography : new material on the anti-slavery movement's preoccupation and involvement with Mauritian slavery is presented, and the metropolitan view of slavery in Mauritius is fully explored. Barker's examination of the census, in chapter , regrettably does not include references to recent studies on this topic, for example, the study of the slave census by H. Ly Tio Fane, and my own on the slave census. His analysis of trends in the transformation of sugar and slavery, the two most closely intertwined and critical issues of these times, would have carried more weight had the right direction. Kenya's political history may yet recover a much needed degree of objectivity.